Chapter Six
CHAPTER SIX
A MATURING DISCIPLINE
We must no longer be children, tossed to and fro and blown about by every wind of doctrine, by people's trickery, by their craftiness in deceitful scheming. But speaking the truth in love, we must grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ, from whom the whole body, joined and knit together by every ligament with which it is equipped, as each part is working properly, promotes the body's growth in building itself up in love.
—Ephesians 4:14-16
You may strive to be like them, but seek not to make them like you. . . .
You are the bows from which your children, as living arrows, are sent forth.
—Kahlil Gibran
I(Kenda) quit my church's youth group during my senior year of high school.The youth group of Grace United Methodist Church—a tiny Ohio farm church where the average age seemed to me to be about nine-hundred— operated as a close-knit band of church malcontents. We thought of ourselves as the "progressives" in our stodgy congregation, if you could call being "progressive" the fact that we sponsored dances and helped with Bible school and raised money for trips to Kings Island. In other words, we looked pretty much like our parents, except that we listened to Chicago and Amy Grant instead of Johnny Cash and the Gaithers. I don't remember playing a single icebreaker (we had known each other since primary choir) or breaking into small groups (on a good night, there were eight of us, scattered between sixth and twelfth grades). At the helm was a balding, sun-burned dairy farmer named "Trox," a good-natured soul who inexplicably heard God calling him to lead us—a role we considered more or less expendable.
By senior year, I was done.
I remember telling Trox it was because I was tired of babysitting younger, rowdier kids who were uninterested in heavy-duty "discussions" about God. That, of course, was only half true. What was also true was that my girlfriends at school had invited me to their "cool" youth group downtown.
"You would love Cindy and Nick," Ellen and Lisa cooed, referring to the hip husband-and-wife team who conducted a youth ministry four times larger than ours, thanks to an ecumenical arrangement between several downtown churches. They played games out of the Ideas series, Nick sang lead in a rock band, and last summer Cindy had taken some teenagers to Appalachia for something I had never heard of: a "mission trip." Their cool factor was off the charts.
"What do you do the rest of the time?" I asked them at school one Monday. "Well," Ellen confided, edging a little closer to my locker, "last night we talked about orgasms. They asked us what we wanted to be doing when we died. And when it was Cindy's turn, she said she wanted to die during an orgasm."
I was hooked.
That was 1977. Youth ministry was an outpost of congregational life, vaguely approved by pastors and tended almost exclusively by generous volunteers. Adolescence seemed to fit neatly between the ages of twelve and eighteen; the first Gallup Youth Survey, piloted in 1977, focused exclusively on high school students. Mike Yaconelli and Wayne Rice's fledgling Youth Specialties company had moved out of Yaconelli's garage to join ranks with Zondervan three years earlier, but most youth leaders had never heard of them. Thom Schultz was still typing a little rag called Group Magazine on a typewriter in a spare room.
In 1977, youth ministries in Catholic, Orthodox, and mainline churches were still regaining their footing from nearly a decade earlier, when the World Council of Churches had expressed concern over the "youth revolt" of a generation "disenchanted" with religion.1 The National Catholic Youth Organization, consisting mostly of priests and nuns, had been reshaped into the National Federation of Catholic Youth Ministry, a professional organization made up of lay youth ministers. Mainline denominations' youth ministry offices were also experiencing a brief lull, unaware that many of them were on borrowed time. The World Council of Churches' recommendation that churches integrate young people into the mission of the church as a whole was beginning to be interpreted by American denominations as permission to slash denominational funds and personnel dedicated to youth ministry. The year 1977 was the calm before a storm of budget cuts just ahead, from which denominational youth organizations would not recover.
While I was attending our town's ecumenical youth group, one of youth ministry's true prophets, Charles Foster, was teaching Christian education and youth ministry at a seminary just five minutes up the road. Unfortunately, in 1977 youth ministry was a marginalized enterprise in seminaries as well. Seminaries tended to view youth ministry as the pesky stepchild of Christian education, a haven for immature theology students and largely irrelevant for everyone else. Years later, I learned about Foster's work through pastors I admired because they prioritized young people and approached youth ministry with uncharacteristic thoughtfulness—pastors who inevitably, I learned, had once had Foster for class.
Youth Ministry Comes of Age (Maybe)
More than three decades later, ministry with young people has exploded as a form of professional ministry, and consequently as a field of study in theological education, as churches struggle to respond to the shifts in culture and in adolescence that we have discussed in these pages. As we have noted, the postmodern age calls for serious reflection on ministry in general, which has created more demand for theologically prepared youth leaders. The early twenty-first century has seen youth ministry's first conscious attempts at self-reflection as an interdisciplinary field of study, profoundly shaping how we prepare leaders for children's, youth, young adult, and family ministries— all of which huddle under the "youth ministry" umbrella in explicit or implicit ways.
Youth ministry tends to serve as a galvanizing force, a place where theological factions and disenchanted churchgoers can come together out of a common and often urgent desire to "hand on the faith" to the young people we love— which most of us understand to mean inculcating a way of life that reflects our own religious values, for better and for worse. Since 1977 we have added enormously to the body of literature surrounding youth and young adult ministry. As the field has both expanded and consolidated, the signs of an emerging discipline are among us: a common language of specialization, a cadre of varied professionals, educational curricula and pedagogical self-awareness, and the beginnings of a research presence.2
Youth ministry tends to serve as a galvanizing force, a place where theological factions and disenchanted churchgoers can come together out of a common and often urgent desire to "hand on the faith" to the young people we love.
