Chapter 7 of 14

Chapter Four

Chapter Four

CHAPTER FOUR

PROMISING POSSIBILITIES

Forget the former things; / do not dwell on the past. / See, I am doing a new thing! / Now it springs up; do you not perceive it? / I am making a way in the desert / and streams in the wasteland.—Isaiah 43:18-19, NIV

You're only given a little spark of madness. You mustn't lose it.—Robin Williams

Bruce Main, executive director of UrbanPromise, in Camden, New Jersey, remembers Albert as a neighborhood kid who practically grew up in the ministry. After-school programs led to summer camps, which led to employment as a "street leader" (a teen leadership program), which led to a scholarship to Eastern University. After graduation Albert wanted to give back to his old neighborhood. He moved back as the director of the North Camden After School Program, one of UrbanPromise's many youth ministries in the "murder capital" of America. "People came from all over the world as volunteers to help me," Albert liked to say. "I made it; now [these kids] can see how they can make it too."

But now, a new drug operation had moved outside the church that hosted the after-school program, and Albert was worried. Junkies were "shooting up just where kids could see what was going down," he recalled. He asked Bruce to help him figure out what to do. They debated about confronting the drug dealer. Calling the police would only bring retribution, but doing nothing would be detrimental to the kids. Finally Albert decided: "I'm going to have a talk with that guy who runs that operation." Bruce tells the rest of the story:

Later that week Albert burst into my office. "Bruce, Bruce, I talked to the guy who runs the corner. . . . I asked him if he could move his operation somewhere else. I told him how I was trying to set an example for the little kids in the community." Albert paused. "Right away the guy started to yell at his crew to clear the corner. Apologetically he told me that he would have them out of there by two o'clock." Albert then looked at me and asked curiously, "Bruce, did we ever have a guy named Jeff work here—about 15 years ago?"

Bruce dug back into his memory. Yes, Jeff had been an intern from Southern California. He had spent a number of years with UrbanPromise before going into teaching. Everybody liked him. "Why do you ask?" Bruce wondered.

Albert paused. "That dealer asked me if a guy named Jeff still worked at UrbanPromise. . . . The dealer [said] he had been part of UrbanPromise when he was in fifth grade, and Jeff was his favorite counselor."

As Bruce reflected on this strange coincidence, he wondered how two boys in the same ministry could turn out so differently. Albert graduated from college and came back to serve his community. Why didn't the other boy have a story like Albert's? "Instead," Bruce mused sadly, "this nameless twentyseven-year-old had slipped through the cracks and ended up a drug dealer— yet a dealer who chose to apologetically shut down his operations so that young kids could safely enter our After School Center." Bruce ends the story with quiet determination, a kind of fire that explains how a skinny white guy from Vancouver came to be trusted—even revered—in the toughest neighborhoods in Camden:

I don't yet know that drug dealer's name. But I will find out. Then, hopefully, and by God's grace, I will have a chance to bring him up to date on the good things happening in Jeff's life, and how those things could happen in his. For I believe the end of this sad story, this perplexing, brief encounter, has not yet been fully written. Our God continues to move in mysterious and exciting ways and writes miraculous stories.1

The Madness of Ministry with Young People

Youth ministry is replete with ambiguous endings. Is Bruce's tale a happy one or a sad one? Does it chronicle youth ministry's success or failure? It's not hard to find people who believe that a touch of madness is an asset for working with teenagers; and if investing in teenagers is not madness, then surely investing in Jesus is. How many people stake their lives on something as outlandish as resurrection? Nothing about the empty tomb makes sense. As the curtain rises on the closing scene of the Gospel of Mark, we see Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James, and Salome trudging toward Jesus' tomb at sunrise, ready to perform that final task of love: anointing the body. Just as they wonder aloud about the logistics of removing the stone from the tomb's entrance, they stop, stunned. The huge stone at the mouth of the tomb is gone. A young man in a dazzling white robe startles them: Jesus is not here; he is risen! Shooing them on, the young man says, "Go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going ahead of you to Galilee; there you will see him, just as he told you" (Mark 16:7).

Youth ministry is replete with ambiguous endings.

The women bolt, but not to tell the disciples the good news—at least, not in Mark's Gospel. Mark's Gospel leaves us hanging.2 The women fled "for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid" (Mark 16:8). That's it. The end. No telling, no fish fry on the beach, no Emmaus Road encounter, just fear and silence. Jesus is ahead of them in Galilee; they will see him, just as he promised. Yet their fear and amazement are well-founded. What they have heard is ludicrous—it is a mad, unfathomable, ridiculous promise. And it is the hope of the church.

Jesus is ahead of us. There is no place young people can go, no place we can take them, that Jesus hasn't arrived first. Even death is old hat to Jesus. As Mark tells it, the end of this perplexing story has not yet been fully written. Just as God continued to write miraculous stories of witness after the resurrection, God continues to write surprise endings into young people's lives today. The question we have to ask when we enter a pastoral situation is not "What can I get going here that would be good for these kids?" but "What is Christ already up to with young people that I can get in on?"3

The most promising possibility in youth ministry is the promise that Jesus has gone on before us, and that one day he promises to let us catch up to him.

The most promising possibility in youth ministry is the promise that Jesus has gone on before us, and that one day he promises to let us catch up to him. Jesus is already at work in the young people we love (and, to be sure, in those we don't)—"Christ is on the loose," as biblical scholar Don Juel put it.4 God gets to our churches, to our communities, and to young people themselves long before we can, kneading stiff necks, softening hard hearts, closing some doors and opening others, kicking up some hope. The dangling ending to Easter in Mark's Gospel reminds us that, crazy as it seems, God's story is not over yet. Christ will not rest until his story includes us.

Promising Possibilities for Youth Ministry

The Theological "Turn" in Youth Ministry

Dick and Jane Go to Church: The Hunger for a Worthy Adventure

The Missional Church: Following Jesus into the World Redefining Community: From Connections to Communion Sacred Practices: Aiming for Embodied Faith

1. Practicing the Presence of God

2. A Curriculum of Sacred Practice

3. The Importance of Parents

Beyond Training Events: New Possibilities for Forming Leaders

Streams in the Wasteland

The Theological "Turn" in Youth Ministry

One of the most promising signs of ministry with young people is that we are becoming far more theologically self-aware. As we have seen, the most enduring themes in youth ministry are theological ones, reflecting Christ's call to young people (and to us) to become disciples. The hopeful signs for youth ministry's future flow from this theological consciousness as well. As we acknowledge young people's witness to and on behalf of the broader church, youth ministers are growing more systematic in our thinking, more deliberate about our purposes, and more self-critical about our practices—to the point that youth ministry has begun to cohere into something resembling a "field of study" within the larger discipline of practical theology. (Skip to chapter 6 if you want to know more.) By grounding youth ministry in the mission of the church, ministry with young people becomes less "hit and miss" and more integrated into the witness of the faith community. We can now discern patterns in youth ministries that thrive, and in those that struggle—patterns that cluster around the presence, or the absence, of certain practices that help young people and their families encounter Christ in the texts and traditions of the Christian community.

