Chapter 9 of 16

4. Emerging Adult Religious Commitment and Identity

4. Emerging Adult Religious Commitment and Identity

the most significant shift in religious commitment among emerging adults has been a move away from identifying with a particular religious group or tradition. As we saw in , substantial percentages of young people from across all of the major religious traditions now identify as Not Religious. As a result, scholars and the news media have steadily begun to pay significant attention to what some are calling “the rise of the religious nones,” referring to the rapid increase in the number of individuals in the United States who claim no religious affiliation.

In this chapter, however, we want to move beyond simply making the case that emerging adults are increasingly identifying as not religious. We will examine what this phenomenon actually looks like “on the ground” and uncover the complexities in the lives of the current generation of emerging adults, who have often been characterized in recent research and media coverage as a monolithic group of either “religious” or “not religious” individuals. We will consider the different ways that religion is part of the identities of emerging adults, the extent to which they identify with and are involved in the life of congregations, and how they fashion their religious and spiritual lives across the multiple facets of religiosity. We will look more deeply at the story of decline, but also the accompanying story of what appears to be a solidifying of religious commitment, as well as those who seem to be somewhere between commitment and disaffiliation.

Self-identification as either religiously affiliated or not religious is only one way to assess religion in the lives of young people. The rate of attendance at religious services, an important measure that is left out of most reports on the increase in the number of religiously disaffiliated, serves as a baseline measure of connection to organized religion and public religious practice. Using attendance as a measure of an individual’s general connection to organized religion and practice is important for many reasons, perhaps especially because it suggests that the more individuals are involved in the life of a religious organization and the larger community of participants, the more that religion is an important part of their personal lives.

As we saw in , attendance at religious services is the religion measure that has shown the greatest decline over the four waves of the study. In 2002, 40 percent of the young people in our study reported attending religious services at least once a week. By 2013, this number has dropped by half, to less than 20 percent. More noteworthy is the fact that 51 percent of the emerging adults in our study now say that they never attend any religious services. This is a dramatic increase even from five years earlier, in Wave 3, when just 35 percent said they never attended services. Although we expected a significant rise in the number of those who never attend, when we first saw these results, we were surprised at the findings: More than half of all the emerging adults in our study are disengaged from public religious practice and largely disconnected from organized religion.

Religious self-identity and attendance at religious services are two distinct measures of religiosity that often overlap but are not perfectly correlated. Given the growing interest among scholars and practitioners in the movement away from organized religion among emerging adults, it is important to consider both of these ways of measuring religiousness in the lives of young people.

In what follows, we take into account religious self-identity and public religious practice to divide emerging adults into four groups: (1) Not Religious: those who are atheists, agnostics, or simply say that they are not religious; (2) Disaffiliated: those who claim a religious identity but no longer attend services and are not associated with any particular religious institution; (3) Marginal: those who attend religious services sporadically (once a month or less) and are thus on the margins of religious institutions, and for whom religion remains on the margins of their lives; and (4) Committed: those emerging adults who regularly attend religious services (at least two to three times a month), suggesting a more religiously committed life. Within each of those groupings, we look at four areas of their religious lives: (1) religious beliefs; (2) centrality of faith, or the importance of religion and spirituality in their daily lives; (3) religious and spiritual practices; and (4) attitudes about organized religion and religious institutions.

In , we examined the differences in survey responses across religious traditions. In this chapter, we look at similar measures of religion. However, instead of comparing across religious traditions, we compare the responses across the four orientations to religion just described. While religious tradition continues to be important, it does not make an appearance in this chapter other than as a descriptor of the respondents whom we quote. Instead, we have divided our sample into these four broad categories that aim to identify the “how” of religious life rather than the “what.” In other words, rather than focus on the particularities of individual religious traditions, we look at the commonalities of how religiosity is lived out at varying levels of commitment among the emerging adults in our study. As we noted in , there certainly are religious particularities that are important to understand. But we also recognize that, increasingly, there are normative scripts for how young people incorporate religion into their lives that are not necessarily bounded by religious tradition. So, in this chapter, we look once again at the range of religion measures from our survey using a different lens.

Religious Groups

The emerging adults in our study are divided into four groups that take into account religious service attendance and self-reported religious identity (see and . We classify as Not Religious those respondents who said they never attend religious services and who answered “no” to the follow-up question, “Do you think of yourself as part of a particular religion, denomination, or church?” This group accounts for 35 percent of the full sample of respondents. A portion of those who said they never attend, however, answered “yes” to the follow-up question of religious identity. These respondents who continue to identify with a religious tradition but reported that they never attend religious services are categorized as Disaffiliated and constitute the smallest group, at just 16 percent of our sample.

A third group of respondents we label Marginal. These respondents consider themselves to be religious, or at least reported some level of identity with a religious tradition and reported some level of attendance at religious services. Attendance at religious services for this group ranges from a few times a year to once a month. The Marginal group makes up 22 percent of the sample. The final category encompasses those we are calling Committed. These are the respondents who identify with a religious tradition and reported that they attend religious services two to three times a month, once a week, or more than once a week. This group constitutes the remaining 27 percent of the sample.

Table 4.1 Religious Groups by Percentage

Not Religious

35

Disaffiliated

16

Marginal

23

Committed

27

Total

100

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.2 Religious Service Attendance

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Never

100

100

~

~

51

Few times a year

~

~

46

~

10

Many times a year

~

~

33

~

7

Once a month

~

~

21

~

5

Two to three times a month

~

~

~

30

8

Once a week or more

~

~

~

70

19

Total

100

100

100

100

100

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Social Characteristics of Religious Groups

When we divide our sample of emerging adults into these four religious categories, some distinct demographic patterns emerge (. First, we see a pattern related to religion and gender. In the sample as a whole, 53 percent of our respondents are female. However, females make up just 45 percent of the Not Religious. The Disaffiliated are 55 percent female, while the Marginal and Committed groups are 59 and 58 percent female, respectively. Next, we examine the relationship between religion and race. The Not Religious have the highest percentage of white emerging adults of the four groups; 77 percent of Not Religious are white. Seventy-four percent of Disaffiliated are white, while 64 percent of the Marginal and 67 percent of the Committed are white. Latinx emerging adults are similarly represented across all four groups. However, black emerging adults are overrepresented among the Marginal and Committed, with each group having about 18 percent black respondents, compared with 13 percent in the full sample. Age and levels of education appear to be distributed similarly within each of the four religious categories.

Table 4.3 Social Characteristics of Religious Groups

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Female

45

54

59

58

53

Age

23–24

31

27

29

29

29

25–26

40

46

42

42

42

27+

29

26

29

29

28

Race

White

77

74

63

67

71

Black

6

11

18

18

13

Latinx

9

9

10

11

10

Other

7

6

8

4

7

Family

Have children

24

28

38

36

32

Married

17

16

23

43

25

Education

High school or less

19

19

21

20

20

Some college

36

36

34

36

36

BA/BS or more

45

44

45

44

45

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

When we examine current family status, we see clear differences across the four religious categories. Among the Committed, 43 percent are married. This is about twice the proportion of married people in the other groups. The Marginals have the next largest proportion of married individuals, at 23 percent, while the Disaffiliated and Not Religious each include about 18 percent of married individuals. The presence of children in the lives of respondents is more evenly distributed across the groups, though still highest among the more religiously engaged. We discuss the link between religion and family life in more depth in , but for now this helps to create a picture of how these groups differ, beyond just their connection to religion.

Thus, the demographic patterns across all four religious categories are similar, and with the exception of marital status, there are no large differences in the demographic distributions in each category. However, the Committed emerging adults are still somewhat more likely to be female, less likely to be white, and more likely to have families of their own than their less religiously engaged peers. At the other end of the religious continuum, the Not Religious have the highest percentages of emerging adults who are white, male, unmarried, and without children.

In what follows, we describe each of the four religious groups using Wave 4 survey data to show the general trends within each group, while also drawing on our interviews of emerging adults to hear how they talk about issues related to religion and spirituality. Tables 4.5 through 4.13 include survey data for all four religious groups in the areas of beliefs, centrality of faith, religious and spiritual practices, attitudes toward organize religion, and spiritual but not religious identity. For easier reference and to avoid repeating the tables for each group, Tables 4.5 through 4.13 appear at the end of the chapter.

Not Religious

We met Josh on a nice sunny day in the same location where we had first met him 10 years previously, outside of a local library located in a quiet suburban neighborhood. Josh is not religious; in fact, he describes himself as a committed atheist—although not, as he said, the “mean type.” Josh was 14 years old when we first interviewed him. When we asked whether he had any religious upbringing, he said, “I was raised, well just nothing, not atheist but not a specific thing, just kinda blank. It’s not like [my parents] are against it . . . it just isn’t there.” His parents, however, did encourage him to seek out religion if he wanted to, and although he said he never really had any desire to be part of a religion, he was always curious about religion and its claims about morality and the cosmos.

Josh, now 24 years old, is about 6’3” tall, thin, with longish, curly hair. In fact, his hair is distinctive enough to elicit a comment from at least one passerby during our interview, who called out to him: “Love your hair!” In general, he has that sort of young artist look—black jeans, gray shirt, black boots, and of course sunglasses. He graduated with an economics degree from a well-known university on the East Coast two years before our meeting and has been looking for permanent work ever since. He is currently working with his mother in her freelance business and lives with his father and stepmother in a house at the back of their property.

Josh is very much at ease with himself and very thoughtful and articulate in his answers to our questions. When we first met Josh in 2003, he told us that he spent a good amount of time at the library, encouraged by his parents to pursue his appetite for ideas and even checking out books from different religious traditions, such as the Tao Te Ching. He seems to have kept up the reading habits he developed when he was younger, and throughout our conversation he interspersed comments related to philosophers, social theorists, and the so-called new-atheists, along with lots of other subjects of interest to him, as well as his propensity to read books about different religions.

When we asked him about his interest in religion and whether this was part of a spiritual quest on his part, he said:

I don’t think that it’s completely separated from some kind of spiritual quest. ‘Cause on some level it would be really nice to find something that I would believe in, you know? I wish that I could do that a lot of times, because of all the benefits you get from peace of mind and purpose and all this, that would be awesome. But—so that’s part of why I’ve looked into so many different [religions]. Sorta to try them out, does that make sense?

Josh does understand the appeal of religion for people, suggesting that the certainty that religion provides is really a type of nostalgic pull to the things one may have learned in childhood. He noted that as some of his friends have faced the difficulties of adult life, they “have started to go back to childhood things, like faster than I thought that they would, you know like become more religious, or . . . more traditional.” He continued, saying:

I mean it makes sense. The world is complicated and scary a lot of times, so I think that’s what they knew when they were younger, and that’s the toolbox that they had built into the back of their brain. So, then it makes sense that when stuff gets too hard for them, they go back and . . . do that stuff. So yeah, I think it’s in response to friction from the outside world, probably.

In the end, even though he tries to remain open to the possibility that one or another religion may be true, they all fail to satisfy his criteria for truthfulness in that they all ultimately require a sort of blind faith that he just can’t accept. He said, “I’m a very strong atheist, I would categorize myself as, you know . . . not in the emotional sense of, like, ‘God is stupid!’ Not like that . . . I basically . . . don’t believe in any kind of mysticism that you can’t explain. Just reason and logic, basically.”

In some ways, Josh is a unique case, with his persistent pursuit of understanding religion coupled with his insistence on using only reason and logic to evaluate the truth claims of different religions. In other ways, however, he offers an illustration of the type of emerging adults who are identifying themselves as not religious. As we listened to him talk about his beliefs about religion and his views of the world, we heard echoes of the themes from our interviews with other Not Religious young people. Even for Josh, a committed atheist, religion is not entirely absent from his life. Like many other Not Religious young people, he is not completely closed off to or antagonistic toward religion. He is open to religion as a theoretical possibility, one that works for some people. However, there is a distinction between religion as a theoretical possibility and religion as personally relevant. For most of the Not Religious young people we spoke with, like Josh, religion is just not something that holds particular relevance for them personally.

Diversity of Identities

As noted previously, Josh does not believe in God and is a self-proclaimed atheist. His atheist identity is rare, even among those who say they are Not Religious. Contrary to what some observers have at least implied, not all young people who say they are not religious are explicitly secular or identify as atheists or agnostics. A first step in understanding this group of Not Religious young people is to recognize the range of ways that they themselves want to be identified—whether atheist, agnostic, or simply not religious.

shows how Not Religious emerging adults identify themselves in the Wave 4 survey. Atheists make up just 13 percent of all of the Not Religious respondents as a group and only five percent of the entire sample of emerging adults. Identification as agnostic accounts for 21 percent of the Not Religious group and about 9 percent of the full sample. These numbers are greater than in the general population and have increased over the years of the study, but still represent the minority belief among Not Religious emerging adults. Some reports suggest that people who do not believe in God are reluctant to identify as atheists because they fear social disapproval of their atheism. Among the young people in our study who said they do not believe in God, just 30 percent identified as atheist in a separate question, though the emerging adults we interviewed did not necessarily express particular aversion to the atheist label. However, those who did identify themselves as atheists were quick to say that they were not overly aggressive in their atheism—the “mean type,” as we heard Josh say. Others made similar qualifications, such as this young man, who told us:

I used to, you know, identify as atheist . . . and for a long time [I] sort of just started being angry with some things about religion, shit like wars that happened over religion or influence in politics. Like you know what, it’s just a waste of life trying, just being angry about something. . . . If people want to be religious, whatever, that’s fine, that’s going to happen. You know I’m not religious, but I’m not going to be actively against it anymore and go on ahead with my life, because . . . it’s just not a part of my life and it never really comes up, so there’s no use in even, in even thinking about it, really. I don’t need it to live the kind of life I want to live and be responsible and have morals and be good to people. I know I’m on the right path and that I’m good to people.

