3. Wonder and Onions: Reframing Celebration in Youth Ministry
Abigail Visco Rusert and Kenda Creasy Dean
People of our time are losing the power of celebration. Instead of celebrating we seek to be amused or entertained. Celebration is an active state, an act of expressing reverence or appreciation. To be entertained is a passive state—it is to receive pleasure afforded by an amusing act or a spectacle. . . . Celebration is a confrontation, giving attention to the transcendent meaning of one’s actions.
—Abraham Joshua Heschel1
So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do everything for the glory of God.
—1 Corinthians 10:31
It turns out priests can cook. Maybe you have read the work of the late Robert Capon, an Episcopal priest and prolific writer on Christian spirituality. But Father Capon had a side gig: he was also a food writer. As it turns out, Capon didn’t cook like most of us, which is why I find his reflections on food completely maddening.
I (Kenda) am an impatient cook. I want to know the recipe: What are the ingredients, how do they go together, how long will it take? I want to get the dish done and throw it in the oven. I want to know how long to set a timer and if I have time to set the table. I love pictures; even before I start, I want to know what the dish is supposed to look like in the end. Boom: Here’s your goal, here’s what you need, here’s how to make it happen.
It’s easy to think about youth ministry the same way. It feeds our proliferating to-do lists: What ingredients do I need? How do I whip them up? What do I throw together for this retreat? What will I get in the end? What are these kids supposed to look like when we’re finished with them? Our hope, when we pull them out of the oven at graduation, is to have faithful, functional adults. We want them to turn out like the churchgoing young adults their parents are expecting them to be.
At least, that’s what we think we want.
Behold the Onion
The reason someone like me finds Capon-the-food-writer exasperating is because he takes forever to get to the recipe. Forever. For example, his instructions for making stew go on for four pages—four pages!—before he tells you the recipe. Capon writes this way because he thinks of himself as an amateur cook, not in the sense that he is a beginner or a dilettante, but in the sense that he is a lover of cooking.2 The word “amateur” comes from the Latin amare, to love. Capon thinks all Christians should be amateurs. Love takes time. Love beholds, and savors, and gazes. If Christians are called to be amateurs, then it would seem that we are called to be lovers. And (according to Capon) if you approach cooking as a lover, you cannot start off your stew by chopping up an onion. First, you have to love the onion.
In Capon’s instructions for making stew, the first step is to behold an onion, because the onion, this orb that God has made, is a miracle. It’s resplendent. It’s magnificent. So Capon advises that we start making stew by spending sixty minutes—sixty minutes—beholding this onion. Spend time, he says, in the “society of the onion,” which “may be something you’ve never done before.”3 You may feel a certain resistance to this project. Please don’t, Capon implores. Onions are excellent company.
He proceeds to outline how to have a meeting with your onion. He claims that we are convinced that we know what an onion is, but all such prejudices must be abandoned. For four entire pages Capon teaches us how to observe an onion: its greenness, its roundness, its sort of roundness. Behold the skin’s papery thinness, the roots at the bottom and that thing at the top that has pulled it out of the ground. This is all before you get out a knife.
Then: the first cut. After the first cut, there’s a whole new world inside: the onion is not round, it’s a series of what he calls “embedded flames.” You press in on it and it feels inescapably alive. And then the onion begins to change you. Tears come. And now, your story is inescapably tied to this onion. The more you behold, meet with, and interact with this onion, the more this onion becomes part of your story, and the more you become part of this onion’s story. As Saint Bonaventure believed, everything in nature is “the mind’s road to God.”4
Behold Your Teenager
Let’s think.
The first step in youth ministry is to spend time in the society of Michael or Kate or Sienna. You may feel a certain resistance to that project. Please don’t. Michael and Kate and Sienna are excellent company. You may think you know everything there is to know about teenagers like Michael or Kate or Sienna, but you have to suspend those prejudices and observe them, for at least four pages. This all happens before the first cut.
