Chapter 4 of 12

Chapter 3: What Age?

Chapter 3: What Age?

CHAPTER 3: What Age?

The perfect time to give your kids a screen (and what to do if you already did)

I HEAR IT EVERYWHERE I SPEAK.

“At what age should I get my kid a phone?”

“At what age should I let my kids be on social media?”

“What if I wanted to wait to give my kids a screen, but their school already issued them one?”

Sigh.

Screens sure haven’t made parenting any easier.

So what is the perfect age to give your kids a screen?

Parental Peer Pressure

If you haven’t given your kids a screen yet, the pressure is on. Even if they don’t have a phone or tablet, chances are their friends already have screens. As I write this, 89 percent of teenagers (ages thirteen to seventeen) have smartphones.[1] This is weird, because if your teenagers don’t have phones yet, I’m pretty sure they tell you, “Aaaaall of my friends have smartphones.” (You probably should resist the temptation to respond, “Actually, only 89 percent of your friends have smartphones.”)

The large number of kids getting phones before they’re even teenagers is becoming less and less surprising. Recently I was hanging out with sixth, seventh, and eighth graders on a middle school campus near my house, and it sure seemed like “aaaaall” of them had smartphones. (I know, I sound exactly like your kid.)

In fact, I was talking with thirteen of these students in a classroom at an after-school program. These were eleven-, twelve-, and thirteen-year-olds.

I wrote my phone number on the whiteboard and said, “Everyone whip out your phones.”

And count ’em . . . all thirteen pulled out a smartphone.

Every single one of them!

This seems bizarre when you consider what I shared in the first chapter about the number of kids who have smartphones:

  • 53 percent of eleven-year-olds
  • 69 percent of twelve-year-olds
  • 72 percent of thirteen-year-olds
  • Nope. Not in this group.

    One hundred percent of them had smartphones.

    So think how your own twelve-year-old is feeling at school every day. Your son or daughter probably feels as if “aaaaall” the other kids have smartphones.

    I decided to play a game with these middle schoolers and see what I could learn.

    “We’re gonna play speed text,” I told them. “The first one to text me what I ask for wins a point. The first one to ten points gets a gift card to Starbucks.”

    (Yes, I bribe middle school kids with caffeine. Parents love me.)

    Kids were already entering my number in their phones and sitting there poised, waiting for my first question.

    “Send me your first and last name and a selfie,” I said.

    They all held up their phones, tapped off a quick selfie, and began typing furiously.

    My phone blew up. Ding. Ding. Ding . . .

    Within two seconds, I had thirteen texts with hilarious pics of each of their faces.

    I kept going. “Send me a picture of your shoes.”

    Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding . . .

    Nikes. Checkered Vans. More checkered Vans.

    “Send me a screenshot of the app you spend the most time on.”

    Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding . . .

    Again, my phone blew up with pictures of Snapchat, Instagram, TikTok, and some of their favorite mobile games . . .

    “Send me a screenshot of the most recent song you were listening to.”

    Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding . . .

    That question was pretty revealing. Kids don’t really stop and think when they’re playing this kind of game. So I was receiving raw screenshots of the songs they had just been playing through their earbuds moments before. Mostly songs Mom or Dad didn’t know about. (You can learn a lot about kids from their phones.)

    A kid named Jordan was the first to ten. I gave him a fist bump and the Starbucks card and then began asking the class questions.

    “So when did you get your phones?”

    Kids didn’t hesitate to answer.

    “Last year.”

    “I’ve had mine for a couple years now.”

    “My older brother got a new one, so I got his old one.”

    “I noticed many of you have Snapchat and Instagram. So when did you first get social media?”

    Kids shouted answers, almost bragging.

    “It’s the first thing I downloaded.”

    “Since fifth grade.”

    Then I asked a question that surprised them a little bit. “How many of you knew you were going to have to lie about your age to get on social media?” (Most of these kids had just admitted they downloaded social media apps before age thirteen. You have to be thirteen to sign up for any of these apps.)

    They all smiled and looked at each other for a moment, as if they were wondering, Should I tell him? But they did.

    “My sister told me I’d have to.”

    “I didn’t know until I tried. But it was simple. You just type in a different year.”

