Appendix A: Gay Marriage
Appendix A
Gay Marriage
The following is a talk I delivered at Mecklenburg Community Church titled “Gay Marriage.” It was the final installment of a series titled Holy Matrimony. The intent was to address one of the hottest cultural topics of the day, offering a position many outside the Christian faith are diametrically opposed to yet in a way that both explained the historic Christian position and maintained the relationship the church had with those who would be in disagreement. For an MP3 or pdf file of this talk or any other talk given at Meck, visit ChurchAndCulture.org.
Introduction
Today we talk about one of the biggest cultural issues of our day. Gay marriage.
Some of you here today are gay. And you are anxiously awaiting what I’m going to say. Well, first things first. Let me just say a few things to you.
As a follower of Christ, a pastor, and a Christian leader, I want to ask for your forgiveness for the way Christians and Christian organizations have often treated you. I’ve seen anger—even hatred—among Christians toward gays and lesbians that is repulsive and repugnant to me. And it is repulsive and repugnant to Christ.
There’s an us-versus-them mentality as if war has been declared, a spirit manifested that shows nothing but contempt. Even to the point of homophobia—an irrational fear from some.
From those who went public after such events as 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina and said it was God’s judgment on homosexuals or on those who support homosexuality.
From those who lead movements to try to get gays fired from public office or to keep them away from fair housing or employment opportunities.
From those who use terms like fag or faggots or hold up signs at funerals that say, “God hates fags.”
Let me publicly apologize to those of you within the homosexual community for that insanity and for the hatred you have felt and even may have experienced from the Christian community.
That has been sin against you, and as a representative Christian, I ask for your forgiveness.
So that’s first.
Second, I want you to know that you matter to God. He loves you, he cares about you, and he has a plan for your life. You are one of his precious children.
Your orientation—and yes, I believe for many of you it is your orientation, not simply a random choice you made one day out of the blue—does not make you a second-class person to God.
Third, I want you to know that you matter to me. Pastors and other Christian leaders haven’t always made that very clear.
Let me tell you a couple of personal stories, because this is very personal to me.
I remember after I became a Christian, I had a friend in college who was probably the most openly gay guy on the campus. I really liked this guy, and I remember we were walking from class one day and in the middle of a discussion. We were near his apartment, and he asked me if I’d like to come in and have a drink so that we could finish the conversation. So we went inside, and a lot of our conversation was on the spiritual side of things, as I was trying to explain my own decision for Christ, and he was very much in objection to that.
I’ll always remember, though, what he said when we finished. I said, “Look, I’ve got to run—I’ve got another class to go to.”
And he said, “Jim, you’re the first Christian who’s ever come into my apartment and was just willing to sit and talk with me.”
And I remember feeling stunned by this. All he’d ever experienced was rejection.
Fast-forward a couple of years, and I’ll never forget receiving a call from a funeral home in southern Indiana where I served as a pastor during my seminary years. A young man who was not connected with a church had died of an AIDS-related illness. Now keep in mind that was twenty-five years ago.
On behalf of the family, the funeral home had contacted pastor after pastor in the area. After finding out the details, each pastor they called had refused even to meet with the family, much less to serve them at the funeral service.
Finally, they got to me—the young seminary kid.
He asked me if I would officiate at the funeral, and I said, “Of course I will.”
He then went on to explain how the man had died and wondered if, after hearing the explanation, I would still be willing to do it.
“Of course!” I said.
I can honestly tell you that it never even entered my mind not to serve this family. And I was disgusted with and ashamed of my colleagues for not serving a family during such a time of grief. I knew then, some twenty-five or more years ago, that something was wrong with our attitudes and wrong with our spirits.
So please know, you matter to me. Deeply.
Fourth, I want you to know that you matter to this church. I can’t speak for every church, but I can speak for this one.
As a church, from day one, there has been an atmosphere of acceptance for everyone who wants to come and explore what Christ could mean for their lives, including those from the gay community. In fact, we were one of the first churches in the area to try to tackle the AIDS pandemic in Africa. And every time we’ve discussed homosexuality, our goal has been to do it biblically—but also lovingly, sensitively, and caringly.
I remember, many years ago, the first time I spoke publically on the subject at Meck; we were just over a year old and meeting in an elementary school. We were in a series on issues related to sex and sexuality, and the final installment was going to be on homosexuality. I prayed and worked on that talk like you wouldn’t believe because I knew even then that we had a fair number of gay people attending Meck. And I had had several conversations with them about where they stood with their spirituality.
And they mattered to me.
They were people open to Christ but burned by Christians.
