Chapter 11 of 16

6. Faith and Family

6. Faith and Family

the institutions of family and religion are intimately intertwined in the United States. Although ties to both institutions appear to be loosening, the nuclear family arrangement, despite its numerical decline, continues to be closely linked to religious identity. Given the interwoven relationship, understanding current patterns of family formation is particularly important for understanding religious trends during emerging adulthood. In this chapter we explore the various ways that marriage and parenthood are tied to religiousness among the young people in our study.

One hope of our research has been to understand the trajectories of young people’s lives as they move from adolescence into adulthood. This transition to adulthood is changing dramatically, shifting with the rapidly changing tides of society. Understanding how current emerging adults are navigating their entrance into adulthood tells us much about their lives, but also about society itself as well as the forces that are at work in shaping the next generation. Along the path to adulthood, most individuals make some kind of transition from their family of origin to establishing partnerships, having children, and forming their own families. Recent decades have brought significant changes to the timing and sequencing of these transitions into life partnerships and parenthood, and we can envision several different pathways into family formation.

There are multiple factors that predict or influence the particular pathways that people follow. And after they opt for one of those different pathways, their lives evolve in distinct and meaningful ways. In this chapter we explore how perspectives and expectations about marriage and family life differ across religious groups. We introduce six different stages of family formation: married with children, married without children, cohabiting with children, cohabiting without children, single with children, and single without children. We then examine how religious identity is related to which stage young people find themselves in, and in turn how these different stages of family formation affect the religious lives of the young people in our study.

The median age of first marriage has been rising steadily over the past several decades. In 2012, the median age of first marriage was 29 for men and 27 for women. Marriage continues to be a desired and significant life goal for the majority of young people. But for a variety of reasons, the transition into marriage has been happening steadily later in life since the 1950s. It is not just a delay in marriage, however, that has been noted by social scientists. There have also been significant changes in the landscape of who gets married and who does not. Rather than the first step toward adulthood, marriage is now often seen as a capstone experience, the culmination of other life achievements, and, for many, a status symbol. Understanding marriage as a marker of “success,” some scholars have noted the growing gaps in marriage rates across different socioeconomic groups and have identified marriage as—increasingly—a status of privilege, easily available to the elite and often escaping the grasp of those at the bottom end of the socioeconomic ladder.

When it comes to marriage rates, just over one-fourth of the respondents in our study are currently married. Another 5 percent have been married at some point previously but are either separated, divorced, or widowed. shows the marital status of the emerging adults in our study. Altogether, approximately 30 percent have been married at some point, and another 10 percent are currently engaged to be married. Two percent reported that they are in a civil union, registered domestic partnership, or common-law marriage. The remaining 58 percent have never been married. This is not entirely surprising, considering that the age range of our respondents, 23 to 28, does not include the median age of marriage for men (at 29) and only barely captures the median for women (27). So, those in our sample who are married are on the early side of the curve when it comes to marriage timing. The emerging adults in our study have a slightly lower marriage rate than we see in other nationally representative data, though it follows the general trend of low marriage rates among people in their 20s.

Table 6.1 Wave 4 Marital Status

Never married

58%

Currently engaged

10%

Currently married

25%

Civil union

2%

Separated or divorced

4%

Widowed

<1%

Total

100%

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Similar to marriage, the average age at which women have their first child is also increasing. In 2000, the average age of first-time mothers was 24.9 years. By 2009, this average age at the time of a first birth had increased to 25.2 years, and five years later in 2014, it was up to 26.3 years. This increase can be attributed both to a decline in the rate of teen pregnancies over the same time period and the fact that more women are waiting until they are older than 30 to have their first child. In 2000, 23.9 percent of first births were to women older than 30, and in 2014, these women accounted for more than 30 percent of first-time births. These statistics confirm that the transition into family formation has been delayed across the population.

Given the age range of our respondents—from 23 to 28—we would expect that many of them have not yet transitioned into parenthood. Nationally, the percentage of women who have had a child during this age range has been decreasing steadily over recent decades. In 2000, 50 percent of women ages 23 to 28 had already had at least one child, while 50 percent had not had any children yet. By the year 2010, only 45 percent of women ages 23 to 28 had at least one child, and 55 percent were still childless. Compared with these general US statistics, our sample is less likely to have transitioned to parenthood. Sixty-six percent of the young women in our study have not given birth to any children, while 34 percent reported having given birth to at least one child at the time of the Wave 4 survey. If we include nonbiological children, such as adopted children or stepchildren, then slightly less than 40 percent of the women in our sample reported having at least one child. About half of the parents in our study have only one child, while the members of the other half of the parent cohort each have more than one child.

Expectations and Plans for Marriage

There is a well-established body of literature documenting that religious identity is related to earlier transitions into marriage and parenthood. Scholars have proposed many possible reasons that religious young people transition into family formation at younger ages than their peers. Religious congregations are often a context where young people will hear pro-family messages and see family life as the normative standard in their communities. Early transitions into marriage and parenthood are often encouraged and supported by religious groups. In addition to the pro-family messages that encourage marriage and parenthood, religious communities can also create a context that discourages behaviors that might otherwise make it possible to postpone marriage.

The increasing social acceptance of nonmarital sex and cohabitation before marriage allows young people to engage in romantic partnerships that can, in turn, delay marriage. Work by Manning and colleagues found that, while the median age of first marriage has increased, the median age at which people create their first union or romantic partnership has remained stable. In other words, for many people, cohabitation has replaced marriage as the first step toward family formation. Religious individuals, however, are more likely to oppose nonmarital sex and cohabitation. Without cohabitation as an option during the emerging adult years, religious individuals may be more likely to transition directly into marriage. And earlier marriage is often correlated with earlier timing of having children.

People’s attitudes and intentions offer helpful, if imperfect, predictors of their future behavior. Researchers have found young people’s attitudes about gender and marriage to be predictive of their future behaviors and transitions into marriage. Similarly, we expect that how emerging adults view marriage and form their expectations about the timing of marriage will be important factors in their decisions about whether and when to marry. Further, we expect that these attitudes and expectations will be shaped by the context of emerging adults’ lives, and religious communities that encourage marriage while discouraging nontraditional family arrangements are an important part of this context.

