Chapter 5 of 14

2. “Ain’t Never Had a Friend like Me”: Rethinking Friendship in Youth Ministry

2. “Ain’t Never Had a Friend like Me”: Rethinking Friendship in Youth Ministry

Wesley W. Ellis and Kenda Creasy Dean

It was . . . clear to everyone that Eustace’s character had been rather improved by becoming a dragon. . . . The pleasure (quite new to him) of being liked and, still more, of liking other people, was what kept Eustace from despair. For it was very dreary being a dragon.

—C. S. Lewis1

“I do not call you servants any longer, because the servant does not know what the master is doing; but I have called you friends, because I have made known to you everything that I have heard from my Father. You did not choose me but I chose you.”

—John 15:15–16

I (Kenda) have said it too, with the best of intentions. I remember taking a deep breath and putting on my grown-up-youth-leader pants to say it: “Kim, I love you, but I am your youth leader, which means I can’t be your friend. I’m sorry.”

We were in the hallway outside my office, standing under a spluttering fluorescent ceiling light. All these years later, I still remember the look on her face. I wasn’t sure what emotion flickered across it—was it hurt? confusion? disbelief? betrayal? I do remember one thing: I wondered if I would ever see Kim again.

There’s plenty of advice out there against youth worker friendship with youth. A quick Google search is all it takes to find it:

  • One blogger writes: “Students don’t need youth workers to be their friends, they need adults who will lead them to God and invest in their lives. Unfortunately, many of us have bought into the lie that we need to be ‘friends’ with our students in order to have influence in their lives.”
  • A whole training session entitled “Friend vs. Youth Worker” is available to “help your adults move from friendship to being effective youth workers.”
  • An online author (whose bio says he “reeks with passion”) calls befriending youth one of the top mistakes youth leaders make: “Students don’t need any more ‘friends.’ They actually really don’t want your friendship. They need adults passionately following Jesus.”2
  • All these admonitions assume a certain definition of friendship, namely, one that is an undifferentiated relationship of equals, in which all friendships are alike, in which “equals” implies equal maturity levels, equal power of authority, equal access to information, equal levels of affection, and so on. These warnings also imply that a caring adult who spends time with young people while maintaining his or her appropriate role and status as an adult is definitively not a “friend.”

    These assumptions are false.

    Leaf through your high school yearbook, and you’ll recall that, in practice, you never actually thought of friendship in this way. You were friends with people in different grades. You shared some information with some friends but not with others, simply because the nature of your friendship shaped the kinds of conversations you shared. You had more inside jokes with Anton than you did with Greg, and you shared your deepest secrets with Tamar but definitely not with Michelle—yet Anton and Greg and Tamar and Michelle were all genuinely your friends. Friends come in many flavors, with different norms and expectations governing each relationship. That is why, as an adult, you can be friends with your neighbor and your spouse and your sister, but you don’t mix them up (at least not without serious consequences).

    For far too long we youth workers have, either by distortion or by conscious decision, withheld our friendship from young people. We have either entered into friendship under the false assumption that we need to be “like” a young person to befriend a young person, thus distorting friendship. Or, under the same assumption, in order to avoid the distortion, we have consciously withheld friendship from young people. The problem is, in withholding our friendship, we’re also missing out on the joy of youth ministry. More importantly, the young people closest to us miss out on joy as well. For in a world haunted by transactional relationships and bound by an obsession with achievement, there’s perhaps nothing young people need more from us than our friendship. We need to restore friendship in youth ministry because we need to restore joy to youth ministry.

    The Theological Necessity of Christian Friendship

    Let’s be clear at the outset that no adult who forgets his or her responsibilities as an adult should be doing youth ministry at all, for reasons that include and go well beyond the potential to misunderstand Christian friendship. It’s not because there’s anything wrong with youthfulness or acting young, as such; it’s just that an adult who cannot bear the distinctive responsibilities adults have toward young people should not be in a position of authority with youth. An adult who fails to act like an adult fails to discern roles properly—a key sign of the inability to know when one’s own needs are getting in the way of making decisions based on the needs of others. I understand the motivation behind the scores of web pages advising against becoming “friends” with young people, because I share their concerns—concerns about appropriate boundaries, unhealthy need fulfillment, poor decision making, and flat-out failure-to-launch among youth workers who are often young, inexperienced, and eager to please.

    These are crucial concerns for youth ministry. The problem, however, is that they have nothing to do with friendship—in fact, advising youth workers to avoid befriending youth demonstrates a serious misunderstanding of Christian friendship that is both theologically deficient and pastorally ill-advised. The fact is, compelling data underscores the importance of appropriate, faithful, nurturing friendships between adults and young people for faith formation, including friendships between young people and their pastors.3 Furthermore, none of these concerns takes into account the theological necessity of Christian friendship: to follow Christ is to extend friendship to one another as Christ extended friendship to us.

    The issue is that what often passes for friendship in our culture is not friendship at all—it’s a transactional, tit-for-tat, self-interested relationship that, at best, turns young people into relational consumers and exhausts youth workers who try to deliver. Even Jesus recognized this transactionalism as a substitute for friendship, not as the real thing. Jesus was alert to how these relationships differ from real friendship, because they do not invite vulnerability: they do not give the other permission to affect us. On the contrary, such relationships are intended for influence. This one-way objective makes them guarded, even manipulative—and those of us in youth ministry have been guilty of our share of them. Whenever we “earn the right to be heard” with young people, offering a relationship to teenagers that is designed to win their trust in order to gain a hearing so we can get them to youth group or encourage their conversion, however noble our intentions may be, we are dabbling in imposter friendship. “Friendship” under these circumstances becomes something we do to others in order to get them to do what we want them to do.4 It is a far cry from real friendship as a practice of appropriate mutual vulnerability. What we actually protect when we avoid friendship in youth ministry is not the young person, the relationship, or even our role as adults in their lives. What we are protecting is ourselves. Rather than becoming vulnerable enough to be affected by our encounters with these young people, we are preserving our distance and our authoritative status as adults.