They were people who were trying to figure out how the teachings of the Bible meshed with their sexual desires and lifestyles.
They were people trying to figure it all out.
I taught what I felt the Bible said as clearly as I knew how. I tried to explain the Bible’s teaching, why it mattered, and what it could mean for all of our lives—gay and straight.
When the talk was over, a woman came up to me and said, “Well, I’m one of your lesbian fans. I had a pretty good idea what you were going to say today. But what I didn’t know was how you were going to say it. And I just want to say thank you.” And then she hugged me.
I then saw that she had bought about five or six cassette tapes—it was cassette tapes back then—to give to her friends.
You have no idea how much that meant to me and what a personal victory that was for me. She may have disagreed with what I said, but she sensed that our church was marked by love and grace. Not just about the subject but for her.
Finally, I want you to know one last thing before we jump in. We’re not fixated on this. We’re not trying to talk about this every few months. We’re not singling this out. We talk about all relevant issues related to sexuality. So we’re not trying to single this out, but it is a big issue. And has been for a while. But we’re in a series on holy matrimony, so it would be crazy not to talk about it here.
So with that said, let’s jump in. I want to approach this in three ways: first, what the Bible says about homosexuality—specifically, homoerotic behavior; second, how that relates to a homosexual orientation; and then third, how all this plays out in relation to gay marriage. So if that sounds like a good road map, let’s get started with the Bible.
I. The Bible
To address the issue of homosexuality biblically, we have to begin with God’s original design for human sexuality and relationship. This design is found in the book of Genesis, the first book of the Bible, which tells the story of the very creation of humanity. Let me read it:
The LORD God said, “It is not good for the man to be alone. I will make a helper suitable for him.” . . . The LORD God made a woman . . . and brought her to the man. . . . That is why a man leaves his father and mother and is united to his wife, and they become one flesh. Adam and his wife were both naked, and they felt no shame. (2:18, 22, 24–25)
There are four foundational truths to be learned from that passage.
First, that God created sexual identity.
Second, that in making sexual identity, he made human beings male and female. That was the sexual identity he made. After Adam, a man, was created, a helpmate was made that was suitable, appropriate, and correct. For Adam, that person was a woman.
Third, we find that God created sexual intimacy. Not just identity but intimacy.
Finally, that God intended the expression of that sexual intimacy to take place between a man and a woman in the context of marriage. This means that femininity and masculinity are at the heart of God’s design. They form the basis for marriage, for the two becoming one. Both genders reflect God’s image, and together they reflect and honor God as they join in union with one another. God created men, God created women, God created marriage—so that their differences would complete one another in every conceivable way . . . emotionally, physically, and spiritually.
Which means marriage is more than merely personal. It is more than a contract. And it is much more than tax returns and health insurance. It is a lived-out parable of the principles that undergird the universe. It is the foundational building block of human society. This is why the Bible says that for this reason a man leaves his father and mother and is joined to his wife, and the two are united into one.
Which brings us to homosexuality.
Homosexual behavior departs from God’s blueprint in two foundational ways. First, instead of embracing the man-woman design, homosexual behavior embraces a same-sex (man-man, woman-woman) preference as the blueprint for sexual intimacy. Second, at least until recently, it also departed from God’s intent for that sexual intimacy to take place within the confines of marriage.
Bracketing off the marriage issue for a moment, let’s look at what the Bible has to say about the choice for same-sex sexual intimacy.
In the Old Testament book of Leviticus, the Bible says, “Do not practice homosexuality. . . . It is a detestable sin” (18:22 NLT). Then one chapter later, it adds, “If a man has sex with a man as one does with a woman, both of them have done what is abhorrent” (20:13 Message).
The same is upheld in the New Testament. This is from the book of Romans:
They traded the truth about God for a lie. . . . Even the women turned against the natural way to have sex and instead indulged in sex with each other. And the men, instead of having normal sexual relationships with women, burned with lust for each other. Men did shameful things with other men. (1:25–27 NLT)
There are other verses, but I won’t take time to read them all.
Suffice it to say that every single reference to homosexual behavior in the Bible—Old and New Testament—condemns it. Without question and without qualification. The passages aren’t ambiguous, in the way that people might have once looked to the Bible to cherry-pick things and erroneously affirm slavery or make women second-class citizens. You don’t have that with these passages.
As Edith Humphrey has written, there are no internal tensions on this matter, and “the moral tradition of the church, from the earliest period into the Reformation and since, has been emphatic: Homoerotic behavior is against the will of God.”
