3. When Christ and His Saints Slept
3
When Christ and His Saints Slept
Never before had there been greater wretchedness in the country. . . . And they said openly that Christ and his saints slept.
Peterborough Chronicle (twelfth century)
There is a dynamic to understanding Generation Z and its members’ spiritual condition that is almost entirely overlooked by those seeking to study their character and disposition.
This dynamic is the manner in which they are being raised.
One of the marks of Generation Z is that they are being raised, by and large, by Generation X—a generation that was warned repeatedly not to become “helicopter” parents (i.e., always hovering over their children). As a result, Generation Z has been given more space and more independence than any other generation. This means that Generation Z is very self-directed.
Consider the free-range parenting movement, a hands-off approach to parenting that entered the cultural mainstream largely through an article by a New York Sun columnist who let her nine-year-old son ride the New York subway alone. She handed him “a subway map, a Metrocard, a $20 bill, and several quarters, just in case he had to make a call.” She purposefully skipped the cell phone and didn’t trail him like a “mommy private eye.” She then celebrated his safe return, ecstatic with his independence. The response to her article led to the creation of the FreeRangeKids.com website, which led to free-range approaches to every aspect of parenting, including letting children take the lead in what they learn, what they eat, and what media they consume.
Perhaps particularly what media they consume.
As one father described his parenting world, after ensuring that his six-year-old daughter was on the family iPad, his eight- and eleven-year-old sons were on the PlayStation, and his two-year-old was watching something on his iPhone, “For me, this was a good morning’s parenting. There had been no arguments and I had been able to read the papers in peace.” To his thinking, any other way of parenting “just isn’t realistic.” Why? The “world has moved on.” Since it’s not always safe to let children venture outside, where they might run or play or use their imagination, children simply have to “spend more time in front of a screen.”
Granted, the author continues, they could go outside or engage in reading, but such an endeavor “invariably involves parental supervision, and that is a limited resource.” So technology comes to the rescue, offering parents a way to occupy their children that does not involve direct parental supervision. As one pediatrician remarked about the time children spend on screens, “It [is] time to stop arguing over whether it was good or bad and accept it as part of children’s environment.”
The Underprotective Parent
If Millennials were raised by overprotective parents, then Generation Z is being raised by underprotective parents. It’s as if the one thing you don’t want to do as a parent is to be (using the pejorative words of the day) hovering, smothering, babying, coddling, or sheltering. The insinuation is that it’s wrong to be overprotective, but it’s not wrong to be underprotective. If you’re going to make a mistake, make a mistake in being loose, in playing fast and free, and in not protecting enough. Because the one big parenting sin is believed to be protecting too much.
Reflect on this in relation to Generation Z. In other words, consider the effect of an underprotective family environment in a day of sexting and Facebook, bullying in schools and internet porn, cutting and hooking up. When children need to be protected as never before, they are met with a parenting culture that is less protective than at any other time in recent history.
The proper assumption with regard to parenting is simple: children are immature and need parental maturity. Parents are to be informed, involved, and in charge. Children are not little adults; they are children. Consider how the following list of rules parents should follow regarding kids and technology would be perceived by the average parent today:
Even half of these rules would be considered almost unthinkable to the average parent of a Generation Z child, which means that in the name of freedom and independence, Generation Z is growing up with the entirety of the world in their vision. As a result, childhood slowly evaporates. Or as Neil Postman writes, in having access to the previously hidden fruit of adult information, the child is expelled from the garden of childhood.
But the self-directed nature of Generation Z isn’t simply a byproduct of the change in parenting from “helicopter” to “free range.” It’s about the changing nature of childhood itself.
The Disappearance of Childhood
I once recall reading two articles in the span of twenty-four hours that charted different, seemingly benign ways that the nature of childhood is changing. The first was titled “Children Losing a Love of Stories in the Digital Age,” and the second was “Game Is Up for Traditional Pastimes with Half-Hour Version of Monopoly.” In the first article, in regard to the digital age, educators lamented how children “exposed to iPads, 3D films, and game consoles are losing interest in traditional storytelling.” They cannot read in silence or listen to stories because they are growing up in a world containing “endless distraction.” Yet it is a love of reading that increases concentration and promotes “deep thinking.”
The second article charted how the toy company Hasbro, in a day of smartphone apps, social media, and short attention spans, determined that children cannot handle long games. So the latest version of Monopoly was tweaked to find a winner in thirty minutes. A commentary at Gizmodo.com lamented the passing of one of the “cornerstones of childhood.” If only that were true. In reality, these are just pale reflections of the real loss of childhood taking place in our world.
One of Neil Postman’s most provocative works was titled The Disappearance of Childhood. His thesis was that children are being robbed of their innocence, their naïveté, their ability even to be a child. He contended that in our world, we ask children to embrace mature issues, themes, and experiences long before they are ready.