We collected both quantitative and qualitative information about what young people expect regarding marriage, as well as the criteria that inform their decisions to marry. In the survey, respondents were asked, “What do you think is the ideal age to get married?” In addition, we asked a series of questions about the things they might want to accomplish before getting married. The common stem of this series of questions was, “People have different ideas about what should be accomplished before one is ready to marry. Please tell me how important it is or was to you, personally, to accomplish each of the following things before getting married.” This was followed by a series of statements:

• Complete your education before getting married.

• Establish your career before getting married.

• Buy a home before getting married.

• Live on your own for a while before getting married.

• Date enough other people before getting married.

• Live with the person you are thinking of marrying before getting married.

• Travel or have adventures.

• Enjoy a long time without commitments or responsibilities.

Respondents were asked to rate the importance of each of the above items with the following response options: extremely important, very important, somewhat important, not very important, not at all important, I do not want or plan to get married. These questions allow us to assess the goals and expectations that young people have about marriage and the timing of the decision to marry.

Regarding the timing of marriage, shows a linear relationship between religious engagement and notions about the ideal age of marriage. Those who are not religious reported an ideal age of about 27 and a half. In contrast, the regularly involved religious respondents reported that 25 and a half is an ideal age to marry.

Table 6.2 Ideal Age to Marry

Mean Age (years)

Not Religious

27.6

Disaffiliated

27.2

Marginal

27.0

Committed

25.7

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

When asking about the criteria for marriage during our in-person interviews, the common refrain is that they are seeking to be “ready” for marriage. What does this mean? For some it is a nebulous personal readiness—know who you are and what you want; be emotionally stable and ready for a commitment. But for many, “readiness” is more practical. Complete your education, establish a career or job path, and most important, be financially able to support yourself and a family. This is not a new story. It resonates with much of what has been written about marriage trends in recent years. Emerging adults place significant emphasis on the goal of financial stability before committing to marriage. Yet, this goal is growing ever more elusive. Scholars have argued that the increasing challenge of obtaining financial stability is a significant driver in the delay of marriage in general. Religiously motivated young people are not necessarily less likely to believe in the importance of being financially prepared for marriage. It was not mentioned as frequently in the qualitative data but was still a common sentiment among the religious and nonreligious alike.

Religious and nonreligious young people have similar aspirations for marriage when it comes to traditional milestones such as completing education, establishing a career, owning a home, and living on their own (i.e., apart from their parents). Comparing the four religious groups introduced in , the survey data do not reveal large differences in the priority given to accomplishing these things before marriage. However, we see greater differences in the less traditional measures: dating enough other people before getting married, living with a partner before marrying the partner, having time for travel and adventure, and enjoying a period of time in life without significant responsibilities or commitments. For each of these four statements about things young people might like to accomplish before marriage, the religiously Committed reported them to be significantly less important to accomplish before marriage than the other three groups (Marginal, Disaffiliated, Not Religious). These four expectations regarding marriage align with the tenets of emerging adulthood and fit well with the idea of this life stage as a time of uncertainty, self-exploration, and identity formation. And these mores of emerging adulthood seem to have taken hold more strongly among the less religious when it comes to their criteria for marriage readiness, while more religious emerging adults are less likely to be embracing these ideals as prerequisites to marriage.

So, while religious and nonreligious young people have similar expectations when it comes to education and careers, they have different expectations about the life experiences they want to have before settling into marriage. It is possible, then, that one reason why religious individuals marry younger is that they are less likely to prioritize having a lot of premarital relationship experience such as dating multiple partners or living with a partner for a period of time before committing to marriage. They are also less likely to say they would put off marriage for a time of self-exploration, as indicated by their responses to questions about travel, adventure, and responsibilities.

Another consideration in understanding marriage timing is the underlying motivation or desire for marriage within each group of young people. The young people in our survey were asked to tell us how they might feel if they did not end up marrying. The question was: “Suppose your life turns out so that you never get married. Would that bother you a great deal, some, a little, or none at all?” In the responses to this question about their future, we see clear differences by religious category. shows that respondents who do not identify as religious are by far the least likely to anticipate being bothered by never getting married. Only 26 percent of the Not Religious said that this would bother them a great deal, and one-fourth said it would not bother them at all. In contrast, about 40 percent of the other three groups anticipated that it would bother them a great deal never to marry. This is true even of the Disaffiliated, who never attend religious services but still carry some religious identity. So, as a life goal, those who are the most disconnected from religious institutions also seem to be least attached to the idea of participating in the institution of marriage. In contrast, young people with a connection to religious institutions express more anticipated disappointment with the idea of never getting married. To the extent that motivation or desire for marriage drives marriage rates, it would not be surprising, then, for religious individuals to marry at younger ages than nonreligious individuals.

Table 6.3 Would Be Bothered if Never Married

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

All (%)

Bothered a great deal

26

41

41

43

36

Bothered some

27

25

27

29

27

Bothered a little

22

16

16

14

17

Not at all bothered

25

18

16

14

19

Total

100

100

100

100

100

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Marriage versus Companionship

Although a sizeable number of respondents reported that never getting married would not bother them, this does not mean that they do not desire committed, long-term relationships. We heard in the qualitative interviews that most respondents do aspire to having a long-term committed partner, and for the vast majority of them, this is likely to mean marriage.

However, there are differences in their visions of the form that this relationship will take. Among those who are more religious, the desire for a committed, long-term relationship clearly implies marriage. This is not surprising, given that most religious groups in the United States encourage marriage as the desired and normative context for adult life. As noted previously, young people who are involved in religious congregations have likely been exposed to a variety of pro-marriage and pro-family messages. Among our respondents, this appears as a theological bent toward marriage—that is, the understanding that marriage is something ordained by God and therefore part of the ideal package for a whole life. This is illustrated by an exchange with this 27-year-old Conservative Protestant young man:

interviewer : How likely is it that you’ll get married someday?

respondent : Yeah, pretty likely, I hope so.

i : And why do you want to get married?

r : Yeah, like the whole thing of creating a family and passing your values onto the next generation of your children and . . . I think, like, God says . . . I mean you need a helper, you can’t just do this all on your own. You can’t go through life on your own. So, like, I think that’s another important part.

This 25-year-old Black Protestant woman also believed that marriage was an important part of life according to her faith:

i : Is there a certain age or point in life when people should take dating more seriously and date to find a spouse, or not necessarily?

r : I think as soon as possible. I don’t think there’s a specific age. As soon as possible. You stick to that one person. Make it work—especially if you love and care for them. There should be nothing to break you up.

i : And if people didn’t really want to date, didn’t really want to get married, should they anyway? Is there one goal for everybody?

r : You’re supposed to.

i : Okay. And why are you supposed to?

r : Jesus. He said so.