If you are the kind of youth minister who loves kids but has no interest in the political terrain of youth ministry education, now is a good time to skip ahead. (We'll meet up again in the last paragraph of this section—or, if you're anxious to get started changing the church, jump to Appendix A and start developing "faith assets" in your congregation.) The research reported in the appendix would not have been possible apart from changes in the field of youth ministry itself, which this chapter summarizes. If you are in youth ministry for the long haul or if you prepare others for youth ministry leadership—or if you just worry about the oddball nature of our vocation in general—this chapter will help you map the ways in which youth ministry is "growing up."
Field or Discipline?
In the academy, "fields" are aptly named. They are the functional equivalent of the American frontier in 1862, when the Homestead Act gave 160 acres to anyone who would improve the land. A field's boundaries are largely in the eye of the beholder; fields are interdisciplinary to the point of crosspollination. Belonging has less to do with your terminal degree than with whether you have earned your chops as a homesteader, noticeably improving the area. Fields create trouble for universities, which are used to dividing up the educational landscape into departments and majors. Fields have wild patches, unknown species, and lots of healthy outliers—unidentified sprouts around the edges that sometimes work their way into the middle. Students, faculty, and research in fields are hard to pin down, and nobody is quite sure what they're up to. Research may be wide rather than deep (after all, there's a lot to plough).
A field's boundaries are largely in the eye of the beholder; fields are interdisciplinary to the point of cross-pollination.
"Disciplines," by contrast, are fields that have been tamed into gardens. They are much narrower than fields and controlled in what they grow. They are neatly bordered, carefully tended, have been fertilized by long traditions, and usually have gates with special keys (Ph.D.s or other official credentials). There are always a few people who jump the fence to get in, but most people behave respectably in a discipline (hence the word). Disciplines are nice to have around in higher education. Since students, faculty, and research cohere, they can be productive in ways that are recognized and understood by other disciplines. There are very few surprises from one season to the next; this year's discoveries lay the foundations for next year's crop.
We think of disciplines as being static, but in fact they evolve with a changing society; nursing, library science, information technology, biogenetic engineering, and film were all professional "fields" fifty years ago but now have disciplinary status and academic majors in major universities. Whenever a field moves toward becoming a discipline, there are gains to be had and risks to be incurred—especially in practical theology. All practical areas of inquiry struggle with boundaries, and theology adds slippery criteria like "faithfulness" that are hard to assess. On the one hand, if youth ministry adhered to the criteria of academic specialization, our future research would build on our current research, gaining new refinement and depth, and would be packaged in an empirical language that our colleagues could understand. Our thinking would be complex but not scattered and our students would be consistently trained and predictably capable. On the other hand, academic specialization could make our intellectual inquiry professionally self-centered and theologically shallow, simply because, as specialists, we no longer need the wisdom of other fields the way we once did. In social science, emerging disciplines readily submit themselves to the intellectual, behavioral, and social criteria of the academy. But in the interdisciplinary world of youth ministry, spiritual maturity is paramount— and notoriously hard to assess.
Most of us don't spend much time thinking about the evolution of youth ministry as a field or a discipline (and let me say at this point, you will live a long and happy life if you choose to ignore these debates altogether). At the same time, the effectiveness and longevity of youth ministry owes much to our academic maturity. Youth ministry's entrance into the academic world affects the research, literature, practices, and teaching available to churches. Yet to call youth ministry a "discipline" at all—a term that generally means we can locate it in a particular body of academic literature—suggests that pastoral effectiveness with young people (with all people) comes from mastering a discrete body of knowledge and from becoming adept at the skills related to it. It implies that we are "masters" of divinity—and that, as we pointed out in chapter 5, is an arrogant and impossible claim.
Specialists or Generalists?
"Specialization" is a hallmark of modernity.3 With the printing press came an explosion of popular knowledge—too much to be mastered by any individual— and the culture of the "expert" was born. By the late twentieth century, professionalization meant becoming a specialist. Teachers prioritized one developmental level at a time—primary or secondary education? Colleges had majors—literature or business? Professional students chose specialty areas— pediatrics or gastroenterology? Tax law or litigation? Elementary or secondary school certification? We learned to privilege these specialists, believing that the depth of their knowledge means that they know "more" than generalists do.
In fact, this is true only at the technical level; what is true is that specialists know differently than generalists do. Being a specialist, like being a generalist, activates some intellectual capacities and disables others. What separates brilliant specialists from brilliant generalists is their epistemology (the nature of their knowledge); at issue is not how much they know, but the way they know, and the kinds of things they pay attention to. Specialists focus intensely on specific bodies of knowledge, mastering technical concepts, vocabularies, and nuances unavailable to most of us. Generalists, on the other hand, focus on integrating knowledge from several fields in a usable and coherent way.
Generalists do not, as a rule, become virtuosos on a single instrument; instead, they become innovators, improvisationalists, people energized by a measure of uncertainty and mess. True generalists are fluent in multiple discourses and cultural styles, and metaphorically "play several instruments" (perhaps not at concert quality). They pursue a disciplined eclecticism, borrowing widely but staying true to a single purpose. A generalist musician, for example—let's say an exceptional music teacher or a talented composer— cheerfully pilfers a huge repertoire of musical forms to memorably teach Bach's "Well-Tempered Clavier" or to compose a score that perfectly suits the Twilight series. We do not admire them for their faultless performances (Peter Schickele, a.k.a. "P.D.Q. Bach," purposefully builds mistakes into his concerts, and almost everything we hear from legendary composer John Williams is produced). We admire them for the genius ways their creations perfectly suit the occasions for which they are made.