Table 4.4 Self-Identity of Not Religious

Not Religious (%)

Total Sample (%)

Atheist

13

5

Agnostic

21

9

Just not religious

38

16

Something else

28

17

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Although there are some who identify as atheist or agnostic, it is more common for Not Religious emerging adults to report that they are “just not religious” rather than adopting a specific identity as atheist or agnostic. Some expressed the view that they were simply uninterested in those discussions and arguments and that, for them, atheism and agnosticism are just other ways of being religious. These emerging adults were happily not religious, and while they did not believe in God, taking on a specific identity as an atheist would (ironically) require a level of interest in religion that they simply did not have. For these young people, arguments either against or for God’s existence were simply irrelevant to their lives. This exchange with a 23-year-old Not Religious young man was typical of this perspective:

interviewer : So you say you wouldn’t describe yourself as a religious person at all?

respondent : No.

i : Do you consider yourself to be an agnostic or atheist?

r : I consider those religions.

i : You consider those religions?

r : Yeah, I mean they’re . . . they’re belief, so I just, I don’t affiliate myself with anything.

i : Nothing?

r : Nothing.

i : You don’t feel passionately about being nonreligious?

r : It’s—I just think it’s a choice that I’ve made, I don’t believe in God, I don’t believe in any religion, and being agnostic and atheist—those things are the religion of not being a religion. I mean, I’m not an atheist, but I’m not—I’m not anything. I guess I don’t really consider myself any religion.

Another issue regarding nonreligious identity is that some religious traditions are closely linked to cultural identity. For some of the young people we interviewed, religious and cultural identity overlap, while for others, these cultural markers hold distinct meaning in their lives. In such cases, people may continue to hold on to their cultural identity even though the religious component of their identity is not particularly salient. For example, one young woman identified as Jewish while also identifying as Not Religious. In this case, the identity marker of Jewish is about her cultural heritage and does not necessarily reflect her religious identity. In reporting the demographic information of these respondents, we try to follow their own language and note both their cultural identity and religious category when they appear in the text.

Beliefs

Just as Josh was clear in his identity as an atheist, he was also clear in his rejection of all beliefs in religion or spirituality. For Josh, the bottom line was that whatever he believed had to be explainable through reason and logic. As Josh expressed it: “It’s fine to believe that, but you have to be very explicit about saying I don’t have a rea—like, I don’t have evidence to believe this, but these are my beliefs separated from my understanding of the world.”

While there are others like Josh who reject all religion and spirituality, this was not necessarily true of all the Not Religious young people we talked to. In fact, surprising numbers of Not Religious hold religious beliefs of one kind or another. Of those emerging adults who consider themselves not religious, 39 percent believe in God, compared with 31 percent who said they do not believe in God and 30 percent who are unsure. Of those Not Religious respondents who said they believe in God, 40 percent of them identify God as a personal deity who is involved in people’s lives, rather than a more general concept of a supernatural force or a higher power. However, looking at the Not Religious group as a whole, just 16 percent expressed belief in a personal God.

Although many respondents acknowledged a belief in God, they seemed to be distinguishing between their belief that there is a God and the fact that they don’t necessarily believe in God or feel any connection to what they believe is God. For example, this 28-year-old woman told us:

I believe in a God and one ultimate creator, an intelligent designer of the universe. I suppose I most closely relate him—if you know, you have to put a term on it—so I would closely relate him to the Christian perspective because it’s what I’m most familiar with. But I guess I’m somewhat shying away from that as I get older, in the respect that you know Christians believe that there is only one God and that is “The Christian God.” I believe that there is one God, and every religion worships the same one, they just do so differently. That’s kind of where I stand on God, or intelligent designer, whatever you want to call it.

Turning to beliefs about the afterlife, 32 percent of the Not Religious said they believe in heaven. For example, one young man who identified as an atheist told us what many across the spectrum of religious involvement expressed—that good people go to heaven and only really bad people end up in hell:

r : I believe that when you pass on, I don’t believe that’s the end of life. I do believe there is an afterlife.

i : So do you believe in a heaven and hell?

r : Yeah, pretty much. I do believe there’s both.

i : What are those like to you? How do people get there?

r : To me, you know. . . . Hell is for, I mean, I look at someone who’s killed someone and to me, they’re going to hell. They took another person’s life, you know, that’s a big step to take. And then like, heaven, I look at it like my grandmother: She did everything she could in life to better her family, to better herself, you know, and I think she put all her effort in that, you know, to me, she’s going to go to heaven. She did what she can to teach her children about everything and teach them—and she even taught them about God, you know, so that’s the way I look at it.

Others expressed similar views. We spoke with one 27-year-old woman who describes herself culturally as Muslim, though she no longer identifies as religious, either in her beliefs or practices. She said, “I think everyone goes to heaven. I don’t think there even is a hell. I think that that’s something people use as a scare tactic. But I think [heaven] is just another plane where others exist. Other souls exist, other consciousness exists. . . . Just conceptually. . . . I still don’t understand it, but I just know that there’s something, an alternate life beyond what you know here.”

Not all of our respondents were as certain about their beliefs in the afterlife as those two young people. We also heard these beliefs framed as either cosmic uncertainties or general hopes about what might happen after death. Even Josh, who said he relies on reason and evidence for his beliefs and view of the world, expressed it as something he just couldn’t come to a conclusion about:

I would like to believe that there is some kind of . . . what do you call it, reincarnation? But I don’t know. I, you know, I try to come at it, think about what it would be to be nothingness. And I don’t know, ‘cause it’s nothingness. I find it really interesting to think about, but I don’t have an opinion on what I think happens when we die.

Still others expressed their disbelief and disinterest in the whole idea of an afterlife as well as heaven and hell. When asked if she believed in life after death, or heaven or hell, the 28-year-old noted previously, who believes in “one ultimate creator,” responded:

Maybe. I don’t . . . that really just doesn’t interest me. You know, whatever may or may not be after here is not for me to know or decide, and there’s absolutely no way that I could ever possibly know, so I just don’t bother myself with it. I just try to live a life that I feel like is good for me and for other people too. And if there is someone with a gavel upstairs, then I hope things go in my favor, you know?

The range of perspectives about God and the afterlife among Not Religious emerging adults is mirrored in their take on religion more generally. Identifying themselves as not religious does not mean that they are closed off to the ideas of religion altogether. In fact, many are open to the possibilities of religious teachings, even if they do not personally subscribe to them. Fifty-four percent of the Not Religious reported that they think many religions may be true (compared with 41 percent who said that there is very little truth in any religion). The Not Religious are also the emerging adults most likely (69 percent) to endorse the idea that individuals are not obligated to accept all the beliefs of a particular religion but can pick and choose what to believe from any tradition. This 28-year-old woman provides an example of this type of eclectic gathering of beliefs by saying:

I kind of take a few things from different religions, I guess. Like . . . I believe in in God, per se, whatever he looks like, or you know or whatever you want to call him. I’ll just call him God. And then, like . . . I believe that we’ve all lived before. I believe in karma. I believe like, just different things that make sense to me [laughs]. There are some things that don’t, so that’s why I just can’t see that being true or believing in that fully.

While there is an openness to the potential that religion may be true, this is tinged with doubt and questions. This 26-year-old woman said that she doesn’t practice “one particular religion. I think I’m more of like a live by morals and treat other people with kindness—send out positive energy to people” type of person. When asked whether she had any spiritual or religious beliefs, she said, “I mean, I don’t know. I really haven’t thought about it lately, you know? I don’t know. I don’t know. Yeah, no, I just, is there a God? That’s a question. I don’t know.” The Muslim woman whom we heard from previously responded to the same question, saying, “I actually . . . recently, kind of came—not came to conclusion, ‘cause you never can really come to conclusion when it comes to God—but, I kind of . . . I’m now viewing God as something that’s within us. . . . In our ability to heal, our ability to just be magnificent creatures.”

Centrality of Faith

Among Not Religious young people, we see a clear distinction between beliefs about religion and the personal importance of religion in their lives. Despite having some level of belief in God, very few of those who said that they are not religious told us that spirituality or faith was particularly important in how they lived their lives, or that they expected to be more religious in the future. And less than 10 percent reported feeling close to God. For many Not Religious emerging adults, religion or spirituality is simply not a part of their daily lives or anything they regularly think about. Most are comfortable with this lack of religiosity and did not feel that they were missing anything by not being religious.

There are, however, some Not Religious young people who acknowledge that religion or spirituality still plays a role in their lives. For example, this 27-year-old said that spirituality is a part of every day for her. She said, “Yeah, it makes me more in tune to my surroundings, to the people around me, a better judge of other people. I put myself in better situations and . . . pull myself out of negative situations. I think it’s just, it’s kind of like what’s been my guiding light.”

This level of intentional spirituality, however, was rare among the Not Religious. Spiritual practice or reflection was more likely to be something that operates in the background of their lives, in some cases a residual habitus from former religiosity. For example, this 25-year-old former Baptist woman told us:

I wouldn’t say I was a practicing Baptist or even practicing really anything. I believe in God, but I don’t have, like, daily devotional time or, really, to be honest with you, I don’t really think about it that often. But I do think that it’s kind of part of my foundation, or my background, so I guess it’s still a part of me, even if it’s not like the first thing that comes out, or anything like that.

When we asked how much that modest amount of religion or spirituality is part of her everyday life, she said, “probably less than two percent, maybe even less than that.” This 28-year-old woman expressed a similar perspective, saying:

I’d say the spirituality aspect is definitely pretty much always present. It’s always in the back of my mind when it comes to making decisions, how I interact with people. It’s like love what you got with all your heart, love your neighbors—those are the two foundations for how I kind of live life.

Beyond this background presence that some spoke about, religion does not appear to be particularly salient for most nonreligious emerging adults. Recall, however, that this does not mean that they are closed off to or opposed to religion. When we asked them whether they would like to learn more about religion, many of them reported that they would. Like Josh’s continuing study of different religions, they are not opposed to learning about religion as an intellectual exercise, so long as they are not being asked to engage personally with religion. However, it is another question entirely as to whether most Not Religious emerging adults would ever engage in learning more about religion or spirituality, whether based on their own past involvements or on curiosity about other religious traditions. Most likely, owing to their other statements about how irrelevant religion and spirituality are in their lives, their claim to be interested in learning more about religion is more aspirational than actual. Rather than ever actually seeking out different forms of religious or spiritual knowledge, their stated interests are likely to remain a theoretical possibility.

Religious and Spiritual Practices

Not Religious emerging adults are by definition disconnected from religious institutions. But another important question is whether they incorporate any personal religious practice or spirituality into their lives. As we discuss later in this chapter, 17 percent of the respondents in our study reported that they would describe themselves as “spiritual but not religious,” indicating that some elements of spirituality are present in their lives. We asked respondents across all four religious groups about a wide range of religious practices, including public practices such as attendance at religious services, and private practices such as prayer, meditation, and reading religious or spiritual materials. Respondents were also provided a list of religious traditions and asked whether they incorporated any practices from those traditions into their own spirituality. Among the Not Religious, 37 percent reported that they do not practice any form of spirituality, while 24 percent indicated that they practice spirituality but do not include any elements of the listed religious traditions. The remaining 38 percent of the Not Religious respondents identified at least one tradition from which they incorporate elements into their own spiritual practice.

While a substantial minority of Not Religious young people make a nod to some form of spirituality in their lives, the evidence of this is sparse when we ask about specific types of religious or spiritual practices. The spiritual practice that was reported most frequently was meditation, with 19 percent reporting that they have meditated in the previous year. Yet, our in-person interviews revealed that it is rare that meditation holds any sort of spiritual meaning for the young people we spoke with. Most who meditated did so as a way to “settle their mind” or “get their thoughts together,” without claiming it had any religious or spiritual meaning for them. The following 25-year-old woman provides a good example of this. She told us that she does yoga and, although she sits quietly during her yoga routine, for her it isn’t spiritual or religious: “No, it’s just—I guess quieting my mind, and not being, like, so frazzled. But I don’t think it’s like a spiritual thing.” So, while they may be practicing meditation from time to time, we are hesitant to point to these data as evidence of spirituality in the lives of the Not Religious emerging adults in our study.

Twelve percent of the Not Religious reported having read religious or spiritual material within the past year, and less than 10 percent reported regular prayer. Observing a weekly day of rest or a period of fasting or self-denial was even more rare among the Not Religious, at three and four percent, respectively. Although personal prayer is not frequently reported by this group, 16 percent said they have experienced an answer to prayer within the past five years. Another 14 percent said they have witnessed a miracle during this same time period.

Thus, as we might have expected, Not Religious emerging adults reported very low rates of religious or spiritual practices such as prayer, reading spiritual or religious material, setting aside a day of rest, or giving up something as a form of spiritual discipline. Of course, it is possible that they are engaging in other types of spiritual practices that were not captured by the questions in our survey. However, the responses to our in-person interviews do not indicate that this is the case. Among the young people who identify as Not Religious, the extent of the spiritual practices we heard about were occasional references to casual prayers and maybe some meditation, though as noted, meditation was not framed as spiritual or religious in nature. In general, Not Religious emerging adults are not engaged in regular or intentional spiritual practices. To whatever extent some of them may have moved toward a “spiritual but not religious” identity, it does not seem to include the element of spiritual practice.

