4. Trace My Hand: The Promise of Confession in Youth Ministry
Justin Forbes and Kenda Creasy Dean
Do not depend on the hope of results. . . . The big results are not in your hands or mine, but suddenly happen, and we can share them, but there is no point in building our lives on this personal satisfaction, which may be denied us and which after all is not that important.
—Thomas Merton1
Charity depends on the vicissitudes of whim and personal wealth; justice depends on commitment instead of circumstance. Faith-based charity provides crumbs from the table; faith-based justice offers a place at the table.
—Bill Moyers2
I (Justin) have always thought of youth ministry as the act of inviting young people to the table, helping them find their seats, and making sure they know they are welcomed and loved there—that, in other words, they belong. So when my wife and I set out in the world together at about the same time that we started in youth ministry, it was clear that we were going to need a large—no, a huge—dining-room table. Luckily, my newly retired father-in-law had taken up furniture making, and our dining-room table became one of his most painstaking projects. He built us a table, but not just any table. It was massive—not just family-of-six massive but invite-the-neighbors massive. It was built to measure for our dining room, and, if you really try, you can seat sixteen people around it for dinner. This table has become one of our most prized possessions. We have brought each of our six children home from the hospital to grow up around this table. We have laughed, cried, and celebrated around this table. Hundreds of middle school, high school, and college students have eaten around this table. It has become the center of our home and the center of our ministry, a vehicle for our call to practice hospitality.
Fostering Belonging
A few years back, Bethany and I began the process of becoming foster parents. Among other things, this involved a three-month training course and multiple background checks and references before we were licensed to care for kids in our community. Since then, we have welcomed children to our table on what, for many, could be described as the worst day of their lives. As part of the healing process, these children have eaten around our table—but they have also inspired a new tradition in our family. Sometimes a foster placement lasts only a few nights, and sometimes the child stays for months or even years. Toward the end of a child’s time with us, we crawl under the table with our foster daughter or son, trace her or his handprint underneath, and write her or his name and the date in the print. Our hope is to remember these children, to keep them with us in a small way, and to hold them close to our hearts each time we gather around our table.
One of the names under our table is Troy. Troy was four years old when he showed up at our house during the Lenten season of 2017. He had been through five foster homes in just three weeks by the time he arrived, and it didn’t take long for us to discover why. He landed in our home like a bomb, his anger and violence leaving a wake of destruction. During his first few days with us, Bethany took him to Target to buy a few essentials. When they reached the back of the store, Troy ran out of patience and lost control. He starting throwing things off the shelves and hitting my wife and our three-year-old. He began screaming, “I hate you! F*ck you, you stupid bitch! I’m gonna kill you, I hate you!!” He was inconsolable. Bethany walked out of the store with Troy under one arm, pushing the cart with our three-year-old buckled inside, to the judgmental stares and shocked looks of strangers.
As Holy Week approached, our family was beginning to feel the weight of having Troy in our home. Though he had been with us only three weeks, we felt exhausted, defeated, and overwhelmed by the demands of loving and taking care of this little boy. By Thursday of Holy Week, I was completely spent. I wanted to be at our church’s Maundy Thursday service, to receive the encouragement of friends and the comfort of worship, but it had been a rough day. Troy had gotten into serious trouble at preschool that day; our other kids were out of sorts; and it was obvious that going to church was not going to be an option that evening. I felt myself get angry. I was enraged that this four-year-old was disrupting my life in such a profound way. I was beginning to resent Troy for all the tension he brought into our home. I hated how our family dynamic had been invaded and was seemingly being destroyed from within. I was out of patience. I had no more grace to give.
That night, as I bathed Troy, sitting on my knees and leaning into the bathtub as I washed his body, I confess that I felt bitter. I began daydreaming about what our church community was doing without us. I needed to be there in worship, but this pint-sized preschool punk had messed it all up! Our congregation was worshiping and praying just then, and soon would be washing one another’s feet. That’s when I looked down at what I was doing.
I was washing Troy’s feet.
