7. Apologetics for a New Generation
7
Apologetics for a New Generation
You know that each evangelist
Who tells the passion of Lord Jesus Christ
Says not in all things as his fellows do,
. . . For some of them say more and some say less
When they His piteous passion would express.
Geoffrey Chaucer
Recently, I was interviewed for a National Public Radio program. The host and I had a good conversation about faith and culture, and we continued talking after the program. When he got me alone and off the air, he said, “Can I ask you a question? You’re a Christian, and you seem intelligent, so answer me this: What the duck is up with this idea that the earth is only six or seven thousand years old?”
Only he didn’t say “duck.”
It just rhymed with “duck.”
Let’s not get into young earth versus old earth. Here’s what everyone should get into: the “What is up with” questions. Why? Because they are the heart of what is churning around in the minds of those on the outside looking in at the Christian faith. These people have so many of these types of questions, and the essence of any conversation that might move them down the spiritual road will involve talking about them.
And without defensiveness.
It’s simply a cultural reality that people in a post-Christian world are genuinely incredulous that anyone would think like . . . well, a Christian—or at least, what it means in their minds to think like a Christian. So of course they are going to ask:
“What is up with not wanting two people who love each other to get married?”
“What is up with thinking sex is so bad?”
“What is up with a loving God sending someone like Gandhi to hell?”
I’m sure you can think of any number of questions.
Answering the “What is up with” questions is what lies at the heart of modern-day apologetics, the pre-evangelism so missing in churches. Apologetics also involves defending the character of God. Many look at the workings of the world and feel like they would act more justly than God appears to be acting. It also involves addressing the most pressing barriers post-Christians have to all things religious, which often have less to do with intellectual issues than emotional ones. As noted earlier, when those outside the faith look at those inside the faith, they don’t think we look very much like our Leader. So apologetics must grapple with the great indictments the world lays at the feet of the church, such as judgmentalism, hypocrisy, anti-intellectualism, a perceived lack of tolerance, and legalism.
That’s why at Meck we do series that actually address these very issues in as direct a way as possible. For example, a series titled “Judged” looked at how judgmentalism works in our world. Or the series “In Search of a Better God” examined how we put God in the dock for our perceived sense of his injustice. The goal is to continually uphold and defend, explain and examine the character of God.
Spiritually Illiterate
But apologetics for Generation Z runs deeper than answering new questions or addressing new barriers. Apologetics, in many ways, is at its best when it finds the cultural bridges we can walk across, and then, while walking, address the questions and barriers that exist along that path. With that in mind, what are the most powerful, fruitful bridges to cross?
Perhaps the most defining mark of members of Generation Z, in terms of their spiritual lives, is their spiritual illiteracy. This is, of course, the defining mark of the post-Christian world. They do not know what the Bible says. They do not know the basics of Christian belief or theology. They do not know what the cross is about. They do not know what it means to worship. But their spiritual illiteracy is deeper than that. They are more than post-Christian. They don’t even have a memory of the gospel.
As a result, there is a profound spiritual emptiness. They’ve never encountered God, experienced God. They are left feeling the sickness of the world’s disease without a narrative, without a story, without a transcendent meaning or purpose. They have a crisis in values; they find themselves needing them but not having them and divorced from any means of finding them. They have a lack of vision; nothing is calling them upward to be more than they are beyond themselves. Yet they cannot help but be incurably spiritual. That is the defining mark of what it means to be human. We are made in the image of God, which means we have been created to be able to respond to and be in a relationship with the living God.
So how is the vacuum being filled?
Largely through the occult and, ironically, science. Not exactly dancing partners. Yet these are the bridges over which we must learn to walk, addressing the key questions and barriers facing a faith narrative. Let’s begin with the occult.
Ghosts Skew Better
Like many Europeans, Marianne Haaland Bogdanoff, a travel agency manager in Norway, does not go to church, except maybe at Christmas, and is doubtful about the existence of God. But she believes in ghosts, even calling in a clairvoyant to solve some troubling supernatural occurrences that were happening in her office.
