1. The Teens from Soul Searching 10 Years Later
sitting across from me in the crowded Starbucks was a mature, self-assured young woman. Newly married and heading to graduate school in the fall, Melody was happy with the way her life was going and optimistic about her future. As we talked, I felt something like pride as I recalled our first conversation and thought about how far she had come since then. At 15, Melody was thoughtful and mature for her age. But she was clearly struggling to figure out her own identity, differentiating herself from her straight-laced twin sister, trying to balance her impulse toward a counter-cultural identity with her desire to fit in and belong. In the coming years, through follow-up interviews, I saw her grow and mature, wrestle with significant hardships, and come out on the other side confident in her own identity and place in the world. While we had just a handful of interactions spread out over ten years, I was grateful for the opportunity to see glimpses of her life as it unfolded.
Melody’s story is but one of many that we were able to follow over a full decade. Unfortunately, we can’t provide updates on all of the young people that were profiled as teens because some of them dropped out of our study. But most of them continued to participate. In what follows, we catch up with several of the people whose stories have featured prominently in previous installments.
Joy
Joy’s life is characterized by resilience in the face of a lifetime of challenges and hardships. When we first met Joy in the summer of 2003, she was 16 years old. She was depressed, doing drugs and drinking a lot of alcohol, and seeking sex with much older men—behaviors that stemmed, in part, from her difficult relationship with her parents. In many ways, she seemed adrift both from any positive relationships with mature and healthy adults and from the Baptist faith in which she was raised.
The second time Joy was interviewed, in 2005, her life had improved somewhat. She had graduated from high school, moved in with her boyfriend, and become pregnant. However, her boyfriend grew distant during her pregnancy and ended up cheating on her with one of her friends, which led to the end of their relationship. Yet, having her baby had a significant effect on her life. She quit smoking and drinking and started to think more about her future, not just the present.
When Joy was interviewed for the third time in 2008, she was 21 years old, and she seemed like a very different person than the teenager who had been interviewed twice before. She was living with her fiancé, Matt, who genuinely cared for her and her baby girl. Joy also reported that in the time between the first and second interviews, she had been placed in foster care a few times and that her foster mother had been an important and caring figure in her life, providing the kind of positive support that she needed and desired but hadn’t received from her own mother. And, as a result of attending a Christian teen rally led by a visiting youth evangelist, she had rededicated her life to God and started attending church regularly with her parents and her fiancé.
When we caught up with Joy for our final interview, she and Matt were married and living together with their three children (Joy’s daughter, Matt’s son from a previous relationship, and a boy they had together) in a double-wide trailer home in a rural, mountainous area in the South. Joy arrived at the interview late—she had overslept—but we were able to conduct the interview at a local restaurant over breakfast. When she arrived, she was wearing a black T-shirt and jeans and had the names of her three children, along with a few butterflies, in a tattoo “sleeve” up her left arm.
As we started the interview, Joy reported that she was slowly rebuilding her life after having a rough time of it over the previous five years. She had given birth to her third child on the side of the road, had several complications, and as a result became addicted to painkillers. She struggled through postpartum depression and post-traumatic stress disorder and had twice checked herself into a psych ward for suicide watch. After being arrested at Walmart for shoplifting—she said that she had been so strung out on pain medication she didn’t really know what she was doing—she decided to go to a detox center. Since then, she had relapsed once, but she reported being clean for the past two to three years. Marriage is a struggle; she reported that she and Matt got married before she was sober, and now she feels like she has no idea who she married. They have some problems to work through. Joy said she considers herself to be an adult, “sadly.” When we asked why sadly, she said, “I don’t know. It’d be great if I could be a kid again.” For Joy, “work and kids, you know, real life” are the main things that make her consider herself to be an adult.
Joy appears to be handling the pressures of her adult life relatively alone. Of all the potential supportive older adults in her life, she feels closest to her mother-in-law, who was a teacher for twenty years and has “tons of experience, she raised two kids herself . . . she is very practical and upfront. She will tell you whether you’re doing right or wrong, and it helps.” As for her own mom, Joy said, “I love my mom, I do my best to take care of her, but as far as being able to talk to her or discuss anything, no.”
Two other adult relationships have significantly shaped her life and the trajectory of her faith. At the time of the third interview, Joy identified her foster mother as her main parental figure and a significant positive influence on her life. Her foster mother lives nearby, and Joy had maintained a close relationship with her over the years. However, when we spoke this last time, the two of them had experienced a major falling out. After a period of sobriety following Joy’s addiction, her foster mother tried to gain custody of Joy’s children, claiming Joy was not a good mother. At the time, Joy and her foster mother had been going to the same church, but after this incident, Joy stopped going to church and really questioned her faith. She believed that her foster mom (and others in the church) were “hypocrites,” and she was unable to reconcile their professed beliefs with the way they had acted toward her.
When we asked whether Joy considered herself a religious person or not, she replied, “I am, but I don’t go to church. I mean, I would go to church, but there’s too many hypocrites.” She said that she would go to another church “far, far away, but I can’t afford it.” Joy had been involved in church and had been baptized. But after the falling-out with her foster mother, Joy said she “just kind of gave up, after all that happened. I’m like, you know what, forget it. I can read the Bible if I want to here at home. I’m not going out there for them to say, ‘Oh there she is, still learning how to take care of her kids.’ ”
During the course of the interview, Joy also revealed for the first time that her stepfather, who was similarly very involved in his church, had molested her from the time she was 10 years old to age 13. He had passed away just a month before we met, and she cried when talking about him. Joy had been his primary caregiver before his death and felt close to him at the end of his life. “I have forgiven him,” she said, “I had to move past it because if I didn’t, I’d never, you know, be okay. It was me that was suffering and not him.”
Although she had forgiven him personally, the impact on her life remained, causing her to question the whole idea of God, religion, and church. She told us, “That’s the thing about my stepdad, too. I was always iffy about churches because he went to church and he was like one of the best members of the church, yet nobody knew what had happened behind the scenes.” She continued, “It really let me down, like I said and, you know at that time, I didn’t know what hypocrite meant [laughs], and . . . you know, it did upset me a lot, though, knowing what was going on. . . . I still went to church, I still believed in God, but I did feel like, you know, during my teenage years like where the hell were you at? You know? With God, it really made me question my faith.”
