8. Decisions
8
Decisions
Life is short, and Art long; the crisis fleeting; experience perilous, and decision difficult.
Hippocrates
A characterless man never reaches a decision.
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel
As we come to the end of our journey, it is a time for decisions. At Mecklenburg Community Church, we’ve made eight strategic decisions in light of everything you’ve read that we are convinced have enabled us to be effective at reaching not only the unchurched but also the unchurched nones and, even at this early stage, Generation Z. Two have already been detailed: we have made the decisions to rethink evangelism and to do so in light of an Acts 17 model, in essence, chapters 4 through 7. Following are six others we consider just as decisive.
We have become cultural missionaries and act according to that identity. I think we all know what a good missionary would do if dropped into the darkest recesses of the Amazon basin to reach an unreached people group. They would learn the language, try to understand the customs and rituals, and work to translate the Scriptures, particularly the message of the gospel, into the indigenous language. When it comes to worship, they would incorporate the musical styles and instruments of the people. They might even attempt to dress more like them. In short, they would try to build every cultural bridge they could into the world of that unreached people group in order to bring Christ to bear.
Why is it that what would be so natural, so obvious, so clear to do in that missiological setting is so resisted in the West?
In being cultural missionaries, we have also decided to be laser sharp in our focus. Much has been written, for example, about disaffected Christian Millennials who are leaving the church. In fact, there seemed to be a season when the evangelical publishing world was fixated on why Christian Millennials were leaving the church. So the evangelical subculture got them to write blogs, articles, and books about their disaffection and from this extrapolated what the church has to do and where it has to change in order to reach that generation for Christ.
Frankly, we’re not that interested. Our mission is not the already convinced. Why focus on Christian Millennials who leave the church in order to learn how to reach non-Christian Millennials who are not in the church? That’s misplaced missional energy. Disaffected Christian Millennials are not abandoning Christ, just the church. Okay, so did their parents. And their parents before them. They either came back to the church or reinvented it stylistically.
Not exactly news.
What is news is the rise of the nones, those Millennials (and every other generation) who are abandoning religion altogether. Not to mention the coming juggernaut of Generation Z and their post-Christian minds. So the real story you need to get as a leader isn’t about Christians wanting more of a narrative, wishing their pastor was more like Donald Miller, hating the big-stage production of the eighties megachurch, or anything else of that nature. That’s an evangelical subculture thing. The real issue is much larger. So if we are going to talk to someone and listen to someone and learn from someone, let’s talk, listen, and learn from those who have not been Christians, much less churched. After all, they are the true mission field.
Skew Young
One of the natural flows of the church, which I first wrote about in my book What They Didn’t Teach You in Seminary, is that left to itself the church will grow old. It will age. First you’ll lose the twentysomethings, then the thirtysomethings, and on the creep will go. And that means, by default, you will not reach the coming generations. While the goal is not to simply be a church for young people (I’ve often blogged about the importance of having older members willing to invest in leadership, in service, and in mentoring the next generation), neither is the goal to be a church for old people—a church that will have one generational cycle before closing its doors.
If the natural flow of the church is to skew older, the leadership of the church must invest a disproportionate amount of energy and intentionality in order to maintain a vibrant population of young adults. At Meck we have used three simple strategies not only to maintain influence on the culture of our day but also to impact the next generation.
First, to attract young people, you have to hire young people. I know that for many people in senior leadership, the thought of having a staff filled with twentysomethings can be intimidating. At Meck, nearly half of our staff are in their twenties and we love it—the young and the old. The younger staff bring fresh insight and perspective on reaching and connecting with the younger generations. When asking one staff member what they valued about working at Meck, this was their response: “For me, working here is fun because it’s challenging. . . . We’re constantly challenged to move to the next level, the next step, the next vision. . . . All the while we are asked to keep in mind that we’re not chasing the next fad but rather the next God-ordained project to get more unchurched people in our doors.”
Second, who you platform is who you attract. From the people on stage in the band to the greeters standing at the doors, it is important to platform those who are young because people are drawn to others who are like them.
Third, to attract young people, you have to acknowledge young people. While every aspect of the service does not need to be designed just for them, and the church cannot “cater” specifically to young people, those who are younger do need to be acknowledged. What does this mean? It means that you take into account their world and all that includes: tastes, priorities, questions, vocabulary, sensibilities, and most definitely their technology. The church needs to learn to embrace the technology of the next generation, as it will fast become the technology for us all. Bottom line? Sometimes bridging a cultural divide is as simple as who you hire, who you put on stage, and who you acknowledge.
