Chapter Three
CHAPTER THREE
ENDURING THEMES
Praise the LORD, all you nations! . . .
For great is [the Lord's] steadfast love toward us,
and the faithfulness of the LORD endures forever.—Psalm 117:1-2
Perhaps we are asking the wrong questions.—The Matrix (1999)
The last time I (Kenda) saw Peter—if you don't count the "save the date" wedding postcard that came this weekend—he was a senior in high school, all red hair and exuberance.1 At the time, Peter was president of the East Ohio Conference Council on Youth Ministry, a United Methodist outfit that was formative in my own life as a teenager, and I was the preacher at annual conference, a regional gathering where Methodist pastors and teenagers were out in force. After worship on Sunday, Peter approached me with a coterie of flip-flop-clad companions. Would I be able to join the youth for Bible study on Tuesday night? Peter thought I might want a couple days' notice.
Of course, this is the kind of invitation youth pastors live for. To be invited by teenagers for a Bible study! I picked a passage, threw some thoughts together, and on Tuesday evening, trudged up the hill to the youth dorm.
That's when I remembered.
When I showed up at the dorm, Peter greeted me, handed me a songsheet, and pointed me to a foyer humming with teenagers. I suddenly realized that I was the most expendable person in the room. Peter had asked me to participate in the Bible study—not to lead it. The youth already had the leadership under control. I was greeted by a perky platoon of welcoming sophomores. An eighth grader prayed. A couple of seniors led the scripture discussion; a few others seemed to be in charge of scouting out reluctant participants and encouraging them to give it a go. A motley assortment of musicians led singing (you could tell who sang in choir); others arranged the room for the Lord's Supper. Adults joined in an easy camaraderie with the young people, stepping in and out of various roles (one played piano with the musicians, a pastor officiated at communion). Adults were clearly valued members of the congregation here, clearly in touch with the youth, but also clearly Not in Charge of the Program.
When I was a high school student twenty-some years earlier, this group had been my spiritual home. When I left Ohio to begin my life as a pastor in Maryland, I thought all youth ministry worked this way. Youth served as primary leaders and peer ministers for congregational and conference events, programs, and mission activities; adults played outfield, offering spiritual guidance, mentoring, organizational help, and occasional last minute assistance. The adult advisors approached youth ministry like driver's ed, riding shotgun while teenagers did the driving. When, as a pastor, I attended my first youth conference in Maryland—an event designed and led by a team of passionate adult volunteers who poured themselves out for the sake of the teenagers who came—it came as a jolt. In Maryland, the adults did ministry for teenagers. Worship, service projects, curriculum, skits, the camp itself were done (very well) by adults doing ministry for teenagers—rather than with them.
The adult advisors approached youth ministry like driver's ed, riding shotgun while teenagers did the driving.
That night in the dorm, I watched Peter and his friends orchestrate a Bible study with the ease that comes from doing something because "this is how it's done." I had forgotten. I began to think of the tracks these practices had laid, in me and in hundreds of teenagers since then, and I marveled at their durability. Little wonder that young people who take part in youth organizations like CCYM—even if they leave their home church or denomination—tend to enter service professions, and professional ministry, in droves. After all, hadn't we grown up doing ministry? Hadn't we been helping lead Christ's church all along? Isn't that what Christians do, guide one another as we row together toward God? Peter is now a youth pastor in Cleveland. No one is surprised.
Some Things Last: Christ's Call to Discipleship
One of the ironies of youth ministry is that God calls us to help young people claim a faith that endures while they are in a stage of life that (optimally) does not. By definition, teenagers are people in transition, "betwixt and between" our increasingly porous understandings of childhood and adulthood. It is not too much to say that the most enduring quality of youth ministry is flux. The pace with which young people change developmentally, socially, and culturally is so swift that it masks our own rapid turnover as leaders. Between the ages of twelve and seventeen, even if family status and geography remain virtually unchanged, teenagers' bodies, emotions, minds, social lives, spiritual sensibilities and, often, physical surroundings undergo a series of revolutions. The conditions that shape young people as seventh graders move so quickly that by senior year they can justly say to us, "Really, you have no idea." They're right, of course; but somehow the church must keep up.
The most enduring quality of youth ministry is flux.
At the same time, some things last. People who stay in youth ministry for decades will tell you that, as adults, "keeping up" with the warp speed of cultural change shaping the lives of contemporary adolescents is a losing battle— and beside the point. Keeping up with the teenager is the point, staying the course with young people throughout life's dips and peaks, suffering with them, enduring the death of half-formed identities that can no longer hold all that they are becoming. Despite the changes inherent in adolescence and the evershifting sands of cultural context, some aspects of youth ministry are constants. While Christ binds himself to particular expressions of "church" in specific moments in time, the Holy Spirit also invites us into a story of redemption that is relevant in every place, and in every moment in time.
Some themes are on the pastoral "to do" list of every Christian community, especially where young people are concerned. It's an uncomplicated list. Include them. Accompany them. Point them toward God's grace in the world.