Theologically engaged youth ministry is patterned after the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ, as young people learn to interpret their lives through the texts and traditions of the Christian community.

All of these patterns signal what Andrew Root has called the "theological turn in youth ministry"5—a shared consensus that youth ministry should stop lingering over logistics ("Who will roll the stone away? How will we keep kids interested on Sunday night?") and start looking for signs of resurrection instead, knowing that Christ is already in young people's lives ahead of us. Theologically engaged youth ministry is patterned after the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ, as we learn to interpret human experience through the lenses of the Christian story, mediated through the texts and traditions of the church. The promises and possibilities for youth ministry all develop relationships that enact Christ's suffering love as we follow Jesus into the world. Mad though it may seem, Christ is ahead of us, waiting to write us into the stories of young people we have yet to meet.

Dick and Jane Go to Church:

The Hunger for a Worthy Adventure

"The challenge of discipleship—of following Jesus—is the heart of the Church's mission. All ministry with adolescents must be directed toward presenting young people with the Good News of Jesus Christ and inviting and challenging them to become his disciples."6 These words from the 1995 National Conference of Catholic Bishops' Renewing the Vision document, outlining the goals for the Catholic church's mission with young people in the twenty-first century, capture the heart of youth ministry for most churches. Pope John Paul II, a successful youth minister in Poland after World War II, minced no words in describing the way the church must meet this challenge of discipleship: by offering young people "a world-shaping vision that meets their hunger for the chance to participate in a worthy adventure."7

As a teenager in the American South in the 1980s, I (Amy) did not think going to youth group was an adventure; it was not even remotely countercultural. Everyone I knew went to church. The values of the church and the priorities of my school and community seemed to be in complete agreement; stores closed on Sundays and schools closed around Christian holidays. It never crossed anyone's mind to schedule a soccer game on Sunday morning (though scheduling games during Friday Shabbat was common). Nor did it occur to us to use the pulpit for cultural critique. Attending Sunday night youth group meant participating in the script of a predictable story: work hard in school, be a good citizen, join the church of your parents, do what your family and peers expect of you. The good people in my congregation considered this Christian formation, but what my church really offered me was a part in a Fun with Dick and Jane story—neat, homogenous, and uncomplicated, with bright pictures and no plot.

The good people in my congregation considered this Christian formation, but what my church really offered me was a part in a Fun with Dick and Jane story—neat, homogenous, and uncomplicated, with bright pictures and no plot.

Dick and Jane remain alive and well in American churches. Very few young people seem to view religious involvement as a worthy adventure. The good news from the (2005) National Study of Youth and Religion is that it jarred many youth ministers, and a few congregations, into reassessing discipleship formation as more than a passive rite of church membership. The overwhelming absence of a theological vocabulary among American teenagers suggests a disturbing distance between the concerns of the church and the concerns of young people. By "theological vocabulary" I do not mean technical doctrinal jargon or facile "Jesus-speak." In interviews, teenagers simply do not articulate their experience using theological categories (for example, being thankful to God, having a purpose in life that may follow Christ's example, sensing God's presence at key moments in one's life), which suggests that Christian teaching is either unfamiliar or irrelevant to them—or both. Meanwhile, teenagers are consistently very articulate about other abstract or meaningful subjects, especially those taught in school or discussed in the media.8

What this tells us is not only that most teenagers, including churchgoing ones, seem to feel uncomfortable discussing religion in public. It also suggests that they have little opportunity for, exposure to, or inclination toward theological reflection. Nor are they practiced at drawing on Christian tradition to inform their daily lives and decisions. It is no surprise that teenagers are hesitant to wear their religious stripes in the "judge-not-lest-ye-be-judged" public square, where religious affiliation often carries political freight. What is surprising is that churches themselves seem to have avoided theological or spiritual engagement with young people, leaving teenagers to grapple with faith privately, without a language to connect their lives to the stories of the Christian community, and without practices that allow them to take this faith with them into the world.

Perhaps we should have seen this coming. In 1950, for example, the Methodist Church, eager to downplay its evangelistic reputation, identified the following as the desired outcomes of Methodist Youth Fellowships (MYFs) in a statement that was soon replicated by other denominations:

  • to build Christian character
  • to provide young people a chance for self-expression
  • to train leaders
  • to develop friendships
  • to promote the welfare of the church.9
  • In the 1950s, many pastors welcomed these goals as a way to move beyond Christian provincialism. In a broad ecology of Christian socialization, where tending the youthful soul was the task of multiple overlapping social institutions (e.g., families, congregations, faith-based community groups, and religious schools), youth ministry could afford to serve as a broadening agent, since teenagers received basic religious formation elsewhere.10 In the 1950s, families, congregations, parochial schools, and Christian colleges all offered opportunities for religious formation, and were contexts where young people could reflect on their lives and the broader world in light of faith.

    Thirty years later, a decisive change in this ecology of religious formation had occurred. In 1980, sociologist Dean Hoge and his colleagues demonstrated a dramatic shift away from theological formation in youth ministries.11 Hoge's team compared the top outcomes sought by youth ministry in six denominations before and after 1980 (figure 4.1). While youth ministry before 1980 placed a high priority on engaging young people in faith-shaping spiritual practices, after 1980 spiritual formation become nearly invisible in youth ministry's priorities. By 1991, a Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development study found that the largest religious denominations/communities in the U.S. (Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish) shared two parallel goals in religious youth work: fostering faith identity (or sense of belonging in a faith community) and providing young people with safe passage into adulthood.12 In 2000, more than two thousand youth ministers once again identified spiritual development as one of several desired outcomes for youth ministry.13 Here is what these studies found:

    Figure 4.1

    Desired Outcomes in Youth Ministry before and after 198014

    For youth ministry to be ministry—bearing witness to Christ's self-giving love in the church and in the world—it must primarily provide a context for spiritual engagement, where a lively, intimate communion between young people and God is nourished through the texts, traditions, and communities of the church. To be clear: in Christian tradition, theological engagement nourishes Christ-like interpersonal relationships and profound social responsibility. Yet unless young people can frame these relationships and responsibilities in light of faithfulness to Christ, youth have no choice but to interpret them using the only tools they know—usually the habits and worldviews they receive from their families, peers, and the global media.

