Chapter 10 of 14

5. Enjoying Young Dragons: Snapshots of Joyful Youth Ministries

5. Enjoying Young Dragons: Snapshots of Joyful Youth Ministries

Wesley W. Ellis, Abigail Visco Rusert, and Justin Forbes

Joy is prayer; joy is strength; joy is love; joy is the net by which you can catch souls.

—Mother Teresa1

Just a word at this point to those who are thinking, “This all sounds profound and beautiful and all, but how on earth am I really supposed to do friendship, celebration, and confession in my ministry context? Tell me what I can do . . . like, tomorrow!”

Ministry is always easier said than done. And that’s the way it should be. If your vision for ministry is small enough for you—or even a community of people—to achieve, then it’s too small. After all, when we talk about “ministry,” before we even talk about something we do, we’re talking about something God does (or more appropriately, perhaps, who God is). God is the minister! So it shouldn’t surprise us that ministry is always bigger than our possibilities. We aren’t expected to do everything that our theology and vision for ministry entail.

That being said, we do think you can do ministry out of joy. In fact, we can think of examples of people who are doing youth ministry this way. The freedom that accompanies a posture of joy in youth ministry leads naturally to a loosened imagination, so many of the most joyful ministries we know are also the most creative. In this chapter, we offer a few snapshots of youth ministries that zero in on some of the practices of joy we have named in this volume. We offer them not as examples to be cloned or duplicated but as prods to your imagination as you become more intentional about practicing joy in your ministry. You’ll notice that our categories are fuzzy and there is substantial cross-pollination between them. Practices of friendship often have characteristics of celebration and confession, and practices of confession can sound suspiciously like friendship and celebration. What unites these practices is a desire for young people to live in God’s joy—and the fact that a bunch of joyful youth ministers dreamed them up.

Practicing Friendship: The Art of “Even If ” Relationships

Young people inevitably think about joy in the context of friendship. As we suggested in chapter 2, friendship in youth ministry is not a mistake. Properly understood—namely, as a free relationship that embraces difference (even across generations)—friendship lies at the heart of youth ministry. Young people need relationships that aren’t based on necessity, conditions, or transactions. They long for fidelity, the “even if” kind of relationship that remains steadfast in spite of whatever dragon scales we wrap ourselves in. Young people should find these friendships in the Christian community, especially since such relationships are elusive in our meritocratic and achievement-oriented society. The youth workers in the ministries below practice “even if” friendships by honoring their responsibility as adults without sacrificing their ability to delight in young people in ways that reflect God’s delight in them.

Changing the First Question

A few years ago in Bend, Oregon, a small group of churches from a variety of ecclesial traditions decided to become friends. They already had youth ministries of their own, but they wondered what it would be like to do youth ministry together. Rather than just doing a one-off event or going to camp together once during the summer, like many churches do, these churches decided to form one big collaborative youth ministry, with weekly gatherings, a staff, volunteers, and all the other trappings of youth programs! What came from their collaboration was eventually called the Bend Youth Collective (BYC): a youth ministry made up of young people from throughout the surrounding community. Over the years, under the leadership of Morgan Schmidt, BYC has cultivated a space that embodies fidelity and the befriending of difference, insisting that “every voice matters.”2 Young people who walk into BYC are not accepted on the condition that they decide to conform their desires to the mission of the ministry. Rather, they are accepted from the very beginning. In fact, one of BYC’s favorite slogans is “we love you already.”3 The relationship is free, and youth workers seek to encounter each young person with expectation and curiosity.

In this way, BYC has fostered a youth ministry with real friendship at its heart. It’s an “even if” kind of youth ministry where young people can experience the fidelity of the church toward them. Youth workers remain adults and young people remain young people, but despite their difference, a real friendship takes shape because Schmidt and her colleagues aren’t just trying to make young people into good Christians; they’re actually taking interest—delighting—in the young people with whom they minister. They expect God to already be present in the lives of each and every young person who walks through the doors. They assume that young people’s desires are inherently good—if sometimes misdirected—and they endeavor to take genuine interest in young people’s experience. One of the key ways in which they’ve cultivated this kind of ministry is by changing their first question.

