Chapter 7 of 19

Chapter 4: The Escape Key Three practices that help prevent cyberbullying

Chapter 4: The Escape Key Three practices that help prevent cyberbullying

CHAPTER 4

THE ESCAPE KEY

Three practices that help prevent cyberbullying

If you’re horrible to me, I’m going to write a song about it,

and you won’t like it. That’s how I operate.

–Taylor Swift

Mallory Grossman was a cheerleader and talented gymnast living in Rockaway, New Jersey, with her mom, dad, and three siblings. Most people described her as happy and lively…

Until she took her own life.

It began back in sixth grade when Mallory’s life took an unexpected turn. A group of girls at school singled her out and began teasing her.

Her parents don’t have any idea what provoked the initial teasing, but it began in the classroom with other students kicking her chair and whispering cruel names like “fat” and “ugly” so the teacher couldn’t hear. What might have been labeled teasing grew to shunning. Her fellow students shooed her away if she tried to sit at their lunch table, telling her she didn’t have any friends and calling her a loser.1

The bullying quickly went digital.

HOME USED TO BE A SANCTUARY, BUT NOW BULLYING REACHES WHEREVER KIDS BRING THEIR PHONES—WHICH IS EVERYWHERE.

Cyberbullying is a unique kind of cruelty, because it infiltrates environments that used to feel safe. Home used to be a sanctuary, but now bullying reaches wherever kids bring their phones—which is everywhere.

Mallory received cruel texts and posts on Instagram and Snapchat. Girls even posted pictures of Mallory on the playground with mean captions. On one occasion Mallory asked a girl to take a picture down. The girl responded, “NEVER,” with a smiley face.

These girls were a unique kind of mean. Mallory’s parents heard from other parents who described the girls who bullied Mallory as “mean, malicious, and nasty.”

Mallory’s mom says she sent countless messages to school officials and they would simply reply, “We’ll look into it.” But nothing changed.

That’s when her parents began noticing symptoms. Mallory’s grades began to slip. She would claim she had stomachaches and headaches and needed to stay home from school. “She was just sad,” her mother explained.

Mallory’s mom spoke to one of the mean girl’s mothers. The mother dismissed the accusation that her daughter was bullying, claiming it was all a “big joke” and she shouldn’t worry about it. Mallory’s mom asked that she please tell her daughter to stop texting Mallory. Mallory received texts from the girl three minutes later.

The parents finally met with the principal and asked the administration to intervene, but felt like the school did not take the claims seriously, even after “months of relentless” cyberbullying. At one meeting her mother said the administration advised Mallory to just “hug it out” with the bullies, and she was actually called out for being a tattletale.2

Mallory didn’t think telling the school would help. In fact, she told her parents, “You just made it worse. You don’t know these girls!” (Words I’ve heard far too many times from harassed kids.)

Mallory was right. After the meeting, the girls followed her into the bathroom and told her, “If you do that again, we’re going to get you.”

One kid told Mallory she should just kill herself.

So that’s what she did.

She was just twelve years old.

Twelve!

How many times do we have to hear the same story?

Did no one see the signs?

It’s interesting hearing today’s young people talk about social media. Most of them seem to have a love/hate relationship with it.

In my interviews with kids, I heard phrases like…

• “I can’t go twenty minutes without it, but then it makes me feel bad about myself when I look at it.”

• “Sometimes I know if I post a certain picture I’m going to get made fun of, but I post it anyway.”

• “My mom told me to ignore the comments people make, but I can’t. They always hurt.”

Digital communication has opened up entire new avenues for hurt. How can we possibly help our kids avoid some of this hurt?

DELAY SOCIAL MEDIA AND MOBILE DEVICES

The most effective solution is one more obvious and overlooked than the emperor’s new clothes: delay social media.

It’s like the old joke:

“Doctor, it hurts when I do this!” The man rotated his arm in a circle.

“So don’t do this!” the doctor replied, rotating his arm in a circle.

Why subject your kids to ridicule on social media when many of them shouldn’t even be on social media? (I’m specifically referring to kids middle school age and younger.)

In a world where the average kid is getting a smartphone at ten years old, and devices with all the same features at even younger ages, we need to ask ourselves, “Are we helping or hindering our kids by handing them these devices?”

Yes, cyberbullying is difficult enough for thirteen-year-olds, fifteen-year-olds, and seventeen-year-olds. We don’t need to subject our eleven- and twelve-year-olds to it. In fact, the government forbids it.

I’m talking about COPPA, the Federal Trade Commission’s “Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act,” which prevents websites and online services (like Snapchat, Instagram, and Twitter) from collecting personal information from anyone under thirteen.

What does that mean?

When your twelve-year-old tries to sign up for Snapchat, the first thing the app does is ask them to enter their birthdate. If they are under thirteen, then Snapchat basically says, “Sorry, you’re not old enough.” Same with Instagram and Twitter.