I was cleaning the wounds on his feet—burns from when he had tried to warm up near a campfire when he was homeless, living in the woods. While Christians all over the world were washing one another’s feet, I found myself washing the wounded feet of this four-year-old terror for whom I held more resentment than I could bear. This child of God had been placed in my care so I could wash his feet.
Like millions of Christians around the world that night, I wept as I realized where I was.
I was at the feet of Jesus.
I wish this story took a positive turn, and I could tell you that things got better. The truth, however, is that we simply hit a wall. After just over three months, we were running out of ways to care for Troy. Our other children began expressing the toll it was taking on them. The moment of truth came when our eleven-year-old called a family meeting and calmly asked, “How do you think it’s going?” Bethany and I made a devastating decision: we would have Troy removed from our home and placed with another family. We wanted to act like this decision was for him, in his best interest. But the truth was more sinister and more painful. We just couldn’t handle Troy any longer. We didn’t have what it took to care for Troy.
A friend of mine, also a foster parent, says that being a foster parent often feels like you’re standing at the edge of a cliff, peering into hell, watching the worst of what society offers and how it affects children. You just stand there, on the brink of hell, holding children back from falling in . . . for a time. Sometimes it’s long enough for them to gain their footing. But sometimes it’s not. Sometimes their straining toward the chasm is so relentless that your arms give way . . . and you let go.
Bethany and I wanted to be so much more for Troy, but we ran up against our limitations. We were falling apart. If we continued to offer hospitality to Troy, we felt we were courting the demise of our family, and we just could not handle it any longer. We weren’t enough for Troy. So after a few weeks of agonizing discernment, we asked the agency to move Troy to another foster-care home.
This would be Troy’s sixth placement. In the foster-care world, this is utter failure—yet another disruption in this boy’s young life, yet another family that didn’t want him, that didn’t care enough, try hard enough, or love enough. It feels hopeless for everyone involved. We stood at the brink of hell with Troy . . . and then we let go.
Youth Ministry: Foster Care for Jesus
I (Kenda) have never been a foster parent. But I’ve been a youth leader. I would not have thought of youth ministry as foster care for Jesus until Justin told me Troy’s story—but this is what we do. We step provisionally into young people’s lives as God’s surrogates in order to stand with them on a cliff when they need tangible signs of divine grace. Sometimes the youth God places in our care are “church kids.” Sometimes they’re our own kids. And sometimes they’re young people with whom we have no connection at all.
Most of us have never had to stand as close to the brink of hell as foster parents do. These saints have been called by God to hold children for a time—children like Troy. Children who need obvious and immediate embrace. That said, many of us have come closer to that brink than we wanted to. The brink of hell, after all, has varied faces for fifteen-year-olds. So we stand there, holding young people back from the edge because we have promised to love them even if we don’t like them—for if we don’t, falling into the chasm of loneliness, rejection, fear, or meaninglessness is a very real option. Sometimes these young people, whom we spend so much energy trying to love well for Jesus—sometimes they thank us. Sometimes they grow strong and faithful. And sometimes they hang themselves.
In this book we have affirmed joy as a starting point for ministry and discussed the importance of reconnecting young people to God’s delight in them (even if sometimes we don’t reconnect them). But in the pit of despair, the scales of the dragon grow thicker. The true self becomes buried more deeply beneath the rough skin of neglect, abuse, sorrow. Standing on the brink of hell, young people seldom know what to do. We don’t know what to do. Worse, even if we do know what to do, we may not be up to the task. We might bungle our earnest attempts to love them, or fail to notice their anguish altogether. We might fail the young people God has placed in our care. And then, where is joy? Then, what possible good is youth group?
The unspoken secret of youth ministry is that we have signed on for an impossible task. Yes, it matters that we have a sturdy theology of belonging—but the kind of belonging young people actually need goes far beyond our capacity to deliver it. What they need is God’s hospitality, not ours. Theologian Miroslav Volf describes this divine belonging—what he calls a “theology of embrace”—in ways that go beyond reciprocity or transactionalism. A theology of embrace goes beyond the unspoken bargain we make with young people (even if we don’t admit it): “The church will lavish extravagant time, kindness, and sacrificial love upon you—and in return, eventually you’ll come around to seeing things our way.”