Attitudes about Organized Religion

When scholars began to see a significant shift in the larger population toward identifying as a religious “None,” one important explanation for the trend had to do with individuals’ distancing themselves from, and dissatisfaction with, organized religion. Rather than disavowing religious belief and salience, the new “Nones” represented a growing distrust of the institutions of religion. While there appears to be more than that going on today, it is the case that the Not Religious emerging adults in our study are the most distanced from organized religious institutions. In response to a series of questions asking about organized religion, the Not Religious have the lowest level of confidence to report. About one-fourth of the Not Religious respondents said that they have a lot of respect for organized religion and that they have positive feelings for the religion in which they were raised. These comparisons are reversed when we asked whether mainstream religion was irrelevant for most people their age, and if they saw organized religion as a big turnoff. Not Religious individuals were far more likely to answer in the affirmative to both of those questions, with 50 percent agreeing that religion is irrelevant for their age group and 72 percent agreeing that organized religion is a big turnoff.

In comparison to the other three religious groups, the Not Religious are the most distant from and suspicious of religious institutions. In our interviews, Not Religious young people expressed this distance and distrust in a variety of ways. One theme we heard was a critique of the financial and bureaucratic trappings that they perceive to be associated with institutions in general, and their disappointment at seeing these traits as part of religious organizations. For example, a 25-year-old told us: “I don’t love it that [religious institutions] have become very corporate, like it’s more of a business than it is actually a place of worship.” Another 25-year-old man is representative of those emerging adults who view the leaders of organized religions as more interested in building their own empires than in serving others. He said, “I don’t like organized religion. I feel like it’s a scam. Everything’s run by money, and they pass that plate around asking for money all the time. I don’t know. Organized religion throws me . . . it leaves a bad taste in my mouth.” Expressing similar sentiments, a 28-year-old said that, for him, organized religion should have “more transparency, particularly around the way that they have their finances. I think that churches kind of get a free ride to do whatever they want, and they don’t pay taxes.” And a 27-year-old said that for her, “Institutional religion is the same thing as any kind of institution. There’s always a hierarchy, there’s always some sort of bureaucracy, and that’s not what . . . religion should be. In my eyes, I think religion should be more spiritual.”

For others, the suspicion was related to the role of religious organizations in the lives of people. One 24-year-old said that he didn’t like “institutionalized religion because I think it takes away from the human capacity to make moral decisions.” A 25-year-old man spoke of religious institutions as misleading, saying that religious institutions are a source of comfort, but that was why he viewed them as “awful, because [people] look to that for their comfort, and a lot of people are just like, ‘Well, I don’t care if my life sucks in this world because the next world is going to be great.’ And it’s like no, to me, this world is heaven or hell and you make it such. There is nothing else that we know of, this is it.”

Still others expressed personal experiences that had turned them off from formal religious organizations, like this 25-year-old woman:

r : You know, it’s just never been a pleasant experience to be in a church and be gay, it’s just not. If they don’t know, they’re completely okay with it. The minute that they find out, then it’s a little different.

i : Have people treated you differently?

r : Oh yeah.

i : What do they say?

r : It’s not as much as they say, it’s how they act.

Viewed from an alternative perspective, however, we see that at least one-fourth of the Not Religious gave answers that are generally supportive of organized religion. To understand the nuance and variation within this group, it is important to keep this in mind. In our interviews, this perspective tended to be expressed as the belief that religious institutions are fine for those who need or want to participate in them, even though interviewees themselves weren’t interested, with a clear caveat that extreme versions of religion are not okay. One 25-year-old said that he was “okay with it. I just am not a fan of extremism, and I’m not a fan of what I think are wrong beliefs, because it’s harming people or it’s uneducated, causing like actual institutional change. But I’m okay with it other than that.” And this 25-year-old woman said that, although she wasn’t interested in organized religion, she saw the benefits for some people:

It’s just something I don’t really do. I think that there’s, like, extreme institutional religion and I do think, like, the extreme extremes kind of make me uncomfortable because I feel like some of them almost take away the gut feeling of right and wrong and influence people too much. But in general, I don’t have a problem with them. I mean I think it’s a good thing for people to have. I think a lot of people benefit from it. It’s a place people can go for guidance or help and you know, tranquility. And for some people it gives them purpose. But I think the thing that really makes me uncomfortable is the extremes.

Thus, among the Not Religious, there are those who have positive regard for religion and see its potential benefits, even if they don’t personally subscribe to or affiliate with religion. And while most of the emerging adults we interviewed said that in the future they will not become religious, some did recognize the possibility that they could become involved with religion again under the right circumstances.

For some Not Religious emerging adults, the possibility of becoming religious in the future is related to the inevitable tough times in life that they anticipate may prompt a return to parts of their lives that they had left behind. Recall what Josh observed about people he knows, who in response to a “complicated and scary” world, have “started to go back to childhood things . . . [and] become more religious.” For others, this was related to particular stages of their lives, whether getting married and having children or simply a part of the process of development that happens as they are getting older.

For example, one 26-year-old man linked the possibility of his becoming religious to having children sometime in the future, seeing one possible future as similar to his father’s life: “My dad was actually kind of like me when he was my age, but when he had kids, he became actually religious.” We asked whether he thought that might happen to him, and he replied, “That may happen to me, I mean I’m open to the idea. I don’t like the prospect of it, but it may happen.” And a 26-year-old woman told us, “I don’t know. I think I’ll still be spiritual. I would like to think that I will have developed a more regular practice by then. And I guess that I would hope that I do a little bit more homework in terms of religion and spirituality before I have offspring that I intend to be teaching those things to.”

In the case of some interviewees, a possible return to religion was framed as a function of what their potential marriage partners might want or if their children were interested in religion, rather than something that they would independently choose for themselves. When asked whether she will be more religious in the future, this 25-year-old said, “I don’t know. I think a lot of it will depend, like you know, on if I’m married, who I married, what they believe. I mean I could see myself being more religious.” Similarly, a 24-year-old linked the possibility of her becoming religious to a shift in how interested in religion her boyfriend or her son might be, saying, “I probably might still be the same way [not religious]. Unless my son kind of drove me into something, or my boyfriend tries to get a little more religious. I would support him, but . . . maybe they might end up changing the way I see it, who knows?” And this 24-year-old man expressed a similar reluctance about the possibility of his future religiosity when he acknowledged, “I want to say less religious, but in reality, I’d imagine it’s up and down. So, imagining I’ll be religious again for a little bit and I’ll lose it again and so on and so on. I see that go like a rocky path.”

For others, the possibility of becoming religious in the future was even more unlikely, unless some miraculous event either drove them back to religion or somehow verified for them that religion was true. When we asked, “What do you think you’ll be like religiously when you’re 40 years old?” these two young people had similar responses:

Not religious at all (chuckles). Unless, like I said, unless something major, you know, happens to show me that there is something to believe in. I don’t see it happening, but if it did, you know, I’m open minded. (25-year-old man)

Probably pretty similar, unless I have one of those supernatural experiences. That could shift things a little bit. (27-year-old woman)

The potential for any return to religion for the Not Religious emerging adults seems to represent much more of a murky potential development for them, rather than a real, concrete option, at least as they conceive of the prospect of increased religiosity now. That is, they could return to religion given the right circumstances, or if their needs were such that they could envision a religious institution as being able to provide for those needs. But even in this theoretical return, it is interesting to note the lack of personal agency in their responses. A return to religion would only be spurred by something outside of themselves, whether prompted by a spouse, children, a miracle, or the inevitable “rocky path” of life. Becoming more religious is not framed as an intentional decision or choice; rather, it is something that “may happen to me,” as if a life of faith is something that would be imposed on them, rather than something that they could cultivate and develop. Overall, they think and talk about religion as something that they are not interested in and that is completely irrelevant to their current lives. And if it were ever to become relevant, it would not be of their own doing because very few expected to be internally driven or motivated to seek out religion in their future.

In sum, Not Religious emerging adults are largely disengaged from religion and spirituality, even though they are not completely irreligious. Religion still operates in the background for some. Some are open to the possibilities of religion, but they are not personally connected to or motivated by those possibilities. For Not Religious emerging adults, religion operates as a kind of theoretical option, but one that could only be realized under particular circumstances. The Not Religious do still maintain some beliefs, although these are more an intellectual assent rather than actual belief or faith in any religious tenets, leaving whatever belief or connection to religious institutions they have largely unrealized. For Not Religious emerging adults, religion, spirituality, and faith, while maintaining a small place in their lives, are largely irrelevant to their daily life. To the extent that religion exists at all on their radar, it is at a residual or potential level and as an unlikely option for their lives in the future.

Disaffiliated

Andrew was born into a Catholic family, and although his parents still attend church every week, he neither attends nor is interested in attending or having anything else to do with the Catholic Church. For Andrew, being Catholic is simply the result of his having been born into a Catholic family—nothing more, nothing less. Andrew’s approach to his religious identity is pretty simple. He said, “If somebody asked me, ‘Why are you Catholic?’ Just ‘cause I was raised that way, I guess.” For Andrew, religion operates merely as a background part of his identity:

r : I didn’t make any like big decisions like oh, I like this religion. It doesn’t, in your everyday life, it doesn’t come up.

i : What I’m hearing you say is that this doesn’t really matter.

r : It doesn’t.

Andrew is 26 years old, with closely cut hair and a light beard. He’s about 5’10” tall and looks like the former high school football player he is. He is unfailingly polite in his responses to our questions and at times seems amused that we keep asking him about religion, despite the fact that he keeps telling us that none of it matters in his everyday life, that he doesn’t believe any Catholic religious teachings, and in general, that he doesn’t have anything to do with the Catholic Church.

We interviewed him in an outside courtyard of a shopping center, next to a Starbucks and some other fast-food stores, in an exurban area that has rapidly developed over the past 20 years and has diversified significantly over that time. He is living with his girlfriend but is in no hurry to get married. He thinks he will eventually marry her, but he makes that sound more like it would be okay, rather than something he really wants to do. He has one son with a previous girlfriend and another with his current girlfriend, who is also pregnant with his third child.

Despite the fact that he personally never attends religious services or does anything else with the Church, Andrew is not opposed to religion or Catholicism. His six-year-old son goes to Catholic school because that’s what Andrew did when he was growing up, and he thinks that it is a good source of morals for his son. He’s not even opposed to his son going to church, although he doesn’t take him. Rather, Andrew drops his son off at his parents’ house so that they can take him to church with them. Despite his lack of interest in church, he thinks that religion could be important for people his age; it just depends on where one’s priorities lie.

Yeah, I mean if you want to . . . if that’s in your life, it can be very relevant. If you’re a believer, it’s relevant to everything that you do. So, it’s . . . I guess it’s to each their own. If you’re a believer, yeah, it’s going to be very relevant to anybody my age. But if you’re not, it’s just it’s equally not relevant.

He continues by suggesting that religion is just another expression of where people decide to put their commitments in life:

People tend to think religions are a lot different than a gym, but they’re not. It’s the same thing. It’s just . . . you value religion more than getting in shape. And for some people, getting in shape is a religion. So, it’s kind of that every faith is fighting for everybody to get them in. ‘Cause more people is better than no people.

In the end, though, Andrew said that it’s just not something that he is particularly interested in: “I don’t really pay attention to how they do it, though. I don’t follow it.”

Beliefs

When it comes to belief in God, 89 percent of Disaffiliated emerging adults in our study reported that they believe in God. More than one-half said that the deity they believe in is a personal God who is involved in people’s lives. However, in contrast to the more religiously involved young people, the beliefs articulated by the Disaffiliated sound more like a general acceptance that religious claims are, or may be, true rather than any deep commitment to a religious or spiritual perspective. For example, a 28-year-old Disaffiliated who identifies as simply a “Christian” said:

I believe that you don’t have to go to church in order to believe. I believe that you should, like they say, you know, treat other people the way you want to be treated. That’s a spiritual thing. And then, I do not believe that you should force your spiritual beliefs on anybody. Everybody has their own choice, their own opinion, and their own option. I do believe that there are right and wrong religions, personally, but I think that everybody who’s religious kind of believes that.

This 25-year-old Jewish Disaffiliated describes her ambivalence about believing in God, given the bad things that can happen in the world. She said, “I kind of believe in God and I kind of don’t. Like, I believe that he made us; I believe that he made the world; but then . . . times like 9/11, what happened in Boston—he’s not there. Because I believe if he was really there, all these bad things wouldn’t happen, so . . . that’s why I think he’s there but he’s not.” A similar ambivalence is noted by a former Conservative Protestant, who said that while she believes in God, she’s not at all sure what that means: “I believe that there is a God, I don’t know if there’s a specific one God.”

For others, these perspectives are more “hopes” than actual beliefs. For example, when we asked Andrew, the disaffiliated Catholic, what he believes, he replied:

I think I have more of a hope than a faith. And the big thing about, like, Christian religion is faith. You have to believe without knowing. And I’m just hoping [laughs]. Like, it would be awesome. Like, if there is a God, that would be awesome, you know? My biggest thing is fear of when I die, that it just shuts off. That sucks. And that’s kind of what I believe. Like your brain’s done, that’s it.

i : But you’re hoping?

r : So, I hope. . . . That would be awesome. . . . It’s hard to be much of a believer when I just don’t, you know?

