Chapter 4 of 14

Chapter One

Chapter One

CHAPTER ONE

HAUNTING QUESTIONS

I thank my God every time I remember you, constantly praying with joy in every one of my prayers for all of you, because of your sharing in the gospel from the first day until now. I am confident of this, that the one who began a good work among you will bring it to completion by the day of Jesus Christ.

—Philippians 1:3-6

If you have a group of twelve kids who don't understand your illustrations and one of them wants to kill you, you have a youth group just like Jesus.

—Mark Yaconelli

It is not just you.

Maybe you haven't put your nervousness into words. But social scientists have, and they are doing it more boldly. Listen to a few who, in recent years, have written about the condition of Christian formation in American young people:

Image1 "Most teenagers who have spent years attending church activities [have not integrated their faith] into who they are and how they live" (Barna, 2003).

Image1"Our distinct impression is that very many religious congregations and communities of faith in the United States are failing rather badly in religiously engaging and educating youth" (Smith, 2004). (Barna, 2003).

Image1 "Emerging adults' religious beliefs have surprisingly little connection to their religious training in childhood and adolescence" (Arnett, 2004).

Image1"The levels of disengagement among twentysomethings suggest that youth ministry fails too often at discipleship and faith formation" (Kinnaman, 2006).

If you have ever wondered if the hours you spend with children, youth, and emerging adults in the name of Jesus Christ make any difference to them, to the church, or to God, you are clearly in good company.

Barbara is asking these questions too.1 She wondered why she could not get high school students to attend "The Well," Resurrection Church's Sunday evening Bible study for youth. Teenagers would promise to come, then at the last minute flood her e-mail with excuses about unfinished homework, changed schedules, and last-minute demands from friends or families. Adult leaders posed challenges of their own; of the seven committed adults Barbara had trained this year, only three remained after job transfers, pregnancies, and increased work responsibilities took their toll. With fewer volunteers, Barbara worked longer hours herself, and she could feel her resentment grow as the youth program seemed to creep into every crevice of her life.

Furthermore, church leaders seemed disappointed with her performance. Barbara came to them highly recommended, and she began ministry amidst high expectations and excitement. Yet the expectations turned out to be illdefined and reflected competing goals between Barbara and the church board. Barbara viewed youth and family ministry as taking up life with Jesus Christ and his call to make disciples, evidenced in worship, acts of compassion, and solidarity with the poor. The church board was interested in how many youth attended each event she planned, and whether mission opportunities could "count" for the high school service hours requirement. Barbara sensed the pastor's support, but she knew from staff conversations that he viewed youth ministry as a potpourri of programs, events, and strategic relationships. Barbara believed adult education was crucial for equipping parents and grandparents to effectively nurture life and faith in their own children. But parents had little time for such offerings, and like the pastor, most parents seemed to think that Barbara was getting paid to get their teenagers to "enjoy church." Frustration gnawed at Barbara's sense of call. She began to wonder, Is any of this making any difference? Is this really what ministry is?

You Are Not Alone

It's not just you. You have plenty of company if you have left a youth gathering wondering if the teenagers heard anything you said; or if you have stared at a stack of budget reports, resource catalogs, or accumulating e-mails from concerned parents and wondered, "Can I really spend the rest of my life doing this?" If the evening news has ever made you wonder whether youth ministry can make a dent in the lives of young people who live in a world swamped by need, the good news is that you are not alone in asking the question. The bad news is that you are right to be concerned.

If the evening news has ever made you wonder whether youth ministry can make a dent in the lives of young people who live in a world swamped by need, the good news is that you are not alone in asking the question. The bad news is that you are right to be concerned.

If you don't plan to read this book in its entirety, you may want to stop here and go find something with a more comforting opening chapter. Ministry with adolescents inevitably raises questions that deserve the attention of youth ministers, parents, educators, and churches. Spoiler alert: While we open this book with haunting questions, we do not end here. But faithful ministry requires us to be awake to the conditions of people's lives and the contexts surrounding the young people Christ calls us to address. So naming these questions will help us frame the church's work with young people as mission, as a field of study, and as a holy vocation for people who care that young people know and love God. Youth ministry has its lonely moments, but it is neither a solitary nor a trivial pursuit.

So read on. And remember, it is not just you.

Telling the Truth: We Do This for Joy

Let's start by admitting what we already know in our bones: much of what we currently do in the name of youth ministry—much less in the name of Jesus—is not "working," whatever that means. Although most (some estimates say more than four out of five) Christian youth workers are volunteers, with more resources and training opportunities available than ever before, youth ministry has been professionalized to a degree that was unimaginable in the 1970s (a matter we will revisit in chapter 6).2 Theologically trained youth pastors are more plentiful and longer lasting than a generation ago, and more of them approach youth ministry as their life's calling, rather than as entrylevel ministry. Yet study after study suggests that the faith of American teenagers—even those who attend church—is extremely tenuous.