Often, our first question as youth workers is about young people’s affiliation with the church or participation in ministry programs. How can I get this young person to go to camp? How can I involve him in my Bible study and teach him about Jesus? How can I make sure she develops a faith that will keep her going to church after she graduates? It makes sense that these would be our questions. After all, church participation has become the primary metric for measuring the faith of young people and the overall “success” of youth ministry in Western society. According to Andrew Root, in this “secular age” of ours, our very concept of faith is driven by sociological rather than theological concerns, even among theologians. “To not have faith is to not go to church or at least to not directly affiliate with an institutional collective (it is to catch a case of the Nones).”4 Faith itself is reduced to affiliation. So we come up with strategies for participation, attaching all new adjectives to describe faith. As Root puts it, “we need faith that is robust, vital, and sticky so young people continue to believe, and participate, in such a way that the space of the religious is maintained.”5 So it makes perfect sense that our first questions would be about affiliation and participation.

There’s nothing necessarily wrong with these questions, in and of themselves. But when they become our first questions, our motivation, we risk missing out on what God is already doing in the lives of young people and, more importantly, we risk making our ministry about our ministry rather than about the young people with whom we minister, thus marginalizing those young people who aren’t willing to be faithful to the church without experiencing the fidelity of others toward them. Faith and fidelity, after all, are not just about affiliation or participation. “Faith is joy in the divine fullness of life”6—even if it shows up outside the programs of the church. And fidelity is about God coming to us as a minister, delighting in us as a friend.

Friendship, like fidelity, isn’t about joining some other mission or just participating in a church program. “[Friendship] is a category that falls outside the framework of calculable social systems.”7 This means that we don’t have to find ways of making faith look appealing so that people will “join” or stay; we can simply look for where God is present in the desires that young people already have. As Schmidt puts it, “If our posture of ministry is about finding ways to coerce students into faith then we’re competing with everything . . . [but] if our posture of ministry is about finding ways to cultivate adolescents’ desire for God, then the whole world becomes a playground.”8 We can expect to find God even in those desires that seem to conflict or compete with young people’s participation in church activities.

The first question of BYC is not “How can I get you onboard?” but “What do you love?” They moved from questions of affiliation to questions of love. Changing that first question makes a huge difference. The posture moves from competition to delight, from presumption to curiosity, and ultimately from transaction (“What can I get from you?”) to friendship (“I want to delight in you!”). When our first question is a transactional question (even if it’s shrouded in theological phrases like “faith formation”), then our posture of ministry becomes an anxious posture. Anxiety makes us listen to the wrong things. Instead of listening to young people in order to take joy in them, we listen to our own worries. We become preoccupied with worry over why young people aren’t coming to church or reading their Bibles enough. We can get overwhelmed by the ominous prospect that the church might “die” because people stop affiliating with it. Schmidt writes, “What if the next time a student chooses to go to soccer practice instead of youth group, we ask him what he loves about soccer, instead of guilting him or passive-aggressively noting how much we missed him?”9

Befriending the Unaffiliated

If friendship is bigger than simple affiliation, then youth ministry also needs to find ways to befriend the unaffiliated, asking fidelity’s question (“What do you love?”) even of young people who aren’t part of church programs. In other words, instead of shaming young people who choose to go to soccer practice instead of youth group, maybe we should go to soccer practice with them and celebrate their passion. In Toms River, New Jersey, a collaboration of three United Methodist churches decided, essentially, to do just that.

First United Methodist Church, Saint Andrew United Methodist Church, and Island Heights United Methodist Church—all medium-to-small churches—became used to hearing complaints and laments about how all their young people were doing sports instead of church. So they decided to start a ministry for young adults in the community called Celebrate:TR.10 The ministry is all about creating “outlets for young adults to be for others, cultivating purpose and belonging through celebrating the Toms River community.”11 Through Celebrate:TR, young adults gather together not to bring more people into affiliation with the church but to get the church into their community to celebrate God’s presence outside the church walls. Every other month or so, Celebrate:TR assembles at a local sporting event or community gathering to lavishly celebrate the teams and the organizers—but not just any sporting or community event. Celebrate:TR tries to celebrate those who don’t usually get celebrated. Whether it’s the JV girls volleyball team, the Little League baseball game, or a dinner for the people who clean the floors at the hospital, Celebrate:TR tries to bring celebration to wherever God delights in people . . . which keeps the options pretty open. Because God has befriended, delights in, and celebrates creation, these young people seek to celebrate it too.