Joy described her religious life this way: “I mean, I’m not a real big Christian fanatic, I believe in what’s right and wrong.” Joy believes in God and that Jesus was “God’s son, he was born, resurrected and died for our sins, so on and so forth. . . . He’s the only one that would ever be perfect.”
She also believes “in heaven and hell. I believe in angels, demons, the devil . . . pretty much everything I was raised on, I guess.” What she was raised on came from the local Baptist church. Joy does not have any particular affinity for the Baptist denomination and is open to attending different churches, but she still identifies as Baptist and has never considered changing her affiliation.
We also asked Joy about her private religious practices. “I do pray,” she said. “When I was younger I used to only pray when good things happened and thank God, and I felt bad if I prayed for stuff, I know that sounds weird, it felt bad to pray for help.” This reluctance to bring her needs into her prayer life has shifted now that she is older. Joy said she prays “when I need to, basically. I have some things going on that desperately, I do need help. And then we do pray at supper time, because we’re all there at supper and we do have our family time at supper and we all pray. That’s probably the only time I really pray.” When asked whether she reads the Bible, she laughed and said, “every once in a blue moon.”
Joy said that she feels close to God “at times,” and this is “relieving and calming” for her. But she also struggles with doubts. When asked whether she has more or less doubts about God now than in the past, Joy paused for a long time, let out a sigh, and then said, “More, I guess? . . . I don’t know, it’s a mixture because, you know at first, when I quit going to church . . . I had a lot more doubts about it because of everything that happened there.” Asked how hard or easy has it been to maintain her faith in recent years, Joy responded:
I questioned it, so it’s been kind of hard. Not necessarily questioning faith, I didn’t mean it that way; I mean, it’s just the whole “why do you let people in your church that are gonna act like this.” It’s not fair, it’s criticizing, but . . . you know, I just don’t think it’s fair, and sometimes I don’t understand why God lets it go on. [Do you see it getting easier in the future?] Yeah. I hope so. I pray [laughs].
Joy told us that she believes only one religion is true and that she knows what is true or untrue religiously because of what the Bible says. However, when it comes to her own life and how she knows or decides what is right or wrong, she said, “I . . . subconscious and experience. Like if I have a bad feeling about it . . . a gut feeling, subconscious, yeah, I will usually make a decision from there whether I think it’s good or bad, and I’m not gonna do it if it’s bad. . . . And experience, you know, like, [I’ve] already been through it or something similar, so I can use that as an example and go from there.”
When asked how easy or hard it is to decide between right or wrong, Joy said, “Pretty easy. I mean, unless it was like an extremely difficult decision, it’s pretty simple for me. I don’t have to think long and hard about it. I used to, ‘cause like: ‘Man, maybe I should; man, maybe I shouldn’t.’ No, now it’s like—that’s wrong, and I know what should be right and what should be wrong, you know? So it’s not really difficult.”
When we asked Joy whether she felt she had a purpose in life, she told us that she thinks she is supposed to help other people and that this is her goal in life: “When I help other people, it gives me a sense of importance, and it makes me feel so much better that I’ve helped somebody.” Right now, Joy feels like she is living out this purpose with her kids, and she said she is happy being a stay-at-home mom. However, she hopes to become a certified nursing assistant and sees her future career as a way to live out her purpose. “I love being at home, but you know, sometimes you have to have a break from three kids.” She thinks of work not only as an opportunity to help others but also as a part of being a good parent. Going to work “is kind of your escape, even though it’s work, it’s a different environment, and you come back home and it’s okay.”
Looking to the future, Joy said that what she really wants to get out of life is to “be happy and to be—I mean my biggest thing is to be happy and to be financially stable. You know, and not have stress constantly.” More than anything, she said she values family. But she also places a high value on being treated fairly. She said, “I don’t necessarily value money or anything. I’m really big on—like I said, I want to make sure everyone’s treated fairly and equally. And I try to teach my kids that, too.” Reflecting back on the events of her life, we asked whether she would do anything differently in her life if she could. Joy told us that there was nothing she would change:
Everything that I’ve done, everything that I’ve been through, everything—the way I see it, if I hadn’t been through it, I wouldn’t be the person I am today. You have to live, and a lot of times, you have to learn the hard way, and I really am happy with the attitude and temperament and all that I do have today. And . . . life lessons. I mean, you either learn, or they make you or break you, is the way I feel about it. So, yeah . . . basically, if it weren’t for bad luck, we would have no luck at all, usually.
Joy has had a lot of ups and downs in her 27 years of life. Yet, despite her difficulties, she has a remarkably positive attitude about her current and future prospects. Most of the adults in her life have let her down or hurt her, but she seems to have been able to learn from those difficulties and is figuring out how to be a positive force in her kids’ lives, even as she continues to work on her own life.
Kristen
Like Joy, Kristen encountered difficulties early in her life. Her parents separated when she was very young. When she was six years old, Kristen, along with her mother and siblings, found her father shortly after he had taken his own life. Yet Kristen’s life has taken a much different path than Joy’s. When raising Kristen and her siblings, her mother relied heavily on her evangelical Christian faith. They were deeply involved in their church, and eventually Kristen’s mother married a widower who shared a commitment to her faith. In each of the four interviews with Kristen, she has remained consistent in her outlook on life: a happy teen, and now a happy and seemingly well-adjusted emerging adult who is committed to and knowledgeable about her faith. Kristen is a well-rounded, socially involved, outgoing young woman.
