Chapter 5 of 16

Introduction

Introduction

i had arranged to meet Michael for our interview at the same Starbucks where I had interviewed him five years before. As was the case with many of the young people I was interviewing, I had spoken to Michael in each of the three preceding waves of data collection for the National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR).

I had always been impressed with how polite and respectful Michael was and with the thoughtfulness of his responses. I was looking forward to hearing how his life had progressed since we had last talked.

Michael was 14 years old when we first met, and his mother and her then-boyfriend (now her husband and Michael’s stepfather) had begun going to church “a lot more” than they had been. Michael was “hoping to become more active over the next few years” in the church they had started attending. In our interview two years later, he reported that he had become more involved in the church and that the family joke was that he was becoming the “preacher’s pet.” When I interviewed him for the third time, when Michael was 19, he said that his beliefs had “really been shaken lately.” He had been researching the relationship between religion and politics and had concluded that religion had “been created to control the masses.” As a result, he was becoming disillusioned with religion, was not sure what was true and what was made up by those in power, and in general was questioning his beliefs and moving away from his faith and church community. Now 24 years old and having recently graduated from college, Michael identified as “not religious.” I wanted to learn what had happened.

When I asked Michael about his current religious beliefs and practices, he told me that he definitely doesn’t acknowledge himself as being religious. He has remained respectful of religion, saying that religion is a good source of moral teachings, but he seemed a bit frustrated that he still makes some decisions based on his past religious ideas: “I still feel like, every now and then, I still hold those values. So, even though I don’t want to be religious, I don’t feel like I believe in God, but I still feel like every now and then. . . .”

Although he does not consider himself religious, Michael does say that he is “a little spiritual. Not very spiritual.” For Michael, being spiritual is “like that good feeling. I know back when I used to be religious, you go to church, you practice or whatever, and at the end of a service you have, like, this good feeling. You feel empowered, your steps feel lighter. That’s kind of like what spiritual is.”

Michael is not representative of all American young people. But his story does illustrate the changes and struggles that many young people are experiencing as they enter adulthood and find themselves making decisions about aspects of their lives—like religion—that had previously been made for them.

What do the religious and spiritual lives of American young people look like as they reach their mid to late twenties, enter the full-time job market, and start families? Most recent media stories, as well as some social scientific research, show that young Americans are rapidly leaving the religions of their youth and now claim no religious identity. Religious leaders have observed large losses of younger members in their organizations and, in many cases, are worried about how to respond. Other reports suggest that, even though these young people are leaving institutional religion, they are busy seeking out alternative spiritualities and can best be described as “spiritual but not religious.” This designation suggests that, like Michael, they maintain a sense of spiritual searching and perhaps some forms of spiritual practice, but they generally are looking outside the confines of a traditional religious institution such as a church, synagogue, mosque, or temple.

A different view is presented in a recent book by Tim Clydesdale and Kathleen Garces-Foley, who argue that young people are not leaving religion en masse as other sources claim. Instead, in their analysis, young adults attend services at “high” rates, are otherwise religiously and spiritually involved, and maintain a commitment to spiritual practices. Clydesdale and Garces-Foley intentionally present an “optimistic story” about young people and religion as a corrective to what the authors see as the bad news that has been widely reported about young adults and religion. Indeed, their book does present a very positive view of the religious lives of young adults, in the end describing them as “postmodern pilgrims” who are actively seeking out a robust and fulfilling religious and spiritual life.

What are we to make of these two almost opposing interpretations of contemporary youth religiosity? While it is clear from available data that we are witnessing a significant increase in the number of young people claiming they are not religious, what does this actually mean? Are they leaving behind the religious involvements of their youth? Are they simply feeling more comfortable acknowledging a distance from religion that had existed all along?

Setting the Stage

This is the capstone book from the NSYR. The NSYR began in 2002 with a nationally representative sample of youth ages 13 to 17 and followed these same young people through four waves of surveys, ending when they were between the ages of 23 and 28. Each wave of surveys was accompanied by a set of in-depth interviews with a subset of the survey population. This methodology allows us to confidently describe continuity and change in the lives of these young people over a crucial developmental period in their lives.

