Chapter 4: “Mom, Can I Have My Phone in My Bedroom?”
CHAPTER 4: “Mom, Can I Have My Phone in My Bedroom?”
The link between screens, sleep loss, and depression . . . and what you can do about it
“TIME FOR BED.”
“Okay.” Sarah complied without any argument.
Sarah’s mom thought, That was easy. She didn’t question her daughter’s unusual behavior until a week later when Sarah slept through her alarm again.
Sarah McKinsey had just turned twelve, and her parents had finally caved and bought her the smartphone she’d been begging for.
Sarah plugged it in and set it on her nightstand every night right before bed.
“I use it as my alarm clock,” she reasoned. But waking up was proving quite difficult.
“Come on, Sarah. Wakey, wakey!” Mrs. McKinsey said, opening the blinds and letting the sunlight pour in.
“Mom,” Sarah whined. “Just ten more minutes.”
“You said that ten minutes ago. You can’t keep hitting your snooze button.”
The battles became more frequent, and Sarah became volatile. After school just two days later, Sarah’s mom reminded her that they’d all be going to her aunt’s house for dinner that night. Sarah blew a gasket.
“What?” she screamed, throwing her backpack across the room. “I hate going to Aunt Lisa’s. Why do I have to go?”
“What’s wrong with you lately, Sarah?” her mom asked.
The battles continued.
Three nights later after Sarah’s dad finished some late-night work in the den, he shut off the lights to hit the hay. Walking down the hallway, he saw a slight glow coming from under Sarah’s door.
He glanced at his watch: 12:42 a.m.
He quietly walked toward his daughter’s door. The floor creaked in its usual spot. He opened her door gently and peeked in.
Nothing.
Her room was completely dark, and Sarah was lying still in her bed.
He walked over to her and kissed her softly on the cheek.
Bzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
Mr. McKinsey froze. He couldn’t tell where the sound was coming from.
Bzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
Then he spotted the phone on Sarah’s nightstand. He picked it up and saw two messages on the screen. Both of them were from a guy named Dillon on Sarah’s favorite social media app.
Her dad scrolled up to keep reading when Sarah opened her eyes, alert as ever.
“Dad, don’t read that.”
“Ah. So were you just playing possum?”
“Give me that,” she demanded, completely ignoring his question.
“No,” Mr. McKinsey said. “I can’t believe you’re up messaging your friends at this time of night!”
Sarah scoffed. “Dad, it’s no big deal.”
That was the night World War III began. Ask anyone in the McKinsey house, and they’ll tell you.
This battle isn’t uncommon. Young people want their phones in their bedrooms, and they don’t care what anyone else has to say about it.
The McKinseys never saw it coming. They never fathomed that Sarah would stay up all hours of the night, messaging her friends on social media.
And being completely fair, no one had ever warned them that phones are by far the biggest cause of kids losing out on needed sleep each night. (And they are.) So by the time it came to their attention, Sarah’s heels were dug in deep.
Most parents don’t realize how much a phone distracts their kids from sleep. Maybe because we didn’t experience that same temptation when we were kids. Maybe we tried to stay up late reading or listening to music with our headphones on. But we sure didn’t have social media, YouTube, Google, Netflix, gaming, or Pornhub—all just a tap away on one simple device.
But let’s not be quick to villainize the smartphone. It isn’t the only screen keeping kids up at night.
My friend’s son Bodie was only thirteen when he got his first laptop, a great tool for school—that’s what his parents said anyway. Maybe that’s why they didn’t think it was a big deal to let Bodie keep the laptop in his room at night.
Bodie’s dad didn’t find anything amiss for months, until he happened to look at his wireless streaming activity, which detailed the times of day when the most streaming took place. The first thing he noticed was that Bodie had maxed out his high-speed streaming two weeks into the month. The family’s wireless service provided tiered service, which slowed down after a certain tier limit was reached. Bodie hit that limit before anyone else. Not only that, but he primarily streamed from 10:00 p.m. to about 2:00 a.m. most of the time.
My friend had actually set controls on his home router to turn off the kids’ access after 9:00 p.m. But what he hadn’t foreseen was that Bodie could use his phone’s hot spot to connect to the internet. If Bodie’s dad had ever walked into his son’s room late at night, which he didn’t, he would have found Bodie wearing a headset and gaming with a bunch of friends.