Some themes are on the pastoral "to do" list of every Christian community, especially where young people are concerned. It's an uncomplicated list. Include them. Accompany them. Point them toward God's grace in the world. The list endures because it emanates from the earliest descriptions of Christian discipleship that we have. The word "disciple" in the New Testament suggests being both a learner and a follower. A disciple is much like an apprentice. Every disciple has a master, every master hands on a tradition to a disciple.2 Rabbinical students in Jesus' day were disciples; they learned the rabbi's way of thinking and way of living by following him around for an extended period of time.
Following Jesus earns no stature—and what's more, Christian apprenticeship has no term limits. Jesus' disciples follow him all the way to the cross.
Jesus called people to follow him too, but he turned the practice of rabbinical discipleship inside out. Most followers choose their master; Jesus chose us. Traditionally, the disciple-master relationship centers on teaching; but Jesus' relationship with his disciples was more personal than pedagogical; he shared his life as well as his teachings. The Pharisees bragged about the burden of discipleship, but Jesus viewed discipleship as a blessing and urged his followers to cast their cares upon him, for his "burden is light" (Matthew 11:30). Traditionally, the objective of discipleship was for the follower to achieve the status of his or her master once the apprenticeship ended. But following Jesus earns no stature—and what's more, Christian apprenticeship has no term limits. Jesus' disciples follow him all the way to the cross.
Thumb-lines in Youth Ministry
Belonging: Including Young People in the Community of Faith
Accompaniment: Joining Young People on the Journey of Faith
Grace: Strengthening Young People for the Life of Faith
The Sign Potential of Community
The Sign Potential of Imagination
The Sign Potential of Adolescence
"Being in Time"
Thumb-lines in Youth Ministry
In jazz, the thumb-line is the underlying, recurring phrase played on the piano by the thumb of the left hand. We don't usually notice the thumb-line right away, but it persists. It is a theme that holds a song (and often multiple instruments) together, freeing the right hand to improvise and respond to other instruments without compromising the song's structure or integrity. It acts as a song's rudder, steadying and steering it while the surface melody responds to the other instruments in the room.
Theological thumb-lines do the same thing for youth ministry. They allow for faithful improvisation while tethering us to a guiding story of faith. These thumb-lines in youth ministry free us to invest more of our energy in creative responses to the situation at hand. The three thumb-lines described in this chapter—inclusion, belonging, and participating in means of grace—have undergirded discipleship formation from the New Testament church forward. Their durability proves their value. It is impossible to faithfully innovate in youth ministry, on the one hand, without maintaining one's allegiance to these broad gospel themes, on the other.
Belonging: Including Young People in the Community of Faith
On the first day of the week, when we met to break bread, Paul was holding a discussion with them; since he intended to leave the next day, he continued speaking until midnight. There were many lamps in the room upstairs where we were meeting. A young man named Eutychus, who was sitting in the window, began to sink off into a deep sleep while Paul talked still longer. Overcome by sleep, he fell to the ground three floors below and was picked up dead. But Paul went down, and bending over him took him in his arms, and said, "Do not be alarmed, for his life is in him." Then Paul went upstairs, and after he had broken bread and eaten, he continued to converse with them until dawn; then he left. Meanwhile they had taken the boy away alive and were not a little comforted. (Acts 20:7-12)
Homiletician Anna Carter Florence maintains that the story of Paul and Eutychus is a play "that gets produced in more local congregations than any of us would like to think."3 This is not a compliment. What she means is that churches risk young people's very lives when we marginalize and anesthesize them, instead of embracing them in the name of Jesus Christ. In the Acts passage, Paul overcomes the dire consequences of boring preaching by giving Eutychus a life-giving, Spirit-inspired hug. The thumb-line of belonging grows out of the conviction that Christ calls the church to include young people as primary (not peripheral) participants—which means, of course, that we must invite them into the middle of our life together, even if they don't come to church.
Christ calls the church to include young people as primary (not peripheral) participants.
The scene in Acts 20 sounds eerily familiar: a preacher drones on and on while young people zone out at the margins, until they finally fall out of church altogether. Eutychus tumbles out the window to the ground three stories below, where he is "picked up dead"; our young people slip out the back door of the church, never to be seen again. Florence refuses to let the passage serve as a smug commentary on long-winded preaching. She sees it as a "text of terror" because it is the church that places Eutychus at risk. The church must take responsibility for Eutychus' fall, and for the falls of other youth on the margins of worship. We are the ones who have allowed them to stay on the periphery when in fact "their safety and well-being—indeed, their very lives—depend on their alert participation in the community's proclamation."4
The tragedy, of course, is that many congregations fail to pay attention to young people until they aren't there. Nobody noticed Eutychus or the danger he was in until he fell out the window and died. Teenagers naturally assume that the church's story is not for them; if they do not know the church's story, and do not speak the church's language—and if nobody bothers to teach it to them so they can participate in a gospel conversation—they understandably conclude: "I am not part of this." As Florence points out, unless we share the language of the church with young people (and fast), "the only way off this windowsill [for young people] is to quit coming to church."5
The tragedy, of course, is that many congregations fail to pay attention to young people until they aren't there. Nobody noticed Eutychus or the danger he was in until he fell out the window and died.
