Chapter 9 of 18

Chapter 5

Chapter 5

[ Chapter Five ]

What to Preach On

How do you decide what to preach? It's a never-ending question for preachers because even after you're committed to preaching the Bible, it's not always obvious which text from the Bible you should preach to your congregation on any given Sunday. Should you skip around the Bible or follow it in order? Should you preach a paragraph, a chapter, a sentence, or a book?

Different men have answered those questions in different ways. Spurgeon wrote in his Lectures to My Students that he read his Bible and waited for the Holy Spirit to impress a text on his mind. Unfortunately, he said, sometimes the Holy Spirit waited until late on Saturday night to do the impressing, and sometimes He even switched things around on Sunday morning!11 Many preachers these days follow that model, choosing a verse or two each week from which to preach. Other men have set out to preach through the entire Bible from Genesis to Revelation, and a few others have even based their entire ministries on one particular book. One preacher named Joseph Caryl, a seventeenth-century Congregationalist minister, preached more than 250 sermons on the book of Job. He started in 1643 and ended almost twenty-four years later, in 1666!12

Similarly, the size of the text from which men preach varies. Some preachers preach only a sentence or two at a time, or verse by verse. Samuel Medley, an eighteenth-century Baptist in England, often preached sermons on just one word from the Bible. D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones, too, preached a famous sermon on Paul's words in Ephesians 2:4, "But God!" Other preachers prefer to preach on a paragraph, a single story, a chapter, or some other self-contained portion of text. Some preachers go even further, preaching a single sermon sometimes on multiple chapters, a whole book, a whole testament, or even the whole Bible!

In this chapter we want to try to make sense of some of these questions and make a case that the best diet of preaching for your church would be one that makes its way through entire books of the Bible—in both testaments and in all the different genres of the Scripture. Once again, we're not saying that this is the only way to think about a long-term preaching schedule. But in our experience this is a plan that tends to teach Christians to read the Bible, to study it for themselves, and to understand better how it fits together.

Preach through Entire Books

Both of us have based our preaching ministries largely on the practice of preaching straight through various books of the Bible. Neither of us does that with every book of the Bible; some of them simply don't demand that kind of progression the way others do. Psalms, for example, could certainly be handled in this way; it has a definite structure, and people can learn from preaching it progressively. But it is also made up of 150 discrete units, each of which can be preached on its own terms without losing most of what the psalmist was trying to convey.

That's not true of most of the books of the Bible. Most of the books of Scripture are organized such that one chapter builds on the previous one and lays groundwork for what's coming in the next one. The narrative books—Genesis, Exodus, the Histories, the Gospels—are stories, in which events follow one after another to create a whole. Similarly, the books of the Law and the Epistles of the New Testament are tightly organized, logically flowing discourses; they are full of "becauses" and "therefores" that only carry their full weight when they're understood in relation to what is said around them. The Prophets, too, build their messages one expanding piece at a time so that their books become most powerful when they are understood in their entirety.

Many Christians—and those who preach to them—treat the Bible as if it's a collection of wise sayings, the order of which doesn't matter very much. It's as if all of Scripture is the book of Proverbs or the sayings of Confucius. But most of the Bible isn't like that at all. God inspired each of the books of the Bible with a certain internal logic and order. He inspired narrative and argumentation and prophetic cases against His people. The books build to climaxes, and they have elegant twists embedded here and there within them. Part of our job as preachers, therefore, is to help our people see the beauty of Scripture. We're not just looking for "nuggets of wisdom" buried in useless iron ore; we want our people to see the majesty of the whole, and preaching through entire books helps us open their eyes to Scripture's beauty.

Now of course it's possible to drop into a book—whether Law, Prophets, Gospel, or Epistle—and be faithful to the context of the text you're preaching. But an extra power comes to bear when you have brought your congregation along from the beginning of the book and then find yourself at one of the mountain peaks of that book. I (Greg) recently preached a series through the book of Judges. We took eleven weeks walking through it and toured one disaster area of a chapter after another! Now I could have dropped right into the book and preached the story of Samson, for example, as a one-off sermon, and I think I could have faithfully kept that story in its context and preached it well. But by the time our congregation got to the story of Samson, we had the whole weight of the narrative behind us—the darkness and heaviness and, frankly, the grossness of it—to help us understand what was really happening when God raised Samson up as judge of Israel.