When my friend asked his son why he did it, Bodie answered, “Because I always have trouble going to sleep.”
And then he declared, “What’s the big deal?”
That’s what most young people today will say: “It’s no big deal.”
So is it? And if so, how can we talk with our kids about it?
The Common Denominator
If I could choose only one rule for kids growing up today, it would be, hands down, no screens in the bedroom. That one simple guardrail would solve innumerable problems.
No, this isn’t an oversimplification. It’s just that after thirty years of working with young people, raising three kids of my own, working in social research, and hearing parents share countless problems and frustrations with their kids, I’ve learned that screens in the bedroom are a common denominator for trouble.
Whether it’s meeting strangers on social media, playing video games well into the night, or watching pornographic videos, whenever kids confess engaging in one of these activities to me, no question, it happened late at night on a screen in their bedrooms.
In fact, whenever I’m taking questions from parents in my workshops or on the radio, I feel like a broken record at times.
They’ll tell me about some random struggle with one of their kids. Then they’ll say, “. . . and the next thing I knew, I discovered Jordan was doing this regularly.”
Without fail, I’ll ask, “Does Jordan have his phone in his bedroom at night?”
“Yes,” they’ll tell me.
Then I’ll reply, “Collect it from him at bedtime and charge it in your room at night. Next question.”
(Okay, I don’t really respond that abruptly. But I’m tempted to.)
In my line of work, I’ve seen it again and again. While working on a previous book that required hundreds of hours of cyberbullying research, I kept encountering the same phrase: “My kid was being tormented all through the night on social media by cruel messages, posts, and comments.”
All through the night.
Many times these kids went into a downward spiral of depression not because of the bullying but simply because they were losing sleep.
Lack of sleep is one of the primary factors associated with depression, and vice versa (hence the all-too-common downward spiral). In fact, in a study of nearly twenty-eight thousand high school students, researchers discovered that the odds of teens feeling sad or hopeless increased by 38 percent for each hour of lost sleep, and the risk of attempted suicide increased 58 percent.[1]
Read that again. Each hour of lost sleep bumps up the chances of your kid feeling hopeless by almost 40 percent.
And what is the number one culprit keeping kids up at night?
Screens.
Two of the few things all experts actually agree on are avoiding screen time immediately before bed and keeping screens out of the bedroom.
Unfortunately, most parents aren’t listening.
Phones in the Bedroom
Long before young people had smartphones, the American Academy of Pediatrics was recommending that parents remove TVs and internet from kids’ bedrooms.[2] Now, your kids have TV, social media, music, and texting on just one device—and your pediatrician’s advice hasn’t changed.
When the majority of American kids ended up with smartphones in their pockets, pediatricians strongly recommended that “children not sleep with devices in their bedrooms, including TVs, computers, and smartphones. [They should also] avoid exposure to devices or screens for 1 hour before bedtime.”[3]
Do you wonder how many moms and dads actually listened to this advice?
Only about 20 percent.
In 2019, an eye-opening study surveyed twelve- to eighteen-year-olds living at home. Researchers specifically asked how many teens brought their phones into the bedroom each night and how often they checked them. The survey revealed that 79 percent of teenagers bring their phones into the bedroom each night, with 68 percent keeping their phones within reach, including 29 percent who actually sleep with their devices in their beds.[4]
So why do so many parents allow their kids to keep their devices in the bedrooms when their family doctors have been saying no screens in the bedroom for literally decades? Perhaps it’s because 74 percent of American adults sleep with their own phones or keep them within arm’s reach.[5]
Maybe it’s because, once again, the pressure is on. When 89 percent of your daughter’s friends have smartphones,[6] and 79 percent of them bring their phones into their bedrooms every night, your daughter might seriously wonder why you have such unfair and archaic screen rules.
So let me ask the question teens are wondering about: Is there a chance loony alarmists and doomsayers are just making an issue out of something that is truly “no big deal”?
Sorry, the facts prove it’s a very big deal. Pediatricians actually know what they’re talking about. There really isn’t any debate about it. The more time young people spend on screens, the less they sleep. And when kids bring their screens into their bedrooms, sleep suffers even more, and the consequences of poor sleep are colossal and costly.