But after their first cut,5 a whole new world of Michael or Kate or Sienna is revealed to us. Suddenly, they’re not at all what they seemed from the outside. These young people we see on the inside, after that first cut, are entirely different. If we press in on them, if we truly allow our lives to be connected with theirs, the tears come. The more tears that come, the more their stories become part of us and the more we become part of them. There’s no putting these changed young people back into the forms they once held. That’s the awe, the wonder, of youth ministry—because at the end of the day, regardless of our theological training or lack thereof, we too are amateurs. Love is what keeps us doing this work, beholding and cooking with young people. And God sees this work we do and calls it good. It is very, very good.
Every youth minister longs for young people to lead joyful lives. And yet, joy is not a product we can manufacture or a solution we can design. Joy is discovered more than created; we discover joy when we love as God loves, which is why Jesus urges his followers to follow his teaching. “Abide in my love,” Jesus tells his disciples. “I have said these things to you so that my joy may be in you, and that your joy may be complete” (John 15:10–11). Apparently, God desires joy for creation so much that we are made to seek it. We can bury or disguise this search (think of poor Eustace under his dragon scales), but God’s joy in us remains: we are God’s children, in whom God delights, and with whom God desires a joyful relationship.
The fact that we are hardwired to discover joy makes us vulnerable, however, to all manner of substitutes. Good behavior, achievement, entertainment, high-adrenalin experiences all feel, momentarily, like the discovery of joy. They feel like ways we might have transcended our daily existence to touch the face of God. But the route to joy is clear: “Abide in my love,” Jesus says. Follow his teaching to love as God loves. Joy is a journey of discovery, not a product to own or a goal to achieve. We can’t chase joy or manufacture it. Not that that stops us from trying.
It’s not that our efforts to create joy aren’t laudable. Theologian David Bentley Hart claims that ethical acts point us to a deeper, more transcendent desire for goodness, which can “reveal itself to us . . . we can recognize goodness when we see it because it has left its impress and its fragrance and its sparks on our souls.”6 In other words, if we peel back the layers of our desire for young people to be good, we may begin to discover that we are not the ones who award the title of “good kid” to the young people around us. God is. We may begin to discover that the ultimate end of our desire for our children is the goodness of God’s own self.
And God’s goodness requires no moralistic act on our end. In fact, our very image has been formed around that goodness, bearing witness to a living, active God. To glimpse that goodness in the life of another person is therefore to glimpse God already alive and at work in the life of that person. It requires only one thing: our capacity to approach the layers of another person with wonder. God’s goodness is not earned; it is a gift already given.
Experts versus Amateurs: Katy Perry’s Mission of Joy
The amateur is a rarity in contemporary culture. Even in ministry (including youth ministry), there is enormous pressure to be an “expert,” a “pro,” not an amateur. Performers are our best examples of this. The Super Bowl (of all things) has been called music’s “most important night of the year,” with Super Bowl halftime performances catapulting singers’ careers to new levels of stardom (or sometimes infamy). One performance, memorialized in countless memes, is Katy Perry’s 2015 Super Bowl halftime show. As she prepared to take the largest stage in the world, Katy Perry gathered her dance team for a preshow pep talk. She was on a clear mission to produce an experience of joy for her audience. “If you are here, you have been chosen,” she preaches to her dance troupe. “We are here to make people feel so much strength and power, and love and joy—ultimate joy—and ultimate light.” Reflecting on the event afterward, Perry’s personal testimony is even more striking:
The Super Bowl was a very spiritual moment for me. . . . At nine years old when you are singing into a hairbrush, you don’t dream of doing it twenty-one years later on the biggest stage in the world. For me, I [needed] something that [felt] new and exciting and challenging. . . . So I went back to the drawing board to create a whole specific show for this one moment in my life.7
Just as I (Abigail) start to accuse her of grandiosity, I remember the last youth event I planned. Like a seasoned youth pastor, Perry assures her leadership team of their critical value to the task ahead. (Check.) Like an adept designer, she carefully curates an experience for those expecting something larger-than-life—an event that might help young people “Ignite!” or “Make Your Life Count” or have “The Best Week of Your Life.” (Check.) The stage, the lights, the amplifiers, the dance troupe: these may not be part of your youth ministry experience. But sometimes it sure seems like they should be.
We sympathize with Perry because we’ve all been there: we’ve all orchestrated what we hoped would be the perfect retreat or the most compelling talk or sermon. Sometimes these efforts work according to plan. And sometimes they get derailed.
