Chapter 8 of 14

Chapter Five

Chapter Five

CHAPTER FIVE

EMERGING COMPETENCIES

Let no one despise your youth, but set the believers an example in speech and conduct, in love, in faith, in purity. Until I arrive, give attention to the public reading of scripture, to exhorting, to teaching. Do not neglect the gift that is in you, which was given to you through prophecy with the laying on of hands by the council of elders. Put these things into practice, devote yourself to them, so that all may see your progress. Pay close attention to yourself and to your teaching; continue in these things, for in doing this you will save both yourself and your hearers.

—1 Timothy 4:12-16

I know God will not give me anything I can't handle. I just wish that He didn't

trust me so much.—Mother Teresa

Growing up as a pastor's kid (that's right, I Rodger am living proof that you can grow up as a pastor's kid and still love Jesus), I remember waking up in my elementary school years and going downstairs in the early morning hours. There in the living room sitting by a solitary lamp was my Dad, reading his Bible. It is one of my earliest and most abiding memories. I remember him greeting me as I made my way to the kitchen to get a bowl of cereal with my mother and other brothers. Every morning without fail, Dad would read his Bible. On those early weekday mornings before going off to school, I do not remember Dad ever telling me that he was reading the Bible. I do not remember Dad ever stopping to point out what he was reading or sharing some new insight or question from Scripture. Certainly there were other times when he would share those things with us either in church from the pulpit or even during times of family devotions. As an adolescent, I came to dread those family devotion times; but now, in my adulthood, I realize that through all those moments, Dad was teaching an important truth. I learned that my father loved the Bible—and that he would never be finished reading it or studying it or loving it.

The Apostle Paul's words to his young friend Timothy ring true. As leaders in ministry, we are to set an example for others through our speaking and, perhaps even more important for youth ministry leaders, in our doing. Paul urges Timothy and all who are called to lead in any form of ministry to live in such a way, reading Scripture, exhorting or admonishing or encouraging others, and teaching so that others see our progress.1 This is one of the reasons ministry with young people is as wonderful as it is precarious. Young people are in a tenacious search for relationships that are worthy of their trust. In my experience, this worthiness comes when they encounter persons whose words consistently match their actions. Parker Palmer calls this "living lives of wholeness . . . of integrity."2

Setting the Believers an Example (or Not)

Several years ago I was invited to speak to a gathering of young people from congregations in the San Francisco Bay area. It was a gray, rainy Sunday afternoon and nearly four hundred youth and adults were crowded into a church gym. I remember the room smelled like wet teenagers. One of the local youth pastors was leading the crowd in a series of group-building activities. The place was too small for the group and the sound system was inadequate. The pastor shouted into the microphone trying to be heard over the noise. His instructions were convoluted, and we were all trying to understand what he wanted us to do and cooperate. Eventually we clustered up in circles of fifteen or so and tried to hear each other's names and churches. Then the pastor called out some objects that we were to try to find within our own group (a cell phone, an iPod, car keys, and so on—he must have expected a wealthy group). If we had them, we were to send a runner to him as quickly as possible. My group was one of those on the farthest edge of the gym; we could barely hear him, much less get to where he stood. Eventually, we gave up and just started telling more about ourselves and trying to get to know one another.

Finally, the pastor rearranged the groups, sending us to the four corners of the gym. He told us to run to the opposite corner as fast as possible when he called "Go!" You have to picture this. So here we are, with about one hundred youth and adults shoved into each of the four corners of the gym, trying simultaneously to get to the opposite corner when he says so. Some of the bigger guys took this as a challenge and ran like offensive linemen through the crowd. Some of the smaller and younger kids were nearly trampled. The wiser ones just avoided the mayhem in the middle and skirted the edges. After doing this a couple of times, the pastor had us all sit down. He asked us to tell him why it was great to be a youth pastor. Some kids did not understand that the question was rhetorical and tried to answer. He ignored them and answered his own question: "Because you get to make people do stupid stuff like you just did, instead of having to do it yourself!" And then he laughed. The group started booing him. I have to confess: I joined them. The pastor did not get it. He needed to read Paul's letter to Timothy.

The call to youth ministry is the call to set an example not just by our words but also by our lives. The call to youth ministry is to lead with integrity so that our words are commensurate with our actions. The word integrity means unbroken, uncompromised, whole. People with integrity lead undivided lives: their hearts and their minds and their bodies and their wills are united. They live comfortably in their own skins, which allows them to be completely present to people who are less comfortable in theirs. Their leadership flows organically from who they are and is not easily reducible to what they do. They lead exactly as they are, and that is enough.

The call to youth ministry is the call to set an example not just by your words but also by your life—and not just for young people, but for all people.

According to Paul, what is the result of practicing and devoting ourselves to leadership with integrity? People see how we progress and grow. Paul reminds Timothy (and all of us who are leaders, young and old alike) that when we live integrated, faithful lives, we grow and others see the Holy Spirit growing in us. The young people we work with see it, the parents we haven't had time to meet see it, our colleagues in ministry see it—even our own children see it on their way to breakfast before school in the morning.

Leading with Integrity: Still Learning

I teach at a seminary and I love what I do. I feel tremendously privileged to journey with these women and men through their years of study as they reflect upon and engage in various expressions of ministry even as they prepare for a further call to ministry. I enjoy the fact that school has a clear starting point (the beginning of each school year in the late summer) and an ending point (the end of the academic year in the late spring). This kind of rhythm fits my soul.

But here's the problem: graduation. The great majority of our students, when they finish their work, are conferred the Master of Divinity degree. Even on our best days that is an audacious claim—Master of the Divine. And some of them, I can tell, actually believe it. They're the ones who make me the most nervous. If I had my way, as soon as they receive that parchment with their name and the degree with the gold seal on it, I would be standing there to scribble something like "in process" or "by the grace of God" or better yet "as if!" on the edge of their diplomas. That seems to be what Michelangelo had in mind when, in his eighty-seventh year, this Italian Renaissance painter, sculptor, architect, poet, and engineer is said to have written the words ancora imparo in the margins of one of the sketches.3 Ancora imparo is Italian for: "And still, I am learning."

