Chapter 7: “I See You”
CHAPTER 7: “I See You”
Teaching your kids to recognize predatory behaviors and spot Creepy Basement Guy
EMMA MET JAYDEN ON INSTAGRAM. Well, “met” is a little misleading, because she never met him face-to-face. But to Generation Screen, meeting online is “meeting.”
Jayden was one of Emma’s followers; he had “liked” several of her pics and eventually commented when she posted a new picture of her dog, Jake.
And they started DMing each other. Jayden was a freshman at the high school Emma would eventually attend. Emma was twelve.
DMing led to texting, and before long the two were texting each other every evening, sometimes late into the night. Jayden and Emma watched the same TV shows and listened to the same music. They were a perfect match. Emma was truly smitten.
And Jayden distinctively seemed to “get” Emma like no other guy ever had. He listened, encouraged her, and told her she was beautiful. Emma had never experienced this before with the guys at school. They were all into themselves and video games. He was almost too good to be true.
Point of fact, he was too good to be true.
But Emma didn’t see it.
She didn’t consider that she had posted multiple pics of her corgi on her profile, and it was obvious she was a corgi lover. She didn’t think about the fact that every little girl her age had seen the movie Frozen with the beloved character Olaf. She certainly didn’t know that her music app of choice was connected to her social media, set on “public,” of course, so everyone had access to every song she played and every playlist she had ever created. And she never really thought about all the times she posted countless stories about her Netflix binges. (“Starting season 9 of Grey’s! Please let McSteamy be all right!”)
Anyone with any presence on any of these apps would “get” Emma in ten minutes’ time.
But Jayden knew the game, taking note of Emma’s favorite pastimes, never advancing too quickly, and always saying the right things. When Emma told Jayden her frustrations with her parents, he consistently sympathized with her, validated her feelings, and made her feel special.
Emma got used to hearing Uncle Mike’s name in Jayden’s texts.
Emma actually looked forward to meeting Jayden face-to-face. She was just waiting for the right moment, because she knew her parents wouldn’t let her.
One night, after a particularly bad fight with her parents, Emma texted Jayden.
The two of them decided to meet at the far corner of the Walmart parking lot. Public, but private.
At 11:40 p.m., Emma snuck out her window.
At 11:58 p.m., Emma was already waiting in the parking lot when she received a text.
And that’s when “Jayden” sent a picture of himself.
Jayden was actually forty-two-year-old William. A quick Google search told him “Jayden” was the most popular baby name the year Emma was born. William had been playing the part of Jayden perfectly. His pics were all of another high school kid he was following from across the country. But none of that mattered now. Because now Emma was expecting “Uncle Mike.” And that’s why Emma didn’t even hesitate to get in the car when William pulled up in the Walmart parking lot.
I heard Emma’s story from her mom after one of my parenting workshops. Not all predators are adults posing as kids; in fact, most of these incidents are kids taking advantage of other kids. But there are also far too many adult predators who don’t even feel the need to hide their age, as well as a smaller percentage who pose as kids, as in Emma’s situation. All of them are predators.
The scary thing is that I hear stories like this almost everywhere I speak, even more so in recent years. Probably because we’re living in the predators’ golden age. You read that correctly. It’s never been a more opportune time for predators than right now. I’m not trying to scare you. I just want you to be aware of this reality. Over the past couple of years, three events have aligned to create a “perfect storm” for predators to swoop in:
Think of what this means for predators. They don’t have to drive their proverbial paneled vans to a mall or a playground to find vulnerable young people, and the more daring predators don’t even need to creep up and peek in a young girl’s bedroom window. Why do this when kids are posting everything a predator would ever want to see on their public, easily accessible social media profiles? And predators can see all of this from the privacy of their own homes, trailers . . . or mom’s basement.
Some apps have even developed a reputation for having a predator problem, such as TikTok, which uses algorithms that track the kinds of videos users like to watch. Algorithms like this actually help pedophiles find more victims by steering Creepy Basement Guy to content he enjoys, like little girls dancing.[3]
Bottom line: predators are exploiting these opportunities while parents, police, and tech companies are scrambling to catch up.
So who are these predators?
