2. Meet Generation Z
2
Meet Generation Z
One generation passeth away, and another generation cometh.
Ecclesiastes 1:4 KJV
Each year students begin college across the nation, forming a new freshman class. In the spirit of understanding generational change, the good folk at Beloit College produce an annual college freshman mindset list. Consider one of their more recent, based on the 2015 freshman class. Students heading into their first year of college in 2015 were mostly eighteen and were born in 1997.
Here are a few of Beloit’s observations:
Since they have been on the planet:
There is one other mark, of course. One that is, without a doubt, the most significant. One that the Beloit observers neglected to include.
The freshman class of 2015 embodies an entirely new generation: Generation Z.
Generation Z
I know some are still trying to catch up with Busters, or Generation X, or whatever we called whoever followed the Boomers. Or maybe you leapfrogged over all that straight to Generation Y (Millennials), on whom marketers have been focused for at least a decade. I could tell you there are actually six living generations in America, but I don’t want to add to your stress.
Let me save you some time. Drop everything and start paying attention to Generation Z, which now constitutes 25.9 percent of the US population (see fig. 2.1). That’s more than Millennials (24.5 percent). That’s more than Gen X (15.4 percent). Yes, that’s even more than Baby Boomers (23.6 percent). By 2020, members of Generation Z will account for 40 percent of all consumers. They will not simply influence American culture, as any generation would; they will constitute American culture.
So who falls into Generation Z? There’s still some debate on exact dates, but essentially it involves those who were born after Generation Y, so approximately 1995 to around 2010. It is the generation that is now collectively under the age of twenty-five.
Some would argue those born from, say, 1980 to the early 2000s are one giant cohort known as Millennials. It’s true that such a grouping would be unified under a technology revolution, but as the research of Bruce Tulgan notes, “This time frame is simply too broad to define just one generation because the 1990s and the 2000s are two distinct eras.” To lump them together would be to link a thirteen-year-old with a thirty-five-year-old. And even technologically, that would be hard to embrace. Much of the 1990s was pre-internet (except for very, very early adopters). And the smartphone? Nonexistent. The ubiquitous nature of these two things alone would decisively divide any generation. “Growing up with a supercomputer in your pocket connected to most of the world’s population and knowledge,” writes David Pakman, “has created an irreversible pattern of behavior unlikely to revert to the ways of previous generations.” Or as an article in the New York Times noted, “A 14-year-old in 2015 really does inhabit a substantially different world than one of 2005.”
Intriguingly, some are calling Generation Z the last generation we will ever speak of. The speed of culture, in which change can happen in a day, will make speaking of generations and their markings obsolete. “Tomorrow will be less about what a difference a generation makes, but more about what a difference a day makes.” All the more reason to make sure we know about what is probably the last, and arguably what will prove to be the most influential, generation in Western history.
So who is Generation Z? They are growing up in a post-9/11 world. They are experiencing radical changes in technology and understandings of family, sexuality, and gender. They live in multigenerational households, and the fastest-growing demographic within their age group is multiracial. But let’s unpack them a bit more slowly. Here are the five defining characteristics of Generation Z.
Defining Characteristics of Generation Z
Recession Marked
With most members of Generation Z born after 9/11, the most defining event in their lifetimes is the Great Recession. Beginning in 2007, this economic era is widely considered the worst global downturn since World War II. While Millennials were “raised during the boom times and relative peace of the 1990s, only to see their sunny world dashed by the September 11 attacks and two economic crashes, in 2000 and 2008 . . . Generation Z, by contrast,” says the New York Times, “has had its eyes open from the beginning, coming along in the aftermath of those cataclysms in the era of the war on terror and the Great Recession.” This helps explain the (surprising to many) embrace of socialism among young voters in the 2016 presidential election, in marked contrast to older voters. A YouGov study found that 26 percent of those between the ages of eighteen and thirty-nine had a favorable view of socialism, compared to only 15 percent over the age of sixty-five.
As members of Generation Z develop their personalities and life skills in a socioeconomic environment “marked by chaos, uncertainty, volatility, and complexity,” it is no surprise that blockbusters like The Hunger Games and Divergent, with their depictions of teens left alone to face a dystopian future, connect with them. Simply put, they are deeply worried about the present.
They are not alone.
