Chapter 11 of 14

6. Why We Do This: Passion as the Labor of Joy

6. Why We Do This: Passion as the Labor of Joy

Wesley W. Ellis, Justin Forbes, and Abigail Visco Rusert with Kenda Creasy Dean

It would be nice, and fairly nearly true, to say that “from that time forth Eustace was a different boy.” To be strictly accurate, he began to be a different boy. He had relapses. There were still many days when he could be very tiresome. But most of those I shall not notice. The cure had begun.

—C. S. Lewis1

This is the tremendous mystery of faith that Christians celebrate: that joy springs from anguish, that love abounds in passion, that life comes from death, that hope hallows despair.

—Kenda Creasy Dean2

The pages you’ve been reading began as a reflection on the core concepts laid out in Kenda Creasy Dean’s 2004 book Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church. The focus of that book was passion, defined as love worthy of suffering—the passion of youth, and the need for the church to recover its own by participating in Christ’s passion. Exploring the steadfast, ecstatic, and intimate dimensions of human passion through the theological lenses of fidelity, transcendence, and communion, Dean asserts: “Joy, not suffering, provides the proper perspective on passion.”3

To risk love is to risk death. If there is a formula for human happiness, this is it. For in risking death out of love—in risking passion—we find freedom and joy, the ecstasy of love returned that far exceeds love given.4

We wanted to tease out the connection between passion and joy, so we used the three theological themes of Practicing Passion—fidelity, transcendence, and communion—to guide us toward practices that help us rediscover the joy of youth ministry. The picture Dean painted describing young people’s search for passion basically stayed the same; we just gave the conversation a different filter . . . kind of like Instagram.

Peeling for Joy: What Youth Ministry Is For

As it turns out, joy—like passion—is not all sunshine and rainbows. Just as passion has a double meaning, containing not only the depth of God’s affection but the suffering and death of Jesus, joy also contains not only the happiness of friendship, celebration, and embrace but also the pain of these practices—the pain of peeling back dragon scales. Passion and joy, as it turns out, are two sides of the same coin. Joy is the impetus of passion, and passion is the labor of joy in a broken world.

Dean’s definition of passion as loving something enough to willingly suffer for it is the undercurrent of this book. In a broken world in search of itself, suffering is implied. But the point of ministry—and certainly the point of the Christian life—is never suffering; it is joy. God’s “dream come true,” as Father Gregory Boyle puts it, is a world bathed in the joy and wonder of human connection.5 Joy is the “why” of our work. What is youth ministry for? Youth ministry is for joy—God’s joy, and ours, as we join in God’s delight of the young people we work with. This delight is not always easy. In fact, loving youth enough to willingly suffer in their stead is often gut-wrenchingly hard. But it is also the most joy-inspiring, awe-inducing, heart-healing, glee-giving, life-giving work we have ever done.

As I mentioned earlier, when I (Wes) was in high school, I was a wrestler—which meant being part of a fellowship that took pride in being a little odd. Any wrestler will tell you, it’s not a sport for the masses. It’s certainly not as glamorous as football. I was on the football team as well, and it’s safe to say that people’s general reaction to the phrase “I play football” was a little different from their reaction to “I am a wrestler.” People in the United States kind of get football. But your average Joe or Joanna is often perplexed by wrestling. “Isn’t that the sport with the leotards?” (they’re called singlets, by the way, and no, it’s nothing like the WWE).

I loved all sports, but it was wrestling that captivated me most. CrossFit had nothing on the wrestlers of Ramona High School; we took pride in being the hardest-working team in school. We regularly got up at five thirty in the morning to go for a run together before school. In the off-season, wrestlers without other sports obligations would sneak into the gym right after school, roll out the mats, and hold their own unofficial practices, complete with conditioning drills. After homework was finished in the evenings, we got together to lift weights. One of my teammates convinced me that a great workout would be to drive his F250 pickup truck up on to the soccer field and then take turns pushing it around while it was in neutral to see who could push it the fastest. This was all routine for Ramona High wrestlers. If any of us felt like slacking off, we’d remind each other that our opponents were also pushing pickups around soccer fields, and that would usually get us back to work.