Is this what we signed up for? Most of us in youth ministry imagined that our work would produce more visible fruit, more satisfied parents, more vital congregations, more life-changing decisions, and more life-giving practices for young people and for the world they inhabit. That was the ministry we imagined, but much of it has been supplanted by crowded calendars, conflicting expectations, and distracting personal circumstances—in other words, by life. We love youth, we really do, but sometimes we think about that job in retail.

The humbling truth is that none of us do youth ministry because we are good at it. We do it because Christ has called us to it, called us to serve him in this way.

The humbling truth is that none of us do youth ministry because we are good at it. We do it because Christ has called us to it, called us to serve him in this way. God has given us a flock of teenagers and called us to serve Christ in their midst. No sane person, we tell ourselves, would head into such a mission apart from a directive from On High. So why do we stay? What keeps us in youth ministry instead of leaving, say, for a job in accounting (which many Christians do just as faithfully)?

The answer is simple and universal: Joy. Most of us cannot imagine another way of life that yields such overwhelming wonder and gratitude. Young people devastate and delight us, but above all they remind us of God's mercy and grace and power. Words do not exist to capture the joy, the awe, the privilege of accompanying a young person in his or her journey to Christ, and of knowing that God has somehow used us as vessels of grace along the way. We are often surprised and humbled that youth we barely know consider us significant in this journey. We have learned to hold loosely those teenagers who seem to reject everything we hold dear, knowing that God has not let them go. It is incredible that God trusts us with this work, given our propensity for screwing things up. We share Paul's grateful astonishment when he tells Timothy, "I am grateful to Christ Jesus our Lord, who has strengthened me, because he judged me faithful and appointed me to his service, even though I was formerly a blasphemer, a persecutor, and a man of violence" (1 Timothy 1:12-13).

Still, questions linger.

The Trouble with Research

Fifty years ago, research on youth ministry was almost nonexistent. Churches seldom mined social science as a resource for youth ministry, and social scientists seldom viewed adolescent faith as a topic worth exploring. What little information on adolescent faith formation existed was largely anecdotal, save for the work of developmental psychologists like Erik Erikson (whose theories, even after fifty years of scrutiny, still profoundly influence Christian youth work). Yet as sociologists Christian Smith and Melinda Denton remind us, "Detailed knowledge and understanding of the social world often raises real questions about cultural and institutional practices and commitments that can make real differences in people's lives."3 Today, thanks to renewed interest in interdisciplinary fields like practical theology and widespread attention from a number of disciplines on the changing nature of adolescence, churches now have several decades of developmental, demographic, sociological, and more recently, neurological and theological research that can inform the way we approach young people, faith, and culture.

Of course, the trouble with research is that, right or wrong, we now have a yardstick by which to assess how youth ministry is doing—and much of this research finds youth ministry lacking. Whether we follow the pioneering findings from the 1970s and 1980s of sociologists like Dean Hoge, Merton Strommen, or educators like Sara Little, Michael Warren, and Sharon Daloz Parks; or glean from the mounds of data harvested annually by Gallup and the Barna Group, the Higher Education Research Institute, or Search Institute; or learn from psychologists and sociologists like Robert Coles, Herschel and Ellen Thornburg, Jeffrey Arnett, Christian Smith, or Robert Wuthnow (the list goes on), much of the research on churches and adolescent faith formation confirms practitioners' suspicions.4 In fact, a quick scan of these studies reveals that, to a large extent, the questions that bothered us about youth ministry in the 1970s are very much like the questions that bother us today. Again and again, we question the depth of young people's spiritual engagement and wonder about the effectiveness of our ministries with them, the sustainability of youth ministry models, and the faithfulness of youth ministry's mission as a part of the church.

Haunting Questions in Youth Ministry

Does Youth Ministry Matter?

Do Our Practices of Youth Ministry Reflect Christ?

    Do existing "models and practices" reflect the church's best theological work?

Do they accomplish what we imagine?

Do they bear any relationship to the church?

Do Our Practices of Youth Ministry Shape Christians?

How Long Can We Keep This Up?

Can we do better?

Does Youth Ministry Matter?

She still had a few minutes before the staff meeting; Maria swerved into the gas station, jumped out of her car, and hit the unleaded button as she shoved the nozzle into her gas tank. As she straightened her back, she caught the eye of a teenage girl standing by the other pump. There was an awkward pause.

"Hey, Maria," the girl said quietly.