Many do come around. Some don’t.
“Even If ” Youth Ministry
The daunting truth is that the vocation of ministry is predicated on a task that only Jesus can accomplish. We’re supposed to stand in for Jesus—we’re supposed to do this work and love these young people even if they don’t come around . . . even if not one life is changed . . . even if not a single person ever responds to us, or to God. After all, that’s the nature of parenting, whether our children are fostered, adopted, born to us, or simply borrowed for a couple of hours on a Sunday night. We don’t choose the children in our homes or in our churches. They are sent to us, by the foster system, by their parents, or perhaps by God. When congregations baptize a young person, we don’t make a deal with them: “We’ll surround you with love and a community that trusts and believes in you—and, in return, you’ll become the person we envision you to be.” On the contrary, we say with the best of intentions, “We’ll surround you with love and a community that trusts and believes in you no matter what. And you will be our beloved child, and we will be your loving parent, even if you don’t act the way we want you to.” After all, as Thomas Merton notes, what matters is that we love them as Jesus loves them. Whether or not we see results is not all that important.3
And yet: the task of setting aside the ego in order to act for the sake of another is monumental—impossible even—apart from the Holy Spirit doing in us what we cannot do for ourselves. What nobody tells us about youth ministry is how often we will fall short of the “even if ” ministry we have signed up for. Those who try to reflect God’s hospitality stand by young people even if they blow us off, even if they never reciprocate, even if nothing we say or do sinks in; nothing separates us from the love of Christ (Romans 8:35–39). Incredibly, this is our calling as well: to stand with young people on the brink of hell, even if they go over the edge.
The Drama of Embrace
Miroslav Volf is unsurprised by our petulant reaction to even if love. He believes that humanity is always hostile to God—but God receives us into God’s own self anyway. For Volf, God’s enfolding grace, which sweeps hostile humanity into divine communion, suggests a pattern of reconciliation that provides the coordinates for Christians’ posture toward others. In this chapter, we will go one step further: we believe that this pattern of reconciliation—what Volf calls the four-act “drama” of God’s embrace of humanity—offers a way we can love young people even if they cannot reciprocate with the kind of vulnerability we want them to have. The image of “embrace” is intended as a metaphor. While we might enact it physically, it describes just as aptly our emotional and spiritual postures toward one another. As we unpack the four acts of this “drama of embrace,” think about some young people you know and your physical, emotional, and spiritual posture toward them.
Act 1: Open Up
Volf calls act 1 the “opening of arms.”4 Here Volf points out God’s desire to invite us into a reconciled relationship. The open arms of Jesus on the cross provide the central image of the “drama of embrace.” These arms open in a particular direction—namely, toward creation. They are a sign of God’s desire to embrace and reconcile all of creation to God.
This gesture of open arms is an invitation. It is a signal of God’s desire for relationship with us and of God’s longing for our return. It is a sign that God has made room for us within God’s own being. As long as humans remain separated from God, this divine longing exists. Opening one’s arms is also a gesture of extreme vulnerability. With arms wide open, we are unable to protect ourselves or fend off attackers. The price of embrace is vulnerability; God, too, chooses to risk vulnerability for the sake of love, to allow humanity unguarded access to God. (To be clear, among humans, vulnerability may also be manipulated or forced, which is clearly violence, not love. So the fact that God chooses to be vulnerable and open toward creation is a not-to-be-missed detail in the divine drama of embrace.)
For Volf, this divine drama functions not only for God’s embrace of humanity but also as a pattern for the Christian life. Created in God’s own image, we too are created for embrace—and are called to approach one another with arms wide open as well. “As the Father has sent me, so I send you,” the risen Christ tells the terrified disciples cowering in an upper room following the crucifixion (John 20:21). In the same way that Jesus’s life and death invite us into the life of God, we are called to approach each other with similar openness, offering a similar invitation to share in each other’s lives.