This chapter proposes the rather simple thesis that leaders called to youth ministry must echo Michelangelo's words: we are still learning. There is never a point in ministry when we have arrived and can sit back contented and sated. To respond to God's call to lead is to engage in the lifelong task of exploring new contexts for youth ministry and the new questions and skills that accompany them. We have spent a great deal of time on questions, challenges, underlying themes, and hopeful possibilities that await us in ministry with young people. What follows is a discussion of some of the emerging competencies that will help us lead in these circumstances—capacities the church needs in those who seek to be faithful in ministry with young people, especially for the church and culture of the early twenty-first century. These discussions are brief and, to be sure, far from complete, but hopefully they offer a glimpse of what it means to speak and live out Michelangelo's affirmation that, no matter what our age, we are all learning still.

Emerging Competencies in Youth Ministry

Setting the Believers an Example (or Not)

Leading with Integrity: Still Learning

  • Searching the Scriptures: Transformation in Bible Study
  • Inviting Wholeness: Identity and Integrity in Teaching
  • Stilling the Soul: The Practice of Presence
  • Soul Doctors: Nurturing Hope amidst Suffering
  • Spectators No More: Creating Church versus Consuming It
  • Choosing Life: Discerning Vocation with Young People
  • Benedict of Nursia, Youth Guy

    Searching the Scriptures: Expecting Transformation in Bible Study

    I was sitting in the back of a large auditorium filled with more than a thousand high school young people. It was the last day of a week-long summer conference and there were two young women on the platform presenting an impromptu skit encouraging the group to attend next year's conference. The skit was cleverly done. They were "texting" each other. Behind each one was a screen that displayed their texts and two voices were also reading out loud the words they were sending to one another. One of the young women was trying to convince the other to come to the conference.

    "It will be fun," she wrote to the other.

    "Well, what do you do?" asked her friend.

    "It's totally cool. There are lots of fun things to do and cute guys. You'll like it," she assured her.

    "But I've never been to a Christian camp before," her friend wrote back. "I mean I don't even own a Bible. Do I have to bring a Bible?"

    Quickly her friend replied: "A Bible? No! This is a Presbyterian church camp. We don't use the Bible!"

    I remember the auditorium broke out into laughter and applause. I didn't think it was that funny. Sadly, Christians tend to approach the Bible in one of two ways. Some churches are literally stuck in the Bible. Young people in these churches are unable to move and sometimes barely able to breathe, as if the Word of God were wet concrete, something we step into and never move again.Not surprisingly, the only way to get out of this kind of theological suffocation is to break out a jackhammer, which makes for a noisy, destructive escape with lots of shrapnel. Other churches act as though they can live without the Bible, reducing it to a quaint relic, abandoning it as a source of God's revelation and as a guide to holiness. Young people in these churches think of the Bible as philosophically interesting but certainly not authoritative, and certainly not for them.

    Nothing could be further from the truth. From the days of the early church, Christians have understood Scripture as a place God meets us—not as a historical figure or a philosophical muse, but as the living, saving God in Jesus Christ, who is active in the world. Reading Scripture is an activity of cosmic significance. The Holy Spirit bursts into our lives, kneading our souls, turning our soil so we will be receptive to the Word of God that falls on us. When that happens, the Holy Spirit kicks into high gear, helping us understand God's meaning. Luther taught that the Word of God was unintelligible unless the Holy Spirit showed up to illuminate it.4 As we mentioned in Chapter 4, Luther, Wesley, and many other reformers understood Scripture sacramentally, as a "means of grace" that ushered God's salvation into the world. For Wesley, the Spirit was active and present whenever God's Word was read, "making alive the truth that is already in the text of Scripture" so that the hearer could apply it.5

    Reading Scripture is an activity of cosmic significance.

    Somewhere in their bones, adolescents already know that if Scripture is to bear witness to God, then reading the Bible must be an opportunity for divine encounter and not just a text. What young people need and seek in the Bible— and what we need and seek in the Bible—is not the Bible, but God. Barbara Brown Taylor remembers responding to her congregation's desire for a Bible study by offering a series conducted by local seminary professors. Despite the high-powered leadership, attendance was lousy. "Finally," she says, "I got the message. 'Bible' was a code word for 'God.' People were not hungry for information about the Bible; they were hungry for an experience of God, which the Bible seemed to offer them."6

    Young people are not dying for Bible studies, but they are dying for God, and approaching Bible study as transformation prepares them for this holy encounter. Throughout our history, Christians have claimed that the Bible is the power of God. We have confessed the Bible as central to our life and our mission. We are to know its stories. We seek to hear its words of comfort and challenge and wisdom. We wrestle with its claim upon our lives as the Bible forms our very identity as God's people. In its pages we struggle to hear not just about God, but from God. So we must wonder, how is it possible that we have understood the Bible as rigid? How is it possible that we have conveyed the message that the Bible is optional?

    Old Testament scholar John M. Bracke and Christian educator Karen B. Tye remind us that the goal of teaching the Bible is transformation rather than just information.7 When we teach the Bible for information, as little more than a series of ancient stories, for instance, we fail to realize that we are actually in these narratives and that these stories are not disengaged from our own experience. At the same time, without denying that facts and information are important, Bracke and Tye argue that "Bible study" as we usually approach it simply ends there, as we wrongly assume that when you know the information in the story, you somehow have taken the text and made it part of your own identity, part of your own story. No wonder, in an information age in which young people have become numb to moment-by-moment bombardment of facts and figures, the Bible becomes one more thing to take in momentarily and then discard.

    Transformational Bible study, on the other hand, borrows the insight of the church fathers and mothers and the reformers alike that the Holy Spirit is present in every reading and experiencing of the holy narrative. Because this is true, we must approach Scripture with humility, anticipating that somehow we are about to be confronted with the Maker of the Universe who is drawing us in and changing us in ways beyond our imagining. For North American Christians, this posture of humility presents a particular challenge. Ethicist Stanley Hauerwas writes:

    No task is more important than for the Church to take the Bible out of the hands of individual Christians in North America. North American Christians are trained to believe that they are capable of reading the Bible without spiritual and moral transformation. They read the Bible not as Christians, not as a people set apart, but as democratic citizens who think their common sense is sufficient for the understanding of scripture.8

    Hauerwas has it right. We usually read Scripture to "get something out of it" by our own means and through our own understanding. We do this because we have been trained to think this way—to rely, as Hauerwas writes, on our own "common sense." We do not approach Scripture with humility, as a source of wonder and mystery. As a reminder of the correct posture for Scripture reading, one youth group I know does every Bible study barefoot. Before the reading of Scripture begins, the youth leader asks people to take off their shoes and sandals, as Moses was instructed to do in Exodus 3 when he encountered Yahweh in the wilderness through a burning bush. "It's a tangible reminder," the youth leader explained to me, "that when we read the Bible, we are doing something that is special for our community. This is not just another activity. We anticipate being changed and called out just as Moses was changed and called out by God."

