Chapter 7 of 16

2. Setting the Context: Transitions to Adult Life

2. Setting the Context: Transitions to Adult Life

we cannot understand the religious lives of emerging adults without first understanding the cultural moment within which they are living their lives. However they embrace and embody religion, they do so in a way that is embedded in a larger social context that is inhabited by family and friends and shaped by work, school, politics, and a variety of other cultural realities. The goal of this chapter is to provide a broad picture of how emerging adults are transitioning to adulthood and of the general cultural setting within which they are making these transitions. Thus, this chapter focuses on important themes and markers of adulthood that are necessary to set the stage for understanding how religion is lived within these contexts. In turn, the themes from this chapter will come up again in different ways in subsequent chapters. Our goal here is to provide a deeper understanding of the social and cultural worlds from which emerging adults approach religion and of how they may be reshaping religion as they transition into adulthood.

Entering Adulthood

The young people in this book are between the ages of 23 and 28, and many are still at the beginning stages of their adult lives. In most cultures, and until recently in the United States, marriage served as the marker between adolescence and adulthood. Yet, marriage, while still important and meaningful in American culture, no longer functions as the definition of attaining full-fledged adult status. Jeffrey Arnett has argued that the primary marker for emerging adults to be considered adults is that they become self-sufficient, which includes taking responsibility for oneself, making independent decisions, and becoming financially independent.

Although there is variation in how they are reaching these markers of adulthood, the young people in this study are moving into adulthood and taking on the traits of self-sufficiency articulated by Arnett. For example, even though most of them have yet to marry and start their families, they are setting out on their own in important ways. More than 70 percent said that they have their own place to live, while 21 percent reported that they still live with their parents. The remainder of the cohort maintain some other sort of living arrangements, such as dorms or other group-style living. This contrasts with many news media stories that suggest that most emerging adults live with their parents well into their 30s. While for some emerging adults this appears to be true, the majority of those in our study are leaving home and establishing their own places to live, which in turn suggests that they are ready to take on more adult responsibilities.

In our interviews with emerging adults, one of our first questions for them was whether they considered themselves to be an “adult.” Their responses indicated that not all of them are convinced that they have reached adult status. In general, this hesitancy revolved around how independent and self-sufficient they considered themselves to be. This then led to a discussion about their age, what they thought it means to be an adult, and how those two variables might be related. Most of the young people we interviewed initially expressed ambivalence about their status as adults, suggesting their location somewhere between late adolescence and adulthood, having yet to achieve full-fledged adulthood. Overall, this idea of attaining self-sufficiency informed their responses. They believed that a central part of what it means to be an adult is being able to take on “adult responsibilities,” like a decent-paying job, the ability to take care of themselves and the independence that implies, and for those who are parents, the responsibility that goes along with having children.

The more responsibilities they had—whether a full-time job, kids, or simply taking responsibility for themselves—the more certain they were that they had reached adulthood. For example, when we asked whether she considered herself an adult, a 27-year-old woman answered, “Yes, I’m a mother [laughs]. I have to be. I wish I was still a kid being able to do my homework and not have to get up every morning and go to work or do the errands and not have to worry about cooking or cleaning, you know? I had to grow up a little bit.”

For most, having a job—and the pay that goes with it—seemed to be a key marker for adulthood. Not only did this signal responsibility and the money to pay their own way, but in many cases, it was a source of pride for them, particularly in terms of the adult obligations and concomitant independence that having a job means. This was true even for those young people still living at home, who on average framed their living situation as a chance to save money or pay back loans. They still considered themselves independent, primarily because they were employed, and regardless of their living situation, felt like they were supporting themselves. For example, a 26-year-old woman told us that she considered herself an adult because, “I’m financially stable apart from my parents. I’m independent of my parents.” Another answered, “Unfortunately, yes,” she did consider herself an adult. She continued, “We’ve [she and her husband] been having this conversation of like do we consider ourselves adults, and I mean basically like we own a condo, [and] are financially responsible for ourselves.” Although she expressed what sounds like disappointment in having reached what she considers adulthood, perhaps betraying a nostalgia for an earlier time in her life, she identified being financially independent of her parents as the marker of adulthood.

Similarly, even those who do not yet consider themselves full-fledged adults primarily pointed to their lack of independence and financial stability as evidence of their not-quite-adult status. Like their peers, they also identified achieving the markers of a stable job, having their own place, and ultimately getting married and having children as indicators of when they would know that they were adults. Michael, who we met in the first pages of this book, said that he still thought of himself as a “young adult,” but his age was at the “cutoff” line of becoming a full-fledged adult. When asked what his criteria would be for knowing that he was an adult, he replied, “I say a career. Like a career as being like a, a big piece. Up until this point I’ve been in school, so I haven’t really had a career. I’ve just been a full-time student. So once I have a career, I see that more as like, what your time is being used for. What you’re about. I see that being a part of adulthood.”

Family and Friends

In our interviews with emerging adults, the overwhelming majority expressed gratitude for their lives, including for their family and friends. Family came up repeatedly in our interviews as they answered our questions, including mentions of both parents and siblings, as well as their marriages, or desire to be married, and the families they were forming, or hoped to form. Most of the emerging adults we spoke with indicated that their relationship with their parents remained close. Even for those with difficult or distant relationships with their parents, these challenges did not seem to be a major source of anger or frustration for most.

