Conclusion: Emerging Adults and the Future of Religion—Making Sense of It All
emerging adults are , overall, moving away from formal religious beliefs, practices, and participation in religious institutions. Even for those emerging adults who maintain a place in their lives for religion, it tends to be treated as just one part of their lives among many, not necessarily more important than any other. One explanation of their changing religious and spiritual ideas, beliefs, and practices is that this is part of their “identity exploration” resulting from their in-between status—no longer adolescents, not quite adults. For emerging adults, religion just doesn’t fit particularly well with who they understand themselves to be.
The young people in our study do express almost unbridled optimism about their own ambitions to pursue opportunities and dreams, however unrealistic these may be. Recall, for example, John and Raymond from , who each seem to have an optimistic outlook that is disconnected from the reality they are living. This applies to religion, too, as we heard from emerging adults who are no longer religious but held out the option that “anything can happen,” whether a return to church, an interest in meditation, or a self-styled spirituality. They are hopeful that there is a life after death, but they are uncomfortable with the idea of hell. As Heather said, “I don’t really do hell.” Yet, digging a little deeper exposes their general lack of interest in actually doing anything related to religion and spirituality.
The five characteristics of emerging adulthood that we outlined at the beginning of the book—(1) identity exploration, (2) a period of instability, (3) a time of intense self-focus, (4) a time of transition or “feeling in-between,” and (5) a time of possibilities—at least imply that emerging adults are thinking deeply about their lives and trying to determine who they are and who they might become. And some emerging adults do pursue such introspection and personal development. Yet, we do not think this is the norm for emerging adults. Rather, they tend to be mostly pragmatic in their dream-making, whether about a career, marriage, kids, or religion—they ask, “Does this work for me?” They are not as self-aware as those five characteristics might lead one to believe, particularly as they think about and enact their religious and spiritual lives.
This is not to say that these different characteristics fail to capture the context within which emerging adults are living. Rather, emerging adults are largely passive in how they approach their “identity work,” particularly in how they think about the role of religion and spirituality in their lives. Thus, contrary to the claims made by some scholars that emerging adults are “spiritual but not religious” or “postmodern pilgrims” who are actively seeking out new spiritual experiences, practices, and communities, we find that they are not, on average, pursuing any sort of spiritual quest or pilgrimage.
Despite the general decline and move away from religion among emerging adults, they do not seem so much opposed to religion or to religious organizations, at least in the abstract, as they are uninterested in religion, at least as they have experienced it. In general, they simply find it inconsequential in their lives. This is certainly true for those who identify as Not Religious, but we can also hear echoes of this among those who remain committed and active in their faith.
Emerging adults who consider themselves Not Religious are the most obviously disengaged from religion. Yet, they are not all completely “secular.” For some, the religion of their youth still operates at a residual or background level, as evidenced by belief in God or an impulse to pray when they feel as though they need help or guidance at a particular moment. This is not to say, however, that religion has any sort of real presence in their lives. Rather, they are open to and acknowledge the possibility of religion, while maintaining a personal distance from any religious tradition or community. Thus, religion remains largely irrelevant; they are neither for it nor against it. For the Not Religious, to the degree that religion exists in their lives at all, it is as a more or less theoretical or abstract option, but one that they are unlikely to ever choose for themselves.
Disaffiliated emerging adults are those who maintain a religious identity but are otherwise uninvolved with religion. They maintain a peripheral connection to religion, more as a cultural identity marker than as a meaningful spiritual commitment. They often expressed “hope” that there might be something beyond this life, and given this glimmer of possibility, they are not willing to completely reject their religious beliefs or identity. Many think religion should be part of their lives, even though it isn’t—as opposed to the Not Religious, who don’t seem to feel the same regret.
Overall, these emerging adults do not have strong negative feelings toward organized religion. Yet, despite their generally positive feelings and their maintenance of a vestigial religious identity, they exhibit no personal interest in having any involvement with religion or religious institutions. Religion doesn’t really affect or benefit their lives in any direct, practical, everyday sense. Religion occupies a residual space for them, where it would “be nice” if religious claims were true, but most likely they aren’t, so it is not worth the investment of time and energy to pursue. Although they may participate in some limited forms of spiritual practice, these tend to be specific and idiosyncratic to the individual and his or her background.