Although not particularly forthcoming with the details of this theological mandate, she is clear that Jesus desires people to be married.

The connection between companionship and marriage is not as clear-cut for those who are not religious. The rising acceptance and occurrence of cohabitation has contributed to an openness to considering alternatives to traditional marriage. Among the Not Religious respondents, marriage is still the most likely scenario, but it is not the only possibility. This group seems to privilege the relationship, in whatever form it takes, over the marriage itself. For example, this 24-year-old Atheist is not married in the legal sense, yet he had this to say about his current relationship:

Oh yeah, I feel like we’re already married. Yeah, I would do the same thing a married guy would. I take care of her and cook for her and all that stuff, so you know, we’re married. I mean, why do you have to have a piece of paper and a ceremony to say you’re married?

This sentiment about marriage being “just a piece of paper” was echoed by other nonreligious respondents as well. This is what we heard from a 25-year-old Not Religious woman on the subject:

i : Do you think you want to get married someday?

r : Maybe. I don’t know.

i : And what do you think it would be like to live with somebody you’re married to versus living with them when you are not married?

r : I really don’t think it would be any different. Like, my family doesn’t believe in, like, the whole you wait to live with them ‘til you’re married and stuff like that. My mom was with my stepdad for years and years and lived together before they got married, and so I don’t see that big difference. Like, it’s just a piece of paper or a ring. I don’t think it’d be any different.

i : And do you want to get married someday?

r : Hmm, I think. I mean it’s not, like, that important. I—we’re talking about marriage not just a relationship right? Yeah, I don’t—I mean if you have someone, you have somebody.

i : And how likely do you think it is that you’ll get married?

r : It’s a 50/50 chance at this point [laughs]. I don’t know.

While the majority of the young people we spoke with believe they will marry eventually, the sense of necessity for marriage was stronger among those who identified themselves as religious. Although marriage was certainly valued by religious and nonreligious respondents alike, those who are not religious were more likely to be open, at least in theory, to alternatives to formal, legal marriage and less likely to be disappointed in the event that they never marry.

Attitudes about Nonmarital Sex

When considering the religious differences in attitudes about marriage and openness to alternative forms of relationships, one important component is attitudes toward nonmarital sexual behavior. Religious affiliation and belief have been linked to more conservative attitudes about nonmarital sex and delayed sexual activity among adolescents. The emerging adults in our survey were asked, “Do you think that people should wait to have sex until they are married?” Half of all respondents answered, “Not necessarily” to this question. Twenty-one percent said yes, people should wait, and 29 percent said no, people do not need to wait for marriage to have sex. Examining responses across the four religious groups, we found that among the Committed emerging adults, 58 percent agree with the proposition that people should wait to have sex until one is married, and 16 percent of the Marginal emerging adults hold this belief. In contrast, only 2 percent of Not Religious young people and 6 percent of the Disaffiliated think that sex should be saved for marriage.

There is quite an ideological gap between the religiously Committed and the rest of the sample when it comes to views about sex before marriage. While these beliefs about nonmarital sex do not perfectly predict the decisions young people will make about their own sexual activity and relationships, research shows that disapproving attitudes toward nonmarital sex are linked to starting sexual intercourse at a later age. Those who are more religiously engaged are more likely to believe in delaying sex until marriage, and these beliefs may encourage some young people to enter into marriage sooner.

Cohabitation

Cohabitation is also an important part of the larger puzzle of emerging adult relationships and the transition into marriage. Whether emerging adults themselves realize it or not, cohabitation offers a viable alternative to marriage for those who are ideologically open to such an arrangement, and it has the potential to influence their timing of marriage. As with attitudes about sex before marriage, there is a gap across religious groups when we consider attitudes about cohabitation.

We asked respondents who had not already lived with a partner whether they would consider doing so in the future. Among the Committed emerging adults, just 42 percent said they would be willing to cohabit. More than 80 percent of the Marginal and Disaffiliated respondents expressed that willingness, while 93 percent of the Not Religious agreed that they would consider cohabiting in the future. shows the percentage of each religious group that has, in fact, cohabited with a partner, and their behavior appears to line up with the attitudes they reported about cohabitation. The Committed emerging adults reported the lowest rate of cohabitation, at 36 percent. Among the remaining three groups, more than half have cohabited, including 66 percent of the Not Religious emerging adults.

Table 6.4 Ever Cohabited

Not Religious

66%

Disaffiliated

57%

Marginal

57%

Committed

36%

All emerging adults

55%

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Attitudes about cohabitation are not simply theoretical, and they are also linked to future marriage patterns. The question about willingness to cohabit in the future was also asked in the Wave 3 survey, and those who said they would cohabit are much less likely to be married five years later, compared with those who are not willing to cohabit with a partner in the future. Of those who were already cohabiting or who said yes, they would consider cohabitation in the future, 21 percent were married by the time we surveyed them in 2013. However, this is significantly less than those who at Wave 3 said that they would not consider cohabitation; 32 percent of these young people are married by Wave 4. In other words, holding proscriptive ideology about cohabitation is linked to higher rates of marriage among these emerging adults.

The act of cohabiting is also associated with marriage patterns, as seen by comparing emerging adults who have lived with an unmarried partner at some point in the past with those who reported that they have never lived with a romantic partner to whom they were not married. Among those who have never cohabited, 33 percent are now married. However, among those who reported cohabitation, less than 20 percent are currently married. So, among the emerging adults we studied, cohabitation is inversely correlated with being married before age 30.

The causal arrow surely runs in both directions here: Those who marry young have less opportunity for cohabiting relationships. On the other hand, those who enter into cohabiting relationships seem less likely to end up married before age 30. We must proceed with caution in our interpretation because many of these young people have not yet reached the average age of marriage in the United States. So, we can’t comment on the long-term marriage prospects of respondents, or how cohabitation influences their marriage trajectories in the long run. What we can say is that cohabitation does not appear to correlate with marrying on the younger side of the age continuum. This is consistent with research that suggests that the rise of cohabitation may be contributing to the overall delay in marriage, and this is most common among those who are not religiously opposed to cohabitation. On the other hand, when highly religious young people find themselves in a romantic relationship, proscriptive beliefs about nonmarital sex and cohabitation may provide a stronger incentive to marry earlier, compared with their peers for whom marriage is not a requirement for the initiation of sexual activity and living together.