    “I used my same birthday but a different year. That way people still know my birthday.”

    Then I asked one final question.

    “How many of your parents know you lied about your age?”

    After just fifteen minutes interacting with this particular group of young people, it immediately became apparent: These kids all had smartphones, they spent countless hours soaking in mobile entertainment, and they were all on social media. Their parents also knew very little about what they were doing on their phones every day.

    Maybe that’s why parents are so quick to hand their kids a screen. They have no idea what they’re actually giving their kids. That’s why I typically spend the first half of a parenting workshop giving parents a very realistic glimpse of what’s on their kids’ screens. I show them a few snippets from the top songs, games, and videos. Then I’ll show them real comments that have been posted and predatory behaviors that happen on social media when kids leave their privacy settings on public. As I mentioned earlier, an overwhelming majority of young people use the public setting because they want more followers.

    After showing parents all of this, I ask, “Do your kids have their privacy settings so anyone can see their profile?”

    I can see the looks on their faces. Moms and dads have no idea, and now they’re thinking, Why did I give my fifth grader a phone?

    But some parents didn’t even make that decision themselves. I talk with divorced parents frequently, and some of them tell me that the other spouse gave their kids a phone without discussing it with them first. No divorced parent wants to be the bad guy and say, “Not in this house!” They know that their kids will simply say, “Well, then I want to go live with Dad!”

    Sometimes schools issue screens, and not just during global pandemics. Some schools issue fourth and fifth graders iPads or other tablets.

    Parents always ask me, “Can my kid get into any trouble on these screens?”

    It depends. I’ve spoken with several people who work in technology for school districts all over the country. Most of them are pretty confident that kids can’t wander into too much trouble while they’re connected on the school networks. But when kids bring the devices home—and most do—they’re often free to browse wherever they want, depending on the home connection. (More on this in our chapter about parental controls.)

    So here are the key questions we’ll talk about in this chapter:

  • What is the right age to give kids their own phones?
  • What about other screens?
  • What if your kids already have screens, and you’re having second thoughts?
  • Let’s see if we can answer them.

    What Is the Right Age to Give Kids Their Own Phones?

    I think it’s always helpful to look at what the experts are saying about this issue. These are the people who really know the ins and outs of technology.

    In a recent interview with The Mirror, Microsoft founder Bill Gates revealed that he didn’t let any of his three children get a smartphone until they were fourteen and in high school.[2] He also doesn’t allow screens at the dinner table, and he limits screen time for his youngest child before bedtime.

    Like Gates, CEO Jim Steyer of Common Sense Media didn’t give his kids smartphones until high school, “after they [had] learned restraint and the value of face-to-face communication.”[3]

    I know what you’re thinking. Is waiting until high school realistic when all my kids’ friends are getting devices younger? I hear you, and I agree it’s frustrating. But if you research this topic, you’ll encounter the words high school again and again. The age level is about the same as learning to drive.

    Greg Lukianoff, coauthor of The Coddling of the American Mind: How Good Intentions and Bad Ideas Are Setting Up a Generation for Failure, speaks about this topic not only in his book but in countless follow-up articles. In one of those articles, he was very specific about age, especially after examining extensive research on the effects social media has had on kids, particularly on young girls:

    The case is now much stronger that girls who become heavy users of social media have worse mental health. . . . Parents should try to delay the day when their kids (especially daughters) get accounts on Instagram and other platforms where people rate them and comment on their looks and their posts. They should talk with their children about the dangers of these platforms, and they should consider tight time limits on their use (such as one or at most two hours a day). School districts should help parents by strongly suggesting the norm that no kids get social media accounts until high school, to avoid the fear of exclusion that leads many parents to allow their kids to lie about their age and open an Instagram account in sixth grade, or even fifth grade. Middle school is already so hard on kids, and social media makes the worst parts even worse.[4] (Emphasis added)

    There are those words again: high school. I hope school districts take Lukianoff’s advice and recommend that parents create a norm of delaying when kids get devices. Because right now, kids who don’t have phones feel excluded. Middle school kids without phones feel pressure from their friends to have them so they can get on social media with everyone else.