    Dodging theological content in youth ministry impairs teenagers for accepting their identities as God's beloved and stunts their participation in a faith community.

    Some churches, of course, have long traditions of theologically engaging young people (even churches in the denominations studied above). After several decades of well-meaning avoidance (i.e., "the Bible turns teenagers off"), we now know that dodging theological content in youth ministry actually impairs teenagers for accepting their identities as God's beloved and stunts their participation in a faith community that "speaks Christian," as Stanley Hauerwas puts it.15 A number of developments in current trends aim to deepen young people's participation in identity-forming Christian practices, engage more fully with Christian texts and traditions, and reflect on their lives, and on the world as a whole, from an explicit theological point of view. This chapter will consider three promising possibilities: attention to mission, attention to communities of belonging, and attention to sacred practices.

    The Missional Church: Following Jesus into the World

    It would be hard to overestimate the importance of mission for the church in a post-Christendom age. Mission (from the Latin missio, "to send") does not mean proselytizing. In fact, missional theologians are anxious to avoid the imperialistic and exclusivist claims associated with "mission" in previous centuries, reminding us that the church's original identity was as people sent by God into the world. "As the Father has sent me," Jesus told his disciples, "so I send you" (John 20:21). The church's job is to confess, not convince.16 Mission was never intended to become the job of a few individuals sent to some faraway place to persuade others to join the Christian movement. God sends the whole church, youth included, into the world to confess Christ, which means two things for youth ministry: (1) we don't have to go very far to engage in mission, and (2) congregations are themselves "missionary"—eliminating the need for many denominational and even pastoral "middle managers."

    The growing emphasis upon the local congregation is accompanied, in churches of the Western tradition, by the diminishing importance of regional and national church structures. They are both getting smaller and are being redefined. . . . As they decrease in size and authority, denominational structures in the North Atlantic context increasingly affirm the local congregation as the prime unit of mission.17

    One significant shift in our understanding of mission has been the view that North America—and the North American church—are themselves loci of mission communities in need of the good news of the gospel. Missional theologians like Darrell Guder argue that reorganizing the church does not go far enough to restore the church's true identity as an agent of Christ's mission in the world. What is required is nothing short of conversion, "the continuing conversion of the church."18

    Churches are not gatherings of "the saved" but are communities of "the sent."

    The missional church movement is a bid to disestablish churches from their dominant culture captivity.19 The term missional church (a phrase that strictly speaking is redundant) does not mean a vigorous campaign to convert people to Christian faith but rather a church that participates in God's healing and transforming purposes in and for the world. The phrase "missional church" was coined by a group of scholars who took seriously the consensus statement of Vatican II: "The church on earth is by its very nature missionary since, according to the plan of the Father, it has its origin in the mission of the Son and of the Holy Spirit."20 To understand this statement means we must first admit what mission is not. It is not one of many church programs; it is not a matter of sending a few Christians into a foreign culture to convert unbelievers; it is not about dispatching a van full of youth on a mission trip to Appalachia or Mexico on behalf of the rest of the congregation. To be a missional church means, first and foremost, that everything we do bears witness to God's reconciling mission for the world. Being missional requires us to understand that churches do not exist for the benefit of our own members. Mission is the business the church is in. A church that is not missional is not a church in the first place.21

    To be sure, most young people disenchanted with their churches do not form a "missional church"; they just quit. In the U.S., 11 percent fewer people said they are Christians in 1990 than in the decade before. "When it comes to religion," writes Cathy Lynn Grossman, reporting the results of 2008's American Religious Identification Survey, "the USA is now land of the freelancers."22 The study concludes: "The challenge to Christianity. . . does not come from other religions but from a rejection of all forms of organized religion."23

    1. Vocation and Mission

    The missional church offers young people a "worthy adventure" through the vocation of discipleship. Churches are not gatherings of "the saved" but communities of "the sent"—people called and sent by God into the world as envoys of Christ's saving grace. Missional churches do not view the Christian story as a vehicle for socializing young people into better church members or more wholesome citizens. For them, to follow Christ is to take part in a great adventure story—more Lord of the Rings trilogy than Fun with Dick and Jane. Youth ministry that takes seriously the church's missional identity invites young people into a way of life that reflects the dying-and-rising rhythm of baptism, as they step into an adventure with great risks and greater rewards.

    To follow Christ is to take part in a great adventure story—more Lord of the Ringsthan Fun with Dick and Jane.

    But to become a worthy adventure, youth ministry must invoke gospel madness, the inside-out logic in which the last shall be first and the first shall be last. David White explains, "Youth ministry, at its best . . . engages youth as partners in the Kingdom of God, mobilizing the skills, practices, and attitudes to sustain a countercultural Christian faith beyond adolescence into adulthood."24 In other words, missional churches introduce young people to their vocations as fullfledged witnesses to the gospel. Forget the stereotypes of "witnessing" as knocking on doors, handing out tracts, or preaching on the street corner. All Christians are called to serve as witnesses—not just those who volunteer to serve on the evangelism committee, not just adults, not just those with enough interpersonal chutzpah to risk ridicule at school. Theologian Karl Barth proposes that our very identity as Christians is found in our calling to serve as witnesses: "[Christians], with their whole being, action, inaction and conduct, and then by word and speech, . . . have to make a definite declaration to other[s]. . . . The essence of their vocations is that God makes them witnesses."25

    2. Through the Roof and through the Window

    There is no right way to go about youth ministry in a missional congregation. As a youth minister in Virginia explained, "I aim for mission and kind of hit youth ministry along the way," which suggests the kind of ministry we read about again and again in the gospel.26 In Mark 2, we meet a group of friends so determined to bring a companion to Jesus that they carry their paralyzed buddy on a stretcher to the house where Jesus is staying—only to find it "standing room only." Purpose, creativity, and determination make these friends missional. They adapt to their context in ways that some might call ingenious, others might call destructive, but that changes the status quo for the sake of allowing someone on the margins to encounter the healing ways of Christ. These friends are not willing to wait for the crowds to disperse, any more than our youth are willing to wait for the church to evolve into something they can relate to after graduation. Like the paralyzed man's roof-scaling friends, teenagers are impatient. They are creative. They are persistent and bold and unconventional. The paralyzed man's friends opt for a top-down approach: one hole in the roof and down he goes, stretcher and all, to see Jesus. Jesus acknowledges the friends' faith, forgives the paralyzed man of his sins, heals his body, and sends them all home.