Religion and Family Status

Marriage and childbearing have become more disconnected in recent decades, and a single trajectory of “marriage then children” no longer fits for large portions of the population. Recent work by Amato and colleagues highlights the need to consider both marriage and parenthood in the study of transitions into family formation. Yet, examining these two issues separately does not account for the ways in which marriage and parenthood interact on the path to family formation. The impact of becoming a parent is different within a marriage context than if one is parenting children without a partner. Similarly, marriage often takes on different meaning when it is paired with parenthood.

The emerging adults in our study are at different stages of their family formation trajectories. There is much more variation and complexity than can be captured in a single chapter on this topic. Of specific interest in this section, however, is whether we find in our data support for previous research that suggests that religion is associated with earlier transitions into family formation. For our purposes, we will focus on six main categories of family status with regard to partnership and parenthood, as mentioned earlier in this chapter. To account for the different configurations of marital status and parenthood, we will focus on the current status of each respondent at the time of the Wave 4 survey: married with children, married without children, cohabiting with children, cohabiting without children, single with children, and single without children. The family status indicators, shown in , only measure the respondents’ reported relationship status and parent status at the time of the Wave 4 survey. Although we do not account for the timing of the birth and/or marriage, we can assume that the starting point for these family statuses occurs at some point before the Wave 4 measure of religion. The separation of unmarried respondents into single and cohabiting categories acknowledges that cohabitation continues to be a liminal status in terms of family transitions, serving as a precursor or alternative to marriage for some young people, while also potentially delaying marriage. In addition, as discussed previously, cohabitation is often discouraged within religious communities. Choosing to remain single as an early emerging adult does not run counter to pro-family religious norms in the same way that cohabitation might. Therefore, these two family stages are examined separately because their relationships with the religious lives of young people likely follow different patterns.

Table 6.5 Family Status by Wave 1 Religious Tradition

Religious Tradition Wave 1 (Ages 13–17)

All (%)

CP (%)

MP (%)

BP (%)

RC (%)

J (%)

LDS (%)

NR (%)

Married with children

14

18

11

11

9

9

30

14

Married without children

12

17

13

3

9

6

13

9

Cohabiting with children

6

6

5

7

6

0

7

9

Cohabiting without children

11

9

15

5

12

4

7

16

Single with children

11

10

6

36

10

0

4

8

Single without children

46

40

50

37

54

81

39

45

Total

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

BP = Black Protestant; CP = Conservative Protestant; J = Jewish; LDS = Latter-day Saints; MP = Mainline Protestant; NR = Not Religious; RC = Roman Catholic.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion surveys 2003, 2013.

Early family formation is linked both to religious tradition or institutional affiliation and to personal religious practice and belief. We examine the relationships between adolescent religion (i.e., the religious identity of emerging adults when they were teens) and future transitions to marriage and parenthood that appear in our data. Looking first at the broad categories of religious traditions, we see that emerging adults who identified as Mormons, Conservative Protestants, or Black Protestants in their teenage years are the most likely to have made family transitions by the time we survey them for Wave 4 (. Among the respondents who were Latter-day Saints (LDS) in their teens, 30 percent are currently married with children, 13 percent are married without children, and 11 percent are cohabiting or single with children. Only 46 percent of those who were Mormon as teens have not experienced either marriage or parenthood. Among the emerging adults who are identified as Black Protestant or Conservative Protestant at the time of the first survey, only 37 and 40 percent, respectively, are single with no children. Thirty-five percent of the Conservative Protestants are currently married, and 34 percent have children at the last survey. Including the 7 percent who reported a previous marriage (not shown), 42 percent of Wave 1 Conservative Protestants reported having gotten married at some point during the course of the study.

Measuring religious salience from the teenage years tells a very similar story. compares Wave 4 family status by levels of importance of faith at Wave 1. Among those for whom faith was very or extremely important as adolescents, 32 percent are married by the time they reach their 20s, and 36 percent have children. In comparison, just 18 percent of those who as adolescents said faith is somewhat important and those who said it is not very or not at all important are married at the final survey, while 28 and 22 percent are parents, respectively. Thus, among emerging adults for whom faith was important as teenagers, less than half have not yet transitioned into either marriage or parenthood. For their counterparts for whom faith was less important as youth, more than 60 percent are still awaiting these transitions.

Table 6.6 Family Status by Wave 1 Importance of Faith

Not Important (%)

Somewhat Important (%)

Very/Extremely Important (%)

Married with children

9

11

17

Married without children

9

8

15

Cohabiting with children

5

7

6

Cohabiting without children

16

14

8

Single with children

8

11

12

Single without children

53

50

41

Total

100

100

100

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion surveys 2003, 2013.

Religious affiliation is certainly not fixed, and many of our respondents change their religious affiliation or identity over the course of the study. This warrants an examination not just of early religion on future marriage but also of current religious identity as it relates to current marital status. Looking at Wave 4 religious tradition, the pattern is similar to the Wave 1 analysis (. Among the emerging adults who identified as LDS in the Wave 4 survey, 42 percent are married with children and 15 percent are married without children, meaning that 57 percent of this religious group is currently married, compared with just 26 percent of the entire sample of respondents. Another nine percent have children but are unmarried, leaving just 34 percent of current Mormon emerging adults who have not experienced either marriage or parenthood by the time they reach the ages of 23 to 28. Conservative Protestants have the next highest family transition rate, with 56 percent who are married and/or have children. This means that 44 percent of the current Conservative Protestants are unmarried and without children. Mainline Protestant and Jewish respondents have marriage rates of less than 30 percent each; 25 and 20 percent, respectively, of these two groups have children, either within or outside of marriage. While a relatively low number of Black Protestants are married (19 percent), they have the highest rate of respondents with children; 58 percent of Black Protestants have had children either within or outside of marriage. The lowest rates of marriage are for the Catholic and Not Religious groups of emerging adults, each with only 17 percent currently married. The low marriage rates are somewhat offset by higher rates of cohabitation among Catholics and Not Religious. However, even if we consider marriage and cohabitation together, just 36 percent of Catholic young people are currently partnered—less than any other group—while 41 percent of the Not Religious have partners through marriage or cohabitation. The differences in marriage rates across religious traditions are consistent with other research findings on this topic.