Youth ministry—which, as we have noted, now contains a number of specialty areas of its own—came of age in this culture of specialization. Indeed, it is almost impossible for educated people today not to specialize in something. Generalists like Schikele and Williams are, after all, musicians (very accomplished ones), though their refusal to limit themselves to a single field or set of skills within their discipline accounts for much of their distinctiveness. Or take our family's general practitioner. His specialty is sports medicine (if you knew our household's total ineptitude for sports you would find this hilarious). But five minutes in "Dr. Lev's" office sees as many octogenarians as teenagers streaming in and out of his care. He attends conferences on cholesterol and cancer treatment, follows acupuncture and prescribes flaxseed. His effectiveness as a physician is based, not on his specialty, but on his medical agility. Over the years, Dr. Lev has developed a medical imagination, enabling him to move back and forth between many subjects and skills to treat the particular patient before him, the one dangling her legs over the edge of the examining table, awaiting a diagnosis and treatment plan that Dr. Lev has matched to the idiosyncracies of being her.
The Risks of Intellectual Maturity
Despite calls to reclaim pastoral agility as a goal of theological education, most churches buy into the paradigm of expertise that dominates our culture.4 When church leaders began to ask, "How can we improve the quality of ministry available to children, youth, emerging adults, and their families?" our first instinct was to develop "experts."
Today youth ministry majors and seminary specializations are increasingly common; producing "experts" is a booming business in youth ministry leadership formation. Graduate degrees in youth ministry frequently exempt students from other theological coursework to make room for classes that focus on the specialty skills of youth ministry. Continuing education events and publishers approach youth ministers as a niche market, assuming (correctly) that most church heads of staff will "opt out" if the brochure mentions youth ministry. Tapping into our culture's infatuation with experts—people who have contributed mightily to "raising the bar" for churches' ministries with young people—has improved youth ministry's professional status and solidified its reputation as a specialty ministry.
Such specialization, however, comes at a price. It makes it easier to separate youth ministry from ministry as a whole, creating the impression that adolescent discipleship formation is the province of "experts" rather than the responsibility of the entire faith community. A parallel narrowing occurs in scholarship too. Communication scholar Brenda Dervin warns that, when a field gains the status of another major subject and discipline, it also loses its healthy roots in basic disciplines (sociology, political science, linguistics, literature, and in our case, theology) while becoming more and more dependent on empirical and practical aspects of reality.5 In short, we become more inward and insular, which undermines the vocation—indeed, the identity—of the church.
Specialization makes it easier to separate youth ministry from ministry as a whole, creating the impression that adolescent discipleship formation is the province of "experts" rather than the responsibility of the entire faith community.
To become less integrated with general fields that inform the church's general ministry would be an ironic step backward for youth ministry, since much of what has motivated us to study youth ministry in the first place has been our dissatisfaction with young people's marginalization in the church, illustrated by the still-popular "the one-eared Mickey Mouse" model of ministry (see chapter 3). Much of the literature that now exists for children's, youth, young adult, and family ministries urges us to integrate young people more fully into the relationally rich practices of the congregation, even while offering teenagers important peer relationships as they grapple with faith.
There is little question that, thanks to the corporate structure of most North American congregations, youth ministry is a specialty profession—and the ability to specialize in a number of forms of youth ministry is one of the marks of its emerging maturity. The 2005 National Study of Youth and Religion found that 30 percent of (U.S.) teenagers studied came from congregations with a full-time youth minister (Figure 5.1); outside the U.S., full-time professional youth ministry leadership is extremely rare. In 2001, the "Transforming Youth Ministry" study reported a "mushrooming number of training organizations" in youth ministry, dedicated to supporting both volunteers and professionals through colleague networks and formal and informal youth ministry education.6 In short, we are a far more sophisticated lot when it comes to ministry with young people than we were a generation ago, if we measure the maturity of youth ministry by academic standards.
Figure 5.1
Full-Time Youth Ministers (by denomination)7
But there is more to the story. Youth ministers are called to a pastoral vocation that exceeds a single specialty area. How we know matters as much as what we know. The hallmarks of pastoral identity are not only the depth of our knowledge but also the shape of our lives and our imaginations, our ability to envision how to serve Christ in situations that call for holy discernment, leadership, and action, and how to help young people do the same. If anything can prepare us for ministry with young people in the twenty-first century, it is more likely our ability to exercise a pastoral imagination than our ability to plan a sexuality retreat or Youth Sunday.
