Chapter 11 of 12

Chapter 10: Putting It into Practice

Chapter 10: Putting It into Practice

CHAPTER 10: Putting It into Practice

Real-world stories from moms and dads parenting Generation Screen

AT THE END OF EVERY ONE of my Parenting Generation Screen workshops, I always save time for moms and dads to ask me questions. I do my best to provide answers.

Some questions are fairly specific:

  • “Jonathan, what about this new app that teenagers are downloading?”
  • “Jonathan, have you seen that new Netflix show my kid says everyone is watching?”
  • “Jonathan, I’ve tried setting parental controls on the new iPhone, but now they’ve made updates. Can you help me figure it out?”
  • One of the struggles we experience as we try to help our kids wisely navigate entertainment media is that it’s always changing. The moment you think you understand your kid’s favorite app, a new app emerges. The day after you set the parental controls on your kids’ devices, an update is released, and you have to revisit those controls.

    That’s one of the reasons it’s helpful to connect with other parents who are experiencing the same struggles you experience today as you parent Generation Screen. It’s nice to know you aren’t alone.

    When my kids were teens and tweens, my wife and I helped lead a Sunday morning fellowship group (dare I call it a Sunday school class?) at our church. It was appropriately named the Family Zone. Moms and dads from this unique life stage—they all had kids in middle school or high school—met together for encouragement, fellowship, and teaching. Each week a speaker would teach on faith, marriage, or parenting, and then we’d discuss it. I loved teaching this class because I knew I could easily kick off the discussion by providing a case study.

    For example, I’d say, “Your sixteen-year-old son comes home and announces that he doesn’t want to go to church anymore. He says, ‘Church is stupid.’ How do you respond?”

    Or “Your daughter has been posting videos on YouTube, and today she tells you that she doesn’t want to go to college anymore because she wants to be an influencer. What do you tell her?”

    After sharing one of these situations, I’d walk around the tables and eavesdrop on the conversations. I can’t tell you how many times I would hear, “Well, actually, Chris did come home and say that last summer.” And another person in the group would share, “Taylor did the same thing.”

    Then I’d inevitably hear, “So what did you do?”

    It’s good to know someone else is going through the same thing, isn’t it?

    Chances are, many of you might be struggling with very specific issues like these:

  • I’m a single mom with two kids, ages ten and twelve, and they already have phones. Their dad gave them phones last year, even though I told him we should wait.
  • Our daughter is truly obsessed with social media. She’s a good kid, but she is way too caught up with what others think of her. Social media has made this one hundred times worse.
  • My wife and I didn’t give our kids screens, but their school did. At school the devices have all sorts of content blockers, but we learned the hard way that those devices didn’t have those blockers when on our home network.
  • Our kids are grown and out of the house, but now our youngest daughter, a twenty-four-year-old single mom, is struggling with personal issues, so we are helping her raise her kids in our home. It’s really difficult because she lets them have anything they want.
  • My husband and I homeschool our kids, now thirteen, fifteen, and sixteen, and they have limited access to screens. But recently, my sixteen-year-old spent the night at her friend’s house, and the two of them watched . . .
  • My son won’t stop playing video games—ever! And when we do stop him, he throws a fit. Every time. He’s intolerable.
  • Maybe you can relate to one or more of these scenarios.

    After I finished writing this book, I gave my loyal readers an opportunity to review it as a work in progress. I asked them to please write comments, make suggestions, and share stories of how these issues played out in their homes. As I read many of these stories, I connected certain parents.

    “You two should talk,” I told them. “You’re going through the exact same thing.”

    In fact, even some of the marketing people asked me, “What did you tell her? My daughter told me the same thing last month.”

    It quickly became obvious that many of these issues were painfully common, and parents were desperate to talk with other parents experiencing the same thing. They wanted to ask, “What did you do?” and “How did that work?”

    For this reason, I’m going to share a few stories from other parents. Then I’ll offer a little feedback—literally just a few sentences—at the end of each story.

    Enjoy!

    YouTube Envy

    Our son is eight years old, and he’s already feeling the pressure to be on YouTube.

    And we’re not alone.

    We became fast friends with four other couples at our church with kids the same age. Our families do a lot together, and the kids always have fun running around playing with each other.

    Sadly, one of the couples already let their son—also eight years old—have his own phone. His favorite pastime is watching funny YouTube videos. Now, whenever all our kids are together, we always see him with his phone out and every other kid gathered around the phone laughing at some funny video.