Postman argued that the very idea of childhood is that there is a time when young people are sheltered from certain ideas, experiences, practices, expectations, and knowledge. They are sheltered from adult secrets, particularly sexual ones. Certain facets of life—its mysteries, contradictions, tragedies, violence—are not considered suitable for children to know. Only as children grow into adulthood are such facets revealed in ways that children can assimilate psychologically, emotionally, and spiritually.
Postman’s analysis, first offered in 1982, was prescient. Today twelve- and thirteen-year-old girls are among the highest paid models in America, presented to us as knowing and sexually enticing adults. Much young adult fiction is as mature in its themes as anything on the adult lists. The language of adults and children—including what they address in life—has become the same. It is virtually uncontested among sociologists that the behavior, language, attitudes, and desires—even the physical appearance—of adults and children are becoming indistinguishable. Even the children on TV act like adults. They do not differ significantly in their interests, language, dress, or sexuality from the adults on the show, making the same knowing wisecracks and tossing out the same sexual innuendo.
This is why for years the books that were read in the fourth grade or seventh grade or ninth grade were chosen not only for their vocabulary and syntax but also because their content was considered to contain fourth-, seventh-, or ninth-grade information, ideas, and experiences. But when the line between the adult world and the world of children becomes blurred or no longer exists, childhood disappears.
Growing Older Younger
What has been the result of the disappearance of childhood? This can be summed up with a simple acronym: G.O.Y. (Grow Older Younger). Sometimes referred to as K.G.O.Y. (Kids Getting Older Younger), it is something that we see played out more and more in the culture of the day. As Pamela Paul wrote in the New York Times, “G.O.Y. [has six-year-olds going to school guidance counselors] complaining that So-and-So won’t play with them because they like the Jonas Brothers and the ‘It girls’ like Miley Cyrus.” So culture is now dictating that at six, it is more age appropriate to keep up with Lady Gaga than Lady and the Tramp.
Tracy Vaillancourt, who specializes in children’s mental health at the University of Ottawa, says, “Kids mirror the larger culture, from reality TV to materialism.” Who they see is who they want to be.
And the influence of their peers can be utterly overwhelming. As their closest friends succumb to the trend of G.O.Y., many children feel pressured to match them for the sake of popularity and acceptance. And sadly, instead of stepping in to be the voice of reason, many parents are feeding into this cultural trend.
Many parents, wishing their children to fit in, begin to give in, thus escalating the downward spiral, because the truth is that parents can be just as quick to give in to the trap of peer pressure as their children:
While parents know what they should do, want to do, and feel is best to do for their child, around every corner they are confronted by what everyone else is doing. The choice becomes to either swim upstream or go with the current.
The Soundtrack to Their Lives
It is helpful to remember the way such exposure, especially exposure to media, actually works. The great communications theorist Marshall McLuhan wrote, “All media work us over completely.” He added, “They are so pervasive in their personal, political, economic, aesthetic, psychological, moral, ethical, and social consequences that they leave no part of us untouched, unaffected, unaltered.” Fred Fedler, author of one of the most widely used college textbooks on mass media, says that “the media may constitute the most powerful education system ever known to man.” Or as MTV founder Bob Pittman once said, “At MTV, we don’t shoot for the 14-year-olds, we own them.”
So how is that media shaping this new generation?
It’s difficult to know for sure at this point, but at the very least, we know what it is attempting to convey. Take a moment to Google the lyrics for the top iTunes downloads. I think you will be shocked at what you find. Between the sexually explicit lyrics and the use of expletives, they are far from innocuous.
But without a doubt, the most pervasive and influential aspect of media shaping Generation Z in a way no other generation has been shaped is pornography, and this is where underprotective parenting may be leaving its most lasting mark.
Pornography
Being the first generation with a connection to the internet in their pockets has, as you would imagine, its dark side—namely, the ubiquitous presence and availability of pornography. No other generation has had pornography so available, in such extremes, at such a young age. Seventy percent of all eighteen- to thirty-four-year-olds are regular viewers. The average age to begin viewing? Eleven. It’s been called the “wallpaper of our lives.” In 2014, one porn site alone had over 15.35 billion visits. No, that was not a typo. That’s “billion” with a b. To put that into perspective, at the end of 2015, the entire population of the world was just over seven billion.
The degree to which members of Generation Z live in a pornified world and are themselves immersed in it as a “new normal” was revealed in the 2015 Cybercrime Tipping Point report, which found that sixteen- to seventeen-year-olds were not overly concerned about revenge porn (when explicit photos from a previous relationship are posted online without consent). For them, the larger issues were hacking or fraud. The report concluded that revenge porn was nothing more than an “everyday concern” for modern teens. But even though Generation Z may not be worried about porn, those who care about the generation should be.