The group of emerging adults who have a Marginal involvement with religion seem best understood as occupying the space between the Disaffiliated and the Committed, tending more toward the former than the latter. However, they are distinct from the Disaffiliated emerging adults in that they put more importance on faith than do either the Disaffiliated or the Not Religious. We can divide the marginally committed into two further types. First are those who are “hanging on,” thinking that religion might ultimately prove true, and if so, might gain greater meaning in their lives. At present, however, religion is given a low priority in their lives, and it seems likely that as they move into the more regular routines of adult work and family commitments, religion will become even less of a priority for them, ultimately losing out to the other demands of their lives. Thus, these emerging adults seem more likely to become Disaffiliated in the future.
There are others in the Marginal category, however, who seem content with the limited presence of religion in their lives and for whom it adds something, whether spiritual or social, that seems important enough to maintain. Perhaps they are looking for a place to feel whole or fulfilled, or to have some sort of experience, or possibly to find answers to questions they can’t quite articulate. Many in this group of the marginally religious have had some previous experience in religious institutions, which has somehow kept them connected to religion. They seem likely to maintain their current level of religious commitment until whatever benefits they receive from it cease to be an important part of their lives.
Of course, it is possible that either of these two groups of marginally religious emerging adults could increase their commitment levels at some point in the future. Their connections to religious communities, however tenuous, position them to respond to challenging life events or experiences in ways that could activate their religious commitment. But for emerging adults who already have one foot out the door of their religious traditions, this seems unlikely to happen.
Finally, there are the emerging adults we have identified as religiously Committed. These emerging adults evince more religious engagement and spiritual practice than their peers, and they acknowledge the importance of religion in their daily lives. They are going against the dominant trend of decline, and in some ways it appears that their involvement and commitment may have actually increased since their teenage years. For a subset of them, religious faith is a significant driver in their lives, shaping their decisions and life trajectories.
For most Committed emerging adults, however, religion is less a driving force than it is a routine part of their lives, not dissimilar from work or family obligations. Religion seems to fit into their lives as one among many other obligations—or perhaps preferences—as they are settling into adulthood. It is part of the overall package of their adult lives. For example, recall that the religiously committed are more likely to be married, which in many ways requires a set routine with demands from work, home, kids, and the like. Religion is simply one more of these life obligations.
For these young people, religious practice and engagement take a rather conventional form, mostly through attendance at religious services and unstructured, reflexive prayer. They do not show much evidence that they are developing intentional spiritual practices. They tend to draw on religion for their own individual well-being, while keeping it in a place in their lives where it makes few demands of them.
Despite the general trend away from religion among emerging adults, there seem to be varying degrees of “hanging on” to a very basic set of beliefs, along with some individualized spiritual practices that suggest they are maintaining at least the possibility that there is “something else” beyond material life. In some cases, this amounts to hedging their bets, to greater or lesser degrees, about whether religion might really be true and, if so, whether it should or could be a part of their lives. Of course, that implies that they are giving significant thought to issues of religion or spirituality, which for most does not seem to be the case. Indeed, in our interviews, many seemed to consider religion only because we were asking about it, not because these issues regularly occupied their thoughts. Thus, even though emerging adults may remain open to the possibility that God exists and that prayers might be answered, for many of them, religion ranges from being inconsequential in their lives to being, at most, an unremarkable presence. Religion remains something in which they could believe or to which they could belong, but it doesn’t have the pull or attraction to gain their attention as something to which they might actually commit in any significant way.
The maintenance of various levels of belief and practice does suggest that they want to hang on to different parts of religion that they find to be beneficial in their lives—but strictly on their terms. They are exercising the agency to choose the important things in their lives, and religion is further down the list than other things like family, romantic relationships, and friends. It seems that what emerging adults are trying to figure out is a more general self-identity, rather than a specific religious identity. And, for some of them, this search for self-identity includes the question of whether to include any of their religious upbringing in the identity they are crafting for themselves as they enter adult life.
Inarticulacy of Beliefs
Throughout our conversations with emerging adults, most spoke about their lives, their relationships, their hopes and dreams, and even their failures in articulate and insightful ways. Yet, the ability to fully express how they viewed their relationships and their lives in general did not extend to their ability to talk about religion or spirituality. This inarticulacy is something that has been noted over the life of this research project, starting when they were teens. In the intervening years, their ability to articulate religious teachings and exactly what they believe doesn’t seem to have improved in any significant way.