    But peer pressure doesn’t change the opinions of mental-health experts. A few years ago, the New York Times ran an article asking, “What’s the right age for a child to get a smartphone?”

    “The takeaway will not please smartphone makers,” the author concluded. “The longer you wait to give your children a smartphone, the better.”[5]

    Jesse Weinberger, author and internet safety speaker, says, “The longer you keep Pandora’s box shut, the better off you are.”[6]

    Simon Sinek, author and professor at Columbia University, speaks to this in his YouTube talk about smartphone addiction and the dopamine hits social media provides:

    Parents have to intervene. We have to stop giving our kids free access to social media and phones at young ages. They are not ready for it. Their minds cannot cope with the dopamine.[7]

    Dopamine is a chemical released in the reward centers of the brain that helps you remember what feels good when you do certain activities, like taking drugs or playing the slots in Vegas. The next time that particular activity is dangled before your senses, dopamine gives you a rush, triggering the anticipation of good feelings and fueling a desire to engage in the activity even more. For that reason, dopamine-triggering behaviors easily become a habit, which is why most studies show that social media leads to more social media. (And since I’m not a neuroscientist, I’m going to leave it at that.)

    Tristan Harris, a former design ethicist at Google, says that phones are designed to be addictive.[8] Citing Harris, Humanity Forward founder Andrew Yang says, “We’re all walking around with slot machines in our pockets. We don’t let our children into casinos; we should be just as wary of letting these casinos into our children’s hands.”[9]

    Young people don’t recognize these dangers. That’s why the advice I give is similar to the advice of these tech experts: Don’t be in a hurry to give your kids a phone. Only give them a device this powerful when you can invest the time in teaching them how to use it responsibly. Don’t just toss them a device with the excuse that they probably understand how to use it better than you do. Sure, they might know how to operate it, but most young people haven’t thought through the ramifications of whom they friend, what they post, and where they navigate. These are very difficult decisions for a child.

    Some parents will press me for a number.

    “What age?” they ask.

    “It depends on the kid,” I always respond. “It’s about maturity more than age.”

    But for some reason, people always insist I give them some sort of broad-stroke average age.

    “When are they typically mature enough?” they ask.

    So I’ll tell them, “Bare minimum, thirteen years old.”

    Why? Because one of the first things kids download on their phones is social media, and you can’t be on social media until you’re thirteen without lying about your age.

    This makes the social media debate pretty clear cut.

    If they want to know why, tell them it’s the law. It’s called COPPA, or the Federal Trade Commission’s Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act. And even if your kids have never heard of the law, they know about it. Because when anyone tries to sign up for Snapchat, Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, or any other social media app they desire, they first have to enter their birth date. If a kid is under thirteen, the app will reply, “Sorry, you are not old enough to use this app.”

    That’s because COPPA doesn’t allow websites or social media apps to collect personal information from anyone under thirteen without parental consent.[10]

    Does it work? Does it prohibit kids under thirteen from getting on social media?

    Not in the slightest.

    That’s because no one’s policing it. Especially parents. Every time I’m on a middle school campus, I see countless eleven- and twelve-year-olds on Snapchat and Instagram, because they simply lied about their age to sign up.

    So the pressure is on. When you tell your kid, “Sorry, you can’t download Snapchat because you’re not thirteen yet. It’s the law,” your kid is going to argue, “But Chris has Snapchat, and he’s eleven!”

    Your kid isn’t lying.

    That’s one of the reasons why it’s better not to give your kids a phone until thirteen years of age or later. The temptation to lie about their age to get on social media is just too great.

    Every weekend at my workshops, I talk with parents who gave their kids a phone at age eleven or twelve. And they all quickly discovered that their kids immediately wanted Snapchat or Instagram so they could communicate with their friends.

    “Why have a phone if you can’t have Instagram?” kids say.

    Even if Mom or Dad says no, many kids will disobey and download social media without their parents’ knowledge. So delay device ownership.

    The answer isn’t no; it’s not yet.

    What about Other Screens?

    “Oh, I would never give my kids a phone,” one mom told me.

    Wait for it.

    I knew it was coming.

    “I got them an iPad.”

    Whenever a parent tells me this, I try to be understanding, so I just walk them through the logic.

    Think about this for a second. What’s the difference between a phone and a tablet?