In Souls in Transition, Smith and Snell observe a subtle shift in the way emerging adults interact with family and friends. They note that young people seem to have narrowed their social circles, with family and a few close friends becoming more central in their lives while wider networks hold less sway for them. This trend seems to have continued into the final wave of the interviews, with the social worlds for most emerging adults shrinking even beyond what Smith and Snell observed. This development can also have implications for their religious lives. Religion is transmitted and reinforced through networks of family and friends. Thus, as these worlds become more insular for emerging adults, understanding those connections will add nuance to our understanding of their religious lives.

Marriage and Parenthood

A significant marker of adulthood for many emerging adults is the transition from one’s family of origin into new family formation through marriage or parenthood. Becoming a parent—and to a lesser extent, getting married—marks a clear transition to adulthood for many emerging adults. And as we will see in , these family transitions are also interwoven with religious engagement in significant ways. While almost 60 percent of the emerging adults in our study have yet to marry, around one-fourth are currently married, and another 10 percent are engaged to be married. Four percent have been previously married but are now divorced or separated. Thirty-one percent of the emerging adults in the study have at least one child. Thus, at least one-third of the emerging adults are busy forming families—getting married and/or having children. While the majority have yet to embark on that journey, this is definitely a priority for most emerging adults in terms of their life goals and desires.

Regardless of whether they are married at this point in their lives, the idea of marriage was a major theme shaping their lives and giving them meaning. For those who have transitioned into marriage or parenthood, these relationships were highlighted as a major source of responsibility and meaning in their lives. But we also heard them acknowledge the significant impact these obligations have on their life choices and opportunities. For example, among those who had children at a young age, parenthood was clearly a factor that influenced their educational outcomes and the kinds of jobs they had taken to provide support for their families.

For most, however, the limitations that having children may have placed on them were outweighed by the positive aspects of family life. This included the realization that they could no longer focus only on themselves. A 26-year-old woman told us that having children “helped me not be so selfish, and [realize] it’s not all about me.” Similarly, a 28-year-old man told us that his daughter causes him to “take her into consideration before making decisions.” One 27-year-old man acknowledged that having children “brought on a whole lot of responsibilities and made me feel [like] more of an adult.” Still others said that their children had given them direction and purpose. Another 27-year-old man told us that having a daughter had “changed my life dramatically. It’s turned me into the person that I was meant to be . . . [and] I don’t think my parents would be as proud of me if it wasn’t for my daughter.” And, a 27-year-old woman said that her kids provided a “deeper sense of purpose in life, to be more responsible. . . . Having children has changed me 110 percent for the better. It has made me more responsible and given me more drive and more desire.”

Relationships with Parents

Over the 10 years of the National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR) project, a consistent theme has been the importance of parents in the lives of their adolescent and emerging adult children, particularly in shaping the religious trajectories of respondents. Throughout our interviews, we continued to hear about the importance of parents, with many telling us that their parents—either as a couple or individually—were among the people that they most looked up to and respected, and whom they considered as having a significant influence in their lives.

In the survey data, we see that emerging adults reported closer relationships with their mothers than with their fathers, with 66 percent saying that they are very or extremely close with their mother and with 52 percent of those who identified a father figure in their life saying that they are very or extremely close with him. In the in-person interviews, there was a generally positive response to our questions about parents, both mothers and fathers. However, this was often followed by an explanation of the different ways that they were close to their mothers and fathers. Mothers tended to be social and emotional confidants, while fathers were usually framed as a source of practical advice and someone who could get things done for them. A good example is this 26-year-old woman who said that she feels close to her parents in different ways:

My mom and I do the whole let’s talk about like my relationships and you know, that kind of stuff, and my dad and I will have like—I think we have like more . . . serious conversations. Like we’ll talk about the news. . . . I feel like whenever I need something, like how to read my lease, or how do I do something or just like random advice on life type thing. I go to him for that.

This difference in how young people related to their parents can help explain the differences between the reported closeness with mothers and fathers, with mothers filling an emotional role more often associated with the idea of relationship closeness.

It is important to note that not all of the emerging adults we spoke with reported being particularly close to their parents. For these young people, their more distant parental connections seem to be a continuation of the kind of relationship they have had with their parents throughout their lives. This was mostly expressed as a neutral or perhaps benign relationship that was neither close nor a priority, yet with the possibility that it could develop into something more significant in the future. A 24-year-old woman gave a response that was typical for these young people:

interviewer : How close do you feel to your parents these days?

respondent : I’m closer than I was, I suppose. Our relationship’s always just been kind of . . . I can’t even really think of a word to describe it. Very, uh, bland, I guess. You know, it’s not like we have a really close relationship. We don’t have any problems with each other. You know they’re not, they’re not the type of people that I call up with everything I have to say. I don’t share my most intimate, you know, things with them, but you know we’ll, we’ll talk. We get along pretty well.

i : What do you think it’s meant to you being closer to them over time?

r : I mean just kind of a coming to terms with the fact that I was a very surly adolescent and feeling that I have to make up for that, you know? Kind of, also, realizing, like, they’re my parents. They raised me and I definitely owe it to them to share my life with them.

As seen in this quotation, even when the relationship with parents is not ideal, there is a common recognition of the important role that parents play in their lives.