She’s not alone.
While Norwegian churches may be empty and belief in God in sharp decline, “belief in, or at least fascination with, ghosts and spirits is surging. Even Norway’s royal family, which is required by law to belong to the Evangelical Lutheran Church, has flirted with ghosts, with a princess coaching people on how to reach out to spirits.” Roar Fotland, a Methodist preacher and assistant professor at the Norwegian School of Theology in Oslo, notes that “God is out but spirits and ghosts are filling the vacuum.” It’s an important dynamic to understand.
Pitirim Sorokin, the founder of Harvard University’s department of sociology, argued that the pendulum of civilization generally swings in one of two directions: the ideational and the sensate. The ideational civilization is more theological and spiritual, while the sensate culture is more rational or scientific. Sorokin contended that the classic ideational period was the medieval. From the Enlightenment forward, we lived in a sensate world. Sorokin’s thesis rings true. Now in our struggle with what the modern world has given to us—or, more accurately, taken away—there seems to be a swing back toward the ideational.
We live in a world that is more open than ever to spiritual things. Not defined religion, mind you, but spirituality. And specifically, the supernatural. A keenly felt emptiness, resulting from a secularized, materialistic world, has led to a hunger for something more, but many are unable to go further than the search for an experience. As a result, an extraterrestrial will serve as well as an angel, a spiritualist as well as a minister. Borrowing from the late historian Christopher Dawson, we have a new form of secularism that offers “religious emotion divorced from religious belief.”
So God is out, but ghosts are in.
This situation reminds me of something CBS head Leslie Moonves once said when unveiling a fall television lineup heavy on the occult in order to reach a younger demographic in a state of cultural change. After canceling Emmy-nominated and critically acclaimed Joan of Arcadia, in which a young woman speaks to God, in favor of The Ghost Whisperer, a supernatural drama about a woman who communicates with the spirit world, Moonves declared, “I think talking to ghosts may skew younger than talking to God.”
He was right. Even as I write, a new challenge game is going viral. It’s about connecting with a dead spirit from Mexico named Charlie. Fueled by thousands of videos from young people supposedly showing “contact,” the game is played by placing two pencils in the shape of a cross on a piece of paper with the words yes and no. Those present then repeat the phrase, “Charlie, Charlie can we play?” in order to make contact with the demon. If Charlie is there, the pencils are said to move toward his answer. If he is present, then questions of any kind are asked . . . and answered. To end the game, players say, “Charlie, Charlie can we stop?”
The word occult means that which is hidden or secret beyond the range of ordinary human knowledge or below the surface of normal life. When used in that sense, it’s almost a neutral term. But it has come to be used as a reference to those practices that link up, intentionally or not, with the hidden, or secret, world of Satan and his demons. And that is not neutral. Then the occult involves engaging the forces of darkness, connecting with Satan and his fellow demons. When people do that, they willfully open the doors of their lives to Satan’s presence and activity.
What are the marks of the occult?
The first characteristic is the disclosure or communication of information unavailable to humans through normal means. This involves things such as horoscopes, fortune-telling, psychic hotlines, and tarot cards.
The second mark of things occultic has to do with the placing of persons in contact with supernatural powers, paranormal energies, or demonic forces. This mark entails an attempt to summon up a spirit or a deceased relative through a séance, channeling a spirit, or procuring the services of someone claiming to be a medium.
The third mark of the world of the occult is any attempt to gain and master power in order to manipulate or influence other people into certain actions. This mark includes all forms of witchcraft and the casting of spells.
There is no dead spirit from Mexico named Charlie. There are, however, demons only too happy for the ruse. And the open door.
There is one aspect of this turn to the supernatural that works in our favor—namely, that Christianity is very much a faith in the supernatural. We can speak to all things in the spirit world with clarity and definition as well as caution and warning. I know that at Meck some of our most popular and apologetically fruitful series have been on the paranormal world, mapping out the supernatural world biblically and reviewing the marks of the occult.
