Chapter 5 of 14

Chapter Two

Chapter Two

CHAPTER TWO

DAUNTING CHALLENGES

At the end of forty days they returned from spying out the land. And they came to Moses and Aaron and to all the congregation of the Israelites in the wilderness . . . and they told [them], "We came to the land to which you sent us; it flows with milk and honey, and this is its fruit. Yet the people who live in the land are strong, and the towns are fortified and very large." . . . [Caleb] said, "Let us go up at once and occupy it, for we are well able to overcome it." [But] the men who had gone up with him said, "We are not able to go up against this people, for they are stronger than we are. . . . All the people that we saw in it are of great size. . . . To ourselves we seemed like grasshoppers, and so we seemed to them."

—Numbers 13:25-33

I do live in crazy times.

—Anne Frank

First, don't panic.

That's the advice Sara Savage and her colleagues offer, reporting their research on "Generation Y" in response to 2004's Mission-Shaped Church report. The report—an unlikely bestseller in the U.K., penned by a group of Anglican bishops—gained widespread attention for the urgency with which it pointed to the growing cultural gap between the church and the culture of postmodern young people in the United Kingdom.1

Savage and her co-writers point out that in each new cultural era, the church "has been faced with a worldview and a way of life that had previously managed perfectly well without the gospel," so has had to learn how to engage with its new cultural setting under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.2

Throughout church history this has been done well and it has been done badly. When done badly it has tended to leave future generations with baggage they could well have done without. But the missionary story also contains many examples of good practice. Some cultures may prove harder for the Church to connect with than others, but none are harder for the Holy Spirit. There is no effective alternative to inculturation, to engaging people with the gospel within and as appropriate to their own culture and worldview.3

Savage's conclusions remind us that postmodern Christians are not the first generation to feel overwhelmed and outnumbered. Rewind to Numbers 13, after Joshua and Caleb and team return from scouting out the culture next door. If you have ever tried to familiarize yourself with the cultural icons, artifacts, or rituals of the teenagers in your church, you know what Joshua and Caleb must have felt like on the scouting expedition to Canaan. On the one hand, popular culture seems to be flowing with milk and honey; it is replete with visions of "the good life," brimming with resources and opportunities. Surely the church can occupy this culture, enjoy its beauty, borrow its images, and baptize its traditions for the gospel! After all, haven't we already translated football's high holy days into opportunities to raise money to fight hunger, and haven't we drawn on everything from film to hip hop to translate our prayers into a popular vernacular?4

The most thoroughgoing program of formation in North America is the one molding young people into consumers.

On the other hand, the media juggernaut that propels Western ideologies around the world seems irresistible, even when we make the gospel available through clever translations. It is not clear who "wins" when churches borrow from popular culture; does culture become more attuned to the gospel in these efforts, or does the church become swallowed by the culture? The most thoroughgoing program of formation in North America is the one molding young people into consumers. Relentless, zealous, and insidious, this program of formation "brands" young Americans before they can talk.5 Like the spies in Canaan, Christians often feel intimated by the magnitude of these cultural forces; we know they are stronger than we are. The global scope, the incessant pace, the consumer narratives that equate adolescent worth with product consumption—these are Goliath-sized challenges for youth ministry. We seem "like grasshoppers" beside them, microscopic citizens of Who-ville who yell from our speck of dust in hopes of being heard by adolescents before we are run over by them.6

Of course, in the Dr. Seuss story, it took every last Who down in Whoville to make a racket loud enough to be heard by giant-sized Horton and his friends.7 But American churches do not clamor very loudly when it comes to young people. Marketers also view us as grasshoppers—which is to say they are not very worried that the church might derail their ambitions to cast teenagers in the role of consumers-in-training. More often, churches cooperate in this training venture, treating faith as a product to be acquired, and consequently reinforcing our own consumer mentalities.

Spying on Canaan

Most youth ministers have a little bit of Caleb in us, or we wouldn't be in the foolhardy business of immersing consumer-minded teenagers in an alternative story about who they are and why they are here—a story that so radically undermines our homage to progress, success, and personal fulfillment that you can understand why teenagers find it hard to swallow. I (Don) am currently a confirmation sponsor for Thomas, an articulate ninth-grader from my congregation. Thomas attends Sunday worship with his parents and his younger sister every week, takes academic courses on the Bible at school, and can tell you more about the kings of Israel and Judah than any adult I know. For the past few years, Thomas has participated in a Thursday morning before-breakfast Bible study, which teenagers take turns leading. "Those guys really know the Bible," Thomas remarks. "They get me. They see who I am."

For all this, Thomas is not sure whether he believes in God. He's even less sure that "joining" the church makes any sense, other than to please his parents. The God he reads about in the Bible troubles him; God sometimes seems capricious and unfair, which for Thomas makes God unworthy of worship and allegiance. And unless Thomas can write a personal statement of faith with integrity, he does not want to be confirmed.

Two-thirds of American teenagers believe that people do not need to be involved in a religious congregation to be religious and spiritual.

Thomas's attitude toward the church squares with those of the young people interviewed for the National Study of Youth and Religion, mentioned in chapter 1. Two-thirds of American teenagers believe that people do not need to be involved in a religious congregation to be religious and spiritual.8 Most young people treat faith as an individual choice, like considering a product they might want to buy, rather than as a communal undertaking. Smith and his colleagues observe:

This individualistic, antiestablishment proclivity lives, ironically, in the heart of much of American institutional religion itself. And it has helped to form an important popular cultural distinction between "an authentic faith"—which is personally chosen, regularly practiced, and spiritually meaningful—and an "empty faith," which is ritualistically rote, spiritually dry, and invested more in organizational associations than "real," personal experience.9

Historically, youth ministry has challenged the church by insisting that it reflect its cultural location. Christians may be called "to be in the world but not of the world," but (as a friend of mine says) churches shouldn't be "out of it" either.10 Yet changes in both the adolescent lifestage and the North American context influence the way we will approach ministry with young people—and perhaps even underscore a new role for youth ministry in the church.