Act 2 can be a doozy. Just as the second act of a Shakespearean play intensifies the action as the plot moves toward its climax, the second moment in the “drama of embrace” is similarly intense. With open arms and our invitation extended, we wait. The act of stretching out my arms reveals to a teenager—let’s call her Millie—my desire to embrace her, but it cannot proceed further. God’s invitation suggests that God desires a response, just as we want RSVPs from our young people for the next lock-in. But Millie must respond freely if the drama is to continue. And so, just as God waits for us, we must wait for the young people we love to choose to respond to our invitation, without circling or coercing them in any way. If I were to fold my arms around Millie prematurely, I would be violating her space. In act 2, my arms remain wide open as an invitation to Millie, but they must never encircle her without Millie first taking a voluntary step toward me.5
This is harder than it sounds. Remember the last time you held your arms outstretched for an extended period of time? (If not, do it now and count to two hundred.) Waiting with our arms open is not an inconsequential act. It is a posture that demonstrates to the other that I have chosen not to protect myself from attacks. Millie could hurt me if she wanted to. Waiting with arms wide open is exhausting. What feels delightful for one minute hurts like billy-oh after two. We get fidgety; we feel sore and irritated. We become anxious, standing exposed before a young person, wondering if she will ever respond. True, waiting can also be filled with expectation and hope. It can be Advent waiting—hopeful waiting. But even hopeful anticipation can be maddening. As I wait, arms outstretched, I am inviting Millie into a relationship with me—but I am also telling her that I have thrown down my shield and she could hurt me if she wanted to. And sometimes she will. There is no coercion, no manipulation, no pressure in act 2—only patiently and sacrificially waiting with open arms.
The curtain opens on act 3 only if Millie takes a step into the waiting embrace. If Millie responds positively to the invitation to embrace, in act 3 we can begin to close our arms around each other. Embrace is never a solo activity; a hug takes two. There is reciprocity, mutuality, holding and being held. This mutuality is so powerful that it may not be clear who is holding and who is being held; it is so mutual that it doesn’t matter. The point of embrace is not to maintain power or authority but to rest in the reconciled reality of union with one another. In this union, Millie’s identity is both maintained and transformed, as is mine. She is who she is, and I am who I am; yet now we are changed by the presence of the other. Just as the presence of multiple notes transforms a single note into music, the relationship transformed Millie into someone who is embraced, who recognizes that she is loved, who understands herself to stand in relationship with God and others.
Act 4: Release
Act 4 is about release. The full “drama of embrace” is now written:
Act 1: Open our arms
Act 2: Wait
Act 3: Close our arms around one another
Act 4: Release
The goal of embrace is for two not to become one but to remain two bound in a relationship together, fully distinct and genuinely united, and therefore capable of freely sharing the divine embrace with others. True love rules out actions that absorb, enmesh, suffocate, or overpower the beloved. I must remain, as Andrew Root puts it, “completely other than the other” so that I can be “completely for the other.”6 Love affirms both boundaries and freedom, embrace and release. Love cherishes the distinctive beauty of individuals and the collective dance of their fellowship, especially as they extend this fellowship ever further with others. Act 4 affirms our need to belong and the transformation that comes to people who belong to one another.
Yet the critical move in act 4 is release, not embrace. Release underscores our freedom: embrace is not imprisonment. The University of Michigan’s Early Years of Marriage Project—the world’s longest-running longitudinal study on marriage and divorce, launched in 1986—found that unhappy couples cited lack of privacy or time for self as their primary complaint almost twice as often as dissatisfaction with sex. About one-third of all couples—married and divorced—said they wished they had more “space” for themselves in their relationship.7 As Jürgen Moltmann suggests, release is necessary so that we are free “to leave each other in peace.”8
For Volf, this four-act “drama of embrace” is, above all, the story of God’s embrace of us. God’s desire for us is made clear in the outstretched arms of the cross, where Jesus waits for us, forever if necessary, to respond positively to God’s invitation to reconciled relationship. God’s relationship with us in Jesus Christ is not forced upon us. Nor does God’s desire for us depend on our acceptance of God’s friendship. And while Christ does not transform us without our consent, if we hint that we desire God’s embrace, God moves toward us in the Holy Spirit, enfolds us in love, and releases us as people sent to share God’s embrace with the whole world.