    Besides portability and size, there’s basically one difference: cellular connection.

    In other words, smartphones automatically have a cellular connection, but most tablets have only Wi-Fi connectability. However, with a tablet, your kids can still download all the same social media, play the same mobile games, watch the same YouTube videos (but on a bigger screen), stream the same movies (in greater detail), and listen to the same music.

    If your kids have a tablet without a cellular connection, the only thing they can’t do is put their tablet in a pocket, go out in the middle of a field, and connect.

  • They can still connect to everything at home through Wi-Fi.
  • They can still connect at school and almost any public place.
  • They can even still connect in the middle of nowhere by using their friends’ hot spots.
  • Bottom line: if your kids want an iPad or tablet of any kind, use the same discretion you’d use if they wanted a phone. Consider these questions:

  • Are my kids mature enough to begin making these decisions about content?
  • Do I want my kids to start feeling the pressure to be on social media?
  • Am I ready for the battles they will fight over screen time and bringing their tablets into the bedroom at night?
  • Do I want to monitor the apps my kids are downloading, the connections they’re making, and the content they’re streaming?
  • Am I ready to begin teaching my kids the responsibility that comes with tablet ownership . . . or do I just “throw them the keys”?
  • It’s not that screens are bad or evil. Owning a screen is just like owning a car. It requires taking on a lot of responsibility.

    But screens will also change the interaction in your home.

    Last spring I taught a parenting workshop in the South. Loretta Lynn territory. (I had some amazing barbecue on the way there.) A mom approached me after the workshop and told me a story about her son.

    “I caved and bought him an iPad,” she began.

    “When?” I asked.

    “Last year when he turned eight. And slowly he began to change.”

    “How so?”

    “It just started to absorb him,” she explained. “Every time we’d try to talk with him or call him down to dinner, he gave us attitude. It was a fight to get him to put down the screen.”

    “So what did you do?”

    “One day he was being so disrespectful, I just took it away.”

    “How’d that work out?”

    “He threw a fit. Day one, he screamed and yelled. Day two, he argued and fought. Day three, he just moped around like he was on death row.”

    I laughed.

    “But then something interesting happened,” she said. “He slowly emerged from his bedroom like he used to and started hanging around with us again.”

    “That’s cool,” I said.

    “About three weeks passed,” she continued. “And I had told him I was taking his iPad away for a month. But we were supposed to go on a trip, just him, me, and my mom—his grandma. We do this trip every year.”

    “That sounds nice.”

    “So I told my mom that I took away his iPad, and she said, ‘For the trip? Aren’t you going to give it back to him? All that time in the car. What is he gonna do?’”

    “So what did you do?” I asked.

    “I didn’t give it back. He had to ride with us without it, and”—here she paused, and her eyes teared up. I gave her a moment.

    “Sorry,” she said. “But as we hit the open road, he said, ‘Mom, look at that old barn. Look at those baby cows. Look at those trees.’ It was like he had never seen a stupid tree before!”

    She wiped her tears with her sleeve. “I’m never giving that thing back to him.”

    Some kids just aren’t ready for the responsibility that comes with having a screen.

    What If Your Kids Already Have Screens, and You’re Having Second Thoughts?

    Parents always ask me, “What if I already gave my kid a phone, and now I’m having second thoughts? What now? Should I take it away?”

    Here’s one of those instances where you want to be very careful not to overreact and just yank your kid’s device away. That’s like telling your kid, “We’re going to Disneyland!” but then after buying the tickets and walking one hundred feet into the park, you look around skeptically at the crowd and announce, “Sorry, we’re going home!”

    This decision will have a psychological impact!

    “Remember when Dad took us to Disneyland for two minutes?” they’ll say.

    Kids love their screens. Big-time. According to a number of surveys, it’s their most prized possession. So think through this decision shrewdly. And make sure you and your spouse are in agreement (even Stepmom, Stepdad, the ex—everyone), or your kids will start playing the adults against each other.

    Before you take screens away from your kids, consider a few options (and age is a huge factor). If you already handed your eight- or ten-year-old a screen, then, sure, you could explain some of the dangers and take it away. But if you do, prepare for battle. This is something you gave your child and then revoked. That’s tough on a kid.

