Chapter 5: The Unintended Effects of Social Media
CHAPTER 5: The Unintended Effects of Social Media
And how to build your kids’ self-esteem
I ALWAYS FIND IT INTRIGUING when researchers with opposing viewpoints actually agree on something. And one of the few things they came to a consensus about recently, with very little pushback, are the effects of social media on kids’ mental health—especially teenage girls.
Social media is creating a pressurized environment for young people today, and their mental well-being is paying the price.
Why does social media impact mental health more than video games, music, or TV? And why more so since the release of smartphones?
Those are great questions. And the answers are becoming increasingly clear the more kids carry social media in their pockets.
Let’s take a closer look at why too much social media is hurting your kids’ mental health, what you can do to prevent it, and how you can be proactive about building your kids’ self-esteem.
The Barometer of Self-Esteem
I had a really tough time in middle school. I didn’t have many friends, and I ate quite a few lunches alone. One particular kid had it out for me. He and his friends practiced everything in the bullying handbook: knocking my books off my desk, slapping the back of my neck on cold mornings, writing embarrassing insults across my locker in permanent marker. Those were difficult years.
Most of my friends didn’t have it as tough as I did, but few of them would say those years were easy. It’s probably fair to say that adolescents have always struggled with fitting in.
But back then we all had one saving grace—a break from the pressure to be liked. For me, the final bell rang at 2:42 p.m., and I sprinted home to where I was safe until 7:55 the next morning. More than seventeen hours away from the torment.
But kids today don’t get a break from the pressure.
Now, at 2:42 p.m., the phones come out and kids enter a whole new world where they’re compared not only to their peers at school but to kids all over the world—kids who are better looking and more creative, with more likes and followers. In fact, each of these attributes are problematically represented by a number that everyone on social media can see:
These are the elite kids.
Then there are the normal kids like Katherine. She’s fun, creative, sweet . . . and on the swim team. But she has only 237 friends—a number that pales in comparison to the elite kids. And her last picture of her dog, Pugsly, wearing a sweater earned a mere 43 likes.
Do you think Katherine noticed?
Absolutely.
The numbers stare her in the face every time she opens up her social media profile. And scrolling down doesn’t help. More of the same.
The pressure is on.
Followers.
Likes.
I’m sure Steve Jobs never intended it, but the smartphone has become a real-time, portable barometer of self-esteem. It not only tells kids exactly how popular they are and how well liked their posts are; it also exposes them to a nonstop panel of cowardly critics who comment on their posts from the safety of their anonymous usernames.
Fitting in has never been so difficult.
A Consensus
So is all this pressure taking a toll on our kids’ mental health?
The debate has been ongoing for almost a decade.
Are smartphones bad for kids?
Is the increase of screen time linked to the unprecedented rise in depression, anxiety, and teen suicide?
Before I answer these questions, I should note that we’re not talking about a small increase. One in five adolescent girls experienced a major depressive episode at some point during 2017.[1] That’s an 84 percent increase during the past decade. And a report from the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) revealed that suicide rates among Americans ages ten to twenty-four increased by 56 percent between 2007 and 2017.[2] The iPhone came out in 2007. The biggest increases occurred among the very young, with suicide rates nearly tripling during that time period in ten- to fourteen-year-olds.
Researchers have been scratching their heads looking for the cause. Many have seen a correlation between suicide rates among teens and the increase in screen time that smartphones have created. Dr. Jean Twenge points this out in her article “Stop Debating Whether Too Much Smartphone Time Can Hurt Teens, and Start Protecting Them.” She says,
Four large studies of teens from the U.S. and U.K. all show the same thing: happiness and mental health are the highest at a half-hour to two hours of extracurricular digital media use a day; well-being then steadily decreases, with those who spend the most time online being the worst off.[3]
But here’s where the debate gets interesting. With researchers still disagreeing, Jonathan Haidt created an open-source literature review, pasting in the abstracts of all relevant studies he could find on both sides of the issue. He invited other researchers to add to the document, hoping to reach a consensus as to whether social media is a contributing factor in the increased rates of depression, anxiety, self-harm, and suicide among adolescents.[4]
In 2020, while I was writing this book, all of these researchers came to a consensus, basically agreeing on two undeniable truths:
What does this mean?