Daunting Challenges for Youth Ministry

The Challenges of a Changing Lifestage

Expanding Adolescence?

Ending Adolescence?

The Challenges of a Changing Context

A New Sense of Place: The Challenge of Getting Grounded

A New Sense of Time: The Challenge of Changing Tempo

A New Sense of Stuff: The Challenge of Living Generously

A New Sense of Self: The Challenge of Branding

A New Sense of Story: The Challenge of Telling the Truth

Challenges Ahead: Serving Christ in a Post-Christendom Church Learning to Be Church (Again)

The Challenges of a Changing Lifestage

The adolescent lifestage is a modern, Western invention. Until quite recently in human history, you were either a child or an adult; societies invoked rites of passage to announce a young person's readiness to mate, but there was no period of "becoming" that prepared youth for social responsibility unless you were one of the privileged few who could afford the moratorium offered by travel or formal education. What changed in Western society was industrialization. With the technology of the Industrial Revolution, labor demands shifted dramatically, and pressure increased to prevent youth from taking jobs from their elders, and to occupy their free time as a result of their newfound unemployment. In the middle and upper classes, school became the preferred holding tank (although secondary education in the U.S. did not become compulsory, or universally available, until after World War II). This left hundreds of thousands of young people, no longer essential in an agricultural economy, without a prescribed route into adult society—so by the mid-1800s, they were flocking to the cities in search of employment and adventure.

On the heels of the Second Great Awakening, organizations like the YMCA (1844) and YWCA (1855) sprang up to organize urban young people with time on their hands. The expressed desire of the YMCA was to offer young people an "evangelical creed" to help them resist urban temptations.11 By the late nineteenth century, "child-centeredness" had become a middle-class virtue, and small-town, middle-class Protestants began to look for ways to protect their children's childhood and forestall "precocious" adulthood. In cities, the "child saver" movement, an effort to rescue youth from a draconian court system by keeping them busy with organized youth activities, helped teenagers avoid decisions leading to adult responsibility. Historian Anthony Platt points out,

Many of the child savers' reforms were aimed at imposing sanctions on conduct unbecoming youth and disqualifying youth from the benefit of adult privileges.The child savers were more concerned with restriction than liberation, with the protection of youth from moral weaknesses as well as physical dangers.12

This was the milieu that sired the "youth group," the peer-intensive model of youth ministry so familiar to us today. In 1904, when G. Stanley Hall penned his tome Adolescence, he established, securely if erroneously, young people's newfound cultural status as objects of both fear and fascination. Hall described adolescence as a period of "storm and stress" (a view quickly discredited by subsequent research, but the description has been maddeningly persistent).13 For Hall, the outcome of the stormy, stressful lifestage was conversion—not the evangelical conversion sought by American revivalism, but a harmonization of drives and instincts that led to sexual and ethical maturity.14

In this religious and social context, youth suddenly became more than a concept: it became fact. By the twentieth century, the pontoons on which the idea of "adolescence" had been floating were replaced by the steel girders of protection, restriction, and dependence. Churches did their part by establishing "youth ministries" bolstered by early literature in psychology and education.15 After World War II, universally available secondary education laid the tracks for an age-stratified society, allowing "youth" to coalesce into "peer culture" and Madison Avenue to treat "teenagers" and their newly disposable income as a marketing niche (in 1956, the average American teenager had a weekly income of $10.50—and by 1999, $94 a week).16 Writing in the 1950s and 1960s, developmental psychologist Erik H. Erikson launched generations of research on "ego-identity formation" as the defining task of adolescence. Erikson's "moratorium," a socially sanctioned "time out" between childhood and adult commitments, became widely accepted as necessary for helping young people successfully prepare for adult roles in a complex modern society. In short, as young people responded to society's response to them, "adolescence" was no longer the exception. It had become psychologically and culturally normative.17

In 1956, the average American teenager had a weekly income of $10.50—and by 1999, $94 a week.

Expanding Adolescence?

Today, adolescence starts sooner and ends later than it did in 1950, with great ambiguity on both ends. The most obvious markers are biological. Normal puberty (the attainment of fertility) takes between 1.5 to 6 years to complete, and in the last century the average age for the onset of menstruation has dropped from age seventeen to twelve, with secondary sex characteristics (e.g., pubic hair and breast buds) appearing before age 8 for a large number of girls. African American and Mexican American girls start menstruation about six months earlier than girls of European descent.18 Boys also start puberty earlier than in previous generations, though the change is far less dramatic.

Precocious puberty has both social and biological consequences. Early developing girls are more likely to develop breast cancer, become pregnant, perform poorly in school and become victims of physical and sexual violence. Environmental health researcher Sandra Steingraber explains, "Girls get their first periods, on average, a few months earlier than girls 40 years ago, but they get their breasts one to two years earlier."19 The reasons for these changes remain unclear, and probably can be attributed in part to both improved health care and nutrition and patterns of obesity, though many researchers also cite environmental factors (especially hormone-mimicking chemicals commonly found in plastics, fire retardants, and other household items).

An early start to puberty, however, does not signal an early completion of the adolescent lifestage. On the contrary, adolescence ends later than it did a generation ago, and has even provoked some researchers to observe a transitional stage in the lifecycle emerging as the tasks associated with identity formation extend beyond the teenage years. Most contemporary young Americans eschew the title of "adult" until their late twenties or early thirties (one University of Chicago study found that most Americans think adulthood begins at age twenty-six).20 Developmental theorists generally agree that identity formation is the signature task of adolescence—but the tasks associated with identity formation (negotiating commitments of love, work, and ideology) are increasingly postponed. Psychologist Jeffrey Arnett thinks this postponement signals a new stage in the lifecycle, "emerging adulthood," when these tasks are now accomplished.21 Significantly, these developmental tasks include coming to terms with questions of faith, whether young people think of themselves as "religious" or not. As Arnett puts it, human beings "invariably address religious questions as part of our lives. . . . Forming religious beliefs appears to be a universal part of identity development."22

Human beings "invariably address religious questions as part of our lives. . . . Forming religious beliefs appears to be a universal part of identity development."—Jeffrey Arnett

Ending of Adolescence?