But some have still questioned whether what we just read really says what it seems to say. It seems clear enough on the surface, but those who wish to advocate for the legitimacy of a homosexual lifestyle have gone to great pains to discredit each and every biblical reference.
For example, in the passage that we read from Leviticus, they would argue that the book of Leviticus goes on to condemn eating shellfish, cutting your sideburns, and getting tattoos. They would say that it’s all ancient religious law shattered by the New Testament fulfillment in Christ, including what it says about homosexuality.
Friends, I’m sorry to put on my old graduate school professor hat, but if I had you in a basic Bible 101 class—like I’ve taught a thousand times to graduate students and seminary students over the years—I would tell you that is a ridiculous reading of the Scriptures. And it shows a lack of knowledge and, frankly, an ignorance of all this.
You can’t write these off as mere cultic practices in ancient Israel and no longer binding on Christians, because that misses out on one of the basic understandings of the Old Testament—namely, that there is a whole body of teaching on ritual uncleanness and a whole body of clear teaching on immoral behavior. One is time bound—caught up with the sacrificial system of the people of Israel. The other is timeless. One describes temple rituals. The other deals with moral laws. They are two different things.
Further, the New Testament condemns homoerotic behavior too!
So when homoerotic behavior is talked about in the Old Testament, it’s rooted in creation. In morality. It’s not the same as which foods you can eat or what’s kosher or not. Just like the prohibitions in the Old Testament against incest, the prohibition against homoerotic behavior is for every age.
Then there are those who take the New Testament to task by saying that while it seems to condemn homosexuality, it’s really talking about male prostitutes, not same-sex consensual relationships. The problem with that is that the Greek words used for homosexuality in the New Testament are very clear. They refer to homosexuality of any and every kind.
If you have any doubts about whether the New Testament says what it plainly seems to say, we have books in The Grounds and at The Grounds Posts at all of our campuses that get into this.
So the conclusion remains: God created human beings as male and female. He meant for sexual intimacy to be between a man and a woman alone in the context of marriage. As a result, the Bible sees any departure from that design as outside God’s will for our lives, including homosexuality.
II. Orientation
Which brings us to the orientation issue.
Because the biggest argument against what the Bible says really isn’t about what the Bible says—that’s clear—it’s about whether we should accept it. And the biggest reason some give for not accepting it has to do with orientation.
Because people say, “But this is who I am! It’s how I was made!” From this, many homosexuals will say that it is unfair, even cruel, to condemn them for pursuing how they naturally are. They say, “Why should I be condemned for following my natural desire! How can God condemn me when he is the one who made me this way?” Or they’ll say, “How can the Bible be right when God made me gay?”
Because of this argument, some Christians early on in this cultural debate used to deny that it’s really an orientation. That it’s all a choice. But, friends, I’m sorry. That’s crazy. It’s just not true.
Many people who pursue a lifestyle of homosexual behavior didn’t set out to be this way; they really do have a very strong tendency toward that behavior. They genuinely have a same-sex attraction. Arguing that is stupid.
Now, can a homosexual orientation be brought to the surface or pursued through various psychological factors or life experiences? Sure. But here’s the larger truth: a homosexual orientation is no different from any other orientation someone can have toward a particular lifestyle that may be outside God’s will. Someone might have an orientation toward pride, another for chemical addiction, another for gambling or slander, someone else for stealing or lying. All of us have a certain makeup that shapes us and makes us more prone to a particular temptation than others.
It’s really dangerous to say, “God made me this way, so it’s okay for me to pursue this.” Are you sure that God made you that way, or is that just your brokenness? Because this whole world is broken, and we are all sin-stained and sin-soaked. And the world is broken through sin going all the way back to Adam and Eve. So be really careful when you say what God did in terms of how and who you are.
I’m broken.
So play this out: let’s say you want to defend pursuing a lifestyle on the basis of orientation. You say, “I do what I do because I am what I am. And because of who I am, this is what I must do.” Play that one out. Is this right?
It’s certainly not accurate from a psychological point of view. Most would say that who we are is a combination of nature plus nurture. It’s how we are put together and the choices we make in life.
It’s not accurate morally either. If your philosophy is that desire should dictate values, then that means that whatever I desire to do is to be pursued and fulfilled without restraint. Please hang with me on this. If I say that because I have the desire, it must be a legitimate lifestyle, what if my desires are to murder? What if they have to do with molesting young children?
You say, “You’re crazy! Nobody in the homosexual community is saying that!”
Of course they’re not. But that’s beside the point. It is a question of where the philosophy logically leads.