This uncertainty expressed as hope, rather than belief, was a fairly common response to our questions from those who are less involved in religious institutions:

r : God, my beliefs are so fluid. I can’t even pin anything down.

i : Do you believe in God?

r : I think so [laughs].

i : Okay, tell me about that.

r : I would like to think that we have a purpose that’s bigger than just being dropped into this earth and then just leaving. I would like to think that. (24-year-old Disaffiliated Jewish woman)

i : Do you believe in a God?

r : [Pause] Maybe a higher power. Maybe not . . . maybe not a being . . . a person, um . . . maybe just . . . sometimes it sounds so, like . . . contradictory. You know [chuckle]? I’m . . . higher power, yeah. I think . . . yeah. I guess. (26-year-old Disaffiliated Mainline Protestant woman)

This continued belief—or hope—among the Disaffiliated that religion just might be true is apparent in that the majority said they believe that many religions might be true and that it is okay to “pick and choose” religious beliefs, either from within their own tradition or across multiple traditions. A good example of this view is this self-identified “nondenominational Christian,” who shows a typical curation of multiple sources from both within and outside of her tradition:

i : How would you describe yourself to me in terms of your religion, faith, and spirituality?

r : I am eclectic. I’m nondenominational Christian. I believe in free interpretation of the Bible based on current, personal, situational relevance. I believe in gut instincts being a direct influence of God on an individual’s motives. I think that doing the right thing, trying to be the best person that you can be, making the right decisions when the time comes, really thinking it through are the things that make the difference when all is said and done. And I feel like there are elements in this earth that were put here for our healing. I wear a chakra rock for good karma.

Disaffiliated emerging adults also tend to be less certain of their beliefs about what happens after death. In answering questions about whether heaven is a real rather than imaginary place, Disaffiliated emerging adults tended to frame their responses as a belief that all—or at least most—people end up in heaven after they die, and that hell is primarily reserved for murderers and thieves. This 28-year-old Catholic was certain about heaven, less so about hell. From her perspective, hell is reserved for those who commit the most heinous of sins:

r : I believe in heaven. I don’t believe in reincarnation or anything like that.

i : Do you believe in hell?

r : [Long pause] Yes.

i : How does someone get to hell?

r : I think murdering certain . . . um, you know like, murdering, raping, like unforgivable sins. I think there are certain things you can do and I think as long as you turn your life around. Depending on what it is. If you murder somebody, I don’t really know if you’re going to be forgiven for that.

Andrew illustrates how Disaffiliated emerging adults’ beliefs about the afterlife—as with their beliefs about God—were mostly framed as uncertainties or hopes about what might happen after death. His uncertainties about religion in general extend to his thoughts about the afterlife:

i : Are you hoping that there’s an afterlife of some sort?

r : Yes, that would be ideal. I hope that your . . . your whatever it is that you want to save . . . your soul or whatever, just the process of thinking, just goes on and that’s it. That’s what I hope, but it just seems so farfetched.

i : So, what do you think about things like reincarnation or . . .

r : That would be awesome, too. I kind of would like to take from all religions. Like oh, that would be awesome if that was true . . . but I really don’t think any of them are going to happen.

A 28-year-old Disaffiliated Jewish woman provides a similar example of this uncertainty:

I suppose I believe in some sort of heaven. I don’t think I really believe in hell, but, I think we all go somewhere after this, and there’s something more you know, our soul leaves, our bodies stay but our soul leaves, and there’s something. I don’t know what it is though.

Disaffiliated emerging adults are neither complete unbelievers nor atheists. They are open to the possibilities of religious beliefs. But beyond believing, or hoping, that there is a God, the particulars are a bit fuzzy. They like the idea of religious beliefs but can’t quite articulate what those beliefs might be. And even though they hope that there might be something beyond themselves, this possibility doesn’t seem to occupy a lot of their time or thinking. Rather, they seem satisfied to remain in this ambivalent space where they are neither believers nor unbelievers, not really knowing what they finally believe about religion, God, and the afterlife.

Centrality of Faith

Disaffiliated emerging adults in our study are similar to the Not Religious in their hope that there may be some truth to religious claims, but they seem to be keeping their options more open regarding the role of religion and faith in their own lives. As we spoke with Disaffiliated emerging adults, it became evident that these sentiments seem related as much to their residual religious identity and upbringing as to their current status as Disaffiliated. Recall Andrew’s statement that his Catholic identity is a product of his upbringing, but it doesn’t matter for his everyday life. He is not alone in his view; only about one-fourth of the Disaffiliated young people in our study reported that their faith is very or extremely important in their daily lives. Like Andrew, many Disaffiliated emerging adults expressed a disconnect between their religious identity and its importance in their lives. For example, this 24-year-old Disaffiliated woman who identifies as Jewish, framed Jewishness as a key part of her identity, but with no real religious significance:

i : How much would you say that Judaism is part of your everyday life?

r : Um, it’s not. I wouldn’t say it really is. No.

i : Is it a big part of your identity, do you think?

r : Yeah! I would say like it’s not part of my life like when I make decisions, I don’t like refer to Judaism. But I would say, like, when I would describe who I am, that’s like one of the first things . . . it’s like an individualizing factor.

And when we asked this 24-year-old Disaffiliated Conservative Protestant if religion was a part of his daily life, he answered, “I’d like to say yes, but nah, really, I really can’t say that, no.” Thus, religion is still a part of these Disaffiliated young people’s lives in that they continue to identify with a particular religious tradition, but beyond acknowledging the religious identity in which they were raised, it simply is not at all relevant to their lives.

There are other Disaffiliated emerging adults, however, who seem to be caught between feeling that religion and spirituality have little or nothing to do with their daily lives and thinking that they should have more of a presence in their lives. A 27-year-old man provides a good example of this response:

i : How would you say that your faith or religion influences your life?

r : Not as much as it should [laughs].

i : Okay [laughs]. What makes you say that?

r : Just, you know, some of the stuff,—you know, nobody, nobody’s the, the perfect ideal of a Christian or whatever, I mean it. And it, just, you know, there’s a lot of things I could maybe do better on. Do differently, I guess.

Similarly, a 24-year-old Disaffiliated Conservative Protestant said that, for her, religion was a part of her life, “a hundred percent. It’s always in the back of my mind,” but leaves undefined what that actually means for her. It seems that, although religious beliefs are present, they are not particularly salient for this group of young people. While 89 percent of the Disaffiliated emerging adults believe in God, just 27 percent said that they feel very or extremely close to God. Those who said they are becoming less religious outnumber by two to one those who said they have become more religious in the past five years. The majority, 63 percent, reported staying the same religiously during this time period.

These responses help us understand one of the key distinctions between the Not Religious and the Disaffiliated. They are equally distant from religion in that neither group attends religious services. However, in addition to maintaining a religious identity, many Disaffiliated emerging adults still have some sense that religion should be part of their life, even if it isn’t in practice. In leaving the door open to religion, whether through vague religious beliefs or an acknowledgement that religious institutions have some positive benefits, these emerging adults see religion as something that they could call on in times of need.

Religious and Spiritual Practices

Disaffiliated emerging adults are less likely than the Marginal or Committed, but more likely than the Not Religious, to engage in spiritual practices such as prayer, reading spiritual or religious books, or regularly setting aside a day of rest or giving up something as a form of spiritual discipline. However, when we asked whether they drew any spiritual practices from other religious traditions, only 14 percent of the Disaffiliated said they did not practice spirituality at all. The remaining 86 percent identified at least some spiritual practices in their lives. For example, 17 percent have read religious books at some point in the last year, while about one-fourth of the Disaffiliated reported that they pray at least daily.

The particular nature of their spiritual practices, however, seems to fit with the larger picture of the Disaffiliated as connected to the possibility of religion, if not the practice and implementation of religion. For instance, this 24-year-old Disaffiliated Jewish young man talked about prayer as a form of self-reassurance rather than as a means of connecting to God or a higher power:

i : Do you ever pray?

r : [Sighs] Kind of. Um, not so much traditionally. There were many times in college where I would go through periods of acute stress and self-doubt, usually when we got our finals, when everyone’s experiencing that, and prayer for me was never something for it to be answered. It’s more results in opportunity to like . . . it’s a mixture of reassuring myself through prayer and also [laughs] almost like covering my bases. Say like, ‘Hey, feelin’ lost, ‘n like I could use some help.’ Like [laughs], you know, I could use a hand here.

Similarly, this 26-year-old Disaffiliated Catholic female said: “I pray often. Maybe not every day, but a couple times a week.” When we asked what she prayed for, she replied, “To keep everybody safe and healthy, I think that’s the main thing I pray about.” And this 24-year-old said that she prayed, “probably several times a week” and that her prayers were mainly to ask God “to watch over my family and friends and if I have, like, something going on, to help me get through it or, you know, like I hope you have a plan for me, that kind of stuff, to get better or to have a better job or to help me with this.”

Thus, Disaffiliated emerging adults are still holding on to some elements of religion and spirituality in their lives. They are not religiously engaged, but they still acknowledge the possibility of religious meaning and are not ready to give up their own religious identity, however distant it may be from religious organizations.

Attitudes about Organized Religion

Responses from Disaffiliated emerging adults to the questions about organized religion continue to highlight their liminal state. Although they do not attend religious services, the Disaffiliated are more than twice as likely as the Not Religious to say that they have respect for organized religion and are almost three times as likely to say that they have positive feelings for the religion that they grew up in. When asked whether organized religion is irrelevant or a big turnoff, just over one-third agreed. The remaining two-thirds of the Disaffiliated do not have particularly negative views of organized religion. These young people were more likely to answer that religion was—or at least could be—relevant and to disagree that it was a turnoff. As we heard from Andrew at the beginning of this section, “If you’re a believer, it’s relevant to everything that you do. But if you’re not, it’s just, it’s equally not relevant.”

Others told us that they believe that religion serves a good purpose in society, although they tended to frame this in a way that at least implicitly emphasized their distance from organized religion. A 23-year-old Disaffiliated emerging adult said that she appreciated the diversity of religious groups in the United States: “It’s nice that we have people in this country that believe in lots of different things and have the freedom to practice and believe in what they want to.” A similar sentiment was voiced by a 26-year-old Disaffiliated Catholic, who said, “I think religion in general can be a very helpful thing for society . . . if it’s practiced with a bit of care, and following the core of its beliefs. In all reality religion—all it does is promote a more peaceful, loving, caring society, in most cases.”

Thus, for the Disaffiliated, it seems that their lack of involvement is not likely driven by negative feelings about religious institutions themselves. While negative feelings toward religious institutions may characterize a small subset of the Disaffiliated, the majority continue to demonstrate the “benign positive regard” for religion that we have seen throughout the years of this study. It also does not seem that they are rebelling against their own religious upbringing, given that 71 percent reported positive feelings for the religion in which they were raised. But having positive feelings, or seeing the good that religion can do in society, does not necessarily translate into a willingness to be engaged and committed to their religion or to religious groups.

In sum, while the Disaffiliated are neither completely unbelievers nor atheists, they maintain only a fuzzy set of beliefs and a liminal connection to religion. Still, they have not severed that connection completely. The Disaffiliated tend to hope there is something bigger than themselves but are not quite sure what that might be or how they can make any rational sense of it. They remain doubtful—not willing to reject the possibility of God or the supernatural completely, yet uncertain what they really believe about religion.

In contrast to Not Religious emerging adults, who don’t seem to feel the same sort of regret about their distance from religion, some of the Disaffiliated think religion should be part of their lives, even though it is not currently and seems to be an unlikely addition to their lives in the future. Religion is just not a viable option for their expenditure of time and commitment. It occupies a secondary space where it would be nice if it were true, and they may even participate in some limited forms of spiritual practice. But these practices, such as they are, are idiosyncratic to these individuals and their backgrounds. The Disaffiliated are not opposed to religion and do not exhibit strong negative feelings toward it, but they aren’t particularly interested in committing to any religious beliefs or communities, and, in their view, religion doesn’t really affect their lives in any practical sense.

Marginal

Maria is a fascinating person to have a two-hour conversation with. When we last interviewed her, she had just graduated from dental assistant school. In the five years between interviews, she had gone on to get other certifications so that she would be qualified to assist with more advanced procedures, such as oral surgery. She is very confident in herself and her abilities and is driven to make more of herself. In her own words, she has set her sights on “moving up the corporate ladder.”

Maria is a 27-year-old woman who was very comfortable answering any question we asked her. In fact, she often answered our questions before we finished them! In her telling, she had to take charge of her life from an early age and really enjoys it. She talked about her parents as drug addicts and how she’s taken over their house and mortgage. She has big plans for herself—although those plans primarily have to do with making more money and are short on specifics. She’s thinking ahead in her life to the next thing she can do to make more money and be more successful. Maria has two daughters (ages six and one). She also gave birth to a stillborn child, an experience that changed her outlook and ultimately made her more serious about how she approaches her life and what she wants to accomplish.

When we asked about her perspective on religion, she revealed an interesting amalgam of religious beliefs and views. She and her “significant other”—they have been together for nine years, are not married, and have no plans for marriage—recently started attending services at a local Calvary Chapel about once a month. Maria said that she believes in God and that Jesus was just another human. She prays about four times a week and believes in reincarnation (which is a holdover from her experiences on a local Native American reservation) as well as karma. When we asked about her experience at Calvary Chapel, she said that “they sing too much” and that she would “rather hear the scriptures than hear all the singing.” When we asked her about the importance of religion in her life she said, “Oh, I would say, like, five-percent. I don’t know.”

i : What would that five percent look like?

r : Well, I mean, it doesn’t really bother me. I’m not sitting here, like, what would Jesus do in this situation, or am I going to be judged for this? But, as long as I live my life the way I should and I’m not doing harm to others or doing things where karma would bite me, you know what I mean, then I think I’m kind of okay.