Three Categories of Predators
Here are the three categories of predators I see young people encountering today, starting with the most common.
1. The Teen “Toolbag”
I don’t know if I’d call these kids “predators,” but it’s worth noting that every school I visit—and I mean literally every single one—has students who have exploited other students through their phones.
The most common scenario is when a guy asks a girl for a “nude.” She eventually sends it, usually on Snapchat or some platform where pics disappear shortly after they’re posted. But the guy screenshots the pic, and a week later, a month later, a year later—doesn’t really matter when—he forwards the pic to a bunch of his friends, if not the whole school.
This happens all the time. And by “all the time,” I don’t mean it happens to every kid. I mean it happens in every school. In fact, an analysis of thirty-nine different studies with a total of more than one hundred thousand participants, showed that about 15 percent of kids under eighteen years of age sent “sexually explicit images, videos, and/or messages” (referred to as “sexts”), and 27 percent received them. (These numbers increase as kids get older, especially in their late teens.) On top of that, 12 percent of participants said they forwarded sexts without consent.[4]
Let me simplify it for you. About a third of kids under eighteen have received sexts, and about a third of those kids forward them to someone else. If your kid attends a small country school of one hundred kids, statistically, twenty-seven of them have received a sexually explicit image, video, or text message, and ten have forwarded it to others.
Anyone who forwards nude photos of a schoolmate is cruel, but typically there is at least one of these “toolbags” on every campus who initiates this kind of behavior without any consideration for the individual this kid is exploiting. I don’t typically label these cruel teens as predators, but I do have a couple of other choice names I’d be tempted to call them, because the fallout is always painful. In most situations, the girl whose picture was taken is so embarrassed, she switches schools; and in many situations, she’ll attempt suicide, and she doesn’t typically give thirteen reasons why.
I visited a middle school campus a month ago and asked the principal, a friend of mine, “How’s it going this year? Any incidents with phones yet?”
He sighed. “Well, I just broke up a fight because of one.”
“What happened?”
“Well, it all began last week, actually. Two kids were, let’s just say, engaged in a sexual act in one of the restrooms during class, when another girl walked in on them.”
True story. I couldn’t possibly make this stuff up.
“Let me guess,” I said. “The other girl took a picture.”
“Actually, no,” he explained. “She hung an immediate U-turn, and by the time she got her phone out of her backpack, she was down the hall. But she immediately described what she saw on her social media, and within an hour the entire school knew.”
“Did the two kids in the bathroom come to school the next day?” I asked.
“The girl didn’t. I don’t think she’s coming back. Way too humiliated. But the boy did, and the reason I just broke up a fight is because all the guys keep teasing this guy for hooking up with this girl. Let’s just say she wasn’t on most guys’ list of hotties at the school. So he tried to solve the problem with his fists.”
I spoke in another city where three girls solicited a guy, asking him to send them a nude video of himself. They promised to reciprocate. This guy immediately filmed himself completely nude, and they forwarded the video to the entire school. They never had any intention of returning the favor.
This was a Christian school in the Bible Belt.
The whole school had to shut down because teachers couldn’t even keep order in the classroom. Everyone was laughing, and the joking was out of control.
This isn’t always kids who know each other; in fact, now that almost all teens are setting their social media profiles on public, the number of “stranger” teens asking other teens for nudes has increased greatly. It’s not uncommon for girls to be solicited by other teens asking them to send nude photos. It’s so common that our culture is constantly claiming it’s “no big deal.” For example, teen actress Zendaya played a teenager in a sexually charged HBO show titled Euphoria. In the pilot, her character, Rue, defended sending nudes, arguing, “I’m sorry. I know your generation relied on flowers and father’s permission, but it’s 2019, and unless you’re Amish, nudes are the currency of love. So stop shaming us.”[5]
If your kid doesn’t feel this way, the pressure is on.
This is yet another reason to press the Pause button on giving your eleven- or twelve-year-old kid that phone. Not many people would label me extreme for saying that eleven-year-olds aren’t really equipped to navigate this kind of harassment from friends and strangers.
But sadly, teens aren’t the only ones exploiting teens.
2. Creepy Basement Guy
This is the guy your mother warned you about when you were a kid, but now he has a brand-new device with a high-speed connection.