During wrestling season, things became even more intense. You would think football players, after conditioning all fall, would be in decent shape for winter wrestling, but not so. The first day of wrestling practice brought our school’s most seasoned football stars to their knees. Our warm-up alone was tougher than most teams’ practices, consisting of sprints up and down a steep hill, about a mile from campus, ten or fifteen times. If we were going to be wrestlers, we knew we were going to need to toughen up. Wrestling was tough. The practices were tough, the matches were tough, the schedule, the pressure, the bruises (and let’s not even get into cutting weight)—all of it was tough. When people asked me if I liked wrestling, my typical response was “No.”

Wait—no?

Why work so hard and dedicate so much time for something you don’t even like? Because I didn’t like it . . . I loved it. I didn’t like the pain of practice. I didn’t like the schedule, the pressure, the bruises. Who likes suffering? But I loved the joy that came with wrestling. I loved the joy of friendship with my teammates; of the celebration at the end of a tournament; of belonging to a team that sacrificed for each other, that confessed and forgave one another’s shortcomings; and yes, of getting my hand raised after a match. I loved it.

If you ask me if I like youth ministry, at least on one level I’d have to say no. Who likes suffering? I don’t like lock-ins or dealing with helicopter parents. I don’t like being blamed every time a toilet in the church gets clogged or a window gets broken. And no, I don’t like holding a young person who has just lost a sibling or a parent who’s just lost her daughter. No. I don’t like it. But I love youth ministry. It keeps bringing me back—Christ keeps bringing me back. I love the joy of friendship with and between young people, the joy of anticipating the surprise of God’s presence, the joy of embracing young people when they just need to know they belong and parents when they feel like failures. Without suffering, none of this joy would exist.

Suffering and Joy: Strange Bedfellows?

It’s counterintuitive to associate joy and suffering. In youth ministry it is easy to bifurcate the two, associating joy with the “fun stuff” and suffering with the “heavy stuff.” But pastoral theologian Mary Clark Moschella speaks for youth ministers, too, when she says, “Joy seems to be a comparatively lightweight topic, unrelated to human suffering and the need for pastoral care. Yet . . . lived experiences of suffering and joy are not polar opposites, but often close companions.”6 We know this in our bones. God’s joy beckons us to the front line of suffering, to passion—to a love worthy of suffering. This is because God invites us into God’s own self, and in the very fiber of God’s being, God is joyful—which is exactly why God suffers.

Even though God is a God of joy, according to Jürgen Moltmann, “the face of this world is not peace and joy. It is pain and protest.”7 So what is a joyful God to do in a joyless world? One of Moltmann’s most provocative and inspiring claims in his monumental work Theology of Hope is that “those who hope in Christ can no longer put up with reality as it is, but begin to suffer under it, to contradict it.”8 When we encounter the God of joy and begin to participate in God’s action in the world, we cannot help but swim upstream, against the currents of pain and oppression. “Compassion”—that is, passion for the sake of others—“is the other side of the living joy.”9 Knowing joy in a joyless world, trusting that joy is at the beginning of our work in ministry, not just at the end, means fighting and suffering in protest against hatred, apathy, and despair. As Moltmann eloquently puts it, “Peace with God means conflict with the world, for the goad of the promised future stabs inexorably into the flesh of every unfulfilled present.”10

Freedom from Anxiety

Passion—the self-giving, kenotic love poured out in protest of pain and despair—is what joy looks like in a broken world. It is not the suffering that keeps us coming back. It is not the protest or the anxiety of the struggle that calls us to action, but the joy received as a gift from the God whose own joy overflows into those God has made. Joy is why we stay in the game—and without it, we would burn out in short order.

The beauty of all this is that joy does not depend on us. It does not wait for us to conjure it with some magic spell or fail-safe program. Joy eradicates our need for achievement; it does not wait for the right strategy or practice to happen. “When our labor is successful,” writes Moltmann, “joy has been there at its beginning.”11 So ambition is replaced by freedom. We do not do ministry out of some need or desire for achievement but out of the simple freedom we enjoy through Christ. In this, we are called to what Brother Roger of Taizé refers to as a “spirit of poverty,” which is “found in the joy of a [person] who trusts in God” and keeps us from “cherishing a human ambition.”12 Instead of coming to youth ministry ambitious to prove our worth to God, to youth, to parents, and to ourselves, youth ministry predicated on joy allows us to come before God empty-handed, trusting God’s joy to be sufficient for young people even when ours is not.