In short, these researchers overwhelmingly agreed that our girls are paying a price when they spend too much time on social media.
But these conclusions certainly aren’t unanimous. I just read a report today in which researchers claim that the amount of time adolescents spend on social media is not reliably linked to serious mental-health problems, such as depression and anxiety. They insist there simply isn’t enough evidence. I can’t help but wonder if this particular group of researchers has ever actually hung out with kids, because almost every youth worker I know clearly observes this link—specifically when girls spend too much time on social media. (We’ll talk more about this in the next chapter on screen time.)
Even though most experts have observed that young people suffer mental-health problems when they spend too much time on screens, it would be a mistake to lump all screen time together and call it evil. Netflix and Spotify, for example, don’t appear to have an observable negative impact on our kids’ mental health. But when we look into that social media app our kids love so much, Houston, we have a problem.
Researchers also agreed that the more time adolescents, especially girls, spend on social media, the stronger the connection is to mental-health problems. There is actually little evidence of harm for light daily usage (one hour a day). But most researchers observed harmful effects with heavy social media use (two or more hours per day).
Some studies even revealed that the rate of depression doubles as kids move from light to heavy social media use.[5] In the same way, in seven out of eight studies, researchers observed an improvement in some measures of mental health or happiness after reducing or eliminating social media use for a few weeks.[6]
Bottom line: not only does social media affect the mental health of our kids, especially girls, but the number of hours they spend on social media each day makes a difference.
The most recent studies tracking exactly how many hours young people spend on screens is eye opening, because social media takes up a good chunk of it. Eight- to twelve-year-olds average one hour and seventeen minutes a day on social media sites like Instagram and Snapchat.[7] But if you add in the amount of time they also watch online videos on apps like YouTube, which are technically also social media, the numbers go way up. (And this category of online videos doesn’t include TV shows on apps like Netflix, which is yet another category.) Eight- to twelve-year-olds average an additional hour and forty-four minutes daily watching online videos, which are often funny clips from influencers.[8] Here’s the breakdown showing how much time eight- to twelve-year-olds spend on social media:
Social media
1 hour 17 minutes per day
Online videos (not TV)
1 hour 44 minutes per day
TOTAL SOCIAL MEDIA
3 hours and 1 minute per day
Recommended time:
No more than 1 or 2 hours per day
Teenagers from thirteen to eighteen years of age spend even more time on social media: an average of one hour and fifty-six minutes per day. But they also spend an average of an additional hour and thirty-seven minutes per day watching online videos, with YouTube as their app of choice.[9] Here’s the breakdown for this age group:
Social media
1 hour 56 minutes per day
Online videos (not TV)
1 hour 37 minutes per day
TOTAL SOCIAL MEDIA
3 hours 33 minutes per day
Recommended time:
No more than 1 or 2 hours per day
You might think, What’s the big deal with these online videos?
That’s exactly what teens say. Yet online videos are one of the biggest reasons young people overwhelmingly want to become online influencers in some shape or form.
Follow Me
Ethan is sixteen years old and spends every spare moment making gaming videos and posting them to his YouTube channel. He already has more than four thousand followers. His dream is to get sponsored and become a full-time influencer.
Ethan isn’t alone. He is among 86 percent of kids in Generation Z who want to become social media influencers.[10] Eighty percent of thirteen- to eighteen-year-olds want to be self-employed in the future, 73 percent as freelancers.[11] Ethan has already dropped the bomb on his parents that he doesn’t want to go to college. He wants to create gaming videos as a full-time gig.
Ethan has always loved gaming, and he’s good at it—so good that all of his friends watch him to learn how to pass certain levels in new games. He purchases new games on the release date as if it’s a career and plays them nonstop, except while attending school, eating meals, and catching a little sleep. Within a week, he’s an expert on a particular game, posting reviews and chiming in on strategy in popular gaming forums.
But Ethan needs more followers.