Target Men
Another strategic decision we have made is to unashamedly target men in our outreach, in our messages, in our . . . well, almost everything. We have become convinced through years of experience that if you get the man, you get everyone else within his orbit—specifically, his wife and his children. We have not found the same to be true by targeting women. In fact, churches filled with Christian “widows” (women in attendance while their husbands stay home) is almost proverbial. Truth be told, most churches are oriented toward women. The messages, ministries, outreach, décor, music, videos—they’re all designed for women.
What does it mean to target men? It means you think about male sensibilities in terms of music and message, vocabulary and style. For example, have you noticed how much contemporary worship feels like it’s saying, “Jesus is my boyfriend” when you listen to the lyrics? What guy wants to sing that? No guy I know. So we don’t sing those songs. When I give a message, I talk like a man talks, specifically, the way a man talks with other men. Direct and maybe a little rough around the edges. But men talk football, not fashion. So I cater to a man’s humor, his interests, his world, his way of thinking, his questions. And I deliver those talks the way I would talk to a guy. When it comes to crafting an invitational outreach tool—such as a gift to be given out to invite someone to a Christmas Eve service—we don’t fill it with recipes but with a hefty mug.
One of the most frequent things we hear from women is, “My husband loves this church. I could never get him to church before. But now he comes here even when I don’t!” And she will go where he wants to go. Get him, you get her. Get him and her, you get the family.
It’s as simple as that.
Prioritize Children’s Ministry
Quick—what is the most important outreach ministry in the life of your church? If you hesitated for even one second before answering “children’s ministry,” then you need to read everything I am going to say next with the greatest of attention.
At Meck, we prioritize children’s ministry above every other ministry. Why? Because it is the most important ministry for the mission of the church. Let me tell you a story that may help answer why.
When our kids were young, my family and I went to a church while on our summer study break. It was a new church, very small, that was meeting in a movie theater. How can I say this? . . . It was one of the most programming-challenged services I’ve ever attended. It was so bad that we were looking at our watches five minutes after the service started. When the service mercifully ended, we wanted to get out of there and never return. I know, that isn’t very gracious, and I should have been more focused on worshiping Jesus, but you would have wanted to leave too.
But when we went to pick up our kids, they were having an absolute blast. They didn’t want to leave! A couple had poured themselves into that ministry and made it really, really good. I still recall how they had transformed a meager space into a time machine with special-effects music that took the kids “back” into Bible times. New kids, such as ours, were treated extraspecial and taken to a treasure chest full of small toys from which they could choose, just for coming the first time. The amount of money this took? Next to nothing. The money spent on state-of-the-art facilities? It was a theater rented by a church plant. The time and intentionality? Now that was priceless.
We went to some of the “best” churches in the area that summer, but our kids pleaded with us to take them back to the one we could barely stand. Now, if I lived there and felt compelled to find a church home as a father of four, do you think I would have at least given that church another try? You can count on it. Most parents would. Here’s the lesson: you can drop the ball in the service but ace it with the kids and still have a chance that a family will return. But no matter how good the service is, if the children’s ministry is bad, the family won’t come back.
Too many people treat children’s ministry as a necessary evil. It’s often severely underfunded, understaffed, and underappreciated. Wake up. Children are the heart of your growth engine. If a none ever were to come to your church uninvited, it would probably be for the sake of their kids. If a none comes because they were invited, what you do with their children will be a deal breaker. And if you want to reach Generation Z? Many of them are in your children’s ministry right now or will be reached only if they choose to enter it. Make sure that when they do, it is an experience that will have them begging to come back.
Cultivate a Culture of Invitation
As mentioned earlier, in Michael Green’s seminal work on the staggering growth of the early church, he had one huge conclusion: they shared the good news of Jesus like gossip over the backyard fence. In other words, a culture of invitation was both cultivated and celebrated. At Meck, that’s what we do and what we’re after.
It’s not difficult.
We talk about inviting our friends and family all the time.
We create tools to put in the hands of people to use to invite their friends all the time.
We celebrate and honor people who invite people all the time.
Such tools can be something as simple as pens with the name of our church and our website on them that people can give to someone, whether a friend they run into in the grocery store or a waiter at a restaurant. During the summer, we might hand out empty pizza boxes with a card inside inviting them to Meck and a voucher for a free pizza—no strings attached. For special times in the life of the church, like Easter and Christmas, we design tools to be fun—fun to give and fun to receive. People use these tools all the time to reach out to their unchurched family, friends, neighbors, and anyone else they interact with in their orbit.
For all of you wondering about discipleship, here’s your moment. We take discipleship as seriously as anyone—maybe more. We’ve simply determined that there is a need for a third leg on the stool.
Let me explain.