When we interviewed Kristen for the final time in 2013, she told us that she had graduated from her Christian college in December 2009 and then went on a four-month-long mission trip to the Middle East. When she returned to the States, she enrolled in a master’s degree program in “worship studies” at an East Coast seminary. She expected the program to be oriented toward music performance, one of her passions. However, she instead found herself spending most of her time in libraries and writing papers, which she said allowed her to “stretch” into an area where she was less comfortable. After getting her master’s degree in 2012, she joined a group from the church she was then attending to plant a new church in a large city in the desert Southwest. At the time of our interview, she was renting a room in the home that the pastor of the church lived in with his wife and kids. She said that she appreciated being able to have a close relationship with the wife and to watch how her hosts interact as a married couple. Kristen had recently become engaged to a young man who was also a member of the church-planting staff. He, too, had been a student at her seminary, although she said she had not known him well there.
Kristen is 26 years old, is very outgoing and gregarious, and laughed a lot throughout our interview. Looking back at her three previous interviews, her life is incredibly consistent, in both the kinds of relationships she values and maintains with her parents and other adults in her life and how she understands the world as a committed young Christian woman. She said that she is very close to her parents, but since she graduated from college, their relationship has changed somewhat: “In college, when I’m walking to class, there’s a lot of dead time, I called my mom a lot. So, I would say that I probably talked to her, in a healthy way, like probably every day if she was available. And now I don’t talk to her every day, but she still knows what’s going on in my life, or if I have questions, I call them and ask them.”
She said that her fiancé is her best friend and she spends most of her time with him. Given the time commitment her church activities require, her primary friend group right now is made up of others who are also involved with her church. However, she still remains in touch with her friends from home, college, and seminary. Religion is a frequent topic of conversation with all of her friends. And, even when she meets new people, issues of faith “just really easily come up in the conversation.” Kristen’s faith is a central part her daily life and interactions in a way that is not typical of most of the emerging adults we spoke with.
Kristen thinks that the biggest challenge facing young people is one of identity and said, “A lot of people my age have come from, ‘I grew up this way and now I don’t really know who I am and . . . I’m still trying to figure out my identity and like what suits me.’ ” Kristen, however, is confident in her identity. She said:
I know that I believe that God created me, and so he made who I am. So, finding out who I am is really based on who he is, and so a lot of my identity comes from that. Like, I’m a child of God, I’m a daughter . . . in Christ I’m forgiven, like I’m free in that. And, so, there’s identity there that speaks into the rest of my life, and so that’s where I have found my identity.
Kristen said her faith is “part of who I am, so it affects how I think and what I do, and so in that way, it’s part of everyday life.” She continued, “What I believe and know to be true affects the way I live. It affects my actions, it affects my thoughts, it affects my attitudes, it affects the way that I deal with situations. It affects the way that I go to events.”
Her perspective on morals—knowing right from wrong and doing the right thing—also stems from her religious identity. According to Kristen, striving for moral uprightness is just a part of who she is:
It’s not like when every decision comes, “Well, is this good or bad, right or wrong?” It’s a lot a part of, like, who I am, and . . . what I’ve learned from church and the Bible and from God, and so it’s not necessarily like, “Oh, okay, so I have a decision, which one is right?” It usually is evident just because of who I am, but who I am is not because of me.
This ingrained moral compass is a result of the influence of her parents, other adults, her church, her friends, and, ultimately, her relationship with God. She believes that there is definitely right and wrong in the world and, for her, that boils down to “the general principle that it’s wrong to be selfish.” We asked her to explain what she meant, and she replied, “I think Christianity’s the opposite of that, where it’s very selfless. I think that’s the portrayal of Christ: very selfless, and so the opposite of that—selfish. I mean, murder is very selfish . . . speaking poorly about someone else is very selfish . . . greedy, being greedy. Greed is very selfish. I think that abortion is very selfish.”
Kristen believes that not being selfish is a core principle from which one can reason out and think about all moral decisions. “I mean if what people desire is love, like, love isn’t selfish, and so I would say that’s what . . . if people are striving for . . . no matter who you talk to, everyone wants to be loved. They want to feel connected with someone whether they believe in God or not. So, if we’re striving towards love, then selfishness is a standard of wrong.”
As should be clear from Kristen’s responses to our questions, her faith is an integral part of her life, shaping who she is. But it is also—owing at least in part to her role in her church— the focus of much of her activities. Kristen spends most of her time with the other church staff, doing community work and holding worship services on Sundays. They also meet together for an hour and a half each morning for prayer and Bible reading. She said that for her, prayer is “talking to God”:
[Prayer] comes out of whatever we read in scripture, and like whatever I’ve read. So, thanking him for whatever that is and praising him for who he is, for what he’s done in general and then also in my life. And then also asking him, like, “God, you know me, and you see these things in my life, and I’m terrified of this and please give me clarity on this.” So, a lot of asking for myself, and asking for other people. Like, “God, my sister, she is hurting, like, please show her love today, or send people in her life to just blow her away at your love.” So, those things.
We asked Kristen to describe her religious beliefs, and she had a ready answer:
I believe that the Bible is true, that it’s the word of God and it can be proven throughout history to be accurate. I believe that God is the creator. That he made man, that he made the Earth, and I believe that God lives in heaven, where it’s the perfect place. I believe that God loves us. . . . I believe that there is sin, and . . . I believe that there’s a payment for that sin that none of us could pay because no one’s perfect, although we try. So, I believe that God sent his son Jesus, who left his perfect home in heaven to come live here on Earth and to pay the result of our sin because he was perfect. So, I believe that Jesus paid for our penalty by dying on the cross. That he was dead and he rose again three days later. And that when we confess our sins, and that we choose to also believe in God, that he forgives us of our sins, and so we have a new identity that once we were dead spiritually but now we’re alive spiritually. That’s it.
Kristen said that she’s “very happy” with how her life is going. When we asked why, she replied, “I’m happy because I know that I am where I’m supposed to be. I think that my purpose is to love God and love other people and to tell them about God.” She said that the most important thing in life for her, aside from God, is people. “I think people are what matter. Things, they’re all good, they can burn out, but people.”
As we were winding up the interview, we asked Kristen what would count for her as having lived a good life. She said, “Being obedient to what I know is true and . . . becoming more selfless and loving. If I go to my grave being selfish, I would be very disappointed.” Overall, success and happiness in her life will mean that she is “a part of people’s lives. I want to make a difference in people’s lives . . . with how the Lord has made a difference in mine, and love people and be generous. I want to be obedient to what the Lord has given me in my life and teach other people how to do the same.”
