Chapter 10 of 12

Chapter 9: When They Break the Rules

Chapter 9: When They Break the Rules

CHAPTER 9: When They Break the Rules

Correcting without destroying connection

I THOUGHT MY KIDS were all on board. We had talked about being screenwise countless times. They knew exactly what was off-limits, but my son decided to cross the line anyway.

I can clearly remember the day it happened. I wasn’t even snooping through his stuff. I just stumbled upon it. My son had downloaded some inappropriate music. Come to find out, he had downloaded it months earlier and was listening to it regularly.

I was hurt.

And when he got home, I let him know. He argued . . . and I blew up.

“Don’t even argue with me,” I yelled. “You know you weren’t supposed to do this, yet you did.”

He argued more, and the battle grew heated.

Lori came into the room and put her hand on my shoulder, simply saying, “Jonathan?” She was really saying, “Jonathan, do you realize you are out of control and need to stop now?”

But I turned to her and told her something idiotic. I said, “I got this.” I lowered my voice for about ten seconds, until my son argued again, and then I blew up some more.

True story.

The part I remember most clearly is when my youngest daughter, Ashley, began crying. It tugged at my heart.

“Ashley, what’s wrong?” I asked.

I’ll never forget her words.

Between sniffles she simply said, “I’m just sad.”

“Why?” I asked.

“Because you’re being so mean.”

It wasn’t wrong to correct my son. He needed to be corrected. But the truth of the matter was, I wasn’t ready to correct him at that moment.

I was out of control. “I got this” was the furthest thing from the truth. I didn’t have anything. The only thing I ended up doing was shaming my son in front of the whole family, and the unintended result of that moment and others like it was that I clearly communicated to all three of my kids, Dad isn’t safe.

Safe

I hear it after every school assembly I speak at.

Kids come up to me and begin asking questions about sensitive subjects. I always respond the same way, almost as an experiment just to see how they’ll respond. I ask them, “Have you tried talking with your parents about this?”

Students literally laugh and say, “There’s no way I’d talk to them about this.”

I ask, “Why?” and it’s the same response every time.

“Because they’d freak out.”

It’s not that I’m some unique parent whom kids feel they can trust. Whenever I speak at a school assembly, I have two advantages:

  • I’m a stranger. The stranger-on-the-train phenomenon, as some psychologists call it, is when people find it easier to share something personal or vulnerable with someone they know they will never see again. The risk is minimal.
  • The kids just heard me talk about the issues at hand, and whenever I talk with students, I try to come across as someone who refrains from judgment and just provides them with good information so they can make an informed decision. This makes me seem safe.
  • There’s that word again: safe.

    It’s a word I’ve been hearing in mental-health arenas a lot lately. When people feel safe, they’ll open up and engage in meaningful conversation. When they feel shut down or shamed, they retreat.

    How do your kids feel in your home?

    Let me be clear. I’m not saying you shouldn’t correct your kids. Just like they need loving limits, they need caring correction. But if you’re like me, you might need a little work on the whole caring part of that correction. If we correct without care, our kids might resent our rebuke. And resentment leads to rebellion.

    So how can you correct without shaming?

    How can you correct in a way that makes your kids think about what they did and learn from their mistakes?

    What can you do to help them feel safe with you? When they feel safe, they’ll think, Mom and Dad love me unconditionally. They’re always there for me, even when I mess up.

    Seven Tips for Correcting without Destroying Connection

    Following are seven helpful tips that not only keep you from destroying connection but also catalyze connection. I wish I had learned these a little earlier in my parenting.

    1. Prepare Yourself.

    Your kids are going to break your rules. Prepare yourself for that moment.

    Do you remember what it’s like to be a teenager? All those insecurities, feelings, and desires bouncing around in your rapidly changing body?

    It’s even more sobering when we consider this fact: we have no idea what it’s like to be a teenager today. Screens have provided some fun and convenience, but they have also added a lot of complexity to an already difficult time in young people’s lives. The pressure screens are creating is like nothing any of us experienced when we were our children’s age.