Every influencer does.
Back when Ethan was fourteen, one of his friends filmed him cracking jokes while conquering a new Call of Duty game and posted it to YouTube. The video tallied more than fifty thousand views the first week. That’s when Ethan got the idea to become an influencer.
A lot of young people post videos of themselves gaming, but Ethan’s combination of humor and skill made him pretty popular.
Problem is, followers are a lot harder to come by than Ethan fathomed. He figured that fifty thousand views should generate fifty thousand followers. But Ethan soon realized that viewers might watch ten seconds and then move on to another video, then another and another and another. Getting a viewer to stay a couple of minutes and then subscribe to his YouTube channel is a whole ’nother feat—one that began keeping Ethan awake at night.
Why does this guy JoshMerc have 123,000 followers when he’s so lame! Ethan wondered.
That’s one of the things that happens with social media: comparisons.
It’s inevitable in the social media world, regardless of the platform. If you want to be a YouTube star, there’s always someone with more followers (unless your name is PewDiePie).
That’s one of the by-products of kids “just watching videos” on YouTube or TikTok. Many kids see new “role models” posting fun videos and think, I could do that.
In fact, whenever I talk about the subject of kids wanting to be influencers, I’m always overwhelmed with how many parents come up to me after a workshop and talk about one of their kids who spends every waking moment on YouTube and wants to be the next Dude Perfect.
My friend Julie teaches third grade, and every week she interviews one of her students in front of the class, asking questions like “What do you want to be when you grow up?” She said that years ago, kids always responded, “A doctor,” “a dolphin trainer,” or “president of the United States.” Now, she says, eight out of ten students say, “I want to be a YouTuber.”
There’s similar pressure on Instagram to be an Insta-celeb. Your kids’ generation has grown up seeing nobodies become somebodies on Instagram doing simple things like putting on makeup or posting funny pics. And they think, I could do that.
Dealing with our kids’ aspirations is a difficult position for parents, because we don’t want to be dream crushers. But at the same time, we don’t want our kids tossing away college plans to aim for Insta-celebridom (I think I just made up that word). More importantly, we don’t want our kids to put themselves at risk physically and emotionally in an attempt to be influencers. I’ve seen kids do both far too many times.
The physical harm lies in the simple fact that kids become willing to do almost anything to get more followers, including engaging in risky behaviors. Kids sometimes try stupid stunts. For instance, consider the Fire Challenge, where kids try to light themselves on fire and post the video on YouTube (no, I’m not making this up).[12]
Let me be clear: stunts like these, including the choking game and the Tide Pod Challenge, are real, but they aren’t commonplace. The everyday risk that most kids take today is simply leaving their profiles on the public setting, which allows anyone to follow them. This is so common in a culture where kids want followers at any cost that I’m devoting an entire chapter to it (chapter 7, “I See You”).
In fact, some social media profiles now even default to “public” when your kids download the app and sign in the first time. I recently reviewed a social media app that gave this warning to kids if they flipped the switch to private: “Are you sure you want to do this? By switching to private, your potential followers won’t be able to follow you without sending you a request.”
Here’s the main point: if your kids keep their profiles public, pedophiles will surely find them, look at their pictures undetected, and in most cases, discover more information about your kids than they ever intended to reveal.
The pressure to get more followers is also taking an emotional toll on our kids, which is probably one of the biggest reasons all of those researchers reached the consensus that too much social media is harmful. All the pressure to be liked and followed is stressing our kids out.
Consider Sam Benarroch, who had about 166,000 followers on social media but purposely took a break from it because of the anxiety he experienced when his “likes” started dropping. Sam confessed,
Not getting the numbers that you want is so harmful. . . . It’s scary because it’s this spiral of not ever feeling like you’re enough, and that leaves this mental scarring. It’s contributed to my mental health not being the best lately. I definitely had to get some therapy because of this.[13]
So how can we help steer our kids away from spending too much time on social media?
Five Ways to Protect Your Kids from the Dangers of Social Media
1. Delay Social Media.
If your kids ask for social media before they’re thirteen years of age, the simple answer you can give them is, “I’m sorry. It’s against the law.”