Or take another example. You could drop into the book of Matthew and preach the story of Jesus' temptation in the wilderness, and you could do a good job explaining to your congregation what is happening in that story. But imagine if you were coming to Matthew 4 with all the weight of Matthew 1–3 behind you in your people's minds. For three chapters Matthew's been laboring through genealogy, narrative, and prophecy to show that Jesus is the long-awaited King of Israel; and finally in chapter 4, immediately after His baptism, Jesus takes up the work of being Israel's King. He confronts Satan and, acting as Israel's Champion, recapitulates each of their paradigmatic failures. Unlike Israel, He rebuffs Satan's temptation to demand comfort from God ("Command these stones to become bread," v. 3). He turns back Satan's demand that He try to force God's hand in caring for Him ("Throw yourself from the temple," v. 6), and He refuses to compromise with God's enemy in order to gain His kingdom ("Worship me," v. 9). You see? The narrative of Matthew builds step-by-step to that point when Jesus straps on His kingly armor and goes to war with Satan as Israel's Champion!

Another good reason to preach through books of the Bible in their entirety is that doing so forces you to preach on uncomfortable portions of Scripture. Few of us relish the thought of preaching on the Bible's texts about divorce. It's a touchy subject with multiple twists and turns in the teaching that are hard to get skeptical listeners to follow, and it's frankly easier just to go to John 3:16 again than to plant yourself for a few weeks in Matthew 19! And yet it is in Scripture, and we are called to preach the whole counsel of God to our people. That's where preaching entire books helps. After Matthew 18 comes Matthew 19. After 1 Corinthians 5 comes 1 Corinthians 6, and if you've established a pattern of preaching straight through books, you can't avoid them.

That has lots of good effects in our preaching and in our larger spiritual lives. For one thing it works hard against any fear of man that lurks in our hearts. One of the most crippling diseases for a preacher of God's Word is a fear of saying hard things from the pulpit—a blanching at the thought of preaching something that might offend and a resulting tendency to stay away from hard passages of the Bible. Preaching through entire books works against that fear and tendency because it forces us to preach those hard passages when they appear. In fact, it can help turn our sinful fear of man against itself—think ju jitsu!—because we won't want to face questions about our lack of courage if we skip from Matthew 18 to Matthew 20!

On the other hand, preaching through those books also protects us from being "blamed" for preaching hard passages at particular times. If you just skip around the Bible preaching what you think the congregation needs to hear, when exactly do you decide to preach on Jesus' teaching about divorce? The week you hear about a troubled marriage? The week after one of your church members, or their daughter, files for divorce? See, the trouble is that when it comes to those touchy passages, there's never a Sunday when you can preach them without somebody in your congregation thinking you've chosen this Sunday because of them. If your practice is to preach through entire books, though, you can lessen that danger considerably: "Sister Susan, no, I didn't preach this sermon because your daughter filed for divorce last week. I've been preaching through Matthew for three months, and we just happened to be in Matthew 19 today. Maybe you should send her this sermon, though? It might be helpful for her."

Not only that, but preaching through books forces you as a preacher—and therefore your church as well—to grapple with passages of Scripture with which you're not already familiar. As a result, you learn new things; you grow in your knowledge of God and His Word; and you mature as a Christian and as a pastor. If you skip around the Bible in your preaching, you will likely gravitate toward passages you already have thought long and hard about, passages you know a lot about already. We'd bet you're not likely to skip over to 2 Kings 14:7, for instance, and preach on King Amaziah's slaughter of ten thousand Edomites in the Valley of Salt and his renaming of Sela as Joktheel. Who would? Give me John 14:7 any day! But God inspired 2 Kings 14 for a reason, and the story of Amaziah's disobedience to God is part of the whole counsel of God that we are to preach to our people. Preaching our favorite passages, or the texts with which we're most familiar, means that our growth as preachers and even as Christians will be stunted. There are treasures unknown in the text we encounter as we preach through books.

Preach from the Whole Bible

We hinted at this point in the last paragraph, but we as preachers are called to preach the whole Bible to our people. If people sit under our preaching for any length of time, they should eventually hear us preach from a good cross-section of the entire Bible. That doesn't mean we should start in Genesis and end in Revelation; many men have done that, and it could be a fine idea sometimes. In our ministries, we have made it a practice to preach systematically through the various genres of Scripture and to move back and forth between the two testaments as we do so.

