Chapter 10 of 19

5. Finding Our Voice

5. Finding Our Voice

5

Finding Our Voice

For the word of God is alive and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart.

Hebrews 4:12

The pastor of a large and influential church was recently asked about his stance on gay marriage. He gave what I thought was a very astute response. He said that in regard to such matters, there are three things that must be considered: “There’s the world we live in, there’s the weight we live with, and there’s the Word we live by.”

That’s actually quite right.

Consider the world we live in. Its position on gay marriage has changed seismically over the last few years. Churches have never failed to have the moral high ground on this matter . . . until now. Our voice, as Christians, is clearly a minority report in the modern world.

Consider the weight we live with. Who isn’t heartbroken that people of any orientation or lifestyle, color or creed are bullied, discriminated against, hated, or terrorized? Speaking to the issue of gay marriage in a manner that would consciously add in any way to such repugnant behavior would be unconscionable.

But then we must consider the Word we live by. By this he meant, “What the Bible says.” Where the Bible stands, we must stand.

Then came the awkward moment. The pastor continued, saying, “It would be much easier if you could feel like all of those three just easily lined up. But they don’t necessarily. . . . The real issues in people’s lives are too important for us to just reduce it down to a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer in a media outlet.”

Now before you rush to a cry of “Compromise!” he’s once again actually right. First, they don’t line up. At all. Second, anyone who works with people—I mean, really works with people—knows that there is a serious pastoral side to such issues. Making simple declarations of your stance at conferences filled with the already convinced does not represent the real world. Nor are these declarations particularly helpful to those we are trying to reach. To give an answer that truly serves the historic Christian position on such an issue takes more than a tweet. Further, when we are being asked such a question in a secular context, we must be even more careful with our answer.

Why? Because there is a thin line between maintaining an earned voice through which to speak to culture and compromising the very message we long to share. There are certain things we know we can say that will shut the other side down. And we don’t want to shut the other side down. But we don’t want to compromise either. So when dealing with the secular world, we pick our way through such conundrums with care. Never lying, never compromising, but picking our battles—answering in ways that let us maintain a voice so that we can continue to have listening ears when it’s time to express the voice of challenge.

I’ll give you a somewhat less controversial example. If you were to ask me, point blank, if I had a denominational heritage, I would answer “Baptist.” But I don’t lead with “Baptist.” I lead with “Christ follower.” And when asked about the church I pastor, Mecklenburg Community Church, I lead with “interdenominational” and stress that we have people from all backgrounds, including no church background at all. While I hold to such classic theological tenets as congregational participation, believer’s baptism by immersion, and biblical inerrancy, the tag “Baptist” is one of the more pejorative, jarring, discomfiting labels around. For reasons, I might add, that have more to do with social and cultural missteps by various leaders than its actual theological and ecclesiastical sinew. Yet there is little doubt that our theology is clearly baptistic.

Choosing his battles wisely is something Jesus did masterfully. He refused to get pulled into Roman politics, even when baited. He didn’t rise to many of the theological squabbles among the Jews. But when he did, it was always for something significant. Like the debate between the Pharisees and the Sadducees concerning the resurrection; to Jesus, that one mattered.

So returning to our pastor, should his be the model response to a question on gay marriage? With respect, no—because the nature of marriage and family lies at the heart of the created order, and the nature of sexual expression lies at the heart of physical morality. The third leg of the cultural conundrum, following the world we live in and the weight we live with, is the Word we live by. And when we consider the Word, we find that it does offer a concrete position. Its response to whether gay marriage is acceptable, no matter how much we might need to explain such a response, is a simple no. And to his credit, the pastor in question later added a clarifying word: “My personal view on the subject of homosexuality would line up with most traditionally held Christian views. I believe the writings of Paul are clear on this subject.” But as Jonathan Merritt rightly pointed out in covering the matter, “In a moment when so much is at stake a non-statement statement is, well, quite a statement.”

Yes, it is.