These are important issues to talk about with your kids, and as we’ve already discussed, they don’t want to hear a simple “Because I said so” or, in this case, “Because your doctor said so!” This is another opportunity to dialogue with them about the reasons behind the decision so they can be equipped to make the same decision for themselves when they’re out on their own.
So let’s look at some of these reasons, beginning with exactly how screens affect sleep.
Do Screens Really Affect My Kids’ Sleep?
Everyone agrees that teenagers should sleep about nine hours a night. Younger kids need considerably more sleep. But currently, almost half of American teenagers average fewer than seven hours of sleep per night.
When did this happen?
Let me give you the history of smartphones in four sentences: In the early 2000s, kids had plain old cell phones. If they wanted to be on social media, they did it on a computer. But then the first iPhone was released in January of 2007. America immediately fell in love with smartphones, and by 2012, more than half of teenagers already had them in their pockets.
That’s when the shift happened.
Between 2012 and 2015, the number of teens who got fewer than seven hours of sleep per night increased by 22 percent.[7]
I look at these types of statistics a lot. The numbers change 3 percent, 5 percent . . . and at times, maybe even 10 percent. But a 22 percent jump only occurs when a new variable is introduced into the scenario. And 2012 actually introduced several new variables: It was the year when a majority of kids became smartphone owners, Snapchat was released, and Instagram exploded in popularity.
Now that kids carry screens, and social media, around with them 24/7, almost half of them sleep fewer than seven hours per night (which is actually a 58 percent increase in the number of teens who slept fewer than seven hours in 1991).[8]
That’s a lot of tired kids!
So how are screens keeping them up at night?
1. Screens Delay When Your Kids Go to Sleep
First, let me just quickly address the almost insignificant fact about screens: the blue light they emit is known to hurt our bodies’ ability to sleep. Why is this insignificant? Because it’s an easy fix. Chances are, your kids already know about this and consider it “no big deal,” since all they need to do is switch their phones to “Night Shift” or “Night Light” mode to kill the blue light. Countless online sources explain how to do this.
Your kids are right—the blue-light issue is an easy fix. But the loss of sleep young people are experiencing is from more than just the lights their screens emit. Even without the blue light, screens engage our kids’ brains, causing them to be alert and stimulated, which makes sleep more difficult.
The more our kids become engaged with screens, the worse they’re sleeping.
That’s why your pediatrician is instructed to advise you and your child, “No screens one hour before bedtime.” Yet, an overwhelming majority of parents ignore this advice.
Not only do 79 percent of teenagers bring their phones into their bedrooms each night, but, as the same study revealed, 70 percent use their devices within thirty minutes of lights out.[9] And then they lie there in bed with their minds racing.
Social media is probably one of the biggest culprits that keep kids awake at night—by design. No, it’s not like evil app developers necessarily wanted to keep our kids awake so they would perform poorly at school the next day, but these developers definitely did create the app to engage kids, stimulate their brains, and reward them periodically to keep them engrossed. Scrolling through social media is known to stimulate dopamine in their brains, telling them, “Hey, man, this is gonna feel good!” And that anticipation typically increases wakefulness.
The same is true of looking at internet pornography. When a kid encounters pornography repeatedly, the mere anticipation of the visuals gives him a dopamine rush before any physical pleasure even takes place. I intentionally say him not because girls don’t ever look at porn, but compared to young boys, fewer than half the number of young girls engage in frequent porn viewing. The Barna Group conducted a survey to find out how many “practicing” and “not practicing” Christians from thirteen to twenty-four years of age seek out porn “at least once a month.” Here are the results:[10]
Let those numbers sink in for a moment. Even if your son goes to church and loves Jesus, 41 percent of “practicing” Christian males from 13 to 24 years of age frequently seek out porn.
The lure of porn is commonplace today, with countless gateways. Consider YouTube, a favorite online destination for young people. Even if your kids are watching an innocent video, when that video ends, YouTube “kindly” suggests more videos your kids might like, and every once in a while, one of those “suggestions” features a slightly alluring image. And as many of you know, tapping on that video link can lead viewers down a rabbit trail to porn.