Biological markers signal the beginning of adolescence, but the end of adolescence is far more ambiguous. If fertility is no longer the sign of adulthood, then what is? Some scholars argue that since adolescence no longer functions as a transition into adulthood, it should be abandoned. They believe that middle-class interests have artificially reinforced and prolonged adolescence, infantilizing young people who are sexually, intellectually, and psychologically capable of making adult commitments far sooner than our laws or our morals allow. "Teens have become the last group whose disempowerment is invisible because it is so much taken for granted," argues psychiatrist Philip Graham.23 These scholars maintain that social forces not only invented adolescence; they have prolonged it long past its due. Psychologist Robert Epstein criticizes religious communities for their uncritical buy-in of a view of adolescence similar to G. Stanley Hall's in 1904, in which teenagers are weak and incompetent and in need of strict adult supervision.24 Instead of creating structures that reinforce these stereotypes, Epstein believes, social institutions like churches should accord teenagers the same power and privileges they offer adults, enabling youth to live into the roles and responsibilities of adulthood.

Epstein grossly oversimplifies religious communities' attitudes toward young people (and maturation in general); young people are often prophetic leaders in churches, and youth ministry has frequently served as a venue for leadership formation in and beyond the church.25 But many youth ministers (including the authors of this book) share the intuition that American social institutions expect too little of teenagers, disenfranchising and infantilizing them—and churches are no exception. Practical theologian and youth minister David White writes perceptively that this attitude is no longer tenable in American culture:

Until recent years, the bargain of adolescence—dependence and education now, responsibility and independence later—has worked reasonably well for many, due primarily to its brief span and the certain reward of middle class employment. However, recent cultural developments have made problematic this unwritten treaty with youth. These developments relegate youth to institutions in which they have less than full power for longer than any age cohort in the history of the world, leaving them considerably less free to make their distinctive mark on history, and are quickly shaping them as passive consumers rather than active agents and shapers of history.26

American social institutions expect too little of teenagers, disenfranchising and infantilizing them—and churches are no exception.

While scholars like Epstein argue that adolescence should be terminated as an unnecessary step toward adulthood, others argue that adolescence has already ended by virtue of its conflation with adulthood. By the late twentieth century, adolescence had become a lifestyle as well as a lifestage, possible to cultivate and prolong by choice. As a result, many people who were chronologically adults remained socially (and sometimes psychologically) adolescent. Some people have always made the "bargain of adolescence" that White describes—a moratorium way of life marked by dependence, preparation, and postponed responsibilities—somewhat permanent, but for most people the need to pay bills generally made this a short-term arrangement. Today, consumer culture thrives on blurring the borders of adolescence, hawking adult toys to youth (and children) and marketing youth-like lifestyles to adults. Purchasing power, not maturity, is the prerequisite for full participation in consumer culture (and adolescents do a fine job of this without an integrated identity). Whether extended moratoria lead to (or cause) either the "slacker" stereotypes once associated with Generation X, or the "risk averse" mentality said to characterize their younger siblings—or whether social attitudes simply encourage us to stay "young" as long as possible—the upshot is that today's adolescents and adults often look very like one another, making the adolescent lifestage seem increasingly irrelevant.

These attitudes do meet resistance, sometimes from young people themselves. Comparing the effects of 2008's plummeting economy on young people to youth growing up in the Great Depression, a widely read New York Times article predicted a reversal of prolonged adolescence. Emerging adults, negatively affected by the poor economy, are making a return to "Things That Matter," according to author Kate Zernicke—thus ending the ever-expanding carefree moratoria associated with adolescence. Even before the so-called Recession Generation, some upwardly mobile twenty-somethings (dubbed the "New Victorians") united behind a fierce commitment to marriage, parenting, and vocation early in life, "settling down" with families in their early twenties in a bid to choose adulthood as a way of life.27

These debates over how adolescence is changing raise two sets of core questions for the church. First, who is youth ministry for? In other words, in contemporary American culture, who "counts" as a youth and who doesn't? Second, should Christians protect young people from precocious adulthood, or should we encourage adulthood to start sooner? Does God call us to shield young people from the dangers of a predatory dominant culture by immersing them in an alternative "Christian" culture instead? Or, does God call us to liberate youth from the dominant culture's ideological shackles (including those imposed by the church) to assume their identities as Christian adults—even if they lack sufficient formation to know what "Christian" adulthood means?

We are using youth ministry as an umbrella term that refers to ministry to, with, and for adolescents and their families, focusing especially on young people from the onset of puberty through emerging adulthood. (We also refer to "teenagers" or "adolescents" from time to time, to acknowledge the age groups that churches most often have in mind.)28 We recognize that the term youth ministry is problematic; societal changes and regional customs make the definition of youth itself something of a moving target. (Outside the U.S., youth commonly includes persons in their twenties and thirties, or persons of any age whose parents are still alive.) What we can say with certainty is that churches can no longer afford to limit youth ministry to teenagers who gather in the church basement. The research on adolescence, and our citizenship in a global village, require us to extend our reach.

Churches can no longer afford to limit youth ministryto teenagers who gather in the church basement. The research on adolescence, and our citizenship in a global village, require us to extend our reach.