And that is the challenge we all face in finding our voice culturally, specifically in speaking to Generation Z. As detailed earlier, members of Generation Z hold few things dearer than acceptance and inclusivity. They view many moral stances, such as opposing gay marriage, as social stances in line with racism. To them, acceptance means affirmation. If you don’t affirm, you don’t accept. This unfortunately permeates all of culture, not just Generation Z, where to be considered welcoming to, say, the LGBT community, is code for condoning their lifestyle.

So what kind of “voice” should we use?

Three Voices

Biblically, there are three primary voices speaking into culture: the prophetic, the evangelistic, and the heretical. The prophetic voice, such as Jeremiah’s, is clear in its denunciations and warnings. The prophetic voice is an admonishing one, a “thou shalt not,” a clarion call to turn to God and get right with God. It is not a popular voice for culture to hear. That is why it is not a popular voice for Christians to use. Quick, name a popular prophet. See? As an old seminary professor of mine once quipped, “Assume a prophet’s voice, expect a prophet’s reward.”

The second voice is the evangelistic voice. This is the apostle Paul standing on Mars Hill (Acts 17). It is the voice attempting to build bridges across cultural divides, to explain things, to make apologetic cases. The evangelistic voice is focused on calling people to a relationship with Christ as Forgiver and Leader.

The final voice is the heretical voice. To be sure, heretical voices in the Bible are never celebrated, but they are noted. The false prophets of the Old Testament and the false teachers of the New Testament are frequently detailed. As the apostle Peter declared, “There will be false teachers among you. They will secretly introduce destructive heresies” (2 Pet. 2:1). This is the voice that not only speaks against the gospel but also, more specifically, attempts to distort the gospel’s presentation to culture itself.

The heretical voice is most at play and seems to be the most seductive for Christian leaders when attempting to engage culture. Nearly forty years ago, writing about the challenges of communicating the message of Christ in the twentieth century, John R. W. Stott wrote of the three chief obstacles facing preaching: “the anti-authority mood makes people unwilling to listen, addiction of television makes them unable to do so, and the contemporary atmosphere of doubt makes many preachers both unwilling and unable to speak. Thus there is a paralysis at both ends, in the speaking and in the hearing.” It is precisely in the “speaking” end of things that we must not lose focus.

It is tempting to try to connect with a post-Christian culture by mirroring its post-Christian values and sentiments. For example, Rob Bell, former pastor and frequent guest on Oprah Winfrey’s said television network, maintains that a church that doesn’t support same-sex marriage is irrelevant. Bell earlier questioned the existence of hell in his 2011 book Love Wins. Bell made the comments about gay marriage on an episode of Winfrey’s Super Soul Sunday, where he appeared with his wife to talk about religion and spirituality. He called the church’s acceptance of gay marriage “inevitable” and the reason that it should be accepted is because loneliness “is not good for the world.”

“I think culture is already there,” Bell continued, “and the church will continue to be even more irrelevant when it quotes letters from 2,000 years ago as their best defense.” His thinking is that for the church to be relevant, it must not only embrace homoerotic behavior but also jettison Scripture as any kind of authoritative guide in regard to this or (seemingly) any other cultural issue in which public opinion goes against Scripture. The new source of revelation is personal fulfillment. In this case, no one should be lonely, so whatever fills the loneliness gap should be affirmed.

We must understand the danger of such an approach. Yes, it landed Bell on television. Yes, it was and is a popular stance culturally. But if the Bible is to be cavalierly abandoned as mere “letters from 2,000 years ago,” then historic orthodoxy has truly been abandoned. Christians embrace the Old Testament as inspired by God because Jesus did, and the New Testament as equally sacred because it is based on the teaching of Jesus and his apostles. If we relegate the Bible to less than the revelation of God, then we are relegating Jesus to less than the Son of God. As Christians, we can have robust discussions on the nature of inspiration, and certainly on the dynamics of interpretation, but not on the authority of the Bible itself. That was established by Jesus.

Further, to adopt self-fulfillment and self-satisfaction as the ultimate apologetic is to make the self central to all things. This was, of course, the great temptation put before Adam and Eve in the garden that led to the fall of humanity. Pursuing whatever we desire is not what is best for the world. What is best for the world is when we submit our desires to what is best for the world. And that is determined by God.