In short, porn is a huge temptation for young people today, especially males. Having a phone in their bedrooms increases accessibility, with less accountability. And the more kids view porn, the more they desire it. Internet porn has a way of leading to even more internet porn.
It’s the same with video games. Unlike movies or TV programs, video games are interactive. Most studies show that playing video games before bed not only increases “sleep-onset latency” (the time it takes kids to fall asleep), but it also amps kids up so much, it hurts their ability to transition into a deep sleep.[11]
What does all this mean?
Our doctors are right when they advise us, “Stop using screens before bedtime. It will hurt your sleep.”
2. Screens Interrupt Your Kids’ Sleep.
Screens not only delay when our kids go to sleep; they also interrupt sleep throughout the night. One in three teenagers wake up in the middle of the night to check their phone.[12]
Think about that for a second. If you have three kids with phones in their bedrooms, then statistically, one of them is getting up to check a notification or jump on social media real quick in the middle of the night.
Ask yourself, Would this affect my sleep?
You have to step into their world for a moment to try to understand.
For most kids today, “likes” and followers are everything. In a world where almost nine out of ten young people (86 percent) want to become social media influencers,[13] social status is everything. (We’ll spend plenty of time diving into the influencer phenomenon in upcoming chapters.) So if your kids post a new video right before bed, chances are they’ll wake up during the night to check likes and comments.
And how do you think it’s going to affect their sleep when they don’t get as many likes as they wanted?
Will their minds become engaged when they read a negative comment trashing their video? (Sadly, internet “trolls” are everywhere. These people love to provoke a response with their critical or cruel comments, like a fisherman trolling for a catch.)
Far too many kids tend to wake up and peek at their phones when they have them in their bedrooms. As I’ve already mentioned, one in three teenagers (statistically 36 percent) wake up at least once during the night to check their mobile devices.[14] But honestly, I think that number has grown since 2019. Social media has become even more engrossing. I’ve met numerous kids who claim they’re up “all through the night” checking notifications. Some almost seem to brag about insomnia.
Like Adam.
Adam’s grades were dropping, he was having outbursts at school and home, and he was showing signs of depression. When I spoke with him, he told me, “I can’t sleep, so I just stay up and play video games.”
He was right about not sleeping, but he wasn’t clued in about the root of the problem. Adam had a computer in his room. His parents caught him staying up several nights to play games and look at pornography. When they confronted him, he argued, “Well, you don’t know what it’s like to not be able to sleep.”
I hung out with Adam several times on youth-ministry camping trips and observed him without him realizing it. I know what sleep problems look like.
You see, I have severe sleep problems. I’ve had them ever since I was a kid. Numerous therapists have described me as ADHD and OCD among other things. Many wanted to prescribe various medications. Regardless, I didn’t sleep well at night. I had a hard time shutting down my thoughts. I remember spending much of my childhood wandering around in the dark, exploring and getting into trouble.
Sleep never came easy to me.
I know the symptoms, the causes, and the countless theories about potential remedies.
When I became an adult, my insomnia came in handy in my youth-ministry job. I remember being in charge of a couple hundred high school kids sleeping in a gym at a weeklong event. I was literally always the last person in the room to fall asleep. Teenagers were always surprised when they tried to sneak out hours after bedtime and I was waiting for them by the door.
That week, I watched Adam engage in all kinds of healthy activities during the day (undoubtedly more physical activity than he experienced at home), eat a healthy dinner without caffeine-filled beverages, and then go to bed without a screen (we were out of cell range, so no one had screens).
It’s funny how the self-diagnosed insomniac slept like a baby night after night.
I didn’t know it at the time, but what I observed in Adam was almost textbook. Screens, diet, and physical activity all affect sleep, and consequently, all of these affect a teen’s behaviors the following day.
This is exactly why I think this issue is so vital. Screens in the bedroom affect sleep, and sleep affects mental health—big-time.
What Happens When Young People Lose Sleep?