    Some Christian communities go to great lengths to carry out a missional mindset, breaking holes in the roofs of tradition so that young people can encounter Jesus. Founders of the "emerging church movement"—a loose collective of Christian communities who adapt their practices for the mission field of postmodern culture—believe that most churches have become so culturally bound to modernism that alternative practices must be developed to address postmodern young people, whose cultural experience makes traditional expressions of Christianity completely alien. Emerging churches often "poke holes" in the modern church roof, challenging its institutional structures, its systematic theology, its professional clergy, its propositional teaching methods, and its preoccupation with bringing people into the church rather than with bringing the church to people to transform their lives and contexts.27 As a result, emerging churches have developed countless creative ways for lowering stretchers into the church, helping young men and women, who might not otherwise see Jesus, get into a room, where they can encounter the transforming presence of God.

    Other missional communities forego the hole in the roof in favor of opening a window, providing alternative entry points into the church that, in turn, offer alternative perspectives on Jesus. The front door still works for some youth; but going through the window provides fresh theological angles, benefiting traditional church members as well. Congregational mission and service trips are perspective-changing examples. For a teenager to experience mission as a witness to Jesus Christ is quite different from experiencing "missional tourism"—trips that make no long-term claim on us, do not invest in real community or compassion, though they may help young people feel good about themselves and fulfill high school service requirements. Practical theologian and educator Don Richter encourages mission planners to include prayerful, reflective practices that awaken young people to systemic injustice, open them to the witness of others, and overcome the tendency to relegate "community service" to an annual experience that bears no relationship to their daily lives.28

    Of course, missional churches—like all churches—must be critiqued as well; as theologian Ted Smith points out, since consumerism capitalizes on the new and the different, being countercultural hardly protects us from being co-opted by dominant culture values.29 Yet the missional church conversation offers the church different endings to the Easter story we read in Mark, helping us imagine how we might run from the tomb to a world that is wildly unprepared for good news.

    Three Missional Churches

    Outreach Red Bank (ORB) in Red Bank, New Jersey, began as a ministry to disenfranchised homeless youth who hung out in a local park. Young adults had a simple vision for the ministry's beginnings: since teenagers weren't going to church, these adults brought the church to them. They ate together, sang together, and talked about God. As ORB grew, other adults in the community caught the vision and got involved. Today, ORB is an intergenerational congregation, but it retains its original missional purpose: to bear witness to Jesus Christ among young people, especially those on the margins, in the Red Bank community. www.theorb.org

    BroadStreet Ministries, on the Avenue of the Arts in Philadelphia, is a new church development initially supported by mission dollars from local Presbyterian Church (USA) congregations. Meeting in a once-abandoned Presbyterian church building, the congregation was formed by young adults who wanted to be Christ's witnesses to people in the neighborhood—many of whom were artists with few (or negative) church experiences. In addition to developing youth ministries, mental health initiatives, and a variety of programs to serve homeless Philadelphians, BSM builds bridges between the arts and Christian spirituality by sponsoring CD release events, concerts, a film and speaker series, art exhibits, and other public events for local artists and by having a Curator of Experiential Arts on staff. www.broadstreetministry.org.

    Oconnee Presbyterian Church in Watkinsville, Georgia, was formed around a vision of a church that is radically inclusive of all generations. If you were to visit on Sunday, you would find children and youth participating in worship, worshipers being asked to greet someone twenty years younger or older (who is not a family member!), and first and second graders reading Scripture or leading in some other fashion. To encourage multiple generations in worship, soft cushions are placed around the sanctuary in case anyone wants to sit on the floor; multisensory elements are included in sermons and the liturgy; and the community gathers at other times besides Sunday morning. During the week, teens and adults work together to provide meals and shelter for those in need. At church suppers, guests are frequently seated by birthday month, so that table conversations may include several adults, a few teenagers, a three-year-old, and a ten-year-old, all of whom share April birthdays. http://opcusa.org/.30

    The Emerging Church

    Emerging churches "emerge" around the mission of serving Christ in a postmodern context. Nadia Bolz-Weber is the "mission developer" for House for All Sinners and Saints in Denver, Colorado. She describes House for All Sinners and Saints as "an urban liturgical community with a progressive yet deeply rooted theological imagination." It is also, according to her blogspot, an "Emerging Church a la Luther."31 In a post on March 19, 2009, she offers her take on the emerging church:

    If I had a dollar for every person who has asked me "So, what IS the emerging church?" we could meet our budget this year. Here's my own definition, and it is just that—my definition. Not the definition. When I use the term "emerging church," here's what I mean by that . . . (I feel like I'm walking into a minefield, but here we go . . . )

    Emerging Church: Christian communities that emerge out of very particular cultural contexts where the traditional church is basically irrelevant. These cultural contexts are more often than not urban, youngish, and postmodern.

    Emerging church is not a worship style. I know emerging churches that do traditional liturgy with jazz (Mercy Seat), who use electronica (Church of the Beloved), who are a cappella Gregorian chant (House for All Sinners and Saints), and who do nothing but old-time Southern gospel (House of Mercy).

    So, when trad churches in the suburbs are wanting to attract young people (with all the good intentions in the world) and they ape some kind of worship style they read about in a Zondervan book by starting an "emerging" worship service, it's a bit ironic.

    Ok, now before you leave me angry responses, let me say: this is not saying that there is something wrong with the traditional church. Trad church is often a faithful expression of Christian community. But my friends would have to culturally commute from who they are to who the trad church is. This is why I want to make a t-shirt that says, "Light all the candles you want to; they are not coming." The back of the shirt would say "It's OK to be who you are (traditional, suburban, small town, conservative, Methodist . . . whatever it is. Be it.)"

    For the record: I wanted to start a church in a context that I am native to. I am not "targeting a population" nor have I at any point had to ask myself, "What is it they want"? They being postmodern urban young adults. I am they.