    A shrewder approach might be to sit down and talk with your kids about the dangers and then just set some very strict boundaries with the screens, letting your kids know, “If you violate any of these rules even once, say good-bye to your screen until age thirteen.” Then if your kids violate the screen rules, it’s much easier to take their devices away (not without whining and complaining), because at least they understand that it’s the punishment for violating the rules.

    While you’re at it, access the parental controls on your kids’ devices and block out many, if not most, of the dangers. No, I’m not talking about filtering software. I’m talking about fully lobotomizing their phones, setting secure passwords, blocking the ability to download apps or social media without a password, and thinking of ways to limit screen time to a minimum. (We’ll talk more about screen-time limits in an upcoming chapter.) Minimizing screen time is better than taking your kid’s phone away and announcing, “Sorry. My bad. I should never have given you this phone in the first place.”

    For example, if you gave your fourteen-year-old a phone, and you’re just scared because of all the dangers, in 95 percent of cases, I wouldn’t take it away. In fact, I would consider giving my fourteen-year-old a phone if he or she asked for one (but I wouldn’t bring it up). That way, teens can start learning to be responsible before they leave the home.

    If your teens break a rule with their devices or prove to be irresponsible, sure, you might ground them without their phones for a period of time or until they prove they’re responsible. But taking away a phone just because you’re worried could have very negative consequences. I’ve witnessed hundreds of parents overreact and become too restrictive with their teens. Typically, I’ve seen several negative results:

  • Teens distance themselves from their parents—“Dad just doesn’t understand.” So they look to other role models from whom to glean values and learn how to make decisions. The parents’ impact is severely impaired.
  • Teens cheat and find a way to access screens when Mom and Dad aren’t around. Rule of thumb: the tighter parents squeeze, the more the kids slip out of their hands.
  • Parents panic and tip the scales toward boundaries, and then bonding suffers. Sadly, boundaries don’t teach our kids discernment.
  • You’ll hear me say this over and over: Remember to keep your eye on the calendar. Someday your kids will be eighteen and will leave the house, free to download whatever they want. Are you preparing them for that day? Or are you just making every decision for them?

    So how can you navigate these conversations?

    If you’ve already given your kids screens, think hard before revoking screen privileges. There are much better ways to protect them. If your kids are ten years old or younger, and you’ve already given them screens, maybe just use parental controls, screen limits, and guidelines to severely restrict access. (This book will lay out what those guidelines can actually look like.) If your kids are eleven to thirteen, and you’ve already given them screens, be proactive about connection before correction. They’ll appreciate your talking with them rather than just laying down the law.

    How do you talk with kids about screen privileges?

    Practice the five steps you read about in chapter 2, when you learned how to create a climate of comfortable conversation about these issues:

  • When you read something in this book that piques your interest, bring it up at a family gathering. Break the ice with a fun question. For example, “If there was a power outage and all your screens and devices ran out of battery life, what would be the first thing you’d do for fun?”
  • Bring up the issue you’d like to talk about by reading a noteworthy paragraph or study. Then ask your kids’ opinions. Listen; don’t lecture. Just ask questions, such as . . .
    • When did most of your friends get their phones?
    • Why do you think so many tech experts tell parents to wait until their kids get into high school to give them phones?
    • What are some of the things middle school kids would miss if nobody got phones or social media until high school?
    • What problems might actually be avoided if middle school kids didn’t get phones or social media until high school?
  • Practice empathy by stepping into your kids’ shoes and trying to understand their viewpoints and feelings. Don’t criticize their responses; just listen.
  • Ask your kids, “What do you think is best? How would you solve the problem at hand?” Or, in this case, ask, “When do you think parents should allow their kids to get their own phones?”
  • Delay correction or decisions. Actually walk away. Don’t rush to set boundaries or impose a decision right away. Tell your kids you need some time to think and pray about the situation.

    You might practice these steps over and over as you’re reading this book. Then, eventually, when you finish the book, you’ll add one final step:

  • Set a time to talk about what you’ve read and make some decisions about screens. Give your kids advance notice. You might say, “This Thursday we’re going out for pizza to talk about how we can become screenwise in this house.”
  • Some of you might still be thinking, Jonathan, even if I walk through all of these steps, when I finally get to step six, should I take away the screens?