    Imposter friendship has no place in youth ministry. On the heartbreaking evening before his arrest, Jesus told his disciples: “I have called you friends, because I have made known to you everything that I have heard from my Father” (John 15:15b). The Greek word for “friend” in that sentence is philos, a word used to connote someone who is dearly loved, suggesting a relationship brimming with personal affection. In Matthew 26:50, however, Jesus says to Judas, just before his seizure: “Friend, do what you are here to do,” using the much less common Greek word hetairos, or “supposed friend,” someone acting in his or her own interest. These kinds of friendships are transactional, useful—limited by how much I might benefit another, and vice versa. Such friendships must be constantly earned. They’re exhausting, dehumanizing, and wind up being a form of entrapment, like a genie in a bottle—a relationship based on wish fulfillment, not love.

    We don’t need to eliminate adult-youth friendships in youth ministry; we need to reclaim them and enact this practice of vulnerability in light of Jesus’s friendship toward us, rather than as another manipulative and transactional pseudofriendship like the ones so often offered to young people. Christian friendships honor the uniqueness of the persons involved, including their ages, roles, and life experiences. Jesus befriended the disciples without relinquishing his divinity or his salvific role in their lives; the disciples loved Jesus without fully comprehending the nature of his love for them (or even his identity). Their friendship was a mutual, loving relationship between people who were not “equal” in the sense of being peers, or even in the sense of what they brought to the relationship, but they were—astonishingly—equally loved by God. Friendships that stand in the tradition of Christ honor difference while maintaining the value and humanity of all persons in the eyes of God. In the context of a robust theology of friendship, one that honors and celebrates the uniqueness of each person in a relationship as an embodiment of God’s love in Jesus Christ, youth ministry should encourage youth worker–young person friendships and find ways to cultivate them creatively, appropriately, and robustly.

    Just to be clear, we are not suggesting that Christian friendship is the only kind of friendship there is. One does not have to be a Christian or to believe Christian things in order to engage in or receive friendship. The word “friendship” has a diversity of meanings depending on the context in which it is used. Indeed, as we’ve already noted, some of our confusion around friendship in ministry revolves around the term’s definitional versatility. But we also need to be clear that the kinds of friendships in which Jesus engaged, the kind of friendship God extends toward the world, is friendship indeed; and the relationships that are appropriate and necessary for youth ministry are those that correspond to that kind of friendship.

    “You Ain’t Never Had a Friend like Me”

    I (Wes) was seven years old when Disney released its classic film Aladdin, but I can’t remember a time when it didn’t exist. For my generation, it seems to be one of those movies, like Cinderella or The Wizard of Oz, that you can’t imagine the world without. I remember watching it as a kid and feeling like Aladdin was a friend of mine. After all, his story is like a lot of kids’ stories—the struggle to become something more, and the deep conviction that we are or should be more than meets the eye, a “diamond in the rough.” I remember that magical moment when Aladdin meets the genie. Having been abandoned by the one who promised him liberation, stuck in the Cave of Wonders with no way out, Aladdin accidentally summons the genie from a lamp. The genie wastes little time before marketing himself to Aladdin in the classic song “You Ain’t Never Had a Friend like Me.” The genie, voiced by the late Robin Williams, lays before Aladdin a smorgasbord of appealing possibilities in a spectacular display of attractions. “Can your friends do this? Do your friends do that? . . . You ain’t never had a friend like me!”

    I’ve always loved this song and the magic of that moment. I think just about everyone who has watched Aladdin has been enchanted by the relationship between the genie and Aladdin. But only recently did it occur to me that there is a tragic irony in their relationship. Despite the song’s title, “You Ain’t Never Had a Friend like Me,” the relationship between the genie and Aladdin is anything but a friendship. Good humor and kindness aside—and even though a friendship does eventually unfold (more on that later)—the genie is essentially enslaved to Aladdin, not befriended by him. The genie is bound to Aladdin in a relationship of necessity. The genie’s whole purpose, his very existence, depends on his ability to produce, create, offer something nobody else can, and ultimately help Aladdin achieve a respectable adulthood.

    When Aladdin meets the genie, he is a “diamond in the rough,” shouldering the weight of social pressure to find his place in life, to ascend out of his deficiency, and to become somebody. In other words, he’s an adolescent.

    By the time Aladdin meets the genie, he’s gotten himself into some trouble and is in obvious need of help. But rather than help Aladdin realize that he in fact does not need to become something or someone else to be fulfilled, the genie comes along and says, “Look what I can do! Certainly I can help you!” It turns out that Aladdin needs the genie and the genie needs to be needed.5 And that need turns out to be the true basis of their relationship. It’s not a friendship, it’s a transaction, a contractual partnership. They are bound to one another and (quite literally for the genie, who wears shackles on his wrists) shackled by necessity and obligation rather than liberated by joy.