It would be nice if ministry unfolded as neatly as theology does. What about Troy, for instance? What would the drama of embrace look like in Troy’s case—or for that matter, in the case of any young person in our ministries who just will not do what we want him or her to do? As foster parents, Justin and Bethany opened their arms to a little boy who had been abused, neglected, and ripped from the only family he knew. Using the “drama of embrace” to describe their story, they waited for Troy to take a step toward them, so they could complete the embrace.
Justin and his family held their arms open for days, and then weeks, and then months, trying to welcome Troy into their home. Sometimes they thought they saw the beginnings of a response, a step toward them. When he splashed around at the beach with Justin and Bethany’s other four children on summer vacation, or when he calmed down as they read him stories at bedtime, their hopes were raised that their patience was paying off. But an hour later, Troy would snap back, as though the dragon scales that clothed him were tightening up again. Justin and Bethany went back to holding out their arms, waiting, trying to restrain Troy from the edge of a cliff, even as their arms grew heavy and their souls grew tired.
Prolonged waiting on a response from the other makes us vulnerable and open to attack, which is exactly what life felt like to Justin and Bethany as they parented Troy. As Justin put it, any cute pictures or romantic notions they might have harbored about helping a child in need faded quickly after they found Troy choking their three-year-old. And while they could not embrace Troy without his permission, they also couldn’t wait forever. None of us can sustain the kind of waiting that’s necessary when reconciliation and belonging require us to plumb the depths of hell. Only Jesus Christ makes that trip.9
Confessions of Two Youth Workers
Justin:
So here is my confession: The reality of being a foster parent was that I simply couldn’t be enough for Troy. I showed up, had the best of intentions, but at the end of the day his need was too great for me to bear.
The reality of being a youth minister is disturbingly similar. I have tried to faithfully love young people over the years. At times, ministry has felt like a success, where young people experienced God’s embrace. These are the kinds of stories we like to tell. But hiding behind those stories are moments of shame that I try to pretend never happened. The truth is, many young people I have loved and poured myself into never made it. I don’t tell their stories because I am ashamed of all the times I failed young people like Troy, and couldn’t be for them what they needed me to be.
Kenda:
I’ve never felt the kind of pressure in youth ministry that Justin felt—for one primary reason: I’ve never taken a risk on a young person like Troy. I’ve never been a foster parent or worked in a juvenile detention facility or served in a context where deprivation is a way of life. I’ve worked with young people who have endured tremendous pain—but compared to Troy, their wounds were less visible and their lives were more stable.
Of course, part of the reason I say I do not have a story of failure like Justin’s experience with Troy is repression: I don’t want to remember my failures. I don’t want to remember how I failed to intervene in Kira’s abuse until too late, or how I crossed a line by asking Todd a hurtful question that sent him packing, far away from the church and from me. I’ve buried those stories and many, many others, so far in the soil of my subconscious that I have trouble digging them back out.
But the truth is, I also don’t have those memories because I’ve worked hard to avoid the youth who would cause them. I have not done ministry with youth who would be likely to refuse what I was offering. I’ve picked my horses carefully; I’ve chosen winners. I’ve trained leaders, worked with “alpha” kids, served on camp staffs for self-selected, spiritually interested teenagers. I’ve bet on safe horses. I have left the Troys of the world to Justin and other saints whose work and whose hearts allow them to go far closer to the brink of hell than I would. As a result—after thirty years of youth ministry—I am confronting the fact that my ministry has likely missed the young people who needed me, and Jesus, the most. I didn’t just fail them. I didn’t even see them.
Practicing Confession and Forgiveness
Failure in ministry is an occupational hazard, regardless of its context. We have all failed to offer God’s embrace—God’s radical hospitality—to someone God has put on our path, and most of us tamp down those memories as best we can. But those stories are also much closer to the surface than we want to admit, which means that we must set the table for courageous hospitality by first telling the stories in which we have fallen short. Stories of young people we tried to love but never really connected with. Stories of youth we loved well for a time but then we found that we simply couldn’t keep up, the need was so great; they needed more than we could offer, and they slipped away. Maybe you can think of a teenager in your church, or your classroom, or your neighborhood—or maybe even your own child or grandchild—for whom you wish you had held your arms open for a little longer. But that horse didn’t fit in your stable, didn’t fit in the ministry you imagined yourself having, or the group of people you imagined yourself loving. Perhaps you even held a young person at the brink of hell for a while—until, overwhelmed by fatigue and despair, you let go.