It is natural to approach ministry out of anxiety. For youth ministers, the reasons to be anxious can seem endless. Our culture locates every possible social problem with the young, who find themselves facing down the barrel of a gun both figuratively and literally, as #marchforourlives reminded us. The “nones” are here; social media cultivates previously unimagined vulnerabilities among youth; young adults are alienated from churches. The survival of the church is out of our control, and many North American congregations are getting smaller, older, and poorer. In the United States, shrinking church budgets and staffs suggest that professional youth ministers will be job hunting in the not-so-distant future; today’s flourishing congregations are often found in immigrant communities and nondenominational or new denominational traditions that, for theological and economic reasons, do not cultivate professional youth ministers.13

Youth ministers, it would seem, have lots of reasons to panic. But if joy is youth ministry’s starting point, not just its outcome, then we can rejoice in the fact that the shape of the body of Christ is being molded by God’s hands, not ours. While we are called to passionately and compassionately respond to, and sometimes even protest, devastating circumstances confronting youth, in youth ministry joy replaces fear. When we approach youth ministry as an opportunity to share in God’s delight of young people, our gaze shifts. Instead of fearfully helping young people and the church survive, youth ministry moves away from being a tool for ecclesial survival and toward being an occasion for friendship, celebration, confession—practices that help young people (and help us) experience God’s delight. Replacing our anxiety about survival with a surrender to divine delight—in other words, trusting God’s overflowing joy to be sufficient for us as well—enables us to move into the unknown, into God’s newness, without fear. After all, our ministries with young people are intended to bear witness to God’s resurrection, not to serve as a church improvement plan.

This confidence in the resurrection frees us to creatively and passionately follow Christ, unshackled by fears about church decline or names on a roster. When we do youth ministry not because we have to but because we get to, we have landed at the heart of the matter. Youth ministry is not compulsory. As a teenage wrestler, I had no problem quitting if I didn’t think a team or a class was worth my time. I didn’t wrestle because I had to; I wrestled for the joy of it. So, with reckless abandon, I threw my heart and soul into it. In the same way, we can choose to throw our hearts and souls into youth ministry precisely because we are free not to do so. We are free to live as humans created in God’s image, released from the need to save the world, the church, ourselves, or our young people. “In the Christian way of thinking,” Moltmann says, “the so-called final purpose of history is then no purpose at all. It is the liberation of life which the law had made subject to purposes and achievements, to the all-quickening joy of God.”14 Moving human ambition and anxiety out of the center of youth ministry enables us to fully “practice passion” and engage in the mission of God. The church, unhindered by concerns about institutional survival, is free to go beyond itself and be for others—to be that one institution on the planet that exists precisely for those who do not yet belong to it.

Missional Passion: Learning to Exhale

This is our witness: to live in that joyful freedom that compels the church to continue to reimagine itself. But liberation can be tricky. We can listen in as the disciples wrestle with this new identity—a freedom that was as new to them as it is to us. In the first chapter of Acts, we read how concerned Jesus’s disciples were with getting the show on the road; it seemed that it was time to do this thing and have the kingdom restored to Israel. “So when they had come together, they asked him, ‘Lord, is this the time when you will restore the kingdom to Israel?’ ” (Acts 1:6).