    Redefining Community: From Connections to Communion

    Every youth worker knows that to "belong" is a sacred trust for teenagers. The need for community is part of young people's developmental circuitry; one frequently cited early report on brain development declares adolescents "hard wired to connect."32 Today's emerging adults place a greater value on community than their parents do.33 Yet the ways in which millenial young people belong are quite different than was the case for their Boomer or even their Xer parents. Millennials are less likely to join organizations and more likely to seek out communities and networks. If their experience of the church is positive, they are less likely to think of it as a place and more likely to experience it as a system of relationships.

    In many ways, the impulse to become part of a community or network taps into gospel forms of "belonging" more faithfully than many youth ministry fellowship programs. Communities do not come into being for their own sake; they tend to emerge from a group of people who focus together on common interests and objectives. Anyone who has ever planned an evening for teenagers to "get to know each other" quickly realizes how shallow forced fellowship feels. On the other hand, experiences of risk, vulnerability, creativity, and meaning-making all evoke organic bonds between all who share the experience. Serving in a soup kitchen, discussing theology in a restaurant, repairing porches in Appalachia, playing in a band all strengthen group sinews among young people in congregations. When thousands of young people stream into Taizé, France, each summer to work and pray with the tiny ecumenical monastic community there, nobody plays icebreakers. Instead, points out practical theologian and educator Jason Santos, the Brothers of Taizé practice the radical welcome of Jesus Christ—and as youth participate in these Christ-centered practices, they consistently experience a new, compelling, and transformative way of being human.34 Christian community is less an end in itself than the joyful by-product of people focusing on Christ together. In our common focus on Jesus Christ, the church becomes koinonia—a fellowship created not by you and me but by Christ who draws all people to himself.

    1. New Ways to Belong

    Millennial young people are restructuring the coordinates of community, experimenting with ways to connect that were not possible even a decade ago. Web 2.0 technology offers young people visibility, mutual vulnerability, participation, and a sense of common purpose that transcends time and geography, which are essential for belonging in a networked, globalized society. In fact, some educators believe technology makes these avenues of belonging more readily available than churches do.35 The "flat" world of globalization exponentially expands the number of communities available to teenagers. Belonging is horizontal as well as vertical, wide as well as deep, virtual as well as actual, near as well as far. The technological engines of globalization (the internet, transportation systems, cellular technology, the entertainment media, and so on) make intercultural contact normative, giving teenagers a "planetary perspective" that lets them pick and choose from an endless array of potential communities of belonging. Community is not a given; it is constructed from the possibilities of a global culture. No people group, no part of the planet is off limits.36

    Add to the mix another dimension of belonging for adolescents: participation. "Teenagers belong where they participate," observes practical theologian and educator Andrew Zirschky. "Web 2.0 is all about participation."37 A 2008 Harris Interactive poll underscored teenagers' increasing dependence on cell phones (40 percent of teenagers surveyed said they "would die" without one) and demonstrated how these technologies enable young people to create communities in which they have legitimate power.38 The participatory culture of the twenty-first century offers a context where young people have become creators of cultural content and not merely consumers of it.39 While churches largely follow the traditional American institutional script of restricting full teenage engagement, participatory culture welcomes young people's contributions to the "formation" of culture itself. While most teenagers cannot vote, lack meaningful work, and have limited transportation, in the online world they can and do publish, trade stocks, build businesses, provide services, and engage with other youth and adults on an endless array of topics and causes.

    2. Communion, Not Connections

    An interesting sidebar accompanies the multiple communities and connections available to young people. Despite these communities' virtual forms, young people consistently prefer face-to-face interaction with friends (beeper studies show that teenagers are happiest when partying or when they are with a romantic partner).40 By 2009, media analysts like Danah Boyd and Anastasia Goodstein reported "social networking fatigue" among young people, although youth have not yet moved to other media platforms, and they still depend on social networking sites for community-shaping activities like conversation, coordinating social plans, sharing photos, and so on. Still, adolescents crave interpersonal interactions and "the call of 'real life.' "41 The intimacy young people seek is a deep and spiritual sense of belonging and being known—an intimacy enacted in the Christian practice of communion:

    Culture offers connections, but it can't offer communion. . . . Coming together in church over bread and wine involves human technologies too—humanly made elements of bread and wine—until the Holy Spirit shows up and transforms them. Communion comes as a result of the Holy Spirit in our community.42

    "Culture offers connections, but it can't offer communion. . . . Communion comes as a result of the Holy Spirit in our community." —Andrew Zirschky

    As Zirschky points out, the church is called to cultivate communion and not just connections with young people. Being a face-to-face community is not enough; the church must be a communion (and not just serve it from time to time). We must become a community looking in the same direction, at the same God, seeking union with the Holy Spirit, offering the life-forlife intimacy of being known, the safety of mutual vulnerability, and the agency of participation in a community that transcends time and geography. Many young people seek such intimacy online, and feel more open and understood by virtual friends than by those they see every day. Yet the church concretizes belonging, giving it embodied form in the sacrament of the Lord's Supper. The Eucharist is the "outward sign" of God's gift of inward grace, which is what makes communion—literally, "one-withness"—possible in the first place. When the church becomes a community of belonging, we embody "communions"—one-with-ness in every form—that imperfectly but authentically becomes the body and blood of Christ as we remember him.

    Sacred Practices: Aiming for Embodied Faith

    The importance of communion for youth ministry (both in the sacramental and in the communal sense) points to a third promising theme in youth ministry: a renewed interest in sacred practices, as mentioned in chapter 3.43 Maria Harris's 1981 Portrait of Youth Ministry anticipated the practices paradigm by calling churches to reappropriate ancient curricular forms like teaching, prayer, communion, advocacy, and troublemaking in our ministries with young people. Two decades later, youth ministry emerged as the church's testing ground for a "practices approach" to faith formation that takes seriously calling, preparing, and sending young people (and the rest of us) into the world as Jesus' disciples.

    Practices are the ongoing actions of the Christian community that the Holy Spirit uses to mark us as, and shape us into, followers of Jesus Christ.44 Practices are simultaneously formative and performative; they are actions that God uses to change us and, through the church, to change the world. Christian tradition allows a good deal of latitude for contextualizing faith practices for particular flocks, but because each practice imitates Christ in large or small ways, adapting them does not alter their essential, cruciform shape. We somehow still recognize Christ through the dying-and-rising patterns brought to life in faith practices, as God uses them—uses us—to enter the world. Practical theologian and educator Craig Dykstra explains,

    Christian practices are not activities we do to make something spiritual happen in our lives. Nor are they duties we undertake to be obedient to God. Rather, they are patterns of communal action that create openings in our lives where the grace, mercy, and presence of God may be made known to us. They are places where the power of God is experienced. In the end, these are not ultimately our practices but forms of participation in the practice of God.45

    Practices, therefore, function as embodied beliefs. Remember those sponge bath toys you had as a child, the kind that came in small, compressed pellets? Add water and—presto!—they grew into three-dimensional ducks and dinosaurs. Christian practices are like that. Doctrines are Christian teachings in their flat, compressed form, but practices make these doctrines spring to life in the three-dimensional experience of following Jesus.