John
When we caught up with John in the summer of 2013, he had recently moved back to the East Coast and was living in his mother’s basement for the summer. Five years earlier, in 2008, we had interviewed John in Las Vegas, where he was working as a substitute high school teacher and a semiprofessional gambler. He was barely making enough money to get by, although he still managed to afford trips to California to ski, or to Mexico to party with his friends. His pursuit of a teaching career was mainly to please his parents, and by the time we spoke with him again in 2013, he had given up on teaching altogether. He had, however, continued gambling, primarily on sports, and had expanded into selling tickets for college sports. The summer is his off-time. Once things start up in the fall, he travels to various cities and sometimes stays in motels for a month at a time selling tickets to different events.
During the summer, he was mainly just hanging out and smoking a lot of pot. In fact, many of his answers to our questions seemed pretty disjointed, and he ultimately admitted to having taken a “huge bong hit” just before the interview, saying that he had been smoking so much pot that his tolerance level was “out of control.”
In fact, John’s whole life sounds as though it is disjointed. He’s 28 years old and living in his mom’s basement with nothing to do but smoke pot while trying to hide it from her. His dating and sex life are on hold since, as he told us, “I have no money and I’m in my mom’s basement.” He said that he only has one or two casual girlfriends a year, and these relationships last only a few days. When we asked about his friends, he told us, “I have friends,” and that “everybody’s around” and he sees them “once or twice a year.” But as he thought about it, he concluded that he lacked “a friend’s devoted life.” At one point in the interview he told us that all of the questions we were asking him made him realize, “I’m not really—I don’t really have the . . . human interactions. All these normal parts of life, they’re not part of mine.”
Yet, John said that things are going “really good” for him even though it’s been an “up and down couple of years.” He admitted, though, that he’s “small time” and that he really needs to turn a corner and make more than “$20, 30, 40 thousand a year doing this stuff.” He doesn’t have any other career plans, though, telling us, “This is what feeds me for now, and this needs to sort of come to fruition and then. . . . I’ve thought about, you know, my next business venture. To be honest, it probably won’t work, so, when the time is right, I’ll dip my toe in the water.” For now, though, he said that he gets satisfaction from his work because he travels wherever he wants and does not experience much stress. According to John, his marijuana habit is part of how he copes with living with his mother, but it does not interfere with this work:
I don’t smoke weed when I’m doing my regular life. I might for like a week. I’ll buy like a bag for a week when things slow down and all that. But, no, in my regular life I don’t—I don’t need that stuff. Because the thing is, I’m not some kid anymore. It’s just not like in college. If I was in college, I needed to smoke weed no matter where I was but, no, this is just like I’m home at my mom’s and like if I didn’t step outside every half an hour, [laughs] it would make being at home really bad.
As his comment implies, John is not very close to his parents. This is particularly true of his dad, who often loses his temper. John reported being somewhat close to his mom, but noted that she “doesn’t really support my work,” which adds to the tension to their relationship. He feels pressure from his parents to pursue a more reputable way to make a living, and to that end he has taken a few graduate courses here and there over the last few years, but “it didn’t go anywhere.” Regardless, he said that living with his mom—albeit in the basement—is “okay,” and that it doesn’t take “too much concentration not to get caught smoking weed.” When we asked if he thought his parents were happy with how he’s turned out, he replied, “Probably not.”
When we asked about how he decides or knows what’s good and bad and right and wrong in life, John’s answers had not changed much from our last interview with him. John does believe that there are definite rights and wrongs in the world. However, the only one he readily volunteered as being universally wrong was that “you can’t go like kill somebody and stuff. You can’t do that. Everyone knows that.” However, John does not think that questions of morality are particularly relevant to his own life and said, “I don’t really have these like moral things. Like, they don’t really enter my life. I don’t know—maybe if I had a life like chasing around like three kids . . . or, you know, living with a woman and all that sort of stuff, but I don’t.” He continued, saying that “making decisions with moral consequences” is just not part of his life: “You know, like, I only make decisions on like financial stuff, or like if I want to go somewhere. You know what I mean?” John said that he does not attach any moral meaning to these types of decisions. When pressed further on this issue, John responded:
I think, you know, we all have a moral compass that guides us. But like I said, I don’t feel like my moral compass is used much, you know, because I’m not—I mean, I’m still somebody who’s worrying about me. My problems just concern me, and a lot of them are out of my control. Just do the best you can.
John is Catholic, mainly because his mother is Catholic. As he puts it, “My mom and I are kinda Catholics,” meaning that his Catholic identity does not hold any particular salience or importance for him; rather, “It’s what I’ve always been.” He attends church with his mom a couple of times a year, “maybe a little more,” although they don’t otherwise talk about religion. We asked John what he believes about God and whether he has any doubts about his belief in God. He responded, saying:
I just choose to believe in God. A lot of people choose not to. I do. There’s never been any reason to doubt my religious beliefs. They are what they are. It’s normal to me. I think the other people are weird. Like how can you not believe in God? There are just different facts to everything. You know, it just doesn’t all add up to me. There’s some––something more to everything than protons, atoms, and dumb luck. Like I said, I don’t [have doubts] because, you know, I’m a pretty humble guy and I don’t feel the need to be—have anything proven to me or not.
While he is generally confident in his religious beliefs, when asked specifically about life after death, John said he doesn’t really know. He is similarly inconclusive about the idea of karma, though acknowledges that “things have a way of evening themselves out.” In spite of these uncertainties, however, John said that it has not been too difficult to maintain his beliefs over the past few years, and he has not experienced any significant religious change over the last half decade. John’s religious faith is quite stable, and he does not anticipate any changes in the future. However, this does not necessarily mean that his faith is a particularly important factor in his life. On the contrary, when asked whether his faith is a central part of this everyday life, John said, “I don’t know. It’s there. Like I said, I’m not—I’m not extreme or anything.”