I (Justin) can sympathize. I have prayed this prayer plenty of times: “Lord, let’s do this thing!” Isn’t it high time that God makes all wrong things right? Isn’t it about time God showed up to fix the pain and suffering we witness all around us? Every youth minister has prayed some version of this prayer. When we love the young people around us, we cannot help but cry out on their behalf, begging for their restoration, their healing. I have definitely prayed this prayer for the kids we have loved in foster care. Yet it is seldom answered the way that I desire. I imagine the disciples were perplexed, maybe even disappointed, by Jesus’s response as well. This question about timing and urgency was instead met with a promise:

“It is not for you to know the times or periods that the Father has set by his own authority. But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.” (Acts 1:7–8)

Just as Israel set their sights on a conquering Messiah who would restore power to Israel, we want God to show up. We want God’s kingdom to come in full power and rescue the young people we love. Yet while our hope and confidence are in the reality of the coming kingdom of God, in the meantime we are sent out as witnesses to this good news. Witnesses. This is a complicated word, and I imagine every reader of this book has encountered a dozen different definitions (many of which they have no desire to associate themselves with!). For our purposes, let’s imagine witnesses as those who point beyond themselves to what God has done, simply relaying the message of God’s work in the world.15 We can examine our ministries as attempting to faithfully bear witness to the gospel. When our understanding of mission is grounded in love and not fear, it means our ministries bear witness to the objects of God’s love, namely, the young people God has set before us.

But there is more.

If the church exists primarily for those who do not yet belong to it, then the church is also called to bear witness to young people who are not yet set before us. We are sent as “God-bearers,” people God calls to bear witness to the transforming work of the Holy Spirit, not just to Jerusalem but to Judea and Samaria, to the high school and the correctional facility, to families and recovery centers, and to the ends of the earth.16 The love of God always pushes further and further out to those our society has excluded. For us to faithfully bear witness to the ends of the earth—whatever those ends look like in our own communities—we must wrestle not just with the why of our ministries but also with the what and the how.

My wife, Bethany, struggles with these questions as she walks alongside teenage mothers in our community. These girls feel alienated from the church; frankly, they feel like they do not belong to anybody. They feel unwanted, and sadly, they are often right; most churches have no idea what to do with fifteen-year-old single mothers living on welfare, many of whom are homeless and are desperately in need in every way imaginable. It is hard to imagine these young women fitting into an average youth group. So a local church partnered with Young Life, and together they have begun discerning how to make room for these young women.

The why of this ministry was clear: these teenagers and their babies are beloved children of God for whom Christ died. But discerning the what and the how of this ministry presented some challenges. For these young women to participate in the life of a congregation, issues like transportation, child care, and meals all needed to be considered. A typical Young Life club or church youth group made no sense for girls whose deepest concerns had shifted dramatically from their previous lives as teenagers. Day-to-day issues of pregnancy, delivery, and parenthood leapt to the surface.

Of course, the adults in the ministry learned this the hard way after a few evenings that might charitably be described as “total flops.” What they discovered was that the girls really just wanted space to be together, to share a meal, and to talk about all the different questions and concerns they had as they wandered into a new phase of life. It became clear that some basic parenting skills would be helpful, and that the best way to support these young women was not through a traditional youth group but through relationships with mentors who walked with them, loved them, and sometimes sat with them in the delivery room. Even the proclamation of the gospel needed to be reimagined, as the women leading the group grappled with what it meant to talk—not just to teenage girls—but to young moms and moms-to-be. Eventually, evening messages began to address how the gospel of Jesus Christ changed the way their children could be experienced, as gifts and as children of God themselves.

The development of this ministry was a beautiful, messy, inspiring thing to witness. There were a bunch of mistakes, and on plenty of nights Bethany came home discouraged and frustrated by new challenges that had come to light. What kept Bethany going back, failure after failure, was the joy of loving these young teenage mothers—and as a result, a new form of ministry was birthed. The good news of Jesus Christ reshaped youth ministry into the likeness of a pregnant woman. Given the fact that every youth ministry is pregnant with hope and unexpected possibilities for bearing witness, I wonder if the metaphor is helpful for youth ministry in general. Maybe this is what being faithful witnesses to the ends of the earth looks like.

Joyful Labor: Catch and Release

If you are like me (Abigail), when you read a youth ministry book, your temptation is to look for the pieces of the puzzle that solve your current needs as a youth pastor (preferably before Wednesday at 6:00 p.m.). You need a lesson for youth group; is there anything here you can use? You need a creative way to train your volunteers; could this chapter speak to them? We have suggested something more fundamental. Making joy the starting point of youth ministry reimagines its very heartbeat in the Western church. Hear us out: engaging the gospel on Wednesday night and training volunteers are vitally important. But to be the church with young people also requires some sleeve rolling and creative energy from some of the most capable and innovative folks we know: youth ministers.