Finally, the “relevance” of the church is not found in its capitulation to culture but in its transformation of culture. Any student of ecclesiastical history knows that whenever orthodoxy was abandoned in order for the church to mirror culture, it led to the church’s great demise. We do not gain the world’s attention through a compromised voice but through a prophetic one. No one would argue the need for a winsome and compelling voice for Christ in our culture more than I; no one would argue the need for contrition for a lack of love toward those with a same-sex orientation more than I; no one would argue the need for the church’s relevance more than I. But if we follow Bell’s strategy, the church really will continue to be even more irrelevant than it already is.

Why?

Because it will cease to be the church.

The key in attempting to speak into culture with relevance, but not compromise, is found in the dynamic between translation and transformation. Theologian Millard Erickson, building on the insights of William E. Hordern, notes that every generation must translate the gospel into its unique cultural context. But this is very different from transforming the message of the gospel into something that was never intended by the biblical witness. Transformation of the message must be avoided at all costs. Translation, however, is essential for a winsome and compelling presentation of the gospel of Christ. It is precisely this interplay between translation and transformation that must be navigated by every leader in regard to culture. If transformation takes place, then we have simply abandoned orthodoxy for the hopeful sake of warm bodies, and the tickling of ears does not exactly have a welcome spot in the biblical materials. If translation takes place, we intentionally build bridges of cultural understanding but retain our prophetic voice in the marketplace of ideas.

Transformation is heresy.

Translation is the heart of our mission.

Knowing the difference is the crucible of leadership and the difference between being in the world and being of the world.

I’ve always found pastors and church leaders visiting Mecklenburg for the first time interesting, particularly in what they say about the message. The most common refrain is, “You talk about heaven and hell, sin and the cross more than we do!” Perhaps we do. But that’s the point. When discussing the truths of Scripture, it’s not about what we say but how we say it. It’s not about watering anything down but communicating it in a way that is winsome and compelling, relatable and identifiable. My goal is to take the language of culture and use it to convey the gospel of Christ—not in a way that changes the gospel but in a way that communicates it.

Learning the Prophetic Voice

History teaches that significant cultural change has always been born on the wings of oratory, whether the simple words offered in the “Gettysburg Address” on the field of battle in Pennsylvania or the soaring rhetoric of the “I Have a Dream” speech delivered on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial. This has certainly been the case for all great movements of the Holy Spirit that have impacted society, for preaching has always been in the vanguard of Christianity’s engagement with contemporary culture. As John R. W. Stott has suggested, the art of preaching truly stands “between two worlds”: the world of the biblical text and the modern world to which we bring those words to bear.

The distinctive form of address espoused by the prophets was “thus says the Lord.” Christopher J. H. Wright suggests that there were four principal prohibitions God expressed to Israel that were cultural in nature: idolatry, perversion, that which was destructive of persons, and callousness to the poor. For example, digging deeper into one of these—perversion—we find that immorality was consistently condemned by the prophetic voice of the Old Testament. Such practices as prostitution, homosexuality, bestiality, and incest were denounced. God gave clear directions to Moses for the Israelites that they should “not do as they do in Egypt, where you used to live, and you must not do as they do in the land of Canaan, where I am bringing you” (Lev. 18:3). For example, God directed the Israelites, “Do not have sexual relations with an animal and defile yourself with it. . . . That is a perversion” (Lev. 18:23). Then God added, “Do not defile yourselves in any of these ways, because that is how the nations that I am going to drive out before you became defiled” (Lev. 18:24).

Today few want to use the prophetic voice. In fact, it is often seen as undermining the evangelistic voice. Many believe that the popularity and success of Billy Graham were due, in large part, to the fact that he kept his evangelistic voice and did not fall into a prophetic voice. In like manner, I’ve often heard pastors, particularly of large churches, say they do not want to speak out on the issues of the day for the sake of keeping their focus on the gospel and not alienating people on the front end. But this is a gross misunderstanding of not only Graham but also evangelism itself. Graham took stands against racism and many other social ills of his day, often at great personal cost. He was an evangelist, to be sure, but the lesson he learned was not to avoid social issues but to avoid politics. In fact, his involvement in politics early on in his ministry, particularly with Richard Nixon, proved to be one of his greatest regrets.