In fact, he seems proud of his ability to maintain his religion without it being “extreme.” He goes on to say:
I like to hope that in some ways, you know, I’m an ambassador for somebody who is religious and firm in being religious, but is happy to be casual about it, because in modern society, you know like, religion doesn’t seem to be—it seems to be getting sort of squeezed out.
While John is clear in his identity as “just Catholic,” he doesn’t think that Catholicism, or Christianity more generally, is the only true religion. When we asked him what he thought about whether one or many religions are true, he said, “I don’t know. I think multiple. I don’t see much conflict between them, you know. They’re all sort of similar.” He hasn’t considered any religion other than Catholicism for himself, and when we asked how he knows what to believe when it comes to religion he replied, “Um, I think . . . I just do. It’s my feelings.”
As we were wrapping up the interview, we asked John about the future and what he thought it would take for him to be truly happy when he’s 40 years old. “Forty. Um. Yeah, I guess I need to just—financial stability and, yeah, I guess I don’t want to be, like single when I’m 40. So, somebody willing to put up with me.”
It is clear that our questions about his path to the future also highlight some uncomfortable realities about his present circumstances that he tried to deflect, saying, “I’ll—I’ll start thinking about that stuff when I feel like I’m a person again. I mean I’m just. . . . But whatever. What I am now, it’s, you know—you mix me between like a grad student and like a minor league athlete or someone who sells drugs, or you know? I’m a mix of all that stuff into one.”
Given his evident uncertainty about his life direction, we asked whether there were things he might have done differently in life. His response shifts the responsibility for his challenges to other people: “No, I don’t think so because. . . . But you know, it’s. . . . My problems are more other people who are, you know, swirling around like vultures trying to keep me down.”
Whether John manages to make a go of it gambling and selling quasi-black-market tickets to sporting events is very much up in the air. Despite his uncertainty about the future, John maintains a sense of optimism. Although he explained how difficult his life is, he still seems determined to succeed in his current undertakings. But could this ever translate into a sustainable career that would provide long-term stability in his life and relationships? Even John isn’t optimistic about that possibility.
Heather
We met Heather the Monday after a Saturday night bachelorette party, and she was still on the mend with a significant hangover. She arrived for the interview on time, looking like she had just rolled out of bed, with her blonde hair pulled back, wearing shorts, a T-shirt, and a canvas jacket. When Heather was last interviewed, it was the summer before her last year of college. She graduated in 2009 from a small Catholic liberal arts school in New England. After graduation, she had planned to be a kindergarten teacher. She wanted to move away from the East Coast, and some friends encouraged her to look into the Peace Corps. The Peace Corps didn’t work out; instead, she became an AmeriCorps volunteer in schools on the West Coast, where she ended up living for four years.
When we spoke with her at the final interview, she had recently taken a job in sales back on the East Coast and had moved back in with her parents. She became a certified yoga instructor while she was on the West Coast, and yoga remains an important part of her life. She is also considering moving out of sales and into something more related to helping people, maybe going back to school for physical therapy training.
She gets along well with her parents, and even though she had some doubts about moving back in with them as she transitioned back to the East Coast, she said that they are very supportive of her and are now much more like friends than parents. Her mom is “very Roman Catholic” and is involved as a lay leader in her church. Her dad was raised Jewish but was agnostic until recently, when he went on a work-related retreat and discovered the importance of a having some kind of spirituality in his life.
Heather said that since she stopped attending church back in college, things have been “interesting” with her mother. She said that for her, the Catholic faith “just doesn’t add up.” Even though she went through confirmation, “It just didn’t click for me . . . but I just had to wait until I was confirmed” before she could stop attending church. Her mother attributes this to her church’s leadership not doing a good job of explaining things. Heather sees it differently and tells her mother that yoga is like her church.
After living away for several years, Heather said that she is getting back in touch with many of the friends she still has in the area and that her social circle is “pretty strong.” Her friends have “pretty much nonexistent” religious lives. For some, this is a result of their not being raised by parents with any religious commitments or expectations about religion, while for others, being religious has “kind of like an ‘uncool’ stigma about it.” When we asked her to explain what that was like, she responded that if a person is known to be religious, they are “put in a little box,” and people are surprised if they find out that a “cool” person goes to church regularly.
Heather believes that one of the biggest challenges for young people is work, specifically, “finding work that they love.” She said that she “wants a job that doesn’t feel like work.” Rather than just make a living, she wants to find work in which she has “a vested and personal interest.” She also feels that relationships are a challenge and that technology such as texting makes it easier to hook up, but not to develop a relationship. For her, there is a loss of the personal touch. She also noted that, in her experience, a hookup happens as a prelude to a possible relationship, but does not often lead to a more serious relationship.
Heather is currently single and has recently broken up with a long-time boyfriend, but she wants to get married someday. In addition to offering support and companionship, Heather also sees marriage as an important part of having children, a way to know that her partner is “really kind of tied down to my side” to get through “the bumps in the road of parenting.” When she does have children, rather than raise them Catholic as she was raised, she would want to expose them to multiple options, saying, “And then, you know, they could pick, I guess. . . . [But] I think that too many choices isn’t always a good thing.”
Heather was a pretty hard partier in college, sometimes binge-drinking and getting “blackout” drunk at parties. However, despite her current hangover, she has curtailed heavy drinking, saying that her body can’t take it like it did in college. She does admit that she still smokes pot regularly, for relaxation. She particularly likes to smoke and paint and sometimes will smoke while she is practicing yoga. She said that this lets her “get in my own groove for a while and block myself in.” Since she’s been home, Heather has turned her parents’ attic into a yoga studio. Although her parents are not aware that she smokes, she has been “burning” and doing yoga in the attic. She thinks she’ll continue to drink and smoke pot at about the same levels in the future, although once she has kids, she may curtail her use—“You know, for their safety.”