What, at the end of the day, is the aim and purpose of ministry with young people? We hope you have heard our position in these pages: the aim of our ministry with young people is a joyful life, a life that reflects the joy of God, whose love for us is manifest in Jesus Christ and whose Spirit stirs us to joyful response. Stated differently, when we help youth practice joy, young people encounter the God who delights in them, who begins to shape them into delight-full people—people who enjoy the God who enjoys them. It is not a panacea, of course. We are told that Eustace’s encounter with Aslan made him a “different boy.” There were relapses, of course, Lewis notes. But “the cure had begun.”17

Investing in the lives of young people is like a process of catch and release, embrace and liberation. God pitches young people our way, and our role as youth ministers is to wrap our glove around them in love, exactly where and as they are. To “catch” youth in this way, to make room for them in our glove, is an act of radical hospitality and true friendship. We celebrate their presence even as we try to teach them the way of Christ, making space for them in the life of the church. Yet as every ball player knows, a live ball must be held lightly. Embrace cannot become seizure. We cannot clutch young people in our care, for we must also let them go. In this moment—the moment in which we confess where our work falls short and God’s work exceeds us—we release young people to God. We have (hopefully) shown them the church’s witness and blessed them for the work God calls them to in the world. If we do this well, youth will have not simply experienced God’s joy in them; they will have enacted it for others along the way. The point is not for youth ministry to capture youth but to release them into the arms of God.

A funny thing happens in this moment of release, for young people and for us. We are met by a simultaneous rush of grief and anxiety—and joy. Yes, we must let go of young people who have won our hearts. Yes, ministry is not ours to control. Yes, we must unleash ourselves from fears we have come to love. Yes, we are uncertain how to navigate a world where the fences have been removed. And yet, in release, we also taste liberation. No longer captive to survival anxiety, we are free to follow Jesus in taking risks, traveling new roads, and becoming God-bearers in unscripted and unexpected ways, as we abandon that inner editor that says no to the new.

New Visions for Youth Ministry

Youth ministers often struggle with the youth ministry “industry,” recognizing its tendency to reflect our culture of spectacle that entraps young people (and often youth leaders) rather than frees them. Youth ministry, obviously, is not immune to our culture’s relentless need to produce, achieve, or manufacture experiences that pass for joy—but that are ultimately cheap and fleeting imitations. We have known for some time the blessings and shortcomings of equating youth ministry with youth groups. Youth groups socialize teenagers in ways that serve them well in our culture; they provide them with positive role models, expand their social networks, and teach them to interact with adults outside their own families. If the objective of youth ministry is to form people who are nice, who feel good about themselves, but for whom God stays in the background, then youth group seems to work just fine.18

If, however, our aim is joy—specifically the joy of life with God, the kind of flourishing that comes from lives patterned on the life, death, and resurrection (or passion) of Jesus Christ—then we must aim for something more. If you talk to youth ministers who have made this leap of faith—for whom practices like friendship, celebration, and confession have redirected their ministries away from icebreakers in the church basement and toward Jesus’s focus on joy and human flourishing—you will discover that they share an enviable sense of freedom that allows them to simultaneously cherish the church while moving young people beyond the usual parameters of youth ministry. These leaders have one moment in common: the moment they surrendered their ministries to God, who tore open their old skins to reveal something more devastatingly beautiful, and tender, underneath—something much closer to what they had hoped ministry would be like.

For example, Matt Overton, a pastor at Columbia Presbyterian Church in Vancouver, Washington, turned his congregation’s youth ministry on its ear when he shifted the church’s youth group–focused fellowship program to something closer to the felt needs of local teenagers: having a job. “I was terrified that I had taken too big a risk in launching a social enterprise and mentoring program at my church,” Matt admits. He remembers driving down the road “having an emotional crisis,” thinking about all the times his congregants, friends, and family had been crushed or wounded while “taking risks for the kingdom.”