Certainly, emerging adults from some traditions—Conservative Protestants and Latter-day Saints, for example—were better at articulating the teachings of their faith than others. Yet, even for these groups, the norm was a lack of religious literacy even of their own tradition. In general, emerging adults had difficulty expressing what they know about their religion—including their own religious beliefs—in response to our questions about faith, God, heaven or hell, or any number of other issues related to their religious and spiritual lives, regardless how religiously committed they were. Yet, emerging adults are not alone in this; several studies have shown the limited state of religious knowledge among Americans in general. How can we explain this inability among emerging adults—and perhaps, more broadly, among Americans—to provide articulate answers to questions related to their religious and spiritual beliefs? In our view, there are three likely explanations that are each present, in different degrees, for different people.
First, and perhaps most obvious, there is a lack of knowledge about religion in general and their own religious traditions in particular. As Smith and Denton argued in Soul Searching, attaining religious knowledge is no different from learning other things; it takes an explicit effort. In short, religion needs to be taught. Many emerging adults told us that their parents were “open” to religion. However, it was not something that parents actually required or encouraged, assuming instead that emerging adults would pursue it on their own if they were interested. We’ve also heard the emerging adults in this study talk in the same way about how they want to approach religion with their own children. The end result, then, is that to the extent that emerging adults have picked up on religious knowledge, it is in an incomplete way, and the knowledge they do have is tailored to their own interests and needs.
Second, as we have shown throughout this book, religion just isn’t all that important to most emerging adults and competes with other responsibilities and commitments in their lives. Even for those who are otherwise religiously committed, the tendency is to maintain a level of commitment that is less demanding of their time and effort. Thus, as a completely voluntary institution, and one that can often require time and effort, religion loses out to more pressing demands for their time and attention. In turn, the less they are involved in religious institutions, of whatever sort, the less opportunity and interest they have to develop a bank of religious knowledge.
Finally, for those emerging adults who have maintained some relationship with religion, whether Committed, Marginal, or Disaffiliated, religious knowledge is simply a part of their consciousness that doesn’t really need to be explained. In our view, this is related to the way that emerging adults approach moral issues. Recall that emerging adults consistently frame their moral decision-making as something they “just know” or “feel.” In other words, an act or decision is right or wrong based on “tacit knowledge” that is felt rather than rationally articulated. Similarly, while they may be fairly certain of their religious beliefs, they are only able to express the general contours of their beliefs, without too many specifics. Thus, as they have reached emerging adulthood, their beliefs remain “taken for granted” or an assumed part of their lives, and they are more or less accepting their faith as they have experienced it growing up. As part of the general context of their lives, ideas about God and faith are things they “just know.” With some notable exceptions, emerging adults see no need to develop well-articulated beliefs because they are just an intuitive part of the world in which they have always lived.
The Cultural Spirituality of Emerging Adults
Despite their inarticulacy about specific religious beliefs, emerging adults do maintain a kind of generalized religious or spiritual life perspective through which their particular beliefs are filtered. That is, emerging adults share a more or less coherent view of the world that references the supernatural in its explanations and rationalizations of activities, which helps them understand and organize their experiences in the world. This perspective can be described as a “do it yourself” religious or spiritual outlook, in which they both borrow and develop beliefs and morals from different religious traditions and larger cultural currents. They do so, however, without any need for greater involvement in or commitment to any particular religious tradition or for any actual coherence with these traditions. They have picked up on cues about religion from their youth and how they were raised, as well as from the larger culture, which are then cobbled together into a highly individualized religious/spiritual perspective that is tailored to their own needs. For most emerging adults, this perspective operates mostly as a background assumption of their daily lives, but nonetheless informs how they understand the world.
Thinking about the many ways that emerging adults have expressed this cultural spirituality, we have identified seven core tenets of this outlook: (1) Karma is real, (2) Everybody goes to heaven, (3) It’s all good, (4) Religion is easy, (5) Just do good, (6) Morals are self-evident, and (7) No regrets. These basic tenets are defined and combined in somewhat different ways, depending on the individual, their life experiences, and their relationship to religion, but are present among most emerging adults, regardless of where they could be classified, from religiously Committed to Not Religious.