The Challenges of a Changing Context

The changing adolescent lifestage is largely the result of changing sociocultural conditions in which young people are immersed. Since young people's cultural "screens" and psychological defense mechanisms are not yet fully formed, they are remarkably open to context, and are typically the first to feel the tremors of cultural shifts. Today's adolescents reflect what Savage and her colleagues call the three key coordinates of Generation Y's (born after 1980) culture: globalization and its effects on time and space, electronic and information technologies, and consumerism. Of course, these coordinates affect the entire church as well, but young people pursue these themes with such intensity that it is easy to forget that these engines of cultural change have pursued young people first.

This may be a good time to remind ourselves that the bricks of the church and the bricks of the culture are made from the same mud.

This may be a good time to remind ourselves that the bricks of the church and the bricks of the culture are made from the same mud.29 All anthropologists view religion as a critical component of culture, which means that the church needs the same redemption as other humanly constructed communities. But since Christians' first allegiance is to Christ—not to the state, the economy, the media, the educational system, the nuclear family, or any other lesser gods we might erect—the Holy Spirit nudges us to detach ourselves from competing allegiances and focus intently on Jesus in all that we do. This does, in fact, distinguish those followers of Jesus from those who fix their attention on other human horizons. Unlike worldly wisdom, for example, gospel wisdom calls youth and adults to

  • care for the world God created and loves
  • respect human freedom and finitude
  • consume in ways that honor the earth and one another
  • cultivate their relationship with God through personal and communal prayer
  • tell truthful and graceful stories about our lives as God's children.
  • Attuning our lives to the gospel allows us to hear the dissonance between who we are, and who God calls us to be as followers of Jesus. But it is hard to detect this on our own. The community of faith is our tuning fork, and the power of the Holy Spirit is the vibration running through the church that helps us discern Christ's pitch over the din of cultural clatter. Here are some of the cultural issues making the most noise:

    A New Sense of Place: The Challenge of Getting Grounded

    Grace began volunteering at the foot clinic of Central Presbyterian Church's night shelter for homeless men as an eighth-grade confirmand.30 Every Wednesday night, Grace and the other volunteers offer guests a warm-water soak for tired, sore feet. Grace clips nails, treats infections, bandages cuts, and gives gentle foot massages. Somehow the act of washing restores dignity to the whole body. Even outside the foot clinic, Grace catches herself staring at feet sometimes, wondering where they have walked and what they might need. She feels deeply connected to the men she meets at the shelter. "It's like getting a new family," she says. "You get to know some of the regular guys by name. Sometimes they talk about their struggles with faith. Once I met a guy who was going through a really hard time. He asked me for advice, as though we were already friends."

    For Grace, taking the street-worn feet of homeless men in her hands is an act of genuine humility. The word humility comes from humus, the Latin word for "dirt." Grace's act of footwashing connects her to the men in the clinic, to the feet she sees every day, to the city they share. It grounds her, the way feet ground us in a place—literally, connecting us to the dirt, locating us, giving us a place to stand. The foot clinic also is a place Grace stands her ground beside Jesus. His followers washed his feet and he humbled himself to wash theirs.

    "Place" no longer means what it once did; in a globalized world, "here" and "there" are increasingly detached from geography and redefined according to access.

    Yet "place" no longer means what it once did; in a globalized world, "here" and "there" are increasingly detached from geography and redefined according to access. "Where are you going?" can refer to a location in cyberspace, a virtual visit, a faraway culture. Even rural teenagers, though more rooted to geography than their urban cousins, find their relationship to place complicated by the economic, technological, and cultural changes wrought by globalization. Scholars describe global culture using "liquid" images instead of "solid" ones.31 For the majority of Americans, place is fluid; in the U.S., teenagers watch hometown factories close so that production can be outsourced to regions with cheaper labor. They know they are inheriting (and are already participating in) a global economy that is rapidly depleting natural resources, that objectifies human laborers, and that threatens myriad species with extinction—even as they leverage global systems to make the economy work. Allegiance to place is increasingly expendable; it is easier to make decisions that degrade local ecologies and compromise local lifestyles when the decision-makers don't live there.

    Globalization makes instability a cultural norm, unhinging local attachments, which paradoxically intensifies our longing for "home." In this context, cultivating a community of care for people we do not know personally, and for the world God created and loves, becomes increasingly challenging—and necessary—for the church. The gospel calls us to balance concern for all of God's creation, near and far, with radical connections to the here and now. Christians maintain that the Word of God is a particular, not a generic, Word: it is God's Word in Jesus Christ. The First Council of Nicea in 325 urged Christians to faithfully ground their hope in the particularity of Christ, while recognizing the church's witness in the wider world.32 In no case does the church operate as a multinational organization. Each Christian community is a concentration of the whole church, not a branch office of some larger corporation.

    Globalization makes instability a cultural norm, unhinging local attachments, which paradoxically intensifies our longing for "home."

    What this means is that those of us in youth ministry must learn to view "place" through binoculars, bringing near and far horizons into focus simultaneously. As the gathered church, we are bound together as a ommunity of practice in a particular place.33 A place has density and materiality—bodies and buildings, faces and livelihoods—that a location on a map does not. Whether we gather in an urban cathedral or a rural farmhouse, the church cultivates a fidelity to place often lacking in "the global village." Christian spirituality honors the particularity of its host culture. Churches over the centuries have always been united by their common focus on the person of Jesus Christ, relied on the same holy books, and engaged in the same special practices involving water, oil, bread, and wine—but other than that, a time-traveler might be hard-pressed to find similarities between eleventh-century Celtic monks up to their necks in ice water singing hymns, and twentieth-century Nigerian charismatics dancing through Sunday worship.34 One of the miracles of the Christian community is that we still recognize it after centuries of local adaptation. Yet the church's binocular vision requires us to address both the neighbor beside us and the neighbor beyond us. Christ not only calls the church to take seriously its native soil; Christ also calls us to follow him beyond our provincial boundaries to become apostles as well as disciples, and witnesses in the world.