So why are countless ten-, eleven-, and twelve-year-olds on social media?

Because they lied about their age.

That’s the frustrating element. The FTC has no way to enforce the age rule, and apps don’t require any sort of age verification. As a result, even if you don’t allow your twelve-year-old to have Snapchat, many of their friends will have Snapchat (or as your child will tell you, “All my friends have Snapchat”).

SO WHY ARE COUNTLESS TEN-, ELEVEN-, AND TWELVE-YEAR-OLDS ON SOCIAL MEDIA? BECAUSE THEY LIED ABOUT THEIR AGE.

And they’re right. Sadly, most young people are on social media. In fact, studies reveal that three out of five young people had their first social media account at age twelve or under.3

That probably explains why you’ve read so many stories about eleven- and twelve-year-olds being targeted and ridiculed on social media. Almost every story includes something about them being attacked on Snapchat, Instagram, or Facebook when they weren’t even supposed to be on Snapchat, Instagram, or Facebook. Laws and use policies combined mean your children are prohibited from using them without your consent. The FTC forbids it.

So when should we allow our kids to be on social media?

Health experts agree that parents should delay social media as long as possible. In fact, in January 2018, “a coalition of 97 child health advocates sent a letter to Mark Zuckerberg asking him to discontinue Messenger Kids, a new advertising-free Facebook app targeted at 6- to 12-year olds.” The letter said, “Raising children in our new digital age is difficult enough. We ask that you do not use Facebook’s enormous reach and influence to make it even harder.”4 One of those who signed the letter was San Diego State University professor Jean Twenge, author of iGen.

I had the opportunity to talk with Dr. Twenge at a conference where she presented compelling data showing a huge spike in teen depression, suicide, and overall “unhappiness” in the last five years—just after America crossed the 50 percent mark for smartphone ownership. She highlighted numerous studies showing a correlation between social media and “unhappiness.” One study randomly assigned participants to give up Facebook for a week. Those who did reported feeling less depressed.5

I asked her why she signed the letter asking Zuckerberg to stop targeting six- to twelve-year-olds with social media. Her answer was simple: “Because they’re just kids!”

But cyberbullying isn’t limited to social media. Texting is another common tool for cyberbullies.

Do you know the best way to prevent your twelve-year-old from getting mean texts?

Delay giving them a mobile device.

Don’t take it from me. Again, listen to the health experts. For example, Jim Steyer, CEO of Common Sense Media, was asked when he recommended allowing a young person to get a smartphone. At first Jim didn’t give a number. He gave politically correct answers like, “No two kids are the same, so it’s hard to name one age for all kids.”

But the press continued to ask. “When? Give us an age!”

Jim said, “The longer you wait, the better.”

Finally someone asked him, “When did you give your kids smartphones?”

Jim responded, “When they were in high school and they learned responsibility.”6

Bill Gates, CEO of Microsoft, was asked the same question. You’d think Bill’s kids would have had smartphones coming out of the womb, right?

Wrong.

Bill didn’t let any of his three kids have a smartphone until they were fourteen and they were in high school.7

Think of all the drama you can avoid by delaying social media and mobile devices until high school. And once your kids get to the age where you think they’re responsible enough to get a device, educate them first. Note I said “delay,” not “forbid.” We need to teach our kids how to use social media responsibly. If you feel ill-equipped to do this, just use a resource like my book The Teen’s Guide to Social Media and Mobile Devices as a phone contract. “When we’re done reading this book together, you can have a device.” Meet with them each week and go through the discussion questions at the end of each chapter, opening up the doors of dialogue about important issues like what they’re posting, who they’re “friending,” and safety precautions like whether they are allowing their location to be seen in features like “Snap Maps.”

Delaying social media can delay a lot of grief.

I can’t even begin to tell you how many parents approach me at my parent workshops sharing nightmares about their tweens on social media, or conversations these kids had with some boy or girl late at night. Which brings me to my next tip…

DELAYING SOCIAL MEDIA CAN DELAY A LOT OF GRIEF.

KEEP DEVICES OUT OF BEDROOMS

Way back in 2010 the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) told parents it wasn’t a good idea for kids to have TV or internet in their bedrooms. Of course, this was before the majority of young people had TV and internet on a device they kept in their pocket. But now that the overwhelming majority of teens have a smartphone in their pocket, with complete access to social media…the AAP has not changed its stance. Not only does the AAP recommend that kids not sleep with devices in their bedroom; it also advises avoiding exposure to screens for one hour before bedtime, since that can disrupt sleep.8

Think how many social media rants and mean comments would be prevented if all parents followed this advice.

Sadly, a poll conducted in the United States by the National Sleep Foundation revealed that 89 percent of teens have at least one device in their sleep environment that negatively influences their sleep.9

Today’s kids have very few safe zones. Wouldn’t it be nice if the bedroom was a sanctuary where they were safe from bullying? Or even if from 8:00 p.m. on it was a tech-free zone?