Heather believes that life is “all about being happy, I guess doing what makes you happy and finding people that make you happy.” For her, that means being with her family on the East Coast—something she admitted she would not have expected to say until relatively recently—as well as having a life companion and finding meaningful work. So far, she hasn’t found a career that she’s passionate about. She believes that she has a purpose in life to “serve others in some way.” She would like to do work that serves her larger purpose, but she doesn’t know what that might be right now. She admitted that at the moment she feels a little lost in life. But while she hasn’t yet reached her goals of meaningful work and a life companion, she’s “on her way” to achieving those things.
Heather said that even though she isn’t a practicing Catholic—she doesn’t even claim a “cultural” Catholic identity—she does see the value of her upbringing in the Church and believes that “a lot of my values came from the Catholic Church.” She doesn’t think it is good when people break rules to gain some personal benefit, but she added that this perspective is “another thing that’s sort of becoming normal.” She continued, saying, “You know, just because we can get away with it doesn’t mean that we should.” She said that she thinks that this kind of generalized moral sensibility is becoming much more common, particularly among young people. When we asked why, she said:
I think it’s a sense of entitlement, and I’m not really sure where it’s coming from. I think that I’ve heard a lot that my generation has been parented in a—in a different way of kind of like, “How do you feel?” Like, a little bit more fluffy, I guess . . . which I don’t think that that’s a bad way. But I don’t know—I don’t know really where it was lost on other people, and I don’t know if it’s because I did have that religious upbringing . . . there was that—that discipline there. I don’t know. I think the moral compass on some young people is a little bit skewed.
For Heather, differentiating between right and wrong comes down to “how is it affecting the other person that you’re making this decision with? The other person or community or business or, you know, like whatever it is.” Ultimately, she believes that understanding right from wrong is something “internal, like you know that you don’t steal. And that’s, you know, that is something that I was taught from a very early age.”
Heather considers herself “spiritual . . . I don’t identify with a religion,” and her yoga practice is a large part of that spirituality. And while she appreciates her Catholic upbringing, her appreciation has its limits. She said that there is “some value to their practices,” although “they’ve been tweaked” as she has applied them in her life. Overall, though, she sees the Catholic Church as “more of a—I guess it is a dictatorship” and suggests that the Catholic Church should change with the times. Then she seemed to catch herself, and said, “Not that they—that religion should be changing with the times, because I guess the point is that it’s so old.” But if she does go to Mass, she said that she feels “like I come out of there not really agreeing with what they’re saying or . . . preaching, or that they’re a little bit abrasive in terms of their ‘you must, you must, you must.’ ”
Although Heather no longer considers herself a Catholic and doesn’t identify with any religious tradition, neither does she consider herself an agnostic or an atheist, as she maintains her own set of spiritual beliefs. She believes “that there’s a purpose—I believe that everybody has a purpose. I guess my school of thought would be that, you know, you’re—you’re here for a purpose and to find your purpose, and then to do it.” She believes in “angels and spiritual guides,” although when she talks about spiritual guides, they tend to be other humans who help to direct a person onto a better path rather than something supernatural. For example, she mentioned her yoga teacher, who “reconnected me more to like a spiritual path.” She also thinks that meditation is “really important” and tries to maintain a regular meditation practice, but said that maintaining a “daily self-discipline” of practicing meditation is difficult.
Heather also believes that people “who passed are watching over,” but her beliefs about the afterlife are somewhat colored by her Catholic upbringing. She said that she “has a belief in heaven,” but that “I don’t think I really do hell. I don’t think anybody is burning in hell. And I don’t know that there’s a Judgment Day where there’s, you know, pearly gates are opening.”
She does, though, believe “that you go someplace else” after death. But, she said, “I’m not sure of what I think about the whole rebirth thing.” We ask if she believes in karma. “I do believe in karma,” she said. “I mean, what goes around comes around. And I think that that guides my moral compass. You know, like, if you screw this person over, you know, like you’re probably going to get screwed over. But if you kind of keep on the—you know, like if you do good, then it’s going to—it’s going to come back to you.”
Overall, Heather said that she values her family most in life. She said that she values “the way I was brought up, that we were pretty comfortable financially. I think I was unique in terms of . . . my parents having different spiritual backgrounds, and then just being really accepting of whatever, and being open to things.” Heather said that this openness is “you know, just like a kind of different . . . world view, I think.”
Raymond
When we contacted Raymond, he was eager to sit down with us again. But when we gave him a reminder call about a week before the interview, he had forgotten all about it. Still, he assured us he would be there. On the day of the interview, he forgot the time we had agreed to meet and went to a friend’s house instead. He doesn’t have a cell phone, but we were able to contact his girlfriend, who got the message to him. Raymond eventually showed up for the interview and gave us an update on his life. This chain of events was not unlike the last time Raymond was interviewed. At that time, he had also forgotten all about it, and we were not certain that he would show up. After speaking with Raymond for this final interview, it was apparent that, like his planning skills, the rest of his life has not really moved forward in any significant way since 2008.
Raymond, now 28 years old, is still living with his grandfather in a small rural town in the Pacific Northwest. He helps around the house, doing yardwork, handyman tasks, working on cars, and generally taking care of “grandpa.” Raymond’s grandfather, who is 78 years old, owns the property and pays for most everything, although Raymond said that he “chips in” to pay bills when his grandfather asks him to. Raymond said he plans to stay with his grandfather and care for him as long as he can. He acknowledges that he would have to “try a little harder” if he were to live on his own, but also notes that his grandfather “couldn’t live without me.” It seems to be a mutually beneficial living arrangement.
Raymond has two children from two different mothers; his daughter is now eight years old and his son is two. Though neither of them lives with him, he said he feels close to his children. His current girlfriend lives with him at his grandfather’s house, helping out with his grandpa when Raymond is not around, taking him places and doing work inside the house. Living with his girlfriend, he told us, just “kind of sort of happened.” He said that his grandfather likes her a lot, so it seems to work out. When we asked whether he is thinking of marriage, he told us that his grandfather has been married six or seven times and that his mother has been married twice. Based on their experiences, he concluded, “You know, I just don’t know. Marriage doesn’t seem like all it’s cracked up to be. It’s just paperwork anyway.” He quickly follows that comment with, “Not trying to sound like a hippie or anything, but . . .” suggesting that this isn’t any sort of countercultural decision, just a reaction to his observations of the marriages in his family, which have shaped his thinking in terms of his own relationship.
