Chapter 6 of 14

Intermezzo: From Sorrow to Celebration

Intermezzo: From Sorrow to Celebration

Abigail Visco Rusert

Give sorrow words; the grief that does not speak knits up the o’er wrought heart and bids it break.

—William Shakespeare, Macbeth

We don’t think of death as something to celebrate. It’s the people who rush to the “celebrating life” sentiment at funerals who piss us off the most when we’ve experienced a traumatic loss. Our struggle lies in the fact that death seems to defy rationality—especially when it’s a young person who has died. We do not rejoice over the death of a young person.

The feeling in that hospital room was a far cry from joy. When a teenager who is helping wash dishes after dinner suddenly falls on the floor and is rushed to the emergency room, a family doesn’t expect to end up in the neurological intensive care unit. They don’t think they’ll hear phrases like “ruptured brain aneurysm” or “medically induced coma.” There’s not much that can prepare a parent for the moment when the parent has to make a decision about whether or not to keep a daughter on life support.

But there we were. They—the family in shock. I—the young chaplain.

We spent two days together in the intensive care unit, surrounded by beeping machines and neighboring rooms filled with silence. Most of the patients in a neurological intensive care unit are sedated in some way. Traumatic brain injuries and aneurysms often require surgery. And they also require what feels like an endless amount of waiting. Waiting for any sign of change—or life. It’s the family members of the patients who break the silence.

As Talia lay sedated in her hospital bed, family members and friends poured in and out all day. Her mom, Alina, remained a constant fixture in the room. I remember having to assure her that it was okay to leave her daughter if she needed to go to the bathroom. Talia was young: headed to college and filled with hopeful anticipation for the future. She was surrounded by a loving, supportive family. She was in love. She simply defied the statistics of who usually suffers from a ruptured brain aneurysm.

Over and over again Talia’s family expressed their shock. I was the only stranger to her story during her hospital stay, so I became a vessel for the voices of those who wanted to talk about her life. I heard about Talia’s gentle personality, her generosity, her quirks, and how she was learning to bake. She was the good kid in the family—the one who helped her mom after her parents’ relationship fell apart. And help she did, with things like the dishes. On a day like any other, in the middle of dinnertime cleanup, Talia collapsed. There were no warning signs save a headache that day. Her presence in the hospital bed was almost unimaginable.

I stayed two hours past my shift to sit with the family that first day and then debriefed the night chaplain on duty. I was an intern for the summer, and this was by far the youngest patient I’d had on my unit. I remember walking out of the hospital building where the ICU was housed and into the sweltering August heat of Philadelphia. The city grates spit hot air at me as I made my way to the main hospital building to grab my purse. It wasn’t the first time I’d shed tears while walking down the street after leaving my assigned building, but it was the first time I audibly sobbed in front of store owners and evening commuters.

The next day, I spotted immediately the telling looks on the doctors’ and nurses’ faces.

We were going to lose this one.

My shift was technically over, but I didn’t care. We stood holding hands in a circle after Alina decided, in consultation with the doctors, to turn off the machines that were singularly sustaining her daughter Talia’s life. All summer I’d been practicing the prayerful technique that my boss taught me for patients with whom I couldn’t verbally communicate: breathing. I’d been breathing in time with patients and directing my thoughts and silent prayers to be as present to them as possible. But this family didn’t want me to breathe with their beloved. They wanted me to pray. Out loud.

It seemed too sacred a moment for me, the young pastor-in-training, to take up words. I’d prayed with them the day before, but on that day our prayers were held together by hope and happy memories. I wanted to honor the moment we were sharing on this day, as we waited for Talia’s breath to run out. It wasn’t a moment of hope. It wasn’t a moment of joy.

I can’t remember the words I used over ten years ago at that bedside. I remember that my words contained no platitudes, that tears slowly fell from my eyes as I spoke them, and that we recited the Lord’s Prayer together at the end. I remember that we didn’t rush away from that moment. We held hands for what seemed like a long time. Sometimes it takes a few minutes for the breath of life to leave a body. We continued to hold our circle, and each other’s hands, as Talia’s breath ran out. Every one of us cried.

That night I did something I hadn’t done in a while: I picked up my guitar. The words wouldn’t come for another week or so, but the music did. Twelve years later I’ve long lost the notebook paper on which the lyrics are written. But if you handed me a guitar, I’d be able to play most of Alina’s song.

I’ve often wondered how the family and friends left that space. I’ve wondered about Alina’s life after losing her daughter, about Talia’s boyfriend, and the cousins, aunts, and uncles with whom she was so close. My wonder is reflected in the guitar chords that shift from minor to major and back again throughout the song I wrote so long ago. Mostly now I wonder at the vivid memory of that hospital room, where our sustenance was the stories told—the stories that pieced together Talia’s life for an audience of loved ones and one avid listener. There is beauty in that wonder, and deep gratitude for the invitation into a family’s most sacred moments.

Most youth ministers have walked around in these stories of grief. We’ve sat with a family who has lost a young person, or a young person who has lost a friend or family member. These parts of our youth ministry are not often associated with joy. But I think we are remiss if we don’t see the connection between sorrow and joy. Joy is not a state at which we arrive after a long road of happy memories are strung together. It can be—but it is not limited to that. Sometimes joy takes time to surface in the wake of grief. It is borne in what Dietrich Bonhoeffer would call gratitude: the precious gift of beauty unearthed in the stories we’ve shared and the God-ordained permissions we’ve had to live life together for a time. In suffering and death we do not celebrate the loss itself—we celebrate the shared experiences of love before, after, and in the midst of the lives who have touched us in the most profound ways.

Neuroscientists talk about the plasticity of the brain: the ability that the human brain has to change throughout life. The brain can respond to growth and (some) injuries by rewiring itself for renewed functionality. I think that joy is found in the plasticity of our sorrow: the capacity of God to work wonder and beauty from the dark nights of our souls. Even when we are not immediately delivered from our pain, we can call on the name of the Lord. We can trust in our God as the one who abides with us—in hands held, stories shared, songs written, and prayers spoken. Now that’s something to celebrate.

↑ Back to top

↑