    This kid also has his own YouTube account, and he makes videos. All the other kids think it’s cool and say, “Wow, you’re on YouTube! Look how many likes you got on that one!”

    But mostly, they just sit and watch videos.

    I’ve watched some of the videos—they aren’t bad. But we’ve begun to notice two things:

  • The kids don’t want to run around and play as much as they used to. They just want to sit around and watch videos on this boy’s phone.
  • All the other kids, including mine, want phones now so they can watch YouTube. They ask for our phones during every car ride, and they even want their own YouTube accounts like this boy’s so they can get likes.
  • We don’t want to hate on our friends, but we’re all kind of bitter that they gave their kid a phone, because it’s truly having an effect on our kids.

    Anything we can do?

    —Lyla

    Thanks for sharing, Lyla. You’re not alone. A favorite activity of young people today is watching funny online videos, and YouTube is the channel of choice. And it’s nice when parents of young kids band together and agree, “Hey, let’s not give our kids phones until they are at least thirteen.” That makes it easier for all. But in your situation, show the one kid with the phone lots of grace and balance that with times of creative alternatives. Say, “Okay, everyone, enough screen time.” Then suggest another option: “Let’s all make cookies,” or go on a hike, or make a couch-cushion fort, or do some other nonscreen activity.

    —JONATHAN

    Weekend Binge

    My wife and I were going away for a weekend and leaving our teens at home. We thought, What could happen in just one weekend?

    Oy vey!

    Our daughters, sixteen and eighteen, have always had the rule “No phones in the bedroom after 9:30 p.m.” We charge the phones in our bedroom. Our sixteen-year-old actually thanked us for this recently—because it allows her to paint and do art and stuff. It also gives her an excuse to end conversations and avoid the social pressure, because she can say, “My parents make me put my phone away at 9:30.”

    My wife and I were going on a weekend trip, and we decided to leave our girls at home by themselves because they had earned our trust. We put our eighteen-year-old in charge and removed the screen-time restriction from our sixteen-year-old, who had argued that she needed to have twenty-four-hour access to us for emergencies in case her sister wasn’t around. We agreed, because she’s honestly an incredibly responsible teenager.

    The weekend seemed to go well, but when we got home, our sixteen-year-old was acting peculiar. Nothing specific, just being overly nice and almost clingy. I was doing all I could not to ask, “Okay, what happened?”

    That night she came into our room and started talking. She never does this. But soon she began confessing that she had a boyfriend, and she wondered if she could go on a date with him.

    This was completely out of left field, because, literally, the prior weekend she had told us how much she was enjoying school, youth group, and her friends, and that she didn’t even feel the need to date in high school.

    It felt like we were talking to a different girl.

    I was exhausted, so I said, “This is a lot to think about. Can we think about this and talk tomorrow?”

    She agreed and went to bed.

    As I crawled into bed, I couldn’t stop thinking, What happened? Then I realized that her phone was right there, ten feet from where I was sleeping.

    I’ve always reserved the right to look at her phone—I have her passwords, and I used to look a lot when she was younger. But I honestly hadn’t done that in at least a year.

    That night I looked.

    Texts were normal.

    Insta-posts were normal.

    Snapchat. Who knows. (I hate that app.)

    But then I remembered her Instagram DMs.

    There it was!

    Friday night she got into a long DM conversation with a boy I’d never met named Cody. They had started messaging after school, and the conversation kept going. It was mostly boring. “Yeah, I hate French class,” “I’ve never been to another country,” and so forth. Then I noticed that the conversation changed a bit. They started talking about dating in general. Then, “I really like you a lot,” and soon, “I think we should date.”

    No nude photos, no inappropriate talk . . . but then I noticed the time.

    2:17 a.m.

    2:37 a.m.

    2:57 a.m.

    They had continued to talk until almost 3:00 in the morning and just stopped short of saying “I love you” to each other. All DMs, late at night when they were tired and caught up in emotion.

    The next day, I asked my daughter, “So what time did you and Cody have that conversation about dating?”

    The look on her face said it all. She immediately started making excuses. “I know we were talking late, and I should have gone to bed, but you guys were gone, and I just wasn’t thinking . . . blah blah blah.”

    A day or two passed, and she wasn’t that interested in this boy anymore, nor he in her. Apparently it was just a late-night emotional connection that neither really wanted once reality hit.

    Since then, she’s been a little more eager and willing to give us her phone at night. I feel as if she’s almost saying, “Take this. I don’t want to do anything stupid.”