As youth workers, your ministry does not have to be limited to church programs or to those who have decided to pledge their “fidelity” to the church. In the freedom of God’s friendship with creation, we are free to ask fidelity’s question—“What do you love?”—to the whole world. We are free to seek God’s faithfulness and friendship in the lives of the unaffiliated, befriending them and delighting in them as God delights in them.

Practicing Celebration: Noticing and Naming God’s Activity

Chapter 3 points to celebration as a practice for youth ministry. In young people’s longing for transcendence and communion with God, they need a way of noticing and celebrating the places and spaces where God is showing up. It’s no small thing to name the presence of God in our midst—especially for a young person who has never done so before. Practices of celebration in youth ministry can carve space for us to regularly name, notice, and take joy in God’s presence in young people’s lives. Ministry leaders can pattern their party plans off of Miriam when it comes to celebration. In Exodus 15, Miriam leads the community of Israelites in celebratory song. She packed her tambourine even in the rush to flee from Egypt. Joy was a priority, even when her life was on the line.

The church should be ground zero for celebratory practices, even as we face situations of pain and suffering. Youth ministers must cultivate practices of celebration so that young people connect the dots between a transcendent God and profound moments of joy. But how do we do that? What does celebration look like in youth ministry?

The Art of Extravagant Welcome

If Miriam carved intentional space on her packing list for a joyful celebration, we must carve intentional space in youth ministry for celebration too. Celebrate:TR offers one way to think about celebration in youth ministry, but there are many others. A Nashville church decided to create a regular practice of celebration. They wanted to address a need they noticed among young people—the need to feel loved. The youth director, Adam, decided to address this need from the perspective of those who walked into the youth group meeting for the first time. His goal was to transform the role of “visitor” into “honored guest.” But the adults in the group did not initiate this transformation. It was young people celebrating other young people that made all the difference. Weekly youth group regulars were trained in a practice of celebration: they called themselves the Extravaganza Squad.

The Extravaganza Squad did just what their name entails. They created a celebratory extravaganza for first-timers who showed up at youth group. A group of young people were taught to “own the atmosphere” for every newcomer. They were trained well, prepared both to answer the why and the how for this role. Once they had satisfied the initial training regimen, young people were assigned tasks: greeters, sit-with-and-eat-ers, gift givers at a welcome station, and game leaders for youth who need a kinetic outlet. And the extravaganza experience extended far beyond the first week a “new kid” would show up. Any Extravaganza Squad must contain adept noticers. They are attentive to questions like: Who seems to be on the fringes of the group? What kinds of gifts, passions, loves are represented in those who have walked through our doors for the first time? How can we best continue a process of bridge building between guests and our group? Regular training sessions for the Extravaganza Squad make it possible for celebration to signal love and bridge that love for both squad member and newcomer to the God who first welcomed and loved us.

From Program to Participation

What if your church killed the youth ministry program and replaced it with the practice of celebration? What if that celebration was the lifting up and honoring of other organizations’ youth programs? Broadway United Methodist Church in Indianapolis did just that.

To be clear—it wasn’t just the youth group that bit the dust at this church. Broadway UMC has been closing down programming for years now. Among the programs they’ve closed are their food pantry, a clothing ministry, and an after-school program. It’s not that they weren’t doing their due diligence to address their community’s needs anymore—they had actually discerned that they could have more impact if they reversed their efforts. So, instead of running a program church, Rev. Mike Mather set out to run a church whose DNA is to celebrate, honor, and bless the good work already being done in the community.

The starting place for this practice of celebration is worship. In worship, Broadway UMC honors those who have taken leadership in church programming. They have a ritual for recognizing and thanking those who have faithfully served. They also have a ritual—“A Liturgy of the Animators of the Spirit”—that is used to honor community members who are bringing life to the neighborhood. These community members are not necessarily church members. In fact, they’re not even usually church members. They have been discovered by a team of “roving listeners” and welcomed to share about their good work. They are blessed by the congregation, who shout an enthusiastic “We will!” when asked, “Will you do everything you can to support this person in her ministry?”