    A New Sense of Time: The Challenge of Changing Tempo

    Related to the challenge of displacement posed by globalization is the challenge of unbounded time posed by our "24/7" culture. The metaphor of global village conjures up an image of one large, cooperative community, united by the consumption of common products. But economically, the global village is not a cozy place. The pressure to compete for buyers fuels our determination to push our limits in order to remain competitive. While previous generations experienced the sweep of time using analog clocks, contemporary teenagers know time as a series of discrete, digital moments: now it's 3:34 p.m. . . . now it's 3:35 p.m. . . . and so on. Although physicists maintain that there is no such thing as perpetual motion (gravity and resistance eventually have their way in all matters of movement), global commerce has convinced us that time has no boundaries, and should be leveraged in the service of selling.

    North American young people are formed by a culture where time and aspirations have come unhinged from their natural limits. Like Icarus, our bid to live unlimited lives makes us forget that our wings are made of wax—that being human means that we are made to live within bodies and time, to be present and fully alive in a particular moment. To ignore our moment in time is to squander a piece of our humanity.

    To ignore our moment in time is to squander a piece of our humanity.

    As a result, most of us do not view time as a gift. We tend to think of it as a limit, a commodity to leverage, a product in scarce supply. We may or may not be working more hours than our grandparents did—reports vary, and younger workers are far more concerned (and intentional) about the work/family balance than their parents were.35 What is certain is that technology has blurred the line between worktime and downtime; fewer and fewer people "leave the office" at the end of the day as technology makes it easier (and expected) for us to conduct our professional lives from home. A tsunami of emails and text messages—and the expectation of constant availability—creates low-grade anxiety as we do message-reply triage. We even blur the borders of waking and sleeping; sleep deprivation has been called America's top health disorder (the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration attributes more than 100,000 crashes and 1,500 fatalities a year to driver fatigue alone).36

    Teenagers, of course, are programmed—by biology and by society—to test limits; they often push themselves in work and play beyond their capacities, often with the full cooperation of the adults who love them best. We urge young people to "seize the day," to fill their calendars with "productive activities" that will impress college admission counselors or will at least keep them "out of trouble." The result is a fusion of sacred time with ordinary time, a confusion of Sabbath and labor—which ultimately means a loss of holiness, the "set apartness" of God's people. In a pluralistic culture, Sunday is no longer an agreed-upon holy day, and the common worship hour is challenged by middleclass culture's avalanche of opportunities. Without a day of rest, some youth leaders build youth ministries around mission trips rather than Sunday fellowship gatherings in an attempt to leverage one week a year when young people will prioritize coming together with Christians (providing they plan far enough ahead).

    Fred Edie, commenting on the time crunch faced by youth ministry, observes: "To ask, 'How can we find time to fit church into youths' lives?' is the wrong question. It is far better to ask, 'How can we offer youth the gift of time that God has created, redeemed, and continues to sanctify daily through Jesus Christ?' "37 If the goal of human time is work and productivity, the goal of liturgical time is to enjoy God and imitate Christ. The church sets its clock by Easter, and Christianity's two most subversive timepieces, the liturgical calendar and the practice of keeping Sabbath, explicitly undermine our enslavement to the limits of time by boldly embracing the freedom of the resurrection. Christ has removed death as our human time limit. Easter offers concrete evidence that time belongs to God, who chooses to share eternity with us.

    "To ask, 'How can we find time to fit church into youths' lives?' is the wrong question. It is far better to ask, 'How can we offer youth the gift of time that God has created, redeemed, and continues to sanctify daily through Jesus Christ?'"—Fred Edie

    The liturgical calendar gives young people a different way of telling time than the one dictated by the academic year or soccer season. The liturgical year is comprised of "a sequence of days and seasons, woven together in an order that tells the story of Christ and leads believers ever deeper into the mysteries of the Christian faith."38 During Advent, we emphasize waiting (anathema to merchandizing). During Lent, we prepare ourselves to encounter Jesus' betrayal, crucifixion, and resurrection, a decidedly different approach to spring break than the one proposed by MTV. God gave Sabbath to the Israelites to remind them that their enslavement in Egypt was over. No more 24/7 workweeks: "[For] six days you shall labor and do all your work. But the seventh day is a sabbath to the LORD your God; you shall not do any work" (Exodus 20:9-10). It was a commandment designed to subvert business as usual, to help the Israelites—and to help us—experience the freedom of lifegiving boundaries. Sabbath offers young people a way to say "No" to the slavery imposed by an endless cycle of producing and consuming, and "Yes" to feasting, worship, and playful re-creation.39

    Of course, the real challenge of embracing liturgical time with young people is to become committed Sabbath-keepers ourselves.40 "Teach us to count our days," the psalmist implores, "that we may gain a wise heart" (Psalm 90:12). If time is God's gift, a rhythmic reminder that genuine freedom is always circumscribed by human finitude, then our best shot at teaching young people to receive the day as a blessing instead of a burden is by modeling Christian timekeeping—a rhythm of life punctuated by Sabbaths, and that trusts that time belongs to God.

    A New Sense of Stuff: The Challenge of Living Generously

    Every Wednesday night, teen volunteers at the Agape Community Kitchen in Westfield, New Jersey, prepare and serve a nutritious meal to 250 people in the nearby town of Elizabeth. Teenagers started (and continue to lead) this soup kitchen ministry, which also provides a clothing closet for guests to receive blankets, clothes, and shoes. What began as a Presbyterian youth group's hands-on service activity has become a weekly, way-of-life priority that for almost a decade has attracted a very diverse corps of teenage volunteers. Young people are drawn to an activity that matters, that makes a difference in the world. Over time, Agape "forms" participants by engaging them in gospel practices of hospitality, bread-breaking, and justice-seeking. Stories and images of Christ emerge organically as youth stir chili, wash dishes, and listen to the testimony of guests. After serving, sharing dinner with, and cleaning up after their guests, young people debrief the evening with a pastor: Where was Christ most clearly present tonight?