As in 2008, Raymond is still working at odd jobs doing “handyman stuff here and there” a few days a week, earning “50 dollars a day or so.” He has recently started a two-year business management program at the local community college and is open to going for a four-year degree, “Depending on how things are at the end of the two years, I guess.” We ask whether he considers himself an adult at this point in his life, and he said, “Yeah, by now, yeah.” He said that for him, being an adult means that you are “able to support yourself. Take care of yourself, and those of yours. You know, your kin, as it were.” When we ask about his friends, he talked about having different friends all over the area. However, when we ask how well he knows them, he doesn’t sound particularly close to any of them. He said that “in general” his parents are pleased with how he has turned out. And his grandfather tells him that “he’s really happy with how things have been going. He’s been telling me that for the last two years now.”
When we interviewed Raymond in 2008, he reported regular drug use and heavy drinking. At one point, he had even ended up in the hospital with significant health problems as a result. This is one area of his life that has changed in the intervening time since that 2008 interview. He reported in this interview that he hasn’t “used that meth stuff since I was 18 or 19.” More recently, he has stopped using marijuana and reduced his drinking. Raymond told us it had been about 15 months since he “drank drank, you know, in the way to drink and have fun and do whatever we would do.” The break from alcohol seems to have been precipitated by an incident that he did not want to talk about, saying simply that “I did some pretty bad things when I was drunk. Part of the reason I haven’t [been drinking] for so long.” Thinking ahead five to 10 years, Raymond said that he thinks that he still won’t be drinking to excess as he has in the past. Then he added, “Weed though. . . . I love marijuana. I do. And I, when I’m, you know, when I’m done with school and stuff, and I’m, you know, in a position that I got money saved away and can do pretty much anything, then, you know, on weekends and stuff, I’ll smoke with my friends and hang out and do whatever.”
Beyond his responses to specific questions about things like living arrangements, work, and school, Raymond’s answers to many of our questions were somewhat vague. He was often unsure what question he was answering or would lose track of the question as he answered. Sometimes he rambled on in his responses, connecting thoughts and experiences that did not seem to be related—several times, in the middle of his response, he would ask, “Now, what was the question?”
This was especially true when it came to religion. When we asked how he described himself religiously, he said, “Um, the Lord is good.” When we pressed him as to whether he identified with a specific religion, he replied, “Methodist slash Catholic, I guess.” A few minutes later he told us that he was “raised Catholic and RLDS,” a branch of the Latter-day Saints movement, although most of his responses seemed more generically Christian and not specifically related to any of those traditions. For Raymond, any differences between Methodists or Catholics and other denominations were all connected to requirements about tithing and how that was linked to getting into heaven. “Methodists, you give what you can. Whereas Mormons say, you have to give at least 10 percent. You have to, or you will go to hell.”
Raymond sees Catholics somewhere between the Methodists and Mormons: “The Catholics do say 10 percent I think, too, but not, I don’t think you’re going to go to hell for it. If you can’t give that, at least give what you can.” When asked to describe his own religious beliefs, Raymond said:
I believe in God. I believe that we should follow his law. I believe, not maybe not every single little tiny thing that teachers of religious law tell you. But I do believe in, in large part, it is all. Oh, I believe in the Our Father, and I believe . . . at least in the Lord. I believe that he put us here, he does in fact have a purpose for us. I do believe that we do all have a purpose and that it is his purpose, whether we know it or not.
When asked what he believes about Jesus, Raymond continued:
Well . . . I believe that he came here to die for our sins. Or at least that he spoke the truth, and it was just the religious leaders did not believe the same as him and he suffered for it. Whether or not you believe, he came here specifically to die for our sins. But, he may not have. He may have just been one of, you know, one of God’s messengers to tell us what he wanted us to know. Either way, he was here because God made him, made him to be here. Sent him, however you want to say it. In my opinion, of course, again.
In the end, the most important religious beliefs for him are “well, laws for sure. His law, like not to kill, not to steal, and not, you know, to do all that stuff he says not to do. But to do for [help] others.”
Turning to issues of life after death and the existence of heaven and hell, Raymond expressed some uncertainty. Like many of the young people we spoke with, he would like to believe that life doesn’t just end after death and that heaven really exists as a perfect place where the soul can be with God after this life is over. But he admitted that he is still undecided and does not know for sure what he believes about these issues.
On the question of reincarnation, he is also uncertain and referenced his Native American heritage in his response. “I don’t know. Okay, I’m part Cherokee, so, I don’t know. I know plenty of Indians that say that it is [true]. Wolves, eagles, snakes, you know, whatever creatures, but it depends on what you did in life as for what you’ll become. I could come back a wise owl, you know, or something like that. If that’s what happens.”
Following up, we asked whether Native American spirituality is important to him, and he related a story of an ongoing experience with an owl and how he is trying to determine whether it is a message from God or perhaps from his grandmother:
There is this owl. And, as silly as it may sound, for like the last two years, usually when it happens it’s at night. I’ll hear an owl screech and I’ll look up and see him immediately, instead of having to search for him and it’s dark. And he’s a white one, or gray at least, enough that I can see him in the dark up in the sky at night. And he follows me sometimes and like he hangs around the house, too, in the big tree within a block’s radius, he lives in there somewhere. Could be a sign, or I don’t know. It—you know, maybe it could be my grandmother, you know, trying to tell me something. So, I guess I do believe that it is possible. . . . I want to believe in it, but I don’t know.
After discussing his religious beliefs, we ask Raymond if he has any spiritual practices like attending church, praying, or reading the Bible. He told us that he doesn’t attend church, “not like I should. I guess grandpa and I have been being lazy.” Instead of going to church, they stay home and watch a TV preacher a couple of times a week, and he reads the Bible along with the service as they watch. He also said he prays three times a day. He does volunteer work at a local Nazarene church, but doesn’t attend any services there.