Some of these guys are adults posing as teens, like the one who solicited Emma at the beginning of the chapter. But the majority of online predators actually don’t hide the fact they’re adults.[6] They just do what they can to groom, trap, or even “sextort” young people into giving them what they want.
The law enforcement friends I’ve made who work in ICAC (Internet Crimes Against Children) always tell me that when they catch these predators, they typically have conversations going on with dozens of kids at once, seeing which ones pan out and bailing out at the first sign of danger.
A youth worker I know was playing video games with his son. They were connected to his eleven-year-old nephew across the country and a couple of strangers. During game play, one of these strangers kept making inappropriate comments. My friend let a couple of the comments slide because some people tend to use foul language while gaming. But this guy began making some sexual comments. So my friend said, “Hey, man, how old are you?”
Immediately the guy disappeared from the game.
Many of these guys (and I say guys, because the vast majority of predators are males) are either really bold, dropping sexual hints and fishing for a response, or they’re expert groomers. All of them have learned that young people want to feel noticed, heard, validated, and even attractive. And when an older adult gives them this attention, kids feel special and eventually safe enough to share more about themselves.
But so many of these guys work straight out of the pedophile’s handbook. That’s why it’s important to teach our kids how to recognize predatory behaviors. In fact, in my Teen’s Guide to Face-to-Face Connections in a Screen-to-Screen World, I warn young people to look out for specific grooming behaviors. Here are just a few of them:
I warn young people that if they ever see any of these grooming behaviors from someone online, they should tell their mom, dad, teacher, or youth pastor immediately. Even if they aren’t sure.
Some of these tips seem obvious, but young people tend to think they’re invincible. I just spoke on this topic at a banquet for a large youth organization, where I was equipping parents to help their kids recognize some of these predatory behaviors. The head of the organization told me afterward, “I’m amazed how many times we can warn kids about this stuff, and yet they completely ignore it. Last month we took a hundred kids on a trip and stayed in hotels each night. My adult chaperones had to sleep by the door because kids kept trying to sneak out to meet someone they had just met online that day.”
But sometimes these predators are more than just some creepy guy wanting to hook up with a kid.
3. The Sex Trafficker
Sex traffickers might seem like the individuals I just described, since they use many of the same tactics. But these predators have streamlined these tactics into a business model.
I don’t want to mislead you, so I’ll be candid. Most sex traffickers target especially vulnerable kids who are escaping what they perceive to be a negative environment. The friends I have who work with organizations that fight sex trafficking all tell me the same thing: Sex traffickers typically target runaways, foster kids, or kids with addictions. Kids who are questioning their sexual identity are also more at risk because they often feel safer going to online sources and are afraid to tell anyone at home. Traffickers might start grooming kids the same way Creepy Basement Guy does, but their goal is to “sextort” them or get them to meet somewhere.
Sextortion is blackmailing a kid to do something sexual.
For example, I met a nurse whose niece was a foster kid. This young girl met a guy online who claimed he was a teenager. The two grew close, and it wasn’t long before he asked for a nude photo. Once she sent a nude, everything changed. He threatened to send the photo to every one of her contacts, including her foster parents, unless she met with him. So she agreed.
“Just please don’t send that pic to anyone,” she pleaded.
When she went to meet him, he wasn’t even the one who picked her up. She was trafficked to Vegas, where she was forced to prostitute herself for the weekend. The traffickers then used the video footage from those encounters to threaten her even more.
She was trafficked several times before she finally told her foster parents. The police removed her from that home, and the nurse I met adopted her.
Sextortion is a “particularly damaging form of online abuse.”[8] In 2016, a Department of Justice report revealed that most perpetrators “target girls between the ages of 10 and 17, . . . conducting conversations online to build trust, asking for sexual photos, then using those photos as [a] basis for blackmail.”[9] The report analyzed forty-three separate cases of sextortion. Two of the forty-three victims eventually committed suicide, and ten others attempted it.[10] Let those numbers sink in. That’s more than one-fourth of the victims.
The initial contact between a teen and a sex trafficker almost always begins through a comment or DM on social media. Any friend or follower can typically DM your kid unsolicited unless you specifically go into the app and turn off direct messaging.