    Practices are the ongoing actions of the Christian community that the Holy Spirit uses to mark us as, and shape us into, followers of Jesus Christ.

    1. Practicing the Presence of God

    Practices, like signs and sacraments, are human actions that point to the promise of God, and that often serve as a context for divine-human encounter. Because sacraments allow us (quite literally) to "practice the presence of God," as Brother Lawrence (1614–1691) famously put it, they function as means of grace that invite our participation in the life of God. Sacraments like baptism, for example, enact this participation explicitly. Yet sacraments "proper" are not the only human actions that serve as opportunities for divine-human encounter. For Brother Lawrence, every practice of Christian life amounted to a form of prayer, and every "common business" was a medium of divine love.46 Youth ministry includes many other means of grace that outwardly signify the divine grace that fuels the Christian life. For young people accustomed to a participatory, image-driven culture, the power of outward signs—active, tangible, and personal—is significant.

    For young people accustomed to a participatory, image-driven culture, the power of outward signs—active, tangible, and personal—is significant.

    Young Catholics, for instance, are rediscovering sacramentals, which practical theologian Tom Beaudoin describes as "miniature, personal signs of God and God's grace in the world."47 For Catholics, sacramentals may take any number of forms: prayer, the use of holy water, salt, and other blessed foods, the avowal of faults in Mass, the giving of alms, or priestly blessings involving candles, ashes, or palms, to name a few. Sacramentals emphasize faith's personal dimensions, especially God's presence in daily life, which heightens their power for young people who tend to view personal experience as the ultimate test of "what counts as religious."48 Beaudoin explains sacramentals' appeal to Generation X (born roughly between 1961–1981): "Grounded in accessible, quotidian practices, sacramentals help Xers see their own experience as religious. The divine may be present in the artifacts that attend Xer quests for the religious life."49

    Meanwhile, Protestant youth ministry tends to emphasize actions that imitate Christ more than material signs of God's grace, though sometimes these actions are indistinguishable from sacramentals. Martin Luther, for instance, considered confession, absolution, and reading and hearing the gospel sacramental. John Wesley defined means of grace as actions that God uses to strengthen us for "holiness of heart and mind," and divided them into two categories: works of piety (i.e., prayer, searching the Scriptures, holy communion, fasting, Christian conferencing, and healthy living) and works of mercy (i.e., doing good, visiting the sick, visiting the imprisoned, feeding and clothing those in need, earning/saving/giving all that one can, and seeking justice).50 In Wesley's view, practices were not only signs that help us grow in faith; they were the Holy Spirit's means of equipping and sending God's people into the world.

    2. A Curriculum of Sacred Practices

    Because God uses these sacred actions to transform the church (starting with us), "practicing the presence of God" provides a curriculum for participating in the life of Christ. Faith is not formed through the heady dispensation of data, but by the gift of the Holy Spirit imparted in relationships through which Christ is known. By inviting young people to participate in the practices that have bound Christian communities to Jesus Christ for two thousand years, young people come to know themselves as Jesus' followers, both because they act like other Christians and because through these relational practices, God transforms us into people who resemble Jesus.

    "I may have been fooling around, but Jesus wasn't. My heart may not have been in it, but Jesus' was."—Barbara Brown Taylor

    Sacred practices offer young people concrete ways to participate in an ancient tradition of faith, while simultaneously creating space for holy encounters that are immediate, personal, and transformative, even when we do not consciously look for them. Recalling a half-hearted prayer in college that put her on a lifelong pursuit of Christ, Barbara Brown Taylor recalls: "I may have been fooling around, but Jesus wasn't. My heart may not have been in it, but Jesus' was."51 Sacred practices do not just pass along information about Jesus; they immerse young people in an embodied version of the Christian story, taking part in God's action in the world here and now.

    3. The Importance of Parents

    In the "Concluding Unscientific Postscript" to Soul Searching, sociologists Smith and Denton mull over ways that churches might deepen teenagers' engagement with their faith traditions. Besides reiterating the importance of adult-youth relationships and religious practices for adolescent discipleship, they contend that adults need to stop thinking of teenagers as a separate species and start practicing faith along with them:

  • The best way to get most youth more involved in and serious about their faith communities is to get their parents more involved in and serious about their faith communities.
  • Parents and faith communities should not be shy about teaching teens.
  • Religious educators need to work harder on helping young people articulate faith.
  • Religious communities might themselves think more carefully and help youth think more carefully about the distinctions among (1) serious, articulate, confident personal and congregational faith, versus (2) respectful civil discourse in the pluralistic public sphere, versus (3) obnoxious, offensive faith talk that merely turns people off.
  • Regular religious practices in the lives of youth (beyond those in and of collective weekly congregations) seem to be extremely important.52
  • It is strange to hear such recommendations from social scientists; they are commonly heard—though seldom heeded—in youth ministry. Yet without this research, youth ministry has often been stuck at the level of "lore," habits of thinking that attribute lively faith in young people to some mysterious alchemy between youth ministers' training and leadership skills and the peer relationships and practices of youth themselves. Research is abundantly clear: if we want young people to have faith, we must attend to the faith of their parents and congregations.

    "The best way to get most youth more involved in and serious about their faith communities is to get their parents more involved in and serious about their faith communities."—Christian Smith and Melinda Denton

    The National Study of Youth and Religion is one of dozens of studies that identify parents as the most important influence on the religious lives of their children. Longitudinal research from the NSYR reveals the significance of parents' religiosity for emerging adults, as well; youth between the ages of 18-23 who remain devoted to religious faith after the high school years are overwhelmingly young people whose parents were highly religious while their children were teenagers—and, for young people without religious parents, congregational relationships with other Christian adults often compensated.53 The 2004 Exemplary Youth Ministry study links thriving faith in teenagers to congregations' capacities to theologically engage parents and other adult leaders. While theologically prepared leaders and peer relationships were regarded as enormously significant, the EYM study found adolescent faith maturity to be most evident in churches that immersed teenagers in congregational life, and that cultivated partnerships with parents for the faith formation of their children (see Appendix A).54

    Beyond Training Events:

    New Possibilities for Forming Leaders

    Most churches know that the stereotype of a young, hip youth leader who plays the guitar and makes it cool to be for Jesus is a cartoon (not that they wouldn't hire this person if they found him—or less often, her). That didn't stop one search committee, phone-interviewing several graduating M.Div. students from the seminary where I (Kenda) teach, from asking each candidate to please play a "youth ministry song" on the guitar (over the phone) as part of the interview, to assess his or her readiness for the position.