"Hi, Carmen," Maria smiled, thankful that the girl's name had suddenly resurfaced. It had been almost a year and a half since Maria had seen Carmen, and she tried not to stare. The shoulder-length black hair Maria remembered was now stained with bright red streaks. Carmen's shoulders were hunched, her clothes were baggy, and her eyes looked dead. A silver stud jabbed into her left eyebrow.

Two summers ago Carmen had accompanied Maria and a dozen other teenagers and adults from their church on a mission trip to Tijuana. On that trip, Carmen seemed to come alive. She jumped at the opportunity to share her experience during mass the Sunday after they returned, and movingly described the way the families they met in Tijuana had helped her see her life differently. Maria remembered that Sunday with pride; she loved seeing spiritual "light bulbs" go on over a teenager's head. Following the trip Carmen had been a regular at church, attending beach volleyball nights and a weekly teen prayer group. Then school started—and then, nothing. Carmen vanished into another world.

Yet here she was. It had only been two years since that summer, but Carmen looked five years older. They shared awkward, superficial chitchat until Maria heard the welcome "pop" of the gas pump indicating the tank was full. Relieved, Maria said goodbye and drove to the church, berating herself. "Why didn't I reach out to her more when I first noticed she stopped coming to mass? Should I have confronted her just now about where she's been?" and—most unsettling: "Was Carmen's experience of Christ on the mission trip real, or was it just some fleeting emotional experience?"

Anyone working in youth ministry knows the joy of new life, the anxiety of stunted growth, and the gut-wrenching disappointment of watching a young person walk away from faith. Sometimes the young people who walk away are the ones we love most; sometimes they are our own sons and daughters. Sometimes they are like Carmen, experiencing dramatic changes in their lives after leaving church. Sometimes they walk away from the congregation but not faith, and sometimes it is the other way around. Sometimes—and this is the most disturbing scenario—young people walk away from faith and the church and experience little discernible difference in their lives at all.

Does youth ministry make a lasting difference? Do our present practices invite young people to mature and lasting Christian faith?

Does youth ministry make a lasting difference? Do our present practices invite young people to mature and lasting Christian faith? Researchers have been raising questions about the effectiveness of youth ministries within the larger church context for at least the last thirty years. Of course, before we can ask whether youth ministry is effective, we have to define what effectiveness means. Early youth ministry research tended to focus on church attendance as a measure of youth ministry effectiveness. In 1975, sociologist Dean Hoge studied a cohort of twenty-five-year-old Presbyterians who had been baptized as infants and confirmed as teenagers. He found that, somewhere between adolescence and young adulthood, 75 percent of them had quit going to worship regularly (defined as attending at least once a month) and were not engaging in Christian activities.5 A year earlier, Christian educator Michael Warren had identified a similar pattern emerging in Catholic young people, estimating that "two-thirds of Catholic youth were not being reached in any significant way."6

Contemporary studies show similar patterns of participation across the U.S. While teenagers are 10 percent more likely to attend church than their parents, participation declines precipitously throughout adolescence.7 Younger adults are less involved in churches in the early twenty-first century than they were a generation ago; one survey found that 70 percent of 23- to 30-year-old Protestants who had attended church regularly as youth stopped attending regularly for at least a year between the ages of 18 and 22 (35 percent eventually returned).8 Catholic teenagers are especially likely to be unengaged in their parishes; according to the National Study of Youth and Religion, two-thirds of Catholic teens who attend churches that sponsor youth groups do not participate in them.9

With notable exceptions, the emphasis of most research on adolescent religiosity is less on what young people believe about God or how faith influences their self-understandings than on their level of religious engagement. Youth ministry "works," by these standards, when young people join and remain involved in a community of faith. Today, teenagers are less likely than in previous generations to equate church participation with faith in God; most American young people, even the ones who leave church or have never attended a church, say that religion is a good thing, and that they believe in God and pray regularly (especially when they are in need or crisis).10 The question that lurks behind the religious formation of these young people is not whether they believe in God (almost all of them do),11 but whether believing in God matters—a question that requires us to go beyond church participation alone to assess youth ministry's effectiveness.

Do Our Practices of Youth Ministry Reflect Christ?

Greg sank deeper and deeper into the pew. For months he had lobbied the Christian education council to cancel Sunday school once a month so teenagers could attend Sunday morning worship. The youth Sunday school class ran concurrently with the Sunday morning worship service—much to the disappointment of the youth leaders. Greg shared their disappointment. As the associate pastor for discipleship, Greg envisioned a worship service with young and old singing side by side, with the sermon addressing younger congregants, and with teenagers leading and participating in worship alongside adults.

The council granted Greg's request, sort of. This was the first Sunday of the month and someone posted a large sign on the door of the youth room: No Sunday School—Go to Worship. Greg had seen some of the upperclassmen roll their eyes and slip out a side door, no doubt in search of a pancake house. The rest of the teenagers had trudged their way to the sanctuary and plopped down in the pew next to Greg.

