Chapter 6: The Thing about Screen Time
CHAPTER 6: The Thing about Screen Time
Helping your kids learn to make wise screen-time choices
NATALIE IS FOURTEEN YEARS OLD, and like most of her friends, she’s had her smartphone since middle school. But after a few huge blowups over how much time she was “wasting” on her phone, her parents limited her screen time to just two hours a day. It was “unfair and oppressive” in Natalie’s opinion, but her mom had read some article about it.
So it was written; so it shall be done.
Natalie’s parents don’t really know what Natalie is doing on her phone. The reality is that social media is the one screen activity that seems to draw her in and distract her from what’s important.
Natalie’s app of choice is TikTok. She has Instagram and a few others as well, but TikTok is the one that distracts her from her homework. Whenever she opens up the app, she loses track of time. That’s what happens on TikTok. Kids are watching a never-ending variety show of the most popular acts in the world. The app quickly discovers what they like to watch and provides them with an endless supply of it, in unedited form.
Natalie’s parents never look at the app, so they have no idea what their daughter is watching. But they do occasionally remind her, “Only two hours, right?”
“Yes, Mom. I probably don’t even hit that anymore,” Natalie insists.
She isn’t really intending to lie, but she’s clocking way over that.
She’s not alone. The average teenager clocks more then seven hours of screen time daily.[1] These numbers vary by age, gender, and other factors—even household income. For example, teens from higher-income homes ($100,000 or more) average six hours and forty-nine minutes per day of daily screen time, while teens from lower-income homes (less than $35,000) average eight hours and thirty-two minutes per day.[2]
This is just screen time. It doesn’t even include the time kids spend listening to music on Spotify or iTunes. That’s a lot of entertainment media.
Natalie is a good student and an athlete, so she doesn’t quite approach the seven-hour average, but she easily doubles her screen-time limit, exceeding two hours on social media alone.
Her attachment to her phone is evident seconds after her phone alarm goes off in the morning. Her phone is right by her bedside.
The first thing she does after turning off her alarm is check Instagram. In middle school, all of her friends used Snapchat, but now Instagram is Natalie’s main way of connection with her friends.
Typically she’ll check a few of her friends’ stories, along with a couple of celebs she follows. Then on the way to school, she’ll scroll through her Insta-feed to see who’s doing what. Once she’s caught up, she’ll open TikTok until she arrives at the campus.
Then she’ll greet her friends, but before school, everyone’s phones are still out. Sometimes she and her friends will show each other a funny post or video they saw the night before. Then they’ll all return texts and DMs.
By the time the first bell rings, it’s unusual if Natalie has spent less than thirty minutes on her phone.
Phones are supposed to be kept in students’ pockets during the school day, unless a teacher specifically allows students to have them out. Two of Natalie’s teachers don’t mind students pulling out their phones when their work is finished. And kids tend to find other times to use their phones, such as in the bathrooms or in between classes when no adults are around. Natalie can usually clock in another twenty to thirty minutes of screen time during school. And honestly, that’s a lot less than most of her friends.
Natalie clocks another ten minutes close to or during soccer practice. And another ten on the way home.
By the time Natalie arrives home, she’s usually approaching ninety minutes of screen time.
Before dinner, Natalie showers and then plops on her bed and looks at TikTok videos, thinking, I bet I could do that. She doesn’t want to become a full-time influencer by any means. But it would be fun to have enough followers to get a few sponsors.
No screens are allowed during dinnertime at Natalie’s house. But dinner is usually only about fifteen minutes, and then everybody scatters. That’s when Natalie attacks her homework—with her phone right next to her books.
And that’s where screen time is pretty hard to track:
Do math three minutes uninterrupted.
Bzzzzzzz.
Who’s that? Oh. Just Kristen posting a picture of her stupid Frenchie.
Math one minute.
Bzzzzzzz.
Michael trying to flirt.
Math two minutes.
Bzzzzzzz.
Alexis posting a rant about an unfair quiz Mr. Reynolds gave. Tons of kids are commenting. Ha. Chris Mangold is so funny.
Math one minute.
Bzzzzzzz.
Michael again. Another DM talking about a video, and a link.
Natalie watches the four-minute video. Some girl from Atlanta posted it. She’s a really good dancer. Then Natalie swipes to see some of her other videos. They’re good. She clocks another twenty minutes watching her videos.