Most churches have two legs on their stool. One is the weekend with all of its services and events, and the other is small groups. There’s a third, strategic leg that is entirely missing. We feel there needs to be a third leg that is completely devoted to discipleship. Yes, I know, many churches feel that both weekend services and small groups should be discipleship oriented. We disagree. The weekend service should be, at least for now, the front door of the church for outreach. As a result, it should be crafted optimally for that outreach. That often means it is not crafted optimally for discipleship.
Every church must also decide if small groups are for outreach, discipleship, or care and assimilation. We have never felt they are best for outreach or ideal for discipleship. We chose to have our small groups for care and assimilation. And the entry points for our small groups are designed for people who have never thought of them, much less been in one before. So we gather groups of 150 to 200 for a meal, organize them into small groups (based on life stage, where they live, etc), and invite them to continue gathering together once a week for six weeks. After that time, they have the option to continue meeting together as a small group.
So where does discipleship find its home?
The third leg.
We created the Meck Institute, a community-college approach to discipleship that offers classes, seminars, experiences, and events designed wholly for spiritual growth and formation. Like classes at a community college, new classes and experiences launch each season: spring, summer, fall, and winter. They are offered on all days of the week at a variety of times, and we also have online classes. Offerings include the most foundational of all classes—titled “Foundations,” I might add, addressing how to be sure you are a Christian, how to pray, how to read the Bible, and how to have a quiet time—all the way to seminary-level courses on systematic theology.
I cannot begin to express how important it is to “disciple your mission.” I’ve never heard that phrase, so let me coin it. To “disciple your mission” means that you develop your discipleship, first and foremost, around who it is you are trying to reach. We are trying to reach the unchurched and, even more than that, the nones, in view of the pressing challenge of the rise of Generation Z. So our discipleship is going to be twofold: serve the needs of our existing believers for missional engagement and disciple the newly converted on the most foundational aspects of Christian life and thought.
What, you might ask, of the needs of existing believers who want to be fed? If you mean titillated by the latest biblical insights slathered on an already calorie-rich meal they have been feasting on for the last several years, we honestly don’t care.
The Secret Sauce
But here’s the secret sauce, the ingredient behind all of those decisions.
We really are on a mission. We really are turned outward. We really are after the unchurched. Really.
As I wrote about in The Rise of the Nones, our mission is one of the most important values that we hold as a church and one that shapes everything we do. This means that we go to war against the tendency of some churches to pull back and separate themselves into some kind of Christian clique. We never view those outside of the church as the enemy, with an “us versus them” mentality, because that is the exact opposite of the life that Jesus lived. Jesus spent his time with those far from God; he built relationships with them, dined with them in their homes, and went to their parties. This was clearly a life value for him, so it must be what drives the church.
What is killing the church today is having the mission focused on keeping Christians within the church happy, well fed, and growing. Discipleship is continually pitted against evangelism and championed as the endgame for the church. The mission cannot be about us—it must be about those who have not crossed the line of faith.
The problem is, we like the mission to be about us. And this has caused a spiritual narcissism to invade the church. You hear it in the words people utter when they walk out of a service and say, “I didn’t get anything out of that today.” You hear it from the church hoppers, bouncing from one church to the next, when they say, “I really need to go where I’m fed.” Please tell me where in the Scriptures you find any talk about that being the mission of the church. Certainly not from the mouth of Jesus, who said:
The Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many. (Matt. 20:28)
Anyone who wants to be first must be the very last. (Mark 9:35)
Whoever wants to be first must be slave of all. (Mark 10:44)
Not my will, but yours be done. (Luke 22:42)
The individual needs and desires of the believer have become the center of attention, which is why most churches have as their primary focus reaching and then serving the already convinced. So the mission isn’t making disciples but caring for them. This is an uncomfortable truth. Because almost everybody who follows Christ and almost every gathering of those Christ followers constituting a church say the same thing: “We want to reach the world for Christ.”
Where’s the breakdown?
Jesus knew.
When questioned about his own missional emphasis to those on the outside of faith, he said:
Who needs a doctor: the healthy or the sick? Go figure out what this Scripture means: “I’m after mercy, not religion.” I’m here to invite outsiders, not coddle insiders. (Matt. 9:12–13 Message)
The problem, according to Jesus, are the insiders: Christ followers who have given themselves over to spiritual narcissism and champion that above those who are lost. How does Meck guard against this attitude creeping in? Our secret sauce is simple. It’s in a four-word mantra we say to each other all the time around here: “It’s not about you.” It’s about the person who isn’t even here yet.
Don’t like the new music?
It’s not about you.
Don’t like the new style of worship?
It’s not about you.
Don’t like the new dress code?
It’s not about you.
Don’t like what we’re doing with video?
It’s not about you.
Don’t like the new website?
It’s not about you.
It’s about them.
Discussion Questions