Karma is real. In our interviews, many emerging adults explicitly referenced their belief in karma, while others expressed a similar idea, such as “everything happens for a reason,” or some related perspective that suggests that they believe in a “spiritual” or perhaps undefinable supernatural force that generally works to make for a just and ordered world. Their view of karma is a popularized version that is not particularly true to its actual religious meaning. For emerging adults, it is a way to explain how they try to act toward others in the world and a way to explain how both the bad things and the good things that happen in their lives tend to balance out. In reality, the concept of karma that operates in the lives of most emerging adults is something along the order of “what goes around, comes around.” In this sense, karma operates as a quasi-moral code that provides them with some sense of the necessity to treat other people well, or to otherwise do good (or at least not harmful) things in the world. It also serves as an explanation—a nonreligious theodicy of sorts—for why good people ultimately end up having good things happen to them and bad people end up having bad things happen to them.
Everybody goes to heaven. For most emerging adults, going to heaven is generally a result of how you act in the world, rather than being related to any specific religious teachings about heaven, hell, or the afterlife. On the one hand, emerging adults tend to express a belief that people go to heaven because of their good works on earth, which they often link to their perceptions of religious teachings about the afterlife. But, in reality, what they actually believe is that it is the rare person who does not go to heaven. Thus, rather than there being some sort of ledger that weighs a person’s good actions against their bad actions—such as in their version of karma—for emerging adults, being kept out of heaven is determined by whether a person performs actions that are unforgiveable. And, as we’ve seen, this punishment is mostly reserved for murderers, rapists, or those who have hurt another person in a significant way.
Just do good. The golden rule for emerging adults is to be good to other people and to treat them fairly. This is related to their beliefs about karma and who goes to heaven as well as the conviction that the most important moral code is not to hurt anyone. If you treat people well, you increase your odds of going to heaven. But, more than this, being good to others is an expected way to live and act, although the particular elements of “treating others well” are largely undefined. This outlook has persisted throughout the course of this 10-year study, as exemplified most memorably when one teenager told us in Wave 1 that his perspective on life boiled down to, “You know, don’t be an asshole.”
It’s all good. We’ve all heard the saying, “it’s all good,” usually as a replacement for saying something like, “everything’s okay,” or “don’t worry about it.” Yet, this term also highlights how emerging adults strive to live their lives as nonjudgmentally as possible. For emerging adults, “it’s all good” means that other people can believe whatever they want, or act how they want, and as long as they aren’t hurting others, it is seen as no problem: “It’s all good.” For emerging adults, then, two key tenets of life, tolerance and acceptance, are exemplified in this approach. It doesn’t matter if they agree with others on religion, politics, whatever; it’s all good.
Religion is easy. According to most emerging adults, maintaining one’s religious life is “pretty easy,” primarily because their understanding of religion imposes no significant demands on them. For emerging adults, one takes what one wants from religion and leaves behind anything that is irrelevant or inapplicable to one’s life or that goes against one’s own sense of what is right or wrong. Emerging adults don’t want religious organizations to tell them what to do or believe, particularly on issues such as gender identity, sexuality, abortion, marriage, and the like. Further, religion and spirituality constitute just one part of life, and not necessarily the most important one. In the end, you get—or take—what you want from religion. Again, some people are more religious, some more spiritual, but overall, whatever they are, it’s all good. And that equanimity is easy to maintain.
Morals are self-evident. Emerging adults adhere to the idea that morals and values are self-evident—you just know or feel what is right and wrong—even though they’re all relative. In some ways, this is related to emerging adults’ perspective on the ease of maintaining their religious and spiritual lives. That is, because morals and values are self-evident, they ultimately don’t present any sort of dilemma when confronted with making a moral decision—you just know. Things just feel right or wrong. This all sounds pretty relative, and in some ways it is, although there are limits. Emerging adults also say that it is not okay to cheat in order to benefit personally. But this, too, is self-evident for emerging adults because it would go against their commitment to treating others well.
No regrets. If “it’s all good” is one mantra of emerging adults, a related one is “no regrets.” In fact, having regrets is something that most emerging adults at least imply would be a negative thing in their lives. This seems to be related to their belief in karma, in that there is some force or cosmic logic that evens things out and helps make sense of the inequities and bad things that happen to a person. Thus, all of the life experiences a person has had are what have made them who they are, and if any of those were changed, they would be a different person. Certainly, some acknowledge decisions and choices they may have made that weren’t great, or some things that didn’t work out, or opportunities they wish they had pursued. But, taken together, all of those experiences and decisions make a person who they are, and nobody wants to be any different from who they understand themselves to be. In turn, this helps to explain the preference among emerging adults for religion with no demands; such a religion would require a person to confess or repent of sins, or otherwise change their choices or behavior in many circumstances.