Pastoral Imagination:
Job #1 for Preparing Youth Ministers
To say that youth ministry is a pastoral vocation is to suggest that our work must be gauged according to pastoral criteria. Chief among the excellences of pastoral ministry is what Aristotle called phronesis, or the art of practical wisdom. Phronesis makes us agile practitioners who can tack back and forth between deep wells of knowledge, imagination, and courage to improvise faithfully in the moment calling for Christian action. A pastoral imagination, contends practical theologian Craig Dykstra, is
the capacity to perceive the "more" in what is already before us. It is the capacity to see beneath the surface, to get beyond the obvious and the merely conventional, to note the many aspects of any particular thing or situation, to attend to the deep meanings of things.8
According to Dykstra, many pastors hear the call to develop a pastoral imagination as a daunting, discouraging, nigh-impossible task. Dykstra counters by citing British theologian David Ford for whom Christian faith is a matter of being overwhelmed. Ford describes Jesus Christ as the "embodiment of multiple overwhelmings": his immersion in the Jordan River, his temptation in the desert, his agony at Gethsemane, his betrayal, torture and crucifixion, dying as he cried, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" Then came the resurrection, "the most disorienting and transformative overwhelming of all."9 In baptism, observes Ford, we join Christ in a life of multiple overwhelmings. Christians are shaped by being overwhelmed.10
Such a view of Christian formation may ring true for people in youth ministry (who are overwhelmed most of the time), but it is not for the faint of heart. The good news, Dykstra reminds us, is that pastoral imagination is not an achievement but a gift; even our ability to receive this gift is by the power of divine grace:
At the very heart of pastoral ministry lies the good news of a power that is not ours, a labor that ultimately is not our work, a grace that is not of our doing. The way is not so much one of earnest striving as it is "the 'active passivity' of letting ourselves be embraced, or letting ourselves be fed the food and drink that can energize us for" ministry.11
So how are we to assess our effectiveness in a "discipline" that is less the result of education than of being swept into the life of God, who calls us to become not simply experts, but vessels of suffering love. After all, we study youth ministry, not for the sake of advancing a discipline, but for the sake of advancing Christ. We are, by necessity, specialists who are evaluated by standards of academic excellence—standards that have given the church much needed rigor in our reflection on young people. But we are also pastors, in need of pastoral imagination and interdisciplinary agility. Above all, we are Christians, committed to a counterintuitive community whose signature practices embody self-giving love and willing vulnerability before God and others, and whose integrity as a discipline is bound to virtues like collaboration and generosity, holy friendship and humility, as well as to as much depth in intellectual content as our eardrums can handle.
These standards directly challenge the highly specialized, individualistic, achievement-focused, competitive norms common to modern academia, which is one reason emerging disciplines like youth ministry education or adolescent discipleship formation do not "fit" into academic categories. Yet Christ calls us to attend to these pastoral variables, even as we become more proficient at mastering a recognized body of scholarly research. Is it possible to do both? Can youth ministry combine academic standards with the imitation of Christ? Can the practices and virtues of the Christian community that we covet for the young people in our care also characterize youth ministry as an emerging academic discipline?
Practical Theology: The Parent Discipline of
Youth Ministry
Maybe. Much depends on whether we are willing to see ourselves as a practical theological discipline instead of as an "enriched" educational, psychological, or organizational one. Practical theology entails prayerful reflection on Christian life, and on those contexts where God's action intersects with the church's actions. Practical theology is concerned with how God reaches for human beings through concrete situations, and the concrete ways in which humans reach back.12
Practical theology is concerned with how God reaches for human beings through concrete situations, and the concrete ways in which humans reach back.
1. Practical theology implies that youth ministry is theological.
To call youth ministry a form of practical theology sets it apart from most academic disciplines in at least four ways that distinguish all forms of practical theology. First, youth ministry is practical theology, so we can infer that the church's work with children, youth, emerging adults, and their families has pastoral and theological significance. It matters to the church. It matters to the kingdom of God. It influences the ways in which we imitate Christ—and because it is prayerful reflection on Christian action, doing youth ministry as practical theology is a way to imitate Christ. Youth ministry as practical theology simply cannot be reduced to either a social science or a liberal art.
2. Practical theology implies that youth ministry is interdisciplinary.
At the same time, to understand youth ministry as practical theology means that our work is informed by social science and the liberal arts. Practical theology is interdisciplinary (as well as cross-disciplinary, intradisciplinary, and so on). Youth ministry cannot be reduced to a single subject area. Practical theology honors the tension between specialists and generalists, but no one in ministry—least of all ministry with young people—can afford to build "silos" that separate youth, or youth leaders, from the rest of the church, or that separate the church from the rest of the world. While educational theory is essential to our work, assuming youth ministry is a "subarea" of educational ministry profoundly distorts the reality. The church's work with young people is a form of pastoral ministry, defined not by the task but by the flock—a flock that requires us to be thoughtful theologians-in-traffic, careful biblical exegetes, deft deliverers of pastoral care, skillful communicators who are keenly aware of community and interpersonal dynamics, and so on.
3. Practical theology implies that youth ministry reflects on God through Christian action.
In addition, youth ministry as practical theology offers a way of knowing— and a way of knowing God—that is distinctive. As I mentioned earlier, practical theology is concerned with those human situations in which God's action and human actions intersect. Technically, it is a "performative" theological discipline, which means we do things to know God, as well as think about them—and we assume that through these human actions, God does things as well. Practical theology's deepest truths are embodied truths, which is why Kierkegaard compared the Christian life to swimming: you can watch from on shore, admire the strokes, appreciate swimming's strength and grace. But eventually, if you want to understand swimming, you're going to have to get in the water.13 In the same way, we can study prayer, admire prayers, appreciate people who pray—but we will never truly appreciate prayer until we pray. The practices of Christian life that identify us as Jesus' followers are practical theology's primary "texts." As practical theology, youth ministry focuses on practices that allow us to perceive God with and through young people.