Natalie’s mom peeks in the door and sees Natalie looking at her phone.
“Natalie, aren’t you supposed to be doing homework?”
“I am,” Natalie says, throwing her phone aside and picking up her pencil. “I just need my phone for my homework. Group project.”
“Well, don’t get distracted,” her mom says. “Remember your two-hour limit.”
“I’m not distracted, Mom. I’ve barely been on my phone at all today. I haven’t had time.”
Natalie knows she’s stretching the truth a bit. But honestly, she has no idea that she’s already spent more than two hours on social media alone. And when she finishes her homework, she’ll clock in at least an hour on Netflix and another hour on social media, depending on the night. And once her lights are out, she often scrolls through social media in her bed until she falls asleep. This can last twenty minutes . . . or hours.
After all is said and done, Natalie typically spends about four to six hours on her screen each day, well short of the average screen time for teens her age.
Is this too much?
Should Natalie’s parents do anything different?
How Much Time?
Nearly every expert agrees it’s wise for moms and dads to set some helpful screen-time limits for their kids. The question is, how much?
Wouldn’t it be nice if the answer was a simple number?
Two hours of screen time. No more.
And how do you track something so sprinkled throughout the day?
Sadly, it’s not that simple. On top of that, all screen time is not created equal. I think America witnessed this in 2020 during the COVID-19 outbreak, when everyone was sequestered in their homes. No contact with anyone—except through screens. Even those who were set against screen use realized that if they prohibited screens, they were cutting off their kids’ distance learning and social connection. All screen time is not the same.
It makes sense. Your daughter’s Zoom call to her cousin shouldn’t be lumped in the same category as scrolling through her Instagram feed. We’re talking about two very different screen activities. In fact, most experts would actually recommend using screens to engage in conversations with extended family. And yes, as we read in the previous chapter, most experts would severely caution against any young girl spending more than two hours a day on social media.
Screen time varies.
My nephew loves YouTube. Sometimes he’s just watching silly videos. But at other times, he’s learning new skills by watching talented guitar players. (He’s getting really good.) His dad doesn’t want to limit his guitar-learning YouTube time. But endless silly videos? And they’re both on YouTube. How do you set parental controls for that?
How are parents expected to navigate this? And should they even worry about screen activities like playing video games or watching videos?
Honestly . . . is it too much work to track?
The good news is, doctors do almost unanimously agree on screen-time limits for young children. The research is pretty clear. As for adolescents, there is still some debate, but as you read in the last chapter, researchers from opposing viewpoints recently came to a consensus that too much social media has a negative effect on the mental health of our kids.
Let’s look at some helpful screen-time recommendations; then I’ll offer a few tips on how to apply them in your home.
Screen Limits for Young Kids: Birth to Age Five
Screen-time recommendations are pretty clear for young kids. It’s as simple as this:
I know, I know. If I had kids under five years of age, I’d probably be screaming at this book right now: “Do you realize how hard it is to raise a two-year-old and a four-year-old?”
It’s okay. Scream at me. I can take it. (I can’t, actually. I’m kind of a wimp. Way too sensitive. But I don’t mind if you yell at my book.)
When my three kids were one, three, and five years old, I watched them in the morning while my wife, Lori, was at work. And on many mornings by ten o’clock, I was already spent! (I told you I’m a wimp.) But I knew if I put on the movie Aladdin (one of my son’s favorites), I had one hour and twenty-six minutes of peace and quiet (that’s when the credits start to roll). Even my one-year-old would sit there in her baby bouncer and become entranced by the screen. (I’m admitting it. I put my baby in front of a screen.) I’ll be completely candid: It was wonderful! I cherished that ninety minutes.
Nothing held my kids’ attention like Aladdin!
And now I hear parents tell me similar stories.
“If I don’t give my kid my phone in the car, he freaks out!”
“If I limit my son’s video-game time, he’s a monster!”
I don’t want to be the bad guy, and I don’t want to go on a tangent about coddling or even enabling your kids, but I will say this: Don’t get your kids hooked on screens early. An hour or two max.
You are the parent. It’s okay to say no.
Let me add that most of the screen-demanding behaviors of kids are taught, not inherited. In other words, if we didn’t give our kids our phones in the car in the first place, they wouldn’t get in the habit of watching videos in the car, and we wouldn’t have to deal with any tantrums when we suddenly deny them of that privilege.