    Before youth ministry can contribute to the mission of the twenty-first century church—before discipleship formation is possible—young people must recognize that the power of the Word of God is placed in their hands through Scripture.

    Before youth ministry can contribute to the mission of the twenty-first century church—before discipleship formation is possible—young people must recognize that the power of the Word of God is placed in their hands through Scripture. Bible study, therefore, has explosive potential. Leaders in youth ministry must embody not only an anticipation of being transformed as they read Scripture, they must also embody a love for and a competence about it. When young people know we regularly and faithfully take time to read Scripture, we are doing precisely what Paul encouraged Timothy to do—to lead by example. When we share our excitement for what the Holy Spirit is teaching us in our own study of Scripture, we show young people what it is like to take the narrative into one's own being. Increasingly we are learning that this kind of teaching has less to do with pedagogical technique than with the person of the teacher, which leads to our next emerging competency.

    Inviting Wholeness: Identity and Integrity in Teaching

    In the early years of youth ministry education, youth ministry literature focused on "right method." The objective of youth ministry resources was to offer formative techniques and educational strategies for the classroom or the youth room. This philosophy convinced us, for a time, that if we had the right program or used the right activity, young people would come and would "get Jesus." What happened as a result (and we should have seen this coming) was a dangerous emphasis on education—and indeed ministry—as entertainment, which led to a bizarre escalation of ever more outlandish and frenetic techniques. Churches, trying to compete with schools, civic organizations, and one another for adolescents' increasingly limited time and attention, found themselves doing everything from renting inflatable carnival rides to raising thousands of dollars for trips to exotic locales, convinced that these experiences would help their young people know what it means to be a disciple of Jesus. What happened? Pretty much the opposite. Teenagers learned two things exceedingly well: that youth ministry can be fun, and that the church is no different from any other group begging for their time and energy.

    I am not saying fun is irrelevant to good youth ministry leadership. There is a proper and crucial role for play in youth ministry. But twenty-first-century youth leaders are starting to remember that our job is not to compete with other forms of entertainment (if we even could) but to offer the truth of a gospel that genuinely and authentically demands much and delivers even more. Our methods as educators grow out of reflective practices that enact our core values and being, and are developed to be suitable for "this particular case." Quaker educator Parker Palmer says it this way: "Good teaching cannot be reduced to technique; good teaching comes from the identity and integrity of the teacher."9 For Palmer, the role of the teacher is to connect the student to the subject. For youth leaders, this means that our task is to connect young people to the gospel of Jesus Christ—a connection conveyed by the identity and integrity of our discipleship, and by our faithfulness as pastors and educators.

    "Good teaching cannot be reduced to technique; good teaching comes from the identity and integrity of the teacher."—Parker Palmer

    For Palmer, identity refers to one's whole self—differentiated, defined, and deeply connected to others, embracing all of who we are physically, emotionally, intellectually, spiritually, and experientially. Parker believes that too many leaders, motivated by fear, try to hide parts of their identity or compartmentalize these dimensions of the self. Integrity, therefore, refers to coherence between the leader's soul and role, the congruence between inner and outer self, the ability of the teacher to bring all of the dimensions composing his or her identity into an integrated and coherent whole.

    Of course, this does not mean that when we teach or lead or counsel or speak we open our guts and plop them in the middle of the youth room for all to see. But it does mean that every interaction, every conversation springs out of our identity and our integrity as we do our best to be honest with God and with ourselves about our vulnerabilities, limitations, hopes, and dreams. Historian Stephen Rosen, of Harvard's Derek Bok Center for Teaching and Learning, offers a useful rubric for professional conduct in teaching that youth ministers can adapt for teaching with integrity:

    • Know (and love) our material

    • Know (and love) our learning environment and context

    • Know (and love) our students

    • Know (and love) ourselves.10

    To these four guidelines, youth ministers and Christian educators must add a fifth: "To know (and love) God, our true teacher and subject matter."

    To minister from the depths of our integrity instead of from the breadth of our knowledge requires practical wisdom—the kind of knowing that can discern the appropriate choice in a given situation that comes from years of experience, or from being steeped in a tradition formed by centuries of practice. As leaders, however, this kind of integrity carries the risk for exposure. At the seminary where I teach, the community often holds a service for wholeness and for healing. During that service, there is an opportunity to go forward and speak quietly with those leading the service about a particular need or concern, and to be anointed and prayed over. At one point last year, I was struggling through some painful decisions and went forward. I found to my own surprise that I could not even speak what was breaking my heart at that point. After a few moments of trying, I gave up and just sat there with tears streaming down my cheeks. The two students who were sitting at that particular station simply placed their hands on my head and prayed for me and then anointed my forehead with oil, making the sign of the cross. Later, I saw one of them on campus. I was a little embarrassed by my own lack of control in that service.She smiled and said she had been praying for me. I thanked her. Then she thanked me and said it meant a lot to her to see me act so honestly and vulnerably—that even in that moment, I had shown her a way to live when she was out serving a parish as a pastor.

    The safest space on earth is at the center of God's will. Because of this, youth ministry offers young people space for mutual vulnerability—a shared openness to one another and to God. Being open to the "other" means allowing ourselves to be moved by another, not opening up a guilty vein and spewing forth. Yet when the church provides a context for mutual vulnerability, it allows us to receive others wholly, as they receive us, and to allow ourselves to be moved by them, as we are moved by God.

    Being open to the "other" means allowing ourselves to be moved by another, not opening up a guilty vein and spewing forth.