Friends

When we interviewed these young people as teens, they seemed to have long lists of friends, and in response to our questions about their friends, they would tell us in great detail all about each one of them. As noted previously, as emerging adults, their social worlds seem to be shrinking to family (whether families they are forming or with their parents and siblings) and a few close friends. These friendships tended to be formed around common activities and events related to family milestones or opportunities, with children being a factor for some. One 26-year-old told us that his friends, whom he had known since high school, were all having kids, so their socializing tends to be “go[ing] to our kids’ parties and stuff like that,” or just to get together and “hang out.”

For those with no children, friendships tend to form around their activities with a small group of friends—whether long-term or more recent friends from school or work—who shared interests in the same kind of entertainment, such as music, concerts, movies, video games, sports, and the like. Some weren’t even sure what brought them together as friends. This 24-year-old is a typical example. He said, “Most of my friends are different from me. I don’t know what brings us together. We usually bond over video games, food, and music. . . . We rarely talk about politics. Never talk about religion . . . a few of my friends are very religious, but it’s never been something that we’ve bonded over as friends. It’s usually been just food, video games, music, and playing video games, things like that.”

Both friend and family relationships seem to have deepened in many ways, with young people identifying those who are most important to them in response to a question about friendships, rather than enumerating the laundry list of friends that they had described to us when they were teens. So, asking about the ways that they interact with family and friends is important to understanding their participation in and view of the world. In our survey, we asked them to think of up to five of their closest friends, and then asked a series of questions aimed at helping us understand the kinds of people that they surround themselves with: their beliefs, what they talk about, how diverse their friends are, whether they are married or went to college, and other similar things. While an in-depth analysis of emerging adult friendship networks is beyond the scope of this book, what follows are some basic characteristics of the friends of typical emerging adults.

Although most emerging adults in our study have never been married, more than one-half said that they have at least one friend who is married and a similar number of friends who have at least one child. Almost all of them have at least one friend who went to college, and one-third said that they have at least one friend who does not have a job. Although many popular accounts of emerging adults tout their multicultural sensibilities, fully two-thirds of our respondents said that they have no friends of another race.

The close friends of emerging adults are an important component of the larger social context within which they are working out their transition to adulthood, and in particular the contours of their religious lives. When it comes to a simple count, most emerging adults do have religious friends. Three-fourths of them said that they have at least one friend who is religious, and 90 percent said that at least one of their friends has beliefs that are similar to their own. Young people also said that they talk about religion with their friends, with three-fourths of our survey respondents saying that religion is a topic they talk about.

While it may be a possible topic of conversation, our in-depth interviews revealed that emerging adults are not often actually engaging in discussions about religion. One 26-year-old woman told us that she and her friends talk about religion “once in a while, but not very regularly.” To the extent that conversations about religion do take place, they tend to be episodic and based on something that our respondents have recently experienced. These exchanges do not seem to be particularly deep and engaging conversations about faith. A typical response came from another 26-year-old woman who said that she has “certain friends” that she can discuss religion with, but “not really unless something comes up.” This suggests that while religion and spirituality may not be a completely taboo topic for emerging adults, it does not appear to be a particularly important part of their relationships with their friends. Thus, although religion remains a part of the social lives of emerging adults, it figures into their social identities only in a limited manner. They have friends who are religious, but religion does not appear to play a central role in these friendships, either as a shared activity or as a specific discussion topic.

Work, Career, and Finances

As noted at the beginning of this chapter, self-sufficiency is a major marker of having reached adulthood, usually linked to having work or a career and the financial stability that goes along with that. The majority of emerging adults in this study are working at or near full-time hours, with more than one-half working more than 40 hours a week. Including those who are working between 30 and 40 hours each week, almost 70 percent of emerging adults are working at or near full-time hours. In terms of earnings, the two largest groups of young people in our study are those who are earning between $10,000 and $30,000 annually (37 percent), and those who are earning between $30,000 and $60,000 annually (30 percent). Just eight percent earn more than $60,000 annually. Three percent of our respondents declined to report their earnings, and the remaining 22 percent are earning less than $10,000 annually, with seven percent earning no money at all in the past year.

In our interviews, emerging adults said that work and a career, for them, was not only a marker of having reached adulthood but also an important part of their identity. Many described work as a marker of responsibility, autonomy, and respect. For example, for one 28-year-old man, work entailed the responsibility to “do your job correctly,” which for him resulted in gaining “respect from people because you know what you’re doing and you know what’s expected of you and your job.” The desire for responsibility and autonomy was expressed by several emerging adults who spoke about wanting to have their own business someday. Usually, however, they were not quite able to articulate what, exactly, that business venture would be. For example, a 25-year-old woman who was successful in her current job told us that owning her own business was her “dream job.” Yet, she couldn’t envision what that business would be:

i : What kind of business would you like to own?

r : See, that’s the part I don’t know yet. I mean, I manage this whole business [where she currently works], I run that company, and I enjoy it, I just don’t know what industry I would choose if I was doing it myself.

Thus, while the themes of responsibility and self-sufficiency often took on different forms, even if only as an abstract expression of ambition, it was clear that these are primary goals in the lives of emerging adults.

Another common theme was the desire for work to be meaningful and to contribute to our informants’ larger life purpose and overall happiness. In , we heard Heather express the hope of one day finding work that makes her happy and allows her to pursue a greater purpose in life. We heard many of her peers express a similar sentiment about their desire to make a difference, either within the company they work for, or by making the world a better place through their work. A 24-year-old woman said, “It’s never about the money, ’cause you can get money from anywhere. As long as you’re comfortable in what you’re doing, then you’ll be fine.” A 28-year-old man expressed a similar belief, saying that for him, the most important thing in a job or career was “being happy, and if you’re not helping better the world, then at least you’re not hurting it.” Many emerging adults believe work should be more than just a source of financial stability but also offer a sense of identity and purpose. This was expressed as an ideal more often than a lived reality; that is, emerging adults are hopeful that they will one day have work that is meaningful and a source of personal contentment. However, many acknowledge that their current work is simply paying the bills, but is not yet filling their lives with meaning.