In sum, the cultural spirituality of emerging adults operates at an implicit or “felt” level in their lives. It would be a mistake to suggest that these various components have somehow been systematized into a set of coherent beliefs and practices, but, taken together, this loose set of tenets does provide a basic perspective from which they live their lives. Further, although there is remarkable similarity in how this general outlook is expressed across a wide range of emerging adults—from religious to not religious—each element tends to be tailored individually, with certain elements playing larger or smaller roles in each person’s life. In the end, this cultural spirituality makes no particular demands on the individual because each individual decides how one’s life is to be lived based on one’s own needs and desires.
Moralistic Therapeutic Deism 2.0: The Pocket God
In Soul Searching, the book that reported on the religious and spiritual lives of these emerging adults when they were adolescents (ages 13 to 17), Smith and Denton described the religion of American teens as “Moralistic Therapeutic Deism” (MTD), in which their basic beliefs could be summarized as the following: (1) God created and watches over the world; (2) God wants people to be good, nice, and fair to other people; (3) the main goal in life is to be happy; (4) God does not need to be involved in one’s life other than to resolve problems; and (5) Good people go to heaven when they die.
Much of what these emerging adults told us aligns with the MTD they expressed in their teenage years, including what we have framed as their cultural spirituality. Yet, there have also been some significant changes—most important, in how emerging adults conceive of God and what, exactly, they expect or want from God. Most emerging adults still believe that God exists, although there is significant variation in how they may define and conceptualize God. But, in general, there is not a strong sense that God is or should be involved in their lives. Further, there is a definite lack of interest in pursuing any questions about God and the role he could possibly have in their lives.
As teens, their view of God was that he was “there,” more or less waiting around like some cosmic butler to help the teen who might ask for assistance. As emerging adults, however, God is no longer understood in such a proximate and powerful way. Instead, the idea of God seems to represent their belief, or perhaps hope, that there might be something greater than themselves in the universe. This seems to be true even for those emerging adults who think of God as a personal being—while he is generally acknowledged as “being there,” he is otherwise irrelevant and neutral in most instances. Or, perhaps more precisely, while emerging adults may ask God to help them out, they do not necessarily have any real expectation of a response. Rather, it is the process of asking that is helpful to them. Recall the young people who said they prayed not to a specific person or deity, but in order to articulate a need or to process their thoughts because the act of praying itself brought them comfort. Or those who were more traditionally religiously committed and said that they would routinely perform a “quick prayer” whenever they thought about it. In each instance, we see a traditional spiritual practice—prayer—that is essentially a therapeutic device that is activated through the ritual act.
Thus, God is increasingly remote from emerging adults’ everyday concerns and rarely enters their thinking or occupies any real place in their lives. When they do entertain ideas about God, it is primarily on the terms and conditions that are set by each individual. God is thus controlled by the individual and reduced even further from any previous conception they may have had of such a being as a “creator” or “cosmic force.” But even this implies the existence of a God who is waiting around to be called on to do something that emerging adults might ask him to do. While emerging adults have personalized and “reduced” God to serve their own idiosyncratic needs and desires, they don’t seem to have much need for even this reduced idea of God.
To the extent that emerging adults do think about God, it is a God that is easily controlled, but has the potential to provide answers for them should the need ever arise. In many ways, the MTD God that exists beyond is now a personal “Pocket God,” who occupies the same place in emerging adult lives as do the apps on their smart phones. On the one hand, they always have their phones in their back pocket; but, on the other, like the apps on their phones, God is reduced to just one thing among many other things in their lives. Like an app on the phone, he is accessible but has limited functionality. Moreover, the individual can control the extent to which their Pocket God has any access to and impact on their lives. Individuals access their Pocket God only when they need what he is designed to do, and they can control how he interacts with them. They can allow their Pocket God to know where they are and to provide them with notifications, or not. They can turn him on or off as needed or desired, or even delete him if he is no longer of use to them. In general, the Pocket God performs whatever task he is designed to perform, yet is not particularly useful beyond that singular function.