Research has clearly established that teens who watch movies or listen to music that glamorizes drinking, drug use, or violence tend to engage in those behaviors themselves. A 2012 study showed that movies also influence teens’ sexual attitudes and behaviors. A study published in Psychological Science found that the more teens were exposed to sexual content in movies, the earlier they started having sex and the likelier they were to have casual, unprotected sex.
In terms of pornography, boys who were exposed to sexually explicit media were three times more likely to engage in oral sex and intercourse two years after exposure than nonexposed boys. Young girls exposed to sexual content in the media were twice as likely to engage in oral sex and one and a half times more likely to have intercourse. Research also has shown that teens who listened to music with degrading sexual references were more likely to have sex than those who had less exposure. Beyond sexual activity, similar research has found that early viewing of pornography among children leads to higher-risk sexual activity, sex addictions, and sexual violence.
So what else is pornography doing to them? We don’t fully know as yet. As Eric Schmidt and Jared Cohen opened their book The New Digital Age, “The Internet is among the few things humans have built that they don’t truly understand. . . . [It is] the largest experiment involving anarchy in history.” But what we do know is deeply disturbing. Chloe Combi, a former school teacher and consultant on youth issues for the mayor of London, interviewed hundreds from Generation Z. Her blunt conclusion: “They’re almost certainly imitating what they see in pornography.” For example, according to research from La Trobe University’s Research Centre in Sex, Health, and Society (tasked by the Australian government), nearly three-quarters of fifteen- to eighteen-year-olds have sexted, and half have sent naked or seminaked photos and videos of themselves. Eighty-four percent have received sexually explicit messages by phone or email. The report also found that 70 percent of the surveyed teenagers were sexually active and that nearly three-quarters of those did not regret having sex. Anne Mitchell, author of the report, said, “It’s a social, online world kids live in and sending these images and messages is part of the sexual relationship so it’s really a new form of courtship.”
In her book Pornified, Pamela Paul agrees, arguing that pornography has changed our marriages and families as well as our children’s understanding of sex and sexuality. Her portraits are riveting:
Rob, who insists that his girlfriend look and behave, in bed and out, like a porn star; Charlie, who spends hours cruising porn sites and setting up meetings with women and couples he befriends in chat rooms, while telling his wife that he’s just working late on the computer; Jonah, a fan of violent hardcore porn, who introduces tamer porn to his fiancée in an effort to revive their troubled sex life; Abby, who discovers her husband’s hidden box of CD’s of child porn images downloaded from the internet; preteen girls who start their own pornography websites; teenage boys, mimicking porn, who videotape themselves having sex with an apparently unconscious girl.
Let’s state the obvious: this is sexual sin. Jesus made it clear that when we give in to lust, it is akin to the act of sex itself. It makes no difference whether we know the person or not; lust is not tied to relationship. So pornography may be the greatest area of immorality inflicted on and pursued by Generation Z.
And the cause for concern is great because we know that porn is highly addictive. In fact, 94 percent of all therapists are reporting dramatic increases in the number of people addicted to online pornography. The ease of access to porn is greater than ever before, and for Generation Z that comes in the form of a smart phone sitting in their pocket at all times. Porn is something that can dominate the thought lives of those in its grasp, leading them to need ever-increasing degrees of exposure and experience to provide the same level of stimulation over time.
Porn is not only addictive but also incredibly degrading to women and sends a message to younger children—boys and girls alike—that women are nothing more than mere objects. Susan Fiske, professor of psychology at Princeton University, used MRI scans to analyze men watching pornography. Afterward, brain activity revealed they looked at women more as objects than as people. What is entirely overlooked is that these women (and men as well) are being treated in a way that is contemptible to their heavenly Father and breaks his heart.
Southern Baptist pastor Denny Burk, as quoted in an article in the American Conservative, said, “A growing number of young men are convinced that their sexual responses have been sabotaged because their brains were virtually marinated in porn when they were adolescents. Their generation has consumed explicit content in quantities and varieties never before possible, on devices designed to deliver content swiftly and privately, all at an age when their brains were more plastic—more prone to permanent change—than in later life.” This has led to men becoming sexually more aggressive, leading to date rapes and expected hookups. In other words, what we view can quickly become what we do.
Finally, what may be one of the most troubling effects of pornography is that it desensitizes your soul. And while it is true that sin of any kind desensitizes your spiritual life, the Bible discusses how particularly harmful sexual sin is. The apostle Paul writes, “There is a sense in which sexual sins are different from all others. In sexual sins we violate the sacredness of our own bodies, these bodies that were made for God-given and God-modeled love, for ‘becoming one’ with another. Or didn’t you realize that your body is a sacred place, the place of the Holy Spirit?” (1 Cor. 6:18–19 Message). So those who are a part of Generation Z are post-Christian not only in both spirit and context, they are also uniquely immersed in and embracing a form of sin that is poised to deaden them spiritually.