Yet the temptation to mute the prophetic voice is strong. As noted, some are tempted to believe that speaking out against a homoerotic lifestyle is counterproductive to gaining the listening ear of a culture that has embraced that very lifestyle. So, the thinking goes, let’s drop the prophetic voice because of its cultural disdain in order to maximize the evangelistic voice for the sake of the gospel. And, as also noted, some would even take up the heretical voice and offer support to the homosexual lifestyle.

The dilemma is that without the prophetic voice, there is no gospel. Without a sense of the true nature of our sin condition, which demands an understanding of sin itself, there is no good news. Without the prophetic voice, the evangelistic voice is mere sentimentality. Or worse, just cheap grace. Grace is only amazing when we realize how much we are in need of it. To be sure, the prophetic voice without the winsome and compelling heart of evangelism is just strident condemnation. We need both voices. But in our day, it is not the loss of the evangelistic voice I fear but the prophetic one. And even more dire is the increasing use of the heretical voice in the name of amplifying the evangelistic one.

What we need is the most powerful voice of all, which is, of course, the Bible’s. If we teach the Bible as the very Word of God, then we have unleashed revelation itself. God has broken out into the world in blinding flashes of lightning, and the Bible records the thunder. As a result, we can only bow our heads and open our hearts, minds, and hands. Revelation is different from something merely good or helpful; it is the voice of God echoing down from heaven. It demands that we become like clay—malleable and shaped. If we harden ourselves against revelation’s voice, then again, like clay, we can only crumble in response to its touch.

Not simply in practice but in thought.

As Mark Galli wrote in an editorial in Christianity Today:

The Bible is the Word of God primarily because it reveals the nature of God—who God is and what he has done for us. And that in turn shows us what it means to be those created in his image. Yes, it includes practical teaching for daily living. But most . . . pastors, teachers, and small-group leaders would be wise to spend more energy showing how the Bible is the source of the great church doctrines—which are so often about God and his saving work. It’s time for our main pedagogical question to be not, “What difference does this make?” but “What does this tell us about our good God?”

Sadly, most teach the Bible as a good book or a self-help manual. They fear tapping into its deepest voice, and deepest waters, for fear of turning people away. Yet it’s only the Bible’s true voice that will offer the world what it doesn’t already have.

And most desperately needs.

Ready for an irony?

I find that most people, particularly men, want to be challenged in regard to their deepest held views and convictions. They want to grapple with their opinions and thoughts, perspectives and ideologies. They like to wrestle with another mind, another view, another perspective—if, however, it’s done in a way that makes it a fair match. The prophetic voice is declarative, to be sure, but it is also inviting. It invites people to engage their somewhat settled views with a variant viewpoint.

But first we have to get past the initial response.

A Culture of Offense

Make no mistake: using the prophetic voice will cause offense, particularly in what is increasingly an “offense” culture. In a cover article for the Atlantic titled “The Coddling of the American Mind,” authors Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt explore how in the name of “emotional well-being” college students are increasingly demanding protection from words and ideas they don’t like and seeking punishment of those who give even accidental offense. “A movement is arising . . . to scrub campuses clean of words, ideas, and subjects that might cause discomfort or give offense.”

Two terms loom large on today’s campuses. First is microaggressions. These are small actions or word choices that “seem on their face to have no malicious intent but that are thought of as a kind of violence nonetheless.” The second term is trigger warnings. This is what a professor is expected to issue “if something in a course might cause a strong emotional response.”

During the 2014–15 school year, the deans and department chairs at the ten University of California system schools were presented by administrators at faculty leader-training sessions with examples of microaggressions. The list of offensive statements included “America is the land of opportunity” and “I believe the most qualified person should get the job.” As Lukianoff and Haidt note, this is beyond political correctness. The ultimate aim, it seems, is to turn campuses into “safe spaces” where “young adults are shielded from words and ideas that make some uncomfortable . . . [and] this movement seeks to punish anyone who interferes with that aim.”