Across our interviews, regardless of how religiously committed young adults were, the idea of work contributing to their personal sense of meaning and purpose was frequently expressed. For the most religious informants, this was often, though not always, an obvious outgrowth of their faith or spiritual practice. For the less religious or nonreligious, work may be functioning as an alternative source of meaning in the absence of religiosity. For most emerging adults, regardless of their relationship with religion, work—or the desire for work—was a key part of their identity. Work not only signals that they are responsible and committed people but also serves as a potential, even if not realized, source of meaning and fulfillment in their lives.

Although most young people are working at or near full-time, many are still struggling to make ends meet. We asked emerging adults a series of questions about their relative ability to pay their bills and the amount of their overall debt. One-third said that there was a time over the past year when they were unable to pay a bill, and almost one-fourth said that they had received some form of public assistance at some point in the past two years. When we asked about total current debt, one-third of our respondents reported having no debt or owing less than $5,000 (15 and 18 percent, respectively). Yet, there is a large percentage of emerging adults who have significant debt: 26 percent owe between $5,000 and $25,000, and 12 percent owe between $25,000 and $50,000. Almost one-fourth of the young people we surveyed have debt totaling more than $50,000. Many of them, therefore, are heading into adulthood with a substantial financial burden already on their shoulders.

Given the landscape of financial challenges facing these emerging adults, it is not surprising that significant numbers of young people rely on their parents for various forms of assistance. When asked in our survey about different forms of assistance they may have received from their parents over the past year, about one-third of emerging adults said they had received help from their parents for a place to live, whether providing the place or providing money to pay for rent. Thirty-one percent said that their parents have helped them with groceries, one-fourth had received help with transportation, and close to one-fourth had received help with babysitting and child care. Fewer numbers of these young people had received help with such things as educational expenses (12 percent), money to pay their bills (14 percent), and general spending money (16 percent).

Even though emerging adults receive a wide range of support from parents, when we asked the monetary value of the help they had received, 41 percent said that the total monetary value of assistance provided by parents was zero. Another 27 percent reported receiving assistance of less than $1,000. While young people may not be receiving cash from their parents, they are most certainly receiving assistance with things that would otherwise cost them money that they may not have. Thus, even though the perception of most emerging adults is that this support has little or no monetary value, parents do seem to be supporting their emerging adult children in significant ways.

Despite their current financial struggles and the assistance they receive from their parents, most of the young people we surveyed have a fairly optimistic outlook for their future. Slightly more than half said that they expect to reach a higher standard of living than their parents, while one-third said that they expect to reach the same standard of living. Only 14 percent said that they expect a lower standard of living than their parents. Yet, this optimism, at least among some emerging adults, may be misplaced. Recall Raymond from and his plans to finish a community college program and move on to a successful life. Despite his desire to succeed in school and become self-sufficient, it seems doubtful that he will fully reach his goals, given the limitations within which he is living and his own difficulties with alcohol and drugs. And, as we will see later, Raymond is not alone in this. Many emerging adults seem to have grand plans with no realistic avenue by which to reach those goals.

Caring for Others

Emerging adults overwhelmingly said that they care about important social issues. Almost 60 percent said that they care very much about racial equality and the needs of the elderly, while 51 percent said they are very concerned about the needs of the poor. Another one-fourth to one-third reported caring somewhat about these issues. But, are young people putting this desire to help others into action? Charitable giving is one way to act on values with a relatively low level of commitment. Almost 60 percent reported they had given money to an organization at least once in the past year. However, when they were asked how much of their own money they had donated, one-half of all givers reported donating less than $200, with one-half of those having donated less than $100. Although these numbers are not particularly surprising given the relatively low incomes and financial struggles reported by emerging adults, neither do they indicate a strong commitment to financially supporting the causes they reportedly care about.

So, is it possible that the financial constraints of emerging adults lead them to give of their time instead? This does not appear to be the case. When it comes to volunteering or community service, the level of participation was even lower, with only 42 percent saying that they had volunteered at least once in the past year. When we asked young people how much they had personally helped the homeless or people in need over the past year, just 18 percent said that that they had helped a lot, despite the fact that more than one-half of them reported that they care about the poor very much. Just over one-third reported helping some, and another one-third said they helped others in need a little.

Thus, there are some disconnects between what most emerging adults think or believe about caring for others and what they are actually doing. Most said they are concerned and presumably want to help care for others, but this level of concern seldom results in actual volunteer activities. In our face-to-face interviews, some said that they had volunteered in the past or that they sometimes volunteered, but they had difficulty coming up with specific examples of volunteering and giving. In general, the young people we spoke with were not actively participating in volunteer opportunities in any regular or sustained way. A 24-year-old man provides an example of the desire to volunteer combined with the failure to follow through on that desire. When we asked whether he had volunteered in the past five years, he replied, “I don’t know. I [sighs] . . . I actually don’t know if there have been any real organized clubs or anything that I’ve been a part of. I mean, I always normally do stuff, you know, like I collaborate with different people, but it’s . . . I don’t think there’s really been an official organization that I sign on to, pay membership dues, all of that.”