Despite her solid performance, Super Bowl XLIX’s halftime show is remembered best not for the huge golden lion Katy Perry rode into the stadium, not for the “ultimate joy” she had worked tirelessly to create, but for a backup dancer in a shark costume who went rogue during a beach scene number. Right Shark (yes, the dancing shark to the right of Perry) got all the moves, well . . . right. Left Shark, standing to the left behind Perry, in full view of the cameras, began dancing to a different drummer, an ebullient, bouncy, and weirdly lovable shark whose moves bore no resemblance to the show’s music or choreography. The next day, CNET’s news headline read: “Seahawks Lose Super Bowl, but Left Shark Wins the Internet.”8 Local news outlets floated leads like “Katy Perry’s ‘Left Shark’ Becomes America’s Darling,” and the London Telegraph observed that two dancing sharks “stole the show.”9 Two days, even two weeks, after the Super Bowl, #leftshark had more views than #patriots or #katyperry. What produced the most joy in Super Bowl XLIX’s halftime show was not the megawatt performance designed by a superstar but the screwup of a minor member of the troupe. Joy erupted rather than emerged by design. It broke out in the unexpected. It was “in spite of” more than “because of.”
God has a penchant for showing up in the places we haven’t planned for.
Both Robert Capon and Katy Perry would say they were on missions of joy. As youth ministers, we would too. But what is our approach? Are we more like Robert Capon, preparing to make a stew with an onion, or Katy Perry, getting ready for the Super Bowl? Do we approach joy as something to celebrate when discovered, bursting forth from what we think we already know—or is it something to design and produce, and invest with expertise? Is joy the result of loving preparation that beholds the onion, or is joy something we create in order for young people to feel moved?
From the Mountaintop to the Colloseum: Moving Closer to God
Performers like Katy Perry and youth ministers like us get two things right when we attempt to design for joy: (1) young people are, in fact, neurologically hardwired to be “moved,” and (2) we can design experiences that trigger elation and ecstasy—the experience of being “beside ourselves” and part of something larger-than-life—which we easily confuse with manufacturing joy. If there’s one thing we know about young people, it’s that they long to be moved. To be clear, we’re talking not about the movement that is bound to our physical world but movement that sweeps them into a larger purpose, and in so doing connects the dots between mind, body, and spirit. A desire “to be moved” is part of our human makeup. Those who vie for the attention of young people—performers, advertisers, educators, coaches, and youth ministers (to name a few)—have learned to capitalize on this desire.
This is hardly new. Humans have long known how to exploit human desires, including the adolescent longing “for locomotion,” as psychologist Erik H. Erikson once called it10—the desire to be moved, to be “on the go” physically and existentially. In the Roman Colosseum, the spectacle of choice included Christians, especially young women, succumbing to the lions. Their chase and subsequent death moved the crowds to cheer. In our century, we have the spectacle of the Super Bowl halftime show, which has the same goal of inciting cheers from the crowd. A young woman (Katy Perry) rides a lion into the arena (coincidence?). Justin Timberlake sings a tribute to the late pop star Prince. These moments are designed to move the crowds to cheer.
This is the objective of spectacle: to move us, viscerally and primally, in our gut. Perry wants to move us to joy. Timberlake wants to move us to tears. And it works. At the end of the game, we are “beside ourselves” (the Greek origin of the word “ecstasy”) with elation or grief; after the 2018 Super Bowl, overjoyed Philadelphia Eagles fans scaled lampposts and crestfallen New England Patriots fans commiserated over drinks (another time-honored way to be “moved” beyond yourself). Locomotion is the reason we get tickets to the show. Millions of dollars, elaborate costumes, and star-caliber players all unite so we can be swept into something that feels larger than life. Such design is as intentional (and profitable) as it is effective. There’s nothing amateur about it.
1. Manufactured Movement: Triggering Locomotion
Two forms of spectacle are especially beguiling to youth ministers, what we might call manufactured movement and manipulated movement. Teenagers possess a profound desire to be moved, and they are not terribly picky about what moves them. Even the young Augustine noted that he loved to “suffer” and sought occasions for weeping as a teenager.11 He didn’t care about what made him weep, as long as he got to do it. Every teenager who’s read Harry Potter or smoked weed can identify with Augustine’s perspective.