But there is another aspect of this interest in the supernatural that can help us reach a post-Christian world. Whenever I speak on the missional challenge of our day, particularly overseas, I am often asked where “signs and wonders” fit into things. The more I’ve reflected on this topic, the more I believe it may fit quite strategically. Too many Christians have stripped their faith of its supernatural elements, whittling the spiritual dynamic down to quiet times and promptings. Theologically, we believe in miracles and healings and pray for them regularly. Functionally, not so much. Yet biblically, the primary role of a miracle (or sign, or wonder) is to authenticate biblical revelation in fresh missional settings.
To be sure, miracles and miraculous signs and wonders are just that—miraculous. They are out of the ordinary; they are not commonplace. Otherwise they would cease to be miraculous. They are extraordinary events, creative deviations from God’s normal and natural ways of working—that’s the very definition of a miracle, a sign, or a wonder. Even within the ministry of Christ, peppered as it was with miracles, they proved to be a very small part of his day-in, day-out ministry. In fact, huge portions of the Bible go without miracles altogether, and significant men and women of God whose lives are recorded in the Bible, such as John the Baptist (John 10:41), experienced no miracles whatsoever.
Yet the purpose and function of miracles were clear. Miracles and miraculous signs and wonders are found in four main clusters in the Bible. First, they cluster around Moses (e.g., plagues of Egypt, crossing the Red Sea, manna from heaven). Second, they cluster around the prophets, such as Elijah and Elisha. Third, they cluster around Jesus himself. And fourth, they cluster around the apostles. Miracles in the Bible by and large cluster around these four poles, which represent the four main epochs of revelation—the four main eras when God was breaking out, making himself known, and releasing the Bible’s message. Through Moses, God brought the law. Through the prophets, he delivered the prophetic word. Through Jesus, he revealed his teaching and the very gospel itself. Through the apostles, he gave the New Testament writings.
It would seem clear that the major purpose of miracles was to authenticate each fresh stage of God’s revelation, drawing our attention to what God wanted us to take note of, revealing that it really was from him. Moses was a prime example: “How will they believe me?” he asked. God’s answer? He would perform signs and wonders.
Fast-forward to Acts 2:22, where Peter says that the ministry of Jesus was accredited by signs and wonders and miracles (the same is said in Heb. 2:3–4). And throughout the book of Acts, the miracles were done not just by anyone but by and large through the apostles—the only two exceptions were by men who were specifically commissioned by the apostles. And Paul, in 2 Corinthians 12:12, points out that what marks an apostle are signs, wonders, and miracles—in order to authenticate their position and message.
From this, it shouldn’t surprise a Christian that missionaries going to previously unreached people groups experience the advent of signs and wonders through their ministries at an uncommon rate. The reason would seem to be that such miracles are simply fulfilling their intent—authenticating the fresh outbreak of God’s Word. Might not the case be the same in cultures that are increasingly post-Christian yet wildly interested in the supernatural? All I know is that in many pockets of the Western world that are the most advanced in their post-Christian status, people are finding that signs and wonders, in their proper biblical place, penetrate deeply secular minds.
But there is another, equally strategic bridge we can cross. We can speak to people’s interest in the awe and wonder of the universe.
The Heavens Declare
Within our world, there is an amazingly deep sense of awe and wonder about the universe. And the ones who feel this the most? Younger Millennials, also known as Generation Z. As figure 7.1 indicates, nearly half (49 percent) express this feeling, up dramatically from earlier studies.
This openness to spirituality via cosmology was confirmed in another research project, conducted by LifeWay (see fig. 7.2), which found that “more than 4 in 10 of the nonreligious believe physics and humanity point to a creator.” Further, they are more likely to agree than disagree with the statement, “Since the universe has organization, I think there is a creator who designed it.” Granted, younger Americans are more likely than older Americans to believe human life may exist without a Creator, but with 72 percent of all Americans who agree that human life is evidence of a Creator, we have fertile ground. As LifeWay’s research director concluded, “Traditional evidences for belief in a creator resonate with most Americans.”