Don’t shoot the messenger. The fact is, the American Academy of Pediatrics has been recommending strict screen limits for years, and they’ve done the research to back it up.[4] Face-to-face connection with infants and toddlers is far superior. And if you do allow your two- to five-year-olds to watch any programming, experts recommend you watch it with them so you can dialogue with them about it and help them apply it to real life.
“Do you see what Sarah Connor is doing? She’s training her son to evade the evil Terminator so he can save the human race. You can do the same with bullies at preschool.” (Okay, maybe not that movie.)
So don’t just plop your kids in front of the TV and take a nap. Watch their favorite show with them, and when you’re done, play with them! Run up to your toddler and in your best Grover voice say, “Near.” Tickle them, then run away and say, “Far.”
Interacting with our kids is crucial. Most studies reveal that “passive screen time shouldn’t replace reading, playing or problem-solving.”[5]
In short, keep screens off as often as possible when your kids are young, especially in the evening hours. Research shows that “even infants exposed to screen media in the evening hours show significantly shorter night-time sleep duration than those with no evening screen exposure.”[6]
A screen might seem like a great babysitter because TV makes your kids happy for the moment. But so do cake and ice cream for breakfast.
So be proactive about creating safe areas where kids can have unstructured play. Get toys that allow them to be creative and active. And mix in structured activities where you can interact with them about what you’re doing. Take them on walks and talk about what you see around you. Bring them to a park or playground where they can play with other kids their age. And if your location permits, make a safe place in the yard where your kids can play outside.
I remember when my five-year-old would become restless and give me that “There’s nothing to do” look. That’s when I’d usually say, “Okay, time to go outside.”
He would put on his little rubber boots, go into the backyard, and play. He was always a little pouty at first, but typically within about three to five minutes, I’d see him walking around with a stick, stabbing imaginary dragons, and making a fortress out of old boxes and lawn chairs.
And if I was being a really good parent, I would go out there with him after a while and say, “Can I play too?”
Yes, this takes a little more work.
Good parenting always does.
Screen Limits for Preadolescents: Ages Six to Eleven
Here’s where the limits on screen time become a little blurry. As kids grow and mature, you’ll start to hear researchers who study the effects of screens on children say things like “Not all kids are the same” and “There is no one-size-fits-all approach.”
But I find it interesting to note the areas where most researchers agree.
Studies vary in their conclusions about how much video-game time is too much or how much TV our kids should watch. But almost every study about preadolescents and screens agrees on the following guidelines:
Yes, none of these guidelines talk about how many hours. That’s because no one agrees on a specific “healthy” number of screen-time hours for preadolescents. But I think you’ll find that if you adhere to the recommendations that experts do agree on, it really won’t allow for a lot of screen time.
For example, consider the guideline “Make sure your kids are close by when they’re watching screens, not off in a bedroom by themselves.” This guideline alone will really help filter both the quality and quantity of screen time. If little eight-year-old Madison is flipping through the channels and lands on Pulp Fiction, Mom will hear Samuel L. Jackson yelling and switch channels.
That’s one of the reasons I didn’t allow headphones in my house. I wanted to hear what my kids were listening to. In fact, as they got older, I bought each of them a nice speaker for their phones so they could play loud music in their bedrooms.
Some of my friends asked me, “Jonathan, why did you get your kids big ol’ speakers? Won’t you constantly have to ask them to turn their music down?”
I always replied, “Because I considered the alternative: them listening to who knows what through headphones. Speakers provided a certain accountability while they were young.”
For those of you who are still wondering, “Jonathan, if experts don’t agree on specific screen-time limits, how many hours should I let my ten-year-old lie on the couch playing video games?”
Personally, I think that gaming screen time for this age group should be limited to just one or two hours a day, depending on the kid and his or her age. And I might make exceptions; for example, when Mom or Dad plays with their preadolescent kids.
Some kids don’t even like video games and would rather sit and watch TV all day. Those kids might need TV screen-time limits. I say need because if we don’t limit screen time, we’ll start to see the consequences. For example, according to the Mayo Clinic, “too much or poor quality screen time” is associated with the following:
This means you’ll need to find some helpful screen limits that fit each of your kids in your setting. During the summer, you might let your kids have a little extra recreational screen time. If your nine-year-old is creative and loves to make little videos, you might not want to limit that screen time as much. But as soon as he wants to start posting those videos publicly to YouTube, you need to become highly involved, because YouTube is officially a social media site for people over thirteen years of age. (Kids under thirteen are supposed to go to YouTube Kids, but not many do.) Whenever your kids post content for others to view, like, and comment on, you’ve entered a whole different category of screen time, and the research about that is becoming crystal clear: monitor it and limit it heavily.