The Bible isn't all the same. It contains poetry, narrative, tightly reasoned argumentation, apocalypse, lists, numbers, law, biography, letters, wisdom, prophecy, and other genres, too. And of course, it's also made up of two testaments, the Old and the New. All of that, in its own way, is useful for our people; they need to hear from all of it over a given period of time. Both of us therefore have adopted a certain method for trying to make sure we preach from all the different parts of the Bible over a short period of time. Here's how we do it.

The Old Testament can be divided into five different genres, or categories if you prefer: Law, Histories, Wisdom, Major Prophets, and Minor Prophets. Similarly, we've divided the New Testament into the categories of Gospels and Acts, Pauline Epistles, and General Epistles and Revelation. With those categories in mind, we try to bounce back and forth through the categories and between the testaments. Here's how it looks:

  • Law
  • Histories
  • Wisdom
  • Major Prophets
  • Minor Prophets
  • Gospels and Acts
  • Pauline Epistles
  • General Epistles and Revelation
  • A preaching schedule for a year might look something like this: I pick a book of the Law, then a Gospel, then an OT book of history, then a Pauline Epistle, then a Wisdom book, then a General Epistle, then a Major Prophet, then another Gospel (or perhaps Acts), then a Minor Prophet, then another Pauline Epistle, then a different book of the Law, and so on. If your preaching series are ten to thirteen weeks in length, that lineup you've just read could stretch over about three years. If your series are generally longer, you could be looking at half a decade or more. Here, for example, is a list of the sermons I (Mark) preached at Capitol Hill Baptist Church over the first four years of my pastorate:

  • Mark in 13 sermons
  • Ezra in 4 sermons
  • 1 Thessalonians in 7 sermons
  • Ezekiel in 4 sermons
  • Overviews of the General Epistles (1 sermon per book) in 9 sermons
  • Proverbs in 5 sermons
  • Mark 1:1–3:6 in 9 sermons
  • Deuteronomy in 5 sermons
  • 1 and 2 Timothy in 6 sermons
  • 1 and 2 Chronicles in 4 sermons
  • 1 John in 5 sermons
  • Joel in 4 sermons
  • Mark 3:7–6:6 in 6 sermons
  • Song of Solomon in 2 sermons
  • Overviews of the Old and New Testaments (1 sermon each) in 2 sermons
  • 1 Timothy in 3 sermons
  • James in 5 sermons
  • Joshua in 5 sermons
  • John in 11 sermons
  • Overviews of the Major Prophets (1 sermon per book) in 4 sermons
  • Titus in 6 sermons
  • Overviews of the Wisdom Books (1 sermon per book) in 5 sermons
  • 1 Peter in 13 sermons
  • The point here is not the length of the series but that, over a reasonable amount of time, our congregations are being exposed to the entire map of God's Word, instead of 250 sermons on Job! No, they're not getting every word of the Bible, but they are hearing us preach narrative, prophecy, law, gospel, apocalypse, epistle, argumentation, and genealogy. They're hearing us preach from both the Old and the New Testaments. They're learning how the Bible fits together, and in the process our hope is that they learn to appreciate and understand all those genres better.

    So, how long should your series be? It's hard to say anything with certainty, but the benefit of using a structure like we've just described begins to break down if you preach five years in Deuteronomy. For that reason we prefer to make our series something like three to six months long. Sometimes we make it through entire books (even long ones) in that period of time, and other times we just take a portion of a book over that time period. When I (Greg) first came to Third Avenue Baptist Church, I preached the first thirteen weeks on the book of Matthew, but I only made it through the first seven chapters. Then the next fall, I picked up Matthew again and preached from Matthew 8–13 in another fourteen sermons. In the meantime I preached a number of other books in series of different lengths. Here's the schedule for my preaching ministry through my first few months at Third Avenue:

  • Matthew 1–7 in 13 weeks
  • The whole book of Genesis in 5 weeks
  • The whole book of Titus in 3 weeks
  • The whole book of Judges in 9 weeks
  • The whole book of Hebrews in 11 weeks
  • Five different Psalms in 5 weeks
  • Matthew 8–13 in 11 weeks
  • The whole book of James in 7 weeks (I broke the OT/NT pattern here!)
  • At that rate I think it will take me one or two years' worth of preaching to make it through the whole book of Matthew. I think it's good for me to preach the book in shorter series, and to take my church to other books in the interim. That way, their minds don't grow cold and bored, and their attention is renewed when we move to a new book.