Table 6.7 Family Status by Wave 4 Religious Tradition

Religious Tradition Wave 4 (Age 23–28)

All (%)

CP (%)

MP (%)

BP (%)

RC (%)

J (%)

LDS (%)

NR (%)

Married with children

14

20

13

14

8

12

42

9

Married without children

12

21

16

5

9

16

15

8

Cohabiting with children

6

6

2

9

7

8

4

6

Cohabiting without children

11

5

8

4

12

12

2

18

Single with children

11

9

10

35

7

0

5

8

Single without children

46

38

51

33

57

52

32

50

Total

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

100

BP = Black Protestant; CP = Conservative Protestant; J = Jewish; LDS = Latter-day Saints; MP = Mainline Protestant; NR = Not Religious; RC = Roman Catholic.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

When we examine family status by the four categories of religious engagement, we see a large difference between those who are regular attenders and those who are not (. Emerging adults in the Committed group are the least likely to be single without children: just 38 percent fall in this category. They are also the group least likely to be cohabiting without children, at just three percent. By comparison, 46 percent of Marginal attenders, and half of the Disaffiliated and Not Religious respondents, are single without children, while the rate of cohabiting without children ranges from 10 to 18 percent for these three groups. Among the Committed emerging adults, 44 percent are currently married, while 23 percent of the Marginal attenders are married. Disaffiliated and Not Religious emerging adults are married at rates of 16 and 17 percent, respectively. The Committed emerging adults are also the most likely to have children: 38 percent reported being a parent, and the majority of these regularly attending parents are currently married. Among each of the other three groups, the percent who are unmarried with children is higher than those who are married with children.

Table 6.8 Family Status by Religious Group

Not Religious (%)

Disaffiliated (%)

Marginal (%)

Committed (%)

Married with children

9

8

15

23

Married without children

8

9

8

21

Cohabiting with children

6

7

8

4

Cohabiting without children

18

13

10

3

Single with children

8

14

13

11

Single without children

50

50

46

38

Total

100

100

100

100

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

By each religion measure examined previously, young people who are more religious, both as teenagers and emerging adults, are more likely to be married or have children in early emerging adulthood than those who are more disengaged from religion. Given the age limitations of our sample, we note that we cannot predict the eventual marriage or parenting status of those in our study. But what we can say is that religion is associated with earlier transitions to marriage and parenting among this group of emerging adults. In all likelihood, this will also translate to higher rates of marriage and parenting over the life course, but that is a conclusion that can’t be drawn at this time from these data.

Family and Future Religion

The National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR) sample is consistent with other research that finds that religious individuals generally transition to marriage and parenthood at an earlier age, on average, than those who are less religiously engaged. A parallel question that is of considerable interest is whether the transitions to marriage and parenthood have implications for the ongoing religious lives of young people. That is, does the causal arrow run in the other direction as well? Although religious individuals are more likely to get married and have children in the first place, is it the case that marriage and parenthood act to increase religious engagement for those who make early family transitions? Previous research has found some evidence for increased religious participation among those who are married or have children. In the following section we turn to these questions, looking at how not just religious participation but also self-identified religious salience and change are shaped by new family relationships.

The short answer is that there is still much we do not know about the long-term effect of marriage and parenting on the religious lives of emerging adults. The emerging adults in our study are between the ages of 23 and 28. As we noted previously, this means that many of them have not yet approached the average age of first marriage for people in the United States. Among the respondents in our final sample, just one-fourth are currently married, and another four percent have been married but are currently divorced, separated, or widowed. This means that, for almost 70 percent of the sample, we do not yet know when they will marry or whether marriage will affect their future religious lives. Likewise, just more than 30 percent are parents, leaving a sizeable portion of our respondents yet to experience the impact that children might have on religious belief and practice. However, examining the lives of those in our study sample who have already made the transition to marriage or parenting can offer some insight into the relationship between early family transitions and religious engagement.

Among those who are already somewhat religious, family commitments may encourage more regular attendance at religious services. compares the current religious service attendance of the six family groups, and we see that marriage appears more closely related to attendance than does having children. Married emerging adults reported attending religious services more than those who are not married, regardless of whether they have children. About 35 percent of both groups of married respondents attend weekly or more, and a similar percentage reported that they never attend.

In contrast, among the cohabiting and single emerging adults, weekly attendance ranges from just 3 percent to 16 percent. And reports of never attending religious services are much higher among the unmarried compared with the married respondents. Cohabitors without children have the highest rate of saying they never attend religious services, at 73 percent, with the other three groups falling just above or below the 50 percent mark. While the presence of children was not associated with differing levels of attendance among the married respondents, parenthood is more closely associated with attendance for those who are not married. Among both single and cohabiting emerging adults, those who have children are somewhat less likely to say they never attend religious services compared with their counterparts who do not have children. Fifty-five percent of single respondents without children say they never attend, while among those with children, this drops to 45 percent. Among cohabiting young people, the gap is even larger. When children are present in cohabiting relationships, reports of never attending services drops from 73 to 53 percent.

Figure 6.1 Wave 4 religious service attendance by family status.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Weekly attendance at religious services has declined, on average, across all groups of the emerging adults in our study. And while there appears to be a strong association between family status and attendance, we have established that individuals who are already religious are more likely to get married and have children sooner than their nonreligious peers. So, while the association between family status and attendance seen in is telling, the question of whether marriage and parenthood have a direct impact on the general decline in religious participation deserves further examination. To address this question, we focus on those respondents who were weekly attenders at Wave 3. Among this group of religiously engaged young people, is marriage or parenthood associated with whether they maintained their religious participation when we interviewed them again at Wave 4?

includes only those young people who attended religious services weekly at Wave 3. Among this group of regularly engaged young people, we can see that those who are married were far more likely to remain weekly attenders by Wave 4 than any of the other emerging adult family status groups. Approximately two-thirds of those who are married maintain weekly attendance from Wave 3 to Wave 4. Those least likely to maintain weekly attendance are the emerging adults who are in cohabiting relationships without children, with only 11 percent still saying they regularly attend religious services.

Emerging adults who are cohabiting without children are those who have not made a transition to marriage or parenthood, more conventionally approved family statuses within religious communities. Instead, they are engaging in a relationship pattern that is often discouraged by religious groups. So while these individuals were weekly attenders at Wave 3, they are no longer regularly engaged in a religious congregation. The implication here is that while marriage appears to help young people maintain their religious engagement, cohabitation may serve as a barrier to participation in religious communities. It is possible that individuals in cohabiting relationships no longer feel welcome or comfortable attending religious services. It is also possible that individuals who have disengaged from religion for other reasons find themselves less bound by religious proscriptions against cohabitation and pursue those relationships more readily.