    Youth Worker Genies

    As youth workers, most of us can relate to the genie. We find ourselves doing all sorts of stunts to get young people to realize how much they need us and our ministries. Of course, our tricks aren’t as cool as the genie’s; we can’t really do magic. But we’ve got camps and worship bands and T-shirts with our church logo on them (that’s still cool, right?) and evangelistic rock concerts and even a Facebook page (oh yeah!). Thankfully, the “attractional” approach to youth ministry seems to be on its way out,6 but we often replace it with what the Center for Youth Ministry Training practical theologian Andrew Zirschky calls the “Moth Myth.” Zirschky writes, “The notion that youth, like moths, are attracted to things that plug-in and light up is truly a myth. None of these approaches are relevant to the heart cry of contemporary teenagers.”7 The temptation to become a youth worker genie lurks behind the “Moth Myth” as well: the illusion that if we can just be cool enough and flashy enough, young people will flock to us.

    We’ve mostly discovered that there’s really no point in trying to compete with Snapchat or the spectacle of a Katy Perry concert, and we’re learning that we shouldn’t want to either. Young people don’t actually want tricks or flashy gimmicks. Relationship is the “heart cry” Zirschky is talking about. Young people need enduring relationships that aren’t just about rewards and benefits. What young people are crying out for are friendships that demonstrate what Erik Erikson called fidelity.

    Fidelity Failure: Young People’s Need for “Even If ” Relationships

    Fidelity is the ability to be faithful to something or someone. Erikson believed that it’s the vital strength that adolescents “need to have the opportunity to develop, to employ, to evoke—and to die for.”8 According to Erikson, “ ‘the cornerstone’ of adolescence [is] the strength of being utterly true to oneself and others amid competing and contradictory value systems.”9 He wrote, “The adolescent looks most fervently for [people] and ideas to have faith in, which also means [people] and ideas in whose service it would seem worthwhile to prove oneself trustworthy.”10

    But there’s a catch. As a teenager, you don’t wake up one day and decide to put your faith in someone. You only learn fidelity from those who have put their faith in you. For young people to establish their own fidelity—for them to commit themselves to something or someone—first they need to experience the faithfulness of others. In other words, young people need people to demonstrate unconditional relationships that endure in the face of whatever may come. Fidelity is the “even if ” kind of relationship.11 To establish their own fidelity and to construct identity, young people are looking for relationships of fidelity, people who will be true to them even if all others fall away.

    Largely, our youth-oriented society does not seem to be meeting young people’s need for fidelity. The truth is that many youth have not experienced enough fidelity on their behalf to acquire it themselves.12 As a culture, we have become so bent on progress, achievement, and accomplishment that our social structures tend to demand fidelity from young people without demonstrating it to them. The upshot is that American young people shoulder the weight of a culture that values them for their potential to become full human beings (namely, adults) and generative participants in economic and social life—but not for who they are as young people right now. Since the dawn of the industrial age, when we learned to see life as a linear progression on a scale of improvement and learned to view time as a commodity in the service of developmental achievement,13 we have viewed children and young people as “in transition” and “on their way” to adulthood.14 These conditions gave rise to “stage theories” of human development and eventually to the social construction of “adolescence” as our chief descriptor of young people’s experience.15 In other words, as the ideal of industrial progress and achievement captured our imagination in the West, it captured the way we imagined human development, too.16 Because we were captivated by the idea of progress in the markets and in society, we began to interpret human life likewise—as proceeding through stages “from simplicity to complexity of thought, from irrational to rational behavior.”17

    North American young people are thrust into this process, pressured to “achieve” adulthood, but are often stuck in the Cave of Wonders. We expect them to become adults but afford them few adequate resources to fulfill this expectation.18 As adults in society, we are still wrestling with how to best aid our young people in this transition and guide them through it. Unsure of what else to do, because of our penchant for progress, we hold maturity out like a carrot on a stick. It is all about improvement and expediency. What has developed through all of this might be called a culture of achievement and a perpetual search for affirmation. As practical theologian Amy Jacober describes it, “The identification of adolescents as feeling first lost and then the almost palpable feeling of being abandoned drives them into a frenetic push for affirmation, loyalty and solid relationships.”19 Nearly all young people in America have this in common: whether they are successful or not, whether they embrace it or not, they are all responding to enormous pressure of achievement and affirmation. Many of them, like Aladdin, find themselves stuck in the dirt with no way to achieve what is expected of them . . . until along comes a genie. Or, in our case, youth ministry.

    Why Can’t We Be Friends?

    Youth ministry, of course, is not immune to our culture’s progress/achievement narrative, and most of us have unwittingly done our share to fuel young people’s (and our own) search for affirmation. Congregations tend to support youth ministry as a “recruitment op,” a means of ensuring that another generation of well-formed church members will one day populate the pews. Youth ministers have been infamously accused of abusing relationships with young people as a means to their own social fulfillment. But even at our best, as Andrew Root has convincingly shown, youth ministry often instrumentalizes friendships, teaching youth workers to make our relationships with teenagers a means to an end—for example, a way to earn trust so we can ask teenagers to do something we want them to do, like come to church or youth group, or, more subtly, a way to convince them to become more like us. In so doing, we sever the relationship between fidelity and “friendship” in youth ministry, making the “friendship” offered by youth ministry look like relationships in so many other parts of our culture: transactions, relationships of expectation and necessity.

    The concept of fidelity should come naturally to the church. After all, we confess faith in a God who is there whether we “ascend to heaven” or “make [our] bed in Sheol” (Psalm 139:8), a God who will never leave us nor forsake us (Hebrews 13:5) and promises that “neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor rulers, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 8:38–39). With this core conviction, we should be different! The church should offer an alternative to the culture of achievement.