I have found that discussing the awe and wonder of the universe, openly raising the many questions surrounding the universe and then positing the existence of God, is one of the most valuable apologetics/pre-evangelism approaches that can be pursued. The existence of human life, the complexity of the universe, and even the starting point of a Big Bang resonate deeply with nonbelievers and provide numerous opportunities to present a coherent and compelling case for God.
So what would that kind of an apologetic approach feel and sound like? Let’s use the Big Bang as an example.
The Big Bang
Recently, a discovery was made that few scientists thought would ever be discovered at all, much less in their lifetimes: ripples made in the fabric of the universe following the Big Bang. Scientists believed that gravitational waves, first predicted by Einstein, were common, constantly crashing over the earth, but they had never been able to detect them.
Then they did.
The ripples confirmed a theory that had been tantalizing scientists for decades—namely, that the Big Bang wasn’t just big; it was fast. As in almost instantaneously, miraculously fast—beyond even the speed of light (which was previously thought to have been impossible). In fact, it happened when the universe was only a trillionth of a trillionth of a trillionth of a second old. As first posited by MIT physicist Alan Guth, the event is called inflation and refers to the universe going from something smaller than the end of your little finger to one hundred trillion trillion times that size.
The idea of the Big Bang was first put forward by Edwin Hubble, for whom the Hubble Space Telescope was named. His theory was that at one time all matter was packed into a dense mass at temperatures of many trillions of degrees. Then about 13.8 billion years ago, there was a huge explosion. And from that explosion, all of the matter that today forms our planets and stars was born. Hubble’s idea was confirmed through what had been called the discovery of the century. On April 24, 1992, the Cosmic Background Explorer satellite, better known as COBE, gave stunning confirmation of the hot Big Bang creation event.
But how did the expansion following the Big Bang take place? If it was a bang that expanded, how did it spread out so far with such equal temperatures? Now we know. As USA Today’s coverage reported, “It underwent a fast and incomprehensibly massive growth spurt in its earliest infancy.” In other words, as we might say, it was a start of biblical proportions. Miraculous, even. Who, or what, can go beyond the speed of light and spread out the entire universe instantly from a single explosion? Sounds like an “in the beginning God created” moment.
We already knew the Big Bang pointed to something outside our boundaries of knowledge. It doesn’t take a physicist to wonder what made the Big Bang bang and even less of one to ask, “If nothing existed before the Big Bang, then where did the stuff that got banged come from?” As Alan Guth himself once noted, even if you could come up with a theory that would account for the creation of something from nothing through the laws of physics, you’d still have to account for the origin of the laws of physics.
Do you see how ripe this is for spiritual conversations directly addressing the awe and wonder people already feel when contemplating the universe? As the apostle Paul wrote in Romans, “For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made” (1:20). Even those in science itself are starting to play along in a way that those trying to reach a post-Christian generation should closely follow.
A Post-Empirical God
The famed scientist Ian Barbour once observed that when religion first met modern science in the seventeenth century, the encounter was a friendly one. “By the eighteenth century many scientists believe in a God who had designed the universe, but they no longer believe in a personal God actively involved in the world and human life. By the nineteenth century,” Barbour concluded, “scientists were hostile to religion.” And the crux of that hostility is rooted in what can be called a reductive naturalism. Naturalism is the idea that nature is “all that is.” Reductive naturalism posits that all that can be known within nature is that which can be empirically verified.
So a reductive naturalism contends that what is real is only that which can be seen, tasted, heard, smelled, or touched, then verified, meaning able to be replicated in a test tube. Knowledge is “reduced” to this level of knowing. If something cannot be examined in a tangible, scientific manner, it is not simply unknowable; it is meaningless. This naturalism holds that life is accidental. There is nothing beyond ourselves that will ever bring order, reason, or explanation. We must restrict what can be known to what is immediately before us, to what is “given” or “factual.” This means (again) what can be empirically, or scientifically, demonstrated.