    Palmer writes that too often we, as teachers and leaders, try to protect ourselves from vulnerability, and we end up constructing elaborate structures of separation from students, from our own selves, even from the gospel. When we do this, we deny both our own identity as well as the hope of integrity. Palmer reminds us that there is a proper role for techniques that ultimately connect us rather than separate us from one another. Techniques and activities that reveal rather than conceal our identities as persons created in the image of God help us teach and lead with integrity. Remember the youth pastor who ridiculed us after leading us? It was a teachable moment, all right. He showed me how to use youth ministry techniques and activities to separate myself from the rest of the group and to demonstrate my own need for power. What is so disheartening is that he might have used that teachable moment to convey a very different message: that Christ-following leadership springs from being joined to the Holy Spirit, who joins all of us together. This attention to the Holy Spirit reinforces another emerging competency for youth ministers: contemplative practice.

    Stilling the Soul: The Practice of Presence

    Before I became a seminary professor, I served for a number of years as the director of the youth ministry division for the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.). One of my major responsibilities was to lead a series of summer conferences for young people. These week-long conferences gathered youth and their adult leaders from all over the church. Early in Week Three one summer, two leaders from a church in New Orleans approached me. They asked when the morning speaker or evening preacher was going to issue an "altar call." I explained that some speakers offer such public invitations, inviting teenagers to either commit their lives to Christ for the first time or rededicate their lives to Christ in a new way, but I was not sure about this year. I spoke with the morning speaker and the evening conference preacher and neither planned to issue such a public invitation.

    When I reported that to the group leaders, they were disappointed. "Well, then," they asked, "how are we supposed to find out where our young people are with their faith in Jesus Christ?"

    "Why don't you ask them?" I responded.

    "Can we do that?" they replied, stunned.

    I admit, that sounded like a no-brainer to me. But I offered my opinion. "Actually, it seems to me that since you are the adults who have traveled here with them and spent the week with them and will go home with them, you are the persons best suited to ask that wonderful question of your young people." When they asked how I thought they should go about this, I knew a longer conversation was in order.

    I set up a time to meet with all the adult leaders and suggested some ways they might start the conversation. At the end of the week, I heard from one of the leaders that they had indeed talked with each of the young people and the conversations had been rich and rewarding. "This has been the best week we've ever had," he told me with excitement. "It has been incredible to talk with our young people and to hear their stories and their questions. We're returning home like we are a whole different group."

    Mark Yaconelli contends that if we want young people to live lives of faith, "we need to live in the presence of Jesus. . . . We have to share not only the teachings of Jesus but more importantly the presence of Jesus."11 By "presence" Yaconelli means a number of things: "being open and available to others with as much of ourselves as possible . . . to be awake to the Mystery of God within each moment . . . [and] relating to youth in the way Jesus related to people—with authenticity and transparency."12 The best way to do this, believes Yaconelli, is to spend time in the presence of Jesus ourselves, which for him means participating in ancient contemplative disciplines of prayer and discernment, updated somewhat for contemporary Christians, and inviting young people to join us. (Yaconelli would agree that serving the poor, working for justice, and other forms of active spirituality also place us in the presence of Jesus; his work focuses on contemplative spirituality primarily as a corrective for our over-scheduled, often spiritually vacuous, lives and ministries.) "Who would we become if we spent time in the presence of Jesus?" he asks. Then he identifies the real issue holding us back:

    The central problem in sharing the Christian faith with young people doesn't concern words; it's deeper than that. The real crisis facing those of us who seek to share faith with youth is this: We don't know how to be with our kids. We don't know how to be with ourselves. We don't know how to be with God.13

    He is right, of course. As veteran youth minister Mike King reminds us: "The most important thing we bring to our youth ministry is a heart seeking the face of God and a life that is truly lived in God's presence."14 Yaconelli's work on young people and contemplative spirituality has led youth ministers to explore what it means to be with our young people, with ourselves, and with God as spiritual learners and leaders. As we have noted repeatedly throughout this book, ministry with young people requires more than group-building activities or fun outings or mission trips or even Bible study. It requires us to do more than help youth become good moral citizens or conscientious consumers. Youth ministry aims, above all, to build up young people as disciples of Jesus Christ, calling them into an alternative rhythm of life that practices the presence of God.

    "The most important thing we bring to our youth ministry is a heart seeking the face of God and a life that is truly lived in God's presence."—Mike King

    The competency of presence stands as a direct challenge to ministry (any ministry) that tries to compete with soccer or Starbucks or band or business or you name it. Practicing the presence of God, as Brother Lawrence put it, invites young people, and invites us, to slow down and to place God at the center of our lives. It is an emerging competency because so few of us are good at it yet. For a church seeking to take a prophetic stance against practices of cultural excess, including the need to be more places and to have more time, practicing "presence" offers an alternative to trying to out-program consumer culture. Interestingly, in the early days of Yaconelli's research, he found that young people did not resist contemplative youth ministry; adults did.

    In the early days of Yaconelli's research, he found that young people did not resist contemplative youth ministry; adults did.

    Young people whose lives are already so programmed and driven yearn for an opportunity to step out of the race and slow down. In this they act as prophets in our midst, calling the church to step out of a culture that idolizes busy-ness. Our editorial team shared some of our struggles on this point. Kenda recalled a recent "car conversation" with her sixteen-year-old daughter, Shannon. Kenda was complaining about a spate of church-related deadlines she had agreed to. "It's like Whack-a-Mole," she grumbled. "As soon as I get rid of one deadline, another one pops up."

    "So," Shannon said simply, "stop putting in quarters."

    Of course. While we are being seduced by the "just say yes" culture of accomplishment, teenagers like Shannon see immediately that the way out is to declare Sabbath, to practice Godly presence instead of dutiful compliance. When faith becomes one more thing to do, teenagers understandably (1) opt out or (2) misunderstand Christ as someone who demands their work, rather than hopes for their being. Presence-centered youth ministry refuses to reinforce the frenetic pace at which young people already live; on the contrary, it subverts this pace. The challenge for adult leaders is to live lives that demonstrate this alternative rhythm of life—no easy task, obviously, for hyperscheduled youth ministers. Yet small steps matter: for instance, listening to young people more than talking to them, or honing our own engagement with ancient practices of prayer, meditation, and discernment.