    Preach from Both a High Altitude and a Low Altitude

    Did you ever see the video Powers of Ten? It's an old film that starts with a picture of a couple lying next to each other in the grass, and it tells you that you are looking at them from ten feet above the ground. Then the camera zooms out to one hundred feet, then a thousand feet, then two miles, then twenty miles, two hundred miles, two thousand miles, twenty-thousand miles, two-hundred thousand miles, two million miles, and so on. The earth disappears eventually, and you find yourself staring at the solar system, then the Milky Way, then a thousand galaxies. Then, the camera begins to move in by powers of ten. Eventually the couple on the grass comes back into view, but the camera keeps going until you're looking at a single cell on the guy's hand, then a molecule, then an atom, then an electron, and so on. It's a fascinating video because depending on your altitude, you see and understand different things.

    The same thing is true for the Bible. Many preachers have the idea that the only appropriate altitude, or frame of reference, for preaching is one verse at a time, or perhaps at most one paragraph. Preaching at that level is fine and good. In fact, a short paragraph or self-contained story is probably the most natural level at which to preach.

    On the other hand, there is often much benefit for a congregation when a preacher does something different and gives them either a broader or a narrower frame of reference than what they are used to. In fact, we think it is probably a good idea to vary your altitude in your preaching ministry, to preach some series that take paragraphs as texts, some series that take individual verses, and some that take chapters or multiple chapters or even entire books. I (Mark) tried to make it a point through the first few years of my ministry to preach what I call an "overview sermon" on each of the sixty-six books of the Bible as well as overviews of the New Testament, the Old Testament, and the entire Bible. I'm glad I did that. Those overview sermons have turned out to be some of the most useful sermons I've preached for my congregation because they give a snapshot of entire books and the message those books are laboring to get across.

    Of course preaching from small units of text has advantages, and both of us try to do that on a regular basis. When you are dealing with only a few verses, you can draw out nuance and meaning at a very gritty level. Every word can be considered and opened up; prepositions, adjectives, and connecting words become fountains of meaning. The drawback to that approach is that over time your congregation can have their eyes so close to those individual texts that they lose sight of where they've come from and where they're going.

    Similarly, preaching larger pieces of text, or whole books has both advantages and disadvantages. When you have only forty-five minutes or an hour to preach the whole book of Isaiah, you're necessarily going to miss things. You're going to gloss over whole sections of text with a sentence or two. But we think the advantages of an approach like that make it worth doing sometimes. When you preach a book in one or just a few sermons, what you're doing is taking a step back from its details to consider the thrust of the whole book. Think again about Isaiah, for instance. Most people tend to think about Isaiah as a massive bowl of undifferentiated judgment spaghetti, with a messianic meatball thrown in here and there (Isa. 9; 11; 53). But if you look at the book as a whole, you see that it's really more like a sword than a bowl of spaghetti. It has a shape, a weight, a point, a feel—all of which will be easier for your church to grasp if you preach it at a higher altitude than if you were to preach it verse by verse over several years. I (Greg) preached the whole book of Isaiah in three sermons, for example, one of which was on thirty-eight chapters at once! That experience most definitely challenged me and made me wish at times that I wasn't moving so fast. But on the other hand, people still tell me they remember the shape and weight and feel of Isaiah because of those sermons. They've learned to "wield" it because they were able to take in the whole from a high altitude.

    Besides, it's not as if you only get one shot to preach each book of the Bible. My (Mark's) plan has been to move over the course of my ministry from a generally higher altitude in my preaching to a generally lower one. So I preached a sermon on the whole Bible, then on the New Testament, then on the Gospel of Luke, one chapter at a time. Maybe in a few years, if the Lord tarries, I'll go back and preach it again a paragraph or two at a time. If that happens, that will be something like four times that I've preached through the book of Luke (if you count the times I preached "through" it when I preached through the whole Bible and the New Testament). I'm just preaching through it at varying altitudes and learning new things every time I do.