The experience of being moved is a bodily, physiological experience; we long for joy in our guts. Researchers at UCLA and at McMaster University discovered a micro-neurological pathway connecting the brain and the digestive system. This “brain-gut connection,” as scientists call it, explains that intuition—that feeling in our guts that we claim—actually is in our guts: it is the back-and-forth communication between microbes in our digestive tract and our brains. (The brain-gut connection was not lost on the New Testament writers; Mark’s account of Jesus having compassion upon the man with the withered hand can be translated literally from the Greek as “his guts turned over inside of him.” In other words, Jesus’s gut response to this man moved him to compassion.)
We’re also learning from neurologists like Daniel Siegel that emotions serve a transcendent, integrative function in the body; they orchestrate other physiological systems to work together. Emotions not only make us feel moved but they also get our bodies ready to physically move. In fight-or-flight mode, for example, you feel the emotion of fear so you can dodge the charging lion. Theologian Jürgen Moltmann argues that joy is the body’s existential parallel: “Joy is the power to live, to love, to have creative initiative; joy awakens our senses, energizes mind and body.”12 In short, joy hijacks our limbic systems to move us to a new point of consciousness; when the music, the atmosphere, and the beer all flow at just the right moment, we are “all systems go.” Our experience is no longer enclosed or self-focused; we have broken beyond the self to a broader sense of connection, an experience so powerful that we try to recapture it again and again. We return to the concert the next time the same musician is in town. We become “regulars” hoping for a repeat performance. Youth sign up for next year’s mission trip early, or return to the conference anticipating the same ritual, ecstatic “high” they experienced the first time they attended.
The reality is that certain kinds of ecstasy or feelings of transcendence can be intentionally triggered, because we are physiologically designed to seek them. Hart calls the ecstatic nature of our consciousness—the ability to stand outside one reality as we glimpse another—an inextinguishable yearning for truth; Gregory of Nyssa called it “the soul’s unquenchable eros for the divine.”13 This yearning connects us to the very ground of our reality: the God in whom we live, and move, and have our being. The medieval mystics understood the starting place for this “ecstasy” to be apart from our own actions. In other words, we can’t conjure it. For ancient church leaders, ecstasy was founded in a God who moved toward them—a God who moves toward us.
2. Manipulating Movement: Taking The Bachelor to Church
Of course, it is just a small step from manufacturing emotion to manipulating it for profit, even indirectly. Because our desire to be moved is so ingrained in what it means for us to be human, we have social and cultural liturgies that create these feelings on our behalf.14 Western culture does this by showing us, quite literally, what it wants us to experience. The idea here is that, emotionally speaking, what you see is what you get. Do you want to experience drama, arousal, or escape from your boring life? Don’t worry, The Bachelor airs on Monday nights.
French Marxist theorist and filmmaker Guy Debord argues that our relationships are negotiated by what we see. Debord maintains that when the things we experience in real time with real people (falling in love, for example) are transferred to images (watching people fall in love on reality TV), we negotiate our own relationships and social lives vicariously through those images. Instead of experiencing the real thing, we satiate our desires by watching something that makes us feel like it’s the real thing. The result, says Debord, is a society that has moved from being to seeing, from actual satisfaction to vicarious satisfaction. The images themselves become the “spectacle,” replacing our actual face-to-face, joy-discovering encounters with virtual joy—and we’re paying for it. With cash.
As it turns out, Western societies have been charging people something (money) for centuries to “get” what they want. Ancient Rome perfected the relationship between spectacle and consumerism. A colloseum was built where people could physically attend spectacles of life and death, enactments of their darkest fears and greatest triumphs. As spectators watched the young women face death, and the gladiators occasionally cheat it, the heights and depths of human emotion were triggered.15 These cultural “liturgies,” as theologian James K. A. Smith calls them—patterned repetition to what we’re seeing, doing, experiencing—are formative; they form or “catechize” our desires, wants, and loves.16 Just as the Super Bowl halftime show “catechizes” us to love Katy Perry and the NFL “catechizes” us to love Tom Brady, the church uses liturgy to form us as lovers of God. Think: Hillsong. Think: Thursday nights at camp. The difference between the liturgy of the world and the liturgy of the church is that our worship connects our longing for joy with the One who is the source of joy.