For Maria, religion is one involvement among many that vie for her attention, and not necessarily for obvious spiritual reasons. She attends Calvary Chapel as a way to get some spiritual content in her life—she finds it “peaceful” and “people-oriented”—but it also has a nostalgic appeal, because that is where her mother would occasionally take her when she was a child. In the end, she doesn’t see religion as particularly relevant or integral to her life:

I think I can get by without having a religion, you know, I think a lot of people could. I know I don’t have to sit there and go to church every day, I don’t need to pray every day or anything like that, I can still make it, but it’s just nice to know that you have something out there other than yourself watching out for you.

For Maria, this view extends to others in her generation: “I think a lot of teenagers, young adults these days don’t need [religion].” When we asked whether church could be an option for young people, she replied, “I think it’s . . . a slim option.”

Maria is an example of a group of emerging adults we are referring to as Marginal. Marginals are those who attend religious services at least occasionally—for our purposes, generally once a month or less. Marginal emerging adults are similar to the Disaffiliated in how they express their beliefs and in the way that they pursue religious and spiritual practices. What sets them apart from the Disaffiliated is their willingness to be somewhat active in a faith community, however marginal their participation may be. In the following sections, we examine the facets of religiosity expressed by this group and illustrated by Maria.

Beliefs

Marginal and Disaffiliated emerging adults are very similar in their religious beliefs. The rates of belief in God and belief in heaven are the same for both groups, though Marginals are more likely to report belief in a personal God. Marginals lean a little bit more in the direction of religious exclusivity, though not by a lot. Sixty-seven percent said that many religions may be true, and one-half reported that it is okay to “pick and choose” among religious beliefs. Overall, they share much more in common with the Disaffiliated than with the Committed.

In our interviews with Marginal emerging adults, most expressed their belief in God, but they sounded somewhat unsure of what, or who, God is. Some had fairly orthodox beliefs, while others had developed their own conception of God. When we asked them to describe how they understood who or what God is for them, we got a mix of answers that, in different ways, demonstrated their limited involvement with religion. Most, like this 27-year-old Catholic woman, framed their understanding of God in uncertain generalities. She told us that she believes “there’s something that created us and the world that we live in. I don’t necessarily think that he, you know, messes with, like, the day-to-day occurrence of, you know, what we’re doing. But I think he’s, I think there’s something, there.” When we asked whether she believes in Jesus, she answered, “I don’t know [laughs]. Maybe [laughs]. I mean, I think there probably was a man named Jesus who, you know, was a miraculous being, but I don’t know if he was the Son of God.”

Similarly, this 26-year-old Mainline Protestant described her view of God as somewhat remote, but available if she had any problems or needed guidance:

I always envisioned him up in heaven. Yeah, I mean, I don’t think that he has all the answers and I don’t think that he’s there to give you the answers. Otherwise that would just be too easy. But I do think he’s there to be able to give you advice and guidance when you might feel those moments of struggle, just to be able to have someone to talk to I guess [who] might be able to show you a sign, maybe, which direction you should take.

When asked, she described Jesus as “someone that could be inspiration, just for the, you know, the struggle and the sacrifice that he made.”

Other Marginal emerging adults, however, gave a more abstract description of how they understood God. For example, a 25-year-old Jewish woman told us that, for her, God was “an explanation for things you can’t explain.” And a 26-year-old Catholic man said that God was “. . . forgiveness, happiness, comfort. Probably mostly comfort.” He added that he believed that Jesus was “God, or God’s son, or God basically.”

When we asked Marginal young people whether they believed in the afterlife and whether they thought that heaven was a real place, most expressed a belief in the afterlife and heaven, although some were a bit unsure. Fewer of them said that they believed in hell. Those who were more certain of the existence of heaven described it as “wonderful” or a place of rewards after having lived a good life. A 26-year-old Catholic woman said, “Yes, I believe in heaven and I believe in hell.” When we asked what she thought heaven and hell were like, she replied, “I really don’t have any idea, other than being taught and believing that heaven is better than you could ever imagine, just the most wonderful place ever. And hell was the opposite of that.” Her understanding of how people get to either heaven or hell was typical of most Marginal responses:

i : How do you think people get to heaven or hell?

r : [Pause] I would say heaven, just . . . trying to be the best person you can be. And asking for forgiveness when you aren’t the best person that you can be. See, hell, I guess, I would say ultimately, if you [sigh]. If you commit a lot, a lot of horrible sins, like murder or anything like that, and you’re truly not sorry. ‘Cause I have always been taught that if you murder, or even if somebody killed 20 people, but if they’ve asked for forgiveness, they will not go to hell.

This description of heaven and hell was typical among Marginals: heaven was consistently described as a pleasant or wonderful place of rewards for good deeds performed during one’s life, while hell—if they actually believed in it—was a place of punishment, usually reserved for those who commit the most heinous acts such as murder or rape. A typical description comes from this 28-year-old Conservative Protestant:

r : I believe in heaven and hell.

i : What do you think heaven and hell are like?

r : I think . . . hell is a place for punishment, and heaven is a place where you’re . . . you’re rewarded.

i : How do you think people get there?

r : By the way your life was lived—good deeds and bad deeds.

This Jewish young woman has a similar view:

i : Do you believe in heaven or hell?

r : Not hell.

i : And what is heaven like to you?

r : Pleasant. It’s, I mean, I haven’t been there.

i : Okay. How do people get to heaven?

r : By working off their sins.

Finally, similar to the Disaffiliated, some Marginals were uncertain whether they believed in life after death, or what it might entail. This 27-year-old Catholic provides a good example of this uncertainty:

i : Do you believe in life after death?

r : I don’t know.

i : You don’t have a sense of what might happen when we die?

r : I mean the idea of life after death is nice, right? You know you could always, you know, continue on in heaven or wherever, but I don’t know. Like, when a spider dies, does he go to heaven?

Like those of the Disaffiliated, the beliefs of the Marginals were marked by uncertainty. The uncertainty, though, was of a different character. For the Disaffiliated, there was an uncertainty about whether God, heaven, and hell exist. The Marginals were more certain that there is a God and that heaven exists. But they were not necessarily able to articulate exactly what that means; their uncertainty lies in the details and the implication of these beliefs, rather than in uncertainty about the existence of God and heaven or in the concepts themselves. It is as if, by acknowledging God’s existence, it dawns on them that perhaps the existence of a supernatural being should be followed by some sort of response to this reality—that perhaps they ought to have some understanding about this God and the implications of the fact that God exists. But at the same moment, they also realize that the “so what then?” question that follows from acknowledging this existence is a hard nut to crack with the few theological tools they have at their disposal.

Centrality of Faith

When examining the importance of faith in the lives of Marginal emerging adults, we see more of a distinction between the Marginal and the Disaffiliated, though they are still very distinct from the Committed. Almost half (45 percent) said that faith is very or extremely important in their daily lives. This compares with 26 percent of the Disaffiliated, on the one hand, and 87 percent of the Committed, on the other. Thirty-two percent reported feeling very or extremely close to God—about half the rate we see among the Committed. While the majority of them have remained the same religiously, more than one-fourth reported having become more religious since the last survey. One clear distinction between the Marginal and Disaffiliated is the role they envision religion playing in their future. While Marginals do not currently attend religious services very often, 61 percent said they expect that they will be attending services when they are 35 years old, compared with just 27 percent of the Disaffiliated.

Despite the obvious differences between the Marginal and Disaffiliated groups, each demonstrates at least some interest in religion, though not as a central part of their lives. Recall Maria, who, when we asked how important religion was in her everyday life, estimated its importance at “five percent” and said that “it doesn’t really bother me . . . as long as I live my life the way I should . . . then I think I’m kind of okay.” Other Marginal emerging adults described the role of religion and spirituality in similar ways, suggesting that it operates in the background of their daily lives. In other words, religion is something that can be accessed, but it remains mostly inactivated in their daily lives. A 26-year-old Catholic said that, for her, “it’s not something I think about often, it’s more so I just do—like, if I was to say a prayer, it’s not something that I really so much realize that it’s like a religious part of the day.” A 25-year-old Jewish man responded similarly:

i : How much would you say religion or spirituality is part of your everyday life?

r : Some, a little bit.

i : And what is that little bit?

r : Because your religion not only shapes society if you’re Judeo-Christian, but it kind of shapes the way that you grew up, and the way that you grew up affects your belief system. And your belief system makes you who you are.

i : So, is this on a conscious level, or . . . ?

r : Sometimes, sometimes.

While these responses were fairly typical of Marginal emerging adults, some claimed that religion is part of their lives but were not certain how to articulate the specific role that it plays. A 26-year-old Mainline Protestant woman said that for her, religion is “part of my life every day. Like, percentage-wise, or . . . I mean, like, every day. There’s always something. I kind of think that it’s something that helps guide my life, I guess, is a good way to put it.” This young woman seems to be searching for the answer even as she tries to express her response to us. For Marginals like her, there is a sense that spirituality is a part of their lives and that they believe it should be, but they have not thought particularly intentionally about it and struggle to articulate an answer to the question about the role that religion or spirituality plays in their daily lives.

Religious and Spiritual Practices

As with each of our other groups, prayer is the most common spiritual practice among the Marginal respondents, with 38 percent saying that they pray at least daily and more than half saying they have experienced a specific answer to prayer in the last five years. Yet, what they mean by prayer, as most of them acknowledged, isn’t necessarily a set-aside time of quiet contemplation and interaction with the divine. Rather, prayer for Marginals—as for the Disaffiliated and Not Religious who also pray—tends to be spontaneous and random, depending on what they are doing and experiencing. This 29-year-old, who occasionally attends a Unity Church, said that she keeps “a constant dialogue kind of internally.” She continued, “Prayer, in like a literal definition, I don’t know if I actually am praying, but it’s kind of like a constant check-in, in how I feel and you could say I pray.” Similarly, a 26-year-old Mainline Protestant woman said:

I think that it depends on . . . gosh, I don’t know. I feel like I . . . I think it kind of depends on what I might be going through as far as when I really sit down and say a true prayer. I think that I, you know, will make small prayers here and there, like, oh, you know, “Please God, don’t let me get into a car accident” or things like that. I feel like that happens every day. But if . . . when I sit down and really, like, pray hard for something . . . it kind of depends on what’s going on in my life.

Others, however, did try to have a regular time to pray, as this 27-year-old Catholic told us: “I try to pray every night, if I don’t fall asleep first [laughs].” And a 28-year-old Conservative Protestant said that he tries to pray “at least a few times a week.”

About one-fourth of the Marginal emerging adults said that they have read religious material in the previous year. But, as with prayer, this practice seems fairly irregular and more aspirational in terms of their thinking—that perhaps they should be reading religious books or other spiritually oriented material. A typical response to our question about reading the Bible came from a 26-year-old Catholic, who said, “Nowadays, no, not really, so actually in the future I hope to have more time to do that.” Another said that yes, she reads the Bible, but not “as frequently as I should.”

Attitudes about Organized Religion

Marginal emerging adults present a somewhat conflicted perspective on organized religion and its role in their lives. On the one hand, they are still connected to organized religion by way of their occasional attendance at religious services. On the other hand, however, their occasional attendance limits the likelihood that they are strongly connected to or identified with these religious organizations. As we might expect, then, their responses to these questions fall in between the Disaffiliated and the Committed. Two-thirds continue to have a lot of respect for organized religion, while only about one-fourth think that it is a big turnoff or irrelevant for most people their age. Moreover, 79 percent said they have positive feelings for the religious tradition they were raised in.

Overall, the young people in the Marginal group are not particularly antagonistic toward organized religion, and in fact seem favorable toward it, although they don’t seem to have any particular need to become more involved in religious institutions. For example, Maria—introduced at the beginning of this section—told us that she could “get by” without religion, as could most young people, but that it was “nice to know that you have something out there other than yourself watching out for you.” For Maria, going to church was, at best, a “slim option” for most young people.

This was a common sentiment among Marginals: while they profess no antagonism toward religious institutions, they simply do not seek, or need, any greater level of participation. A Conservative Protestant man told us, “I don’t believe you have to go to church. You know, I believe Jesus Christ died for my sins, and if you repent, you’ll be forgiven, accepted into heaven.” And a Mainline Protestant woman expressed a common refrain, indicating a residual feeling of obligation that was not sufficiently intense to motivate her to increase her involvement:

I think it’s one of those things where I always say, like, “Well I should probably go to church,” and then I just don’t go. But I don’t feel like it makes me a bad person that I don’t go. And I don’t think that it makes me any less of a religious person that I don’t go. I don’t know. I guess it’s just . . . it’s not like on the top of my list to make sure that I go to church.

However, some Marginals did express their dissatisfaction and disagreement with religious institutions, usually around issues like LGBTQ identity, abortion, and gay marriage. An example of this type of response came from a Catholic woman who told us that, while she agreed with most of what the Catholic Church taught, “There are certain things that they teach that I disagree with. One being the whole gay marriage thing. Another would probably be . . . certain things like birth control, things like that I also disagree with.” This perspective is similar to what we heard from the Disaffiliated, who did not want to be told what to think and believe and how to act by religious institutions or religious authorities. Rather, they seem to want to engage with institutions on their own terms, attend when they feel like it, and believe and act how they see fit, rather than conform to a particular religious tradition or instructions from a formal religious leader.

In sum, Marginal emerging adults occupy the space between the Disaffiliated and the Committed, although they seem to be more like the Disaffiliated in their uncertainty, their difficulty articulating their beliefs, and their lack of any regular spiritual practice. They do, however, place greater importance on faith in their daily lives than do the Disaffiliated.