Dr. Michelle Guerrero and her colleagues with the Healthy Active Living and Obesity Research Group in Canada studied more than four thousand eight- to eleven-year-olds. In the study, researchers examined how recreational screen time, sleep, and even physical activity affect the tendency of kids to act impulsively during the day.[15]
I found this study fascinating because of the link they found between screen time, sleep, and mental health, specifically young people’s ability to finish tasks and their outbursts when things didn’t go their way. Interestingly enough, two factors that influence impulsivity rose to the top in their findings: sleep and screen time.
When kids got more sleep (nine to eleven hours per night) and engaged in fewer than two hours a day of recreational screen time, they scored higher in eight out of eight domains of impulsivity. More sleep and less screen time equals fewer impulsive behaviors.
I think it’s worth noting that physical activity is also a factor that affects sleep. When kids are more active during the day, they sleep better at night, plain and simple. Ask any youth worker who takes a group of kids skiing for the day. They all sleep like babies that night.
If kids are just sitting around all day watching Netflix or playing video games, then once again they aren’t getting the exercise they need, which affects sleep. Screen time affects sleep in so many ways. So I wasn’t surprised when these researchers found that sleep and screen time are the top two factors that influence kids’ behaviors during the day.
The researchers concluded that limiting recreational screen time and promoting adequate sleep helps kids avoid impulsive decisions, and in turn, they will engage in less risky behaviors.
The research linking sleep and mental health is immeasurable. When your kids’ sleep suffers, so does their mental health.
But it actually extends further than that. The consequences of poor sleep habits are numerous:
These consequences are significant, but let’s look at the biggest consequence of sleep loss on kids: poor mental health.
Your Kids’ Mental Well-Being
A study by the University of Texas Health Science Center revealed that teens are four to five times more likely to be depressed if they are sleep deprived.[19]
Sleep deprivation and depression have a curious connection. I say curious because the relationship is a two-way street. Kids who are depressed definitely struggle with sleep, but kids who struggle with sleep also have a much higher chance of becoming depressed. The research showing a two-way relationship between poor sleep and poor mental health is undeniable.
In a Harvard Medical School article titled “Sleep and Mental Health,” experts conclude that sleep deprivation can affect your mental health. A study they cite from a Michigan health maintenance organization found that, similar to the University of Texas study, adults who reported a history of insomnia were four times more likely to develop major depression within three years. Harvard researchers concluded,
The brain basis of a mutual relationship between sleep and mental health is not yet completely understood. But neuroimaging and neurochemistry studies suggest that a good night’s sleep helps foster both mental and emotional resilience, while chronic sleep deprivation sets the stage for negative thinking and emotional vulnerability.[20]
Don’t forget the other study I cited earlier in this chapter, where researchers found that each hour of lost sleep resulted in a 38 percent increase in the “odds of [teens] feeling sad and hopeless” and a 58 percent increase in suicide attempts.[21]
The American Academy of Pediatrics concludes that “addressing insomnia will greatly improve treatment of depression.”[22]
Any counselor will tell you that one of the first questions therapists ask patients who are struggling with depression is “How are you sleeping?”
Sleep is vital.
Screen time on social media is never a good trade-off.
Create a Climate of Comfortable Conversation
So how can you talk with your kids about screens in the bedroom? Again, practice what you’ve learned in the last two chapters about creating a climate of comfortable conversation about these issues.
- Why do you think sleep affects school performance, driving, obesity, and behavioral problems so much?
- What are the biggest reasons you think phones keep kids awake at night?
- Why do you think that about eight out of ten kids bring their phones into their bedrooms at night?
You’ll see these steps repeated over and over as you’re reading this book. When you finish the book, add this step:
And when that day comes, and you decide that phones will no longer be allowed in bedrooms, your kids will probably argue, “But I need my phone as an alarm clock.”
That’s when you’ll just smile and say, “Well, there’s another device that does that for you nicely. It’s called an alarm clock! Here’s twelve dollars. You can buy one at Target.”
Discussion Questions
[1] Adam Winsler et al., “Sleepless in Fairfax: The Difference One More Hour of Sleep Can Make for Teen Hopelessness, Suicidal Ideation, and Substance Use,” Journal of Youth and Adolescence 44, no. 2 (Feb. 2015): 362–78.
[2] American Academy of Pediatrics recommendations, in Victor C. Strasburger et al., “Sexuality, Contraception, and the Media,” Pediatrics 126, no. 3 (Sept. 2010): 576–82, https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/126/3/576.full.