    But instead of offering an alternative, youth ministry—like the genie—often markets the church as the next best way to achieve the goal. In discovering young people’s need for adult relationships (and longing for professional legitimization), youth ministers got a little too excited about our own generativity, our neededness. A quick scan of the youth ministry literature of the last thirty years reveals how thoroughly we latched on to our own importance as contributors to young people’s development;20 youth ministers were helpful “mirrors” through which teenagers could see their future selves and maybe (on our best days) get a glimpse of Jesus, to boot. So we marketed adult-youth “friendship” in youth ministry as a means to an end, a path to adulthood, a way for young people to get what they need. With the best of intentions, we offered teenagers the transactional bargain of a lifetime: if you (metaphorically) sign our church’s contract, meet our expectations, come on our mission trips, become the people we want you to be—the church will be there for you. Ta-da! Fidelity!

    As a result, rather than offering an escape from the pressure to achieve, youth ministry often became a set of new achievements that purpose-driven young people could pursue. And for a set of young people (the purpose-driven ones), it worked. But as youth ministers themselves have slowly realized—and as less-driven young people, who were essentially driven away from youth ministry, have always told us, in so many words—young people in our achievement-driven culture do not need another achievement to conquer. What they need, and what they long for, is friendship—relationships with people who genuinely delight in them, and thereby help them discover and enjoy God’s delight (philos) in them.

    No one in youth ministry would disagree that young people—especially in our culture of contractual, conditional, and fleeting relationships—desperately need free, unconditional, and enduring human bonds. We call those relationships friendships. Since these are the kinds of relationships Jesus offered his friends, we’re going to suggest that they should be the kinds of relationships the church offers to young people. What’s more, we’re pretty sure these are the kinds of relationships most youth workers long to offer teenagers (even when they’re critiquing “friendship” as the way to do it). So, what would it look like to get our terms straight and call these relationships what Jesus called them—friendships?

    The Joy of Friendship: Minimizing Distance, Not Difference

    Some philosophers and theologians have constructed a view of friendship exclusively around the concepts of mutuality and reciprocity. These are important dimensions of friendship, but on their own they produce a definition of friendship bound to what John Swinton calls “the principle of likeness”21—the idea that mutuality and reciprocity in friendship must mean the abolition of difference. Even though his contributions to our understanding of friendship can hardly be limited to this, we owe Aristotle for this idea. In Aristotle’s view, because of the centrality of mutuality and reciprocity, friends must be equals—“two good people serving to actualize the virtue of goodness within their friendship relationship.”22 This would mean that young people cannot really be friends with adult youth workers. Youth will be youth and adults will be adults, so “likeness” is impossible. The difference will never really go away. And it is precisely when we try to resolve or minimize this difference that we run into real disasters in youth ministry. As an adult, you have distinct responsibilities toward youth, just as they have their own responsibilities. If there is no room for difference in friendship, then adults certainly can’t be friends with youth without putting their adult responsibilities at risk. But mutuality and reciprocity are not all there is to friendship. Difference is to be expected in friendship, not excepted from it. Indeed, as theologian Jürgen Moltmann puts it, “only someone who finds the courage to be different from others can ultimately exist for ‘others.’ ”23 It’s not “social difference” that must be minimized; it’s “social distance.”24

    So mutuality and reciprocity need to be oriented around another, more fundamental concept in friendship: freedom. Part of what makes friendship special is that it is freely and voluntarily chosen, regardless of the potential or lack of potential for reciprocity.25 This freedom, in fact, is why friendship is so closely linked to joy, because joy also has freedom at its heart. Joy is essentially about delighting in God and, more importantly, enjoying God’s delight in us. Friendship is what joy looks like in the form of a relationship. It is enduring because it is rooted in delight and, therefore, necessarily noninstrumental.26 This goes all the way back to creation itself. Creation itself is God’s free and voluntary act of making something instead of nothing—not to achieve anything but just to delight in it. Creation is not an act of necessity. Creation is an act of joy! As Morgan Schmidt puts it, “the most amazing part of creation is that it didn’t have to happen.”27 God wanted to become creator. But if we were to ask, “Why did God create the world?” from the perspective of our culture of achievement, we would probably be asking, “What was God trying to achieve, or what did God want to accomplish, by creating the world?” When our mode of self-understanding is so instrumental, it makes sense that we would assume creation to be an instrument of achievement rather than an act or impulse of joy.

    But if our perspective is one of freedom—if we believe that God really was free to create the world for no good reason other than that it delighted God to do so28—then, as Moltmann reminds us, “Our existence is justified and made beautiful before we are able to do or fail to do anything.”29 God created the world because it delighted God. In a way, this undermines the intent of the question, “Why did God create the world?,” because it demolishes the instrumental categories of goals and outcomes. God didn’t create the world in order to do or accomplish anything with it. God created the world for joy. If friendship is what joy looks like in the form of a relationship, then the act of creation, as God’s free act of joy, is the act of God befriending the world.30 As Hans Reinders has put it, “Our being, at every moment of existence, originates from the gift of God’s friendship.”31 This is the relationship that makes human and divine passion possible. If friendship were only about mutuality and reciprocity, then friendship between God and the world would be impossible. In what way could we possibly expect the world to reciprocate creation? And yet, in creation, God freely extends friendship to the world. It is out of God’s friendship with the world that God goes to the cross in Christ. Jesus gave his life, a gift that cannot be paid back. “No one has greater love than this,” Jesus said, “to lay down one’s life for one’s friends. . . . I do not call you servants . . . I have called you friends” (John 15:13–15).32

    Striving for Joy—or Not

    We want to suggest that all this makes a practical, not just a theoretical, difference in the way we approach ministry with young people. If God’s joy in creation is expressed through friendship, then grounding our relationships with young people in a theology of friendship ought to free us from doing somersaults to “create” or manufacture joy in youth ministry and allow us to enjoy young people instead—and help them enjoy one another, and especially to name and experience God’s delight in them. When we spend all our time and energy striving to achieve joy, accomplishing friendships, helping young people achieve adulthood, investing in an endless stream of antics designed to win young people’s allegiance, affection, and loyalty to the church, we obscure and miss out on God’s presence in the actuality of young people’s concrete and lived experience.33 We fall into a kind of works righteousness youth ministry—which is seldom joyful and almost always exhausting. In such ministry, the adult-youth friendship becomes just another professional tool that we leverage to get the job done, the way Aladdin used the genie to escape the Cave of Wonders.