Obviously there is nothing wrong with designing for joy. Churches and youth ministers do it too—and why wouldn’t we? If there’s a place in the church where joy is lived out loud, then it’s decidedly in our youth ministries. We know the connection between joy and the divine; we want our young people to participate in the joy of the living God. We want young people to long for God’s presence. So we too design “moving” experiences, and specifically experiences aimed at moving youth closer to God. In this, we are not amateurs; we roll up our sleeves, pep-talk our teams, and carefully curate experiences of transcendence for the teenagers in our care. We have convinced ourselves that, with good enough design, with sufficient planning, and with adequate elbow grease, we can produce joy for young people. We can move them closer to God.
We’ve been here before. We call it Babel, described in Genesis 11:4, when the people tried to build their way to God and the whole project disintegrated into confusion. Like the builders of the tower of Babel, we sometimes forget that no amount of professionalism, no amount of planning or design on our part will move young people closer to heaven—which, of course, is the reason God came to us. Like an amateur derailing the show, God creeps in through the cracks of our best-laid plans and captures our affection in Left Shark–worthy, unexpected ways—whether it is what we have designed or not.
Responding to the Great Attractor
While Katy Perry was preparing for the Super Bowl in 2015, cosmologists at the University of Hawaii were mapping the universe. Brent R. Tulley and his team of intergalactic cartographers mapped the distance from Earth to “local” galaxies and the distance between galaxies. In 1961 we glimpsed Earth from outer space for the first time, and in 2016 Tulley’s team mapped a hunk of the universe that is 500 million light-years across. (Just to give you a sense of the scope of that map, it contains 100 million billion suns—including our own little star.) They named the newly mapped star supercluster Laniakea, or “immeasurable heaven.” But the fact that they claimed to have measured the immeasurable is not the interesting part.
Tulley’s team discovered, in the midst of these measurements, a gravitational push-and-pull within our supercluster of 100 million billion suns. Our immeasurable heaven is moving toward something. Cosmologists don’t know what is drawing the supercluster toward it, but they’ve given it a name: the Great Attractor. And it is directing Laniakea’s movement, whether our supercluster of stars perceives it or not.17
Christians believe we have been telling the story of the universe’s Great Attractor for centuries; “I, when I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all people to myself,” Jesus told his disciples (John 12:32). Alongside the modern-day magi of the University of Hawaii, we too stand in awe of the Great Attractor in our immeasurable heaven. Despite using a different calculation, we’ve arrived at the same stable, in front of the same Great Attractor whose gravitational force overwhelms us with wonder and joy.
If we are not called to manufacture or manipulate joy, then, how do we position young people to discover it? We stand in a tradition of those who seek: Augustine’s claim of restlessness until we rest in God; Blaise Pascal’s pronouncement of an infinite abyss; contemporary philosopher Charles Taylor’s claim that we are God-haunted, and that our longing for fullness cannot be filled by just anything.18 We are oriented toward a particular north, the person of Jesus Christ, who moves us by drawing us toward God, the source of joy.
Positioning young people to discover joy instead of consume it requires us to “flip the script” for much of what we do in youth ministry. Instead of being joy producers, we catechize young people into becoming joy responders, primarily by becoming joy responders ourselves. We become people who look for joy everywhere: in the lives of the young people we serve, in our own stories, in sorrow and in celebration. Instead of creating joy, we mine for it. Instead of manipulating for joy, we wait expectantly for joy to emerge.
It’s no secret that none of us leaves the spectacle, the show, the movie, or the colloseum having achieved deep and abiding joy. Like a fountain drink, the spectacle is never enough. To be clear: God can show up at a pop concert. (Karl Barth believed “God may speak to us through Russian Communism, a flute concerto, a blossoming shrub, or a dead dog.” We might add: “Or through Katy Perry.”)19 But spectacle primarily mimics the performative liturgies that the church has produced for centuries. Like the team of astronomers arriving late to the party, the pop culture industry is on to what the first-century church knew and practiced: humans long to joyfully worship a living God.