Ready for another term? Try vindictive protectiveness.

In essence, in the name of emotional well-being, students can eliminate anything they do not want to think about, read about, or be challenged about. And penalize those who would expose them to it.

How?

In the name of “offense.”

“Emotional reasoning dominates many campus debates and discussions,” write Lukianoff and Haidt. “A claim that someone’s words are ‘offensive’ is not just an expression of one’s own subjective feeling of offendedness. It is, rather, a public charge that the speaker has done something objectively wrong.” For example, a student at Indiana University–Purdue read a book titled Notre Dame vs. the Klan, a book that honored student opposition to the Ku Klux Klan when students marched on Notre Dame in 1924. The cover of the book featured a picture of a Klan rally. Despite the book’s actual content, the student was found guilty of racial harassment by the university’s Affirmative Action Office.

Or consider “Hump Day” at the University of St. Thomas in Minnesota. Inspired by Wednesday being known as hump day in the workweek, students were going to be allowed to see and pet a camel. But a group of students created a Facebook group protesting the event for animal cruelty, for being a waste of money, and for being insensitive to people from the Middle East (despite the event being devoid of any reference to Middle Eastern peoples). The event was canceled because the “program [was] dividing people and would make for an uncomfortable and possible unsafe environment.” All to say, the “thin argument ‘I’m offended’ becomes an unbeatable trump card.” This is breeding a generation to “focus on small or accidental slights” and, even more, to then “relabel the people who have made such remarks as aggressors.”

Imagine if the offense was not “micro” but “macro,” as the Bible’s most penetrating statements most certainly are. Which means that if we use the prophetic voice, we will have enemies. A lot of enemies. This isn’t a popular idea. Many Christians seem more intent on fitting into culture, or at least getting its affirmation, than opposing it. And the entire idea of being an enemy, or having one, seems out of sync with the Christ life.

But it isn’t.

Jesus made it very clear that he did not come to bring peace but a sword (and rumor has it his own life did not end in a crowning but in a crucifying). The apostle Paul talked about open spiritual warfare in his letter to the Ephesians. The Bible speaks plainly about the “god” of this fallen world, and it is Satan himself.

So why is there such a great temptation for Christians today to opt for a popular stance instead of a prophetic one? For many, there is a bitter taste in their mouths from the caustic and abrasive era of the Moral Majority and the Religious Right, so much so that they have overcompensated by not wanting to be seen as condemning anything. For others, it is spiritual insecurity. Somehow they are not “legitimate” until they are embraced by MTV or fawned over by Slate. It is as if our model is Bono—be a cultural rock star while espousing a nonoffensive Christian faith. Not to denigrate Bono, whose faith is sincere and who has worked tirelessly for AIDS orphans around the world, but the better model would be Bonhoeffer, someone who clearly saw the lines of good and evil and worked tirelessly to overthrow evil (in his case, Hitler and the Third Reich). Rather than gaining popularity, Dietrich Bonhoeffer experienced execution at a concentration camp.

Suffice it to say, we are behind enemy lines. When behind enemy lines, there are enemies. The goal is not to be enemy-free, as if Christianity at its purest is so winsome and compelling that no one who “gets it” will ever reject it. No, the gospel is scandalous and offensive. Many will openly reject it, not to mention its moral mandates. We are not to embody culture but the Christian counterculture. The kingdom of God we advance is not the kingdom currently in place.

The problem isn’t having enemies. It’s having the right ones and for the right reasons. Don’t have enemies because you are intentionally offensive in spirit and interrelational dynamics. Don’t have enemies because you are caustic and abrasive. Don’t have enemies because you are unfeeling and unloving.

But . . .

Do have enemies because you stand for truth. Do have enemies because you will not waver in the face of majority opinion when it crashes against biblical authority. Do have enemies because you will not personally compromise your convictions.

After all, Jesus did.