Thus, while MTD still operates in the lives of emerging adults, it now exists in a heightened form of individualization, customization, and singular functionality in their lives. Emerging adults are not looking for much in the way of help from or interaction with God. Rather, God seems more like an unseen companion that they can interact with whenever they desire and do it on their own terms. MTD 2.0 is really more of the comfortable feeling that emerging adults have when they know their Pocket God is with them, close at hand but safely stowed out of sight.
Will Emerging Adults Return to Religion?
When we talk about our research, we are inevitably asked whether we think that emerging adults will return to religion at some point. Most of the time, underlying the question is the assumption that young people will return to a more fully engaged religious faith after they marry and have children. There is some evidence for this pattern, at least for previous generations. The idea is that when people have children, they want to expose them to religious teachings, which in turn will serve as some sort of moral foundation for their lives. Among the emerging adults in this study, we did hear echoes of this perspective. Some told us how they wanted their children to be exposed to religion for moral teachings or to expand their knowledge of religious worldviews.
Other observers argue that after people have left religion, they are unlikely to return. These researchers maintain that the increase in the number of emerging adults who are moving away from religion is mainly a result of unanswered doubt about God or religious teachings, or that they “just stopped” believing, or they have a negative view of religious institutions. Thus, emerging adults are not likely to return to religion, mainly because they’ve already made up their minds and have rejected religious beliefs.
This question of whether young people will eventually return to religion in any significant fashion is a pressing one. In our view, whether emerging adults who have left religion will ultimately return is likely a bit more complex and contingent than the notion that they want their children to be exposed to religious and moral teachings, or that they experienced doubt as teens and therefore decided to chuck it all in response to their unanswered questions. The young people in our study are at the beginning of their journey into adulthood, and it would be irresponsible to claim that we can definitively address this issue with the data at hand. What we can do is make some observations about the trends we see in the data so far and the implications those trends might have for the future religious lives of emerging adults.
At each wave of the National Study of Youth and Religion project, we have identified a group of religiously committed young people. These are the respondents for whom religion plays a central role in their lives, and we have seen some evidence of increasing religious ownership and commitment among these emerging adults. When asking the question, “will they return to religion?” then, we are not asking about these particular young people. They seem to be securely rooted in their religious lives.
Among the remaining respondents, the question of religious return needs to be contextualized within two significant themes from our years of research. The first is that, over the 10 years of the study, the aggregate trend is one of declining religious engagement and a move away from involvement with religious institutions. While we have uncovered nuance and variation along the way, religious decline has been the consistent trajectory for our respondents as a whole. Second, although our research has focused on the causes and correlates of religious change, those patterns of change are set within a larger context of general stability. As a whole, the young people we studied have not experienced dramatic or unexpected changes in their life trajectories, including their religious lives. Certainly, at the individual level, there are plenty of examples of instability and dramatic life changes. At the aggregate level, however, the lives of the young people in our study have progressed in generally stable and predictable ways over the course of our research, and the trend of gradual religious decline has remained consistent for the duration of the project.
As we look back over the past 10 years of their lives, we consider how the inertia of these two trends—general stability and relatively gradual religious decline—might inform our expectations about young adults’ future religious re-engagement. To this point, we have not seen any evidence that the way these emerging adults have arranged their lives will, at some point, lead them to shift course and re-engage with religion. While many expressed an openness to the possibility of future religious faith, very few expected to take any active steps in this direction.
Recall from the young people who spoke about a return to religion as something that might “happen to them,” but not as something that they would seek out on their own. Sociologically, we know that while individual agency alone is not a sufficient predictor of life events, it is unlikely that full-fledged engagement in a voluntary social institution such as a religious congregation will spontaneously impose itself on our respondents at some point in the future.
The inertia of their lives points toward a continued drift away from organized religion. But what about the introduction of marriage and children? These are the life events that observers point to as a potential impetus for a religious return—the point at which young people will re-evaluate their lives and return to religious faith. And, as noted, there is evidence that, in generations past, marriage and parenthood have brought people back to religion. As we showed in , we do find that religious emerging adults are marrying and having children earlier than their peers, which in turn acts to slow down the rate of exit from religion.