When youth ministry points to God’s joy instead of manufacturing a facsimile of it, we help young people recognize God’s movement toward them instead of mustering our energies to move them toward God. When we name the One who breaks through an immeasurable heaven and is now nearer to us than our hands and feet,20 the adolescent desire for locomotion is flipped. Instead of needing to achieve joy, young people are invited to commune with the source of joy, whose image marks the core of their beings like embedded flames. In this moment, the celebration shifts: no longer do we celebrate the joy of consumerism; we celebrate the joy that is all-consuming.
Practicing Celebration like Amateurs
What if youth ministry were less a workshop for creating well-adjusted, thriving adults and more a crucible for celebration, where the God of joy who is working in young people’s lives is noticed and claimed? In Scripture, the heroes are a bunch of amateurs: lovers of God, not religious experts (in fact, the religious experts do not fare very well in many biblical stories)—people with an unnerving propensity for celebration in the face of adversity. On the night of the Passover (with eighteen minutes’ notice, according to Jewish midrash—the amount of time it takes to bake matzoh), the Hebrews flee Egypt for their famed passage across the “Red” Sea. The fear of escape, the terror of an army at their heels, the horrors of passing through the sea make it one of the great dramas of all time. But read closely. For after the crossing, the first thing the people do upon making it to shore is celebrate, giving thanks to God. Moses’s sister Miriam leads the women in singing and dancing with tambourines (Exodus 15:20–21). What’s striking about the moment is not Miriam’s musical or communal leadership. It’s that every woman thought to pack a tambourine.21
Centuries later, a teenage girl in Nazareth learns via divine messenger that she would bear God’s Son into the world. We don’t know much about Mary’s story before this moment. We only know that, when God’s movement toward her is noticed and named by Elizabeth—in the midst of a pregnancy that could have been social suicide—Mary rejoices. It is worth noticing that Mary’s celebration is not a knee-jerk reaction or a shallow impulse to “party.” In fact, Mary’s first response is one of doubt, not celebration: “How can this be,” she asks the angel, “since I am a virgin?” (Luke 1:34). Waiting (ask any pregnant woman) is part of the suffering that comes with pregnancy: discomfort, worry, and impatience all come with the territory. Yet when Elizabeth sees Mary, even the baby in Elizabeth’s womb leaps in recognition that God is on the move and God’s purpose is being accomplished. As Elizabeth names God’s action in Mary, the Magnificat bursts forth. Before the results are fully in, Mary celebrates.
This is the nature of Advent—a season, like pregnancy itself, in which we practice anticipatory hope. Advent is a season when the church celebrates the fact that God is active, yet the finality of God’s action has not yet been revealed. Since the practice of celebration names God’s action, not ours, we are relieved of the need to produce results in order to give thanks and praise. At times, it might feel like we are waiting forever for God to show up, just as it seems to take pages and pages to get to the list of ingredients for the stew, but the stew doesn’t start by chopping an onion. We cannot practice youth ministry without wonder and celebration. We are called to notice, name, and praise the living God who delivers us, who made the onion, who created the young people we are called to serve. And so we wait, we hope, we celebrate.
The Celebration To-Do List: Advice for Amateurs
Maybe we can take some cues from Miriam and Mary about celebrating in the midst of anticipation. The structure of these stories gives us a place to start. Three things stand out:
1. Anticipation and celebration go together. For amateurs, anticipation and worry are not antithetical to celebration but rather serve as the context for celebration. In Christian tradition, celebration notices and names what God is doing, not what we are doing; it involves thanksgiving and praise for who God is as well as for what God does. As a result, celebration may seem premature; after all, the Hebrew people had not found food or drink or shelter when Miriam leads the singing and dancing, and Mary’s pregnancy was barely into its second trimester when she breaks into song. This is possible because, in both cases, the celebration is about God and not about them, noticing and naming God at work in their midst. Christian celebration takes place in the context of hopeful anticipation—waiting on the Lord, expectantly, while praising God for accomplishing God’s purposes.
In youth ministry, practices of celebration include strategies for anticipatory hope. Spending an hour in the society of a teenager is joyful because we anticipate the person God has created in the teen. Of course, this way of celebrating a young person requires us to abandon our prejudices of what we think the person is like, and instead actually behold the gift before us that God is revealing. Every game, concert, or coffee conversation with teenagers is an opportunity to practice noticing, beholding, and even naming God’s gracious activity in them, as revealed in their stories and experiences. Encountering young people with the expectation that God is already at work in their lives removes the pressure that we must somehow conjure God up for them—or worse, attempt to play God for them ourselves.