What makes this youth ministry? Two things: (1) The young people at this church have no set-apart program. Their youth ministry is fully integrated into the life of the congregation. What the congregation celebrates, the youth celebrate. And vice versa. While the absence of a youth group may seem like a jarring problem (churches sometimes say they don’t “do” youth ministry because they don’t have a youth group—although nothing could be further from the truth), the young people at Broadway UMC function as full-fledged community members as opposed to members-in-training. (2) The youth are given an intentional role in this process of noticing and celebrating. They are the roving listeners.

Rev. Mather describes the task of the newest roving listeners: “Those young people do three things: first, name the gifts of their neighbors; second, lay hands on them and bless them; and, third, connect them with others who care about the same thing. Name, bless, connect. Over and over again.”12 Here we have an example of a church that is not only celebrating young people but also inviting them to celebrate God’s work in the world, reaching beyond its walls to do so. The roving listener role sets young people up to cross boundaries in the name of Jesus. This practice of celebration not only joyfully recognizes a very present God who is alive and well in Indianapolis. It points young people to the possibility that the way they live and move and have their being alongside those in their community might have value that is named and noticed by the God they seek to serve.

Practicing Confession: The Relief of Removing Our Masks

Chapter 4 invites the reader to consider confession as a practice that might just shape youth ministry. The idea here is that when we face our limitations, our inabilities, and our failures, we are then and only then able to receive the forgiveness of God and the resulting assurance of pardon promised in the good news. As old things are put away and all is made new, we are free to walk alongside the young people we so dearly love. It is in this freedom that the youth worker is enabled to truly embrace young people from an honest position, recognizing that what is needed is not our embrace but rather the reconciling embrace of God. If you are asking, “So what does that look like?”—keep reading.

Doubt Night

A small youth ministry on the New Jersey Shore recently decided to reconstruct their youth group curriculum. They had been doing a traditional Bible study, moving through books of the Bible. But when one of the young people in the ministry lost her father to a heart attack, the pastor knew that the group needed to shift gears. The youth group was intimate and closely knit, and the young woman who lost her father was an integral part of the group. Not only that, but this young woman’s father had been involved in the youth ministry and the young people knew him. It was clear that the youth ministry could not continue with the status quo.

To move on as though nothing had happened or to try to offer consoling platitudes with handy Bible verses would have dishonored the situation. So they decided to build their new curriculum to center around a monthly “doubt night.” The idea was to allow a space for the group to be honest together about the doubts they were facing, especially in light of their grief and loss, and ultimately to share the place of the young woman who’d lost her father. On the first “doubt night,” the group was invited to spread around the room and write down their most “haunting” questions. On another night they were asked, “What makes it difficult to pray?” The written questions and struggles were kept anonymous and collected; the idea was that the questions would be addressed—not answered—every following “doubt night,” so that doubt would become a “part of” faith instead of its opposite.

The questions were deep and the conversations were lively, but even more interesting was what “doubt night” did to the overarching ethos of the youth ministry. “Doubt night” began to cultivate a culture of honesty and confession in the group. Young people discovered that they could voice their struggles without judgment or stigma. Doubt became the new normal, and young people learned that they weren’t alone. They began to learn that God could handle their doubt and that, sometimes, it is precisely in the moment when we confess that we feel that God is absent that we discover Christ’s presence with us. “Doubt night” revealed itself as a practice of confession, exposing hidden places and opening new spaces to the extravagant assurance of God’s forgiveness, acceptance, and grace. And, as confession is wont to do, it became contagious.

Along with “doubt night,” the new curriculum included something called “youth group,” where one of the young people was invited to lead the discussion. It wasn’t by design that “doubt night” would feed so directly into “youth group,” but as a different young person led the discussion each month, a common theme of confession emerged. Young people took “youth group” as an opportunity to share specific stories of how they were challenged in their faith by circumstances of life and (usually) how God came to them in their struggles, either through the faithfulness of friends or through more mysterious experiences of the Holy Spirit. “Doubt night” became ingrained in the fabric of youth ministry in this church to the point that youth took the initiative in testifying to God’s faithfulness in the midst of their doubts and struggles.