Discipleship formation begins with the invitation to belong. The Acts passage opens by illustrating a persistent misunderstanding in youth ministry— the separation of young people from the church as a whole, what has been dubbed the "one-eared Mickey Mouse model of youth ministry" (see Figure 3.1).6 The congregation meets in the sanctuary, the youth meet in the youth room; the congregation worships, the youth group does devotions; the congregation has a budget, the youth group has a bake sale. Come graduation, young people who may have been active in youth ministry find nothing in the "adult" church that looks remotely like the Christian community they experienced in youth ministry. Florence illustrates the point with preaching: "We have separated preaching and youth, both literally and figuratively, in the church and in the academy. We have separated them into distinct ministries, and then we have not talked about it, so that our silence perpetuates the problem and maintains a mute, marginal caste of Christians in our own churches." Paul's sermon may have seemed enthralling to the adults in the front row, but it is well past midnight and, over by the window, a sleepy teenager perched on an open ledge is an accident waiting to happen. "Why does no one notice?" Florence demands. Why don't we interrupt the sermon or pull Eutychus into the center of the room? What will Paul say (what would we say?) to the boy's parents after he falls off the grid—parents "who thought that because their son was at church he was safe?"7
Figure 3.1
The One-Eared Mickey Mouse Model of Ministry
Youth ministry insists that the church counter the separation of young people from the congregation as a whole by heeding God's call to include young people as participants in the faith community, not in the church basement or on a third-floor classroom windowsill, but at the very heart of the Christian community. Throughout the Bible, God seems to exercise a "preferential option for the young," calling unlikely youth—David, Jeremiah, Mary, Timothy, unnamed slave girls and unprepossessing young men asleep at the switch—to proclaim God's salvation.8 As young people take part in proclaiming the good news of Christ's salvation, rather than watch from a remote corner in the back of the room as others proclaim it, they become God's witnesses—participants, not onlookers, in God's story.
If Paul indirectly contributed to Eutychus' unfortunate fall, Paul also illustrates a constructive way forward for churches that fail to notice young people until too late. First, Paul stops preaching at them. When we realize young people are dying in our midst, "everything has to stop," insists Florence. "We must take a good, hard look at what's going on"—and why—before the church can even think about resuming business as usual.9 To Paul's credit, once he realizes the problem, he takes immediate, decisive, extravagant action on Eutychus' behalf. He does not tiptoe around the issue, or address it in increments ("Let's look into this, and appoint a committee") or waste time rationalizing ("I shouldn't have preached so long") or blaming ("The kid was an idiot, sitting in an open third floor window!").
Instead, Paul acknowledges the crisis, and holds nothing back—nothing—in restoring Eutychus to the community. Paul goes outside the church, looking for the boy, pursuing him. When he finds Eutychus sprawled on the pavement, he falls upon him, embraces him, wakes him up, does whatever it takes to bring Eutychus back. The text tells us that Paul hurled himself onto the young man in an undignified manner, the way the prodigal father flung himself at his wayward son who returned home.10 "Paul understands that it is more important to find life than to find fault in the youth," Florence observes. Though Eutychus fell to his death, Paul proclaims that "his life is in him."11 The moral of the story for Florence is that the church must urgently pursue the young people we lose, embrace them, and celebrate whatever speck of God-given life is in them—and then restore them to the community's shared life of faith, giving them seats in the center of the room.
The church is called to urgently pursue the young people we lose, embrace them, and celebrate whatever speck of God-given life is in them—and then restore them to the community's shared life of faith, giving them seats in the center of the room.
Eutychus illustrates adolescents' vocation as bellwethers for the church's overall spiritual health. For decades researchers have recognized that adolescents' well-being is a benchmark for the health of an entire community; likewise, the spiritual vitality of young people in a faith community serves as a sign of overall congregational vitality.12 The story of Eutychus reminds us that bringing young people to life in congregations has the effect of bringing the church to life as well. But to do this requires our undignified embrace of young people at the margins, whose inclusion emboldens us with the unabashed, unfiltered witness of adolescents themselves.
Accompaniment: Joining Young People on the Journey of Faith
As they came near the village to which they were going, [Jesus] walked ahead as if he were going on. But they urged him strongly, saying, "Stay with us, because it is almost evening and the day is now nearly over." So he went in to stay with them. When he was at the table with them, he took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to them. Then their eyes were opened, and they recognized him; and he vanished from their sight. (Luke 24:28-31)
Solvitur ambulando, roughly translated, means "it is solved by walking"— or, as we might say today, "We will find the answers as we go."13 Emmaus was a three-hour trip in sandals, but the events of the week had been so staggering, and the day itself had been so utterly bewildering, that Cleopas and his companion needed to walk it out. We can imagine them saying to one another, "Maybe a walk will clear our heads." Maybe the mystery of recent events will be "solved by walking." "We had hoped that he was the one to redeem Israel," Cleopas and his friend lament to the stranger who joins them on the road (Luke 24:21). And then they told him about the women, talking of resurrection. What were they to make of these events? Surely a walk would help.