    Contemplative practices do not naively disconnect us from daily living; in many ways, they allow for more honest ways of seeing the world, freeing us for unworried lives of joy and freedom. This reorientation also helps us see clearly, and face squarely, the pain and suffering of young people so that our presence can share their burdens, lightening their load. For all of our skills as teachers, leaders, counselors, and life coaches, what young people need us most to become is their pastor (and if we don't do this, who will?). And of course, in this process of shepherding, this act of accompanying them into the world and home again, young people accompany us as well.

    Soul Doctors: Nurturing Hope amidst Suffering

    There are some young people you meet that you immediately enjoy. Sarah was one of these. She was one of the high school leaders of a weekend retreat where I was speaking in the Santa Cruz Mountains in California. Barely sixteen, she laughed easily, smiled often, and gave energy. She and the other youth and adult leaders had arrived at the conference center early and set up the place. When hordes of youth and adults began to arrive, Sarah was out front greeting them and directing them to cabins or dorm rooms. When one young girl arrived, struggling with her backpack, duffel bag, sleeping bag, and pillow, Sarah grabbed the duffle bag and walked with her to her cabin, chatting and asking questions of the young girl. It was obvious she transformed the girl's first few minutes of the retreat.

    At the evening session, Sarah and the other student leaders led us in several probing group-building activities. I noticed that it was Sarah who reached out to include some of the youth who were on the edges of the room. She ran up to one guy, a big, athletic-looking young man who was easily a head taller than she was, introduced herself and stood next to him, encouraging him to participate while other young people led an activity. In no time, he was sitting on the floor in a small group, smiling and enjoying himself. I leaned over to one of the pastors and asked about Sarah. He told me she was one of their best leaders, effervescent and yet humble. He was hoping she would go to seminary following college. I hoped the same. She was just the kind of person I would want for my pastor.

    The next day, Saturday afternoon, after I had finished speaking, I was delighted when Sarah asked if she could talk with me. We sat down outside at a picnic table and Sarah told me her story, a story that revealed a depth of pain that called upon everything I had ever read in psychology and addiction.She asked me to pray for her, and especially for her little sister Maddie. Sarah and Maddie lived with their grandparents, who had become their legal guardians because the courts declared their mother an unfit parent. A drug addict, her mother had often left Sarah and Maddie to fend for themselves and, in fact, had allowed one of her boyfriends to abuse Sarah a few years earlier. I realized that some of Sarah's gifts, including her desire to please, had evolved to help her cope with living in a household riddled with addiction and abuse. Now her grandparents had retired and were thinking about moving. Sarah and Maddie hoped to stay put because they loved their schools, their church, and their friends. As Sarah shared her story, she began to cry quietly. I took her hands, and we prayed together. What struck me was the way Sarah prayed:

    I know you have a plan for me and for Maddie (her little sister), and I am so grateful for grandpa and grandma, and I know it's been hard on them raising us but Lord, I am wondering if it would be possible in your plan for us to stay somehow because it seems that you have given us such a wonderful place to be and a wonderful community that helps us know what it is to live as a family. I know your family is all over the world and that you are at work in it and even in Mom's life. I just want to be faithful to you, so please help me to listen to you.

    It was a jaw-dropping holy moment, one of those breathtaking interludes when you just want to thank Christ for the privilege of being in his presence as he shone through this young person. When we finished praying together, Sarah looked up and smiled and wiped the tears from her face. She apologized for crying and for taking up my time. I told her how honored and humbled I was to be with her. Then I asked if we could read some Scripture together. ("Sure.") "Do you know Jeremiah 29:11?" (She wasn't sure.) So we read it together:

    For surely I know the plans I have for you, says the LORD, plans for your welfare and not for harm, to give you a future with hope. (Jeremiah 29:11)

    After we read it, Sarah said, "Wow." I told her this passage came to mind because of the way she prayed. I also told her how grateful I was for the way she framed her life experience through her relationship with God. "You're a fine theologian," I said to her. When she objected, I insisted, "I am learning a lot from you today, and I am the one who is grateful for your time."

    That's how it is with fine theologians. Theologians help us see our whole life experience, both joys and pain, through our relationship with God. Today, it is all too easy to compartmentalize our school world or work world or family world and play world as separate and unrelated. Developmental psychologist David Elkind says the result is a "patchwork self"—a sense that our lives are a series of unrelated moments that have no effect on one another.15 A patchwork self is assembled by appropriating the feelings, thoughts, and beliefs of others. As a result, the young person has no inner sense of coherence, no integrating core, and is therefore wildly susceptible to outside pressures and the inner whims of emotion and indecision. Christian theology offers a different understanding of self. Theologians do not deny that there is pain and suffering in the world; in fact, they help us understand God's presence in those moments of despair. These dark nights of the soul, painful as they are, can become new sources of spiritual growth and wonder, providing a more profound sense of God's presence and a deeper grasp of God's ways.16

    Theologians help us see our whole life experience, both joys and pain, through our relationship with God.

    Adolescents are by no means immune to pain and suffering, and their anguish strikes at the very core of their being. Young people need, as pastoral theologian Robert Dykstra puts it, "physicians of the soul," people attuned to the spiritual as well as the psychological and physical dimensions of pain.17 A 2008 YouTube video of an old (1994) Foreigner song makes the point:

    I need to see the soul doctor before the fever begins.

    You know I'm searching for the soul doctor when love is wearing thin.

    Doctor Soul is in.

    Drawing on the tradition of the ancient church, in 1958 pastoral theologian Seward Hiltner argued against reducing pastoral care to psychological healing; rather, he said, the church's job was to assist the Great Physician in the "care and cure of souls," which has the effect of making every pastor a "soul doctor," called to leverage every available resource—psychological and theological—in order to address human suffering.18 Hiltner's emphasis on the theological as well as psychological dimensions of pastoral care represented one of the first responses to the twentieth-century tendency to shrink spiritual care into modern, secular categories.