Whatever the causal direction, it is clear that the trajectories of family formation among emerging adults are intertwined with their ongoing religious participation. Given that cohabitation is becoming much more common, this could signal yet another factor that is related to the overall decline in religious service attendance among young people.

Figure 6.2 Wave 4 religious service attendance if weekly attender at Wave 3.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion surveys 2008, 2013.

Attendance at religious services demonstrates one facet of religious engagement. In addition to the public religious practice of service attendance, however, another way to measure religious engagement is to consider the extent to which religion is salient and meaningful in people’s lives. Marriage and parenting may reinforce the practice of religious service attendance, but does it change the role of faith in the personal lives of individuals?

Again, we compare reports from the young people in six different stages of family relationships. shows the percentage of each group who reported that faith is very or extremely important to them as well as those who said it is not important. Looking at the numbers for very or extremely important, we see the highest percentages among those who have family commitments: married with children, married without children, single with children, and cohabiting with children. Emerging adults who are cohabiting or single without children reported that faith is significantly less important compared with the married with children group. These two groups who are not married and do not have children have the most respondents who say that faith is not important to them, at 48 and 36 percent.

Figure 6.3 Wave 4 importance of faith by family status.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

demonstrates how marriage and parenthood affect the salience of faith over time. Looking at only those young people who reported faith to be very or extremely important at Wave 3, this chart shows their reported salience of faith at the time of the Wave 4 survey. The first thing to note is that stability for this measure is greater than for the measure of attendance. Across all six groups, those who reported their faith to be important to them at Wave 3 were quite likely to still report this to be the case by the time they reached ages 23 to 28.

Similar to the findings for attendance, however, the largest change is among those who are currently cohabiting without children. For this group, less than half continued to say that their faith is important to them five years later. The second largest drop in importance of faith is for the single without children group. While all groups show some decline, this decline is the greatest for emerging adults who have not yet married or had children.

Marriage and parenting may not necessarily create an increased importance of faith. However, they do appear to stabilize the faith that emerging adults already have. In other words, when it comes to the personal salience of religious faith, it seems that transitioning into family life has a stabilizing effect. Marriage and parenting are not necessarily causing a significant increase in the importance of faith, but family responsibilities may help to solidify its place in their lives. Conversely, cohabitation is the family status that is most closely associated with a decline in religious salience and appears to have the most disruptive impact on the religious lives of emerging adults.

Figure 6.4 Wave 4 importance of faith if very/extremely important at Wave 3.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion surveys 2008, 2013.

Another way to consider the impact of family relationships on religiosity is to look at self-reported religious change. The emerging adults in our study were asked to reflect on the past five years and to report whether they thought they had become more religious, less religious, or stayed about the same religiously. shows the results of this question across the six family status groups. Emerging adults who are married with children are the most likely to report becoming more religious (41 percent) and least likely to say they became less religious (11 percent) during the past five years. In contrast, those least likely to report becoming more religious are the emerging adults who are not married and do not have children: 18 percent of those cohabiting without children and 21 percent of those single without children.

Respondents were offered the opportunity to give an open-ended answer about the primary reason for why they had become more or less religious. Among those reporting an increase in their own religiousness, about 13 percent mentioned marriage or a partner, and 27 percent identified their children as the primary reason for this change. In other words, 40 percent of the respondents who said they became more religious also said that the change can be primarily attributed to their family relationships.

Figure 6.5 Wave 4 self-reported religious change by family status.

Source: National Study of Youth and Religion survey 2013.

Family commitments may serve as a catalyst for drawing people back to religion. While the results of our analysis are largely consistent with this expectation, we suggest that family transitions encourage religious stability more than religious revival. Caution is necessary in drawing conclusions from these observations because we have only the first scene in multi-act play. The individuals in our sample who have married and had children have done so at an earlier than average age. They are a select group of individuals who we know were already predisposed to be more religious than their peers. We do not want to overstate the claim that marriage or becoming a parent creates a religious awakening. That is more dramatic than what appears to be taking place. Rather, we think marriage and parenting create a context in which individuals may find support for their existing religious identity and practices.

This 23-year-old Conservative Protestant illustrates this point when he discusses the effect of marriage on his church attendance:

I wasn’t too good about going to church when I was in college; I wish I had done a better job with that. I had a church, but there wasn’t any church that I really felt I connected with. . . . A lot of it probably was just me trying to want to sleep in on a Sunday or whatever. But it’s gotten better, because now that we’re a couple and we’re in a different city, we wanted to meet more people, so we’re . . . being intentional about that—joining groups and stuff like that. And so . . . that’s brought a whole lot more to the church and everything, which has been great.

For this young man, having a partner with whom to share the process of seeking out church involvement made a difference in his regular attendance pattern. And while relocating often creates a disconnect from religious communities, in this case, the relocation created an opportunity for him and his wife to get involved in church.

In addition to the practical motive of wanting to meet people, some respondents spoke of the role their marriage played in encouraging them in their faith and keeping them engaged at a personal level. The young man quoted previously went on to say:

I can’t imagine being married to someone who didn’t share my beliefs, because it would be tough not having someone to go to church with or, like, go to classes with and everything. So just having that influence in my life . . . has been really helpful, along with my family and everything like that. But just my life with her now has just been really helpful.

There were others who shared similar sentiments—that their spouse was a partner in religion as well as life. While this was not uncommon to hear, it was certainly not the most common response among the married interviewees. While it was clear that religion was a shared aspect of their lives, many of them did not speak about it as clearly as this or even acknowledge that their marriage influenced their religious commitments in any way. It is not that they would disagree with that sentiment, per se; rather, this young man was more aware and articulate than most about how his marriage changed his religious practices and personal engagement. As we have seen in other areas of our study of these young people, they are often unaware of the social forces that are operating in their own lives.

A common refrain across the long arc of the NSYR has been that a lack of awareness on the part of the participants does not mean that religion isn’t operating at some level in their lives. In this case, the survey data suggest that marriage and parenthood serve as agents to solidify the religious engagement of young people. We do not think they spin people full circle—that is, they are not turning atheists into attenders. More accurately, we think marriage and parenthood stem the tide of religious decline. If young adults marry someone who shares their religious commitments, then that partnership makes it more possible for young people to remain religiously engaged in ways that being single might not. Likewise, when people become parents, they are more likely to want to remain connected to those institutions that offer support and guidance for them as they raise their children. In other words, formal family commitments, whether marriage or parenthood, reduce the likelihood of drifting away from religious engagement.