Once you make a philosophy such as this a guiding value system, it applies across the board. You can’t pick and choose where you want to apply it. Either desire legitimates behavior, or it doesn’t.
What matters is not so much where you are tempted, friends, but what you do with that temptation. I may have moments when in my anger I desire to inflict bodily harm on someone. In fact, a person who struggles with anger is very much oriented toward that very action. But that’s very different than it authorizing me to give in to the feeling and act on it.
This is very important. The Bible doesn’t condemn anyone for homosexual desire. You need to know that. There’s nothing condemning homosexual desire but homosexual practice. But like any other desire outside God’s will for our lives, it calls us to resist that temptation.
If someone tells me they’re gay, I hardly bat an eye. What I want to know is what choices they are making about how they are living in light of their orientation.
The Bible makes this very clear in the book of James. Let me read its words:
The temptation to give in to evil comes from us and only us. We have no one to blame but the leering, seducing flare-up of our own lust. Lust gets pregnant, and has a baby: sin! Sin grows up to adulthood, and becomes a real killer. (1:14–15 Message)
The progression there is critical to note.
Temptation comes through our own desire. But just because desire is there doesn’t mean what we want to do is okay. Each of us has our own unique areas of weakness, areas where we have desires that aren’t of God.
As a straight man, I may have desires for sexual fulfillment outside of marriage with a woman who isn’t my wife. But that is no different in God’s eyes than the homosexual temptations another person might have. When faced with that temptation, it is up to both of us to choose—to either turn away from the desire or give in to it.
Now the gay person might say, “Well, at least you can get your sexual appetite fulfilled in a marriage. I can’t!”
But that’s going back and saying that desire is what determines everything. That sexual fulfillment is the one area in our lives that must be in charge and determine everything. You’re saying the most important guiding value of your life is making sure you have an orgasm. Really? As if somehow that is the one temptation that should not be fought.
But that’s not what the Bible tells us about temptation, no matter what kind it is. Listen to this from the New Testament book of 1 Corinthians:
The temptations in your life are no different from what others experience. And God is faithful. He will not allow the temptation to be more than you can stand. When you are tempted, he will show you a way out so that you can endure. (10:13 NLT)
It’s a really interesting verse. A direct promise that no temptation has seized you that is different from any other temptation any of us face. And that God is faithful. He will provide a way out for you to choose if you so desire.
III. Gay Marriage
Which brings us to gay marriage, which in many ways we’ve already answered, not just today but throughout this series.
According to the Bible, a homosexual union is in direct contradiction to God’s original design in creation. So even if you do have a loving, monogamous relationship with someone of the same sex, it’s still a violation of God’s design for that relationship to be between a man and a woman in the context of marriage.
But some would say that regardless of where you might stand morally, gay marriage should be endorsed as a fundamental civil right. Even further, that any pledge of love and commitment between two people can only be a positive move, even if you do not support the lifestyle.
But that misses the point. It’s not about civil unions. It’s about marriage. And wanting this legitimized as a definition of marriage. Which biblically, you just can’t do. Biblically, marriage isn’t something we make up or we define. God did it. And it is what it is.
Now if we as a culture want to reduce the idea of marriage to a civil union and make them synonymous—which is what we’re essentially doing—then fine. But as a Christian, I can’t endorse it.
See, here are the two things that can happen and that are happening: you can lower the definition of marriage to just a civil union or a contract. But biblically, we can’t do that—it’s so much more. Or you can elevate the civil union and say that fulfills God’s vision for marriage. And we can’t do that either.
Christians are simply being forced to choose another word for the biblical vision. Or certainly give a different definition. Which has really been the point of this series. That things have become so watered down that what we need to talk about isn’t marriage but holy matrimony. The biblical idea of what marriage really is about. And it is countercultural, and it is different. Because it’s a whole lot more than the right to participate in state-defined benefits.
So do I think Christians should oppose gay-marriage amendments? I think you should vote your conscience. But I will say that I will stand firm, to the end, on the biblical definition of what marriage should be in our culture. And even if I’m the last lone voice crying out in the wilderness, I will be that voice.
IV. Final Pastoral Words
Now having said all of this, I have two closing pastoral words.
First, I know that some of you are instantly thinking that all this acceptance talk that I started off with just got ripped away from you. You will say this is not accepting at all. And here’s why. Because to you, the only acceptance that you will accept as acceptance is affirmation. Approval. If you don’t approve, if you don’t affirm, then you don’t accept.
Okay, you are now being as unfair to someone like me as Christians used to be unfair to you.