In this way, Marginals maintain a level of occasional attendance but resist a greater level of commitment. It is unclear whether they continue to attend services because of their commitment to the importance of religion, or if their occasional attendance is what serves to keep religion a presence in their lives. In any case, there seem to be two types of Marginals. The first are those who are simply hanging on with their marginal involvement in the hope that something about religion might prove to be true, perhaps providing answers to questions that they can’t quite articulate, and thus potentially gaining salience in their lives. The second are those like Maria, who appear to be perfectly content to occasionally attend religious services without considering any greater level of commitment, either at church or in their personal practices. For these young people, religion functions as an occasional event and provides a little “something extra” in their lives. But religion does not make great demands of them; rather, it rounds out their lives without making too many waves.

Committed

Amber, a 26-year-old whose father is a pastor in a Pentecostal church, is in many ways a typical Conservative Protestant: she has remained committed to her Christian faith, although she now attends a non-Pentecostal church that emphasizes peace and justice in its theology. She graduated from an evangelical college with a degree in psychology and spent the next year working as a waitress while saving money for a two-year mission trip to Europe, where she worked with young women who had been victims of human trafficking. While on her mission, she maintained a long-distance relationship with her boyfriend, whom she married upon returning to the United States. When we interviewed her, she and her husband had just celebrated their one-year anniversary. She still lives near her hometown, which is also near where she went to college, so she has friends and family in the area. She looks forward to having children and being a stay-at-home mom.

When we interviewed Amber, it became evident that, for her, religion—while important in her life—operated simply as one of her responsibilities and commitments rather than as the core motivating factor in her life. She enjoys singing, so she sings in the worship band at her church. She said that she thinks of Christianity more as a “mindset” than a set of rules and said that she doesn’t feel like her faith is necessarily obvious to others at her work, although she does want to influence them through how she lives her life. Although she attends church regularly, she is somewhat ambivalent about institutionalized religion, believing it to be a mix of good and bad: “When the church organizes, it has incredible potential for good, and when it organizes to just control people or just be greedy with money or whatever, it can be very bad.” She does believe that churches have great potential to solve different social problems, such as hunger, poverty, or human trafficking, if only they “got together and really organized themselves.” But, she added, “most Christians, me included, aren’t doing their jobs.”

As a group, emerging adults we label as Committed are those for whom religion is clearly a part of their lives. By definition, the Committed group includes those who are regularly attending religious services at least two or three times per month. We also see a variety of other ways in which religion plays a role in their lives. What all of the Committed share in common is that they have settled into their religion and appear to be carrying it into adulthood. Through the course of our interviews, however, we came to see that, within this group of young people that we consider to be religiously committed, there are two distinct subgroups.

The first is a smaller group of individuals—like Kristen, whom we met in —for whom faith is a driving force and a central motivator in their daily lives. These are the emerging adults who can clearly articulate what they believe and how those beliefs affect their daily lives, and who are regularly and intentionally involved in religious or spiritual practices. The second and larger group of Committed emerging adults are represented by Amber. These young people seem to have settled into a more routine approach to religion, in which it remains an important part of their lives on one level, yet appears to be just one more regular aspect of their lives, like commuting to work or going to the grocery store. For these young people, religion does not necessarily hold compelling authority in their lives, but rather is part of the larger package of “a good life” and is available for them when it serves to meet particular needs. Thus, in general, not unlike those in the Marginal and Disaffiliated groups (and to a much lesser degree the Not Religious), these Committed emerging adults draw on religion for their own well-being, though it does not make significant demands of them or their time.

In this section we examine the general trends among the Committed emerging adults, while keeping in mind the distinction between the different types of religious commitment we heard among this group.

Beliefs

In many ways, the Committed emerging adults are as we would expect when it comes to their religious beliefs, with most holding to conventional beliefs. Among the Committed, fully 98 percent believe in God, and 83 percent identify God as a personal deity who is involved in peoples’ lives. Not surprisingly, Committed emerging adults are more likely than emerging adults in the other groups to say that they believe in heaven. Conversely, the Committed are less likely to believe that it is okay to pick and choose religious beliefs, or that many religions may be true—although roughly one-third of the Committed do agree with these statements. Yet, in the context of our interviews, it became clear that there is significant variation among Committed emerging adults in how they are able to articulate the particulars of their religious beliefs. In this articulation of beliefs, we see the distinction between the religiously motivated and the religiously routinized.

Amber provides an example of those Committed emerging adults who, on the one hand, are fairly certain of their beliefs, but when asked to tell us what they believe, tended to provide only general statements of belief without too many specifics. When we asked Amber what she believes, she replied, “Well, the Apostles Creed, I basically follow that. That’s the gist of it.” When we asked what she believed about God, she said, “To me God is good. He is compassion. He is all that is beautiful in the world. This sounds really trippy, but [laughs] I don’t know how to put it. He is just. I mean there’s a lot of words. There’s a lot of words. Gracious. Merciful. Lots of things.”

A 28-year-old Catholic woman presented her beliefs with a similarly general description:

i : Do you believe in God?

r : Yeah, absolutely. I believe he created the world. I believe he kind of has our path set for us. I think he does give you free will. That’s the most important thing he gave you, you can make right decisions or you can make wrong decisions. That’s still your decision.

This 25-year-old Unitarian woman is another example of those who provided a generalized description of their beliefs and, like some Marginals, seemed to be struggling to understand the specifics that underlay the generalities:

I believe people have souls, and I think it has to do with the way that we’re—I think it’s people, and the way that we connect to one another and also other living things. But life is really a force, and I think that collective life is—there’s something collective about the way that we are alive together. I think that . . . people have spirit, and there’s something that is what enables us to connect to one another that’s not just, you know, neurons firing in a certain way.

In a similar manner, this 25-year-old Latter-day Saints (LDS) man responded that he believed that life “is a creation. And that it’s just too, it’s too beautiful to be something by accident. And that . . . people do have a spirit about them. I find that some people are more in tune to different . . . feelings, emotions, spirits—stuff like that, rather than others.”

As we noted previously, there are also Committed young people who are able to articulate their beliefs with greater precision. Kristen—mentioned earlier and in —is one of the most fluent about her beliefs among those we interviewed. Here, again, is her immediate response when we asked her to tell us what she believed:

I believe that the Bible is true, that it’s the word of God and it can be proved throughout history to be accurate. I believe that God is the creator. That he made man, that he made the earth, and I believe that God lives in heaven, where it’s the perfect place. Nothing bad happens there, you always have health insurance [laughs], and . . . It’s the perfect place.

She continued:

I believe that God loves us. . . . I believe that there is sin, and I believe that there there’s a payment for that sin. That none of us could pay because no one’s perfect, although we try. So, I believe that God sent his son Jesus, who left his perfect home in heaven to come live here on earth and to pay the result of our sin, because he was perfect. So, I believe that Jesus paid for our penalty by dying on the cross. That he was dead and he rose again three days later. And that when we confess our sins, and that we choose to also believe in God, that he forgives us of our sins and so we have a new identity that once we were dead spiritually but now we’re alive spiritually.

Very few of the Committed emerging adults had as much to say about their beliefs as Kristen, but they still have a firm grasp on what they believe. This 27-year-old Conservative Protestant was not as effusive about his beliefs as Kristen, but his response demonstrates a similar certainty and specificity that was missing in what we heard from the more routinized Committed emerging adults:

I think that there is only one God. There is only Jesus, and he’s the only . . . savior, so that’s how I think that other religions are not true. And so I think that Christianity is the only truth. I believe in the Trinity, and I believe that after you die, you either go to Hell or Heaven, and we’re all going to be judged at one point and that Jesus is, is God. That’s our only savior, true heaven. That’s what I believe.

When we asked the Committed emerging adults to describe their beliefs about life after death, most were certain that there was an afterlife, although some were less certain about heaven and hell and how a person might end up in either place. For example, Amber told us that she believes in life after death, but that she has “no clue” as to what that might actually be. She told us, “I would never presume to say what that’s like. Like, heaven, I don’t think is this place with gold castles in the clouds. I don’t know what it is. I just believe it, but I have no idea what the specifics are, and I’m kind of okay with it.”

A 28-year-old Mormon woman told us that she believes in God and that she believes that “as long as you’re a good person and make good choices, you will go to heaven. And by choices, I mean, like, you don’t rob a bank or not even that because you can repent and be sorry for that. But maybe, like, don’t kill anybody, and be nice [laughs].” A 28-year-old Catholic said that she imagined life after death as a “happy, quiet place that’s very light and with friends and family that I’m no longer with.” She added that she believes in heaven and hell but that “hell is not fire and brimstone, I believe it’s just dark. I believe it’s the absence of love—that’s what I believe in.”

The more religiously motivated Committed emerging adults gave responses that expressed more certainty, along with views about the afterlife that evince a deeper knowledge of their religious traditions. Kristen once again provided a more definitive response, saying, “I believe that there is a heaven and a hell, and that if you die not knowing Jesus, that you will spend eternity in hell. But if you die knowing Jesus, you will spend eternity in heaven.” And this 28-year-old Conservative Protestant said: “I definitely think there’s an afterlife and a heaven for those who have received salvation, and then hell and ultimately the circle of fire after, you know . . . the long haul of the revelation period and all that.”

Thus, religious beliefs among the Committed are fairly conventional, if not always fully in agreement with finer theological points. And, despite the fact that they regularly participate in services at religious institutions, there are distinct differences in their ability to articulate their beliefs. Among those who are more motivated by their faith, we heard clearer and more confident statements of religious belief. By contrast, among the majority of Committed emerging adults for whom religion seems to be more of a routinized component of their lives, we heard more uncertainty, as they were unable or uninterested in clearly articulating specific beliefs. That relatively few of the Committed emerging adults we spoke with were able to clearly articulate their beliefs is something we have seen in each wave of this study, dating back to when they were teenagers. Yet, this inarticulateness does not seem to be specifically related to their age, as some reviewers suggested was the case when our respondents were teens. Rather, as they have grown up, their lack of ability to articulate their beliefs has remained, perhaps because there is no reason for them to have well-articulated beliefs. They have simply accepted their faith as they have experienced it throughout their lives.

Centrality of Faith

For further evidence about the centrality of faith in the lives of Committed emerging adults, we turn to the questions of religious salience. The emerging adults in the Committed group are more likely than those in other groups to say that faith is an important part of their everyday lives. Among the Disaffiliated and Marginal respondents, we saw that religion did not play a central role in their lives, with less than half of respondents identifying faith as very important to them. While they held some religious beliefs and had varying levels of connection to religious practices, religious faith was for the most part just not salient for them. In contrast, Committed emerging adults offer a view of how religion can be a more integral part of one’s life. Eighty-seven percent of the Committed respondents said that faith is very or extremely important in daily life. For the religiously motivated Committed respondents, their religious faith is a core element of who they are and how they live. For example, one 27-year-old man replied, “I think it shapes a lot of my life. I mean the way that I live my life, to interact with other people. Decisions on hobbies and social gatherings . . . just the way that you treat people and your decision-making abilities.” This type of response was most common among the religiously motivated Committed emerging adults. As a 25-year-old Mormon young man told us:

It affects me a lot. It makes me the person I am, a lot of the time people find me to be a little bit different. I don’t swear; some people look at that as odd. I don’t really drink anymore because of that . . . and some things that I do or practice, they find it different. They might not know why I do it, but they do notice it.

A 27-year-old Conservative Protestant woman answered, “How much is it? Pretty much it’s who I am. I mean, I base decisions on my spirituality understanding and religion understanding, so yeah, it’s pretty much who I am, so everything.”

Yet, even as we see religious salience among the Committed in ways that we do not see it among the other groups, it is not universal within this group of young people. While few would deny that religion is important in their lives, our face-to-face conversations reveal variations in what they mean when they say that faith is important. For example, Amber told us that, for her, religion is “central at my core . . . but it’s not central in every single thing I do. I live a pretty normal life, like my coworkers don’t see me as this weird super Christian. I think I’m pretty normal. So it’s central, but it’s also not something that I’m always talking about.” For Amber and other more routinized Committed emerging adults, faith exists as a more mundane part of their lives and is worked into their daily routine as the rest of life permits. Faith is important, but in the sense that it is one of many important factors that make their lives complete, not necessarily the central factor around which their lives revolve. A 28-year-old LDS woman provides an example of how issues of religion and faith are just one part of her family’s life:

I think, I don’t want to say it’s a really big part, like we’re . . . our days are not based on religion, if that makes sense. But it does, it does tend to come up, like over the dinner table or breakfast table or you know, sometimes even while we’re doing our homework or something. Somebody asks a question or something, I guess if that makes sense. Like it’s not like the center of our world.

Similarly, a 28-year-old Conservative Protestant told us that, for him, religion and spirituality were a part of his life “100 percent as much as feasible.” He provided examples of how religion is just one of the routines in his life:

I mean, obviously, you know, sitting through traffic isn’t necessarily a religious or spiritual experience. I mean, it could be if . . . depending on how bad it is [laughs]. But, yeah, I definitely think it’s a part and I think since I work at a private university too that is, you know, Christian-focused . . . it’s just involved I think in my work life as well as my home life.

And this 24-year-old Catholic woman suggested that, even though she was a regular church-attender, religion was a fairly limited part of her life. She said, “I wouldn’t say it’s part of my everyday life. It’s part of, like, my couple days a month life [laughs].”