As I mentioned in chapter 3, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) prohibits websites and social media apps, including Snapchat, Instagram, TikTok, and Twitter, from collecting personal information from kids under thirteen without parental consent.
2. Discuss the Dangers of Social Media.
When your kids turn thirteen and ask, “Mom, can I download TikTok?” it’s time to talk with them about the dangers. At the beginning of this book, I pointed out that most parents would never throw their kids the car keys without first making sure they know how to drive responsibly. If they want to drive, kids have to wait until they’re the correct age. Then they’re required to take a driver’s education course, pass a written test, and even take a road test.
Isn’t it bizarre how hands-off our society has been about educating our kids to use social media responsibly?
Think about it. Even with anxiety, depression, and suicide at unprecedented levels, and countless warnings from the mental-health community about smartphones and social media, most parents still just hand their kids a phone with very little instruction. In fact, I find that most parents say, “My kids know more about this device than I do.”
I think moms and dads need to rethink this. Even though kids might be more tech savvy, they certainly aren’t wiser about what to post, whom to friend, what to stream, or how much screen time might be too much.
This is why I always encourage parents to set the parental controls on their kids’ devices so they can’t add an app without Mom’s or Dad’s pass code. This prompts kids to ask Mom or Dad, “Can I download this new app?” This is especially important for the first few years they have a phone.
When your kids ask you this question, it’s always best to respond, “I don’t know. Let’s check it out together.”
This simple response doesn’t just give your kids a yes or no. It opens the door for dialogue. It gives you an opportunity to sit down with them and teach them how to look at any app objectively and evaluate its content.
So let’s say one of your kids asks to download a new social media app called Friendmigo (yes, I just made that up).
“Mom, can I have Friendmigo?”
You reply, “I don’t know. Let’s check it out together.”
Then sit down on the couch with your laptop and start by googling “Friendmigo safety,” and then maybe “Friendmigo parental concerns.” You’ll typically find several articles. Read about the app together, then discuss these questions with your child:
You’ll probably find that at least one or two of these questions will red-flag most social media apps, and you’ll have to make a discerning decision. For example, Instagram currently shows how many followers and likes users have, but it’s pretty good at monitoring content and doesn’t celebrate anonymity. Instagram can be a pretty innocent place for young people to post fun pics, but it can also put a lot of pressure on them—especially girls—to get more likes and followers.
You’ll need to weigh these elements as you evaluate each app with your kids.
So engage your kids in conversations about these issues. Teach them to recognize some of the dangers of social media. This could be as simple as grabbing my Teen’s Guide to Social Media book and telling your kids, “This book is your new phone contract. Meet with me each week, and we’ll discuss a chapter at a time. When you finish the book, you can have Instagram.”
3. Limit Social Media.
Once your kids get on social media, take the advice of researchers and limit their screen time. Don’t let your kids average two hours a day scrolling through their social media profiles, and another two hours a day watching online videos that make them feel the desire (dare I say the pressure) to become influencers themselves.
I’ll be honest, this step is by far the most difficult for parents. Some apps have individual limits. As I write this, TikTok enables parents to set controls limiting the app to just forty minutes a day. But kids are smart. Sometimes they’ll open a second app and sign up under a second username or on a second device and use a different profile without limits. (That old phone you forgot about in a drawer, or that old iTouch your kids used to have can both download apps and run on Wi-Fi.)
This is why boundaries are not as effective as bonding. In other words, discussing the dangers of social media with your kids is far more important than limiting social media. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t limit it. But as I said earlier, rules won’t raise your kids. You need to teach them how to make discerning decisions on their own.
One of the best ways to limit social media is by adhering to what you learned in chapter 4: keep your kids’ devices out of their bedrooms at night. These practices and other family media habits, such as “No tech at the table” and watching media together as a family, keep kids from isolating in their bedrooms for hours at a time, sometimes at unhealthy levels. (We’ll talk a little more about this in the next chapter about screen time.)