This offers support for the close link between family formation and religious engagement and suggests that young people who are starting families of their own may in fact seek out the support of religious communities during this life stage. It is certainly possible that emerging adults will make more significant efforts to seek out religious faith after they marry and have children. Given that the median age of our sample is still younger than the median age of marriage in the United States, our data are not suited to clearly assessing this possibility. However, we can make some observations about this expectation, based on what we know about the lives of emerging adults in our current social context.
Previous work from the NSYR found that the drift away from religion begins in late adolescence. At the same time, entrance into marriage and parenthood continues to be pushed later in the life course, and overall rates of marriage and childbearing in the United States are declining. Thus, compared with generations before them, current emerging adults will experience an extended period of time between the onset of religious decline and starting their own families. It is during this same period that emerging adults are said to be engaging in self-focused identity exploration and transitions, crafting identities, and making life decisions that set them on various paths for the future. So, these processes of identity formation and life decisions are likely to be informed only marginally, if at all, by religious ties and sentiments.
We did hear from emerging adults who say that they hope to raise their children in a religious community in the future, even though they are not currently religiously active. What we did not hear, however, was a clear conviction that they would be able to successfully act on this desire. The stories of Ashley and Carla from illustrate how the confluence of religious drift, delayed family formation, and the characteristics of emerging adulthood may create obstacles to a return to religious engagement when marriage and children are on the horizon. Both Ashley and Carla have drifted away from the religious faith in which they were raised, though they continue to identify as religious and express a desire to one day raise their children to be religious as well. During their own hiatus from active religious involvement, they have continued to move forward in other areas of their lives, completing educations, figuring out careers, and selecting partners whom they will marry and with whom they hope to have children. Both women are now partnered with men who do not share their desires for a religious upbringing for their children. And, during the course of our interviews, they both grappled with the implications of being married to a nonreligious spouse and the potential challenges this would create for returning to religion after they have children.
Selecting a marriage partner is just one example of a life choice made during emerging adulthood that has the potential to shape one’s prospects for a future return to religion. We also heard young people talk about constructing their daily lives through decisions about educational pursuits, careers and employment, geographic relocation, and other similar life events. Rarely did we hear them consider whether these pursuits would leave space in their lives for religious engagement. On the contrary, we often heard that their lives were constructed in such a way that religion was squeezed out or moved to the bottom of the list of the many demands for their time and attention. And the more distant their current lives are from religious ties, the more challenging it will be to reactivate those ties and forge a path back to a religious community.
So, what will happen when marriage and children are introduced into these lives that are constructed around priorities other than religious faith, and where ties to religious communities are tenuous? While marriage and parenthood may create the desire for religious re-engagement, the practical constraints of a life that has not already made space for religious engagement will raise the bar and make a religious return more difficult. In the case of Carla, she still lives near family and remains connected to her religious congregation. She can at least imagine where she would return if she did decide to raise her children in a church. Ashley, however, is far enough removed from her own religious identity and tradition that, even if she were to decide to return, she is not confident that she has a religious home to return to. Like many emerging adults we spoke with, her ties to the religion of her youth are stretched thin, and the path back to religious engagement does not seem clearly marked.
There have always been people who move away from religion for a time and then return again. This will continue to be true for these emerging adults as well. The data we have at this point in time do not allow for a full examination of the factors that might facilitate such a return. Given the close links between religion and family formation that we see in previous research, as well as in our data, we do expect that the experience of marriage and having children will likely serve as a motivator for young people to re-engage with religious faith.
These motivating life events will come at later average ages than in the past, and based on current demographic trends, we expect that small but increasing numbers of today’s emerging adults will not make these transitions at all, forgoing marriage or parenthood altogether. For the majority of emerging adults who will marry and have children, however, the theoretical desires to incorporate religion into their newly formed families will be balanced against the practical considerations that contribute to the likelihood of increased religious participation. We expect that the ability to translate motivation into action will be most likely among those emerging adults who have maintained at least some sort of ties to religion or communities of faith. Among the emerging adults in our study, the Marginal and even the Disaffiliated seem better positioned to make a return to religion than those who have embraced a Not Religious identity and who have few, if any, remaining ties to religion.
Another recurring theme throughout the NSYR project has been the importance of parents in shaping the religious outcomes of their children. Parents, as well as the overall home atmosphere related to religion, are important predictors of whether emerging adults remain religiously committed (i.e., on the “Stable High” trajectory), at least as they have moved into emerging adulthood. Emerging adults whose parents were religiously engaged during their adolescent years are less likely than their peers to exit from religion in the first place. But to the extent that they do experience religious decline, we expect that a future return to religion will be more likely among those emerging adults who have religiously engaged parents.