    To be human means to consume. Consumption is an identity-shaping practice; as the saying goes, "You are what you eat." Eating together with Jesus gradually shaped a group of fishermen and tax collectors into Jesus' disciples, just as eating at Jesus' table today profoundly shapes us into disciples as well, as we consume—and are ourselves consumed by—grace. At the communion table, there is always more than enough to go around.

    Consumption is an identity-shaping practice; as the saying goes, "You are what you eat."

    It is ironic that Christians, especially those born into a culture of plenty, buy into the scarcity myth: the fear that there is not enough to go around promotes gratuitous consumption at every level. Despite God's lavish and prodigal grace, which has showered creation with resources that promote the flourishing of life, sin allows the suspicion of scarcity to supplant our awareness of God's abundance. The scarcity myth destroys trust and leads people to hoard rather than share life-giving resources. Whether it is an Israelite squirreling away more than his share of manna or a teenager amassing more after-school activities than she can ever invest in, we humans have perfected the art of distrusting God's providence. We try to protect ourselves against the future. It always backfires.

    In Christian practice, the Eucharist (also called the Lord's Supper or Holy Communion) is our rhythmic reminder that our futures are not in our hands. Paul urged Christians to celebrate the Eucharist in order to enjoy God's gifts and remember that our sustenance comes at the price of another's sacrifice. Grain and grapes were crushed so that we have the benefits of bread and wine; Jesus died so that we might live. The Eucharist helps young people distinguish between feasting (which celebrates abundance) and binging (motivated by food insecurity that leads us to hoard). Paul encouraged every new community of Christians to center its common life around shared meals, and to invite Gentiles as well as Jews to Jesus' table. Wherever house churches sprang up during those first centuries, dining rooms were expanded to accommodate larger tables for feeding the faithful and especially the poor.41 Wherever communion is served today, young people get a glimpse of God's expansive grace that invites all people to be nourished by the gospel together, challenging the hypnotizing drone of consumer culture.

    The Eucharist helps young people distinguish between feasting (which celebrates abundance) and binging (motivated by food insecurity that leads us to hoard).

    A New Sense of Self: The Challenge of Branding

    Paradoxically, cultures of consumption are fueled by a detachment from things. If I'm attached to a favorite coat I've worn for years, I won't run out to buy a new one. At some level I need to be dissatisfied with what I have so that I'll crave something else and go shopping. Marketers work hard to cultivate this dissatisfaction and then to forge a relationship between people and products via branding, getting people to identify with a particular corporate brand. Their goal is to embed products so deeply into my identity that I cannot imagine being me without it.42 Branding cultivates cradle-to-grave product loyalty among consumers, from Mickey Mouse underwear at six to Disneyworld honeymoons at twenty-six, even as the product itself becomes "new and improved."

    The seductive power of branding becomes stronger when relational bonds between people become weaker.

    The seductive power of branding becomes stronger when relational bonds between people become weaker. When friends disappoint, when families feel fractured, when we feel disconnected and apart, brand loyalty offers a sense of identity confirmation and continuity. "Love may let you down, but I'll always be here for you," a brand-name product seems to whisper. When teenagers feel excluded, a brand-name product reassures them that they belong to a worldwide community of product users. Wherever they happen to be in the world, a brand becomes a familiar face in an anonymous, uncaring crowd (especially convenient for U.S. citizens, as our national economy now produces more popular brands than tangible products).43

    Advertising images rarely present and defend truth claims; they rely on suggestion and inference, the power of a story half-told. To finish the story, we must buy into it (literally). Before a product can save us, we must purchase it. Of course, the power of suggestion is not limited to consumer products. Governments instill patriotism; magazines advocate styles of dress, hair, and music; sports teams fan team loyalty; churches develop youth activities to target teens who are "sold" on particular "brands" of piety (spiritual? social? wholesome? pious?)—all suppress diversity in an effort to build loyalty around a particular point of view. And, once categorized, teenagers gravitate toward others who have adopted similar "brands" that, paradoxically, adults have imagined for them. Even "youth" itself functions as a brand in American culture. Celebrity stereotypes commodify young people and youthfulness, reducing young stars to "perpetual youth-hood" as we invest them with perfections, powers, and other airbrushed attributes. There is only one rule: do not age.

    The church confers identity by a cleansing bath rather than by attaching a label. Baptism washes away our fake I.D.s and reveals our worth before God— worth that is independent of purchasing power, personal style, or nation-state affiliation. Through baptism, we become part of a body where everybody counts and nobody is disposable—where in fact weaker members are given greater honor (1 Corinthians 12). If the practice of celebrating communion is one way the church redirects young people's understanding of consumption, the practice of baptism represents the church's attitude toward branding. Christian identity is a gift from God, not the upshot of our relationship with a product.

    Baptism washes away our fake I.D.s and reveals our worth before God—worth that is independent of purchasing power, personal style, or nation-state affiliation.

    A New Sense of Story: The Challenge of Telling the Truth

    The church interrupts the flood of consumer messages with a story, not a sound byte, which proclaims salvation as a person, not a product. Sound bytes may charm or entertain us, but human beings are known through our stories. In a culture that relies on snippets and statistics, chronic alienation among American young people should not surprise us. Without a story to stick to, they have no way of being known, even to themselves. Author Katherine Paterson remembers a therapist who treated troubled teenagers, and who told her he had decided to end his practice. It had been his habit, upon meeting a new patient, to invite the young person to "tell me his or her story," which then gave him clues for how to proceed with treatment. "But that doesn't work anymore," he told her sadly. "I keep meeting with teenagers who look at me perfectly blankly when I ask them about their stories. 'I don't have a story,' they'll say. I'm not sure I know how to work with children who have no stories."44

    Writing in the mid-twentieth century, novelist Flannery O'Connor already noted the devaluation of story in a modern culture increasingly enamored with data and facts: "There is a certain embarrassment about being a storyteller in these times when stories are considered not quite as satisfying as statements and statements not quite as satisfying as statistics," she wrote, adding: "But in the long run, a people is known, not by its statements or its statistics, but by the stories it tells."45 Writer and youth minister Sarah Arthur concurs: "While journalism purports to tell us what happened, story tells us what happens."46 Truth, not historicity, is the aim of story. We may amass data, but we are known by our stories.