You could also follow the steps you learned about in chapter 2:
4. Seek Out Fun Tech-Free Activities.
I just suggested limiting social media. As parents, we sometimes find ourselves getting so caught up in telling our kids what not to do that we forget to teach them what to do. So if you find yourself constantly saying, “Hey, get off YouTube” or “How much social media is that today?” try to shift the focus to affirming positive activities and being proactive about doing nonscreen activities together.
During the global COVID pandemic, many families were stuck together, experiencing screen overload with nowhere else to go. So they became creative, building a firepit in the backyard and roasting s’mores, working on puzzles together, or even taking family walks or hikes.
Sometimes the simplest activities can bring families together.
In my house, whenever my wife began making cookie dough, she would literally announce, “I’m making cookie dough!” It was funny how the kids all began popping their heads out of their rooms like prairie dogs—well, horizontal prairie dogs. Within five minutes, the whole family was gathered around the bowl sneaking handfuls of cookie dough. (Yes, we risked getting salmonella in our house.) But guess what? Whenever kids had cookie dough all over their hands, their phones were nowhere to be seen. In our house, cookie dough meant laughing, talking, and stuffing our faces with unhealthy goodness.
What are some simple tech-free activities your kids would enjoy? How can you be proactive about initiating a few of these activities this week?
5. Remind Your Kids of Their Identity.
Another vital practice that’s probably the most effective at helping your kids see the dangers of social media is to remind them of who they truly are. It’s funny, but sometimes the best defense is a good offense.
I stated an important principle in step 4, and I’m going to state it again: as parents, sometimes we find ourselves getting so caught up in telling our kids what not to do that we forget to teach them what to do.
In the same way, we can get so caught up trying to warn our kids about bad influences that we never encourage them to follow good influences. The world is full of confusing messages about who we are. Make sure your kids are hearing the truth about their identity. Because whenever we give Christ control of our lives, our old identity is gone, and we have a new identity (2 Corinthians 5:17).
Have you talked to your kids about their identity in Christ? Wouldn’t it be cool if kids understood not only how valuable they are to God but also who they are in Christ?
If your kids have put their faith in Jesus, they don’t have to get caught up in “self.” That’s the world’s thinking. In actuality, self has been “crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me” (Galatians 2:20).
Interestingly enough, when kids spend excessive time plugged into entertainment media, they’ll hear plenty of distracting messages about who they are or where happiness comes from: popularity, good looks, instant gratification. The best way to counter these lies is to be proactive about teaching your kids biblical truth.
Consider Colossians 3:2-3: “Think about the things of heaven, not the things of earth. For you died to this life, and your real life is hidden with Christ in God” (NLT).
Sure, you can buy devotionals with all kinds of good discussion guides to help your kids understand their identity in Christ. But don’t be afraid to just open the Bible as well.
For example, take a few verses from Psalm 119:
Blessed are those whose way is blameless,
who walk in the law of the LORD!
Blessed are those who keep his testimonies,
who seek him with their whole heart,
who also do no wrong,
but walk in his ways! (119:1-3)
Read these verses aloud and then ask your kids questions about what you read, such as . . .
I’ve downloaded some excellent free Bible apps, including the Blue Letter Bible, where you can click on any verse, look up the words in the original language, and even see what scholars like David Guzik have to say about them. These resources can be really helpful if you’re trying to start a discussion with your kids.
The more we dialogue with our kids about God’s truth, the more they’ll recognize Satan’s and the world’s lies. And this world is full of lies about who your kids are or who they should try to be.
One of the most effective ways I’ve found to help kids engage in meaningful conversations about their identity is through music. Young people love music, and many songs today stir up feelings about self. We can use these songs to point them to God’s Word.
Step back to 2018 and think of the popular Lauren Daigle song “You Say.” In the song, she talks about the voices we hear in our heads that say “You’re not enough” and the lies that tell us we’ll never measure up.[14]
Songs like this one are great to play for your kids and then talk about. Simply ask your kids, “Do you ever feel like this?”
The Christian band For King & Country has a powerful music video for the song “God Only Knows.” Jump on YouTube and watch that video with your kids. Then ask them these questions:
Are you engaging your kids in conversations that give them a chance to explore the love God has for them?