    Dykstra, too, reminds us that the church doesn't always "get it right" when it comes to addressing suffering. Fully acknowledging that many young people are in crisis, Dykstra says youth ministers, like all Christian leaders, are "heirs to and stewards of the sometimes healing, sometimes destructive doctrines and rituals of the Christian heritage" and that our major work is to discern the "Spirit's stirrings" and to honor and refashion the mysteries and wisdom of faith for a new generation. Essential to this process is the Christian doctrine of hope. Faith in the cross and resurrection of Jesus Christ inspires Christians to a kind of "hope against hope"—a crazy hope, stemming from our amazement at finding the tomb empty, that despite all appearances to the contrary and against all odds clings to God's promise to make all things new.19

    Spectators No More: Creating Church versus Consuming It

    It was an impressive worship service. I was visiting an independent "megachurch" in the Midwest and had worshiped at one of their "seekerfriendly" hour-long services. It unfolded like clockwork, technologically perfect. Not one moment dragged. The service moved seamlessly from the music to a video introduction of the theme for the day. The presenters were clear and energetic. The video clips were clever and perceptive. Several greeters approached me as I made my way to the worship center. The signage was welcoming and communicative. Like I said, it was impressive.

    I walked out shaking my head, remembering some other worship services I had attended that were making an earnest effort at including some media, but the screens were too small, words were misspelled, video clips were unintelligible, PowerPoint slides appeared too early or too late so that we could not sing along. I thought about services where the music was too slow or too fast and services that were lifeless and obtuse. No wonder, I remember thinking to myself, that there are hundreds of bright young adults here.

    As I headed to the parking lot, I overheard a conversation between the three young adults who were walking in front of me. One of them asked his companions what they thought about the service. A woman said she liked it. "That," she said, "was really a great show."

    Now, I don't usually interrupt complete strangers having a conversation in the church parking lot, but I wanted to be sure I got that right. I apologized and explained that I was a visitor too, and asked her what she meant by "show." Forgiving me for eavesdropping, she said, "Well, I guess I was entertained. Not in a totally bad way—but it was really different from what I thought church was supposed to be like. It's sorta like when you go to a concert and walk out saying it was good. That's sort of what it was like." This woman liked the church service the way she liked a good concert.

    The next day I returned to the church for an appointment with one of the pastors. I told him about my conversation in the parking lot. He smiled. "It's not like we're trying to entertain here, but the comparison is not bad. We work really hard at making worship as engaging as possible." I asked him about the difference between "engaging" and "entertaining." He said he thought they were related. That's as far as the conversation went.

    That's a problem.

    Let's be clear about a few things here, since I am well aware that I am walking into a minefield. First, the word "entertain" comes from the French entre + tenir—to bring together. Entertainment brings people together. This is a good thing. Originally worship brought primitive people together to perform a play as an offering to appease the gods (theatre and worship share the same origin). Christians borrowed this pagan notion in developing the first church liturgies; the idea was to worship for God's pleasure, not ours—which of course makes God the audience, and the congregation one of the leads. In fact, street theatres got started in the early Middle Ages because the church no longer welcomed entertainers (acting was considered "deceit"). So plays stopped being religious performances to please the gods and started to be popular performances to please the people, thanks largely to the church's decision to exclude certain kinds of people from worship (a bad move, always).

    Christians also patterned worship after their Hebrew heritage, in which worship meant coming into God's presence with humility—not groveling, sniveling, "yes master" kinds of humility, but grateful, honest gladness that we are not God, but are human and beloved by God. "I do not call you servants any longer," Jesus told his disciples, "because the servant does not know what the master is doing; but I have called you friends, because I have made known to you everything that I have heard from my Father" (John 15:15). We get to come into God's presence as friends. Friends do not need to be appeased; but they do need to be thanked. Christian worship, then, offers God thanks simply for being who God is.

    So we do not need to make worship meaningful; it is already meaningful. An encounter with the living God, coming into God's presence, is as meaningful as this life gets. "Worship," as homiletician Tom Long writes, "is about awe, not strategy."20 So when worship is awful instead of awe-full, we have a problem. We come into the presence of God, not because God commands us to, but because—as any love-struck teenager will tell you—being present with our beloved is everything and enough.

    Worship is a lot like falling in love. When someone falls head over heels for another, adoration flows naturally from the lover toward the loved one. This adoration is not primarily about anything else, nor does it serve any utilitarian purpose outside the love relationship. Indeed, in the presence of the loved one, the lover cannot help but adore, and apart from the beloved, nothing can provoke adoration—not perfume or soft music or dim lights or wine and roses.21

    What matters is not whether worship or ministry in general uses technology or ancient chants; these are merely ways we show our adoration, like perfume and wine and roses. What does matter is that we fall in love with God, who is head-over-heels smitten with us. And falling in love is not a spectator sport.

    What matters is not whether worship or ministry in general uses technology or ancient chants; these are merely ways we show our adoration, like perfume and wine and roses. What does matter is that we fall in love with God, who is head-over-heels smitten with us. And falling in love is not a spectator sport.

    The days of spectator ministry are gone, thankfully, since it was never theologically sound ministry to begin with. In those bygone days, leaders expected young people to sit passively while they filled them up with information and knowledge. When ministry became boring or irrelevant for new generations, passionate church leaders threw themselves into addressing the problem—by coming up with better, more professional, more up-to-date ways for people to be a passive church. A generation later, the cycle started (and will start) over.

    The problem is analogous to the one activist Paulo Freire noticed in education. Friere described "the banking method" of education. He describes a classroom where the students sit like "containers," empty receptacles waiting to be filled by the teacher. The more completely the teacher fills the receptacles, the better teacher she is. The more meekly the receptacles permit themselves to be filled, the better students they are. Instead of educating, the teacher makes "knowledge deposits" which students passively receive, memorize, and recite. The problem, of course (besides sheer boredom), is that students never discover how to actively learn on their own.