The first step toward offering the reconciling sort of hospitality that Volf calls for is confession. The practice of confession is basic to our faith, but it is an underappreciated source of sustenance for youth ministry. Like hospitality, confession opens our arms to God, inviting God to restore the connection between human and divine. Confession captures our vulnerability and humility before God and young people; it “stories” our fallibility as human beings. The narrative format of this chapter is not coincidental. When we confess our failure to embrace young people, we remember their stories; we see them anew. Confession resets our ministries’ reliance on God and removes us from center stage. The good news of confession is that the moment we embrace our inability, we find ourselves held in the loving arms of God. We are no longer at the center of the stage, no longer the primary actor within this drama. While this feels like failure, it is actually good news both for the youth worker and for the young person. It is God’s forgiveness that is needed. It is Jesus Christ who is present in those darkest moments of despair. Liturgically we practice this reality each week. Confession is made both corporately and privately, and in that silence despair can reign . . . yet the promise of God’s loving-kindness rings triumphant: “Hear the good news! Christ died for us, Christ rose for us, Christ reigns in power for us, Christ prays for us. Anyone who is in Christ is a new creation. The old life has gone; a new life has begun!” (see Romans 8:34; 2 Corinthians 5:17).
As the assurance of pardon echoes throughout the sanctuary, we can all breathe a sigh of relief and inhale the hope that has been announced. Reality has been proclaimed, and we are reminded of who and whose we truly are. There is hope for the failing youth worker, for all of us: Jesus Christ has died for that young person we cared for so dearly but failed to love well enough. Christ rose for the youth we overlooked. Christ reigns in power for the teenager we buried, and Christ prays for Troy. Our hope isn’t in our ability to have open arms or to carry out the drama of embrace ourselves. Our hope is in the truth that Jesus Christ has gone the way of death and resurrection, putting death itself to death. Christ did this for us, for the young people we love, and for all of creation. Christ has done this work and continues to do this work. As youth workers, we are invited to participate in this gracious reality, but our successes and failures in ministry change nothing of God’s faithfulness to the young people God loves even more than we do.
Confession is a practice we associate with Sunday worship services, and it’s hard to overestimate its importance there. But the reality is that failure is such a central part of youth ministry that we need a robust practice of confession to infuse our daily lives. Catholics, Lutherans, and some other high-church traditions offer highly orchestrated practices of confession and absolution with a priest or a pastor, but we all need help removing our masks before God. Even informal practices—small friendship groups between youth ministers that weave stories of confession into the fabric of conversation, or practices such as journaling and spiritual direction—help us verbalize our stories of confession. Nonverbally, we can confess to God through art, music, dance, or drama. The point is not how we confess but rather that we confess. Confession is followed by Christ’s assurance of forgiveness—God’s permission to us to love again without fear. This frees us to fail again and again, compelled to open our arms not by fear or the need to validate or redeem ourselves, but by love.
Waiting on Easter
Liturgically speaking, youth ministry happens between Maundy Thursday and Easter morning—that agonizing space that includes washing the feet of young people who bring us to our knees, the disbelief and grief of crucifixion, and the disorienting despair of waiting on God without any sign of redemption. Great youth ministers know their job is not to save young people but to be John the Baptists, pointing beyond themselves to the one to come: “The one who is more powerful than I is coming after me; I am not worthy to stoop down and untie the thong of his sandals. I have baptized you with water; but he will baptize you with the Holy Spirit” (Mark 1:7–8). Our job is not to pose as the solution or the savior but to point beyond ourselves to the person and work of Jesus Christ—which sounds liturgically tidy, but the truth is, it is not very satisfying when we must watch youth we love suffer.