Talking only gets us so far in the life of discipleship. Eventually, notes practical theologian Shauna Hannan, we must walk—we must get up and do the things Jesus did, whether we fully appreciate them or not. That is when the church starts to take shape.14 It was not until Cleopas and his companion did what Jesus did—they invited a stranger home for dinner, and shared bread and table with him—that they recognized that Christ had been with them: "Their eyes were opened, and they recognized him; and he vanished from their sight" (Luke 24:31). In what almost passes as a Homer Simpson moment, Cleopas and his companion lock eyes across the table (Doh!): "Were not our hearts burning within us while he was talking to us on the road, while he was opening the scriptures to us?" (24:32). And straight back to Jerusalem they went, three more hours of walking, to tell the others.
Talking only gets us so far in the life of discipleship. Eventually, we must walk—we must get up and do the things Jesus did. That is when the church starts to take shape.
It is no coincidence that Cleopas undertook this walk of faith with a companion, or that Jesus met them on the road, on the way to discovering that Jesus, in fact, is the salvation God promised. Instead of encountering Cleopas and his companion as the Cosmic Answer, Jesus accompanied them as a fellow traveler, journeying with them, sharing their conversation along the way. If a red thread can be found in Christian discipleship from the early church until now, it is the thread of spiritual accompaniment, the grace-conducting presence of those who walk beside us as we try to decode the divine in the events of our lives. The spiritual accompanist is a millennial version of the ancient spiritual guide. We walk alongside young people, in formal and informal settings, artfully prodding them to reframe the events of their lives in light of God's promise of resurrection and return. Spiritual direction offers a formal version of this role—but youth ministers are far more apt to be spiritual accompanists, cojourneyers who remind young people of God's promises as we walk. Spiritual accompaniment requires intentionality, discipline, humility, sensitivity, prayer, and discernment: pointing out divine fingerprints here, surfacing a spiritual tussle there. At its best, youth ministry surrounds young people with spiritual friends from multiple arenas (coaches, grandparents, stepparents, probation officers, teachers, youth ministry volunteers, confirmation sponsors, and so forth). Youth ministry consultant Mark DeVries advocates a ratio of one youth ministry volunteer for every five youth. But that's not all: he also recommends identifying five adults in the congregation for every teenager in order to immerse them in a community of spiritual companions who offer prayers, care, and a gentle ministry of noticing in and beyond the life of the congregation.15
The art of accompaniment is a thumb-line for youth ministry. The assumption that communicating Christ requires us to employ his methods—in other words, to operate "incarnationally" in deference to God's preference for entering the world through human beings—comes close to functioning as dogma in the practice of youth ministry. As our lives and our hearts become more closely aligned to Christ's, young people experience Christ's suffering love for them through us. Youth ministry literature is close to univocal on this position. The Incarnation has received more attention in youth ministry education than any other theological theme. Just as God came to us in human form, the church is called to "imitate Christ" by translating God's good news into human forms as well. The goal of "incarnational" or "relational" ministry is not to be the savior for young people, but to be transparent to the real Savior whose love shines within us, and is enacted through us. It is a fallible plan, to be sure; God has more confidence in it than we do. Most of our "crash and burn" stories as youth leaders can be traced to our failure to point young people beyond ourselves to Jesus, or our failure to recognize how filthy our theological windshields have become, as our best efforts to be transparent to Christ run afoul. Unsure how to ground relational ministry theologically, we often revert to developmental theory as a default position, justifying our reliance on "relational ministry" as a strategy that addresses young people's developmental need for relationships, capitalizing on these relationships to convince youth of Jesus' importance.
The goal of "incarnational" or "relational" ministry is not to bethe savior for young people, but to be transparent to the real Savior whose love shines within us, and is enacted through us. It is a fallible plan, to be sure; God has more confidence in it than we do.
Spiritual accompaniment, of course, is more than this. Most of us are better acquainted with incarnational strategies than incarnational theologies, but infact these strategies are only possible when they flow from Christ's own selfemptying presence. Christ calls us to view teenagers as fellow travelers toward God rather than as potential ideological converts. "Ministry. . . is not about 'using' relationships to get individuals to accept a 'third thing,' " practical theologian Andrew Root reminds us. "Rather, ministry is about connection, one to another, about sharing in suffering and joy, about persons meeting persons with no pretense or secret motives. It is about shared life, confessing Christ not outside the relationship but within it."16 As chapter 6 points out, Root is one of many young scholars locating youth ministry in the discipline of practical theology, an approach that releases young people from being objects of well-meaning but unexamined pastoral strategies. The journey of faith is one we can share but never orchestrate. We are called to travel alongside young people, and "find the answers as we go."