But that’s not all.
The None Parent
As detailed in the opening chapter, a large and growing number of parents—particularly parents of Generation Z—are themselves in the nones category. So how does an underprotective parent who is religiously unaffiliated raise a child spiritually? Not well. As journalist Ruth Graham started her article for Slate, “I’m the kind of Christian that many adults warned me about as a child: I’ve been a church member for most of my adult life, but I have at times gone years without regular attendance, my theology is squishy, and I don’t really pray, to name just a few qualities that put me on the breezy outer edge of Christianity’s big tent. I think of myself as ‘religious but not spiritual.’”
This, as we explored in the opening chapter, is a textbook description of the spirituality of a typical none. And as I detailed in my book The Rise of the Nones, the real mark of the nones is not a rejection of God but a rejection of any specific religion. When it comes to content, dogma, orthodoxy—anything spelled out or offering a system of beliefs—they’ve gone from “I believe” to “Maybe” to “Who knows?” When pressed as to what they do hold to, they collectively answer, “Nothing in particular.”
Simply put, they are spiritual but not religious.
They may not want to say, “I’m a Baptist,” but that does not equate with, “I don’t believe in God.” In other words, there is a strong reticence toward labels of any kind. It might help to visualize this in terms of a religious axis and a spiritual axis, creating four quadrants (see fig. 3.1).
The caricature of the nones would place them in the “not religious, not spiritual” category, but that would be inaccurate. The vast majority belong in the “not religious, spiritual” quadrant.
“Not religious, spiritual” is not a disavowal of faith or belief. Instead, it is the rejection of a label related to faith or belief. In years past, an unchurched individual might still claim to be Baptist or Catholic. Now there is great cultural freedom to drop the label entirely. The speed with which this has happened supports an old thesis of church historian Martin Marty, who wrote a book half a century ago on varieties of unbelief and who thought that religious cohesion “has long been overstated.”
John Green, a senior research adviser at Pew, breaks the religiously unaffiliated into three groups: First are those who were raised totally outside organized religion. Second are those who became unhappy with their religions and left. And lastly are those who never really engaged with religion in the first place, even though they were raised in religious households. “In the past, we would describe those people as nominally affiliated. They might say, ‘I am Catholic; I am a Baptist,’ but they never went [to services]. Now, they feel a lot more comfortable just saying, ‘You know, I am really nothing.’”
So what of Generation Z? Or more particularly, their parents? As Ruth Graham went on to write, “Somehow the gruel-thin texture of my adult faith has never troubled me. Or at least not until this summer, when my infant daughter careened into my life—including my spiritual life, such as it is.” She reflected that she wanted her child to know certain religious stories and songs, almost out of nostalgia for her own childhood, but “I don’t want her to be afraid of a hell I don’t believe in, and I don’t want to lie about what I believe.” She ended by saying, “I dread the day when my daughter asks me if the stories in the Bible are true. My real answer is that some of them are and some of them sort of are and some of them aren’t. . . . That should work for a 3-year-old, right?”
No, it shouldn’t.
But it’s what we have to work with.
When Christ and His Saints Slept
During the calamitous twelfth century, it was written that “there was never more wretched [people] on this land.” The writer then added, “And they said openly that Christ and his saints slept.”
One might be tempted to say the same of our own day, particularly in relation to how we are shaping Generation Z. There are many ways to characterize them, but in essence, two headlines must not be missed. First, they are lost. They are not simply living in and being shaped by a post-Christian cultural context. They do not even have a memory of the gospel. The degree of spiritual illiteracy is simply stunning. Stephen Prothero, chairman of the religion department of Boston University, once wrote of regularly administering a fifteen-question quiz to his undergraduate students. The quiz included the following:
Name the four Gospels.
Where according to the Bible was Jesus born?
President George W. Bush spoke in his first inaugural address of the Jericho road. What Bible story was he invoking?
What are the first five books of the Hebrew Bible or the Christian Old Testament?
What is the Golden Rule?
“God helps those who help themselves.” Is this in the Bible? If so, where?
“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of God.” Does this appear in the Bible?
Name the Ten Commandments.
Needless to say, most of his students didn’t have a clue. Today I doubt first-year seminary students would have a clue. Imagine how Generation Z would fare?
But second, they are leaderless. Little if any direction is coming from their families, and even less from their attempts to access guidance from the internet. The questions I hear from men and women in their teens and twenties border on the heartbreaking. How do I break free from pornography? How do I be a husband/wife? How do I parent? How do I pray? How do I . . .? The list of life’s most foundational questions is virtually endless, and Generation Z is asking each and every one. They have endless amounts of information but little wisdom, and virtually no mentors.
So how can they be reached?
It is to that task we now turn.
Discussion Questions