Knowing right from wrong is not very hard at all, according to Raymond. His sense of right and wrong comes from “a feeling, you know. You just, you know. We know what is right and wrong.” When asked where this feeling comes from, he said, “I don’t know. Being the way I was raised, I guess.” He acknowledges that his religious beliefs do often play a role in his deciding what is right and wrong, though “it depends on the circumstance. I could say at least 80 percent.” He does not believe that morals are relative, saying, “That’s, I mean, just an excuse for people to go and do whatever they want. You know? Or to do wrong things or to be, you know, I don’t know. It’s an excuse for wrong, sounds like.”
Looking ahead in his life, Raymond expressed very pragmatic goals, saying that what will make him happiest when he’s 40 years old will be “to have an education and a good job, health insurance, benefits, you know, stuff like that.” He’s not quite sure what he really wants out of life and is primarily focused on finishing the post-secondary education that he is just now starting. We ask what would count for him as failure, and he replied, “Not having finished the schooling that I’m talking about.” Raymond told us that the things in life that he most values are family and the loyalty of friends and that he believes he is living his life in a way that lets him live his values through his volunteer work and helping other people. Raymond told us that he doesn’t think he has any regrets about his life so far, and there is not much he would do differently in his life, if given the chance.
Raymond is an engaging, likable young man who has made small but significant changes in his life over the five years between interviews. If he finishes school, that may provide a level of confidence he needs to embark on the life he envisions for himself—a good job with health insurance and benefits, caring for others, and spending the weekends smoking pot and hanging out with his friends.
Conclusion
Although these five stories of emerging adults are not intended to be representative of all American emerging adults, they do echo the themes that we have found, more broadly, in our research. That said, as was noted in the discussion of these same young people after they were last interviewed in 2008, there is more continuity in their lives than there is change.
Of the five emerging adults whom we profile here, Joy is the one who has experienced the most dramatic changes. She seems to have achieved a level of stability in her life. She has been off drugs and alcohol for a couple of years, is in a marriage that is working despite the couple’s problems, and is a good and responsible mother. And, almost unbelievably, she has reached a point where she has forgiven the adults who have let her down—even her abusive stepfather. The move toward more stability was prompted in large part by the intervention of a responsible adult and a religious awakening and reinforced by good decisions on Joy’s part, particularly quitting drugs and alcohol. It is noteworthy, however, that she has managed to maintain a level of stability even in the face of what she views as a betrayal by her foster mother and her subsequent exit from any church participation.
Each of the others we profiled has experienced much more continuity in their lives. And while the particulars of each of their lives vary widely, the stories of these young people reinforce a theme we have seen across the years of this study: the importance of parents and other adults in the lives of young people. John and Raymond, for example, seem the most marginally stable. But what stability they have is owed in part to the adults in their lives. As with Joy, Raymond seems to have benefited from a positive adult relationship, in his case with his grandfather and the sense of responsibility Raymond clearly has for him. It is hard to know how Raymond might manage if he did not live with his grandfather.
John is clearly just getting by. And even though he isn’t thrilled about it, being able to live in his mother’s basement seems to provide an important source of stability for him. If living with his mother were not an option, it isn’t clear what he would do during the times of the year that he has no source of income.
Kristen and Heather demonstrate more stability and continuity in their lives, despite the differences in their life experiences. It is no coincidence that the two women whose lives are the most settled and stable are also the two who are closest to and have the most support from their families. The influence and support of parents and other invested adults play a significant role in shaping whatever stability and continuity are found among these emerging adults.
Across the stories of all five emerging adults, we see some significant similarities that will emerge later in the book. One of the most interesting characteristics shared by all five—which echoes the characteristics of emerging adulthood briefly discussed in the introduction—is that all of them, regardless of their particular circumstances, are optimistic about their lives and the possibilities that may lie ahead for them. This is true even when the objective evidence suggests little reason to be optimistic. Think of John and his dreams of being a much bigger player in the ticket-selling game, or Raymond and his goal of finishing school and getting a good job with benefits and insurance. They may very well achieve these goals, but it is hard to reconcile that prospect with the evidence of their lives, at least at this point. Yet, these young men continue to expect a brighter future for themselves.
Another characteristic common to each of these young people is their tendency to understand themselves as unfettered individuals standing on their own, fully capable of achieving their goals and making necessary changes to reach those goals, despite their life situations. Raymond is a good example of this. His life has not changed appreciably in the five years since he was last interviewed; he’s still living with and taking care of his grandfather and making a small amount of money doing odd jobs. Though he is mostly dependent on his grandfather, he maintains the belief that his future is completely in his hands. He is banking on completing the community college program he just started to allow him to get a good job, yet there is little in his life at this point to suggest that this will happen. If continuity is the norm, then Raymond’s future may not be as bright as he imagines it could be. While his future has partly to do with his own abilities and decisions, it will also be dependent on what resources he has available to complete his college courses and how he handles the other responsibilities in his life.
Finally, this sense of individual authority and agency permeates most aspects of these five lives, including how these emerging adults think about religion and morals. We will see much more of this throughout the book, but for now, recall how, with the exception of Kristen, each of the emerging adults expressed morality as being something that they felt in their “gut,” that it is a feeling they get, and they “just know” right from wrong. Sometimes they could articulate that this belief might come from somewhere, but in general, morals were something that they individually felt or knew.
Similarly, they each (again with the exception of Kristen) have a self-styled set of ideas and beliefs about faith and spirituality. Whether or not they believe themselves to be religious or knowledgeable about religion, there is a significant element of picking and choosing what they like about religion. They seem to be synthesizing their own version of religion or spirituality from a variety of sources, not all of which are religious. How this plays out for emerging adults more broadly is discussed at length later in the book. For now, it is important to point out that these young people are very similar to other emerging adults in their belief in themselves as autonomous individuals in all aspects of their lives.
In the next chapter, we turn to the major themes in the lives of emerging adults as they are moving toward adulthood in order to provide a broader context for their lives in terms of work, friends, family, and the like. Throughout, we focus on how well they are taking on the roles of adulthood as they enter the full-time workforce, start their own families, and otherwise make their way in the world.