To the extent that the emerging adults in our study do engage in somewhat regular volunteer activity, this is more likely to be seen among those who are in some way involved in a church or other religious institution, or a community group that provides the organizational structure through which to volunteer. For example, a 25-year-old woman told us that she participates in Junior League and that she does “a bunch of volunteer stuff through them.” Similarly, a 28-year-old man said, “One of the leaders in our [Sunday school] class is the chaplain for the [local] rescue mission, so a few times a year we’ll usually go and help out with a meal there or running a service.”

The pattern we see among emerging adults doesn’t seem to be much different than the majority of Americans, who say that they are concerned or care about certain social issues yet report only modest levels of charitable giving and volunteering. In fact, the numbers reported by our emerging adults are somewhat higher than what other data show. A look at national data from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics reveals that only about 25 percent of Americans 16 years or older engage in any volunteer activity. Thus, it is important to note that, despite many popular reports claiming that young people are more interested and involved in volunteer activities than other generations, they are not all that different from the larger population in this regard.

Politics

Politically, the emerging adults in our study are fairly evenly distributed along the spectrum of liberal to conservative and among Democratic, Independent, and Republican political affiliations. Thirty-two percent classified themselves as slightly liberal, liberal, or extremely liberal, while 28 percent located themselves between slightly conservative and extremely conservative. Twenty-two percent said that they were moderate, and 18 percent said they did not know whether they were liberal or conservative. When asked how they identified in terms of political party, they divided similarly, with 26 percent saying they were Democratic and 20 percent saying they were Republican. The largest grouping is the 38 percent of young people in the survey who said that they are politically independent. The remaining numbers of emerging adults said that they identified with another party or that they did not know whether they would identify as either a Republican or Democrat.

Regardless of how they choose to identify politically, however, the overriding theme among the emerging adults in our study is that they are not particularly interested in or connected to politics. In the survey, more than one-half of emerging adults said that they are either slightly or not at all interested in politics, and only 17 percent said that they are very interested. When we asked whether the subject of politics comes up in conversations with friends, only 14 percent said that it came up a lot, and 37 percent said that it hardly ever or never came up. The frequency of conversations about politics with family shows a similar pattern, although these conversations happen slightly more often with family members. Twenty-three percent of emerging adults said that politics came up a lot in conversations with family members, and 29 percent said that it hardly ever or never came up.

Our in-person interviews confirmed this sense of ambivalence and disconnection that young people feel regarding politics, whether they thought of themselves as conservative or liberal. A 26-year-old woman said that she’s “not a very political person” but that she would identify as a conservative. For her, that means that “if I’m voting for someone, if I choose conservative, they’re probably gonna be more like-minded with me than someone who is liberal, but that doesn’t mean I necessarily agree with them on everything.” A 24-year-old woman said that she wasn’t particularly interested in politics but that she felt “guilty” about her lack of interest. She expressed an even more varied perspective than the 26-year-old quoted previously, telling us that she was “socially very liberal. Very liberal. And I’m fiscally pretty conservative. I’m all about smaller government where it can be downsized. Like, I’m really into efficiency, and bureaucratic systems that are nightmarishly slow and use a lot of time and money make me horribly angry.” And a 28-year-old man told us that while he tried “to be knowledgeable politically,” he really didn’t like politics. He continued, “I feel like a lot of stuff is just party-line voting, and I . . . have a very jaded view of career politicians. Like, I don’t know how beneficial you can be in there.”

This was a common refrain from emerging adults—politics is distasteful, and politicians are simply careerists with no real desire or ability to create change, make the world better, or serve the greater good. This was true wherever they placed themselves on the political spectrum. The 24-year-old young woman quoted previously likened American politics to the television show “House of Cards,” saying:

[“House of Cards”] brought to life everything that I think is going on in Washington. I’m like, yes. There’s definitely shady things going on, like weird deals, [that] aren’t for the people, but are for the people in power. . . . I don’t have a very high feeling for politicians. Not because I think they’re bad people, but I—I feel like they’re working within a system, you know, like, that makes it hard to do good. And so it’s frustrating.

A 26-year-old man told us that, in his view, “Politics is just draining and annoying, ’cause they’re all just—they all say lies, you know? They’re just trying to get your vote. So what they say doesn’t necessarily mean they’re telling me the truth.” This frustration with politics was common across our interviewees. Although we heard emerging adults talk about pursuing a meaningful life and making the world a better place through their work and relationships, it is clear that they generally do not view the political arena as a viable location for realizing these values.

Morals

When discussing moral issues with the emerging adults in our study, we heard a pretty consistent theme. Regardless of whether they identified as liberal or conservative, religious or not, the most common view on social, cultural, and political matters was “live and let live.” In general, they wanted little interference from others—whether family, friends, religious authorities, or government—in determining what is good or bad, right or wrong. The majority of young people come down on what most would consider the liberal side on different social issues, yet their responses should be understood through their basic perspective that personal freedoms—whether their own or others—are of primary importance.

Thus, when we see that 62 percent of emerging adults said that gay marriage should be legal, and 52 percent said that abortion should be legal for any reason, these results reflect the fact that emerging adults are reluctant to judge or legislate against what others choose to do in and with their lives. A typical example comes from a 25-year-old woman. When we asked whether she believed there were any rights and wrongs that should apply to everyone, she told us that she had “never really thought about that.” She continued, saying that morals were simply a matter of “how you choose live your life, you know?” A 24-year-old man told us that he did not believe there were any rights or wrongs that should apply to everyone, “because I feel that is just like a limit, it’s limiting yourself, you know?”