Over the 10 years of the study and the four waves of data collection, multiple books have been published, each analyzing the latest data while taking into account how these young people had changed since the previous rounds of data collection. Thus, in the first NSYR book, Soul Searching, Christian Smith and Melinda Lundquist Denton analyzed the first wave of data collection and developed several themes, including our respondents’ difficulty in articulating exactly what they believed. The authors introduced the concept of “Moralistic Therapeutic Deism” to describe how teens conceptualized and interacted with God as a relatively remote being interested primarily in their happiness. In A Faith of Their Own, Lisa D. Pearce and Melinda Lundquist Denton described the changes in the religious and spiritual lives of these young people from Wave 1 to Wave 2, and specifically examined how our subjects were devising different strategies to make their relationship with religion “their own,” rather than something they simply inherited from their parents, regardless of whether they were moving away from religion or becoming more involved. Souls in Transition, by Christian Smith and Patricia Snell, analyzed changes in these young people when they were ages 18 to 23 and introduced the concept of “emerging adulthood” as a framework to understand how changes in religion among the young people in this study were related to broader changes in American society that had created a new social-psychological developmental phase for young people (more on that later).

In this book, we focus on these same emerging adults, now between the ages of 23 and 28, showing where they are now in their lives as well as how their views of and participation in religion and spirituality have changed. We track changes across the 10 years of data collection, thus allowing both an analysis of our subjects’ religious lives currently and how their religiousness has changed and developed.

Emerging Adulthood

When the NSYR project started in 2002, all of the subjects were teenagers, and the first two books were about how adolescents understood and approached their religious and spiritual lives as they moved through their teen years. Beginning with Souls in Transition, emerging adulthood became an important concept through which to think about how the religious and spiritual lives of these young people related to other aspects of their lives.

Emerging adulthood represents a relatively new stage of development between adolescence and adulthood. Psychologist Jeffrey Arnett, who coined the term and has written extensively on emerging adults, argues that this new period in the lives of young people is the result of changes in society since the 1970s, particularly the fact that Americans are getting married and having children later than they used to. Arnett argues that the sexual revolution, the broad availability of the birth control pill, and the increasing numbers of young people attending college—including a great increase in the number of women in college—have all contributed to the development of this new phase of life.

As a result, there is now an extended period in the lives of young people—Arnett puts this range from ages 18 to 29—when “emerging adults” are still figuring out their lives. Arnett cites five characteristics of emerging adulthood: (1) identity explorations, in which young people are “trying out various possibilities, especially in love and work”; (2) a period of instability for the individual; (3) a time of intense self-focus; (4) a time of transition, or “feeling in-between” as neither adolescent nor adult; and (5) a time of possibilities, as young people face great opportunity to transform their lives. Emerging adulthood is indeterminate in the sense that emerging adults haven’t quite figured out who they are or where they are going in life, but it is also characterized by a sense of optimism in that they sense the opportunity to make their own way in the world.

In this book, we retain the concept of emerging adulthood because it remains a useful framing device to help us understand the larger context of the lives of young adults and how religion fits into their lives. Thus, to the extent that the other areas of their lives are in flux, we should expect that their religious and spiritual lives are as well.

Yet, the concept also raises certain issues to keep in mind as the reader moves through this book. As defined by Arnett, the age range for emerging adults is eighteen to twenty-nine, with the argument being that the experiences noted previously are particularly acute among young people in that age range, and they have yet to enter into “full-fledged” adulthood. Arnett provides a precise rationale for why “emerging adult” is the most accurate description for this developmental stage, as distinct from “late adolescence,” “young adult,” “transition to adulthood,” and “youth.” A significant part of his rationale is age-based. In other words, emerging adulthood describes young people between the ages of 18 and 29, and their experiences during that time period are common across all individuals in this age range in particular sociocultural contexts that have undergone shifts, including delayed marriage, delayed childbearing, and the like.