    As new possibilities for the future of youth ministry present themselves in the early twenty-first century, leaders must be prepared to leverage them. In chapter 6, we will discuss how the professionalization of youth ministry in the past three decades has catapulted ministry with young people into a completely new sphere of proficiency and theological preparation—but it has not solved every problem in youth ministry. Statistics are hard to come by, but even with the move toward professionalization, the vast majority of youth ministers are not professionals—they're volunteers, with day jobs and busy lives. In a 2002 report commissioned by the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America, 84 percent of churches said their high school youth ministry's primary leaders were adult volunteers; 27 percent reported a lay, paid youth minister as one of their youth ministry's primary leaders—and fewer than 5 percent reported having an ordained, paid youth minister as a primary leader. Most long-term youth ministry training and degree programs (undergraduate and graduate), focus on these last two categories.55

    One of the downsides of professionalization seems to be churches' tendency to hire youth ministers to "take care of" the church's young people—suggesting that faith formation is a job for professionals, not for families and communities. Most churches still expect youth pastors to use their personal charisma and boundless energy to attract teenagers to the church, and once there to keep them busy, happy, and out of trouble. It is an impossible standard to uphold whether you are a guitar-playing twenty-something or a middle-aged mom. Furthermore, most professional youth ministers agree: the days of the solo, lone ranger youth director are over, which should indicate that the days of preparing youth ministers as individual repositories of talent are over as well. Slowly, churches are beginning to recognize that youth ministry leadership must be shared by the entire congregation rather than assigned to one superhuman paid youth worker. More churches are coming to believe that ministry with young people should be incarnational, and more youth ministers are developing methodologies for spiritual formation with young people that echo the relational strategies practiced by Jesus himself.

    Yet models for leadership formation that both acknowledge the communal nature of Christian formation and embody it are hard to come by. Despite our profound commitment to the formative power of relationships in the lives of young people, an incarnational approach to forming leaders in youth ministry has largely eluded us. The "youth ministry training event" model—an event featuring speakers and workshop leaders that requires youth ministers to parachute in for a day and sit passively while being inspired—has become nearly ubiquitous, making leadership formation in youth ministry (1) highly focused on individual leaders, (2) abstracted from actual situations of ministry, and (3) largely concentrated in "one off" events—one-hour presentations, one-day seminars and workshops, or speaker/seminar series ("one off" events in the sense that once completed, they are not repeated).

    Youth ministers are typically so hungry for training that they appreciate whatever youth ministry education is available to them, so well-meaning efforts are not wasted, and they offer short-term benefits and, sometimes, meaningful networks of colleagues for isolated youth workers. Yet the disconnect between the way we prepare leaders, and our increasingly intentional theologies and practices in youth ministry. All of the research we know in youth ministry—all of it—advocates shared, incarnational forms of leadership, not individuals with "skills." And all of the research we know from educational leadership—all of it—maintains that genuinely influential teacher training is communal, repeated, ongoing, and situated.56 Add "Spirit-led" to that list (since, after all, the goal of Christian formation is to cooperate with the promptings of the Holy Spirit) and you get a helpful acrostic to guide youth ministry leadership formation:

    Figure 4.2

    Dimensions of Leadership Development for Youth Ministry

    Incarnational Leadership Formation Is Communal

    Communal leadership formation is a shared proposition at many levels: it aims to shape both congregational leaders (including youth ministers) and congregations, developing a framework of support for youth ministry throughout the entire congregational system. Developing leaders in this way means that leadership education must come alongside both the leader and the congregation as ministry is being practiced. Communal models of leadership education ask questions like, Does every member of the congregation see himself or herself as a youth minister? Does the congregation acknowledge the importance of constellations of supportive adults in a young person's life, in addition to the presence of the youth pastor? Does the church have a plan for dealing with the stresses that youth ministry places on other congregational systems? Has the congregation put time into tilling the soil of youth ministry—developing deep layers of volunteers, identifying stakeholders in youth ministry's mission and vision, equipping parents, creating a congregational culture that welcomes and extends Christ's love for young people (including the ones we never see)? In short, does the church understand youth ministry as a shared mission that requires leadership development for the entire congregation, and not just for the volunteers who show up on Sunday nights?

    Old habits die hard, but some congregations are beginning to realize that youth ministry cannot be functionally outsourced to a hired hand. Young church leaders increasingly gravitate toward leadership teams and equipping ministries, nudging congregations toward models of youth ministry that involve multiple leaders, in differing capacities, and that utilize all the gifts of a congregation. Communal leadership formation involves partnerships of many kinds linking practitioner training with academic programs, developing learning communities (with peers as well as experts), creating venues that facilitate both horizontal (peer-to-peer) and vertical (teacher-to-learner) learning. The most promising approaches distribute support for youth ministry throughout the entire congregational system, while providing education and spiritual growth opportunities for youth leaders themselves.57

    Incarnational Leadership Formation Is Repeated and Ongoing

    As we noted earlier, single youth ministry training events inspire hope, and often launch important friendships (especially among the people leading them), but they do not develop leadership skills, nor do they form people theologically. Developing habits of leadership—and not just knowledge about habits of leadership—requires ongoing focus and attention. If we know from organizational research that it takes 10,000 hours of practice to become good at something (anything), and ten years to become an expert in a field (any field), then it is safe to say that a single exposure to any aspect of ministry is insufficient. Engaging in ongoing, repeatable practices, on the other hand, have enormous transformative potential—especially those that explicitly connect us to others in the Body of Christ, open us to the Holy Spirit's presence, and conform our lives to Jesus' life, death, and resurrection.