Participating in Means of Grace: Strengthening Young People for the Life of Faith
Then an angel of the Lord said to Philip, "Get up and go toward the south to the road that goes down from Jerusalem to Gaza." (This is a wilderness road.) . . . Now there was an Ethiopian eunuch, a court official of the Candace, queen of the Ethiopians, in charge of her entire treasury. He had come to Jerusalem to worship and was returning home; seated in his chariot, he was reading the prophet Isaiah. Then the Spirit said to Philip, "Go over to this chariot and join it." So Philip ran up to it and heard him reading the prophet Isaiah. He asked, "Do you understand what you are reading?" [The eunuch] replied, "How can I, unless someone guides me?" And he invited Philip to get in and sit beside him. (Acts 8:26-31)
Grace is the oxygen of ministry. In his theological dictionary Crazy Talk, theologian Rolf Jacobson describes means of grace as "the simplest stuff of every day through which the most profound event of eternity happens to you."17 In other words, Christ enters our world and our bloodstreams through the "stuff" of our lives, bread and water and wine and Scripture and giving alms—and as we receive these blessings, Christ uses them to transform us into means of grace as well. This thumb-line of youth ministry assumes that young people are strengthened for the life of faith through means of grace, actions God uses to pour divine grace into the world. Means of grace are "living signs" that God is with us, strengthening our faith, empowering our hope, transforming us into the witnesses God has called us to be.
Grace is the oxygen of ministry.
Christians view means of grace as signs of God's presence and promise, outward expressions of the grace God has given us within to sustain and encourage our faith. God is fully present in these signs, but cannot be contained by them. Signs have a surplus of meaning; they both reveal and hide God's presence with us, which means that we are usually knee-deep in divine grace before we know it. Means of grace function as holy portals, doorways through which Christ enters human experience, thresholds on which we recognize God personally whether God meets us in church or in traffic.
Philip's encounter with the eunuch is awash in such means of grace. The story culminates with the eunuch's baptism, but other signs of God's grace pave the way for this moment: the divine messenger, the reading of Scripture, the holy conversation itself. Philip's day job was distributing food to the poor as a deacon in the church of Jerusalem. But after hours, Philip was moonlighting as an evangelist, and a good one; when the angel shows up, Philip is in the middle of preaching an all-out revival in Samaria. Yet God has a new plan for Philip. In a move worthy of a Methodist bishop, the angel gives him different instructions and sends him to a new ministry in the middle of nowhere: "Get up and go to the road that goes down from Jerusalem to Gaza—not the interstate, the desert road." The road less traveled. Not exactly a place Philip can hone his preaching skills.
Enter the Ethiopian eunuch, a man whose skin tone, dress, and out-of-state plates clearly mark him as an African royal official. He was traveling this same desert road by carriage, trying to decode Scripture alone. He had traveled more than a thousand miles (six weeks by carriage) to pray in Jerusalem—but Jewish law prohibited eunuchs from worshiping in the Temple (Deuteronomy 23:1). Eunuchs could be "gate proselytes" (uncircumcised Jewish sympathizers who feared God) but they could not be fully Jewish. So the eunuch had received no help from the assembly in understanding God's promise. Now, heading home, he is left to figure out God's word on his own. But the story makes no sense. "Who is it about?" he asks Philip. The eunuch doesn't realize that God's promise is practically standing in front of him in the Isaiah text. He doesn't know that in three short chapters Isaiah will proclaim God's embrace of eunuchs in particular. Without someone to guide him, he doesn't know who the passage is about, or that God's grace includes him.
With no one to guide them other than media and marketers, young people don't know that God's grace includes them, either. They don't know who the prophets foretold or that the gospel shows God's special concern for the young. Fortunately, the Holy Spirit does not wait for us to help them ask for grace. The Holy Spirit creeps into the cracks of young people's lives unbidden, shoving grace under the door, entering the world through means of grace like water and bread, meeting adolescents "on the road." Meanwhile, God taps us as interpreters, often when we're in the middle of doing something else we thought was important.18
Christ encounters human beings through material signs and repeatable actions of the community of faith. These means of grace are "sacramental" but they are not necessarily sacraments.19 Even youth ministers from nonsacramental backgrounds frequently employ sacramental imagery to describe God's action with young people. The word "sacrament" comes from a Latin translation of the Greek word for "mystery" (Eastern Christians still call sacraments the "Holy Mysteries").20 While churches understand sacraments differently, what catches young people's attention is the mystery of it all—God's willingness to "happen to us" through the earthy materials of human life, while remaining mysteriously and eternally beyond us. Such signs let us participate, mysteriously and concretely, in the dying-and-rising life of God, making God's grace-giving action visible. "Look, here is water!" crows the eunuch as he grasps the good news of Jesus Christ. "What is to prevent me from being baptized?" The eunuch may not have found salvation in Jerusalem—but here, on a desert road at high noon in the middle of nowhere, with Philip pointing to God's promise in Scripture, Jesus "happened" to him.