The implication is that as one moves out of the emerging adult age range, one will enter “young adulthood.” Yet, it is important to note that there is variation within this age group in terms of when particular individuals achieve the different status markers that would designate them as an adult rather than as an emerging adult. Thus, it is important to keep in mind that how particular individuals develop along the life course may vary from what is true for the larger group. That is, some people reach the markers of “full-fledged adulthood” well before they reach the upper limit of the 18- to 29-year age range, while others don’t reach those markers even as they move into their thirties.

Further, our data show that many emerging adults believe themselves to be “adults,” regardless of whether they’ve reached the traditional markers of marriage and parenthood. Thus, it is important to keep in mind not only the psychological and sociological categories that researchers impose on their subjects, but also how their subjects think and act in constructing their own identities—in this case, whether they believe themselves to be “full-fledged adults” as well as how their actions and choices reflect that self-identification.

We also need to point out that the young people in this book are all between the ages of 23 and 28, the older half of the emerging adult age range. Thus, while we use the term emerging adult throughout the book, the reader must keep in mind that we are not referring to all emerging adults, but only to those who are in the 23- to 28-year-old age range.

Emerging Adults and Generations

It has become popular over the past several years to engage in a type of pop sociology that trades on supposed differences between generations—baby boomers, Gen X, and millennials. Although the young people in this book are considered within the age range of the “millennial” generation, we do not refer to them as “millennials.” Despite the popularity of using these kinds of generational groupings, any analysis based on differences between generations presents significant methodological problems that make such an analysis difficult, if not impossible. This is particularly true if the analyst attempts to determine how different perspectives on life can be attributed to being born in a particular generation.

Further, this book is not intended to be a “generational” analysis that would demonstrate how this cohort of emerging adults is different from or similar to their parents’ or grandparents’ generation. Emerging adulthood is a stage through which successive generations will all pass, not one that is unique to one or another generation. Thus, this book is an analysis of the spiritual and religious lives of emerging adults: what they currently think and believe about religion, their religious practices and affiliations, and how these have changed, or not, over the course of their development from adolescence to emerging adulthood. It is important to remember that emerging adults are developing through a life stage, and the kinds of changes we see them experiencing—particularly in their religious beliefs, practices, and involvements—are a part of the “identity work” that they are pursuing during this phase of their lives.

Looking Ahead

Throughout this book, we look beyond the stories that argue that emerging adults are either overwhelmingly leaving religion or earnest spiritual seekers whose religious involvements and commitments remain a significant part of their lives. We show that while the dominant trend across the 10 years of this study is that young people are moving away from religious belief and involvement, there is a parallel trend in which a small, religiously committed group of emerging adults claim faith as an important fixture in their lives. Yet, whether religiously committed or not, emerging adults are increasingly personalizing, customizing, and compartmentalizing religion in ways that suit their individual needs and desires.

The God of emerging adults has become increasingly remote from their everyday concerns and rarely enters their thinking or occupies any real place in their lives. Instead, emerging adults have personalized God to serve their idiosyncratic needs and desires. In the process, they have transformed their conception of God from a powerful being or force that exists “out there” to their own personal pocket God—a God that they can carry around with them, but that exerts little power or influence in their daily lives. God functions, in a sense, like a smartphone app—readily accessible, easy to control, and useful but only for limited purposes.

As emerging adults strive to become “full-fledged” adults and take on the kinds of responsibilities that are associated with adulthood, they are also making important choices about their lives, including whether and to what degree religion will continue to be a part of their lives going forward. Whatever choices emerging adults ultimately make will inevitably be linked to both their personal desires and aspirations, and the larger cultural and social context in which they were raised and are now entering as adults. In turn, understanding the changing relationship between emerging adults and religion provides a window into the future of religion and, more broadly, American culture. We hope this book begins a conversation about what that potential future may look like as emerging adults take their place as leaders in their religious institutions, communities, and the wider society.

↑ Back to top

↑