That brings us to the world of adolescents.
Screen Limits for Adolescents: Ages Twelve to Nineteen
The reason I start with age twelve here instead of thirteen is because twelve is when many kids begin middle school, and that’s a huge year of transition.
The screen limits for adolescents are similar to the screen limits for six- to eleven-year-olds in that there is no consensus among the experts on a certain number of hours. This becomes more difficult with adolescents because they’re more likely to carry a screen with them almost every hour of the day.
How on earth do you track that?
Here’s where I’ll remind you once again: rules won’t raise your kids. You don’t have to track your kids’ screen time. Neither the Bible nor the most current medical journals dictate that you spy on your kids and control their every move. In fact, both the Bible and most medical journals recommend another method: talk with your kids about this stuff . . . a lot!
Don’t get me wrong. I’m not recommending no screen limits. I’m actually trying to let you off the hook a little bit. You don’t need to monitor your kids 24/7. It’s far better to do what we’ve been talking about throughout this book: first engage your kids in conversations about becoming screenwise, then set some fair and reasonable guardrails that will help them stay on course.
So what are some reasonable and loving screen limits for adolescents? Considering what most experts agree on, here are my recommendations:
Yes, you don’t see a lot of specific screen-time limits in this list, other than “No screens one hour before bedtime” and “Limit social media to just one or two hours per day.” That’s because many of these loving limits depend on the kids, their exact ages, and their maturity level.
But don’t underestimate the specificity of these recommendations, because as vague as some of them might seem, the simple “No devices in the bedroom at night” rule will probably keep most kids from spending hours upon hours on their screens daily.
Picture Natalie, the fourteen-year-old at the beginning of the chapter who averaged four to six hours of screen time per day, even though her parents told her, “Only two hours.”
How would the screen limits I just listed help Natalie’s parents?
If Natalie is like most young girls today, the hours she’s devoting to her favorite screen activities are taking a toll on her mental health.
And here’s the scary element of all this: Natalie is actually above the curve compared to most girls her age. She spends less time on screens and actually participates in a sport that gives her more than an hour of physical activity each day.
Don’t underestimate the positive impact activity can have on your kids.
A group of researchers conducted a study with more than 4,200 adolescents ranging from twelve to sixteen years of age to see how their daily activities affected how they felt about themselves. The results were fascinating.[8]
Twelve-, fourteen-, and sixteen-year-olds wore accelerometers so researchers could track their movements. “The study found that every extra hour of daily activity helped to lower depressive symptoms by 7.8 to 11.1 percent, depending on the age of the child.” In fact, depressive symptoms increased by nearly the same percentages “for every extra hour of sedentary behavior” the kids recorded. Sitting around staring at screens didn’t help. “Adolescents with the highest amounts of inactivity during their teen years had depression scores over 28 percent higher than other children.”[9]
Screen time matters.
So what might loving limits look like in your home?
Applying Loving Screen Limits in Your Home
How can you apply these screen recommendations with your kids?
First, engage them in conversations about what healthy limits might look like. Don’t just lay down the law. Discuss the why behind the limits. Maybe even practice what you’ve learned throughout this book about creating a climate of comfortable conversation about these issues:
- Why do you think most experts recommend limiting the time on social media for teens?
- What screen limits do you think would be helpful for most teens?
When you finish the book, add this step:
As you engage in these discussions with your kids, pay attention to their ages, because age and maturity matter.
No Rules Senior Year
If you look at the recommended screen limits in this chapter, you’ll notice a principle that applies to all of parenting: start strict, then give more freedom as your kids mature.
When I was conducting research for my book If I Had a Parenting Do-Over, I asked hundreds of parents one simple question: “If you could go back in time and change one parenting practice, what would you do over?”