So, no, allowing God to remove the dragon scales, acculturation, old habits, and safe patterns that often encrust our ministries is no panacea. “And yet,” Matt says, “there have been so many moments in this journey when faithful risk seems to have been accompanied by a curious kind of abundance.” Six years in, the Columbia Future Forge now houses several teen social enterprises and gives youth paid positions and job training in landscaping and drone flying (among others). More importantly, these youth each receive faithful adult mentors who work alongside and invest in them, as they share the process of discipleship formation and vocational discernment together.19 The educational environment of youth group, in which learning activities, conversations, and intergenerational relationships all must be artificially structured, is replaced by the educational environment of the job site, in which learning activities, conversations, and intergenerational relationships emerge naturally from the task at hand.

Sharing a commitment to a task creates relational consistency that is hard to come by in church groups, and focusing on the work at hand allows both youth and adults to lower their guard. “It was some of the most equal sharing between teens and adults that I have ever seen,” Matt says, remembering his first summer with Mowtown, the landscaping business he created with youth from the community. “A 60-something retired airplane pilot shared his thoughts about the future. Teens talked about the pressure and stress of trying to get into college. A couple of young people said they needed to make money to help their struggling families.”

The growing edge now . . . is helping mentors learn to link personal goals to the life of faith. There are many points of deep intersection between work life and faith. We’re talking about recovering from mistakes, accepting grace, taking risks versus playing it safe, resolving conflict, extending forgiveness, helping our neighbors, striving to achieve versus learning to be content.20

Matt experiences this approach to youth ministry as “a joyous tightrope walk”—which captures some of the spiritual tension that joyful youth ministry entails, existing as it does somewhere between pain and exhilaration.21 Another Presbyterian youth minister, Matt McNelly, also imagined a job-based youth ministry, in which young teenagers learn to fish by catching pikeminnows, predators that threaten the salmon hatcheries on the Columbia River (the local wildlife commission pays them from four to eight dollars per fish). Spending the summer on a church pontoon boat with an inexperienced crew of middle-high teens might be a job that only a youth pastor could love—but Matt does indeed love it. Time on the boat allows for in-depth Bible discussions around fishing stories, but it also is hard physical labor. “I have never in my life been this tired,” Matt confessed to me (Kenda) during his first summer with Go Fish. “And,” he added, “I have never in my life had this much fun.”

Try Pie, a youth ministry/pie bakery (yes, you heard that right), was launched in 2014 by two churches in Cedar Falls and Waterloo, Iowa—a city USA Today once called the “worst city for black Americans” in the United States.22 Megan Tensen, then a twenty-three-year-old youth pastor at Orchard Hill Church, was excited about a ministry to help girls address painful racial and economic divisions in their community. But what should it look like? Sarah Turner, codirector of Try Pie, felt that the conventional way of doing youth ministry to youth rather than with youth was losing relevance. But there were few templates for alternative models.

The teenagers themselves offered a solution: pie. The first time they tried to make crust, Megan remembers, “It didn’t go too well. . . . We were aiming for 75 to 100 pies. We made five.” Teens are paid for their time making and selling pies, and for time spent in class, learning about faith practices and life skills like résumé writing and budgeting. But Try Pie is not primarily a job site or a discussion group about race and privilege. It is a youth ministry that seeks to give girls a diversity of friendships and life skills, and an income that validates the importance of their work together. Megan observes:

We end our shifts eating together each night. . . . Faith development happens during relationship building and eating together. We’ve seen the girls talk about race and how it’s impacted their lives. This is a safe space where it can happen.

The teens concur. “Try Pie makes me happy,” says ninth grader Erin Ochoa. “These girls are my best friends.” Junior Allison Stuenkel nods. “I can be myself. We make friends you wouldn’t otherwise meet. Also, we break out into song a lot.”23

We do this for joy.

The Cost of Cultivating Joy

New visions for youth ministry start at the nexus of anxiety and liberation. There is a direct link between joy and the freedom to imagine new realities, to imagine the world God intends over and against the world that is. We teach young people the stories of faith for this reason: to expand their horizons beyond their own imaginations toward the life of joy God has imagined for us. Yet joy and suffering always walk side by side. Practicing passion—participating in Christ’s sacrificial, self-giving love through practices of fidelity, transcendence, and intimacy (reimagined in our ministries as practices of friendship, celebration, and confession)—points to joy precisely because it is costly. Eustace reimagines who he is and is forever changed, precisely because he has walked in the footsteps of the dragon. He has felt the pain, and the relief, of shedding his thick and knobbly dragon skin.