A religiously engaged family environment contributes to an enduring sense of religious identity among emerging adults that can persist even when they are not actively participating in religious practices. In addition, a religiously engaged family can facilitate continued ties to religious communities that make it more feasible for young people to re-engage with religion in the future. Understanding how emerging adults were socialized toward religion as adolescents is an important key to understanding where they may end up as adults—as either religious or not religious, or perhaps somewhere in between. We would argue that if emerging adults were to return to religion at some point in their lives, the group most likely to return would be those who were raised in homes that were actively engaged with religion.
Potential Futures: Religion for Individuals and Institutions
What might the findings we’ve presented in this book mean for the future of religion in America, both for emerging adults and for religious institutions? Although the dominant trend of decline in affiliation and participation does not bode well for traditional religious institutions, there are, as we have shown, still emerging adults who remain active in religious organizations. Yet these young people demonstrate an increasingly customized religious and spiritual outlook intended to fit their personal needs and desires. As leaders of religious institutions consider their future, they will have to decide whether and how they can adapt to meet the challenges presented by emerging adults who are less interested in the long-established expressions of many religious traditions.
We believe there are at least four potential strategies that religious institutions may pursue as they consider their futures and any role that emerging adults may have in them. First, religious institutions may stay the course and make no changes, expecting that emerging adults will remain engaged participants and perhaps those who have left might return some day. Second, religious institutions may change their traditions, doctrines, or practices to meet the needs and demands of emerging adults, and in the process change their core identity, becoming something other than what they have been historically. Third, they could maintain their allegiance to their core identities, but push those identity boundaries as they reimagine and redefine their message to show how it can have resonance in the lives of emerging adults. Or, finally, new types of religious institutions may emerge that better serve the needs and desires of emerging adults. There are examples of religious movements on each of these paths with varying degrees of success, but it remains to be seen how successful they can be over the longer term.
Regardless of the response of religious institutions – whether staying the course, wholesale change, reimagining themselves, or the development of entire new forms – they will have to contend with the religious sensibilities of emerging adults like those we have come to know in this book. These young people are most interested in customizing or curating their beliefs and practices to suit their own desires and preferences, while leaving behind those beliefs and practices that are irrelevant or that do not have resonance in their lives. Thus, whatever seems comfortable, plausible, and, perhaps most important, allows them to live their lives as they wish without much, if any, intrusion from religious institutions or authorities will increasingly govern emerging adult choices about religion and spirituality.
Recall that we heard from emerging adults who said that they were happy with their church or religious identity, but who didn’t really believe everything that was taught. We also saw this in some individuals who had exited religious institutions yet were still hanging onto certain beliefs and practices that they had tailored to their own particular needs. Thus, for emerging adults, religion as an institution maintains little authority in their lives. Religion might be true, or it might offer something that is of use in an individual’s life, but it isn’t really something that is authoritative in the claims that it makes in a person’s life or as a conspicuous source of moral guidance.
This has significant implications for religious beliefs, practices, and institutions. At the most basic level, if the trends of disaffiliation and lack of participation continue, religious institutions of all types will have a declining pool of potential members and a concomitant decline in resources. Thus, keeping current and future members in the fold is one of the most significant tasks for religious organizations such as churches and synagogues, but also for institutions like religious schools and other faith based institutions.
Further, it is clear from our findings that emerging adults have embraced a highly individualistic perspective that seems to color all parts of their lives, not least how they understand and participate in religion and religious institutions. It remains to be seen whether this is simply a stage that emerging adults are passing through or if this is a more enduring shift in the role of religion and spirituality in their lives. Will they ultimately return to some form of traditional religious involvement as they reach full-fledged adulthood, or will this qualitatively different way of thinking about religion, religious beliefs and practices, and religious institutions persist as they move through the life course?
Whatever the future holds, the present reality includes emerging adults whose viewpoints range from a general lack of interest in religion to a religiosity that is curated and customized from traditional religious beliefs and practices. The changes evinced by these young people will require religious institutions to take their perspectives into account as they think about how to respond to the ways that emerging adults are changing the religious landscape.