The other story worth noting here is the impact of cohabitation. Across the analysis of public religious participation, private religious salience, and self-perceptions of religious change, we see that emerging adults who are cohabiting without children experience the most distance from religion, as measured by our survey items. It is evident that cohabiting relationships do not reinforce or support religious engagement in the same way that marriage seems to. Rather, it appears that cohabitation moves young people further from their faith than other family arrangements.

While the causal direction and mechanisms of influence are not specified by our data, this is a trend that is worth paying attention to. Cohabitation has been rising steadily in recent decades and is now the most common pathway to marriage. At the same time, it seems that emerging adults who are involved in these cohabiting relationships are becoming more distant from communities of faith. Discerning the reasons that cohabitors are less likely to remain religiously engaged may be a key factor in understanding the future landscape of the religious lives of this population.

Ashley and Carla

In contemplating the relationships between marriage, parenthood, and the continuation of religious faith, two young women that we interviewed stand out. Their stories are salient not because they are necessarily representative of the larger group of interviewees—in fact, their stories were not common. But they resonate as examples of the potential connection between religious engagement and marriage and parenting, and perhaps as a counter-example to the more common story of the way that marriage and parenting can hold people in their faith. For Ashley and Carla, marriage might be the thing that keeps them from returning to the faith of their youth.

Some readers may recall Ashley—the Abider from A Faith of Their Own. At that time, she was generally quite committed to her Christian faith, although she had some clear ambivalence about the church. In our final interview, Ashley and I met for coffee on a summer afternoon in the Northwest. She told me that life was going well for her and filled me in on the changes in her life since we had last seen each other. She experienced a traumatic breakup with a long-term boyfriend during her last year of college. She had been diagnosed with depression while she was in high school, and this breakup sent her into a significant depressive episode. During this time, she started spending time with a friend she had met during her first year of college. He was supportive of her during her recovery from the breakup. They eventually began dating and are now married. She has decided to return to school to earn a master’s degree and was excited to be starting that program in the coming months.

Ashley seems happy in her marriage. Although they had a rough start to their dating relationship, she describes their current relationship in very positive terms; she says they get along very well and that he is good for her, noting that she has not had a depressive episode in a very long time and that life is pretty stable right now. As the interview progressed, we turned to the topic of religion. I asked Ashley how she would describe herself religiously and she responded:

Religiously, I guess, I’m a Christian who doesn’t attend church. So I still have the fundamental beliefs . . . but it’s been awhile. And I don’t identify as well, like, with the church as well. Like, I never identified terribly well. But I still really believe, like, the core beliefs, in like God and Jesus.

Ashley expresses something akin to regret over the fact that she is not currently connected with a church. She sees the value in that connection and senses the loss of not being part of a church community. But she always had a hard time fitting in at the churches she attended and says it is hard to get motivated to attend church when it is not a place where she feels comfortable. Despite this, she has not ruled it out of her future. I asked what she thinks she will be like religiously at age 40, and she says, “I hope to be more serious about religion. Like, not necessarily in my parents’ church but, you know. To find a community who think similarly to me and be able to spend time with them would be really nice.” So, while she is not currently attending church, she contends that her beliefs are still the same and she hopes to find a church community again in the future.

Ashley reported that her husband is not particularly religious. He was raised by Southern Baptist parents, but they stopped attending church years ago. While he identifies as a Christian, he does not attend church and has no interest in doing so. Ashley reported that he was a philosophy major in college and “he’s not as firm in a lot of the more traditional, like, doctrine.” I asked Ashley if she were to decide to start attending church, whether he would attend with her. Her response was, “Maybe once in a while. But I couldn’t rely on him to, like, happily attend with me.” When I asked how she felt about this, she said, “I mean it’s not thrilling. But it is what it is. It’s like, something I knew going in and, so, I can’t really be angry with him now. But it would be nice if he was like, ‘okay, let’s go to church.’ But, I’m hoping, you know, we’ll see how things progress. I mean he’s open to it, but yeah, it’d be tricky.”

A few weeks later, I am sitting in the corner of a noisy Mexican restaurant in the Southeast talking with Carla. As a self-proclaimed introvert, she admits that she is nervous about the interview and was hoping the restaurant would have been less crowded. She is hesitant throughout the interview, but lights up when we start talking about her fiancé. They have dated for eight years and recently got engaged. She is convinced he is the one for her and is very excited about finally getting married.

During the course of the interview, my questions about religion bring an interesting response. Carla “shoulds” herself a lot: I should know more about my faith, I should go to church more, I should be more involved with my congregation. She lacks confidence in her own knowledge about her faith and repeatedly seems embarrassed that she is not more conversant in this area. Her fiancé is not religious, and Carla does not think that he would consider himself a Christian. In fact, it seems that she struggles to defend her faith against his skepticism and doubt, and while she wants to express her faith to him, she feels intimidated by her lack of knowledge and conviction about religious topics. She says she thinks he will want to raise children in church with her. But I am not sure she really believes this (and I certainly am not convinced, either).

Ashley and Carla both strike me as individuals for whom marriage and parenthood have the potential to bring about renewed religious engagement. Both express some level of regret over their current lack of religious engagement and acknowledge that their disconnect from church is a consequence of competing priorities. There are many demands on their time, and attending church is not compelling at this stage of their lives. They both report that they would like to attend more or be more involved in a religious congregation, but they have not taken the steps to do so. In addition, they both acknowledge that, in an ideal world, they would hope to raise their children in the same faith tradition they were raised in. In fact, they both see the presence of children as a possible motivator for renewed religious engagement. Here, Ashley speculates on the effect that having children might have on her own religiosity:

i : Do you see it getting any easier or more difficult to maintain your religious faith in the future?

r : I think, I’m guessing if we have kids, it’ll be easier. Because that whole thing, like, “Oh, get your kids into church, get your kids into Sunday school.” But I’m not sure that’s really the right reason to do things. But I think that will make it easier [laughs] even though I think that’s really sort of hypocritical.