    Let’s say your twelve-year-old daughter, Jordan, already has a phone in middle school but desperately wants Instagram. You tell her, “Sorry. You can’t do what all your friends are doing.” You may say this without even considering what it’s like when every other middle school kid is talking about what they saw on Instagram and your kid is out of the loop. Why is she out of the loop? Because she isn’t allowed to have Instagram like her friends. Of course, she doesn’t see the problem that way. She just hears other kids laughing and saying, “Oh right. Jordan’s mommy doesn’t let her have Instagram because it’s evil.”

    So Jordan breaks the rules and downloads Instagram on her phone.

    It happens.

    Even the kindest, most well-behaved, conscientious kids will mess up in some way. Maybe it will be something small . . . or it might be a whopper!

    Are you ready for that moment?

    Repeat after me: “My kids are going to break my rules.”

    Go ahead. Say it out loud right now. (Yes, if other people are in the room, they’ll probably look at you funny. My dog looked up at me when I said it.)

    It’s going to happen. So prepare yourself for that moment. You’re going to be hurt. You’re going to take it personally. And if you’re human, you might even be tempted to snap at your kid in anger.

    That’s why the next tip is the most important one.

    2. Buy Yourself Some Time.

    Even if you’re the most self-controlled parent in the galaxy, giving yourself some time before responding to your child never hurts.

    Most of us aren’t at our best when we’re put on the spot. And that’s a great way to describe the exact moment you discover that one of your kids broke the rules. It won’t be at the perfect time. It will catch you off guard, and you’ll be put to the test right then and there—on the spot.

    Your reaction matters.

    Your kids will remember your reaction.

    Your kids will consider this reaction one day in the future when they are feeling sad, lonely, or guilty and the thought pops into their heads, Should I talk to Mom about this? Is Mom safe?

    What will they decide?

    I’m not implying that if you lose your cool once, you’ve blown it, and your kids are now going to start selling drugs. Parents make mistakes, and it’s okay for you to humbly apologize when you mess up. But if Mom or Dad overreacts all the time, your kids will begin to realize that you aren’t safe.

    Do your kids feel safe messing up?

    Your kids don’t need (or necessarily even want) a parent who lets them do anything they want. What they do need is a parent who is willing to listen and try to understand, a parent who doesn’t freak out every time they mess up. They need someone safe.

    Your on-the-spot responses influence this feeling of safety. So buy yourself some time. In fact, practice your response. Practice it now so you aren’t searching for words in a moment of hurt and anger.

    Maybe you can say something like this to your daughter:

    Wow. I don’t even know what to say at this moment other than I love you so much, even when you break the rules. I need some time to think about this so I don’t say something stupid. Please leave your phone on the kitchen table and go up to your room and do your homework. I need to pray.

    Tone and volume are also vitally important. So take a breath before you say your rehearsed speech. Then say it calmly and softly.

    Safely.

    Do exactly what you told your kid you’d do: pray.

    3. Admit, “I Don’t Have This.”

    Pray and humble yourself before God. I say humble yourself because it’s important in this moment to gain proper perspective. Point of fact, we all mess up, and none of us deserve any mercy. But God loves us so much that He has given us mercy at a huge price, the blood of His Son, Jesus. Jesus is grace and mercy wrapped into one. He’s grace in that He is a gift we don’t deserve. He’s mercy in that through faith in Him, we are shown mercy and are saved from a punishment we do deserve. Our response to these amazing gifts should be humility (and probably a little bit of awe).

    Humility is being wise enough to recognize the foolishness of the little voice in our heads that pridefully proclaims, I got this! I don’t need anyone’s help! Humility is remembering how flawed we are, enough to say, “I don’t have this. In fact, God, I need Your love, mercy, and strength.”

    The cool thing about humbling ourselves and receiving God’s mercy is that it tends to overflow. The more we open ourselves to it, the more it flows out of us. It’s not something we even need to try to do; it’s something we just allow Him to do in us.

    So pray, confess your own imperfections to God, humble yourself before Him, and soak in His love, mercy, patience, kindness, and every other characteristic of love listed in 1 Corinthians 13.

    Take hours if you need to.

    Sleep on it if needed. Of course, let your kids out of their rooms after a couple of hours and tell them, “We’re not going to talk about this today. I want to sleep on it and pray some more.”

    In fact, the waiting is a great punishment in itself. Your kids will hate it. They want to know, “What are you going to do?”