    What if you give your kids a choice?

    The Choice

    Don’t just lay down the law. Make it a choice. Not any old choice, but a choice with a healthy outcome either way.

    I remember talking with a therapist about one of my own kids who was very stubborn and resistant to any kind of rule. If my wife and I set a rule, it seemed as if we were dangling a carrot in front of him and shouting, “Break this rule!”

    I’ll never forget my counselor’s advice. (And yes, I just admitted that my wife, Lori, and I saw a counselor. It was one of the best decisions we ever made for our marriage and our parenting. I wish I had done it sooner.)

    She said, “If you have a kid who is pushing against authority, make everything a choice.”

    “How?” I called her bluff. “What if my kid was spending too much time playing video games?”

    “Say to him, ‘You’ve got a choice between two options: you can either keep playing that game system we bought you and abide by our time limits and grade requirements, or you can go get a job and buy your own game system, and then you’ll only be limited by the grade requirements we all agreed on.’”

    Pure genius. Give kids a choice.

    This would have been a win-win for our family. Even if my son did choose to get a job and buy his own game system (which would actually demonstrate a lot of drive and follow-through), he’d still have to keep up his grades to keep the privilege. This is Adulting 101. Good stuff.

    No matter what situation I shared with my counselor, she was able to come up with a set of choices we could propose to our child.

    You can do the same with your kids if you’ve already given them a phone. You could start off saying, “I’ve gotta be honest, the more I research some of the distractions screens cause and the dangers on social media . . .”

    At this point, your kids’ eyes will probably get really big. They might even scream, “Nooooooooo! Don’t take away my phone!” They see it coming.

    So don’t do it. Don’t take away their screens. Empower your kids by giving them a choice. Tell them, “So here’s what I’ve decided. You have a choice. I can either take away your phone, and you’ll get one when you start high school. It’s like driving—and you can’t do that until you’re sixteen. Or . . . ”

    They’ll be waiting for this “or” because they’d rather do anything but what you just suggested.

    So you say, “Or . . . we’ll go to breakfast once a week and talk about how to be responsible with your phone. If you meet weekly with me and read a book about becoming screenwise, you can keep your phone.”

    You’re giving your kids the choice between correction or connection. Ninety-nine out of one hundred kids will choose connection. (But if your kids choose correction, it’s time to reread chapter 2 and begin working on how you connect.)

    Sometimes kids won’t understand.

    Your son may ask, “Why can’t I just have the phone? My friend Taylor has a phone, and his parents don’t make him do nothing.” (Don’t hold your kid’s grammar against him.)

    If he wants to know why, elaborate with this analogy:

    Your phone is like a car. Some people learn how to drive a car, obey speed limits, change lanes safely, avoid distractions, and drive to school, church, and Grandma’s house. Others drive dangerously, speed, take their eyes off the road, and injure themselves or others. They will eventually lose the privilege of driving. So if you want to drive, you need to wait until you’re the right age. You’ll have to take a driver’s education course, study the driving manual, pass a written test, and even take a behind-the-wheel test. If and only if you prove that you’re responsible will you be allowed to drive. But even then, it will be limited at first. You won’t drive at night, or blast the radio, or have friends in the car. As you grow more mature and become more experienced, you’ll slowly be able to drive later at night and have friends in the car with you. The same will be true of your phone.

    Help your kids understand that the greater the privilege, the greater the responsibility. And once they turn fourteen, continue connecting with them and talking about stuff that matters. (I’ve written quite a few books about this that are just for young people—with discussion questions near the end of each chapter so you can read the book along with them and engage them in meaningful discussions.) Teach your kids discernment in all areas of life.

    Isn’t that the goal?

    Not Yet

    It’s intriguing to learn what people in the tech industry do with their own kids. They know the effects technology has on young people, especially social media.

    A couple years ago, the New York Times released an exposé featuring a bunch of tech-industry executives who live in Silicon Valley.[11] It’s ironic, but when these executives (and former executives) of companies such as Facebook, Apple, and Mozilla were interviewed, they said that when they left their homes in the morning, they gave one simple set of instructions to the nannies: “No screens.”