The contagiousness of this culture of confession found a sort of culmination when, one Sunday at the end of the school year, Youth Sunday came around—that wonderful and infamous day when the young people lead the worship service, right down to the sermon itself. Kate, a high school senior, stood and gave a short, ten-minute testimony that has since proved as effective and profound as any sermon preached by any minister of that church. She shared about her struggle with depression and anxiety, about the torment she felt from her own overthinking mind, about the week she didn’t leave her bedroom, and about how God met her through the faithfulness of friends and the gift of having a space to be accepted even in the midst of her struggle. “I know that I’ll be ok,” she said, “because I know that God is with me in the worst possible places of my life.” People seventeen to seventy have commented that Kate’s sermon pointed them to hope in their own struggles. Kate’s confession, her honesty, created room for God’s assurance.

“Doubt Night” for Youth Workers

While a “doubt night” for our young people sounds inspiring, youth are not the only ones who need a safe space to practice confession. In fact, it would be presumptuous to think that we could have a “doubt night” without affording ourselves the same freedom. It’s an odd thing that youth workers so often find themselves in a place where their own struggles with faith are not allowed. We often hear youth workers say they feel alone and isolated, not having others in the church with whom to express their own doubts, their experiences of failing in ministry, and the fears they face as they try to faithfully serve. Earlier in this book we suggested that one possible way to engage in a faithful practice of hospitality was to begin with confession, reorienting ourselves within the work of God in the world. While this is true, it can’t be done alone. While confession as a part of corporate worship is invaluable, and the weekly routine of this in worship helps us approach confession again and again, there is no substitute for the fellowship that is possible with other youth workers.

Youth workers looking for a safe space to confess their limitations in ministry (which is not the same thing as a gripe session) often spontaneously organize their own de facto “doubt nights.” I (Justin) host one such group as a part of Flagler College’s youth ministry program. A small group of youth workers from various backgrounds have lunch together monthly. Catholic, Protestant, nondenominational, and parachurch youth ministries are all represented, and our only rule is that we can’t compare ministries. Instead, one person typically describes her call to ministry or what she’s been learning, or she simply shares about her own faith journey. Then we go around the circle and share what’s been going on in ministry. Sometimes these are fun and celebratory announcements of God’s presence in plain sight. We also share the places where kids, families, or the youth workers themselves are suffering. We listen to each other and we pray. Everyone has moved beyond platitudes and clichéd anecdotes filled with empty words. There are times when the sadness lingers and we simply acknowledge the pain. Conversations have been shaped around questions like:

  • What are some difficult aspects of ministry right now?
  • What challenges are you facing with kids, volunteers, or parents?
  • Describe ways in which you felt like you were afraid or doubting.
  • Describe some moments or places where it seems that God is present.
  • Name some encouragements you have received from kids, volunteers, or parents.
  • Where in your ministry do you feel hopeful?
  • Where in your ministry do you feel at a loss?
  • Something special happens in these times together. There is a freedom in knowing that we all care deeply for young people in our community, and that we need everyone in the room (and more!) if we have any hope of faithfully walking alongside all the young people in our small town. It is those moments of sharing both the beautiful and painful aspects of life in ministry that help remind us of our vocation. It is through these vulnerable confessions—where we don’t know what to do or say or how to be there for young people—that we are reminded of our need for God.

    We always end our time together by acknowledging how special it is that we share this calling together—a vocation of ministry with and for young people. We also are aware that there are few spaces in the world today where Catholic, Presbyterian, Methodist, nondenominational, Young Life, and other youth workers are all under one roof enjoying one another. It is special. But it is grounded in confession—sharing in one another’s inability to open ourselves to God’s forgiving grace, or to the good news of assurance, as we claim our dependency upon Christ to do these things. When our gathering began, some youth workers did not see it as a good use of time, since we did not have an agenda, a clear purpose, or a desired outcome. They did not stick around long—and that was okay. Those who stayed ended up becoming deeply connected to each other and have forged an irreplaceable community with one another.

    Your Turn

    Of course, the ways we can practice friendship, celebration, and confession—the ways we help young people experience God’s fidelity, transcendence, and communion—are nearly endless; your ministry may already be quite strong in at least one of these areas, and we have a lot of confidence that you already have fifty ideas for the other ones. We invite you to have this discussion with your team: What practices of joy resonate most strongly with the young people you know? How are you incorporating them into youth ministry? Are they practices that require young people to come to church to learn, or are they practices in which young people are better served by the church coming to them? What might that look like?