There is clearly a range of religious salience among the Committed emerging adults that we spoke with. But even among those who do not talk about their faith as central to their daily lives, there is a clear sense that religion and faith have a seat at the table and are a component of their identity, however compartmentalized that might be. This is distinct from even the Marginal emerging adults, for whom religion operates primarily in the background of their lives and is accessed only on demand, should the need or desire arise.

Another measure of religious centrality is how close Committed young people feel to God. While 87 percent reported that faith is very or extremely important in their lives, just 61 percent said that they feel very or extremely close to God. This is higher than other groups by almost double, but a much lower percentage than those who respond similarly about the importance of faith. The contrast between the responses to these two questions is telling. When respondents say that faith is important in their daily lives, this can mean that it is important on an internal emotional level, or at the instrumental level of playing an important role in their identity and the overall function of their lives. In our face-to-face interviews, we heard both types of responses. But asking respondents how close they feel to God taps into a component of religion that might be missed by the importance-of-faith question. This is more specifically a measure of their own felt connection to their faith—the internal emotional component that may or may not be part of the calculation when answering the question about the importance of faith.

Feeling close to God implies not only a connection to faith but also confidence in one’s relationship to the professed faith. So, we find it noteworthy that among the group of our respondents who we label as religiously Committed, less than two-thirds reported feeling very or extremely close to God. While this alone does not tell a complete story, these survey findings lend further support to the notion that religious commitment takes different forms. That there are more Committed young people who profess to the importance of faith than who personally feel a close connection to God suggests that, for at least some of the Committed, the faith that they speak of may be more pragmatic than personal.

In addition to the salience of faith in the daily experience of Committed emerging adults, there is evidence to suggest that religious beliefs and practices will continue to be a core part of their lives—in whatever form it takes—into the foreseeable future. More than half of the Committed reported that they have become more religious over the past five years, while 93 percent reported that they believe they will be attending religious services when they are 35 years old. By their own accounts, then, there is momentum in the direction of continued religious engagement.

Religious and Spiritual Practices

As with each of the other groups discussed in this chapter, among the Committed respondents, prayer was the most commonly mentioned spiritual practice. For the Committed, however, prayer was a much more traditional practice related to the rest of their religious lives than for young people in the other groups. More than 70 percent of Committed emerging adults said they pray at least daily, although again, the particular form of prayer varied. Many have set aside time—whether daily or weekly—to pray, maybe read scriptures, and in general just recalibrate their lives. For a few respondents, prayer is very intentional and scheduled. For example, this 24-year-old Hindu woman detailed her daily prayer regimen:

i : Do you pray?

r : Yeah, I pray three times a day: when I wake up, every time I have a meal, and right before I go to bed.

i : Okay, and what kinds of things do you pray for or about?

r : When I wake up in the morning I pray to God, I thank him for giving me my mind back in the morning, because we believe that when you’re asleep you don’t know, you know, Bob from John, I don’t know that I’m a daughter, I don’t realize that I’m a student. There’s no worries. But as soon as I open my eyes all of that comes back, and I thank God for that. I apologize to Mother Earth for stepping on her throughout the day. And then, when I eat, I thank God for turning the food that I eat, whether it’s good for me or not, into blood that is useful to my body, for providing food that I do have. And then when I go to sleep I thank him for the day that I’ve had, regardless of whether it’s good or not. And again, I apologize for stepping all over Mother Earth throughout the day, or doing anything wrong that I may or may not have realized.

Of course, the particular form and frequency of this young woman’s daily prayers are at least partially linked to her religious tradition. But other Committed emerging adults show a similar commitment to regularly set aside a time of day to pray. For example, a 27-year-old Mainline Protestant told us that he prayed “three times a day. I pray for God’s will to be done, I pray for moral help, I pray for specific life issues, and, you know, job, good place to stay, make a right decision, feel better, be able to help someone, have spiritual gifts, [and] have power to help other people.”

Most, however—like this 28-year-old Conservative Protestant—have a somewhat more flexible version of a regular prayer time:

I probably set aside time for prayer at least once every other day. I’ll do a lot of, like, quick prayers, like while I’m driving or whatever, that’s usually if something pops in my head. I might pray for a friend if I think of something they told me about. But in the other times it’s more prayer over maybe things that are coming up in the week or things that are going on either at work or at home, and kind of realigning myself, just like realigning my spiritual center to get back on track and kind of get rejuvenated for what’s going on.

These responses suggest two types of prayer: regular time set aside for prayer and quick prayers in the midst of other activities. The latter form of prayer is what we heard more commonly from all four groups of emerging adults, including the Committed group. Many Committed respondents framed prayer as more of an ongoing part of their daily lives—a reflex almost—rather than a set-aside time or practice. Similar to the Conservative Protestant man quoted previously, this 28-year-old Catholic said:

I guess it depends. Do I sit down and have, like, long prayers? No, not really . . . probably not too often. But there’s little things throughout the day, you know, like I said, if I’m late to work and the lights are green and, like, just thankful and I’ll be like, “Oh thank you God that everything’s working out well and I’m getting to work on time.” But I don’t, you know, it’s not like a nightly thing where before I go to bed I say prayers.

These responses demonstrate a regular connection to prayer for Committed emerging adults, but it would be a stretch to say that prayer is an intentional spiritual practice in their lives. It would be more apt to say that it seems to be evidence of the general relationship to religion that we have found across each of our groups, where they draw on it for their own well-being, but it makes few demands of them or their time.

Committed respondents also reported other religious and spiritual practices at significantly higher rates than emerging adults in our other groups, such as having read religious or spiritual material in the previous year (58 percent), practicing a weekly day of rest (39 percent), or denying themselves something as a spiritual practice (36 percent). Those in the Committed group also reported religious experiences at much higher rates than other young people, with 77 percent saying that they had experienced an answer to prayer and 63 percent reporting that they had witnessed a miracle sometime in the last five years.

Overall, religious engagement among the Committed emerging adults takes a rather conventional form—in particular, public religious attendance and unstructured, reflexive prayer. We do find that the Committed are much more likely to be engaged in religious practices than their peers, by a significant margin. However, we do not find much evidence that intentional spiritual disciplines are being regularly incorporated into their daily lives.

Attitudes about Organized Religion

Among all of the emerging adults in this study, the Committed have the highest level of respect for organized religion, with 78 percent agreeing that they have a lot of respect. That leaves almost one-fourth of the Committed emerging adults who are at least somewhat disillusioned or otherwise dissatisfied with organized religion—although only 12 and 19 percent, respectively, go so far as to say that they think organized religion is a big turnoff and is irrelevant for most people their age. In comparison to respect for organized religion in general, Committed emerging adults are more positively predisposed to the particular religion in which they were raised, with 88 percent reporting positive feelings toward the religious tradition of their childhood.

When we asked about their feelings toward organized religion and religious institutions, Committed respondents tended to frame their answers from within their own religious traditions and experiences, often noting the limitations of these institutions, despite their overall acceptance of them. For some, similar to Marginals, their reservations about religious institutions centered around issues such as gay marriage or abortion—asserting, for example, their belief that churches or other religious institutions should not be able to tell people whom they can love or marry, or otherwise direct such personal aspects of members’ lives. For example, a 28-year-old Catholic woman said that while she enjoys being Catholic, she thinks that “the Catholic Church is a little outdated, but they have . . . everybody believes in something different. So they have what they believe, whether it’s gay marriage, whether it’s abortion. To me, I don’t think really anybody should be able to tell us who we can and cannot marry, if that’s who makes you happy—that’s who makes you happy.”

Commenting more broadly about problems or scandals in religious institutions, a 24-year-old Catholic man suggested that, when individuals do bad things, the broader institution should not be tainted by their misbehavior:

I mean there’s always going to be controversy of things that swirl around it. [But] I trust mostly because [even though] I have had little bumps in the road about, like, certain priests doing things which aren’t good, but at the end of the day . . . that shouldn’t make me feel less joy when I go to Mass or do anything within the Catholic faith.

A 26-year-old Conservative Protestant woman similarly acknowledged the good and bad inherent in any institution, saying that churches and religion are “a mixture of good and evil,” but also that religious organizations are positive influences in society “that do a lot for a lot of people. There are a lot of churches who have food banks and just even with their offerings and things give to the poor families.”

When asked whether they thought religious institutions contribute anything good or helpful to American society, most Committed emerging adults said that they thought this was true. Some, like this 27-year-old Mormon man, framed their view in religious terms, saying, “I think more people need it right now. I know the trend is kind of declining for . . . at least practicing religion on a regular basis. And I think that’s not going to be good in the future. I think—yeah, I wish it was going the other way.” A 28-year-old Catholic woman answered similarly, saying that she thinks that religious institutions promote unity through their practices: “I believe in the idea of if you pray together, you stay together . . . you know, having some sort of union together, being grateful to something bigger than yourself.”

Other Committed emerging adults framed their positive view of religious institutions in more practical terms related to the different kinds of assistance they provide. A 27-year-old Mormon woman emphasized the kinds of assistance that the LDS church is known for, such as responding to natural disasters, saying, “They do a lot of good . . . when natural disasters happen. Different things like that. Funding to help them, you know, with the tornados or with tsunamis that come up. I feel like churches are also ready to step in and help out.” And a 28-year-old Conservative Protestant man asserted that, in his view, “churches do good deeds,” giving the example of a program in his city where local religious groups come together to serve the city.

Religion—whether measured by attendance at religious services, religious beliefs, or different religious and spiritual practices—is much more a part of the lives of Committed emerging adults than any of the other groups discussed in this chapter. But there also appears to be a divide within this group. There are some for whom religion is the key motivating factor in their lives, driving their decisions and life choices. For many others, there is a clear commitment to religion and its importance in their lives, but it takes a different role. For these religiously Committed young people, religion takes a seat at the table of their lives. It connects with other parts of life in a supportive fashion, though it does not take over or dominate the whole; religion is always there and can be called on in a crisis to offer additional support without dominating all aspects of their lives. Religion is very much a part of the experience of the group of young people we call Committed. But in reality, only a small subset of these emerging adults are motivated by or particularly enthusiastic about its presence in their lives.

Excursus: Spiritual but Not Religious

Much has been made over the last several years about the apparent rise in individuals who describe themselves as “spiritual but not religious,” particularly in relation to the increase in numbers of those who claim no religious affiliation. This idea, while present in each of the four groups of emerging adults that we’ve been discussing in this chapter, is not a particularly prevalent or important part of how emerging adults are thinking about their religious and spiritual lives, regardless of where they are placed within our four groups. Yet, owing to the prevalence of this theme in both academic literature and popular media, it is worth taking a look to see how emerging adults think about the phrase “spiritual but not religious.”

At its core, the notion of spiritual but not religious emerging adults is intended to evoke the idea that, although the individuals are not affiliated with any religious organization or particular faith tradition, they maintain some sort of inner spiritual life in which they contemplate their own existence and the possibility of the sacred or divine. Thus, the concept of spiritual but not religious brings to mind images of spiritual seekers engaging in intentional sacred practices such as meditation or prayer as well as personal experiences that are interpreted as mystical or spiritual in nature. Recent research, however, indicates that identifying as spiritual but not religious takes on a variety of meanings for individuals, many of which are not consistent with this popular image of the spiritual seeker. We find further evidence of this in our in-person interviews with the young people in our study.

We first asked these young people as teenagers if they had ever heard the phrase “spiritual but not religious.” At that time, the overwhelming response was that they were unfamiliar with the idea. Only eight percent of Wave 1 survey respondents said that it was very true that the term “spiritual but not religious” described them. Our follow-up in-person interviews suggested that, of this eight percent, many were actually Conservative Protestants who used the term to refer to their personal relationship with Jesus (in contrast with rote religion), and their use of this term did not signify a rejection of traditional religion or an embrace of alternative spirituality.

Now in their 20s, the emerging adults in our study seem to have a better understanding of what that phrase might mean. The percentage of our respondents who said that the term “spiritual but not religious” is a very true description of themselves, while still not large, did increase from eight percent in Wave 1 to 17 percent in Wave 4. As expected, the emerging adults in the Committed group are the least likely to identify as spiritual but not religious—10 percent said it is very true—while the differences across the other three groups are minimal, ranging from 17 to 21 percent.

While more emerging adults now identify spiritual but not religious as a true description of themselves, their responses in follow-up interviews still don’t fall into the categories that we might expect, given the existing literature and how this terminology has become understood in more popular explanations. Among the Not Religious, Disaffiliated, and Marginal, we heard very similar variations of two themes when it came to discussions about “spiritual but not religious” and whether that term accurately described their views. The first type of response was from emerging adults who did identify as being spiritual but not religious. They explained that, for them, it meant that they believed in God or some higher power. However, being spiritual but not religious was generally unrelated to any specific spiritual practices such as prayer, meditation, reading sacred texts or other religious material, or even a more general effort to seek out deeper meaning in their lives. Certainly there were those who, for example, said that they prayed; but in general, there was no significant or regularly pursued form of spiritual or religious practice associated with this concept.

For example, a 25-year-old man who identified as Not Religious responded, “I guess it depends on how you describe spiritual—like do I pray, or have crosses in my house? No. Do I believe in a higher power? I guess if that’s spirituality versus religious, then yes.”

In some of these cases, like this young man, emerging adults agree that they are spiritual but not religious, yet seem almost to be talking themselves into this identity as a response to our questions. This 28-year-old Disaffiliated woman seemed to come to her conclusion in the process of providing her response:

I believe, definitely. I believe in certain things. I believe in the religious aspect, like, what they say is right and wrong. I agree with it. And I agree that there is God and I agree with all that stuff, but I’m not religious to the point where I go to church and I do those kind of things. So yeah, I guess the spiritual but not religious kinda makes sense.