I spoke at a church where one of their high school girls was trafficked and eventually rescued. She responded to a “modeling opportunity” she received via Instagram. Her parents allowed her to go, but there was no agency at the address. She was abducted going into the building.
Months later, someone happened to see her downtown, drugged out of her mind. Her youth worker, who was an adventure-sports nut, went downtown, posed as a client, and rescued her. (They should turn that into a movie!)
I share these true stories every time I speak at school assemblies, and after my presentations, kids will often tell me their own experiences of strangers sending nude photos or requesting to meet. The crazy part of this is that whenever I speak at one of these schools, regardless of the size of the town, I’ll look at the school’s Instagram page, tap on “Followers,” and begin looking through students’ profiles. Whenever I find a picture of a student posing in a bikini or short shorts (they aren’t difficult to find), I’ll show it to school adminstrators, and we’ll immediately scroll down to the comments. It’s almost more common than not to find these types of messages:
I typically link the profile and send it to my ICAC contact in California, asking if any of the messages are legit.
She told me, “Modeling agencies aren’t perusing high school kids’ profiles looking for new clients. These are typically very suspicious. Assure these kids to definitely not meet up with any of these people.”
Protecting Your Kids from Predators
So how can you protect your kids from any of these predators? Here are a few tips:
Creating a Climate of Comfortable Conversation
Don’t forget to practice what you’ve learned throughout this book about creating a climate of comfortable conversation in your home:
- Which of the three types of predators do you think is most common? Why?
- Why do you think young people are more vulnerable to these kinds of predators today?
- Why do you think twelve out of forty-three teenagers committed or attempted to commit suicide after being victims of sextortion?
- How can someone avoid these dangers?
When you finish the book, add this step:
Next, we’ll look at how open communication partnered with a few parental controls can help you and your kids on this journey.
Discussion Questions
[1] “Social Media, Social Life: Teens Reveal Their Experiences,” Common Sense Media, September 10, 2018, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/social-media-social-life-infographic.
[2] Survey conducted March 7–April 10, 2018, in Monica Anderson and Jingjing Jiang, Teens, Social Media and Technology 2018 (Washington, DC: Pew Research Center, 2018), 2, https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2018/05/31/teens-social-media-technology-2018/.
[3] Ryan Broderick, “TikTok Has a Predator Problem. A Network of Young Women Is Fighting Back,” BuzzFeed News, updated June 26, 2020, https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanhatesthis/tiktok-has-a-predator-problem-young-women-are-fighting-back.
[4] Sheri Madigan et al., “Prevalence of Multiple Forms of Sexting Behavior among Youth: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis,” JAMA Pediatrics 172, no. 4 (2018): 327–35. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2017.5314, https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2673719.
[5] Euphoria, season 1, episode 1, “Pilot,” directed by Augustine Frizzell, aired June 16, 2019, on HBO, quoted in Jonathan McKee, “What Parents Need to Know about Zendaya and Euphoria,” Jonathan’s Blog, August 6, 2019, https://jonathanmckeewrites.com/what-parents-need-to-know-about-zendaya-and-euphoria.
[6] Janis Wolak, David Finkelhor, and Kimberly Mitchell, “Internet-Initiated Sex Crimes against Minors: Implications for Prevention Based on Findings from a National Study,” Journal of Adolescent Health 35, no. 5 (2004): 11, http://unh.edu/ccrc/pdf/jvq/CV71.pdf.
[7] Jonathan McKee and Alyssa McKee, The Teen’s Guide to Face-to-Face Connections in a Screen-to-Screen World (Uhrichsville, OH: Shiloh Run Press, 2020), 148.
[8] Russell Brandom, “New Bill Would Make Online Sexual Extortion a Federal Crime,” The Verge, July 15, 2016, https://www.theverge.com/2016/7/15/12197712/sextortion-federal-crime-congress-katherine-clark.
[9] Brandom, “New Bill.” See also US Department of Justice, The National Strategy for Child Exploitation Prevention and Interdiction: A Report to Congress—April 2016 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 2016), 74–76, https://www.justice.gov/psc/file/842411/download.
[10] US Department of Justice, National Strategy, 76.