    But if it is true that “identity is ours by redemption, not by development,”34 then we need a radical change of trajectory—from our orientation toward God to God’s orientation toward us. Human flourishing is grounded in God’s joyous action toward us, not our actions that lead to joy. God’s love for us “does not depend on the desirability of its object,” to use the words of  Thomas Merton, but God “loves for love’s sake.”35 God’s friendship with us is the kind of relationship that is not grounded in our need for a relationship. As Swinton puts it, “The commitment to the other . . . is not enforced by obligation, custom or law, but by a desire to be with the other.”36 In other words, friendship brings joy to life, undermines the culture of achievement, and refuses to be merely an instrument of pragmatic purposes—even “Christian” ones. Through friendship, creation is revealed as God’s creation and we are revealed as persons. “In friendship,” Moltmann writes, “we experience ourselves for what we are, respected and accepted in our own freedom.”37

    Genie, You’re Free

    That’s why we think Jesus grounded his ministry in friendship—and it’s why we believe friendship in youth ministry is not just allowed but (ironically, perhaps) necessary. In friendship, both the youth and the adults in youth ministry are invited to do more than just try to escape the Cave of Wonders—we are liberated from the vicious cycle of moving from one achievement to another. Remember that in Aladdin’s story, real friendship isn’t really revealed through the genie’s tricks and gimmicks, no matter how much the song-and-dance routine portends otherwise. In the end, it is Aladdin who demonstrates true friendship to the genie, not by binding the genie to himself in mutuality and reciprocity but by setting him free. Just one wish away from achieving his wish fulfillment, Aladdin chooses instead to set the genie free.

    The genie responds, having anticipated exactly where the path they have been following should lead, “One bona fide prince pedigree coming up. I—what!?”

    “Genie, you’re free!”

    At that, a transformation begins. The genie’s shackles fall from his wrists; the lamp that once imprisoned him falls to the ground.

    Disbelieving, the genie tests his newfound freedom: “Quick, quick,” he says to Aladdin. “Wish for something outrageous. Say ‘I want the Nile.’ Wish for the Nile. Try that!”

    “I wish for the Nile.”

    “No way!!” The genie exults in his new self-determination. “Oh, does that feel good! I’m free! I’m free at last! I’m hittin’ the road. I’m off to see the world!”

    After a somber benediction, the genie leaves his new friend. Ironic, isn’t it? No sooner does the friendship begin than they part ways.38 This does not mean that friendship always means leaving one another, but this is a symbol of what sits at the heart of Christian friendship. As Moltmann notes,

    Friends open up free spaces for one another. . . . One element in this free human relationship is that we can also leave each other in peace. We do not constantly need to assure ourselves of our friendship. . . . What friends do for us are not services that have to be paid back.39

    This echoes Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s perspective on Christian fellowship in his classic theological work Life Together, where he writes, “The Christian community has not been given to us by God for us to be constantly taking its temperature.”40 In other words, only through friendship—the relationship that opens to freedom rather than anxiety—can we rightfully call youth ministry a ministry. Through friendship, we participate in God’s self-giving in the world: a self-giving offered out of joy, free of charge, no strings attached.

    Setting Our Own Genies Free

    When I (Wes) was in high school, I was the kind of kid who went to youth group as often as possible. My parents referred to me as a “youth group junkie.” It got to the point where, if I was struggling with my grades or misbehaving in some way, my parents would threaten to ground me from going to youth group—and, believe it or not, that was usually enough to motivate me to do better. I was committed to my faith and, even more, I was committed to getting other people to embrace the doctrines of my faith. I read all the evangelism and apologetics books, and my youth pastors taught me how to win an argument for Jesus. On one specific occasion, while I was hanging out with a few of my friends after school, I got into an argument with one of my atheist acquaintances. I remember he was challenging me on the plausibility of the historical resurrection of Jesus. He raised question after question, and I had an answer for each one of them. I knew I was right, and I had no problem bludgeoning this kid with the “facts” of the gospel. A few people were listening in on the conversation. Someone walked in late to the show and asked one of the people listening in, “What’s happening here?”

    “Oh, they’re arguing about God . . . and Wes is winning.”

    At the time, I was proud of that review. I was winning! But all I was winning was an argument, nothing else. The kid with whom I was arguing remained an atheist, and, more importantly, we remained merely acquaintances. I don’t even remember his name.

    In that after-school theological debate, I did exactly what I was taught to do; I valued exactly what I was taught to value—the achievement of victory. But wouldn’t it have been better if, instead of caring about winning the argument, achieving, I actually cared about the person with whom I was arguing? What if I had learned from my youth pastors that friendship is more important than winning arguments? It’s in friendship that we encounter God, not in facts and analyses. It’s in knowing God through friendship, not knowing about God, that we experience the joy—the good news— of the gospel. But if friendship is not a high value in youth ministry, it will not likely be a high value to the young people with whom we minister. If we’re not offering friendship to young people, if we don’t demonstrate fidelity to them, we cannot expect them to offer friendship to others or receive the friendship that God is offering them.