From our informants we repeatedly heard variations on the idea that, regardless of whether they agreed with others on any particular issue or belief, it was not their place to judge those other beliefs, relationships, or actions. Furthermore, they would prefer that various authorities—whether religious or political—also not judge or legislate against beliefs, relationships, or ways of life. Consistent with this position, almost 60 percent of our respondents said that they believe that religion is a private matter best left out of public or political affairs. For example, when we asked whether religion should have a role in public debates, a 27-year-old man said, “I think we should be able to express our opinions and beliefs, but I don’t think those should be mandated to people that don’t believe them.” A 24-year-old woman took a stronger stance on religious beliefs in the public sphere, saying, “No, I think it’s personal. Whatever you believe depends on you.”

We heard from emerging adults that religion can serve as a source of moral good in society. Specifically, it can provide moral teachings for children and encourage believers to do good things in the world, such as feeding the poor. As a 24-year-old woman told us, “From a practical standpoint, I feel like there are truths within each religion. And I feel like the whole moral part of religion is really useful. The whole idea of getting direction and everything derived from those texts is important.”

But this perspective has its limits. From the viewpoint of most emerging adults, religion should not be used to justify the imposition of one’s morals or values on others. And in general, emerging adults have a negative view of individuals or groups that they perceive as seeking to limit the freedoms of those who don’t share the same commitments or religious values. The distaste for being “too religious” that we heard when our research subjects were younger continues to be voiced as they enter adulthood, with a particular concern about how extreme religious ideology might infringe on people who do not share those views.

This theme of “live and let live” and freedom from moralistic judgment or legislation helps to contextualize our subjects’ responses to other survey questions about morality. When asked whether it is sometimes okay to break rules if it benefits them personally, only 8 percent agreed with this, while 86 percent disagreed. This suggests that they hold themselves to a particular moral standard of not breaking the rules. But when it comes to more universally applied moral guidelines, there was less agreement. Thirty-seven percent of young people agreed with the statement that “morals are relative, there are no definite rights and wrongs for everybody,” while 56 percent disagreed with this. The remaining seven percent answered, “I don’t know.”

In a similar vein, emerging adults were almost evenly divided on whether moral standards should adapt to social and cultural changes, with 43 percent saying that they should adapt and 47 percent saying that they should stay the same. These numbers suggest that about one-half of the young people we spoke with were not moral relativists but instead believed in concrete moral principles. And our interviews confirm that many do agree that there are at least some things that would qualify as universally moral or immoral. For example, when we asked them whether there was anything that would be wrong for all people, “killing another person” was the most common reply. Likewise, the idea that it is wrong to do anything that would “hurt others” was provided as an example of a universal moral stance. However, when we asked what they meant by “hurting others,” they often had difficulty expressing what that would mean in practice, whether that was restricted to physical violence or would include hurting another person emotionally.

After we moved beyond the moral universals of not killing others and doing no harm, we heard from these emerging adults a moral and cultural relativity that made it difficult for them to articulate general moral principles. They were confident in their ability to determine right and wrong for themselves but did not have much language for talking about morality in a larger sense beyond their own concerns. Most could not think of a scenario in which they were unsure of what was good or bad, or right or wrong, nor could they provide concrete examples of actions or perspectives that were morally good and bad. For most, morals were self-evident and didn’t take a lot of thought—you “just know,” or in many cases “feel,” what is right and wrong. For example, one 26-year-old man told us that, for him, “It’s just a natural thing. I think you just—maybe it’s because of how I was raised or my religion—it’s just there. I’m sure before I was like, ‘What makes this right?’ But now it’s just so ingrained. You just know what you feel is the best way to handle things.”

This young man’s description of feeling his way toward moral decision-making reflects the concept of “moral intuition,” that moral judgments are rooted in embodied, emotional reactions that precede rational explanation. There are some things that are so deeply embedded in culture and everyday interactions that they become ingrained in individuals at an intuitive level, even though they may not be able to express or verbalize this “tacit knowledge.” This understanding may be embodied or experienced even if not fully articulated, like being able to recognize a familiar face in a crowd even if we can’t explain exactly how or why we recognize someone. When emerging adults are unable to articulate any deeper moral reflection, it is easy to conclude that they lack a moral framework or are uninterested in questions of morality. And this may be the case for some emerging adults. It may also be that they have never been presented with the need to articulate specific moral principles because there is a shared assumption that these things are “just known” and understood within their cultural context.

For example, as we heard in , Kristen was among the few young people we spoke with who said that her sense of morality comes from outside of herself, pointing in part to her religious upbringing. Recall that she said, “It’s a lot a part of who I am and . . . what I’ve learned from church and the Bible and from God. . . . It [right and wrong] usually is evident just because of who I am, but who I am is not because of me.” Her comments suggest that “who she is” is the result of the way she was raised, her church involvement, her commitment to her religion, and the like. Yet, even as she acknowledges the influences that created her sense of morality, she now relies on a self-evident, ingrained moral sensibility to guide her decision-making. The assumption is that intuition and personal character can be trusted, and as long as one is a good person, the choices one makes are, by default, the “right” thing to do.