    Effective leadership formation utilizes Jerome Bruner's concept of a "spiral curriculum," which insists that people of all ages learn by following tracks that have been laid by prior learning, but at increasingly complex levels.58 For example, every level of youth ministry involves some kind of incarnational relationships, but our relational skills as a rookie youth minister should be different from our relational skills as a veteran. By naming what distinguishes an accomplished first-year youth pastor from an accomplished fifth- (or fiftieth)-year youth pastor we begin to hold people accountable to appropriate strategic and theological standards while discerning whether these standards are being met. A spiral curriculum offers an ongoing, incremental approach to learning, so that congregations, academic institutions, and continuing education opportunities all play an irreplaceable part.

    Incarnational Leadership Formation Is Situated

    The advantage of situated learning is what some educational theorists call "legitimate peripheral participation"—a kind of actual participation in a community that gradually moves learners from the margins of belonging to full participation in a community as the learner acquires the language and skills needed to take part in more significant ways.59 Situated learning maintains that learning comes from actively participating in communities of practice, utilizing advice from mentors and coaches to become more proficient and confident in the community's defining practices. Despite the dominance of situated learning models in the corporate world, they are quite scarce in youth ministry. Although many congregations "apprentice" teenagers to adults who can model the faith journey for them, apprenticeship relationships in leadership formation are scarce—though where they do exist, they are often cherished. More often, we associate situated learning with "coaching models" of leadership formation, in which corporately minded congregations contract consultants to come alongside them for several months, usually to address some area of concern in the ministry.

    Camping ministries have a long tradition of developing leaders through situated learning; many camp counselors and directors once were campers themselves who moved through the ranks (newbie, experienced camper, junior counselor, counselor) as they mastered the camp's culture.

    The irony is that, historically, situated learning is not a product of corporate culture; it is based on observations of how humans are integrated into social groups. When worshipping communities identify leaders within the congregation and groom them for particular roles, they are employing some of the principles of situated learning. Camping ministries have a long tradition of developing leaders through situated learning; many camp counselors and directors once were campers themselves who moved through the ranks (newbie, experienced camper, counselor-in-training [apprentice], counselor) as they mastered the camp's culture. African American churches offer another example. Many African American churches "raise up" new leaders from within, identifying mentors from the membership to walk alongside congregants who aspire to Christian leadership, as they assist with ministry itself. Academic programs sometimes provide "micro-versions" of situated learning (field education, internships, simulations, micro-teaching, immersion experiences, and other "laboratory" experiences are common). In short, while situated learning is not the norm for leadership formation in youth ministry, it offers great potential for educating church leaders, starting with youth leaders and young people themselves.

    Incarnational Leadership Formation Is Spirit-led

    The church's unique contribution to leadership formation, of course, is attentiveness to the Holy Spirit, who—if Scripture is any indication—routinely transforms "bad risks" for leadership (Moses, Mary, Paul) into towering spiritual giants (Moses, Mary, Paul). New metaphors for leadership in youth ministry in the early twenty-first century—bards, witnesses, Godbearers, place-sharers, spiritual guides—indicate a shift in the way we imagine our task with young people, as we try to cultivate divine attentiveness as much as on cultural or developmental awareness.60 Metaphors have power; they guide our thinking and our practice, but above all they shape our imaginations. All of these popular metaphors for youth ministry are helpful in bringing certain theological priorities to the foreground.

    What they also reveal, however, is a persistent bias in our thinking in the direction of individual leaders—a sense that God is most likely to transform young people in the crucible of a relationship with a single adult, calling into question the role of the church as a whole. To be fair, no one writing in youth ministry today would advocate such a reductionistic (or theologically questionable) view of leadership formation. Still, churches who hire youth ministry professionals (and even those who invest in volunteers) tend to translate our guiding metaphors into individuals who "do" youth ministry. While the adultyouth relationship is pivotal, pointing young people to Christ and equipping them for ministry in the world is a community affair—which only underscores the importance of "C.R.O.S.S." training for postmodern youth ministry education.

    New metaphors for leadership in youth ministry in the early twenty-first century—bards, witnesses, Godbearers, place-sharers, spiritual guides—indicate a shift in the way we imagine our task with young people, as we try to cultivate divine attentiveness as much as cultural or developmental awareness.

    Streams in the Wasteland

    The madness of youth ministry, of course, is the story we proclaim: the stone is rolled away, the tomb is empty, and Christ is on the loose. He is ahead of us, bringing new life to young people and to the church: "See, I am doing a new thing! / Now it springs up; do you not perceive it? / I am making a way in the desert / and streams in the wasteland" (Isaiah 43:19, NIV). As we learn to approach youth ministry as a form of theological engagement, by necessity the church becomes a worthy adventure where what is at stake is death versus life, wastelands versus pastures, despair versus hope. Anything less would defy the gospel. The promise of missional churches, communities of belonging, and faith practices is that they invite young people to imagine the church in new (though not necessarily original) ways. Such imagination inevitably demands that youth ministry leaders develop competencies that participate in these promising possibilities—competencies that are the subject of chapter 5.

    Further Reading on Themes in This Chapter

    Buckingham, David, ed. MacArthur Foundation Series on Digital Learning—Youth, Identity, and Digital Media Volume. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2008.

    Dean, Kenda Creasy and Ron Foster. The Godbearing Life: The Art of Soul-Tending for Youth Ministry. Nashville: Upper Room, 1998.

    Guder, Darrell L. The Continuing Conversion of the Church. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000.

    Jones, Tony. Postmodern Youth Ministry. Grand Rapids: Zondervan/Youth Specialities, 2001.

    Martinson, Roland, et al. Across the Generations. Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg Fortress, 1991.

    Peterson, Eugene. The Contemplative Pastor: Returning to the Art of Spiritual Direction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989.

    Renewing the Vision: A Framework for Catholic Youth Ministry. Washington, DC: National Conference of Catholic Bishops, 1995.

    Root, Andrew. "Youth Ministry as an Integrative Theological Task: Toward a Representative Method of Interdisciplinarity." The Journal of Youth Ministry 5, Spring 2007, 33–50.

    Strommen, Merton, et al. Youth Ministry That Transforms. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2001.

    Ward, Pete. God at the Mall: A Youth Ministry That Meets Kids Where They're At. Peabody, MA: Henrickson, 1999.

    Westerhoff, John H. Will Our Children Have Faith? Harrisburg, PA: Morehouse Publishing; Toronto, Canada: Anglican Book Centre, 2000.

    Yaconelli, Mark, ed. Growing Souls: Experiments in Contemplative Youth Ministry. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2007.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