Youth ministry strengthens young people for the life of faith by immersing them in means of grace, actions God uses to pour divine grace into human communities.
Means of grace rest on the assumption that God does things, and that God does things through us. Means of grace strengthen us for the life of faith; in them, Christ "happens" to us personally. Chapter 4 explores the importance of Catholic "sacramentals" and Protestants' faith "practices" (which include but are not limited to sacraments "proper") for ministry with young people. What matters is not the form these grace-bearing actions take but their ability to shape our identity as Christians, empower us for witness, and point to a way of life in which God continues to "happen." Youth ministry (and Christian life generally) is made possible by God's gift of sanctifying grace that God makes present in these human but holy actions. Some aspects of youth ministry serve as particularly potent signs of God's presence with us, and offer vehicles through which Christ strengthens young people's faith in particularly visible ways. Here we will mention three that are closely tied to the experience of adolescence— and that are especially likely to be overlooked for their sign potential.
The Sign Potential of Community
For Christians, community enacts communion—being "one with" Christ and one another. Apart from the presence of God's sanctifying grace, of course, such oneness is not possible. Communion with God means more than sharing bread and wine together; it implies a willingness to lay down our lives for one another, as Christ laid down his life for us. "Community" is a youth ministry imperative, and when young people encounter its Christian form, they experience love willing to share one another's burdens, love willing to suffer on their behalf. Without such communion, countless young people would be stuck in the back of a carriage trying to figure out God's word on their own—never knowing that Christ is right in front of them, unaware that God's grace includes them.
Youth ministers view "community" as one of a very few nonnegotiables in the church's ministry with young people. As we have noted, it is in the experience of community that we learn to recognize the incarnational, transfigurative, and crucified nature of divine grace. "In communities of faith," wrote Luther, "each of us should become a Christ to the other. And as we are christs to one another, the result is that Christ fills us all and we become a truly Christian community."21 In the intense relational webs of Christian community, the gospel is re-told in embodied form. Nate, a youth pastor I know, told me how his mentor Merv—also a youth pastor, twenty years his senior and technically his superior—became a means of God's grace for him, and how this grace transformed their relationship.
We had breakfast together once a month or so, and it could last five hours. There was no agenda, just a sense that he was further down the road than me, and that he was okay that I wasn't very far down this road at all. It was absolutely not an answer-driven relationship; Merv had no answers for me. If he had a story that connected to mine, he would tell it; if he had advice to share, he would give it. But mostly, we just shared life. I drove away from those meetings questioning what we did there. Was there some specific point when he was no longer my conference youth pastor, but a colleague? Was he just there because he was paid to be there? Merv choked up the last time we were at a youth service together; he said: "And so, we've become good friends."
Pausing for a moment, Nate spoke for countless youth ministers by saying: "That's why I do this. I want to give others that same life, that same presence."
The evidence that a community is a means of grace is participants' willingness to "suffer love" for one another. The emphasis here is on love, not suffering—but as any teenager will tell you, true love is worthy of sacrifice. True love is worth dying for. Through acts of suffering love, we become "little incarnations" of God's self-giving love in Jesus Christ. Unexpectedly, as we follow Christ together, we find ourselves reflecting God's glory in "little transfigurations." When others risk themselves for our sake, we experience "little crucifixions" on our behalf. As a community, we re-constitute the body of Christ in actions that re-member (anamnesis, or put back together) Jesus' life, death, and resurrection.
"In communities of faith each of us should become a Christ to the other. And as we are christs to one another, the result is that Christ fills us all and we become a truly Christian community."—Martin Luther
The Sign Potential of Imagination
An equally potent mediator of divine grace—especially in a culture increasingly marked by creativity and collaboration—is a holy imagination. One of the most disturbing conversations I ever had was with Cuyler Black, youth pastor-by-day and cartoonist-by-night. At the time, Cuyler was toying with the idea of applying to seminary to pursue ordained ministry. (Okay, I was recruiting him.) Meanwhile, his career as a Christian cartoonist was taking off. We had both been to a seminar on cultivating our callings, and Cuyler confessed his divided heart: God had gifted him for more than one kind of ministry. His gifts for ordained ministry seemed indisputable to me; theologically passionate, smart, bold, creative, gentle. He seemed to exude qualities of leadership that postmodern churches are crying for. But it was equally clear that God had given Cuyler a snappy sense of humor and profound artistic talent as well. Why not use that talent as a member of the clergy? I asked him, thinking what a breath of fresh air his ministry would be. "Because," he said, with sad eyes I will never forget, "I'm afraid that if I go into ordained ministry, I'd have to surrender much of my creativity."
He said, with sad eyes I will never forget, "I'm afraid that if I go into ordained ministry, I'd have to surrender much of my creativity."