The Public Religion Research Institute’s annual American Values Survey “documents discontent among all major religious groups, races and political views.” As PRRI CEO Robert Jones commented, “I am struck by the high level of anxiety and worry on all fronts.” For the first time in six years of the survey, Americans are split—49 percent to 49 percent—on whether “America’s best days are ahead of us or behind us. . . . Americans of all faiths and viewpoints are gloomy about the economy, anxious about Islam, bothered by immigrants and mistrustful across racial lines.” And adding to the joy, more than seven out of ten (72 percent) believe that the country is still in a recession. “No wonder,” says the research report of Sparks and Honey, “Gen Z developed coping mechanisms and a certain resourcefulness.” Even when news broke of the widespread terrorist attacks in Paris in November 2015, the younger people I engaged were shocked but not surprised. There’s a difference. And the difference is that attacks like these are not simply reality but what life has always been like.
Their coping mechanisms have led to a strong sense of independence and an entrepreneurial spirit. According to a study by Northeastern University, a “notable 42 percent of Generation Z respondents expect to work for themselves during their careers.” But their goal is not simply economic security. They are marked by a very strong sense of wanting to make a difference—and thinking that they can. Among the attendees at a recent Generation Z conference at American University in Washington, DC, was Sejal Makheja. At the age of fourteen, she founded the Elevator Project, an organization that aims to lift people out of poverty through apprenticeship, vocational training, and job placement. She said she went to the Gen Z conference because she wanted to cultivate the skills she’ll need to take the Elevator Project to a national scale. “The young people at the conference want to take an active role in their communities and their futures,” she said. “It’s an upbeat group that’s full of passion.” Not surprisingly, the research of Sparks and Honey reveals that social entrepreneurship is one of Generation Z’s most popular career choices.
This may explain why, when MTV conducted a nationwide survey of one thousand respondents born after the year 2000 to see how they would identify themselves if they had the choice, they came up with the self-important name “The Founders”—as in needing to “found the new world,” rescuing it from the sins of its past. For an immediate and inspiring introduction to this mindset, go no further than one of the many TED talks featuring teenagers sharing their visions and dreams for the future. For example, Logan LaPlante’s presentation at TEDx at the University of Nevada on “Hackschooling” has been viewed on YouTube over nine million times as of the time of this writing. “Hackers are innovators,” LaPlante said from the stage. “Hackers are people who challenge and change the system to make them work differently. To make them work better. . . . I’m growing up in a world that needs more people with a hacker mindset.”
Wi-Fi Enabled
It’s no wonder that a term like hacker is being wielded in such broad ways. While it’s still the early days for Generation Z, research from the Wharton School declares that “already one defining characteristic is abundantly clear: This generation is Wi-Fi enabled.” Many refer to the Millennials as being “digital natives,” due to their comfort and innate abilities with digital technology. But according to David Bell, professor of marketing at Wharton, Generation Z is the “Internet-in-its-pocket” generation.
The speed by which this technological revolution has taken place is stunning and makes it difficult for older generations to realize the radically different world into which Generation Z has been born. As William Bernstein has pointed out, by 1960, only armies, governments, and very large organizations operated computers; by 1970, small organizations had acquired them. By 1980, hobbyists were happily assembling them from kits; by 1990, inexpensive personal computers had entered the home. By 2000, “most citizens of the developed world had access to the Internet.” Generation Z is the first generation that is the product of what Bernstein calls the fourth great communication revolution: the first was language itself, the second was writing, the third was the mechanization of writing, and the fourth was the electronic encoding of information.
Currently, teenagers spend nearly nine hours a day absorbing media. And according to the teens themselves, Mom and Dad may care about the content of what they absorb but not the time spent on media itself. In fact, parents seem to be the enablers. According to eMarketer, in the United States, kids are most likely to be gifted with gaming devices and TVs between ages four and seven. From the ages of eight to eleven, they will receive a gaming console, digital musical player, tablet, or e-reader. Twenty-two million twelve- to seventeen-year-olds in the United States alone owned a mobile device in 2015.