    We may amass data, but we are known by our stories.

    From the beginning, the Jesus movement that became the church was known by the stories it told. The early church had so many stories about Jesus that the Bible finally included four different versions of his life, death, and resurrection. Each gospel account—Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John—portrays Jesus in a different light, suggesting that multiple perspectives on Jesus are necessary. No one can tell the whole truth about Jesus that captures all we need to know about him.

    So perhaps it is not surprising that the so-called "modern church" always seemed like something of a forced fit. Postmodernity, on the other hand, requires us to reconsider the modern era's confidence in data and truth claims. The dilemma facing postmodern young people is not the absence of truth claims, but the abundance of them; with so many truths, so many products, so many styles vying for young people's attention ("Choose me! Choose me!"), it is hard to blame youth for their exasperated "Whatevers!"—a sure sign of overload, not ideological tolerance. Overwhelmed, young people retreat inward. Unable to discern truth from Truth, unable to adjudicate between the thousands of messages bombarding them daily, they retreat to the authority of their own subjectivity.47

    The dilemma facing postmodern young people is not the absence of truth claims, but the abundance of them; with so many truths, so many products, so many styles vying for young people's attention, it is hard to blame young people for their exasperated " Whatevers!"—a sure sign of overload, not ideological tolerance.

    Challenges Ahead: Serving Christ in a

    Post-Christendom Church

    A persuasive case can be made that Americans have replaced the church's authority with the authority of personal experience—the "infallible gut," as Mary Belenky and her colleagues call it in their research on feminine epistemology.48 This shift toward the authority of personal experience has been called a "disestablishment" of Christianity, meaning that the church has lost its power, privilege, and authority in the dominant culture. Theologian Douglas John Hall, for example, believes that we have reached the "end of Christendom," or the end of that period in history in which churches were actually supported by culture—if not officially, as in Europe, then unofficially, through customs and practices, as in America.49 Despite the fact that America's founding patriots were mostly deists, many people still assume that America was founded on a hard bed of "Christian values" that led to a de facto "Christian" nation.50 Christianity—and specifically, Protestantism—became "established" in American culture, not by law, but by habit.

    Referring to the emperor who legalized Christian worship in 323 C.E., ethicist Stanley Hauerwas reminds us why Americans still tend to think of the U.S. as a "Christian" nation, despite pluralism and skepticism:

    Constantinianism is a hard habit to break. It is particularly hard when it seems that we do so much good by remaining "in power." It is hard to break because all our categories have been set by the church's establishment as a necessary part of Western civilization.51

    While religious affiliation has significantly declined among most religious groups since 1990 (in 2009, 15 percent of Americans listed their religious affiliation as "none," the largest religious affiliation next to Catholics or Baptists),52 Hauerwas is right that churches—and church people—have difficulty relinquishing cultural power (think buildings, titles, operating budgets). The loss of young people in the pews—and young leaders in the pulpit—has been chronicled, and lamented, for more than half a century, and cries for ecclesial change abound.53 But institutionalized habits die hard.54 Like all social institutions, churches have a strong tendency to repeat themselves, with little alteration, from one generation to the next.

    The most serious challenge facing youth ministry in the twenty-first century church may simply be our uncertainty about how to go about being the church in an era that no longer grants cultural privilege to Christianity.

    At the same time, it is clear that the cultural hegemony of Christianity in North America is fast evaporating. Today, we cannot count on the presence of a "Christian" culture to support the church's ministries—even in congregations. The Christian story is one of many truths available to young people, which is why "post-Christendom" seems daunting to some and defeatist to others (our own editorial team divided over this one). Yet in a post-Christendom context, Christian teachings and ethics stand in opposition to those in the dominant culture—a situation that, in Hall's view, calls for "creative indirectness," enacting God's word as well as telling, befriending as well as proclaiming.55 The church's story is not a modern, objective one; it is an intimate, subjective one— a love story that calls, invites, and involves us. The point is not to know the story; the point is to know Christ, intimately and relationally, through his story, and in so doing come to know ourselves.

    Hall views "disestablishment" as a promising predicament for the postmodern church. It is a contemporary form of what the medieval church called purgation, a way of ridding ourselves of competing allegiances to Christ in order to regain clarity about the business churches are in. Hall calls this "disengaging-in-order to-engage," and thinks young people have a critical role in disentangling the gospel from its cultural captivity.56 Pointing to the church's dire need for catechesis, especially for a generation numb to theological language, Douglas John Hall comments, "There are no shortcuts: We must begin with basics."