I was shocked at how many parents answered the same as I did: “I wish I hadn’t been so strict with my teenager.” The answer came in many forms:
If you look at the guidelines in this chapter, they are superstrict with young kids: no screen time at all for kids under two years of age. Then the screen-time limits lighten up after age two: one or two hours a day. For preadolescents, screen time varies, but other limits help parents filter the quality and quantity of screen time. And finally, when kids enter adolescence, you begin to see a lot more about helping them learn how to make these screen-time decisions on their own.
I remember when my oldest daughter was in middle school and she was whining to me about one of my rules one day.
“Dad, all my friends can listen to this music!”
That’s when I told her, “You might think I’m strict now, but all your friends are going to be jealous of you your senior year, because you’re going to have no rules at all.”
My daughter was silent for about ten seconds. Then she turned and said, “Oh, okay.” She didn’t even ask another question.
And I kept my word. I was very strict with my kids during middle school, but when they entered high school, they had more freedom, until both of my girls finally experienced no rules their senior year.
Yes, no rules.
Here’s the thing. So many of us lay down rules until our kids leave the house. Then—poof!—like magic, they’re completely free to do whatever they want. Chances are your kids won’t call you from their college dorms and ask if they can watch the new HBO show their roommate is streaming. They’re going to make that decision on their own, and the only question you can ask yourself right now is Am I equipping them for that day?
I let my girls experience no rules a year before they left for college. That included total freedom with their screens. They chose what they downloaded. They decided how much screen time was enough. I knew they’d be making these decisions on their own in college, so why not practice during their senior year of high school?
No rules didn’t mean they could disrespect our family and smoke weed in the living room. In fact, not much changed.
I remember my daughter Ashley asking me, “Dad, can I spend the night at Rosie’s house?”
I laughed and said, “I don’t know. What do you think you should do?”
She inevitably replied, “Oh, that’s right. No rules.”
But then she started to do something very interesting. She’d ask me for advice. “Dad, what would you do if your friends put on a bad movie, and you don’t want to get up, leave, and make a scene?”
That’s where I eventually learned to resist my desire to lecture, or even limit, and listen instead. I would just ask, “What do you think is a good way to handle that?”
My daughters’ senior years became way more about coaching than setting limits.
Limits don’t raise your kids. Limits won’t teach them how to make good decisions. They’ll just help your kids steer clear of some pesky distractions. It’s up to you to engage your kids in conversations about what healthy limits might look like. And it’s up to you to model those limits in your own life.
Let me repeat that last sentence so we don’t miss it: It’s up to you to model those limits in your own life.
Do you have no-tech zones for yourself?
Do you spend too much time scrolling through social media or bingeing on Netflix?
Do you ever find yourself looking at your phone when you’re hanging out with your family (even if they might be doing it too)?
Do you let your phone keep you up at night?
If you think your own screen time is under control, try something. But first you’ll need to pray and ask God to give you a humble spirit, because you don’t want this exercise to turn into a fight. In fact, promise God you’ll listen and not argue. Once you have a teachable mind-set, ask your spouse, “Honey, are there any screen habits you wish I’d change?” Try the same with your kids. You might be surprised what they say.
It’s extremely valuable for your kids to see this humble, teachable spirit from you. You can teach what you know, but you can only reproduce who you are.
Discussion Questions
[1] Victoria Rideout and Michael B. Robb, The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Teens and Tweens (San Francisco: Common Sense Media, 2019), 3, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/sites/default/files/uploads/research/2019-census-8-to-18-full-report-updated.pdf.
[2] Rideout and Robb, Common Sense Census, 5.
[3] Jenny Radesky and Dimitri Christakis, “Media and Young Minds,” Pediatrics 138, no. 5 (Nov. 2016), https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/138/5/e20162591.
[4] Radesky and Christakis, “Media and Young Minds.”
[5] Mayo Clinic Staff, “Screen Time and Children: How to Guide Your Child,” Mayo Clinic, June 20, 2019, https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/childrens-health/in-depth/screen-time/art-20047952.
[6] Radesky and Christakis, “Media and Young Minds.”
[7] Mayo Clinic Staff, “Screen Time and Children.”
[8] Chris Melore, “Sitting around Harmful to Teens’ Mental Health; Just an Hour of Light Activity Can Prevent Depression,” Study Finds, May 25, 2020, https://www.studyfinds.org/sitting-around-harmful-to-teens-mental-health-just-an-hour-of-light-activity-can-prevent-depression/.
[9] Melore, “Sitting around Harmful.”