While Baby Boomers can’t remember a world without TV and Millennials can’t remember a world without computers, “Gen Z does not know a world without constant, immediate and convenient access to the web.” When Steve Jobs announced the original iPhone as little more than a combination of “three revolutionary projects”—a cell phone, an iPod, and a keyboardless handheld computer with internet connectivity—even he didn’t know what had been unleashed. Beyond the more than one million applications and counting, it opened the door to what Brian Chen calls the “anything-anytime-anywhere future” in which we are constantly connected to a global internet community via handheld, incredibly capable gadgets with ubiquitous access to data. As he titles his book, we now live in a world that is “always on.”
This means a world with very few constraints, and members of Generation Z are taking advantage of it. Ninety-two percent report going online daily. A quarter say they go online “almost constantly.” Ninety-one percent go to bed with their devices. No surprise that they also spend more money online than any other generation. Yet the implications of this constant connection to the internet and, through it, the world and all of its information leads to another Generation Z dynamic: the “ability to find whatever they’re after without the help of intermediaries—such as libraries, shops, or teachers.” This has made them “more independent and self-directed than generations before them.”
Like no other generation before, Generation Z faces a widening chasm between wisdom and information. Quentin Schultze writes that the torrent of information now at our disposal is often little more than “endless volleys of nonsense, folly and rumor masquerading as knowledge, wisdom, and even truth.” Chuck Kelley, president of New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary, has noted that “Google has changed the relationship of people to information. For the last three or four hundred years, information has been collected on college, university, and seminary campuses. . . . You went to the collected information to learn. Today the information is available anywhere you want, just Google it.” Kelley observes that the new task of education is to help students evaluate information. He’s right. It is as if we’ve dropped a library card onto the world but removed the classroom that gives us the literacy to read its contents, much less the education needed to interpret its contents.
Then there is social media, which is not merely second nature to them; it is their primary nature. But unlike older participants in social media, they are not wed to any single social network. Further, they are much more private about things than their Millennial elders. They gravitate less toward Facebook than anonymous social media platforms such as Snapchat, Secret, and Whisper. As a Mashable article by Ruby Karp, a New York teenager, was titled, “I’m 13 and None of My Friends Use Facebook.” According to a Pew study, a stunning 57 percent have never posted anything online due to privacy concerns. Arguably, this is a result of seeing how permanent a footprint was left by older Millennials who often posted foolishly.
But because social media is their nature, so is seeking its immediate affirmation and acceptance, “since that’s where all their peers are and where many of the important conversations happen,” writes Jeremy Finch. “They curate different social media personas in order to please each audience and minimize conflict or controversy.” Or as one sixteen-year-old from Arizona said, “We filter out whatever flaws we may have, to create the ideal image.”
According to Keith Niedermeier, adjunct professor of marketing at Wharton, Generation Z’s time online, along with their extensive reliance on social media, means “they’re also highly influenced by others’ opinions and word of mouth.” In fact, while 29 percent still get most of their news from original online news sites like NYTimes.com or CNN.com, “a significant 27 percent receive their information primarily through word of mouth.” Sparks and Honey found that 52 percent of Generation Z even use social media for their research assignments in school.
But don’t think this means they are becoming distanced from personal interactions, much less relationships. Only 15 percent prefer to interact with their friends via social media rather than face-to-face. The vast majority also do not want to ask someone out on a date online or break off a relationship online. While they relate to others through media, it is often through live streaming services such as FaceTime or Skype.
Multiracial
The United States is currently in the midst of a changing racial demographic, what some have called the fourth wave of immigration following the passage of immigration reform in 1965, which eliminated quotas based on nationality. The current wave is the largest in history, with the majority of these immigrants coming to our country from Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean. Between 2000 and 2010, the country’s Hispanic population grew at four times the rate of the total population. In 2006, there was a record number of births in the United States, and 49 percent of those born were Hispanic. Since the early 1700s, the most common last name in the United States was Smith, but now it is Rodriguez.
But this trend is about more than immigration. The number of Americans self-identifying as white and black multiracial rose 134 percent. The number of Americans of mixed white and Asian descent grew by 87 percent. There has been a 400 percent increase in black-white multiracial marriages in the last thirty years and a 1,000 percent increase in Asian-white marriages. Overall, multiracial children are the fastest-growing youth group in the United States. When the 2020 census is conducted, it is estimated that more than half of all US children will be part of a minority race or ethnic group.