    On the other hand, I (Greg) don't have such a structured plan. Even now, in the first few years of my ministry, I'm preaching some books at a high altitude and some at a low altitude. That helps my congregation, I find, not to get too frustrated with either approach. Those who prefer verse by verse exposition are more willing to learn happily while I preach through Genesis in five sermons if they know I'm going to be returning to a closer look at Matthew in the next series. Over time I hope my people are learning to see the Bible in a fully textured and three-dimensional way—as a whole Book, full of whole books, full of whole sentences, in which every word counts.

    Plan Your Preaching Schedule in Advance

    The famous third-century preacher John Chrysostom told his congregation in His third sermon on Lazarus and the rich man, "I often tell you many days in advance the subject of what I am going to say, in order that you may take up the book in the intervening days, go over the whole passage, learn both what is said and what is left out, and so make your understanding more ready to learn when you hear what I will say afterwards."

    We think that's a great idea, and we both try to follow that practice in our own churches by publishing a card that gives our preaching schedule—texts and titles—for the upcoming months. Doing something like that offers a number of benefits. First, like Chrysostom said, it gives your people time to read the passage in advance, to let the Holy Spirit begin to work in their hearts with the themes of that text, and to prepare their hearts to hear the Word of God preached on Sunday. That, in turn, can create a unique sense of excitement in the church. The people come with thoughts of their own, questions and insights about the text; and your words in the sermon are then able to interact with and catalyze with the thoughts they already have. Publishing a preaching schedule will give your people another tool for talking with their non-Christian friends and family about spiritual things. People take those cards, highlight or circle a particular sermon title they think a non-Christian friend might be interested to hear, and then hand it to that person as an invitation to come hear that sermon.

    Sometimes people ask us if we think planning a preaching schedule so far in advance could squelch the Holy Spirit. What if something comes up in the life of the church that begs to be addressed? What if you get sick? What if something happens in the world such that your planned series seems out of place all of a sudden? Good questions all. But we don't think planning a schedule in advance squelches the Holy Spirit.

    For one thing we don't think the Holy Spirit only moves "in the moment." Of course He does that sometimes, but that's not the only time He does it. The Holy Spirit also moves and directs months in advance when we are planning a preaching schedule. Both of us have been amazed at how people in our congregations have been impacted by a particular sermon or series in specific and time-sensitive ways. That's not because we planned for that to happen. On the contrary, we believe the Holy Spirit worked it all together in His providence. Take a look, for example, at this church card from Capitol Hill Baptist Church for the fall of 2001, which included September 11, 2001.

    That preaching schedule was made months in advance of the terrorist attacks in New York and Washington. Nothing was adjusted; nothing was changed in the aftermath of the attacks. But look at God's provision for this congregation right in the heart of one of the cities that came under attack: "The Quest for Justice," "The Quest for Security," "When Bad Things Happen: Questions and Confidence." The Holy Spirit was planning, even months before, to feed His people with truth from His Word that would impact their lives and their needs directly and specifically in the aftermath of—and even in advance of—a world-shaking event.

    Not only that, but adherence to a preaching plan doesn't have to be slavish. Mark tends to stick to a preaching plan more doggedly than I (Greg) do. If Mark gets sick or something else intervenes, the church card is what the church card is—even if it means skipping a sermon in a series. I, on the other hand, have been known to pull all the sermon cards from our pews and print another batch.

    We both have the same approach, more or less, to holidays. We both try to plan series in which the sermons that land nearest Christmas and on Easter won't be utterly weird—though Mark preached once on Christmas Day an entire sermon on death! But we don't insist that Christmas be from Luke 2 and Easter from Matthew 28. On Christmas Day 2011, I'm scheduled to preach on James 5:13–20, the prayer of the righteous for the sick. For Easter 2011, though, I shifted some things around so that I'd be preaching on Hebrews 8 rather than Hebrews 6. That was in the expectation that we would have an unusual number of visitors in the congregation who would attend church only infrequently, and I wanted a text that would have the gospel itself as the main point.

    However you end up doing this, and however tightly you stick to a plan once it's made, the point is that planning your preaching schedule well in advance can give your people a good tool both for their own spiritual growth and for evangelism.

    So, how do you decide what to preach? Well, as we said before, everything should be done for the edification of the church. We would argue that preaching through entire books, preaching from both testaments and all genres of Scripture, preaching from varying altitudes, and publishing in advance what you're going to preach will best accomplish that goal in the long run.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