Now, halfway through the worship service, Greg already regretted his request. The singing was listless. The pastor's sermon was painfully dull. No one in leadership seemed to notice that young people existed, much less were in the room. "This is where I want youth on a Sunday morning?" he wondered. He began to fear that his efforts to build strong ties between the larger church body and the teenagers would only turn them off more. And, truth be told, he didn't blame them. As the congregation droned through the third hymn, Greg wished he had joined the students looking for pancakes.

This wasn't the first time Greg had raised questions about the relationship between youth ministry and the larger church. He had often wondered how he could cast vision for youth ministry to those who saw youth ministers as glorified babysitters. He wondered how to respond to the adults who seemed uncomfortable around the few students whose faith had caught fire in the past year, and who were walking around with a newfound God-vocabulary. Bottom line, Greg wasn't so sure that the church he knew was the best conduit for spiritual transformation. By the early twenty-first century, questions like Greg's began to haunt people in youth ministry.

Do existing "models and practices" of youth ministry reflect the church's best theological work? Are we helping young people become part of the larger body of Christ?

Do existing "models and practices" of youth ministry reflect the church's best theological work? Are we helping young people become part of the larger body of Christ or involving them in one more glorified extracurricular activity? Christian identity, by definition, involves immersion in a faith community, but using youth ministry as a defensive measure to stave off church membership losses is practically and theologically problematic. Instrumental approaches to youth ministry—in other words, pastoral relationships that have other, unstated purposes (like getting youth to come to youth group or worship)—represent a distorted view of the Incarnation. Jesus did not call people to come to church; he called them to change and share their lives, to repent, be baptized, take up their crosses and follow him. By the early twenty-first century, the purpose of youth ministry was beginning to be called into question, and with it came questions about youth ministry's status as ministry. Does the church's ministry with young people cultivate disciples of Jesus Christ who seek justice, love kindness, and walk humbly with God (Micah 6:8)? Or does it cultivate interpersonal niceness, social acceptability, civic engagement, and— as a primary goal—church membership?

The available data both affirms teenagers' belief in God and challenges that belief's ultimate significance for their lives. Three out of five American teenagers say they regularly attend church (including youth ministry and Christian education programs), but longitudinal research is inconsistent about the influence of adolescent religious training on faith during early adulthood.12 An Evangelical Lutheran Church in America study found that only about one-third of Lutheran young adults aged 21 to 29 attended worship or engaged in ministry.13 Sociologist Tim Clydesdale finds this pattern among college freshmen in particular. According to Clydesdale, four out of five college freshmen stow their religious self-understandings in "identity lock-boxes" once they enter college, effectively putting their religious identities under wraps—and on hold—indefinitely.14 Meanwhile, pollster George Barna sees evidence that people who attend church as teenagers are more likely, as adults, to say that religious faith is very important to them. At the same time, says Barna, "most teenagers who have spent years attending church activities [have not integrated] their faith . . . into who they are and how they live."15 Tactfully, sociologist Christian Smith writes that "most teens seem simply to accept religion as taken-for-granted, mostly operating in the background of their lives."16 Jeffery Arnett is more pointed, observing the faith during the "twenty-something" years bears surprisingly little connection to childhood religious training.17

Take a moment for that to sink in.

Decades of research that identifies parents as the primary influences on adolescent faith (not to mention Proverbs 22:6: "Train children in the right way, and when old, they will not stray") call Arnett to closer scrutiny; he seems perplexed by the findings himself.18 Longitudinal research from the National Study of Youth and Religion also indicates a profound role for religious adults—if not for religious youth programs—in faith that survives emerging adulthood.19 Yet youth ministers hear in Arnett's observation a faint ring of truth that boils down to this: youth ministry may not be as adept at forming the disciples as we once thought. David Kinnaman, president of the Barna Group, argues for an "overhaul" of American youth ministry that makes faith sustainability the criterion for youth ministry effectiveness, "not because churches fail to attract significant numbers of young people, but because so much of those efforts are not creating a sustainable faith beyond high school."

There are certainly effective youth ministries across the country, but the levels of disengagement among twentysomethings suggest that youth ministry fails too often at discipleship and faith formation. A new standard for viable youth ministry should be—not the number of "attenders," the sophistication of the events, or the "cool" factor of the youth group—but whether teens have the commitment, passion and resources to pursue Christ intentionally and wholeheartedly after they leave the youth ministry nest.20

These are strong words and Kinnaman is not alone in his assessment. Practical theologian Andrew Root tackles the most sacred cow in ministry with young people—relationships between adult youth workers and teenagers—and demands that we examine their motivations and outcomes. Root believes that youth ministry often bends interpersonal relationships with teenagers into vehicles of personal influence with the "unquestioned objective of conversion."21 Root calls the church to stop using relationships in youth ministry as commodities: "The incarnation is not about influence but accompaniment. It is not about getting us right but bearing what is wrong with us, so that we might find that we are only right in the embrace of a God who loves so much to be with us!"22

Do Our Practices of Youth Ministry Shape Christians?