Cuyler is still a lay youth pastor in Connecticut and the artist behind a successful (and funny) cartoon series (check out www.inheritthemirth.com). I understand why he stayed in youth ministry; it is one of the church's best opportunities for helping young people develop what practical theologian Fred Edie calls "artistic knowing."22 God's overwhelming, self-giving love defies human logic. It can only be approximated by stories and symbols, metaphors and imagery—human containers for truths too large to tell in full. The surplus meaning of these symbols and metaphors nourishes the kind of imagination that is capable of perceiving the divine grace they convey.23 A holy imagination makes mysticism, the "raw material of all religion," possible.24 When we stoke young people's imaginations with the stories, symbols, and images of Christian tradition, we equip them for the kind of artistic knowing that helps them, like the Ethiopian, "know what they are reading."
Edie believes that artistic knowing is essential to Christian faith—as essential as cognitive and social knowing—because God uses human imaginations to be recognized.25 The issue is with the antennae, not the broadcast; God does not need art to communicate divine mystery and grace, but we need art to recognize and appreciate them. Nowhere is this artistic knowing more necessary than in the interpretation of scripture. Theologian Garrett Green points out: "To call the Bible scripture is to claim that it enables its users rightly to imagine God and the world."26 Yet our chances of "rightly imagining" God and the world are becoming slimmer; American churches face "astounding illiteracy and inarticulacy of the mainstream populace regarding theological and biblical concepts," and research describes teenagers themselves as "incredibly inarticulate" about Christian faith.27 Without artistic knowing, young people lack the tools to recognize themselves in the Christian story, or to perceive Christ's mysterious, pulsing presence through it.
Artistic knowing is essential to Christian faith—as essential as cognitive and social knowing.
Youth ministry's reliance on symbol, metaphor, story, and art helps young people hone sacred intuition, the kind of imagining that recognizes God from behind, through indirect means that acknowledge a sacred role for bodily knowing and participatory engagement, and that pursues creativity as a playful form of divine discovery. Young people's desire for primary—and primal— experience makes them voracious participants in the arts. They disproportionately comprise what has been called society's "creative class," a tendency accentuated by today's participatory culture, as young people self-consciously produce global cultural content.28 Nearly all research on assets for youth development identifies an important role for the arts. Art prompts visceral responses, "sighs too deep for words" (Romans 8:26), prayers that both utilize and transcend human modes of communication. God is profoundly present in the elements of daily life, but God is also decidedly and mysteriously free from them. God comes to us in ways that are both kataphatic and apophatic—in ways that can be perceived through the senses, and in ways that defy explanation, that exceed our imaginations.
So artistic knowing, which is necessary to perceiving God's revelation, is at once necessary, ambiguous, and generative. The ineffable nature of faith (i.e., it can't be described in words) requires an embodied telling. We need mystics and artists—"the saints and the poets," as playwright Thornton Wilder put it—to serve as intermediaries and interpreters, translators and storytellers, priests and youth ministers who have been to the mountaintop and can testify to God's glory in imaginative, nondiscursive ways.
To reclaim the imagination's vital role in spiritual formation, youth ministers must "become bards: poets charged with the tasks of imparting the stories, language, and beliefs of a culture."—Sarah Arthur
Sarah Arthur blames young people's inability to experience Scripture as a divine encounter on the church's "colossal failure of the imagination regarding both the claims and the demands of the gospel." 29 To reclaim the imagination's vital role in spiritual formation, Arthur calls youth ministers to "become bards: poets charged with the tasks of imparting the stories, language, and beliefs of a culture."
We are wordsmiths, as the ancient meaning of the poet implies: "speech-weavers" who take the many texts of our hearers' lives and thread them through the warp and weft of the Christian narrative until patterned meaning emerges.30
Ultimately, the church is a troubadour of hope, and the Bible is the loom that weaves young people's lives into a pattern that has purpose and meaning. Arthur turns to author Madeleine L'Engle, who asks, "Why does anyone tell a story? It does indeed have something to do with faith, faith that the universe has meaning, that our little human lives are not irrelevant, that what we choose or say or do matters, matters cosmically."31 Adolescents are story people, entrusting us with their stories of faith and unfaith, tacking back and forth between the Church's story and their stories, cobbling together hope that there is meaning in the world after all, and purpose, and significance.
The Sign Potential of Adolescence
This last means of grace in youth ministry is, perhaps, too obvious to mention; then again, it may be the sign that churches most frequently overlook. God employs young people themselves as signs of God's grace in the faith community, and in the world they inhabit. Much has been made of adolescents' unique vulnerability to culture, and to teenagers' receptiveness to the spirit of their age. Adolescence has been called "the human condition on steroids:"32
Young people have always served as barometers of the human condition, indicators of rising and falling pressures on the human psyche. . . . Because adolescence itself is a modern invention that weds social location with psychological development, young people inevitably "act out"—acutely—what is required for being human in their particular moment in history.33
At the same time, young people seem to embody Irenaeus' conviction, "The glory of God is a human being fully alive."34 Because adolescents are human beings in "acute" form, they point to the glory of God in their unswerving commitment to feel life deeply and experience life fully, even when that means experiencing—with unfiltered intensity—suffering as well as joy.