This way of knowing is deeply embedded in Christian tradition. Christianity did not emerge as a collection of "great thoughts about Jesus." It emerged as a distinctive way of life that Jesus' followers eventually had to explain to newcomers. By retelling the stories and teachings of Jesus, and by reflecting on those stories' significance for the community, "doctrine" emerged. For example, today we tend to teach young people about the Eucharist before they participate in it. But if we lived in the first or second century, we would have saved this instruction until after newly baptized Christians took their first communion. Ancient church leaders believed that only by participating in the mysteries of Christ's presence in the bread and wine was it possible to truly recognize Christ's presence in them. In many ways, youth ministry intuitively continues this tradition, immersing young people in the "way" of Christian life, making connections between these practices and the stories and teachings of Jesus as we go.
4. Practical theology assumes youth ministry is particular.
A fourth way youth ministry as practical theology stands out from other theoretical disciplines is its emphasis on the particular. Practical theology listens intently to discoveries drawn from other disciplines but does not pretend to generate universal truths or one-size-fits-all practices of ministry. Like all practical wisdom, youth ministry starts on the ground, not with a theory, but with a teenager—let's call her Katt—who is seventeen and plays the piano and lives with her grandmother and her yellow cat. Unless we are too new to know better, we do not impose a "theory" of youth ministry on Katt, indebted as we are to theories of human development, sociology, education, and even other theological disciplines that help us understand Katt and her world. Katt pushes back, challenging these broad theories with her own human uniqueness. The theoretical literature is not irrelevant, but it is not universal either. Christian theology meets every adolescent's one-of-a-kind story with God's own one-of-a-kind story, the particularity of Jesus—a thirty-three-year-old Galilean who worked as a carpenter and whom we proclaim was God-madeflesh.
Christian theology meets every adolescent's one-of-a-kind story with God's own one-of-a-kind story, the particularity of Jesus.
Discipling a Discipline
Locating youth ministry in the parent discipline of practical theology is fairly straightforward. Establishing it as a discipline in its own right is more difficult, especially if pastoral imagination serves as one of our norms. In some ways, of course, the term "discipline" exactly describes what we do. The word comes from the word "disciple"; throughout most of human history, education has been a discipline because it meant becoming a disciple of a master teacher. Humanist educators during the Enlightenment decoupled the "disciplines" from their religious roots, but the church's view that all knowledge comes from God, and that all learning should prepare us to serve Christ, suggests that for youth ministry to mature into a "discipline" is exactly right.
Yet so far we have no academic standard for assessing research and scholarship on the basis of discipleship, in youth ministry or any other field. This is partly because as an intellectual field, the study of youth ministry is too new for any one approach to dominate our scholarship. But it is also because it is unclear whether any one approach should dominate youth ministry scholarship. Like other so-called "emerging disciplines" (e.g., information technology, criminal justice, women's studies) youth ministry's interdisciplinary nature makes it difficult to evaluate. Whose standards should we use? Systematic theology deeply informs our work but misses youth ministry's performative dimensions. The arts provide models for assessing performance, but youth ministry is far less subjective; relating to a teenager is not a matter of taste, but a matter of fidelity to the gospel. Social and hard sciences offer methods for empirical research—but insert God into the equation, and science suddenly gets skittish. IBM vice president Gina Poole puts it succinctly:
New fields of study, especially those requiring interdisciplinary involvement, are sometimes perceived as too "soft." But as we've seen with computer science and software engineering, acceptance is a matter of time. Higher education doesn't turn on a dime. It took nearly two decades from the time the first computer science course was offered before the first doctorate in computer science was granted in 1965.14
If youth ministry is a form of practical theological reflection, then we must evaluate our maturity as a field of study by posing questions that underscore our commitment to theology, and that acknowledge norms of interdisciplinarity, practice, and particularity. These questions tend to appeal to postmodern scholars, who are at home with a certain amount of ambiguity and who welcome eclecticism, community, embodiment, and context. Taken as a whole, these questions also have great integrity for ministry itself. However, they are not usually the criteria that modern institutions—especially universities—use to evaluate academic discourse. Clearly, we must incorporate the best of social scientific research and disciplined reflection at all levels of ministry with young people. Yet Christians maintain that spiritual, ecclesial, and theological maturity matter as well—and when forced to choose, these qualities matter more.
"New fields of study, especially those requiring interdisciplinary involvement, are sometimes perceived as too 'soft.'"—Gina Pool
Report Card for an Emerging Discipline
I have some reluctance about calling youth ministry a "discipline" (hence the quotation marks), despite its clear movement in that direction.15 Since emerging disciplines never fit neatly into existing criteria for academic research (indeed, this is what makes them emerge), the question we must ask, as youth ministry moves from an interest area into an "emerging discipline," is whether youth ministry as practical theology can be researched and understood on its own terms. Can we evaluate our academic work according to the difference it makes—or fails to make—for a fifteen-year-old girl in Poughkeepsie? In the academy, disciplines tend to "emerge" (meaning, a field starts becoming tamed into a garden) when six markers can be discerned:16
Missing from this list, of course, are those indicators that suggest a field's spiritual maturity, which we have discussed throughout this chapter. The following pages, therefore, evaluate our theological progress as well—but you may want to apply your own "grading criteria" as we proceed.
A common mission
A common language
A cadre of professionals
Academic Programs
Academic research
Distinctive pedagogies
Figure 5.2
Markers of Emerging Disciplines
A Common Mission: Theological Education and Reform
Nature—and academics—abhor a vacuum. Like most new fields of study, the academic study of youth ministry emerged to address a series of "lacks": a lack of quality church leadership for children, teenagers, and young adults and their families; a lack of theological training for current leadership; a lack of research to assess whether anything we are doing makes any difference; a lack of systemic support from congregations or denominations—and a general lack of ecclesial interest on the part of young people themselves, which makes youth ministry a prime place to "test drive" alternative practices and ecclesial visions that may not win adherents from the congregation at large.