    So what might youth ministry look like if the church offered young people friendship with no strings attached? What would youth ministry be if youth workers did not have to accomplish joy—if we did not need to achieve anything through our relationships with young people but rather could approach the church as a community where young people experienced God’s delight in them and could practice God’s delight in others?

    For this to be possible, of course, we have to do more than simply inject new activities into the youth group. The church is intended to offer a foretaste of the reign of God, a glimpse of an alternative reality to the one young people experience daily. The issue at hand is not just young people’s inundation with imposter friendships, or relationships saturated by expectations of accomplishment. The issue is simply that, when young people encounter church, they experience nothing different. Here is where we can adopt a “medieval cathedral” perspective: the grandeur of the cathedral in the Middle Ages, in contrast to the daily life of common people, was intended to signify God’s connection to the human experience but also allow them to glimpse the utterly magnificent, soaring “otherness” of the dominion of God.

    This “otherness” of God’s intended reality is no longer always reflected in church architecture, which today often mimics public spaces rather than seeks to stand apart from them. What matters for our purposes is not the architectural difference of the church from daily life but the relational difference. As young people enter Christian community, they transition from a culture that objectifies them, packages them into roles prescribed by cultural scripts, or (at best) reduces them to their hoped-for potential into a culture that offers them an alternative way of being. Through practices of joy and friendship, churches offer young people a different experience of themselves, an alternative to black-and-white instrumentalism and productivity expectations; they offer them a color-drenched Oz of freedom and love where they experience God’s delight in them, from beginning to end. What does God’s delight in young people look like in this alternative reality? Here are a few possibilities we might tend to.

    1. Trust for Trust’s Sake

    If we’ve been seduced by the temptation to use the trust we build with young people to influence their lives, we need to learn to build trust for its own sake. Instead of wielding the trust that young people offer us for the sake of other outcomes, we need to delight in the privilege and gift of being trusted as an end in itself. The win here is not primarily that young people trust us, though that is a penultimate goal. The win is that we trust young people; we are willing to let them affect us. The seeds of trust are found in shared vulnerability—not “equal” or “reciprocal” or “like” vulnerability—but appropriate, shared vulnerability. This is why periods of hardship, challenge, or depletion bring communities together; they have experienced vulnerability together.

    This means turning our attention to different measures of effectiveness in ministry. When asking “What does good look like?” in our ministries, we will describe trust levels as well as attendance, we will count opportunities for shared vulnerability as well as programs, we will look at the nature of our relationships as well as the fact of them. It has been said that either we measure what matters or what matters is what we measure. To gauge effective youth ministry on the fruits of the Spirit—“love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, generosity, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control” (Galatians 5:22–23)—instead of merely “butts in pews” is a first step toward making authentic friendship matter.

    2. Wonder-full Ministry

    Few people contest the importance of engaging young people with Scripture in youth ministry. Most of the time, our approach to teaching and studying the Bible is to get young people to understand something—a theological lesson or moral. Even our approach to prayer and worship is frequently guided by a desire for young people to “get it right,” to learn who God is—and who God isn’t—and how to apply this knowledge to their daily experience.

    These are noble desires. But consider an alternative. Reading the Bible is a good thing, but enjoying time spent with God is what transforms the reading of Scripture. Knowing about God is a far cry from knowing God. What plucks the dragon scales from young people’s lives is not resolving textual tensions in Bible study but “searching the Scriptures,” as John Wesley puts it, for places the Holy Spirit encounters them, piques their curiosity, leads them through mystery. More important than a teacher with a seminary degree or a Bible commentary are examples of people who love the texts and traditions of Christian faith, who are beguiled by Jesus, and whose curiosity for what God is doing in the world is so insatiable that they constantly search Scripture for clues. In short, it matters more that youth ministry bathe young people in wonder and encourage questions of the curriculum, of Scripture, and of God than that we indoctrinate them in dogma—and this requires a wide-eyed willingness to wonder about God ourselves.

    3. Playful Vulnerability

    Sometimes we treat play and playfulness as pesky things we have to do to keep kids interested, the warm-up act to the real ministry. But no practice of friendship comes as easily, or offers a more effective antidote to the culture of achievement, than play. The Christian community should be playful—and not just “youth group.” Play is itself ministry (after all, in its most ancient form, worship was a play performed for the gods). By definition, play creates a space in which the only expectations are created by the game itself, which is why we “get lost” in games, we lose track of time in a good conversation or a good book, we “forget our feet” in the joy of the dance. We’re not performing to meet others’ expectations—we are simply delighting in the play itself.

    Play has rules and roles that make sense in the context of the game, but they may be completely upside down from the rules and roles we play in daily life. Play levels the playing field between status differentials in the school hallways; it gives every participant a meaningful part to play in achieving a common goal. These roles prescribe appropriate levels of vulnerability for the purpose of the game, which eases our anxiety (and theirs) about interacting with young people we don’t know well. A playful church liberates us from expectations of usefulness, status, and the constant pressure to improve, develop, and mature. Instead, it invites young people—as it invites us—to “waste” time before God as we enjoy the freedom and friendship God offers.41

    4. Gracious Encounter

    Youth ministers tend to be gifted in the art of gracious encounter, befriending not only our “own” young people but other people’s youth as well. This is a gift that we are called to share with young people, and with churches themselves, who often view friendship with “others” as threatening or irrelevant. Yet no follower of Jesus would argue that God’s delight is limited to those in Christian congregations. The practice of friendship in youth ministry must extend beyond churches’ “usual suspects.” If joy stands at the beginning of our work, rather than arrives as its culmination, then all youth need to experience God’s delight in them—maybe especially those who aren’t involved in Christian communities (which, remember, is most of them).