[3] Megan A. Moreno, Yolanda Reid Chassiakos, and Corinn Cross, “Media Use in School-Aged Children and Adolescents,” Pediatrics 138, no. 5 (Nov. 2016), https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/138/5/e20162592.
[4] Michael B. Robb, Screens and Sleep: The New Normal; Parents, Teens, Screens, and Sleep in the United States (San Francisco, Common Sense Media, 2019), 26, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/sites/default/files/uploads/research/2019-new-normal-parents-teens-screens-and-sleep-united-states-report.pdf.
[5] Robb, Screens and Sleep, 25.
[6] “Social Media, Social Life: Teens Reveal Their Experiences,” Common Sense Media, September 10, 2018, https://www.commonsensemedia.org/social-media-social-life-infographic.
[7] Jean Twenge, “Analysis: Teens Are Sleeping Less. Why? Smartphones,” PBS News Hour, October 19, 2017, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/analysis-teens-are-sleeping-less-why-smartphones.
[8] Jean M. Twenge, Zlatan Krizan, and Garrett Hisler, “Decreases in Self-Reported Sleep Duration among U.S. Adolescents 2009–2015 and Association with New Media Screen Time,” Sleep Medicine 39 (Sept. 2017): 49, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1389945717303507?via%3Dihub.
[9] Robb, Screens and Sleep, 7.
[10] Josh McDowell Ministry and Barna Group, The Porn Phenomenon: The Explosive Growth of Pornography and How It’s Impacting Your Church, Life, and Ministry (Plano, TX: Josh McDowell Ministry, 2016), cited in Barna Group, “Porn in the Digital Age: New Research Reveals 10 Trends,” April 6, 2016, http://barna.org/research/porn-in-the-digital-age-new-research-reveals-10-trends.
[11] Markus Dworak et al., “Impact of Singular Excessive Computer Game and Television Exposure on Sleep Patterns and Memory Performance of School-aged Children,” Pediatrics 120, no. 5 (Nov. 2007): 978–85, https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/120/5/978.short.
[12] Robb, Screens and Sleep, 26.
[13] Morning Consult, The Influencer Report: Engaging Gen Z and Millennials, cited in Sarah Min, “86% of Young Americans Want to Become a Social Media Influencer,” CBS News, November 8, 2019, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/social-media-influencers-86-of-young-americans-want-to-become-one.
[14] Robb, Screens and Sleep, 7.
[15] Michelle D. Guerrero et al., “24-Hour Movement Behaviors and Impulsivity,” Pediatrics 144, no. 3 (Sept. 2019), https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/144/3/e20190187.
[16] “Improve Your Child’s School Performance with a Good Night’s Sleep,” Sleep Foundation, accessed July 28, 2020, https://www.sleepfoundation.org/excessive-sleepiness/performance/improve-your-childs-school-performance-good-nights-sleep.
[17] “Drowsy Driving Prevention, Teens Ages 16 to 19 Years,” New York State Department of Health, revised February 2018, https://www.health.ny.gov/prevention/injury_prevention/children/fact_sheets/teens_15-19_years/drowsy_driving_16-19_years.htm.
[18] Neeraj K. Gupta et al., “Is Obesity Associated with Poor Sleep Quality in Adolescents?” American Journal of Human Biology 14, no. 6 (Nov./Dec. 2002): 762–68, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12400037/.
[19] Robert E. Roberts and Hao T. Duong, “The Prospective Association between Sleep Deprivation and Depression among Adolescents,” Sleep 37, no. 2 (Feb. 1, 2014): 239–44, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3900610/.
[20] “Sleep and Mental Health: Sleep Deprivation Can Affect Your Mental Health,” Harvard Mental Health Letter, Harvard Health Publishing, March 18, 2019, https://www.health.harvard.edu/newsletter_article/sleep-and-mental-health.
[21] Winsler et al., “Sleepless in Fairfax,” 370.
[22] Judith Owens, Adolescent Sleep Working Group, and Committee on Adolescence, “Insufficient Sleep in Adolescents and Young Adults: An Update on Causes and Consequences,” Pediatrics 134, no. 3 (Sept. 2014), https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/134/3/e921.