Stephanie described herself as an "A" student and a lifelong Presbyterian who had "come to everything" at her church since she was a baby. Sitting across the table from me at TGI Friday's, she happily chatted about her experience in a congregation not far from where I teach.

I was interviewing Stephanie for a research project, hoping to find out what she believed, how she practiced her faith, how her faith influenced her daily life. Stephanie was in the middle of explaining how much she loved her church youth group, and how close she felt to the youth pastor, who had been a guiding force in her life.

In what way? I asked her.

Oh, in so many ways, she sighed, smiling at the memories. All-night games of sardines in the church. Pranks that involved climbing around on the roof by the church steeple at night, led by the youth pastor. She appreciated the latenight conversations she had with the youth pastor, alone in the church sanctuary, and she admired his decision to ignore drinking at a recent retreat. She loved his ability to "act like a teenager himself" and "have fun" with the kids.

I did a quick mental scan of my students, hoping that Stephanie's youth pastor was not one of them.

"Let's talk about what you believe," I suggested, moving down the interview form. "You said you are a Christian and that you've been involved in this church your whole life. So what would you say makes you a Christian?"

Stephanie looked confused. The chatty Stephanie disappeared and a blank look overtook her.

I pressed: "What do you do, or what do you think about God, that makes you a Christian instead of something else?" Pause. "Does being a Christian make you think about God differently than some of your friends?"

"I guess so."

"Okay, tell me about that. What do you think about God?"

"Um."

"What about Jesus?" I ventured.

"Like, what do you mean?"

"Like, how would you describe Jesus? Does Jesus matter?"

"Not really."

"Okay," I said, trying to think of another way in. "So . . . what about being a Christian is important to you?"

She brightened up a little. "Well, it makes you nicer. I like being active in church—stuff like that."

And so it went. Is there any difference between the way you live your life and the way your non-Christian friends live their lives? (No, everyone is the same.) So why are you a Christian? (It's how I was raised.) Anything else? (No.) But being a Christian is important to you? (Absolutely.) Why? (My youth pastor is awesome.)

I wondered how a young person like Stephanie, raised and active in a Christian congregation, could have so little to say about being a Christian. I could not shake the sense that church was an important activity in Stephanie's life, but not one that pointed her beyond herself. While her congregation's youth ministry clearly had important social and perhaps developmental benefits for Stephanie, memories of Christian teaching seemed curiously—and disturbingly—absent.23

Recent research has posed yet another set of questions to churches: Do our current practices of youth ministry help young people understand themselves as Christians? Are we passing on adequate understandings of God, the church, and the world?

Recent research has posed yet another set of questions to churches: Do our current practices of youth ministry help young people understand themselves as Christians? Are we passing on adequate understandings of God, the church, and the world? After interviewing more than three thousand 13- to 17-yearolds in the U.S., the National Study of Youth and Religion makes a powerful case that the answer to both of these questions is "no." Faith is a low-impact exercise for most American teenagers, even when they are active in their churches. Christian Smith, the study's principal investigator, dubbed the de facto religion practiced by contemporary American teenagers as "moralistic therapeutic deism." Smith and his colleagues believe that moralistic therapeutic deism has colonized American churches, supplanting Christianity, and that it now constitutes the dominant religion in the United States.24 Despite the fact that three out of four teenagers claim to be Christians, the NSYR found that most young people describe their core religious values like this:

Moralistic Therapeutic Deism

1. A God exists who created and orders the world and watches over human life on earth.

2. God wants people to be good, nice, and fair to each other, as taught in the Bible and by most world religions.

3. The central goal of life is to be happy and to feel good about oneself.

4. God does not need to be particularly involved in one's life except when God is needed to resolve a problem.

5. Good people go to heaven when they die.25

Like David Kinnaman, Smith and Denton found that most Christian young people do not seem to know much about Christianity, possess little in the way of a theological vocabulary or knowledge of the Bible, and have few tools to help them think about and process life from a Christian viewpoint. By and large they consider religion "a very nice thing," potentially useful but not something they personally need. The National Study of Youth and Religion found little in the way of teen rebellion against religion (on the contrary, young people seemed positive but remarkably complacent about religion, mostly because it mattered very little to them). As Smith and Denton put it, "The problem facing most churches is not teen rebellion, but teenagers' 'benign whatever-ism.' "26