    Three frontiers for the practice of gracious encounter stand out. One is youth ministry in church communities overflowing with young people (yes, there are many): immigrant churches, new Christian communities, and Southern Hemisphere churches, which are largely “off the radar” of North America’s dominant “youth ministry culture.” These vital ecclesial communities are some of our best teachers of forms of friendship like mentoring and discipleship as apprenticeship. On the other end of the spectrum are missionally-inventive churches where most of the youth ministry happens outside the church. These congregations also have the potential for vital youth ministries—they just serve young people who do not belong to anybody in the congregation. Adopting a school, hosting bus-stop hot chocolate stands, creating community-based SAT prep courses or pop-up cafes for studying during final exams—the list is endless for ways the body of Christ can champion young people in our communities, extending the hand of Christian friendship to them. For churches accustomed to paying youth workers to serve congregants’ children, this represents a massive shift in focus—but we suspect this shift is already in progress, and naming it legitimizes work they are already doing as ministry.

    The third frontier for gracious encounter is brokering intergenerational friendships in and beyond congregations. One family in our small church decided to open their barn loft—which they converted into a fully operational woodworking shop—every Thursday night to anyone interested in learning to create things with wood. They provide the tools, the support, and even the wood itself. All you have to do is come with an idea, and the Kane family helps you see it to completion. It’s actually a fairly low-key activity and might sound a little mundane. But as one young person in our congregation noted, “It’s the only church activity I’ve ever been to that I’m not embarrassed to invite my friends to.” Each week young people gather alongside older adults for snacks, conversations, and some instruction on how to handle a lathe. They create picture frames, jewelry boxes, cutting boards, wooden spoons—all in the context of community. The evening is framed in a short reflection on the Bible passage to be preached that Sunday. Most importantly, everyone enjoys each other’s company. There was no real plan to get it started, just one family’s desire to share something they love with young people from their church.

    Because We’re Friends

    For the record, Kim—the young person I (Kenda) thought I couldn’t befriend—did come back. In fact, she remained a key member of our group until she graduated. But what I wish I would have said was not “I can’t be your friend” but “Because I’m your friend—and because you’re sixteen and I’m not—we’re going to take some boundaries seriously. Having some rules will free us to be the people God brought together in this relationship: a young person and an adult. And that is a beautiful thing.” Rethinking the practice of friendship in youth ministry not only gives young people a way out of the culture of achievement’s Cave of Wonders, it also frees youth workers to stop using our relationships with young people as means to accomplish certain goals. It frees us to delight in youth as God delights in them, recognizing our differences while extending fidelity to them. There are rules to the game, and in a world broken by sin and injustice, we must take them seriously. But we are invited to play. We are invited to stop instrumentalizing our relationships, instrumentalizing ourselves, and start delighting in young people, inviting them to delight in the joy of God’s friendship with them. Friendship is not a mistake. Friendship—true friendship—is the heart of youth ministry.

    Questions for Youth Leaders

  • Can you think of a time when you thought someone was a friend but it turned out that person was just trying to get something out of you?
  • What’s the Cave of Wonders for the young people in your life? What pressures and expectations have trapped them?
  • How does viewing the act of creation as the act of God befriending the world change your perception of friendship? Of ministry?
  • Pro Tip: Start a session with your team by reading the story “I Also Had a Friend” (pp. 16–18). Ask: “Did you ever have an adult befriend you in church? What made it welcome instead of creepy?”

    1. C. S. Lewis, The Voyage of the “Dawn Treader” (San Francisco: HarperCollins, 1994), 72.

    2. Phil Bell, “Youth Ministry Leadership: Friend or Leader?,” Phil Bell, March 13, 2012, http://philbell.me/2012/03/13/youth-ministry-leadership-friend-or-leader/; Doug Franklin, “Friend vs. Youth Worker,” Leader Treks Youth Ministry, https://www.leadertreks.org/store/friend-vs-youth-worker/; Jeremy Zach, “9 Mistakes Made by Youth Pastors,” Church Leaders, November 10, 2010, http://www.churchleaders.com/youth/youth-leaders-articles/146054-9-mistakes-made-by-youth-pastors.html.

    3. Young people mentioned with special affection their relationships with their pastors. The more supportive, faithful adult-youth relationships teenagers had, the more likely they were to have durable and highly devoted faith. Cf. Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005); Christian Smith and Patricia Snell, Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009).

    4. For an extended treatment on this theme, see Andrew Root, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press), 2007.

    5. In this, in a sense, the genie truly represents the “generativity” that has traditionally defined adults in their relationship to young people. As Erik Erikson has written, “mature man needs to be needed, and maturity is guided by the nature of that which must be cared for. Generativity, then, is primarily the concern for establishing and guiding the next generation.” Erik H. Erikson, Identity: Youth and Crisis (New York: Norton, 1968), 138.

    6. Mark Ostreicher, Youth Ministry 3.0 (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2008).

    7. Andrew Zirschky, Beyond the Screen: Youth Ministry for the Connected but Alone Generation (Nashville: Youth Ministry Partners and Abingdon Press, 2015), 15.