That is why it helps to remember that youth ministry takes place in the soul-space between Maundy Thursday and dawn on Easter morning. On Maundy Thursday, Jesus commanded his disciples to love one another, broke bread with them and washed their feet, and became exhibit A of God’s self-giving love: “No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends” (John 15:13). Then comes Friday, and death, and the utter, final failure of crucifixion. For most of us in youth ministry, Friday’s anguish hits all too close to home. Friday reminds us of our failure to stand in the gap with young people, whether they are grieving the death of a dream or the death of a friend.
And then comes Saturday.
“Holy Saturday,” as the church calls it, is traditionally considered a time of waiting and despair. On Saturday, the disciples faced the consequences of the failure of the Messiah movement. Feeling defeated and terrified, they lost hope, holing up in a locked upper room where no one would find them, wondering what to do next. We get that; we too have found hiding spaces where we could cower in shame, confess our doubts, and even run from responsibilities as we experienced the shrapnel of failure. We too have cried out, “How long, O Lord?” Holy Saturday comes each time we confront the fact that the absolute best we had to offer was not enough. A dream still died. A young person still went over the edge. We still fell short. On Holy Saturday, battered and defeated, we confess. We are not courageous or hospitable. This work we do—this life we have been called to—requires far more than we can offer.
And yet, Christian tradition holds that while we were hiding with the disciples out of fear or despair on Holy Saturday, Holy Saturday was a very busy day for Jesus Christ. In the “harrowing of hell,” as the Orthodox call it, Jesus descended into Hades, unlocked the gates of hell, and proclaimed the good news, opening his arms to the “dead” (1 Peter 4:6). Just because we lack the strength to hold young people back from the brink of hell does not mean God lacks the strength. What’s more, Christ goes into hell with them, to search them out and bring them back. Hell cannot keep God out.
We have been called to love young people even if we are not enough for them, even if we see absolutely no results, even if hell opens up beneath us. It’s a fair question: Why do we keep showing up for work, again and again, under such impossible conditions? There is only one explanation: we are waiting on Easter. We have heard about resurrection. Saturday is here but Sunday is coming, and in Jesus’s death and resurrection, God’s outrageous hospitality is on offer for these young people we cannot reach and we cannot save. We keep showing up because we have not given up hope that Jesus will chase young people all the way to hell if necessary in order to embrace them in resurrection. Resurrection could happen. For them. For us.
Nothing we do in youth ministry makes any sense apart from Easter. Were it not for Easter, we should be cagey about whom we work with in youth ministry—we should pick the best racehorses possible. Were it not for Easter, we should prioritize working with youth who are leaders—the key kids, the kids who buy in. Inviting Troy into a relationship with us, and with Jesus, makes no sense apart from an audacious hope of resurrection, and any account of joy or the good life that does not include Troy and others like him is fake news, not good news. The good news is that Jesus has unlocked the gates of hell. Just when our work with a young person seems as arid and lifeless as the desert—just as the Troys of the world are handing us our butts on a silver platter—it is here in the Valley of Dry Bones that resurrection happens.
What we do know is this: repressing our shame for failing young people, failing to confess our doubts and shortcomings, swallowing our experiences with the Troys of the world, betting on safe horses—this is not the route to joy in youth ministry. The route to joy takes us to the brink of hell with young people who terrorize us, whose families don’t want them or us—to hills where crucifixion is a very likely possibility, where graves are filled with dry bones. Yet this is where Easter happens, which is why the crucified God is the foundation of joy.
Michelle
Within a month of Troy’s departure from our home, our family (Justin’s) got back in line to receive another foster child. A few weeks later, Michelle showed up. She was six days old and had just been weaned off marijuana, cocaine, and the alcohol that were still in her system from her mother’s drug use. Her eyes were still bloodshot. But on the brink of hell, before she could know what grace was and before she could ask God to enter her life, Christ appeared—we hope—in the form of a foster family. When people ask why, after all the trials associated with foster care, Bethany and I keep requesting placements, neither of us has an answer save for one: it’s for the joy of these children. Foster care has ushered in some of our family’s most difficult moments—moments of anger, fear, and despair. Caring for kids like Troy has brought us to our knees more than once. And yet, Jesus appeared to me one night through the scarred feet of a four-year-old homeless boy. It was only after embracing the truth that we could not be for Troy what he needed that we were able to be ourselves for other foster kids. What we can offer them is only our very limited and broken attempts at hospitality—and our absolute reliance on Jesus Christ to fill the gaps.