By the end of the twentieth century, colleges and seminaries (and, significantly, funders) had begun to identify youth ministry education as a gap they could fill. Armed with grants from the Lilly Endowment (or, rarely, independent funding), schools turned their attention to adolescent discipleship formation. Some of these efforts focused on seminarians and pastors; others focused on practitioners; many focused on teenage leaders themselves.
At the same time, academics and practitioners—concerned about the increasingly dire outlook for congregations generally—began to view youth ministry as a likely venue for initiating change in the church. History indicates that this is not a new role for youth ministry; youth ministry has often served as a kind of protest movement, calling into question practices that, to young people, seem transparently problematic.17 Christian Endeavor modeled coeducational leadership a generation before women gained the right to vote in the U.S.; Young Life integrated clubs and leadership teams a generation before the civil rights movement. Historian Jon Pahl points out that Christian youth organizations like the Lutheran Walther League, the Catholic Young Christian Workers, Youth for Christ, and numerous African American youth ministries contributed to changing cultural attitudes toward gender, the middle class, media, and civil rights.18
Youth ministry has often served as a kind of protest movement, calling into question practices that, to young people, seem transparently problematic.
To the degree that youth ministry's focus on education and reform is theologically driven (and is not just another defensive measure to shore up church membership), it clearly falls within the domain of practical theology. In fact, youth ministry stands to become even more significant as a context for shaping church leaders like Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Billy Graham, Pope John Paul II, and Bill Hybels of Willow Creek, whose visions of the church were provisionally tested in their days as youth ministers.
COMMON MISSION
Grade:B (needs to clarify theological thesis)
A Common Language: A Conundrum
Over time, emerging disciplines begin to share common terminologies—but youth ministry as a field of study is still in the "Goldilocks" stage, trying out terminology, searching for one that is "just right." What should we call this emerging discipline? We have already noticed that adolescence is a moving target, making the question of who youth ministry addresses very slippery. The phrase "youth ministry" is itself extremely problematic. It ignores youth ministry's relationship to other age groups (e.g., children and emerging adults), only vaguely describes the people it addresses, and in churches is often a code phrase for silliness that belies our current seriousness of purpose. "Youth and" designations underscore the interdisciplinary nature of the field but could go on endlessly: youth and young adults, youth and families, youth and mission, youth and discipleship, youth and children (and young adults, and families—and so on).
"Adolescent spiritual formation" sounds more academically respectable, and acknowledges the contributions of developmental theory and other social sciences. Yet each word in the phrase is problematic. Without a clear sense of when adolescence begins and ends, "adolescence" continues to mean one thing to social scientists and another to parents and congregations. "Spiritual" is one of those non-empirical words that bothers academics, and "formation" suggests youth ministry's debt to education, but not to God's transformation. Describing our work functionally might be a solution (e.g., "mission with young people," "discipleship formation with young people," etc.). This tactic clarifies youth ministry's purpose—although, as we have seen, there is not yet consensus on what our mission actually is. Furthermore, it invites another endless list of possibilities; is there any practice of the church that should not involve young people? As a matter of practical theology, a common language seems far away, and risks becoming a barrier that artificially narrows youth ministry's scope.
COMMON LANGUAGE
GRADE: D (works hard, but not progressing)
A Cadre of Professionals: A Significant Presence
One of the most obvious signs of youth ministry's maturation as a field of study is its increasing professionalization, which we have already discussed at length. Professional youth ministers are not new, though the model of a single professional youth minister leading hordes of young people—the "Pied Piper" image popularized in the 1940s and 1950s, when denominations had huge professional youth ministry staffs—is unrealistic today.19 In 2005, the average salary of a full-time youth worker in the U.S. was just under $40,000—just under the national average of American workers everywhere. While salaries remain low in youth ministry, they have apparently become high enough that fewer full-time youth workers are moonlighting at second jobs. In 2003 about one in three full-time youth workers (29 percent) had another job outside the church; by 2005, that number dropped to about one in five (17 percent).20
Today resources, professional networks, and academic journals have swelled the support systems available to youth ministry specialists, including those called to teach and research youth ministry. Specialty areas have proliferated (e.g., campus ministry, young adult ministry, ministry with young families, senior high and middle high ministry, older elementary ministry, and so on). Doctoral students, housed in parent disciplines like practical theology, education, or sociology—and who increasingly participate in networks facilitated by guilds and peer associations—have begun to focus Ph.D. research on pertinent issues in youth ministry, and some prominent institutions explicitly encourage research in youth ministry in their doctoral programs.21
In some ways, professional guilds serve as Rorschach tests for a new field of study's growing pains. Commenting on the 2005 annual meeting of the International Association for the Study of Youth Ministry, beliefnet commentator Tony Jones—then a Ph.D. student in practical theology—observed:
The first generation of youth ministry professors were old and wise youth workers who were hired by colleges and seminaries to teach this new discipline of church-based youth work. The second generation, and the bulk of those currently in most positions, hold terminal degrees in the social sciences (sociology, education, anthropology, cultural studies). And now there is an emerging generation of scholars (among which I count myself) who are primarily theologians. Thus, there are social scientists with an interest in theology and theologians with an interest in social science. Both sides have the tendency to get arrogant, yet each side needs the other.22
While numerous organizations exist to support the secular study of adolescence, only a handful currently support youth ministry's theological interests and those who teach them, or publish academic journals to that end. Some, like the National Federation of Catholic Youth Ministry, focus on training professional youth ministers but also function as networks for teachers, bishops, academics, and researchers who collaborate to improve professional competency in Catholic educational and catechetical organizations. Others, like the Association of Youth Ministry Educators and the International Association for the Study of Youth Ministry, focus on professional development for professors in colleges and seminaries, and leave the training of professional youth ministers to entrepreneurial groups like Group and Youth Specialties, and to an ever-increasing number of continuing education events offered by colleges and seminaries.