Thus, in what can appear to be a rootless moral outlook, what these emerging adults learned and experienced growing up forms the core of their moral compass, which then frames their own sense of morality in everyday situations. Of course, some young people were better at expressing this idea than others. But while they were almost universally reluctant to judge others’ lifestyles and moral choices, they themselves “just know” what is right and wrong because they have absorbed moral guidelines—including the notion that judging others is to be avoided—from parents, schools, peers, teachers, pastors, media, and other sources. For emerging adults, it seems easy to figure out what is right and wrong in any given situation. What is difficult for them is that they are not comfortable making grand moral claims for all people in all places. This may be related, in turn, to their ambivalence about moral and religious authorities who do make such universalistic claims. Yet, even their general disdain for politics and politicians shows that emerging adults do have baseline moral stances that guide their lives, and these have generally to do with honesty, integrity, and treating others well. How these concepts are defined for them, however, is highly dependent on their own individual experiences growing up and on how those experiences have helped to form their moral understandings.

Life Outlook

Overall, emerging adults have a positive, optimistic, and forward-looking outlook on their lives. Almost 90 percent said that they think about and plan for their future very or fairly often, and almost 70 percent said that they are more optimistic now than they were five years ago. Only 13 percent of emerging adults said that they are less optimistic now than they were five years previously.

In our survey, we asked emerging adults to respond to several statements related to how they generally viewed their lives, asking how they perceived their goals or direction in life, whether they lacked direction and purpose, and whether they believed that they had the personal agency required to make important changes in their lives. Approximately two-thirds of the young people in our study agreed or strongly agreed that in most ways their life is close to ideal (62 percent) and that the conditions of their life are excellent (63 percent). Similarly, 73 percent said that they were satisfied with their life.

Similar numbers of emerging adults said that they have direction and goals in their lives. Almost three-fourths of the young people (73 percent) disagreed or strongly disagreed with the statement: “Your life often seems to lack any clear goals or sense of direction,” and 74 percent answered the same to the statement, “You don’t have a good sense of what it is you’re trying to accomplish in life.” Seventy-seven percent agreed or strongly agreed with the statement: “Some people wander aimlessly through life, but you are not one of them.” When we asked about meaning in life, 69 percent said that life rarely or never feels meaningless. Similarly, almost 50 percent said that they thought about the meaning of life very or fairly often. Another 34 percent said that they thought about the meaning of life sometimes, and only 6 percent said that they rarely or never thought about the meaning of life.

When it comes to focusing on the needs of others versus their own needs, one-half (51 percent) said that they were at least somewhat more focused on the needs of others than they were five years ago. Twenty-six percent said that they were about the same as five years ago, and 23 percent said that compared with five years ago, they are currently more focused on their own needs than on the needs of others.

The way that these young people expressed how they view their lives can be understood as the different ways that they are settling into their roles as emerging adults. This includes not only the increased responsibilities that they are taking on but also how they believe that their lives will progress. Much of their perspective is based on their hopes for the future, yet many of them expressed dreams and goals that seemed unattainable, given their current situations.

In our interviews with emerging adults, we heard them talk of big dreams for their lives and their aspirations to do work that they are really engaged with and that is personally meaningful for them. Yet, often what they described as their life dreams and goals seemed disconnected from any realistic path to get there. That is, their dreams and goals for their lives seemed out of reach in light of their current education, work experience, and relationships. They had no real plans to achieve those goals, which seemed more an expression of their personal interests than the drivers for long-term planning and preparation. A typical response comes from one 25-year-old man. When we interviewed him, he was a bartender and played in a band but told us that he “wanted to finish school and get into the medical field, just to make some money.” He added, “But then I would also like to, on the side, start to build my own line of guitar and bass-effects pedals, and maybe build different types of electronic instruments. Eventually I’d like to teach, maybe. I don’t know, I want to do a lot of different things.”

Another example is found in the statements of a 27-year-old man who worked for a video production company during college. He shared with us that his long-term goals include “running my own business. My dream job would be doing video stuff, writing movies, making movies—stuff like that. Or being in a rock band.” While his work experience is more directly related to his stated life goals, he has yet to narrow down his options or map out a path that might get him there.

It is not uncommon for young people to have a variety of dreams and goals that are not yet narrowed down, and in some ways, we should expect them to have this outlook at this stage of their lives. Thus, rather than taking a view that insists they have their life goals mapped out with a logical and reasonable path to achieve them, many are still dreaming big, and sometimes contradictory, dreams. What was notable, however, was how little they seemed to be prepared to actively pursue these goals or to adjudicate between the often-conflicting life paths they imagined for themselves.

Thus, these life goals and dreams seem to be about the kinds of things they could do, things that interest them, that in the abstract are still possibilities to consider. The practicality of reaching one or another of these goals seems less important than the notion that they can think about their life potential in these big ways. They seem to understand themselves as still being young and thus having plenty of time to change their mind as their life develops.

Regrets

Throughout the interviews with emerging adults, as they talked about the ups and downs, successes and setbacks across many areas of their lives, we heard some expressions of regret or disappointment with specific things such as educational pursuits cut short or career plans unrealized. Toward the end of the interview, we asked them to look back over their life as a whole and consider whether they had any regrets or whether there were things they wish they had done differently in their lives. Despite some of the specific regrets we heard discussed in earlier sections of the interviews, when asked to provide a global assessment, again and again our informants insist that they have no regrets.