    Next time, we’re probably going to think twice about leaving the kids alone.

    —Rick

    Thanks for sharing, Rick. I can tell you twenty stories of stupid things I did when I was fifteen, sixteen, and seventeen years old, all when my parents were out of town. The good news is it sounds like your daughter learned from her experience. It’s like I always say, “Most of us don’t make good decisions after 11:00 p.m.”

    —JONATHAN

    Windshield Conversations

    My sixteen-year-old and I have a rule for the car, especially driving to school: “Cars are for conversations.” No screens, no radio, no headphones.

    Me, too. I don’t answer the phone when my son is in the car.

    I’m glad he opted into this rule when he was young, because it’s like he’s never known anything different. So whenever I pick him up from school, he just starts talking. He knows it’s his time. He likes that I listen.

    Sometimes I don’t say one single word the entire drive home, and then when he gets out of the car, he says, “Nice talking with you, Dad.”

    I’ve heard people say that men prefer not looking each other in the eyes when they talk. They talk more when they’re looking forward doing something else. I have no idea if that’s true. All I know is that when we’re in the car . . . we talk.

    No complaints.

    —James

    That’s awesome, James. Many of us are jealous. I love that you established this rule when your son was young and built good habits. Good listeners are rare these days. Once your son got a taste of having his dad listen to him, he knew where he could always get it. Keep up the good work!

    —JONATHAN

    Video Star

    It has been four years since my daughter got her phone, and we have never had any problems at all—until now. After a lot of deliberation, I allowed her to start a TikTok account. I’ve never regretted anything more.

    Two weeks in, we began noticing a change. She would disappear into her room; then we’d hear her singing songs, many with foul lyrics; and then she began dressing—how to even describe it—more sexy. Eventually I confronted her, and she didn’t respond well.

    Two more weeks passed, and we noticed more of the same. Again I talked with her. Nothing.

    It’s been five weeks now. I don’t even recognize my little girl anymore. She’s acting out and having outbursts. I can actually see physical symptoms of stress manifesting, so much so that I did something I’ve never done before. I peeked at her phone. I couldn’t believe what I saw.

    She was texting friends links to TikTok videos she had made. The lyrics and subject matter were horrifying.

    So I’m at an impasse. She hasn’t responded to any of my conversations. I’m wondering if I should limit social media, ban TikTok specifically, or take her phone away completely.

    I just read your previous chapter about correcting without destroying connection. I’m going to try the seven tips today.

    I’d love your prayers!

    —Jessica

    Thanks for sharing, Jessica. I wish I could tell you this was uncommon, but honestly, I’m not even surprised anymore when I hear stories like this, particularly when you consistently see the pressure social media is putting on young people, girls especially. I hope the seven tips help you connect. We’re all praying for you as you continue to respond to your daughter in grace and truth.

    —JONATHAN

    Data Hog

    Last year my wife and I moved to a rural area without any decent internet connections. After almost a month of research, I finally found an internet provider that offered a decently reliable tiered plan with only so many gigabytes of data. After that’s used, it drops to the next slower tier. Well, we didn’t have a problem with it until my eighteen-year-old son moved back home.

    He had been home just four days, when all of a sudden, our Netflix began streaming in extremely low res—with pixels the size of a pizza box. Come to find out, he had been gaming every night since he moved in. He used up a month’s worth of high-speed internet in just three days.

    Of course, when I asked him about it, he said, “What? That’s stupid. Why don’t you have fast internet?”

    I tried to explain, but he wasn’t interested in understanding.

    The next month he did it again—using up the data allowance in two days. This time I didn’t even say anything. I just changed the password. About ten o’clock that night, there was a knock on my bedroom door.

    Oh, you’re ready to talk now, eh? I thought.

    —Robert

    Ha. Well, Robert, you can certainly attest that parenting adult children is never easy. (I have three.) On paper, they’re adults who can legally live on their own, but sometimes, mentally, they are still children lacking real-world experience of “adulting.” Parenting adult children needs to be more about coaching than parenting. You can’t tell your eighteen-year-old how to live his life. At the same time, that doesn’t mean giving him whatever he wants. We have to balance the truth with smiling and telling our adult kids that we love them. In your case, that could mean saying, “Get your own internet, you data hog!”