CADRE OF PROFESSIONALS
GRADE: B (has made great strides, enthusiastic contributor in youth ministry discussions, but research is uneven and the relationship between professionalization and faith maturity in adolescents remains muddled)
Academic Programs: Proliferating
As churches began to recognize children's, youth, young adult, and family ministries as legitimate vocational options for pastors and educators, academic programs in youth ministry began to proliferate. "Proliferation" is a relative term; most are small programs located in evangelical undergraduate colleges, with mainline liberal arts institutions and Catholic universities and seminaries are slowly but steadily adding to their number.23
Yet the curricular maturation of youth ministry is far from complete. Several problems dog youth ministry education at the curricular level, both in terms of what we teach and who teaches it. Academic programs fill a critical need but fail to address the vast majority of youth workers who are volunteers; what legitimizes these programs is the fact that students who enroll in academic youth ministry programs tend to wield more influence in churches than volunteers, and often train volunteers in various capacities. For this reason, the content of youth ministry curriculum has far-reaching impact. Jack and McRay's research on undergraduate youth ministry education programs (2005) found that students in these programs generally receive a background in biblical and theological studies, augmented by large servings of psychology, sociology, and educational theory, with various ministry courses sprinkled throughout. Yet Jack and McRay's study also revealed a dearth of educational offerings that fostered critical thinking, theological reflection and integration, empirical sophistication, attention to globalization or cultural "others," or pastoral (as opposed to therapeutic) identities among youth ministry graduates.24
Despite expanding curricular opportunities, coursework related to youth ministry (like children's ministry and emerging adult ministry) still tends to be "outsourced" to wise professionals instead of taught by regular faculty. This strategy brings great practical wisdom to students but reinforces youth ministry's peripheral status, and many practitioners struggle to strike a balance between praxis and theological reflection. Equally worrisome is the amount of so-called soft money supporting youth ministry in colleges and seminaries. Typically, grant-supported programs (in theological settings as in secular ones) are considered experimental or auxiliary to institutions' core values—nice, but not necessary. Grant money allows for unparalleled creativity—but at the cost of permanency. Soft money tends to create temporary faculty positions and temporary programs, which makes research difficult and faculty influence brief. Most leaders of such programs (typically youth ministers whose entrepreneurial skills have been honed by years of "making do") demonstrate remarkable resourcefulness within such institutional constraints. Yet outsourced and grant-supported youth ministry programs are a double-edged sword. On the one hand, grants have garnered unprecedented academic attention for youth ministry in the early twenty-first century. On the other hand, the temporary nature of grant funding contributes to youth ministry's marginalization in academic settings.
ACADEMIC PROGRAMS
GRADE: C+ (Shows vast improvement but has difficulty fully participating in academic discussion)
Academic Research: A Hopeful Sign
For most of the twentieth century, youth ministers relied on anecdotal evidence to determine the effectiveness of their work with young people. By the 1990s, however, churches began to scrutinize their practices of youth ministry, revealing a paucity of research that could guide them. Youth ministry's first foray into academic research was as a consumer: we borrowed research from secular fields and adapted them for our needs in ministry. Marketing research, psychology, sociology, cultural anthropology, and educational theory all provided invaluable data that helped us understand our work with adolescents. Youth ministers learned to be deft interdisciplinary synthesizers, adept at cross-disciplinary conversations that still allow us to draw, unabashedly, from research in disparate fields for the sake of living out the gospel with teenagers.
Youth ministry's first foray into academic research was as a consumer: we borrowed research from secular fields and adapted them for our needs in ministry.
While these interdisciplinary skills deepened youth ministry's intellectual work appreciably, we overlooked a significant point: that theology contributes to the interdisciplinary discussion as well, and that youth ministry has its own contributions to make to theology and social science. Thanks to the high percentage of youth ministry professors who are sociologists, psychologists, and educators, nontheological empirical research still dominates youth ministry research. Yet by the 1990s, we had begun—somewhat intuitively—to leverage decades of experience with young people to theologically reflect on adolescent development, leadership, and mission. What we learned was that much of what is true for ministry with adolescents is also true for the entire church. Inevitably, questions of importance to the whole church fall first to the young, starting with questions of identity: Who are we, the church, called to be in a cyber-connected universe? What is the role of the pastor for the Facebook generation? In a world where adolescence seems to be expanding and contracting simultaneously, what is the purpose of youth ministry? Questions that will undoubtedly shape the twenty-first century church, but that Christian young people are already grappling with, include:
Future Research Directions for Youth Ministry
Not only does youth ministry model interdisciplinary thinking, it helps advance Christian theories of leadership and adolescence, and invites us to rethink ecclesiology in culturally specific ways. Instinctively, youth ministers tend to employ practical theological methods in their work. As a result, youth ministry provides a lively laboratory for learning how Christian communities can contribute to interdisciplinary scholarly dialogue.