Young people seem to embody Irenaeus' conviction, "The glory of God is a human being fully alive."
Pastoral theologian Roland Martinson hypothesizes that the first third of life is "paradigmatic" for God's plan for us to be fully human. Jesus suggested as much:
People were bringing even infants to [Jesus] that he might touch them; and when the disciples saw it, they sternly ordered them not to do it. But Jesus called for them and said, "Let the little children come to me, and do not stop them; for it is to such as these that the kingdom of God belongs. Truly I tell you, whoever does not receive the kingdom of God as a little child will never enter it" (Luke 18:15-17).
We tend to trot out this text for Christian Education Sundays in order to demonstrate that churches like children ("Jesus wanted children to come to him, and we do too"). But none of the synoptic accounts of this moment are value statements about children; they are value statements about adults. The paradigmatic human beings in God's kingdom, the ones adults are meant to emulate, are not wise or even self-consciously faithful; they are young. Little wonder that one measure of church vitality is the presence of young people in the pews. The church is more fully alive through them.
"Being in Time"
These thumb-lines of youth ministry tether us to a tradition so that we can freely improvise ministry with young people while maintaining the basic shape of discipleship with the other. In this way, youth ministry is like jazz itself, which trumpeter Wynton Marsalis calls "the art of negotiating change with style."35 The description could just as easily describe the church's ministry with young people. Marsalis grew up around the "jazzmen" of New Orleans, and admired Coltrane, Davis, Monk, and Armstrong as a young musician. But he saves his loudest praise for the shop musicians of New Orleans who could take a thumb-line and improvise. For Marsalis, improvisation requires three skills: (1) being able to honestly express your feelings; (2) being able to genuinely listen as other people express theirs; and (3) being committed to "working it out" together. Unlike some forms of music that require a common level proficiency for musicians to play together, jazz bands would stand a ten-year-old boy beside a sixty-year-old man, as their instruments "learned" to talk to each other. Marsalis remembers: "To be heard demanded that we . . . listen to one another. Closely. And to sound good we had to trust one another."36
Youth ministry is like jazz, which trumpeter Wynton Marsalis calls "the art of negotiating change with style."37 The description could just as easily describe the church's ministry with young people.
As a result, Marsalis recalls, jazz players were people who could help you out in a tight spot: they could come up with the right words at the right time and the right notes at the right time. They could talk and they could listen. This ability to listen to the underlying theme of a song and respond is what Marsalis calls "being in time."
Swing is a matter of manners. When you are in time you know when to be quiet, when to assert yourself, and how to master the moment with an appropriate or unusually inventive response. . . . To be in time requires you to make the subtlest kinds of adjustments and concessions to keep everyone in a groove. And your colleagues have to be willing to do the same for you. . . . Being in time . . . gives you the confidence to take chances.38
But Marsalis noticed something else too. The most meaningful phrases in jazz were not the most difficult ones. They were almost never technically challenging.Anyone could play them. They anchored a song because they "were succinct phrases that would run right through you, the way profound nuggets from Shakespeare's plays can both cut through you and linger; all those words in Hamlet, but you remember 'To be or not to be' or 'to sleep perchance to dream.' Something in those types of phrases reveals universal truth."39 As in jazz, the thumb-line of our work with young people, the notes that tether youth to Jesus' call to make disciples, are as straightforward as they are enduring: help young people belong in a community of faith, accompany them on the journey of faith, immerse them in means of grace that strengthen them for faith. Anchored by these thumb-lines of discipleship formation, the promising possibilities of youth ministry can begin to take flight.
Further Reading on Themes in This Chapter
Arthur, Sarah. The God-Hungry Imagination. Nashville: Upper Room, 2007.
Bass, Dorothy and Craig Dykstra. Practicing Our Faith. San Francisco: Jossey Bass, 1998.
Beaudoin, Tom. Virtual Faith: The Irreverent Spiritual Quest of Generation X. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2000.
Carotta, Michael. Sometimes We Dance, Sometimes We Wrestle: Embracing the Spiritual Growth of Adolescents. Orlando, FL: Harcourt Religion Publishers, 2000.
Cummings-Bond, Stuart. "The One-Eared Mickey Mouse," Youthworker 6 (Fall 1989), 76.
Dean, Kenda Creasy. Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004.
Edie, Fred. Book, Bath, Table and Time: Christian Worship as Source and Resource for Youth Ministry. Cleveland: Pilgrim Press, 2007.
Florence, Anna Carter. "A Prodigal Preaching Story and Bored-to-Death Youth," Theology Today 64 (July 2007), 233-43.
Green, Garrett. Imagining God: Theology and the Religious Imagination. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998.
Jacobson, Rolf. Crazy Talk: A Not-So-Stuffy Dictionary of Theological Terms. Minneapolis: Augsburg, 2008.
Mercandante, Frank. Growing Teen Disciples: Strategies for Really Effective Youth Ministry. Winona, MN: St. Mary's Press, 2002.