    8. Erikson, Identity, 232–33 (emphasis added).

    9. Kenda Creasy Dean, Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004), 76.

    10. Erikson, Identity, 128–29.

    11. “For Erikson, fidelity is an unflagging commitment to an ideology that transcends the self and brings about genuineness, sincerity and a sense of duty to others.” Jack O. Balswick, Pamela Ebstyne King, and Kevin S. Reimer, The Reciprocating Self  (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2005), 179.

    12. Dean, Practicing Passion, 77.

    13. See John Swinton, Becoming Friends of Time (Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2016).

    14. See Chris Jenks, Childhood, 2nd ed. (New York: Routledge, 2005), 8.

    15. We consider “adolescence” a social construct, despite recent attempts to destabilize this theory. For instance, Crystal Kirgiss has shown us that the term “adolescence” was not a postindustrial invention, as some have suggested, nor is the social distinction of youth between childhood and adulthood an exclusively modern Western phenomenon (cf. In Search of Adolescence: A New Look at an Old Idea [San Diego: Youth Cartel, 2015]). Kirgiss’s historical work helps recontextualize the use of the term “adolescent,” though it does not refute the social construction argument sufficiently enough for us to completely abandon it. We maintain that youth, like childhood or any other social identity in the life course, serves as an interpretive framework and not just a nominative category, and that “adolescence” began to operate as a distinctly modern interpretive framework in social science (especially developmental psychology) in the early twentieth century (see Allison James and Alan Prout, eds., Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood: Contemporary Issues in the Sociological Study of Childhood [New York: RoutledgeFalmer, 1997]; Jenny Hockey and Allison James, Social Identities across the Life Course [New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003]; also see Andrew Root, “Adolescence and the Creation of the Secular Age of Unbelief,” Reformed Journal, January 9, 2017, https://perspectivesjournal.org/blog/2017/01/09/adolescence-creation-secular-age-unbelief-2/).

    16. See Erica Burman, Deconstructing Developmental Psychology (New York: Routledge, 2007), 15.

    17. James and Prout, Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood, 10.

    18. See Chap Clark’s concept of “systemic abandonment.” Chap Clark, Hurt (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2004).

    19. Amy Jacober, The Adolescent Journey (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2011), 88.

    20. While we believe youth ministry has overemphasized young people’s developmental need for adult relationships, we acknowledge that this move helps us see our shortcomings in meeting the needs of young people, and we are indebted to those who have highlighted them. The examples are too numerous for thorough citation. But see, for example, Duffy Robbins, The Ministry of Nurture (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1990); Richard R. Dunn and Mark H. Senter III, eds., Reaching a Generation for Christ (Chicago: Moody, 1997); Jim Burns and Mike DeVries, The Youth Builder (Ventura, CA: Gospel Light, 2001); and Wayne Rice, Generation to Generation (Cincinnati: Standard Publishing, 2010).

    21. See John Swinton, From Bedlam to Shalom (New York: Lang, 2000), 84–86.

    22. Swinton, From Bedlam to Shalom, 83. Also see Hans S. Reinders, Receiving the Gift of Friendship (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008), 358–62.

    23. Jürgen Moltmann, The Crucified God (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993), 16.

    24. Erin Raffety creatively applied this distinction in academic research with children, but we find the distinction equally helpful for thinking about youth ministry. See Erin L. Raffety, “Minimizing Social Distance: Participatory Research with Children,” Childhood 22, no. 3 (2014): 409–22.

    25. Reinders, Receiving the Gift, 5.

    26. As Aelred of Rievaulx, the great Cistercian abbot, wrote, “Spiritual friendship, which we call true, should be desired, not for consideration of any worldly advantage or for any extrinsic cause, but from the dignity of its own nature and the feelings of the human heart, so that its fruition and reward is nothing other than itself.” Spiritual Friendship (Notre Dame: Ave Maria, 2008), 41.

    27. Morgan Schmidt, Woo: Awakening Teenagers’ Desire to Follow in the Way of Jesus (San Diego: Youth Cartel, 2014), 46.

    28. As Jürgen Moltmann points out, this is the position of the Westminster Catechism (1647): “What is the chief end of [humankind]?” “To glorify God and enjoy [God] forever.” Theology and Joy (London: SCM, 1973), 42.

    29. Moltmann, Theology and Joy, 44.

    30. “[God’s] freedom . . . lies in the friendship which he offers men and women, and through which he makes them his friends.” Jürgen Moltmann, The Trinity and the Kingdom (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993), 56.

    31. Reinders, Receiving the Gift, 320.

    32. As John Swinton writes, “Sacrificial friendship is the definition of love.” Resurrecting the Person (Nashville: Abingdon, 2000), 43.

    33. Andrew Root has described the theological turn in youth ministry as seeking “to share in the concrete and lived experience of young people as the very place to share in the act and being of God.” Bonhoeffer as Youth Worker (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2014), 7.

    34. Dean, Practicing Passion, 84.

    35. Thomas Merton, “The Good Samaritan,” in A Thomas Merton Reader, ed. Thomas P. McDonnell (New York: Doubleday, 1989), 349.

    36. Swinton, From Bedlam to Shalom, 79.

    37. Jürgen Moltmann, Church in the Power of the Spirit (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993), 115.

    38. Not to draw too strong a connection here, but it’s reminiscent of the story of the road to Emmaus in Luke 24:13–35. Just after he’s revealed to his friends “in the breaking of the bread,” the resurrected Jesus disappears from their sight.

    39. Jürgen Moltmann, The Living God and the Fullness of Life (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2015), 119.

    40. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Life Together (London: SCM, 1954), 30.

    41. For a more extended treatment of this topic, see Wes Ellis, “Youth Ministry Games: Play as Ministry,” Kindred Youth Ministry, November 3, 2016.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