To become a new creation—as humans, as churches, as teenagers, as youth ministers—cuts deeply. But the result is the unbridled, unfathomable joy of sharing in God’s delight—the God who strips off our protective layers, frees us from our dragon skins, and gives us a glimpse of the creatures God intended us to be. And when, by God’s grace, we get to witness this process with a young person, the experience (to quote Eustace) is so “perfectly delicious” that we barely notice God has taken away the pain—theirs, and ours. There are relapses, of course. But this is how we begin.

1. C. S. Lewis, The Voyage of the “Dawn Treader” (San Francisco: HarperCollins, 1994), 112.

2. Kenda Creasy Dean, Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004), 198.

3. Dean, Practicing Passion, 44.

4. Dean, Practicing Passion, 140.

5. Gregory Boyle, Barking to the Choir: The Power of Radical Kinship (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2017), 12.

6. Mary Clark Moschella, “Calling and Compassion: Elements of Joy in Lived Practices of Care,” in Joy and Human Flourishing: Essays on Theology, Culture, and the Good Life, ed. Miroslav Volf and Justin E. Crisp (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2015), 98.

7. Jürgen Moltmann, “Christianity: A Religion of Joy,” in Volf and Crisp, Joy and Human Flourishing, 14.

8. Jürgen Moltmann, Theology of Hope (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993), 21.

9. Moltmann, “Christianity,” 14.

10. Moltmann, Theology of Hope, 21.

11. Jürgen Moltmann, Theology and Joy (London: SCM, 1973), 44.

12. Brother Roger of Taizé, The Dynamic of the Provisional (Oxford: A. R. Mowbray, 1981), 39, 57.

13. Cf. Mark Gornik and Geoman K. George, “Passing Down the Faith in the New Immigrant Church,” Faith and Leadership, November 3, 2015, https://www.faithandleadership.com/mark-r-gornik-and-geomon-k-george-passing-down-faith-new-immigrant-church.

14. Moltmann, Theology and Joy, 56.

15. For more on the Christian life as defined by witness, see Darrell Guder, Be My Witnesses (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1985).

16. For a discussion of the role of youth ministers as “God-bearers,” an image based on the Orthodox understanding of Mary as theotokos, see Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster, The Godbearing Life: The Art of Soul-Tending in Youth Ministry (Nashville: Upper Room, 1998).

17. Lewis, Voyage of the “Dawn Treader,” 112.

18. For one study outlining the benefits and shortcomings of youth groups, see Patricia Snell, “What Difference Does Youth Group Make? A Longitudinal Analysis of Religious Youth Group Participation Outcomes,” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 48, no. 3 (September 2009): 572–87.

19. Matt tells the full story of this shift in his ministry in his book Mentorship and Marketplace: A New Direction for Youth Ministry (San Diego: Youth Cartel, 2019).

20. Matt Overton, “Work Is a Great Vehicle for Mentoring Teens,” Faith and Leadership, November 29, 2016, https://www.faithandleadership.com/matt-overton-work-great-vehicle-mentoring-teens, and “How Social Enterprise Has Changed My Congregation and Me,” Faith and Leadership, November 14, 2017, https://www.faithandleadership.com/matt-overton-how-social-enterprise-has-changed-my-congregation-and-me.

21. Overton, “How Social Enterprise Has Changed My Congregation and Me.”

22. Samuel Stebbins and Evan Comen, “These Are the 15 Worst Cities for Black Americans,” USA Today, updated February 27, 2019, https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2018/11/16/racial-disparity-cities-worst-metro-areas-black-americans/38460961/.

23. Susan Flansburg, “Try Pie Helps Iowa Teens Build Bonds across Racial and Economic Divides,” Faith and Leadership, January 10, 2017, https://www.faithandleadership.com/try-pie-helps-iowa-teens-build-bonds-across-racial-and-economic-divides.

↑ Back to top

↑