Smith and Denton are not the first to suggest that youth, and churches themselves, are in the grips of something like moralistic therapeutic deism.27 Since the 1980s educators like Michael Warren have focused their research on the ways in which culture, education, and young people interact—a project that has led Warren to unmask consumerism's voracious appetite for converts among young people. As a Catholic educator, Warren's goal is to raise young people's awareness of the processes of consumerism, creating space for critical reflection that helps them recognize how the marketplace vies for their souls. Concerned that churches are not making enough of an effort to resist consumer culture, therefore allowing young people and youth ministry itself to be coopted by the marketplace, he writes:

If popular culture is in our time an enormous picture window showing people even more fantastic views of what life is all about, then maybe education becomes a kind of tiny peephole not accessible to very many and at which one has to strain to see anything. . . . The magic window is so automatic and easy; the peephole requires more effort.28

Warren worries that the power of youth ministry's explicit curriculum pales in comparison to the power of the curriculum of the lived experience of young people.29 Foreshadowing the "moralistic therapeutic deism" that Smith and Denton would name twenty years later, Warren wrote that—Christian or not—the "real curriculum" in the lives of both youth and their adult leaders makes an idol of "warmth" and interpersonal closeness, and that these core values become the "shaping metaphor" for their lives. He quotes sociologist Richard Sennett:

The reigning belief today is that closeness between persons is a moral good. The reigning aspiration today is to develop individual personality through experiences of closeness and warmth with others. The reigning myth today is that the evils of society can all be understood as the evils of impersonality, alienation, and coldness. The sum of these three is an ideology of intimacy; social relationships of all kinds are real, believable, and authentic the closer they approach the inner psychological concerns of each person. This ideology of intimacy defines the humanitarian spirit of a society without gods; warmth is our god.30

Whether the surrogate spirituality is interpersonal warmth or moralistic therapeutic deism, the problem points back to the church's failure to offer the gospel—the story of God as it has been handed down to us in Christian texts and traditions—as a compelling (not to mention transformative) alternative to the creeds of the dominant culture.31

How Long Can We Keep This Up?

Adam felt his blood pressure rise as he drove past New Life Community Church, behind the university athletic complex just three blocks from campus.32 The church had been around for less than five years and already was making an impact on the university community. The praise service on Thursday nights was bursting at the seams, and was already a popular venue for informal preaching and young adult musical talent. New Life's spring break mission trips had more takers than they could handle, and were intentionally linked to university courses that addressed the trips' cultural contexts.

Adam thought about the small group of college students who came to his Bible study at University Church on Sunday mornings. Compared to the hordes in New Life's raked sanctuary, the University Church group looked small and lost in the 1960s multipurpose room where they met.

"I could have big numbers if I ran a circus too," Adam muttered as he pulled into the church parking lot. He was immediately ashamed of his judgmental spirit towards the "rival" college ministry. Anyway, he was too busy to be petty; as University Church's pastor to youth and families, his plate was already full. He had high school leaders to mentor, parents to placate, a Lenten retreat to plan. And now he had a college group to build.

When University Church launched a student outreach program last fall, the chance to reestablish a thriving denominational presence on a state university campus had excited Adam. He adapted to the rhythms of the semester, made himself available during "student hours," organized Bible studies and service opportunities to help students discern God's movement in the world. It was rewarding but wearying work. Next on tap was a discussion group for graduate students at a local pub—though Adam was already dreading the idea of yet another night away from home.

Early on Adam had decided not to sugarcoat the gospel in order to attract students. No Bible-lite. No insulting youth group games involving cotton balls and two-liter bottles of soda. At a state university, he wanted to give students a place to celebrate their theological tradition, though he understood that God was calling him to service, not results. If God chose to bless University Church's college ministry with large numbers, great—but if not, Adam vowed to faithfully tend the flock that showed up. Of course, a larger budget and some committed volunteers would help.

But perhaps he had been naïve. If God was really behind this ministry, more students would be involved, right? "Should I get a wireless connection? A big screen and a gaming system? Maybe a more exotic mission trip?" He wondered if he was selling out.

"What do you want from me, God?" Adam prayed. "Just tell me and I'll do it. I'll gladly do it. I just don't know." One thing Adam did know, however: he couldn't keep up his current pace much longer. "Have you really called me to this, Lord?" he asked. "Because at this rate I don't see how I can devote the next few years to ministry—much less the rest of my life."

Maybe it was time to move on.

Is our current practice of youth ministry sustainable? Does our understanding of our vocation rest on valid assumptions?