    —JONATHAN

    Foster Love

    I’m a Court Appointed Special Advocate (CASA) volunteer who ensures that children and youth in the foster-care system have both a voice and the services they need for a stable future. I was matched with a family last year that’s fostering three brothers, ages five, six, and eight. And boy, do these kids have a lot of energy.

    The first time I picked these boys up to take them to swim lessons, they saw the big screen on the dash of my Subaru. All three yelled, “Wow, look at that screen!” And without any hesitation, they started punching buttons.

    It took me an hour just to undo what they had done.

    The first time I pulled out my phone to write down a date in my calendar, they did the same thing.

    “Cool! An iPhone. Can I see it? Pleeeeease!” And they wouldn’t let up about it.

    Bottom line: These kids love screens!

    Every time I’m with them, they’re begging to play with a screen.

    One time when I took a picture of them, they all began asking, “Can I see it? Pleeeeese?” I got tired of saying no, so next time I took a photo, I asked them, “Do you want to see it?”

    “Yes! Yes! Yes!”

    So I showed them not only the picture I just took, but my other pictures as well.

    Soon, they started asking me questions about my photos. “Is that your dog? What’s his name? What kind of dog is he?”

    And that led me to ask them, “Do you have a dog? What kind? What’s your favorite pet? Do you take care of him? Are you going to have a pet when you grow up? What kind?”

    I quickly realized something: pictures create conversation.

    Now I’m taking a lot more photos.

    —Tim

    You’re a good man, Tim. Today’s young people need positive mentors desperately. Thanks for helping out young people in the foster-care system. And I’m so glad you discovered a way to use screens to catalyze conversations. Nice tip.

    —JONATHAN

    Saying Yes

    Have you ever noticed how often parents say no?

    Maybe it was just me, but I began noticing that I was saying no to my kids half a dozen times a day.

    “Dad, can I watch TV?”

    “No.”

    “Dad, can I have some ice cream?”

    “No.”

    “Dad, can I stay up and play video games?”

    “No.”

    I got tired of being the bad guy. So I began rewording my answers so my kids heard yes more than no.

    For example, if I was talking with my wife and my kids interrupted, instead of saying, “I can’t talk right now,” I said, “I’d love to talk with you as soon as I’m done talking with Mommy.”

    Or if one of my kids asked me, “Dad, can I go over to my friend’s house on a school night?” instead of saying, “No. Go to bed!” I would say, “You definitely can go to your friend’s on the weekend sometime. Or maybe you would like to have your friend over this weekend?”

    This took a lot of practice, but I noticed my kids felt less shut down.

    —George

    Thanks, George. That’s solid advice. This is a great way to focus on connection more than correction. Keep up the good work.

    —JONATHAN

    Distance Learning?

    It seemed like screens in our home were under control until last year when our country shut everything down. We barely left the house anymore, and my son had to do distance learning.

    Without any of his normal activities, my eight-year-old turned to screens. This required a lot more attention from my husband and me because we didn’t know anything about half the games he wanted to play.

    After reading a PluggedIn.com review of one of his games, we blocked it. But this didn’t stop him from going on YouTube and watching videos of other kids playing it. We began noticing him using some swear words and discovered he was learning them from these videos. (YouTube definitely isn’t for eight-year-olds.) This became really difficult to monitor. He was supposed to be doing schoolwork, but he would switch over to YouTube. We tried setting some parental controls, but he got around them. So we tried to be in the room whenever he was distance-learning on his screen. But do you realize how much time that is each day? That’s a lot of time being in the room. And honestly, sometimes we can’t even tell the difference between his online math games and other games.

    I hate screens!

    —Alyssa

    Thanks, Alyssa. You’re not the only one frustrated with distance learning. We want our kids to have unlimited access to learning, but it’s tricky to keep that from becoming unlimited access to everything else. Sigh. One thing you can do is simply block YouTube completely from his devices. I agree with you: YouTube is definitely not for eight-year-olds. So block it completely.

    —JONATHAN

    Alone

    I could relate when Jonathan wrote about that group of middle school kids who all had phones—every single one of them.

    My twelve-year-old son (almost thirteen) is truly the only one of his friends at school who doesn’t have a phone.

    This year, none of his close friends had the same classes as he did, but he was positive about it, saying he could at least find his friends to sit and talk with at lunch. After a week or so, I asked him if he was at least enjoying getting to talk with his friends at lunch, and with a disappointed look on his face, he said, “Not really.”

    When I asked him why, he said, “Everyone was on their phone the whole time.” That was how I learned that all his classmates had phones, and they were allowed to have them out during lunch with no restrictions.