    And these parents are screen experts!

    Chris Anderson of Wired magazine said this about screen time:

    On the scale between candy and crack cocaine, it’s closer to crack cocaine. . . . We thought we could control it, and this is beyond our power to control. This is going straight to the pleasure centers of the developing brain. This is beyond our capacity as regular parents to understand.[12]

    Anderson didn’t give his kids phones until the summer before they started high school. He didn’t let them on social media until they were thirteen, and he didn’t allow phones in their bedrooms.

    These are extremely helpful guidelines from a guy who really understands technology.

    In the next chapter, we’ll look a little closer at why that last rule he mentioned—no phones in the bedroom—is so important.

    Discussion Questions

  • Why do you think so many tech experts, including Jonathan, wait until their kids are thirteen or fourteen before giving them phones, when most parents give their kids phones at the average age of ten?
  • What are parents communicating to their kids who are younger than thirteen when they let them lie about their age to get on social media?
  • What would happen if every parent in your community listened to Jonathan’s advice: “Only give your kids a device this powerful when you can invest the time in teaching them how to use it responsibly”?
  • If you gave screens to your kids when they were younger (before high school), were you surprised at Jonathan’s advice to “think through the decision shrewdly” before you take away their phones? Did you like any of the alternatives he suggested? Which one did you like most?
  • What’s the benefit of empowering your kids by giving them a choice, such as the choice to have their phones taken away or to meet together weekly to read through a book and discuss being wise with screens?
  • How do you think your kids would respond if you compared using a phone to driving a car?
  • How can you begin engaging your kids in these types of conversations this week?
  • [1] “Social Media, Social Life: Teens Reveal Their Experiences,” Common Sense Media, September 10, 2018, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/social-media-social-life-infographic.

    [2] Emily Retter, “Billionaire Tech Mogul Bill Gates Reveals He Banned His Children from Mobile Phones until They Turned 14,” Mirror, April 21, 2017, https://www.mirror.co.uk/tech/billionaire-tech-mogul-bill-gates-10265298.

    [3] Brian X. Chen, “What’s the Right Age for a Child to Get a Smartphone?,” New York Times, July 20, 2016, https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/21/technology/personaltech/whats-the-right-age-to-give-a-child-a-smartphone.html.

    [4] Greg Lukianoff, Adam Goldstein, and Pamela Paresky, “Catching Up with ‘Coddling’ Part Two: Trigger Warnings, Screen Time v. Social Media, COVID-19 and the Continuing Decline of Gen Z’s Mental Health,” FIRE, May 12, 2020, https://www.thefire.org/catching-up-with-coddling-part-two-trigger-warnings-screen-time-v-social-media-covid-19-and-the-continuing-decline-of-gen-zs-mental-health/.

    [5] Chen, “What’s the Right Age?”

    [6] Chen, “What’s the Right Age?”

    [7] Simon Sinek, This Addiction Is Ruining the Upcoming Generation (YouTube video), InnerLight Media, December 13, 2018.

    [8] Tristan Harris, interview by Christophe Haubursin in It’s Not You. Phones Are Designed to Be Addicting (video), Vox, February 27, 2018, https://www.vox.com/2018/2/27/17053758/phone-addictive-design-google-apple.

    [9] Candice L. Odgers and Michael B. Robb, Tweens, Teens, Tech, and Mental Health: Coming of Age in an Increasingly Digital, Uncertain, and Unequal World 2020 (San Francisco: Common Sense Media, 2020), 13, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/sites/default/files/uploads/pdfs/tweens-teens-tech-and-mental-health-full-report-final-for-web1.pdf.

    [10] Federal Trade Commission, “Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule (‘COPPA’),” 16 CFR Part 312, https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/rules/rulemaking-regulatory-reform-proceedings/childrens-online-privacy-protection-rule; see also Federal Trade Commission, “Complying with COPPA: Frequently Asked Questions, https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/complying-coppa-frequently-asked-questions-0.

    [11] Nellie Bowles, “A Dark Consensus about Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley,” New York Times, October 26, 2018, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/26/style/phones-children-silicon-valley.html.

    [12] Bowles, “A Dark Consensus.”

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