2. Friends help. Both Miriam and Mary celebrate with friends—people who have witnessed and can point out God’s incredible work in their lives. Whether the intimacy of Mary’s relationship with Elizabeth or the shared public witness of Miriam and the Hebrew women, celebration is a practice that shares what God is doing with others.
We all need people who “get” us in our ministries. Who helps us sing and dance in light of the good news that God’s purpose is being accomplished? To visit a colleague who understands your call might change the way you think of refueling your ministry. To attend a conference or nurture your own web of holy community are both valid options—for you, and for your young people. Who might they share their anxious waiting with, to the point that they can break out in song? What community helps them celebrate a milestone and names God’s gracious activity even before they have fully lived into it?
3. Pack your tambourine. I am astonished that Miriam had the presence of mind to pack a tambourine in the midst of the thousands of details she had to remember during the Hebrews’ escape. But the community’s celebration on the far shore of the “Red” Sea depended on someone remembering to pack the instruments for celebration. What does it look like to “pack your tambourine” in youth ministry? When our time seems dominated by the details of the mission trip, we have to plan on noticing and naming God in the moment. This might mean leaving some other things off our agenda. There is no faster way to forget to celebrate than overscheduling. Even spontaneous celebration is less likely to erupt if there is no space to do so. Prepare for eruption. Pack a set of notecards and pens to celebrate the young person who names God at work for the first time on a youth retreat; leave room during the lock-in for worship, silence, even sleep; block out days around trips so you have room for a leisurely dinner with your family or a day with your beloved to reconnect—all are ways we pack tambourines, anticipating opportunities to notice and name the good work of God among us.
What’s Already Done
No one in the church is better at celebration than people in youth ministry. If youth ministers bear any witness to the broader church, it is the gift of knowing how to celebrate, often against incredible odds. This is the triumph of Miriam (you saw us through that, God? Really?!). This is Mary’s song in the Magnificat (God, you’re changing the world through—of all people— me?). God has chosen us for youth ministry, people who notice and name God’s joy in young people’s lives before they have a chance or the tools to name it for themselves. If youth ministry is the epicenter of that celebration in the church, then we become God’s witnesses, not only to the broader congregation but also to the broader world—not because of a finished product we have manufactured but because of the signs of God’s hope already in our midst.
Youth ministry is not a process of mixing and adding ingredients in just the right amounts. We can let God be the master chef when it comes to that. Perhaps we’re the sous-chef. We’re the amateurs, taking cues from the master, discovering the richness of a new recipe for each young person’s life, and beholding the good, good work of the one whose joy is so deeply satiating for our souls.
Pro Tip: Have your leadership team read “From Sorrow to Celebration” (pp. 46–49). Ask your team to bring to your next meeting a story from their own lives that links sorrow and celebration. Consider having your volunteers host a night where young people (or an intergenerational cast!) prepare and share stories of sorrow and celebration.
1. Abraham Joshua Heschel, The Wisdom of Heschel (New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1986), 152.
2. Robert Capon, Supper of the Lamb: A Culinary Reflection (New York: Modern Library, 2002), 2–3.
3. Capon, Supper of the Lamb, 11.
4. Bonaventure, The Mind’s Road to God, trans. George Boas, Catholic Primer’s Reference Series (2005), https://basilica.ca/documents/2016/10/St.%20Bonaventure-The%20Minds%20Road%20to%20God.pdf.
5. Here we are using “cut” metaphorically, to refer to the experiences of adolescents that alter their worldview or have a profound effect on their lives.
6. David Bentley Hart, The Experience of God: Being, Consciousness, Bliss (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2013), 255.
7. “Katy Perry—Making of the Pepsi Super Bowl Halftime Show,” YouTube, February 9, 2016, www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFttH_etf4Y. Katy’s speech begins at 42:40.
8. Eric Mack, “Seahawks Lose Super Bowl, but Left Shark Wins the Internet,” CNET, February 2, 2015, https://www.cnet.com/news/seahawks-lose-super-bowl-but-left-shark-wins-the-internet/.