Carla also wants religion to be a part of her children’s lives. However, before we hear her assertion of this fact, she spends time fumbling through an attempt to explain her fiancé’s position on this issue:

i : If you were to have children, would you raise them in a particular religion or faith tradition?

r : It’s also something that I’ve discussed with my fiancé, and I think since he wasn’t in church a lot growing up, since he was raised by a single parent and no father. . . . I guess in his house, he sees things a little bit differently. He . . . said he wants to go to church, it’s just—God, what did he say the other day?—but yes, I do—I do want to raise my kids. I don’t want them to just go to. . . . I want them to, you know, to go to church with someone with morals and values, what’s right and wrong.

While both women talk about their future children and the importance of raising them in church, they also acknowledge that this will pose a challenge with a husband who is not as committed to the idea of raising children within a religious community. Ashley says that her husband is open to the idea in theory but has no interest in attending church himself. Ashley seems resigned to her husband’s lack of interest, though she acknowledges that their religious differences affect her more than him:

I don’t think that [our differences] bother him. Because for him, it’s. . . . I feel like he’s kind of on the easier side, like not believing, being more casual about a religion and being with someone who’s more serious doesn’t affect him probably as much as me being with someone who is more casual. Because I want him. . . . You know, he doesn’t really care that I’m more serious. Whereas I would like him to be more serious.

While she says she is content with her current situation, she indicates that the religious disconnect between her and her husband may be more of an issue in the context of thinking about the future and the possibility of returning to church once she has children. I ask whether her husband’s lack of religious interest might prevent her from being as religious as she would like to be, and she responds:

r : I think I am okay with where I am. I don’t know if, down the road, like I see it as something that may be a problem at some point. . . . But as of right this moment, it’s okay.

i : Okay, and it might be a problem because of children or something else?

r : Just if I really decide I want to get reconnected, I will want him with me, just because he’s my partner. And so it’ll be difficult if that’s something he really isn’t willing to do.

Although Ashley expresses some regret about her current disconnect from church, and she says she wants to take her children to church in the future, she does not sound optimistic about having the support of her husband. As for Carla, she tells a similar story of a fiancé who is not opposed to her taking their future children to church. Just after telling me that her fiancé would not identify himself as a Christian, she proceeds, unprompted, into the following remarks:

r : I hope in the end that doesn’t become an issue when I do get married and have kids, but I mean it’s stuff I’ve talked about. You know, like, look I’m getting married to you. This is something [chuckles], you know, we got to think about ahead of time. So if we have kids—but you see, he’s not, he’s not opposed to the idea. He does want our kids to be, you know, in church, around, you know, the right crowd of people. . . .

i : So, he wouldn’t be opposed to you if you chose to take them to church?

r : No. Guess I’d go by myself, if I’d have to [laughs]. Nah, he would, he would probably go too. I think he’s up to, you know, trying new things and learning new things.

She ends by saying that she thinks he would go with her if she chose to take the children to church. She is telling me with her words that this is something that he will be on board with. But sitting across the table from her, I see her nervous laughter and hear the doubt in her voice. At the conclusion of the interview, I wrote the following in my field notes: “I got the impression that our conversation seemed to make her consider in a new light the fact that she was marrying someone who is not religious and the potential problems that might cause in the future.”

Religion shapes (or doesn’t shape) the path to marriage and creates a trajectory that continues to operate in people’s lives. Ashley and Carla are examples of women who were raised in religious homes and married at relatively young ages. Ashley married her husband at age 24. At 27, Carla is a little older than Ashley, though it is clear that she has been anticipating and planning for her marriage for a very long time. The timing was constrained by socioeconomic factors as well as the fact that it took her and her fiancé a long time to work their way through college. Carla’s brother and twin sister are already married with children, and she is anxious to “catch up” with them now that she has graduated.

Neither Ashley nor Carla is particularly involved in religion currently. On the one hand, we see the influence of their religious upbringing in the way that the tendency toward early marriage is still operating in their lives. However, stepping away and taking a break from religion shifted their trajectories when it came to selecting a marriage partner. And their choice of a partner, rather than bringing them back to the faith of their youth, will likely solidify their movement away from it, at least in their practice and active engagement, even if not in their core beliefs or personal desire for a future faith for their children.

The stories of Ashley and Carla are not meant to represent the majority of the individuals we talked to. Statistically speaking, we have shown that marriage and parenthood do, on average, create a buffer against religious decline. However, their stories illustrate the potential for marriage to work in the opposite direction. In the same vein as “my marriage partner provides encouragement to my faith,” being partnered with someone who is not religious can present obstacles to remaining engaged in one’s faith. To be fair, Ashley and Carla were already disconnecting from religion when their relationships began. And this disconnection seems to have been a factor in their decision to move forward in a relationship with someone who did not share their faith (we see among the strongly religious more commitment to religious homogamy). But, once that trajectory is set, it makes it even less likely that the forces within marriage or parenthood that could potentially lead them to re-engage will do so, in their case.

The stories of Ashley and Carla stuck with me long after I had completed the interviews that summer, perhaps because of the uncertainty and regret that were just under the surface as they spoke. Or the recognition that this situation was the result of their own choice, unlikely to change, and something they hadn’t really considered much before. It was that sense of the weight of the choices we make as young people that carry implications beyond what we can fathom at the time. Perhaps it was because I could see down the road something that they couldn’t as well; as a social scientist, I am aware of the statistical probabilities that await them. And I feel their ambivalence and their sense that maybe they had missed something.

Conclusion

Throughout this chapter, we have looked at the often reciprocal relationship between religion and family formation. People who are more religious are more likely to transition into family formation sooner in life. Through their religious engagement, they are likely to hear pro-family messages and see family life held up as the normative standard in their religious communities. This social context encourages earlier transitions to marriage and childbearing. In turn, those young people who marry and have children may be looking to religion as a source of support during this life transition. Religious congregations and personal religious faith can offer solidarity and encouragement for the challenges of marriage and parenting. So, young people who are entering into new family relationships are more likely to stay engaged in the religious life that offers support for and normalizes their family choices.

There are those who see the precipitous decline of religion among young people and reassure themselves that they will come back to the church once they get married and have children. We caution that this interpretation of the data may be too generous. The significant delay in marriage and childbearing means that, for many emerging adults, by the time they make these family transitions, they may be so far removed from their previous religious identity that they will not have the kind of connection to religion that would support that renewal of faith. We do not yet have evidence to suggest that those who completely defect will return to religion upon marriage or even parenthood. However, when marriage or childbirth happens while they are still religiously committed, those life transitions can solidify their faith and keep them engaged.

↑ Back to top

↑