    We have two or three generations of people in and around the churches now who are, most of them, not only unfamiliar with the fundamental teachings of the Christian traditions but ignorant even of the Scriptures. . . . Until a far greater number of church-going Americans and Canadians have become more articulate about the faith than they currently are, we cannot expect the churches to stand back from their sociological moorings far enough to detach what Christians profess from the mishmash of modernism, postmodernism, secularism, pietism, and free-enterprise democracy with which Christianity in our context is so fantastically interwoven.57

    Disestablishment requires practices of catechesis to familiarize newcomers with the core stories of Christian identity, and with core practices that enact it like discernment, justice-seeking, and truth-telling, to name a few. By realigning communities of Christians with the gospel, these stories and practices help churches gain clarity about their mission in the world. As Episcopal priest and organizational consultant Loren Mead puts it:

    Congregations must build themselves up as religious communities, as bases from which ministry is done. They need first to get clear that this is their primary business. They are in business to help people find God and be found by God, to build a community in which God's Word is studied and reflected upon, a community in which people are nurtured, healed, and fed.58

    Taken together, Hall, Mead and others suggest a new role for youth ministry in the twenty-first century church: helping Christians reconceive the church for a post-Christendom world. Practices of catechesis and disestablishment are inscribed in youth ministry's DNA. Teaching Christianity's stories of origin and practices of community are part of every youth ministry curriculum, and teenagers are only too glad to point out where Christian communities need to become realigned with the power of Christ instead of the powers-that-be. Hall sees this realignment as requiring people who seek moral authenticity, develop meaningful communities, search out transcendence and mystery and meaning—a description that reads like a profile of adolescence. He advocates a new language for the story of Jesus Christ to be heard in a post-Christendom culture—one that sounds less like speech and more like prayer, less like words and more like dance, less like reason and more like joy59—a language, in other words, that sounds much like the communication of the young.

    Practices of catechesis and disestablishment are inscribed in youth ministry's DNA.

    Learning to Be Church (Again)

    Of course, these daunting challenges to youth ministry are challenges facing the whole church, and not young people alone. Youth ministry tends to function as the church's "research and development" wing, where congregations explore new ways to relate to culture with minimal resistance in the pews.60 Many people enter youth ministry partly because it is one place where ecclesial change seems possible, even as we hand on a sacred story from one generation to the next. Youth ministry offers a theological laboratory for exploring difficult questions like:

  • What happens to the church when the postmodern accent on personal experience trumps communal traditions?
  • What does a church look like that is genuinely inclusive, starting with youth?
  • In sharing faith across the generations, are we conveying cultural messages that unwittingly undermine the church's own story?
  • In what ways might a robust ecclesiology help teenagers (and all people) entertain doubt?
  • What kind of church makes sense to young people (and all people) who never darken the door of a church building, who are just trying to survive?
  • Youth ministry tends to function as the church's "research and development" wing, where congregations explore new ways to relate to culture with minimal resistance in the pews.

    All of this leaves youth ministry in a somewhat unanticipated position—as unlikely leaders in a postmodern, post-Christendom church. Youth ministry offers the wider church tools for making disciples who take a global, participatory culture for granted. Rewind to Thomas, the teenager I mentored through confirmation. We met for dinner at his favorite pizza place to discuss the statement of faith he is required to submit to the church session (the governing body of a local Presbyterian church) to be confirmed. The conventional, programmatic aspect of confirmation bothered Thomas. It seemed domesticated and accommodating. I tried to point out that, in the U.S., where we often don't examine or question Christianity, confessing our faith is easy to take for granted. It's a luxury that believers in many other parts of the world do not have. "If you were being confirmed in a country where Christian faith is a scandal or illegal . . ." I began. Thomas finished my sentence. "Then I'd do it in a minute," he said, "because then it would count for something."

    In the end, Thomas decided not to be confirmed. He continued to attend worship and youth activities, and still participates in the Bible study before school. On Youth Sunday, he composed the following prayer and read it after communion:

    God of Eternal Glory, we have been united with all Christians, living or dead, in your Son. Our stomachs are filled with the bread of life and our thirst for you quenched with the cup of salvation. Help us show in our daily lives the thanks we give for the life of Jesus Christ. Amen.

    It's a remarkable prayer, really. Using simple words, Thomas confirmed that we can still participate in Christ, even when filled with doubts. Steeped in the changes swirling around his development as an adolescent, his cultural context, and the church itself, Thomas' decision to formally "join" the body of Christ of his own accord is a far more complicated decision than it might have been fifty years ago. His journey did not end with confirmation; it isn't clear where it will end. There are no guarantees in youth ministry. Young people ultimately must find a faith that authentically bears witness to Christ in the contexts of their lives. Their ability to do so, we must humbly confess, often has distressingly little to do with us.

    Yet while we must stay alert to issues posed by youth ministry's developmental, cultural, and ecclesial contexts, the gospel transcends these challenges. Some themes in youth ministry have stood the test of time in spite of these changes, and therefore predict promising possibilities for ministry with young people in the future. The next two chapters outline some of those themes, and introduce reasons we have for hope.

    Further Reading on Themes in This Chapter

    Arnett, Jeffrey. Emerging Adulthood: The Winding Road from the Late Teens through the Twenties. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.

    Bass, Dorothy C. Receiving the Day. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2000.

    Borgmann, Albert. Power Failure: Christianity in the Culture of Technology. Grand Rapids: Brazos Press, 2003.

    Cavanaugh, William. Being Consumed: Economics and Christian Desire. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.

    Graham, Philip. The End of Adolescence. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.

    Hall, Douglas John. The End of Christendom and the Future of Christianity. Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 1997. For a condensed version of Hall's argument directed toward youth ministers in particular, see "Where in the World Are We?" and "Finding Our Way into the Future," For Such a Time as This: Princeton Lectures on Youth, Church and Culture (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Theological Seminary, 2006); available online at www.ptsem.edu/iym/index.aspx?id=3904 (accessed April 13, 2009).

    Kett, Joseph. Rites of Passage: Adolescence in America 1790 to Present. New York: Basic Books, 1978.

    Richter, Don. Mission Trips that Matter. Nashville: Upper Room Books, 2008.

    Savage, Sara, et al., Making Sense of Generation Y: The World View of 15-25-Year-Olds. London: Church House Publishing, 2006.

    Smith, Christian and Patricia Snell. Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009.

    White, David. Practicing Discernment with Youth: A Transformative Youth Ministry Approach. Cleveland: Pilgrim Press, 2005.

    Williams, Rowan, Graham Cray, et al., eds. Mission-Shaped Church. London: Church House Publishing, 2004. Available online at www.cofe.anglican.org/info/papers/ mission_shaped_church.pdf.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