Some questions gnaw at us in youth ministry because deep down we already know the answers. To respond to these questions requires courage more than scholarship—questions like, Is our current practice of youth ministry sustainable? Does our understanding of our vocation rest on valid assumptions? In the Study of Protestant Youth Ministers in America (2000), Merton Strommen, Karen Jones, and Dave Rahn asked 2,130 full-time youth ministers what they found most encouraging and discouraging in their experience of youth ministry. These pastors identified six experiences that had caused them to seriously consider leaving youth ministry:

1. Feeling a sense of personal inadequacy

2. Experiencing strained family relations

3. Sensing a growing loss of confidence

4. Feeling unqualified for the job

5. Feeling personally disorganized

6. Experiencing burnout.33

To address these issues requires more than better self-care. Strommen's team made the unsurprising observation: "Youth ministry is very difficult work, far more difficult than parents and congregational leaders realize. The pressures on a youth minister are enormous, and these pressures are ones for which few have been adequately prepared."34 Some studies indicate that mastery of a field requires ten years of experience in that field, or 10,000 hours of practice. Pastoral proficiency in youth ministry (i.e., becoming skillful at communicating faith, navigating relationships with youth and parents, working productively within congregational systems, etc.) is no different. Yet youth ministers stay in a church, on average, 3.9 years—which creates an obvious problem: few youth ministers stay in their positions long enough to become effective in them.35

By the end of the 1990s, youth ministers themselves sensed the need to change some of their basic assumptions about ministry, even if churches failed to follow suit. Youth ministry literature began to use evocative phrases like "soul-shaping," "contemplative," "Godbearing," "presence-centered," "emerging," and above all, "authentic" to emphasize God's transformative presence in the practice of youth ministry, instead of focusing on programs aimed at making church more fun.36 Three recurring conversations pushed youth ministry toward a broader sense of purpose, suggesting that youth ministry had as much to offer the church as vice versa. These conversations included:

1. The "practices" discussion. A prominent stream of literature encouraged churches to reroute youth ministry (and ministry generally) through Christian "practices"—in other words, to involve young people in the historic actions of the Christian community, such as prayer, biblical interpretation, hospitality, justice-making, and Christian fellowship, to name a few.37 By borrowing faith practices that have helped centuries of believers encounter God and participate in the self-giving love of Christ, many youth pastors hoped to develop more sustainable, theologically nourishing ways to work with adolescents that would prove life-giving for leaders as well.

2. Theological dialogue. Equally important, a new standard for evaluating youth ministry began to challenge unthinking pragmatism: theological intentionality. Reframing youth ministry as a context for divine transformation changed the terms for "effective" youth ministry (this "theological turn" in youth ministry, as Andrew Root calls it, will be explored in chapter 3). Participation was no longer sufficient as a standard for assessing effective faith formation. Youth ministers recognized that some popular approaches to youth ministry actually undermined the faith that was youth ministry's goal. Theological integrity became an overt standard for ministry with young people, on the assumption that the church's practices, relationships, and methodologies for ministry with teenagers must conform to Christ—even if to do so leads to (hopefully metaphorical) crucifixion and new life.

3. Dialogue with systems. Veteran youth pastor and systems consultant Mark DeVries believes that theological integrity and organizational savvy need not serve as opposing poles in sustainable youth ministries. Christ-like patterns of self-giving love can (and must) be translated through congregational systems. When we do so, "sustainable" youth ministry becomes part of a congregation's organizational DNA. DeVries insists that congregations, not gifted youth pastors, are the key to youth ministry effectiveness and sustainability—and in fact, they make theologically intentional ministry possible. As a youth ministry consultant who is deeply indebted to systems analysis, DeVries' work has led him to conclude that most churches struggle in youth ministry for one of two reasons: (1) a congregation invests too little in youth ministry, compromising theological intentionality with a "survival" mentality (e.g., one youth leader for forty kids; a program calendar too full for the number of volunteers who support it; salary levels that implicitly suggest the job of youth director is a short-term position, etc.); or (2) a congregation invests its resources in the wrong things (i.e., new buildings, a "star" youth pastor, the latest program)—things that cannot bequeath life-giving practices of faith, bring teenagers more fully into the Christian community, or engage them in ministries of self-giving love. The solution is for congregations to invest in youth ministry's infrastructure: clarifying the mission and vision of ministry with young people, shoring up volunteers, budgets, and staff relationships, developing sinews between pastors, parents, and volunteers, and so on. Congregations that do this consistently and predictably see "delightful and dramatic" returns on their investments.38

Congregations that wholeheartedly invest in youth ministry's infrastructure consistently and predictably see "delightful and dramatic" returns on their investments.—Mark DeVries39

Can We Do Better?

