Appendix C: Why Believe in God?
Appendix C
Why Believe in God?
The following is a talk I delivered at Mecklenburg Community Church titled “Why Believe in God?” It was the second installment of a series titled Why Believe. The intent was to address reasons for belief in an age of skepticism and also to build on what still constitutes common ground, such as Generation Z’s sense of awe and wonder at the cosmos and how they feel it might reasonably point to God. For an MP3 or pdf file of this talk or any other talk given at Meck, visit ChurchAndCulture.org.
Introduction
Welcome to Meck!
We’re getting ready to enter the big summer movie season, with the latest Avengers film starting things off in just a few weeks. So let’s play some movie trivia. I’ll throw up the questions, and see if you can guess the answer. And just guess in your head. Here we go:
1. Who was the first female monster to appear in a movie?
A. Godzilla
B. the bride of Frankenstein
C. the Mummy (Get it?!)
D. Kim Kardashian
Got your pick?
Answer: the bride of Frankenstein.
2. What was the first movie that was ever given the title “blockbuster”?
A. Star Wars
B. Gone with the Wind
C. Jaws
D. Dumb and Dumber 3
Answer: Jaws.
3. Which of these actors once had a job polishing coffins?
A. Marlon Brando
B. Sean Connery
C. Robert Pattinson
D. Bela Lugosi
Answer: Sean Connery.
4. Who has the most nominations for an Oscar in movie history?
A. Jack Nicholson
B. Laurence Olivier
C. Paul Newman
D. Justin Bieber
Answer: Jack Nicholson (twelve times).
5. What do the following six actors all have in common—beyond, of course, that they’re all actors: Daniel Radcliffe, Julianne Moore, Keira Knightley, Ian McKellen, Hugh Laurie, and Jodie Foster?
A. They’ve all been nominated for an Oscar.
B. They’ve all had the same director in a film.
C. They’ve all been in a movie that earned over $50 million at the box office.
D. They’re all atheists.
Answer: They’re all atheists.
Last week we kicked off a series called Why Believe with a look at why believe in Jesus and, specifically, his resurrection. Today we’re going to look at why even believe in God.
Granted, not many people are card-carrying atheists. But there are a fair number of agnostics, and you might be one of them. An agnostic doesn’t necessarily reject God as much as the possibility of knowing.
But do you have to be agnostic? Is it possible to dig into whether or not God exists and come away saying, “It makes more sense to believe in God than not to believe in God”?
Let’s find out. Let’s look at some of the reasons why the idea of God is so intellectually plausible—so intellectually compelling—to a lot of people.
I. Cause and Effect
Let’s start with the cosmological reason, or more commonly known as cause and effect. This reason for believing in God rests on a simple, commonsense question: You look around at the world and ask, “How did this happen?” It was caused by something. What was that cause?
The universe had a beginning. Anything that has a beginning must have been begun. It couldn’t have started itself—it had to have been caused by something else.
And going all the way back, what caused everything in the beginning had to have been itself uncaused. In other words, there had to have been a First, Uncaused Cause.
Think of it this way. If you see a row of dominoes, and they are falling over, you know that somewhere, somehow the first domino got pushed.
What about the universe? It’s going. Who, or what, pushed it?
For a long time, skeptics rejected the idea of cause and effect as an argument for God because they didn’t think the universe had a beginning. The idea was the universe was eternal in nature; it didn’t have a start date where, prior to that date, nothing existed.
That’s not what most scientists think anymore.
Most of us are familiar with the second law of thermodynamics, which says the universe is running out of usable energy. If it is running down, then it could not be eternal and must have at one time been given a start. If something is winding down, it must have sometime been wound up.
But what has really laid the eternal universe theory to rest is the idea of the Big Bang. The idea of the Big Bang was first put forward by Dr. Edwin Hubble, the one we named the Hubble Space Telescope after. His theory was that at one time all matter was packed into a dense mass at temperatures of many trillions of degrees. Then about 13.8 billion years ago, there was a huge explosion. And from that explosion, all of the matter that today forms our planets and stars was born. That explosion created the universe as we know it.
Hubble’s idea was later confirmed through what was then called the discovery of the century. On April 24, 1992, the Cosmic Background Explorer satellite, better known as COBE, gave stunning confirmation of the hot Big Bang creation event through its analysis of cosmic microwave background radiation.
Then, in 2014, a team of scientists working in Antarctica found what has been called the smoking gun of the universe’s expansion through the Big Bang. They discovered the gravitational waves that are the evidence of expansion.
If you don’t think this has sent shock waves through the world of cosmology, take a look at this.
Big Bang/Hubble video
So what does this mean?
Well, it means we have a creation event.
But do we have a God?
Science can’t answer that. That’s way above its pay grade. But it sure has led a lot of people to think that way. Here’s why.
If the universe could not have come into being by itself from nothing, because it is a scientific impossibility that absolute nothingness could produce anything—I mean, the original matter had to come from somewhere; and if the universe isn’t eternal—there really was a creation event through the Big Bang—then who made it bang? And where did the stuff that got banged come from?