    Jonathan’s right. The pressure is on. It’s been so hard not getting my son a phone. My wife and I are definitely getting him one when he turns thirteen in a few months. We’re actually going through one of Jonathan’s Teen’s Guide books now to prep him for the responsibility.

    —Jake

    Thanks, Jake. The struggle is real. The world is putting the pressure on kids to own screens at a ridiculously young age. Glad you’re prepping your son for the responsibility. Let me know if those discussion questions at the end of each chapter in my Teen’s Guide book are helpful.

    —JONATHAN

    Screen Sneaks

    My kids gravitate toward screens. Block one, and they’ll find another.

    The other day my kids had been watching TV for a while, so I told them they’d had enough screens for now. After about two hours of housework, I noticed my eleven-year-old was MIA. I went looking around for her and found her hiding in the basement playing Roblox on one of our old phones. (We didn’t even know the phone still existed.) I took away the phone and talked to her about the sneaking around—not cool. And then that night, I kid you not, I went into her room to find her under the covers playing the same game on her laptop.

    I didn’t react very well.

    How many screens does this house have?

    Sadly, she’s not alone. I’ve caught her older sister on her phone at one o’clock and two o’clock in the morning several times. We take away our kids’ screens, and then when they get them back, the problems happen again.

    I’m finding myself being reactive. This book is nudging me to become a little more proactive. Thanks for the advice!

    —Lindsey

    Lindsey, I’m so sorry to hear about your kids pushing the limits. That’s not easy to navigate. But I encourage you to do exactly as you wrote—become more proactive. Talk with your girls about the reasoning behind the rules. Don’t just take screens away. Teach them why you don’t want them on screens at 1:00 a.m. Help them understand so they’ll be equipped to make these decisions on their own.

    —JONATHAN

    Connection before Correction

    My daughter Willow has been on her screen a little more than usual these days. Normally she’s shown amazing responsibility. But every once in a while, she needs a reminder to look up from that distracting little device and enjoy the world around her.

    Last week I decided to talk with her, and having just read your book, I thought I’d try your five steps of connection before correction. After all, they looked pretty good on paper.

    So I did exactly what you said. When I found a particularly informative part of the book, I sat down with her and shared some of the eye-opening data you mentioned. Then I asked her what she thought, and it was a fascinating discussion.

    She then assured me, “Dad, I’m not like all the other kids out there on their phones.” I couldn’t help but wonder, Was she assuring me? Or herself?

    I agreed with her. And that conversation opened up even more discussions.

    One of the biggest challenges for her is not having the phone in her bedroom. It’s like you said. “Dad, aaaaall of my friends have phones in their bedrooms.”

    So I’m not laying down the law. It’s still an open discussion. But overall I’ve been very pleased with her attitude about her phone.

    —Joel

    Joel, Willow sounds like an amazing girl. It sounds like you have truly created a climate of comfortable conversation in your home. Keep up the good work. (And as our friend Jim Burns says, “Nevertheless,” pull that phone out of the bedroom.)

    —JONATHAN

    Obsessed

    Our sixth-grade daughter received a smartphone for her birthday last year. We thought it was a wise idea, since she started playing volleyball and we figured she could text us when practice was over.

    Little did we know that our sweet girl would become obsessed with that phone, and any request to put it away would be torture!

    She is not allowed on social media, but apps like YouTube and Roblox consume her! Gone are the days of her jumping on her trampoline or swimming in her pool!

    Parents, don’t make the same mistake we did!

    —Kelly

    Kelly, I can’t really argue with you. I agree. Hindsight is twenty-twenty. Thanks for your vulnerability and admitting you’d rethink that decision. I agree that sixth grade is a little early to give kids a phone. But you can’t squeeze the toothpaste back in the tube. So try what I recommended earlier in the book. Lobotomize that phone to the max and seek out points of connection with your daughter so she experiences the joy of face-to-face contact in a screen-to-screen world.

    —JONATHAN

    Discussion Questions

  • Which of these parenting stories did you identify with the most? Why?
  • Which story did you need to hear most? Why?
  • What parenting story would you share with Jonathan? What makes your story similar to or different from the stories in this chapter?
  • As you consider the stories in this chapter, which of your parenting practices may you need to adjust?
  • How can you avoid overreacting with your children when you hear stories about other kids acting out?
  • How can other people pray for you as you parent Generation Screen?
  • How can others help you?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