    The rise of participatory culture directly challenges banking models of education—and youth ministry. In fact, people who are in ministry with young people stand at the helm when it comes to developing new competencies for Christian leadership in participatory culture, where interactivity rather than passivity is the new learning culture of young people. To be sure, worship is a spectator sport in traditional churches as often as in megachurches (maybe more often), and participatory worship emanates from all corners of Christian tradition. In many corners of the church (Eastern Orthodox, Pentecostal, and emerging churches all come to mind), worship has never not been primarily participative. For young people who make "playlists" instead of buying compilations of songs produced for them, who create collaborative Wikis instead of appropriating the definitions supplied by others, who write their own blogs rather than admire Pulitzer-prize-winning columnists, participatory culture means making our own decisions from multiple options, and creating cultural content and not just consuming it. In a "karaoke" culture, as futurist Leonard Sweet calls it, music is not music (art is not art, education is not education, religion is not religion) unless one can perform and participate in it if one chooses.22

    Proficiency in participatory culture is both intoxicating and intimidating for most of us.23 On the one hand, it offers a way to counter the conformist nature of teenage faith (adolescents in the National Study of Youth and Religion mirrored their parents' patterns of religious devotion—or lack thereof—to a profound degree).24 When young people contribute to worship or offer creative venues for reconciliation or service, the church is not only less anachronistic to participation-oriented teenagers; we are also far more faithful to the Christian community's call to all of us to bring our offerings to God.

    The church, by definition, is a participatory community; in some ways, our best preparation for participatory culture as adults is to simply be the Christian community Christ calls us to be, a community where every gift is exercised to its fullest for the glory of God.

    On the other hand, proficiency in participatory culture quickly overwhelms those of us who do not think of ourselves as "natives" to such a culture. Yet the church, by definition, is a participatory community; in some ways, our best preparation for participatory culture as adults is to simply be the Christian community Christ calls us to be, a community where every gift is exercised to its fullest for the glory of God. Becoming familiar with the native culture of young people is always important, the way learning the language of another culture is important; it honors those who speak it. But more important still, to young people and to Jesus Christ, is to be the church, people who participate in God's re-creation of culture—whether we know how to use iMovie or not.

    Choosing Life: Discerning Vocation with Young People

    Suzanne is a bright, attractive young adult and an aeronautical engineer working at Boeing. We sat down for coffee at Starbucks one Saturday, where I congratulated her on her new promotion. She looked down and smiled. "I guess that's what's on my mind," she said. She went on to explain that she was rising quickly at work, gaining new responsibilities with a steady increase in pay. Then she looked at me and said, "I have been praying and thinking. I appreciate the recognition and the good salary at work. What I am wondering is if this is it—if I am really doing what God created me to do."

    Suzanne was a child of the church. She grew up in a faithful family, worshiped every Sunday, loved youth group and went on mission trips and conferences. In college, she was part of the Asian American Campus Fellowship. She led Bible studies and now was a youth group advisor and a deacon. "For awhile now," she said, "my energies have been around school, getting my Master's in engineering. But when I think about doing the work that I am doing—not even for the rest of my life, but just for the next few years—I can't stand it."

    As we talked for the next couple of hours, I began to get this sinking feeling in the pit of my stomach. I remembered when she graduated from high school as an honors student. I remembered when she graduated from college magna cum laude. I remembered when she gained admission to the competitive Master's degree program in aeronautical engineering. I remembered when she got her first job at Boeing. The church had affirmed her with each accomplishment. Then she named my growing discomfort. "You know what I have come to realize?" she said. "I have come to realize that my whole life I have been looking ahead . . . looking at the next step, the next task. I've never stopped to just listen to God and hear what I am supposed to be doing right now—not next, but right now. And I guess I am a little surprised because I don't remember anyone at church ever asking me to do that. I mean, isn't that what church is supposed to be about? Helping you find out what God wants you to be and do with your life?" That's when I almost lost my latte.

    Christ's call to us is remarkably straightforward: "Follow me."

    One of the best known definitions of "vocation as call" comes from Christian poet Frederick Buechner, who says, "The place God calls you to is the place where your deep gladness and the world's deep hunger meet."25 In truth, vocation is much simpler than this. The root for the word vocation is the Latin vocare, which is the verb "to call." But Christ's call to us is remarkably straightforward: "Follow me." What Christian young people want to know is: How? Where? To do what? (all of which are moving targets where Jesus is concerned). We want to know what God wants us to do as we follow Jesus—which usually means, what work God wants us to do—and the truth is that this just isn't a subject God weighs in on at all. Plumbers and pastors and parents and policemen and topiary specialists are equally delightful to God. What matters in Christian tradition is not the work we do, but the lives we live—and whether our work helps or distracts us from following Jesus. What Suzanne really wanted to know was whether being an engineer at Boeing would help her delight in, or distract her from, following Jesus.

    Today the most common understanding of vocation refers to one's paid work. This is a secular understanding, not a theological one. You hear it in phrases like "vocational training" and "vocational school" or "vocational counseling." Sometimes we contrast vocation (paid work) with avocation (things outside of work that we do because we delight in them)—which only reinforces the idea that our vocation has to do with work and career. Some traditions turn this understanding upside down; Roman Catholics give vocation a distinctly religious connotation, referring to particular roles in church leadership (i.e., priests, monks, or nuns). Protestants—and teenagers—may use the term more broadly as a synonym for "calling," which generally means a subjective "feeling" that certain work suits them.

    Perhaps that is why catechized adolescents often think that receiving God's calling is (a) a miraculous event (burning bush, anyone?) and (b) unlikely to happen to them. In truth, discerning our vocation is a lifelong process with dramatic results but a lot less day-to-day drama. Key to this process is a theological worldview that says we somehow participate in God's activity in the world by responding to God's call. Christian tradition understands all aspects of life as holy, even the mundane. (Martin Luther said that the labor of a cobbler and of a preacher are equally valued by God, if each is undertaken in faith.) So the idea of vocation infuses all of life with theological significance.

    This theological understanding is important because it helps us discern what is and is not part of our God-given vocation. Some activities—stealing or violence toward ourselves or another, for instance—must be viewed as outside of God's will for our lives. Further, whether we talk about a general calling that is large and lifelong, or particular callings that are more specific and time bound, God is the one who calls. We do not call ourselves nor do we call each other. Familiarizing adolescents with qualities of God's call helps them distinguish between competing voices in their lives: Which voice is from my parents, wanting me to succeed? Which voice is from my culture, wanting me to conform? Which voice is from Christ, wanting me to flourish? Christian tradition suggests that discerning an authentic, divine call involves the following:

    • Dependence and relationship. You are not in this alone; discerning a calling is not simply up to you. The community of believers who know you and love you exist to help you discern your call.