    Don’t even humor the notion. Tell them you need until tomorrow.

    4. Ask Your Kids Their Side of the Story.

    Let’s get back to the situation with Jordan. When you’re ready, sit down with her and say, “Let’s talk about this.” Quickly explain, literally in a sentence or two, what you observed.

    “We made it clear that you weren’t supposed to download Instagram until you turn thirteen. Yesterday I found this Instagram account on your phone, and it looks like you created this behind our backs.”

    Here’s where you refrain from doing what many parents do: lecturing, jumping to conclusions, and imposing punishment without knowing the whole situation.

    First, give your daughter a chance to be heard. Say, “I don’t want to jump to any conclusions, so please tell us your side of the story. Did you do this? If so, please explain.”

    One of the biggest needs of young people today is to feel noticed and heard. Many kids feel their parents ignore—and misunderstand—them. Times like these are excellent opportunities to make your kids feel heard and understood.

    So listen when they talk. Here’s a trick I’ve learned . . .

    5. Secretly Become Your Kids’ Defense Attorney.

    I’ve repeated a word intentionally throughout this book that can change your relationship with your children. That word is empathy.

    It’s part of the five steps (six, actually) that we’ve repeated chapter after chapter to help you listen to your kids’ points of view and create a climate of comfortable conversation in your home.

    When your kids mess up and break the rules, you need to ask them their side of the story and step into their shoes. But it’s much more difficult in these moments, because our tendency as parents is to shoot down their feeble excuses instead of seeking to understand. That’s why when my kids were younger, I played a little game without their knowledge. Whenever I asked them to share their stories, I secretly became their defense attorney and began trying to build their case in my mind. This helped me try to see the situation from their perspective and figure out what the other side (which also happened to be me) needed to understand.

    This can be eye opening.

    No, I’m not some wishy-washy parent who lets my kids get away with everything. If they violate a rule, there will be consequences. I just want to get to the why, because in many cases, that exposes an even deeper problem or need that could be more important than the small infraction at hand.

    Let’s say your daughter says, “I don’t know. I guess I just wanted Instagram. All my friends have it, and it feels like I’m the only one who doesn’t. Christina and Lindsey made fun of me, so I just downloaded it.”

    Instead of jumping to correction, explore a little more by asking another question: “How was it?”

    “I don’t know,” she replies. “Fun at first. But I don’t have many followers. I’m not that pretty. People just don’t like me.”

    Which is more important right now: your daughter’s poor self-esteem or her sneaking behind your back to download Instagram?

    I’m not in any way implying that disobeying is “no big deal” or that it shouldn’t be corrected. It should. But your daughter’s self-esteem is a much bigger deal. She probably doesn’t even realize it, but some of these feelings of low self-esteem might have increased since she started using social media. If you read about the unintended effects of social media in chapter 5, you know that self-esteem issues are common with young girls who pin their hopes of being accepted on the screens in their pockets.

    Now you have an amazing opportunity to talk with your daughter about her self-esteem. Think about that for a moment. Most parents would love an opportunity to dialogue with their daughters about their sense of self. But most girls aren’t very responsive to Mom walking into their rooms and asking, “So how do you feel about yourself?”

    I can imagine the response. “What? Get out!”

    But in that moment, right after you’ve caught your daughter using the off-limits app, she would much rather talk about her feelings in hopes that you’ll understand and show her mercy.

    Read that again: in hopes that you’ll understand.

    That’s really what she wants.

    So in this case, listen and talk about her self-esteem. Maybe even ask her, “What if we went out for frozen yogurt one day a week after school and talked about this?”

    My daughter Alyssa wrote a book for teenagers with me, The Teen’s Guide to Face-to-Face Connections in a Screen-to-Screen World. In that book she tells about a particular day when she posted a bunch of pics with friends, and after looking at them, she thought, Are my arms really that big? and Why do I look like Jabba the Hutt all of a sudden? Later at home, she saw the stories her friends had posted on Instagram and realized that she wasn’t in a single photo. She confesses that she ended up sobbing on her bed, at age twenty-four. That’s the day she decided to take a break from Instagram and all the pressure of comparing herself with others.

    Wouldn’t it be cool to open up the dialogue about these issues with your daughter?