9. Tim Brown, “Katy Perry’s ‘Left Shark’ Becomes America’s Darling, Biggest Hit of Super Bowl Halftime Show,” Oregonian, February 2, 2015, https://www.oregonlive.com/nfl/index.ssf/2015/02/katy_perrys_left_shark_becomes.html; Neil McCormick, “Katy Perry’s Super Bowl Halftime Show Was like ‘The Hunger Games’ Crossed with SpongeBob SquarePants,” London Telegraph, February 2, 2015, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/music-news/11380200/katy-perry-superbowl-2015-halftime-show-review.html; and Telegraph Video, “Watch: Katy Perry’s Dancing Shark Forgets Routine during Super Bowl Halftime Show,” London Telegraph, February 2, 2015, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/culturevideo/11383839/Watch-Katy-Perrys-dancing-shark-forgets-routine-during-Super-Bowl-halftime-show.html.
10. Erik H. Erikson, Identity: Youth and Crisis (New York: Norton, 1968), 243–44; PDF version, https://archive.org/stream/300656427ErikHEriksonIdentityYouthAndCrisis1WWNortonCompany1968/300656427-Erik-H-Erikson-Identity-Youth-and-Crisis-1-W-W-Norton-Company-1968_djvu.txt.
11. Augustine, Confessions, trans. Henry Chadwick (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 37. The word “suffer” here recalls the idea of being totally overcome by one’s feelings.
12. Jürgen Moltmann, “Christianity: A Religion of Joy,” in Joy and Human Flourishing: Essays on Theology, Culture, and the Good Life, ed. Miroslav Volf and Justin E. Crisp (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2015), 72.
13. Hart, The Experience of God, 249.
14. James K. A. Smith references these kinds of cultural liturgies as “secular” liturgies: “Liturgies are the most loaded form of ritual practice because they are after nothing less than our hearts. They want to determine what we love ultimately. . . . ‘Secular’ liturgies are fundamentally formative, and implicit in them is a vision of the kingdom that needs to be discerned and evaluated. . . . Secular liturgies capture our hearts by capturing our imaginations and drawing us into ritual practices that ‘teach’ us to love something very different from the kingdom of God.” James K. A. Smith, Desiring the Kingdom: Worship, Worldviews, and Cultural Formation (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2009), 87–88.
15. “Whether the spectacle was a condemned gladiator fighting to his death or the prolonged suffering of someone on a cross, the spectators reveled in the so-called pleasure of the spectacle. . . . This co-participation in the condemnation of the criminal reinforced the social perception of Rome’s authority.” Chanon Ross, Gifts Glittering and Poisoned: Spectacle, Empire, and Metaphysics (Eugene, OR: Cascade, 2014), 31.
16. “Understanding cultural institutions as liturgical institutions, as dynamic structures of desire, primes us to have a more heightened and nuanced appreciation of what’s at stake in those institutions. . . . We should be discerning to what ends all sorts of cultural institutions are seeking to direct our love. In short, we will only adequately ‘read’ our culture to the extent that we recognize operative there an array of liturgies that function as pedagogies of desire.” Smith, Desiring the Kingdom, 73.
17. “Milky Way’s Place in the Cosmos—‘New Insights into the Great Attractor and Dark Energy,’ ” Daily Galaxy, February 10, 2016, https://dailygalaxy.com/2016/02/-mapping-the-milky-ways-place-in-the-cosmos-new-insights-into-the-great-attractor-and-dark-energy/. Thanks to Dr. Chanon Ross for pointing us to research on Laniakea.
18. Augustine, Confessions, 3; Blaise Pascal, Pensees (New York: Penguin, 1966), 75; Charles Taylor, The Secular Age (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007), 301.
19. Karl Barth, Church Dogmatics I/1 (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1975), 55.
20. Alfred, Lord Tennyson, “The Higher Pantheism,” Poetry Foundation, https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/45323/the-higher-pantheism.
21. Thanks to Rabbi Elan Babchuck, Director of Innovation, Clal, for sharing a similar interpretation of Exodus 15. Personal conversation, April 5, 2018 (Boston, MA).