Youth ministers, adult youth workers, and pastors are moving beyond youth ministry "lore" into more theologically intentional and more empirically viable understandings of God, the church, and vocation that profoundly shape young people's lives, not to mention the future of youth ministry itself. The questions that haunt us in youth ministry are more indicative of growing pains than impotence. By now it is utterly clear that youth ministry is more than a defensive strategy to "get young people in church"—or (let's be honest) to keep the few we have from leaving. We know that Christ calls us to be both faithful and effective in ministry with young people, which means preparing young people to recognize that Christ has written them into God's story of redemption in which suffering leads to joy. The haunting questions that open this chapter remind us that there is work to be done in leading young people into lifelong commitments, practices, and communities of faith. But the promise of the gospel is that God will be faithful to complete the good work that Christ has already begun in us (Phil. 1:6).

In spite of colossal frustrations, youth ministers are a hopeful breed—a trait noticed even by social scientists. Karen Jones's research reveals that youth ministers are older and staying longer than they did a generation ago; compared to youth ministers of the last century, twenty-first-century youth ministers are more likely to "believe that they are called to youth ministry as a vocation, not a stepping-stone profession."40 Christian Smith points out, "There is a national discussion now going on across denominations about rethinking the standard model of youth ministry and youth programming. While this beginning conversation doesn't guarantee solutions it is at least a beginning and that is hopeful. Constructive changes seem to be in the works."41

"There is a national discussion now going on across denominations about rethinking the standard model of youth ministry and youth programming. While this beginning conversation doesn't guarantee solutions it is at least a beginning and that is hopeful. Constructive changes seem to be in the works."—Christian Smith

While the moniker "youth ministry" grows increasingly limiting (an issue we will return to later), the scope of the church's work with young people has never been broader. Youth ministers no longer serve congregations primarily by herding teenagers into youth groups for their protection and entertainment; rather, we shape and mobilize overlapping communities—families, peers, congregations, small groups, and so forth—that all serve as communities of formation in the service of faith and identity. In the twenty-first-century church, youth ministers must become ecologists more than specialists, orchestra conductors more than the congregation's wind or percussion section, leaders who can deftly weave together multiple constituencies for the benefit of young people and the glory of God.

If the research behind youth ministry's "haunting questions" teaches us anything, it is that adolescent faith grows best in a web of support. Vital Christian faith does not survive long on its own, least of all in teenagers. Although we have assumed that "effective" youth ministry depends on our skill as youth leaders, the truth is that young people's faith never depends on us. Their faith, like our faith, depends upon Christ, and Christ alone. We take our places as gardeners who tend the soil of the adolescent soul until the Word of God takes root there, strengthening them for the daunting challenges that lie ahead.

Further Reading on Themes in This Chapter

Baker, Dori Grinenko, and Joyce Ann Mercer. Lives to Offer: Accompanying Youth on Their Vocational Quests. Cleveland: Pilgrim Press, 2007.

Benson, Peter L., ed., et al.. Spiritual Development: New Directions for Youth Development. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2008.

Dean, Kenda Creasy. Almost Christian: What the Faith of Our Teenagers Is Telling the American Church. New York: Oxford University Press, 2010.

DeVries, Mark. Sustainable Youth Ministry. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2008. Fields, Doug. Purpose Driven Youth Ministry. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1998.

Kinnaman, David, and Gabe Lyons. UnChristian: What a New Generation Really Thinks about Christianity . . . and Why It Matters. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2007.

Mahan, Brian, Michael Warren, and David White. Awakening Youth Discipleship. Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2007.

Moore, Mary Elizabeth and Almeda Wright, eds. Children, Youth and Spirituality in a Troubling World. St. Louis: Chalice Press, 2008.

Root, Andrew. Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2007.

Smith, Christian, with Melinda Lundquist Denton. Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.

Yaconelli, Mike. The Core Realities of Youth Ministry. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2003.

The "Classics" Library

Coles, Robert. The Spiritual Lives of Children. Boston: Mariner, 1991.

Erikson, Erik H. Identity, Youth and Crisis. New York: W. W. Norton, 1968.

Harris, Maria. Portrait of Youth Ministry. New York: Paulist Press, 1981.

Little, Sara. Youth, World and Church. Richmond, VA: John Knox Press, 1968.

Martinson, Roland. Effective Youth Ministry: A Congregational Approach. Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 1988.

Morrison, John A. The Educational Philosophy of St. John Bosco. Los Angeles: Salesian Press, 1979.

Ng, David. Youth in the Community of Disciples. Valley Forge, PA: Judson Press, 1984.

Robbins, Duffy. The Ministry of Nurture. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1990.

Strommen, Merton. Five Cries of Youth. New York: Harper & Row, 1979.

Warren, Michael. Youth, Gospel, Liberation. San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1987.

Thanks to Amanda Drury and Ryan Timpte for their research and editorial assistance on this chapter.

↑ Back to top

↑