These responses do not necessarily deny the impact of life challenges or poor decisions; rather, emerging adults frame all of their past decisions or experiences as instrumental in making them into the people they are today. To acknowledge regret would seem to them to be equivalent to rejecting their own identity. For example, one 27-year-old told us that he didn’t think of events in his life in terms of regret. Instead, he said, “I think that . . . whatever happens, happens for a reason, but it’s just kinda . . . you gotta take everything by how it’s given to you. I mean, you can regret what you did, but I really do think that if you were to change certain things from your past, that would change who you are. It might not change you in a huge way, but it has the potential to . . . I don’t think you would be the same person.” A 24-year-old expressed a similar viewpoint about his past experiences making him uniquely who he is now:

r : So far, I’ve learned not to regret anything, because it’s helped me be who I am today. Without those experiences, I wouldn’t be who I am today. There’s some things that I would change that I can’t, really. But at the same time, I can’t really say that I would, because I know I would be different if those things were changed. You know, I would like to say that I wouldn’t have to go through all those experiences when I was a teenager, with all the drugs and stuff, but without it I don’t know where I’d be, I don’t know who I’d be.

i : Is there anything wrong with identifying those as regrettable? Is there a problem saying those are regrets?

r : Not really. . . . I mean, some are probably regrets. But they’re not regrets. I mean, they’re. . . . I’ve come to this point where I’ve accepted those things, I’ve realized what those things were, those experiences were. And I’m happy with them, because I like who I am and I’m happy with who I am, and I know that I’m only who I am today because of all the experiences.

Thus, for emerging adults, regardless of how difficult it may have been, the past is interpreted as being instrumental in the formation of their present lives, making them who they are. Many ascribed to the perspective that everything in life happens for a reason and should therefore be accepted and appreciated as a necessary part of their life. They may acknowledge that they made some bad decisions in the past—whether related to drugs, relationships, or other things—but those relationships, actions, and experiences are valued as a key part of who they are, and they serve as a baseline from which to measure who they want to be in the future. This perspective fits well with their general optimism about the future. It is easier to be optimistic in the face of setbacks when one frames all life events, whether positive or negative, as necessary building blocks for the future.

What Is Important in Life

In our survey, we asked emerging adults to rank different aspects of life in order of their importance for achieving the kind of life that they want to live. The results show that young people overwhelmingly favor close relationships with family and friends over most other aspects of life. The top three ranked items that emerging adults identified as very or extremely important in their lives are to have a good family life (92 percent), a close set of friends (89 percent), and a fulfilling romantic relationship (80 percent). Considering the focus on religion in this book, it is particularly interesting to note that just less than one-half of emerging adults (49 percent) said that having a close relationship with God is very or extremely important for them to have the kind of life they desire. Indeed, when we asked them to select the one item that was the most important for them to have the kind of life they wanted to live, 40 percent said that having a good family life was most important, while only 23 percent said that having a close relationship with God was most important. This percentage of emerging adults is almost matched by the 17 percent who said that having a close relationship with God was the least important thing necessary for them to live the kind of life they desired.

In our face-to-face interviews with emerging adults, we again asked about what they value as most important in life. Their responses were remarkably consistent with the survey responses noted earlier. While some mentioned a job or earning money as an important necessity in life, most discussed relationships, whether with family or close friends, as being the most important thing in life. They recognize that these close relationships are reciprocal, that they get fulfillment out of contributing to the lives of their friends and family members, just as their own lives are enriched through their relationships. For example, a 28-year-old man said, “I think it’s probably just your direct relationships with other people. So, probably primarily family, but also just how that extends into friends and church and . . . I think part of that global responsibility. Like, you know, having good relationships.” A 24-year-old woman told us, “I feel like the important things are just, like, happiness. So like, how would we define that? I define happiness by having, like, close relationships with the people around me, and . . . laughing a lot, and . . . enjoying things and . . . having the—the freedom to do—and, like, the flexibility to . . . do what I want.”

Conclusion

Overall, emerging adults are steadily reaching key markers of adulthood, such as living on their own, working full-time, and, for many, marriage and children. Emerging adults generally consider themselves to be adults, although there is some reluctance and ambivalence about describing themselves as “full-fledged” adults, a status marked by independence and self-sufficiency. Yet, their perceived self-sufficiency is not without potential problems. Although most work at or near full-time hours, they are clustered in the lower income brackets, and significant percentages of them are carrying large amounts of debt. Despite these challenges, most believe that they will ultimately achieve a higher standard of living than their parents.

As the social worlds of emerging adults have narrowed since they were teens, their focus has shifted to family and much smaller circles of friends. Their friends tend to be more like them than different, and they reported that marriage and children are an important—or hoped for—part of their lives. Their primary focus on family, friends, and themselves seems to be the counterbalance to their view of and participation in larger scale social institutions. In general, emerging adults are fairly distant from politics and political institutions and rarely volunteer with local organizations.

Overall, however, emerging adults are taking ownership of their lives and the situations in which they find themselves. Most have a generally positive view of their lives, although this might seem an overly optimistic perspective for many of them. Their optimism is coupled with a lack of regret for bad decisions and challenging life experiences; instead of lamenting setbacks, they tend to frame everything in their lives as “happening for a reason.” Their confidence in some form of larger purpose in their lives suggests some residue of religious or spiritual outlook, even though, as we will see in the next chapter, they are moving away from any significant religious or spiritual commitments and involvements. What do their religious lives look like in more detail? We pursue this question in .

↑ Back to top

↑