As astronomer Carl Sagan argued in his final work, the goal is to rid ourselves of a “demon-haunted” world, meaning anything that would challenge the rule of science and technology as the ultimate arbiter of truth and reality, for there is no other truth or reality to embrace.
So much for God. At least, that was then.
But this is now.
There is now a battle raging over the scientific method itself, particularly between those engaged in cosmology and those pursuing the study of fundamental physics. Quick primer: cosmology is the study of the universe as a whole (e.g., the Big Bang). Fundamental physics is the study of reality’s bedrock entities and their interactions (e.g., the interaction of matter, energy, space, and time).
Here’s the battle. Some scientists want to argue that if a theory is coherent, it does not need to be tested experimentally to be valid. In other words, scientific knowledge does not need to be empirical. The reason some are arguing for this reformulation is because such things as string theory and the idea of a multiverse turn old understandings of what constitutes physical reality on their head.
(Don’t worry if you don’t know what either of these ideas entails—hang with the big picture of empiricism for a moment.)
These new theories are raising questions about the very rules of science when applied to the universe as a whole, because both string theory and a multiverse posit entities that may very well be unobservable or beyond our “horizon.” In other words, while they may be true, their very nature means they can never be subject to empirical verification. This is being called post-empirical science. As a result, philosophers of physics such as Richard Dawid are arguing that in spite of the fact that there is no “evidence” for string theory, it still should be considered the most likely candidate for future research and consideration. As Dawid contends, “No one has found a good alternative to string theory.”
Going further, Sean Carroll—a highly respected and philosophically astute physicist—notes that “whether or not we can observe [extra dimensions or other universes] directly, the entities involved in these theories are either real or they are not. Refusing to contemplate their possible existence on the grounds of some a priori principle, even though they might play a crucial role in how the world works, is as non-scientific as it gets.” As an NPR report on the matter concluded, “Even if a theory predicts entities that can’t be directly observed, if there are indirect consequences of their existence we can confirm, then those theories (and those entities) must be included in our considerations.”
Precisely.
And this was the prime argument brought by theists against the Enlightenment, which sought to bracket off any consideration of God. If God could not be seen, tasted, touched, heard, or smelled, he was deemed irrelevant to scientific inquiry, much less scientific verification. The next logical step? God was obviously nonexistent. Sweet irony that it is science itself that is bringing the consideration of God back into play—and making him intellectually sound.
In many ways, it is the blending of the supernatural and science that provides the apologetic opening to Generation Z. They believe in the supernatural—nothing stirs them more than the cosmos in terms of awe and wonder—which makes them open to supernatural explanations of the universe.
I am reminded of those wonderful words penned by Robert Jastrow, who for twenty years was the director of NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies, as he reflected on the pursuit of ultimate truth: “For the scientist who has lived by his faith in the power of reason, the story ends like a bad dream. He has scaled the mountains of ignorance; he is about to conquer the highest peak; as he pulls himself over the final rock, he is greeted by a band of theologians who have been sitting there for centuries.” No wonder that post-empirical science is being called science’s most dangerous idea.
It may just lead to God. And lead others to him as well.
I was walking out of a grocery store recently when I heard someone calling, “Pastor White! Pastor White!” I turned around and saw a young man walking up to me. “I just wanted to introduce myself,” he said. “Your church has changed my life.”
He was a sophomore in college, and his girlfriend had invited him to Meck. He told me he came as an atheist but then became a Christian, had been baptized at our last baptism event, and just the month before had attended our membership class and become a member of the church.
“I just wanted to thank you,” he said.
I gave him a big hug, and by this time, his girlfriend had joined us. She got a hug too.
They turned to leave, and then he came back and said, “One other thing. I think scientifically, and the way you talked about science, that’s what got me. That’s where I had the most questions. That’s where you gave me the answers I needed.”
Discussion Questions