Similarly, this 27-year-old Catholic woman works through her answer to conclude that she is spiritual, and this is largely attributed to her belief in a higher power:

r : I’m not religious. And I guess . . . a little bit spiritual.

i : You said you maybe consider yourself a little bit spiritual. What does that mean?

r : I believe in God. I believe in a higher power, but I don’t necessarily believe in all the doctrine, the teachings of the Catholic church. I guess I’m spiritual and that I believe in a higher power, but not religious in the sense that I am not a practicing Catholic or practicing anything else.

For these emerging adults who agreed that they were spiritual but not religious, the term may not have immediately resonated, but on further consideration, they were able to find themselves in the concept, seeing how they could maintain the connection to spirituality without the connection to religion. It is our sense that the spiritual but not religious identity among these emerging adults is often more a case of trying on the term to see if it fits, rather than a clear identity that they held before our conversation with them.

A second theme that we heard across all four groups of emerging adults was skepticism about the whole idea of spiritual but not religious. For these young people, claiming to be spiritual but not religious sounded like a dubious notion at best and, at worst, was an identity that had no substantive meaning. One young man from the Marginal group told us that the phrase “sounds like a Miss America answer” and added that, in his view, “Spiritual and not religious is usually what people say to get out of having these conversations revolving around the idea of religion.” Similarly, a Not Religious woman expressed a bit of contempt for the term, considering it a meaningless concept:

I can’t stand that spiritual thing. What does that even mean? That’s a non-answer to me. So no, I don’t consider myself spiritual or religious. I believe in God, which is something to me completely different, because when you put the word religious, when you attach that to it, it means that man has been involved and put his two cents in.

Among the Committed emerging adults, skepticism often took the form of finding the whole concept illogical. These young people either struggled to understand the idea or said that they were both spiritual and religious and that they couldn’t see how one could exist without the other. A 26-year-old Mainline Protestant man said, “I consider myself to be both,” while a 25-year-old LDS man replied, “I don’t know the difference between the two, so I wouldn’t be able to answer it honestly.” When we asked Kristen if she would consider herself to be spiritual but not religious, she said:

I still don’t really grasp the entire concept of that, so no, but I also wouldn’t ever describe myself as religious and not spiritual. I would never say, “Hey, I’m religious.” Like if someone said, “What are you?” I wouldn’t say I’m religious, or if someone said, “What are you?” I wouldn’t say I’m spiritual. I’d say I’m a Christian.

Across all four of the religious groups we have examined in this chapter, we find that spiritual but not religious is not an identity that is deeply held by many emerging adults. More of them are familiar with the term than in the past, and some are able to articulate how it might be an apt description of their own faith or worldview. But even when this is the case, their assent to the description is typically limited in scope to a belief in a higher power and does not encompass a wider ranging impulse toward spiritual seeking. With the decline of traditional measures of religion, the notion of young people embracing spirituality instead of organized religion has taken hold in the popular imagination. On the ground, however, spiritual but not religious does not seem to be a concept that is particularly meaningful for this group of emerging adults.

Conclusion

Any attempt to summarize the religious lives of a group of people will inevitably bump up against limitations and challenges. This chapter is no exception. There are many different ways to conceptualize and describe the lived religious lives of young people. However, in examining these young people through the lens of the Not Religious, Disaffiliated, Marginal, and Committed groups, we have arrived at a few general themes that help us to understand the changing role of religion in the lives of emerging adults.

Divergence

If we take a step back, what is the big-picture story here? In , we provided evidence of an overall religious decline and a general move away from organized religion. Yet, we also saw some evidence of polarization or divergence, with groups like the LDS and Conservative Protestants showing somewhat higher levels of commitment among their remaining adherents—while, at the same time, larger numbers of young people are identifying as not religious. Now in their mid to late 20s, our respondents seem to be settling into these religious identities. Among our sample, there was not much in the way of direct and adamant opposition to religion. Rather, young people are just not particularly interested in religion, and it does not seem particularly relevant to their lives. Of course, this is especially true among the Not Religious and the Disaffiliated, and this trend is evident within the Marginal group as well. But we also hear the echoes of this sentiment among those Committed emerging adults who have adopted the more routinized version of regular religious engagement.

As we saw in and in this chapter, attendance is waning among emerging adults. On the one hand, this signals a movement away from organized religion. Another interpretation of this is that attendance at religious services has become much more voluntary. As young people get older, they become more independent from the religious expectations of families, and they are coming of age at a time when being not religious is more socially acceptable than it has been in recent memory. Whatever the reason, they feel freer to elect not to attend religious services.

If this is the case, the reverse is also true: those who are attending religious services are likely there of their own choosing. When attendance becomes more voluntary and less normative, those who are truly committed will continue, and the less committed will be more likely to drift away. Thus, while attendance at religious services may be lower, it may carry more meaning regarding the religious commitment of the attendees.

We see some evidence for this in the increasing connection between religious service attendance and the reported importance of faith in daily life. One measures public religious practice, the other private religious salience. Over the 10 years of this study, the correlation between attendance and importance of faith has gotten stronger at each time point. At Wave 1, the two variables were correlated with a Pearson’s r of 0.49. This increased to 0.59 at Wave 2, 0.62 at Wave 3, and finally by Wave 4 the correlation between public and private religiosity was 0.68. The increasing strength of the correlation shows that, as young people get older, their public religious practice comes more in line with their personal religious salience.

This alignment happens at both ends of the spectrum, with those who say faith is not important no longer attending religious services, and those for whom faith is very important maintaining their religious service attendance at much higher rates than others. As we saw in , there seems to be a hollowing out of the religious middle, with growing numbers of Not Religious and a smaller but still present group for whom religion is a fixture in their lives.

Liminality

Another theme that arises from our assessment of these four groups of young people is that of liminality—of being in between. The Marginal and Disaffiliated groups each represent different versions of this in-betweenness. The Disaffiliated emerging adults occupy the liminal ground of maintaining some semblance of religious identity but having little if any meaningful connection to religious community or practice. They embody the uncertainty of those who, for all practical purposes, are ready to abandon religion, but their lingering doubts about the possibility of religious truth keep them from cutting the cord entirely. The Marginal emerging adults operate in their own version of uncertainty. They maintain some level of religious connection, but it is on their own terms and to their own ends. However, they seem somewhat uncertain about the deal they have struck. If there really is something to religion, they wonder if perhaps they should be more involved. But why do they continue to hang on if they can’t really articulate how or why religion is relevant to their lives?

Their existence in this liminal space raises the question of their life-history trajectories. Will they make their home in this liminal space, or are they moving in one direction or the other? Consistent with the idea of a liminal space, these emerging adults could conceivably go either way—toward more involvement or toward less involvement. In other words, their liminal status could be the last way station on their journey completely out of religious involvement, or they could find a way back in. Given the very tenuous hold many emerging adults have on their religious faith, it is hard to imagine that they would return to religion in any significant or widespread way. Looking back over the previous survey data, it appears that those who occupied the liminal space at Wave 3 have moved into the Not Religious space by Wave 4. If this is any indication, we might interpret this in-between space as just a point on a trajectory leading away from religion among emerging adults.

It is also possible that this liminal space might be the new religious or spiritual location for emerging adults. It doesn’t take a lot (if any) sort of commitment because whatever religiosity they evince is all on their terms, and they can increase or decrease their involvement as life situations change. As we saw with Maria, it might be that this existence fulfills whatever needs they have and thus suits them just fine. And, in fact, the next theme we discuss would fit well within this narrative.

Hanging On

Despite the general move away from organized religion, there remains among emerging adults a basic set of beliefs and practices that suggest that they are maintaining at least the possibility that there is “something else”—that is, something more than just secular or material life. Yet, even while they leave such a possibility open, this should not be interpreted to mean they are thinking long and hard about it. Overall, with the exception of the most religiously engaged, religion does not have a particularly important role in the lives of emerging adults; it is more of a constant but unremarkable presence.

As such, religion remains a theoretical or abstract option for them, but it just doesn’t have the pull or attraction to really grab their attention as something to which they would fully commit. Many want to hang on to some form of supernatural or mystical belief. But even while they are hanging on, what they are hanging on to is taking on a more symbolic quality. One example would be those who continue to engage in prayer but acknowledge that they think of prayer as a way of talking out problems or connecting with others, rather than an active attempt at communicating with God.

Another example is the difference we see between believing that a divine being exists and professing belief in that divine being as salient to one’s own life. This was illustrated earlier in this chapter by the Disaffiliated woman who said, “I believe that there is a God, I don’t know if there’s a specific one God.” While these young people may be hanging on to general beliefs about religious propositions, this does not necessarily translate to embracing particular religious beliefs in their own lives.

The maintenance of some semblance of religious belief and practice suggests that they want to hang on to the possibility of religious reality, even if it is strictly on their terms. Perhaps this draws on the cultural impulse of tolerance and open-mindedness—not wanting to definitively say religion has no place in the world. But for all practical purposes, there is very little agentic impulse, particularly among the Not Religious and the Disaffiliated, to explore this possibility, and very little expectation that religion will ever be significant in their own lives again. They do have agency to choose the important elements in their lives, and religion is further down the list than other things like family, romantic relationships, and friends.

Throughout this chapter, we have explored the contours of the current religious lives of the emerging adults in our study. In , we widen our lens to consider the different pathways by which these emerging adults arrived at different places of religious engagement or disengagement. Looking across the full scope of the National Study of Youth and Religion, we map out the most common religious trajectories from adolescence to emerging adulthood as well as the factors associated with each of these trajectories.

Tables

Table 4.5 Beliefs about God

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Belief in God

No

31

2

2

1

12

Yes

39

89

89

98

74

Unsure

30

9

9

1

14

Views of God

A personal being

16

52

66

83

51

Uninvolved creator

5

6

5

3

4

Cosmic force

21

18

8

3

13

None of these views

27

22

19

9

20

Does not believe in  God

31

2

2

1

12

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.6 Belief in Heaven

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

No

40

4

5

2

16

Yes

32

80

81

94

67

Unsure

28

16

14

4

17

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.7 Beliefs about Religious Exclusivity

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Truth in Religion

Only one religion is true

5

21

27

61

27

Many religions may be true

54

73

67

37

55

Very little truth in any religion

41

7

6

2

17

Okay to pick and choose religious beliefs without having to accept teachings of faith as a whole

Disagree

31

35

49

71

46

Agree

69

65

51

29

54

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.8 Centrality of Faith

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Importance of Faith in Daily Life

Not at all important

56

8

3

0

22

Very unimportant

15

15

4

1

9

Somewhat important

25

51

48

11

31

Very important

3

17

28

31

18

Extremely important

2

9

17

56

21

Feeling Distant or Close to God

Extremely close

4

8

10

18

10

Very close

5

19

22

43

21

Somewhat close

16

34

41

29

28

Somewhat distant

12

22

18

7

14

Very distant

7

8

4

1

5

Extremely distant

6

4

1

0

3

Does not believe in  God

50

5

4

2

20

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.9 Past and Future Religion

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Self-reported religious change over past 5 years

Became more religious

7

12

27

54

25

Became less religious

28

25

17

6

19

Stayed about the same

65

63

57

40

56

Plans to attend church at age 35

No

61

11

6

0

24

Maybe

34

61

34

6

31

Yes

5

27

61

93

45

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.10 Religious Practices and Experiences

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

In the past 12 months, respondent:

Practiced religious or spiritual meditation

19

15

15

19

17

Read religious or spiritual book other than the scriptures

12

17

26

64

30

Tried to practice a weekly day of rest or Sabbath

3

6

11

41

15

Fasted or denied self something as a spiritual discipline

4

11

15

37

16

Witnessed a miracle in the past five years

Yes

14

33

44

63

37

Maybe

12

20

17

17

16

No

73

47

39

20

47

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.11 Prayer

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Frequency of praying alone

Multiple times a day

3

8

18

44

18

About once a day

4

18

20

27

16

A few times a week

7

19

23

16

15

About once a week

4

8

8

5

6

One to two times a month

7

15

12

4

9

Less than once a month

14

16

13

3

11

Never

61

15

6

1

25

Experienced answer to prayer or guidance from God in the past five years

Yes

16

39

52

81

45

Maybe

15

24

23

13

18

No

69

36

26

6

37

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.12 Attitudes about Organized Religion

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

I have a lot of respect for organized religion in this country

Strongly agree / agree

25

57

67

78

54

Don’t know / unsure

12

14

14

10

12

Strongly disagree / disagree

63

29

19

12

34

I have very positive feelings about the religious tradition in which I was raised

Strongly agree / agree

28

71

79

88

62

Don’t know / unsure

17

12

8

3

10

Strongly disagree / disagree

27

15

9

4

15

Does not apply

22

4

3

3

10

Most mainstream religion is irrelevant to the needs and concerns of most people my age

Strongly agree / agree

50

33

28

19

34

Don’t know / unsure

24

19

17

12

18

Strongly disagree / disagree

27

48

54

69

48

Organized religion is usually a big turnoff for me

Strongly agree / agree

72

36

20

12

38

Don’t know / unsure

9

9

14

9

10

Strongly disagree / disagree

20

55

67

79

52

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Table 4.13 Spiritual but Not Religious

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Very true

21

20

17

10

17

Somewhat true

44

52

50

36

44

Not true at all

35

28

34

54

39

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

↑ Back to top

↑