You can’t not ask those questions! You can’t dismiss the idea of God in relation to the origin of the universe by saying it was the Big Bang. Because you can’t have a Big Bang without a Big Banger!
And as leading physicist Alan Guth at MIT has written, even if you could come up with a theory that would account for the creation of something from nothing through the laws of physics, you’d still have to account for the origin of the laws of physics! Where do they come from?
All of this makes the idea of a creation through a Creator not only compatible with science but almost demanded by it. So when you look back to what the Bible says in Genesis 1:1, that “in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth,” it adds up! One who was without beginning, one who stands outside our boundaries of space and time, created.
As the New Testament book of Romans adds:
What can be known about God is plain to them. . . . Ever since God created the world, his invisible qualities, both his eternal power and his divine nature, have been clearly seen; they are perceived in the things that God has made. (1:19–20 GNT)
II. Design and Order
So that’s one reason to believe in God.
Another reason has to do with design. The essence of this reason to believe is found in a very important question: How do you account for the intricate design of the universe?
This idea is an old one, which tells you of its power. It was first articulated by the Greek philosopher Plato but was popularized many years later by William Paley. The thinking is as follows:
I once heard it put this way: It’s one thing to see a logjam and wonder if there was a beaver behind it; it’s another to see the Hoover Dam and question whether there was intentionality and purpose behind its creation.
Or think of it this way. Imagine you came upon a space shuttle in the middle of the desert. You could reason that it came together by chance, that the metal was flung together by way of a chaotic sandstorm, that the instruments and panels and wings were brought together by a freak accident of nature. But it is highly unlikely that this would be your first thought. If you came upon a space shuttle in the desert, your initial thought would likely be that someone made it and landed it there.
There is staggering design and order to the universe, so staggering that it compels many people to consider a great Designer of the universe. Even the Bible suggests this as a reason for faith in God. Let me read an example from the Psalms:
The heavens are telling the glory of God; they are a marvelous display of his craftsmanship. Day and night they keep on telling about God. Without a sound or word, silent in the skies, their message reaches out to all the world. (19:1–4 TLB)
But this design is not just about the cosmos but also about the intricately ordered wonders of the human body, the most ordered mechanism on the planet.
Now, you might be thinking, “Hold on. Doesn’t that bring up evolution, and doesn’t that disprove God?”
No.
Where are you getting that?
If the theory of evolution were ever 100 percent proved, beyond any shadow of a doubt, it would be a huge reason to believe in God.
III. Evolution
Here’s why.
First, it’s absolutely true that the Bible tells us that God created human beings. Here’s what Genesis says:
So God created mankind in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them. . . . The LORD God formed a man from the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being. (1:27; 2:7)
So without a doubt, the Bible says that we were created by a Creator. That we were wonderfully and carefully designed. That the entire creative process was miraculously and supernaturally generated and guided by God.
But it doesn’t say how, except in a literary, poetic way—using phrases like “the dust of the earth” and “the breath of life.” Which doesn’t exactly sound like it was trying to be a biology text.
So we’re told that God did it but not how.
Evolution is one of the leading theories in science for the “how.” Which is fine. If God used evolution, so be it. That doesn’t mean there wasn’t an original Adam and Eve whom God breathed actual souls into at the end of the process to mark the beginning of the human race as we know it today. In fact, if you know much about evolution, if it’s true, it would take an outside force, an outside intelligence of some kind, to explain it.
The theory of evolution calls for leaps and mutations to overcome massive unexplained gaps that almost scream for an intelligent Designer guiding and helping the process.
Just think about the time issue. If the age of the earth is about 4.6 billion years—which is the current, best estimate of science—and we have evidence of abundant and complex life 3.5 billion years ago—which we do—then that means there was only about 170 million years for the earth to cool from its initial formation and for all of evolution to have taken place. Just 170 million years. And that simply isn’t enough time—by anyone’s calculations—for all of evolution to have taken place.
In fact, noted astronomer Sir Fred Hoyle has written that if you would compute the time required to get all two hundred thousand amino acids for one human cell to come together by chance, it would be about 293.5 times the estimated age of the earth. It would be like having the working dynamics of an iPod, iPhone, iPad, and smart watch all instantly created—by chance—through a single explosion in a computer warehouse. It’s almost crazy to think about.
So if evolution is true, there is the need for some kind of outside, guiding, enhancing force to speed it along in the time frame of the age of the earth.
But that’s not all.
Even if there was enough time, and even if you buy into all of these mutations and leaps filling all of the gaps—just like with the Big Bang—you need something, or Someone, to have gotten it started. At least, that’s what we’re finding through molecular biology.
Think about something like the human eye. According to evolutionary theory, it would have started with a simple, light-sensitive spot and then evolved to what we see with today. The problem is that when we finally got to the point where we were able to study life at the molecular level, we found it wasn’t simple. We found it was irreducibly complex. Which means something, or Someone, had to create those first complex systems, that first light-sensitive spot.
And if I just lost you, let’s see if this video will clear it up.