    6. Ask Your Kids What They’d Do in Your Shoes.

    But what about breaking the rules? Does poor self-esteem excuse bad behavior?

    Here’s another great opportunity to turn situations like these into valuable teaching moments. For instance, if your daughter downloaded Instagram without your permission, ask her this question: “What would you do if your daughter did this? What would be a fair response to teach her that sneaking behind your back isn’t okay?”

    See what your daughter comes up with. Who knows, it might be something even better than whatever you had in mind.

    Compliment her for her ideas and thoughts.

    7. Give Your Kids a Choice.

    In our hypothetical example, your daughter broke the rules by downloading Instagram on her phone because she felt it would help her fit in and feel affirmed by her friends. In a moment when she’s already feeling powerless and a little bit ashamed (which is different than shamed), give her some power. Give her a choice. Talk it over with your spouse ahead of time, making sure you both agree on the choice, and then present it to your child.

    You might say, “Okay, I’m going to let you choose your consequences. You can do one of two things:

    “One: you lose your phone for a month and delete Instagram.

    “Or two: you keep your phone, limit Instagram to only twenty minutes a day, and agree to meeting together every week to read through a book on social media and self-esteem so you can learn how to balance these feelings yourself.”

    Which option would your daughter choose?

    As a parent you’re going to encounter countless situations that allow you to give your kids a choice. In these moments, try to come up with one option that includes very heavy rules and limits and another option with much lighter rules and limits combined with a weekly time of connection.

    Your kids are going to mess up. When they do, you have the opportunity to turn it into a teaching moment.

    And guess what?

    Sometimes after all of these steps, your twelve-year-old daughter will still complain, “But Mom, all my friends have Instagram! What’s the big deal? You’re so unfair!”

    That’s when you just have to say, “Nevertheless . . . ”

    My good friend Jim Burns, author of countless parenting books, taught me that. Sometimes there is nothing you can do. Your kids aren’t going to agree with you no matter what. Life isn’t fair, and that’s okay.

    So you say, “Nevertheless . . . you still can’t lie about your age to get Instagram.”

    But don’t jump straight to responding with nevertheless. Start with the seven tips we just discussed. These tips give your kids a chance to feel noticed and heard. The seven tips also give them an opportunity to think through what they’ve done and empower them to choose what happens next.

    Practice “the Seven”:

  • Prepare yourself. Your kids are going to break your rules, and you’re going to be tempted to overreact.
  • Buy yourself some time. Practice a response where you tell your kids you love them unconditionally and you admit you need some time to think and pray about the situation. Be someone safe whom your kids can turn to when they mess up, because they know you won’t freak out.
  • Admit, “I don’t have this.” Pray and humble yourself before God. Ask Him for patience. Take hours if you need to. Let God’s love fill you so it overflows to your kids.
  • Ask your kids their side of the story. Listen to them. Give them a chance to be heard, noticed, and understood.
  • Secretly become your kids’ defense attorney. Empathize with your kids. Step into their shoes and try to see the situation from their perspective. Seek to understand their side of the story.
  • Ask your kids what they’d do in your shoes. Turn the situation into a valuable teaching moment. Give your kids the opportunity to step into your shoes as a parent and consider how a loving mom or dad should respond in the situation.
  • Give your kids a choice. Come up with one option that includes very heavy rules and limits and another option with much lighter rules and limits combined with a weekly time of connection. Let your child choose one of these options.
  • Correction doesn’t need to destroy connection.

    Do your kids feel safe to fail?

    Discussion Questions

  • Share a time when you corrected your kids even though you weren’t ready to do so.
  • Which of Jonathan’s seven tips for correcting without destroying connection do you need most?
  • How come most of us don’t practice the simple habit of pausing the conversation until we’ve had time to think and pray?
  • Jonathan confessed his need to stop, pray for humility, and rely on God’s strength for these tough moments of correction. Honestly, have you ever tried that? Do you need to?

    Read Ephesians 6:4. What do you think this passage is telling parents? How does that apply to moments of correction?

  • What do you think of Jonathan’s advice to not only give your kids a chance to share their side of the story but also secretly become their defense attorney? How might that change your perspective?
  • I know this is a tough question, but do your kids feel safe to fail?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