ACADEMIC RESEARCH
GRADE: C+ (Shows vast improvement, particularly in terms of practical theological reflection; consistency and quality of work remains erratic)
Distinctive Pedagogies: Still Evolving
Most professional fields develop pedagogies that immerse students in conditions, real or simulated, that enact situations and evoke practices indigenous to their field of study. Aspiring doctors have residencies, new teachers do student teaching, budding counselors log clinical hours. Even future academics immerse themselves in scholarly reflection and class presentations, on the assumption that the disciplined habits of mind required by scholarly inquiry should be practiced in doctoral seminars. Ministry with young people makes certain generalizations about adolescent learning styles (namely, that young people are more likely to actively, rather than passively, engage material—an assumption that has been both complicated and intensified by participatory media culture). However, youth ministry as a field of study for adults is still awaiting a distinctive pedagogy.
In fact, youth ministry pedagogy has much to offer theological education generally, since the issues confronting youth ministry as an emerging discipline tend to confront theological education as a whole. Youth ministry education gravitates toward coaching, mentoring, and apprenticeship pedagogies because they tap into youth pastors' relational instincts. As we have seen, situated learning stresses participation and education-in-context, and helps explain the power of retreats, campus mission trips, and other "immersion experiences" in the Christian life. Transformative learning—intended for adults—offers a method for evoking paradigm shifts that youth ministers employ instinctively, almost without exception. Even without reading the theory, what youth leader has not presented a "disorienting dilemma" to teenagers, in order to decenter them long enough to entertain a new idea or practice?25
And yet, when it comes to teaching adults about youth ministry, most of us teach the way we were taught—which is to say, we teach youth ministry the way we teach everything else. Furthermore, while the educational methods we use with teenagers may offer our best hope for modeling and developing pastoral imagination (for all areas of theological education, not youth ministry alone), the links between discipleship formation and educational methods remain implicit and underutilized.
DISTINCTIVE PEDAGOGIES
GRADE: B (Enormous natural talent here, but not living up to potential. Need to apply ourselves)
Growing Pains in a Growing Field
On a 12-point scale, we get a C+ overall as an emerging discipline, slightly above average and tipping toward "not bad." We're not failing, and in fact we have made noticeable and impressive strides, but there is plenty of room for improvement. To move "up" to full disciplinary status in the academy requires straight A's. As the scope of youth ministry broadens to include academic preparation, the theological purpose of the field inevitably challenges many of the norms of modern professional life. Unless we redefine what we mean by "academic discipline," youth ministry faces two problems in its journey toward disciplinary status. First, it is likely to have difficulty meeting the criteria for academic longevity, in part because longevity is still difficult for youth ministry leaders, and also because the norms of youth ministry challenge the competitive, individualistic, achievement-oriented habits of academic culture. Second, in the absence of clearly articulated (and widely shared) goals related to faith formation and practical theology, youth ministry is likely to capitulate to the standards of social sciences, overlooking the very standards that Christians deem crucial to forming and living as disciples of Jesus Christ.
Is academic respectability a pipe dream for youth ministry, and must we sell our souls to get it? Or do we sell our souls without it?
In the meantime, the most important question facing us is one of integrity. Daily, those of us who teach others in ministry must ask ourselves and each other, "How do we live the life we teach about?" How do we practice the kind of soul-full ministry we covet for young people themselves, when the cultureat-large seems anything but redemptive? How do we become means of grace in our communities, even academic ones? Is academic respectability a pipe dream for youth ministry, and must we sell our souls to get it? Or do we sell our souls without it? Is youth ministry a harbinger of things to come in the church and in theological education generally, an example of an emerging discipline for a postmodern church, a model for integrating the imagination, experience, and courage that finds its truest expression, not in academic criteria, but in young people themselves?
Much will depend on your ministry, and the intentionality with which you pursue these questions. The end of this book has yet to be written, for the conversations we have started on these pages are ongoing, and are being shaped by ministries like yours. These pages represent our stick in the sand, a marker of how far we can see the tide coming in from where we sit. But where scholars place the marker next depends largely on where God takes your ministry, and on where God takes you. We are watching with gratitude and anticipation. Carry on.
Further Reading on Themes in This Chapter
Dykstra, Craig. "Pastoral and Ecclesial Imagination," in Dorothy Bass, ed., For Life Abundant. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008, 41–61.
Foster, Charles, et al. Educating Clergy: Teaching Practices and Pastoral Formation. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2005.
Jacks, Andrew S., and Barrett W. McRae. "Tassel-Flipping: A Portrait of the Well-Educated Youth Ministry Graduate," Journal of Youth Ministry 4 (Fall 2005), 53-73.
Lave, Jean, and Etienne Wenger. Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation. Cambridge, England: University of Cambridge, 1991.
Mezirow, Jack. Transformational Dimensions of Adult Learning. San Francisco: Jossey Bass, 1991.
Osmer, Richard R. Practical Theology: An Introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
Pahl, Jon. Youth Ministry in Modern America, 1930–present. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 2000.
Paulsell, Stephanie. "Pastoral Agility and Intellectual Work," lecture, Yale Divinity School (April 2003), Harvard Divinity Bulletin, http://www.hds.harvard.edu/news/ bulletin/articles/paulsell.html
Schön, Donald. Educating the Reflective Practitioner. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1987.