Would Martin Luther King Jr. Be Heard Today?

Journalist Sharon Shahid once openly wondered whether Martin Luther King Jr.’s famed essay “Letter from Birmingham Jail” “would have made such a lasting impression or had as powerful an impact if today’s instant communication devices existed, and if someone smuggled a BlackBerry or a mobile phone into his cell. What would have happened if he texted the famous letter or used Twitter—in 140 characters or fewer?”

“Instead of a legacy,” she suggests, “he most likely would have started a conversation.”

And that’s all.

“King’s voice—so poignant and crystal-clear in print—simply would lose its resonance in cyber ink. . . . A tweet would have faded into ether minutes after it was released, drowned out by a thousand other disparate musings.” But that is the least of the challenges King’s words would face from our current context.

Why?

His was a prophet’s voice based on a thoroughgoing Christian worldview.

And today there are few such prophets.

Consider the term itself, worldview, from the German Weltanschauung (literally, “world perception”), which suggests more than a set of ideas by which we judge other ideas. It is, as Gene Edward Veith has written, “a way to engage constructively the whole range of human expression from a Christian perspective.” Or as Jonathan Edwards, arguably the greatest intellect America has ever produced, once contended, the basic goal of any intellect is to work toward “the consistency and agreement of our ideas with the ideas of God.”

Now consider the worldview questions posed by Charles Colson and Nancy Pearcey based on creation, the fall, and redemption: Where did we come from and who are we? What has gone wrong with the world? What can we do to fix it? How now shall we live? Reflect on the response to the first and most foundational of these questions—Where did we come from? There are a limited number of answers at our disposal: we came about by chance (the naturalist contention); we don’t really exist (the Hindu response); or, we were spoken into existence by God. If one makes the even more obscure suggestion that we were seeded here by another race of beings from another planet, as suggested by Cambridge physicist Stephen Hawking, one would then have to account for their existence.

So, for the Christian, the answer to “Where did we come from and who are we?” gives a foundation for thinking that no other answer gives. Because we were created, there is value in each person. There is meaning and purpose to every life. There is Someone above and outside our existence who stands over it as authority. Because of this answer, Martin Luther King Jr. could write the immortal words found in his jailhouse correspondence:

There are two types of law: just and unjust. . . . A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. . . . Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust. All segregation statutes are unjust because segregation distorts the soul and damages the personality.

King’s argument was based on the worth of a human being bestowed by God regardless of what other humans might have to say; King laid claim to a law above man’s law. No other worldview would have given King the basis for such a claim.

And from such a worldview, the world was changed.

But would such a worldview get a hearing today?

Only if it, too, was rooted in a prophetic voice.

Discussion Questions

  • When dealing with the secular world, it is wisest to approach sensitive topics with care. Never lying, never compromising, but picking our battles. The goal is to answer in ways that allow us to continue earning a voice in people’s lives that will one day result in the opportunity for direct challenge to their worldview, but only when the time is right. Does that approach align with yours? If not, how do the two differ?
  • Generation Z views moral stances, such as opposing gay marriage, as social stances on par with racism. Does that shock you? Do you know how to approach such topics in light of their views?
  • Honestly evaluate your ministry. Are you treating the Bible as the Word of God, with all that entails, or are you treating it as something different from or less than that?
  • The relevance of the church is not found in its capitulation to culture but in its transformation of culture. Does that convict you in any way? If so, what about your church should change?
  • Every generation must translate the gospel into its unique setting without transforming the message itself. If an average none from Generation Z were to sit in your service this Sunday, would the experience make any sense to them? If not, how can you work to translate elements of the service so that the service connects with them without compromising the truth it contains?
  • Which voice, the prophetic, the evangelistic, or the heretical, is most prominent in your church? Assuming it’s not the heretical, what can you do to introduce elements of the missing voice while maintaining a strong call to God’s revealed truth?
  • When you think about your life, are you interested in being accepted and being safe? Are you interested in fitting in and keeping quiet? What problems does that present considering the mission of the church?
  • ↑ Back to top

    ↑