You rightfully rebelled against those who wanted to single out and criminalize your lifestyle, but now you want to criminalize those who disagree with your lifestyle and say that the only way you can have acceptance and tolerance is if I affirm you.
Well, I’m going to push back, because that is a screwed-up idea of tolerance. And I’ve talked about this before. There are three kinds of tolerance.
The first is legal tolerance. This has to do with our basic first amendment rights to believe what we want to believe. There is nothing in the Christian stance on gay marriage that goes against that. In fact, the Bible is a great advocate of legal tolerance.
The second is social or cultural tolerance. This is accepting someone else as who they are regardless of what they believe. Loving them, caring about them, being open to them relationally. There is nothing in all of this against that either. If Jesus stood for anything, it was open, loving acceptance of others as people who mattered to God.
The third is intellectual tolerance. This is accepting what someone believes as right regardless of what you believe or think is right. And it’s only in that sense that the Christian stance on gay marriage would be considered intolerant, because Jesus didn’t believe that everything and everyone was right. The Bible clearly holds to the idea that there is right and wrong, true and false.
But that’s the way most of us feel, isn’t it? Think about it. Do any of us really believe in rampant intellectual tolerance? That there is no right, there is no wrong, it doesn’t really matter?
Perhaps someone came up to you and said, “I believe that the best way to improve the performance of your car is to pour sand into the gas tank.” Now, can I be tolerant of that person—legally and relationally—without buying into what he says? Of course!
I can say, “You know what, I think you have every right to pour sand into your car. It’s your car—and I’m not going to get all worked up to try to stop you legally from doing it. Have at it. And if you do, I’m still gonna come over to your house this weekend so that we can watch the finale of Breaking Bad. This doesn’t impact us socially at all. You’re still my friend.”
But being legally tolerant and socially tolerant doesn’t mean I’m going to be intellectually tolerant. I’m still going to tell you that I don’t agree. I’m not going to put sand in my car, and I don’t mind telling you that, much less advising other drivers that I don’t think they should either. And I’ll go further. I will resist you trying to make it so that I affirm sand in the car as an option or that somehow I get roped into putting sand into mine.
If that’s the endgame here—where it’s not just about acceptance or legality but the desire to criminalize any denunciation and force others to participate or affirm—well then, friends, we’re into a whole different territory.
And I’ll say to my gay friends, “I hope that you can see that’s where this is heading, and I hope that you’ll join me in denouncing it.”
So it is one thing to be against homosexuality and to affirm that the Bible rejects the practice of same-sex lifestyles—which I believe it does—but it is another to be against homosexuals—which I do not embrace. And I can be accepting of you, loving toward you, and hold to that. And I hope we all can uphold that together.
Here’s my second pastoral word, to all of us. This sin is no greater than any other sin. The struggle of gays in being attracted to the same sex is no different than my struggle with anger, or with impatience, or with gluttony. And when people give in to it, it is no worse than any other sin. All sin, at its heart, is rebellion against God.
Now it’s true that sexual sins are particularly destructive to our lives. But that’s true no matter what the sexual sin is—whether it’s adultery or an addiction to pornography. All of us are broken sexually. We all need healing and health, wholeness and redemption.
If you are gay, the ultimate issue is not the gay lifestyle. My primary issue as your pastor is not your homoerotic lifestyle. That’s not the starting point. The first and most important issue is not that you straighten yourself out in this area and then come to Christ. The most important issue is your relationship with Christ. That you come to Christ first and then see how he applies to your sexuality and sexual choices.
Conclusion
Just like the rest of us are doing. We all have the same disease. We’re all being treated for sin-sickness. We’re all in some kind of recovery. So whatever you brought with you today, you’re not alone. And we do not condemn you. You are no different from any of the rest of us struggling with areas of temptation and desire. And we’ve all failed in those areas.
But Christ is working on all of us.
Meck is nothing but a colossal collection of moral foul-ups. Really, if you’re new here, I have to warn you—you’re in some bad company here. We have sins of pride, greed, pornography, self-righteousness, lying, stealing, adultery, insensitivity to others. . . .
But through the power of Christ, there is hope for all of us.
But here’s what else you need to know. We want to expose those areas in our lives—not deny them or rationalize them away. We want to run to what the Bible says, not to find loopholes or ways to justify or denounce what it says. Not in a way that condemns but in a way that transforms. We want to discover our junk, go to God for forgiveness, and become increasingly changed people.
So our invitation?
Join us.
Join me—the chief of sinners. But oh if you only knew what I was like before Christ started to work in my life.
So that’s all I have to say on this one.
Let’s stand for a closing prayer.