Irreducible Complexity/Michael Behe
So evolution doesn’t war against believing in God. In fact, believing in both is called believing in theistic evolution—meaning that God created and chose evolution as the means.
People who believe in God simply point to the idea that naturalistic evolution—meaning an evolutionary process not helped along by an outside and guiding force—is highly improbable.
The design of our bodies and the complex interrelationships that exist in our universe beg for a Designer. The alternative is to say that time plus chance in the context of chaos created a universe of incredible order and creatures of stunning design. That’s a hard sell.
In fact, it was precisely this line of reasoning that led Antony Flew, the Oxford philosophy professor who wrote the quintessential articles in favor of atheism for college philosophy textbooks the world over, to renounce his atheism. This is of personal interest to me because I studied at Oxford, and Antony Flew was just legendary.
And I don’t know if you remember this, but if you take your old college philosophy textbooks, when you go to the “God section,” they would have one writer giving you a reason to believe in God and then another article telling you why you shouldn’t believe in God. Almost always the article written about why you shouldn’t believe in God was written by Antony Flew from Oxford.
Well, he renounced his atheism because of what we just talked about. Here’s an interview where he talked about it.
Antony Flew Interview
Related to all this is something called the anthropic principle, from the Greek word anthropos, which means “man” or “human.”
Our world is uniquely suited to human beings and carbon-based life, the only form of life known to science. The argument is that as there are so many wonderful details that if changed even slightly would make it impossible for us to exist, then one is compelled to consider that somehow it was intentionally created for that very purpose.
Even Stephen Hawking, arguably the most brilliant physicist since Albert Einstein, wrote:
It would be very difficult to explain why the universe should have begun in just this way, except as the act of a God who intended to create beings like us.
Take a look at this video at how this plays out from a scientific perspective.
Anthropic Principle from “Case for a Creator”
begin at :53 into the clip
IV. The Humanness of Humans
So you have cause and effect, design and order. But there’s another reason to believe, and it’s what you know best: You.
Where does human personality come from? It’s difficult for many to believe that the human personality—the soul, if you will—evolved out of a pool of primordial slime. Legs and arms and lungs, maybe—but what is inside of us? That which makes you, you? Consciousness itself?
When the philosopher René Descartes attempted to boil down his one and only true starting point for reflection, he came up with his famed phrase cogito ergo sum. I think, therefore, I am.
But where does that “thinking” come from? How are we able to think, reflect, feel, and reason? There is a voice inside of my head, a personality, a living spirit that I know exists and that is tangible and real when I think to myself. What is that, and where did it come from?
And that includes our spirituality. Because we are, all of us, deeply spiritual beings. One of the most interesting manifestations throughout all civilizations is the deep spiritual hunger of men and women. Anthropologists have discovered that human beings are incurably spiritual and conscious of the idea of God.
This was described by Blaise Pascal, the great seventeenth-century philosopher and mathematician, as the “God-shaped vacuum” in every human being. If there isn’t a God, and we evolved naturalistically, that would not make sense.
In reflecting on this, C. S. Lewis noted that drives supposedly come about due to the realities of our world. For example, we have an appetite for food, and there is food to satisfy that need. The idea of naturalistic evolution is that our drives developed out of our bodies’ needs and from the realities of the world.
We have this drive to know God, an authentic spiritual hunger, but there is no God? That doesn’t make sense. If it were true, we shouldn’t have the drive. Why would creatures who evolved by chance as a result of naturalistic causes alone desire and hunger after a Creator God?
Some have suggested that the answer to this is not God at all but a so-called God gene that has been hardwired into our genetic constitutions. But why would a gene like that have ever evolved?
Some take another tack and say the reason we’re so spiritually hungry is simply our desire, our hope for a God. This was the belief of Sigmund Freud, the father of the psychoanalytic school of psychology.
The dilemma is that it doesn’t explain the universal desire for God throughout time and across civilization. At some point, particularly in our modern context, you would think that the wish, desire, or need for God would simply end. Yet it only grows. In fact, just this past week (you may have seen it) the results came out from a twelve-year Pew research study that was charting out the future of world religion from 2010 to 2050. The headline was that we’re going to be even more religious than ever. Religion is going to keep ascending. Which makes no evolutionary sense if there is no God.
But then there’s the Bible’s answer. We’re spiritual because we were made to be. We were created by God and for God. Or as the biblical writer of Ecclesiastes put it, God has “set eternity in the human heart” (3:11).
Conclusion
So now it’s your turn.
This was a lot to take in in a short amount of time, and we only just skimmed the surface.
Does the existence of God make more sense than the nonexistence of God?
You can say that the Big Bang banged itself.
You can say that the complexity and design of the universe, not to mention our bodies, came about through chance.
You can say our innate spirituality is just a fluke.
Or you can say, “Man, I’m having to work really hard to keep God out of this. Maybe it makes more sense to put him back into the equation. Because he seems to answer more questions than any other factor. Maybe all of this stuff thunders out the very reality of God.”
And if you were with us last week, not just any God but the God who came in the person of Jesus. A God who wants to be known.
Let’s stand for a closing prayer.