    • Gratitude to God. Humility is an essential trait in pursuing a God-given vocation. Divine calls are not graded; some are not better or worse than others. God calls all of us to follow Jesus, and to build up the church in gratitude for God's amazing love, shown to us in Jesus Christ.

    • Obligation. There is much concern these days about a growing sense of entitlement and privilege among young people. Helping young people recognize their grateful obligation to God deflates this tendency. This obligation does not put our salvation at risk; rather, it is a posture of gratitude, of being "beholden," a willingness to allow an other (or Other) to place a claim on us.

    • Meaning. Ultimately, human beings are meaning-makers. We are made to seek meaning, which is what makes us human, and what leads us to seek God. A key task of vocation is to find purposeful work, to contribute to the world in a way that transcends our own pleasure or growth. Suzanne was on that search. Truthfully, we are all on that search.

    For these reasons, practical theologian Brian Mahan reminds us that vocation is less about discovering our occupation and more about uncovering our preoccupations.26 Because adolescents are at an extraordinary time in their lives, looking for their place in the world—and because they do not hear the theological language of God's calling anywhere else in their lives, not at school, not in the wider culture, and increasingly not at home—a critical emerging competency for youth ministry leaders is helping our young people discern God's call.

    Benedict of Nursia, Youth Guy

    Pope St. Gregory (540–604) wrote that if anyone wants to know about St. Benedict of Nursia's character and life, they should read the Rule that Benedict wrote to instruct the brothers how to live together.27 Fifteen hundred years after Benedict's death in 547 C.E., Benedictine orders all over the world still depend on his "little rule for beginners." It contains directions for all aspects of the monastic life: from establishing the abbot as superior, arranging psalms for prayers, and correcting faults, to details of clothing and the proper amount of food and drink. Benedict believed that the love of Christ comes before all else, and clearly recognized the frail nature of human beings, encouraging even the abbot to "distrust his own frailty."

    What we don't always realize about St. Benedict is that he was a youth minister: his work as an abbot included overseeing the youngest people in the monastery's care, who were boys—children and teenagers—given by their parents to be brought up as monks.28 According to Pope St. Gregory, Benedict literally worked miracles with youth, raising a boy from the dead who had been crushed by an overturned wall (tradition has it that Benedict raised him and sent him back to work).29Benedict's Rule insists on including the youngest monks in the community's deliberations, because "the Lord often reveals what is best to the youngest."30So Benedict's rules are not only helpful for youth ministers because of their clarity and practicality; they also come from a place of deep affinity for the work we do. In many ways, our leadership with young people resembles Benedict's leadership of the abbey—which means that Benedict's second rule, on the qualifications of the abbot, include instructions that youth ministers can take to heart:31

    • Remember the One you represent. Benedict calls upon leaders to remember first that you represent Christ since, like Christ was among his disciples, you are addressed as "abbot," a derivative of father. Therefore, all that you teach and command must comply with Christ's own teachings and commandments.

    • Remember to whom you are accountable. An ongoing theme in his rules, Benedict calls upon leaders to remember that ultimately they bear responsibility to God for those whom God has entrusted to their care. Leaders are like shepherds who care for their sheep just as Christ was the Good Shepherd.

    • Remember how you are to guide and teach. The best way to lead and to teach is by example more than by words. If you want it to be done, show them by doing it yourself. In the same way, if you do not want them to do something, then you should not do it.

    • Remember how you are to treat others. Do not play favorites and do not act as if you are a better person than those whom you lead. The only way the abbot should be found better is in good works and humility.

    • Remember how your people best learn. Benedict also calls upon leaders to remember that each person learns in different ways. Some respond best to verbal encouragement, others learn best by doing. Benedict says the abbot must know the learners well enough to adjust his teachings appropriately.

    • Remember what is expected of you. Since as the leader more is entrusted to you and because you hold the place of Christ, more is expected of you. Live your life accordingly.

    • Remember to keep the important things central to your life. Benedict tells the abbot to not show "too great concern for the fleeting and the temporal things." The challenge is to not be distracted from the primary task of glorifying Christ and caring for souls.

    We need neither romanticize nor be naïve to the responsibility we bear as leaders in youth ministry.

    Benedict closes his discussion on the Qualities of the Abbot with yet another reminder, that "anyone undertaking the charge of souls must be ready to account for them . . . and indeed for his own as well." Clearly Benedict felt the weight of leadership profoundly—and there is great wisdom in this for us all. It was Jesus himself who warned his disciples: "If any of you put a stumbling block before one of these little ones who believe in me, it would be better for you if a great millstone were fastened around your neck and you were drowned in the depth of the sea" (Matthew 18:6). We need neither romanticize nor be naïve to the responsibility we bear as leaders in youth ministry. It seems fitting, then, to end this chapter where we started: with the reminder that we are still learning, and with Paul's message to Timothy ringing in our ears: Leadership in any of these competencies will show best through both words and example. Pay close attention to your own self, and to your own growth, and continue on, for by doing this, you will save both yourself and your hearers.

    Further Reading on Themes in This Chapter

    Apter, Terri. The Myth of Maturity. New York: W. W. Norton, 2001.

    Benedict. The Rule of St. Benedict, ed. Timothy Fry. New York: Vintage Spiritual Classics, 1998.

    Dykstra, Robert. Counseling Troubled Youth. Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1997. For Dykstra's thoughts relating his work to youth ministry, see his lectures on www.ptsem.edu/iym.

    Elkind, David. All Grown Up and No Place to Go, Revised edition. Cambridge, MA: Perseus Books, 1998.

    Gregory, Pope St., I, and Terrence Kardong. The Life of St. Benedict. Collegeville, MN: The Order of St. Benedict, 2009.

    John of the Cross. The Dark Night of the Soul. Grand Rapids: Christian Classical Ethereal Library, 1999.

    King, Mike. Presence-Centered Youth Ministry: Guiding Students into Spiritual Formation. Downer's Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2006.

    Long, Thomas G. Beyond the Worship Wars: Building Vital and Faithful Worship. Herndon, VA: Alban Institute, 2001.

    Mahan, Brian. Forgetting Ourselves on Purpose: Vocation and the Ethics of Ambition. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2002.

    Palmer, Parker. A Hidden Wholeness. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2004.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