    One final note: We can’t give what we don’t have. While most youth ministers are not pastors in the formal sense, we are pastors in terms of the work we do with young people, and we share many of the same habits. Findings on pastoral well-being paint a cautionary tale. Vocational friendships are highly correlated with longevity in all forms of ministry—but most pastors say they do not have one close friend.13 Pastoral satisfaction ranges from “meh” to “fine” for most pastors; two-thirds say they are somewhat or moderately happy (the number spikes close to quitting time each day).14 Pastoral narcissism appears rampant (one study found narcissism to be five hundred to three thousand times more frequent in pastors than in the general population).15 Leaders of all kinds are vulnerable to joyless work; it is quite likely that our ability to help young people practice joy depends, in part, on our ability to practice it ourselves. We, too, live under the dragon scales, which is why we will spend our final pages discussing some conditions for more joyful youth ministry—for young people and for us.

    Questions for Youth Leaders

  • What ministries do you know that restore joy with young people well? Are practices of friendship, celebration, or confession/forgiveness part of that?
  • What do you love? What do the young people in your ministry love? How can you celebrate those things?
  • What do young people experience in the first four minutes after they arrive at your church or ministry? How can you cultivate extravagant welcome?
  • Can you think of a time when “program” got in the way of actually participating in something God seemed to be doing?
  • Is there room in your context for your volunteers to acknowledge failure, confess limitations, and be reminded of God’s forgiveness? How can you help foster this within your ministry community?
  • 1. E. Le Joly, Mother Teresa—Messenger of God’s Love (Strathfield, Australia: St. Paul Publications, 2004), 55.

    2. Bend Youth Collective, “BYC Mission, Vision, and Values,” https://static1.squarespace.com/static/56ba484437013b3ea9247d27/t/5a5912e2652dea7bdd95d3da/1515786980315/BYC+Mission%2C+Vision%2C+Values+%26+Theology.pdf, accessed August 6, 2018.

    3. Bend Youth Collective, “We Love You Already,” http://bendyouthcollective.org/, accessed August 6, 2018.

    4. Andrew Root, Faith Formation in a Secular Age: Responding to the Church’s Obsession with Youthfulness (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2017), 109.

    5. Root, Faith Formation, 108.

    6. Jürgen Moltmann, The Living God and the Fullness of Life (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2015), 74.

    7. Moltmann, The Living God, 118.

    8. Morgan Schmidt, Woo: Awakening Teenagers’ Desire to Follow in the Way of Jesus (San Diego: Youth Cartel, 2014), 70–71.

    9. Schmidt, Woo, 71.

    10. This ministry was birthed through a Lilly Endowment–funded initiative through Princeton Theological Seminary called the Zoe Project. For more information on the Zoe Project, see http://zoeproject.ptsem.edu/.

    11. Celebrate:TR, www.celebratetr.org.

    12. “ ‘Roving Listeners’ and the Practice of Ministry With,” Center for Mission Innovation, January 19, 2017, http://centerformissioninnovation.org/roving-listeners-and-the-practice-of-ministry-with/. For more on Broadway UMC and Rev. Mike Mather, see Michael Mather, Having Nothing, Possessing Everything: Finding Abundant Communities in Unexpected Places (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2018).

    13. Richard J. Krejcir’s work from 1989 to 2006 sought to replicate research from Fuller Seminary with similar findings in 1998. “What Is Going On with Pastors in America?” (white paper, Francis A. Schaeffer Institute of Church Leadership Development, 2007). Summary available at http://lifechristiancounseling.com/pastors/Statistics%20on%20Pastors.pdf.

    14. Matthew Bloom, “Flourishing in Ministry: Emerging Research Insights on the Well Being of Pastors,” Flourishing in Ministry Project (Notre Dame: Mendoza College of Business, 2013), 15, 10.

    15. Glenn Ball, “Frequency of Narcissistic Personality Disorder in Pastors: A Preliminary Study” (unpublished paper presented to American Association of Christian Counselors, Nashville, Tennessee, September 26, 2015), 9.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