The Journal of Youth Studies conducted a study surveying over nine hundred adolescents between twelve and fifteen years old and discovered that one in five reported “almost always” waking up to check social media or text messages throughout the night. Those who did check their phones not only were three times more likely to report feeling “consistently tired” at school, but “reported significantly lower levels of wellbeing than their classmates.”10

Don’t get me wrong; I’m not suggesting that if our kids don’t have devices in their bedrooms, they will be immune from bullying. Bullies can still say mean things during the day. But we can limit the influence of bullies by limiting their reach. There is no reason your kids need to be inundated with the regular pings of bullies throughout the night.

It’s amazing how much bullying goes on at night. Google the words “late-night cyberbullying” and you’ll discover countless stories about people receiving late-night hate texts or seeing late-night mean posts or comments, all when young people are in their rooms alone with no accountability at all.

And mean words aren’t the only things young people end up viewing when they have their device in their room late at night. In a world rampant with porn, young people are soaking in plenty of it…even very young. Sadly, one in ten visitors to graphic porn sites are under ten years old.11

What does this have to do with bullying or intimidation? The connection is closer than you might think. Consider this study highlighted in the cover article of Time magazine:

In a study of behaviors in popular porn, nearly 90% of 304 random scenes contained physical aggression toward women, who nearly always responded neutrally or with pleasure. More insidiously, women would sometimes beg their partners to stop, then acquiesce and begin to enjoy the activity, regardless of how painful or debasing.12

No wonder girls are receiving countless messages and texts asking them to send nude pics. Because they all must “want it,” right?

These pressures and intimidations are bad enough during the day. Our kids don’t need to be experiencing them all night. Do your kids a favor and plug their phones into a charger in your bedroom every night an hour before bedtime. Who knows? This practice might encourage some actual face-to-face conversation, which leads to my next point…

MAXIMIZE FACE-TO-FACE INTERACTION

Consider what we’ve discussed in this chapter alone. The more someone is on social media, the more unhappy they are. In fact, the more time a young person spends online, the more likely they will experience mental health issues. “Teens who spent five or more hours a day online were 71 percent more likely than those who spent only one hour a day to have at least one suicide risk factor (depression, thinking about suicide, making a suicide plan, or attempting suicide).” The one antidote health and wellness experts seem to agree on is face-to-face interaction. Dr. Jean Twenge argues, “Interacting with people face to face is one of the deepest wellsprings of human happiness.”13

So consistently look for opportunities to interact with your kids, and encourage them to get involved in hobbies, sports, and social events where they interact with others.

But begin in the home. Bullying makes young people feel worthless, helpless, humiliated, and socially isolated. Make home a place where they feel exactly the opposite. Make them feel valued, empowered, honored, and an important part of the family. Find settings where your kids relax and open up. You might have to be proactive and look for venues they enjoy. Take them out for french fries at a restaurant they like, or join them in playing their favorite video game. These fun settings often catalyze moments of meaningful conversation. Don’t force conversation; just seek out times of face-to-face interaction and conversation will eventually happen naturally.

One of the simplest venues I suggest in my book 52 Ways to Connect with Your Smartphone-Obsessed Kid is dinnertime. I merely advised families to try “no tech at the table”—that includes Mom and Dad. Make dinner a cherished time when screens are turned off and phones set aside for even just half an hour. This doesn’t guarantee meaningful conversation every meal, but it does open the door to dialogue. Some of my best conversations with my kids were at the family dinner table.

Maximize every opportunity to connect with your child.

FOOLPROOF

It would be foolish for me to say that these three steps I’ve shared will completely prevent cyberbullying and bullying. Sadly, a loving home and a few prudent guardrails aren’t a bulletproof vest. I’ve met countless parents—really good parents—who made all the right efforts and their child still suffered ridicule. I know a mom and dad who signed up their son for football so he could meet new friends and boost his confidence, only to find the football field another place where he was mocked for not being good enough.

Sometimes “prevention” isn’t foolproof. Some kids just have a more difficult time making friends. And when teased, many are ignorant of the conflict management skills that can help them evade recurring incidents.

So how can a caring adult offer ongoing support?

It all begins with being approachable. Let’s focus on what that looks like in the next chapter.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?

2. Why do you think young people spend time on social media even if it’s frequently a painful place for them?

3. Why are so many kids under age thirteen on social media sites that forbid anyone under thirteen?

4. How should a caring parent respond to their twelve-year-old who asks, “Can I have Snapchat?”

5. Why do you think Bill Gates, Jim Steyer, and other experts on the world of technology make their kids wait until high school to get a smartphone?

6. How would life change if every young person turned off their phone at bedtime and put it on a charger in their parents’ bedroom?

7. Why do you think Dr. Jean Twenge claims, “Interacting with people face to face is one of the deepest wellsprings of human happiness”?

8. What is one way you could implement one of the three practices covered in this chapter with a young person this week?

↑ Back to top

↑