As a result, Generation Z is the most racially diverse of any generation to date. As a writer for the Bloomberg News put it, “It may be the first generation for which diversity is a natural concept.” They are globally connected, which means their social circles are often global. Or as one research project put it, “26 percent of Gen Z would need to fly to visit most of their social network friends.” This diversity also leads to being “accepting” and “inclusive.” Some have described this as the “Kumbaya” dynamic, members of Generation Z standing in a circle holding hands. They are connected to people around them and aware of the world beyond themselves.
Sexually Fluid
The accepting nature of Generation Z leads to strong support for such things as gay marriage and transgender rights. They are coming of age in the era that has put such things in the mainstream, such as in 2015 when the Supreme Court legalized gay marriage and former-Olympian-turned-reality-TV-star Bruce Jenner very publicly became Caitlyn Jenner. Indeed, according to the Northeastern University study, the “question of same-sex marriage is decisively settled for them, with 73 percent in favor. Notably, they also support equal rights for transgender people in high numbers (74 percent).” For Generation Z, the idea of “acceptance” is often interchangeable with the idea of “affirmation.”
Yet it would be a mistake to see Generation Z as simply the product of an abrupt social change related to such headlines. As Michael Gerson and Peter Wehner have noted, when the Supreme Court decided in Obergefell v. Hodges that the Constitution guarantees a right to same-sex marriage, it was the result of cultural trends that emerged in the context of heterosexual, not homosexual, relationships. “Marriage was not redefined only by the Supreme Court,” they write. “It was also redefined by decades of social practice.” In other words, decades of radical individualism—particularly in sexual ethics—that resulted in a “shift in attitudes, behavior, and laws on divorce, abortion, cohabitation, out-of-wedlock births, gender roles, and now, decisively, same-sex marriage.” Translation: Generation Z is the cultural product of decisions made by earlier generations as opposed to their own.
Nonetheless, from this shift in attitudes and behaviors Generation Z has become sexually and relationally amorphous. Consider the influential statements by outspoken young celebrities such as Kristen Stewart, Miley Cyrus, and Cara Delevingne. Stewart, when asked about her sexuality, said, “I think in three or four years, there are going to be a whole lot more people who don’t think it’s necessary to figure out if you’re gay or straight. It’s like, just do your thing.” And from Miley Cyrus: I don’t “relate to being boy or girl, and I don’t have to have my partner relate to boy or girl.”
They are not alone.
A recent UK study revealed that nearly half of all young people don’t think they are exclusively heterosexual. The YouGov survey revealed that 49 percent of people between the ages of eighteen and twenty-four identified as something other than 100 percent heterosexual. This despite the repeated findings that only about 4 percent of the entire adult population is actually homosexual. What is being revealed is an increasing sexual fluidity that refuses either the homosexual or the heterosexual label. The idea is that both labels are repressive. Sexuality should be set free from any and all restrictions, and people should be allowed to follow their desires, moment by moment.
Why? Because the greatest value for this generation is nothing less than individual freedom. So don’t be misled by the studies reporting that they don’t drink, smoke, take drugs, or sleep around (and to be sure, their percentages on each are lower than previous generations). They are not, in any way, socially conservative philosophically.
Beyond what we’ve already detailed, it is interesting how marketing firms package their conclusions regarding Generation Z. For example, according to the marketing research of Sparks and Honey, here are the top “Z” headlines:
All true, but this is a very tame list—quite frankly, one you would expect from a marketing firm. And not surprisingly, it misses the biggest headline of all, which constitutes the fifth and final defining mark of Generation Z.
The most defining characteristic of Generation Z is that it is arguably the first generation in the West (certainly in the United States) that will have been raised in a post-Christian context. As a result, it is the first post-Christian generation.
Yes, most people of Generation Z still believe in the existence of God (78 percent). But less than half attend weekly religious services of any kind (41 percent), and only 8 percent would cite a religious leader as a role model. The largest single religious category in the Harvard Crimson’s “by the numbers” survey of the class of 2019 was “agnostic” (21.3 percent). Recall the statistics from the previous chapter: the younger the demographic, the greater the percentage who fall into the category of the religiously unaffiliated—the nones. And, Pew reports, they do not seem to be growing more religiously observant as they get older. As the research of the Barna Group concluded, the “pattern is indisputable: The younger the generation, the more post-Christian it is.”
Discussion Questions