In 2020 I had the opportunity to lead a group of families in my neighborhood through a study of Jesus’ words in the Beatitudes from His Sermon on the Mount. This powerful little passage is packed with perspective. (Do you like my use of alliteration?) In a world where so many people are caught up in money, looks, and status, this passage walks us through the things that really matter. Most importantly, it reminds us that we have all we need every day just by putting our faith in Jesus and being part of His Kingdom.
I led this study much as I did in the earlier example from Psalm 119. I read a verse and then broke it down. So first I read “Blessed are the poor in spirit” (Matthew 5:3).
The word blessed here basically means “joy because God has given you everything you need.” You don’t need anything the world provides. How could this kind of joy change your perspective?
Poor in spirit means to realize your own shortcomings and be utterly dependent on God. It’s complete humility before God. Why does realizing our need for Him give us a joy beyond comprehension?
This passage is eye opening.
When I did this study, I rarely had to argue that social media is harmful and entertainment is twisted. Instead, I just opened up the truth of God’s Word, and the young people there soaked it in.
Martin Luther King Jr. said, “Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that.”
Are you having these conversations with your kids?
Discussion Questions
[1] 2017 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, cited in A. W. Geiger and Leslie Davis, “A Growing Number of American Teenagers—Particularly Girls—Are Facing Depression,” Pew Research Center, July 12, 2019, https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/07/12/a-growing-number-of-american-teenagers-particularly-girls-are-facing-depression/.
[2] Data from National Vital Statistics System (NVSS), cited in Sally C. Curtin and Melonie Heron, “Death Rates Due to Suicide and Homicide among Persons Aged 10–24: United States, 2000–2017,” NCHS Data Brief, no. 352, October, 2019, https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db352-h.pdf.
[3] Jean M. Twenge, “Stop Debating Whether Too Much Smartphone Time Can Hurt Teens, and Start Protecting Them,” Time, March 21, 2019, https://time.com/5555737/smartphone-mental-health-teens/.
[4] Jonathan Haidt and Jean Twenge, “Social Media Use and Mental Health: A Review” (unpublished manuscript, New York University, updated May 5, 2020), https://docs.google.com/document/d/1w-HOfseF2wF9YIpXwUUtP65-olnkPyWcgF5BiAtBEy0/edit.
[5] Haidt and Twenge, “Social Media Use.”
[6] Haidt and Twenge, “Social Media Use.”
[7] Victoria Rideout and Michael B. Robb, The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Teens and Tweens (San Francisco: Common Sense Media, 2019), 12, table A, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/sites/default/files/uploads/research/2019-census-8-to-18-full-report-updated.pdf.
[8] Rideout and Robb, Common Sense Census, 11, table A.
[9] Rideout and Robb, Common Sense Census, 13–14, table B.
[10] Morning Consult, The Influencer Report: Engaging Gen Z and Millennials, cited in Sarah Min, “86% of Young Americans Want to Become a Social Media Influencer,” CBS News, November 8, 2019, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/social-media-influencers-86-of-young-americans-want-to-become-one/.
[11] Manisha Patel, “80% of Teenagers Want to Be Self-Employed in the Future and Are More Inclined to Be Freelancers,” Fintech Times, May 30, 2020, https://thefintechtimes.com/80-of-teenagers-want-to-be-self-employed-in-the-future-and-are-more-inclined-to-be-freelancers/.
[12] Jamie Ducharme, “A 12-Year-Old Girl Who Took Part in the ‘Fire Challenge’ Is in Intensive Care with Burns Covering Half Her Body,” Time, August 23, 2018, https://time.com/5373180/fire-challenge/.
[13] Rebecca Jennings, “Tikked Off: What Happens When TikTok Fame Fades,” Vox, February 27, 2020, https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2020/2/27/21153364/tiktok-famous-backlash.
[14] Jason Ingram, Paul Brendon Mabury, and Lauren Daigle, “You Say,” performed by Lauren Daigle, copyright 2018, Centricity.