Youth ministry is no different. We show up in the scarred lives of young people because we meet the risen Christ in the weakest, most wounded, most vulnerable places of our lives. So we keep showing up. We keep confessing our failures. And we keep striving to emulate God’s embrace by practicing the most outrageous—and perhaps even courageous—hospitality we know how to offer. As I write this, Bethany and I are in the middle of attempting to adopt Michelle. Our hope is that she will have a place at our table forever, but there is a long road ahead.
Tracing Handprints under the Table
After Troy was packed up and ready to leave the house, we crawled under our dining-room table with him and began to trace his hand on to the wood. We wrote his name and the dates he had been with us. We intended it to be a sign that Troy would, in some way, always be part of our family communion. But it was also an act of confession, a visible reminder of a boy loved by Christ that we could not love enough. The handprint under the table was a reminder that we had done our best, but our best wasn’t nearly good enough, and Troy will always remember ours as a home that wasn’t his. We ran out of ourselves. Our arms grew tired; we were not able to extend the invitation of embrace any longer. Our only hope was to crawl under the table, trace a physical reminder of the imprint Troy had made on our lives, and release him, trusting that God’s arms are still open to Troy.
In Scripture, the hand (usually the right hand) symbolizes both power and blessing. Because the “mighty hand of God” was a metaphor for divine action, the hand was an emblem of strength and authority. But hands are also used to bless and to heal.10 In short, hands are where God chooses to work through humans, so God’s work may be accomplished on earth, as we become conduits of God’s grace and blessing in the world.
Our hands cannot save the young people God has placed in our path—and what’s more, they were never meant to. Only God’s hand has the power to save. We bear witness to resurrection, we don’t cause it. What we can do, and what we are called to do, is bless. We can open our arms and wait, as long as we can. We can embrace if young people give us permission to do so, and we can release them to God. If we only address the young people we can count as “success stories,” we will never bear witness to the young people who need us—who need Jesus—most. And where is the joy in that?
Pro Tip: Start your leadership team meeting by reading “Not a Story about Football” (pp. 70–73). Ask: “Have you ever had a failed dream turn into a greater one? How did you respond to God in that unexpected experience?”
1. Thomas Merton to Jim Forest, February 21, 1966, quoted in Jim Wallis, Faith Works: How Faith-Based Organizations Are Changing Lives, Neighborhoods, and America (New York: Random House, 2001), kindle ed., 19.
2. Bill Moyers, quoted in Wallis, Faith Works, 18.
3. Merton, in Wallis, Faith Works, 19.
4. Miroslav Volf, Exclusion and Embrace (Nashville: Abingdon, 1996), 141.
5. Volf, Exclusion and Embrace, 142.
6. Andrew Root, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry: From a Strategy of Influence to a Theology of Incarnation (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2007), 127.
7. Terri Orbuch, Finding Love Again: 6 Simple Steps to a New and Happy Relationship (Naperville, IL: Sourcebooks Casablanca, 2012), 119ff. For summary, see Sandy Smith, “Forget Sex: The Secret to a Long-Lasting Marriage Is Space,” Sydney Morning Herald, November 6, 2012, https://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/forget-sex-the-secret-to-a-longlasting-relationship-is-space-20121105-28tle.html. For the Early Years of Marriage Project web page, go to http://projects.isr.umich.edu/eym/.
8. Jürgen Moltmann, The Living God and the Fullness of Life (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2015), 119.
9. “With his shameful, chaotic, horrible death he has gone to the very bottom, to the darkest and deepest place of ruin, and has planted there the sign that says ‘Rescued.’ ” N. T. Wright, Christians at the Cross (Frederick, MD: Word Among Us Press, 2008), 57.
10. “Hand,” https://www.biblestudytools.com/dictionary/hand/, accessed August 5, 2018.
