Chapter 7
[ Chapter Seven ]
The Structure of a Sermon
Have you ever built a model rocket? Neither have we. But from what we understand of model rockets, it stands to reason that if you were going to build one, it would be really important to get all the pieces in the right places and working properly. If you put the rocket's nose on the side instead of on the top, the thing is not likely to fly. If the thruster is on the top rather than on the bottom, you'd probably get a nice fire but little altitude. Even if everything is in the right place but one part isn't working properly, the rocket isn't going to fly—at least not straight. If you want the rocket to fly, all the various pieces have to be in the right place, and they also have to be functioning properly.
A sermon is something like a toy rocket. If you want it to fly and accomplish its purpose, you have to understand something of the various pieces, you have to get those pieces together in good order, and you have to make sure each piece is functioning properly. In this chapter we want to consider five "pieces" of a typical sermon, give some advice about them, and make some comments about how they fit together to make a sermon fly. Those pieces are introductions, exegesis, illustrations, applications, and conclusions.
Introductions
Martyn Lloyd-Jones was a doctor before he was a preacher, and he often took his medical perspective into the pulpit with him. He thought of the people arrayed before him as his patients, and his task as a preacher was to give them medicine from the Word that would help heal them from their spiritual diseases. Lloyd-Jones thought highly of the usefulness of the first few paragraphs of a sermon. They were, he said, his first and best chance to win the attention of people who otherwise would not care what he was saying. Here's how he put it:
I am not and have never been a typical Welsh preacher. I felt that in preaching the first thing that you had to do was to demonstrate to the people that what you were going to do was very relevant and urgently important. The Welsh style of preaching started with a verse and the preacher then told you the connection and analyzed the words, but the man of the world did not know what he was talking about and was not interested. I started with the man whom I wanted to listen, the patient. It was a medical approach really—here is a patient, a person in trouble, an ignorant man who has been to quacks, and so I deal with all that in the introduction. I wanted to get the listener and then come to my exposition. They started with their exposition and ended with a bit of application.13
I (Mark) think Lloyd-Jones is absolutely right. The introductions I often hear in otherwise good sermons are frequently underused. Sometimes they are simply an invitation to turn to the text, which is really no introduction at all. Other times they're a story or a joke with only a tenuous connection to the sermon's main theme. Great things can be accomplished in sermons through introductions. Each preacher will develop his own style, of course, but introductions should not be thrown away as if they don't matter or are not spiritually useful. On the contrary, introductions form a kind of funnel for the congregation's interest. They draw together all the disparate and conflicting focuses that mark your congregation and pull attention to the themes you're going to be preaching on. Even more, sermon introductions are a good way to front-load application for the Christian and also to let non-Christians who are present know that they are welcome, and that they are heard.
What do I mean by front-loading application for the Christian? I don't mean that you should literally begin with all your applications. What I mean is that your congregation will be helped to listen well if they understand why the things you're saying are relevant to them. That relevance can be in any number of categories. It may be a challenge to their way of thinking, or an exhortation about their Christian lives, or a clarification of some doctrine. The sermon can matter to them in the sense of encouraging or comforting them as they come to understand God and His ways more, or it can matter in the sense of instructing them on what they ought to do. Whatever the kind of relevance, the point of an introduction should be to teach your congregation that they listen to sermons not just to pile up religious knowledge so they can win Bible Trivial Pursuit the next time they play! No, the reason we listen to sermons is to be instructed, encouraged, challenged, corrected, and spurred on in the faith; and sermon introductions can be a valuable way of setting that expectation right up front.
Any text of Scripture you handle in a sermon will have implications for people's understanding or feeling or doing, and if you start with just a taste of some of those implications—if you ask some of those questions or challenge some of those presuppositions up front—it will help your congregation pay attention. It will help them care about the sermon more than if you simply say, "Last week we finished chapter 7, and now we begin with chapter 8 verse 1." That kind of approach assumes a great deal of interest in the text; it assumes everyone present is waiting with baited breath to hear what you have to say about chapter 8. That may be true of your church; if so, never leave! In most churches, though, it's just not the case. People come into corporate worship with a thousand things on their minds—children, the in-laws, who's coming to dinner, how am I going to pay that bill, wow look at her dress, I need a nap, do the Cowboys play at 12:30 or 4:00—and if you don't arrest all those lines of thought right from the beginning, you'll probably never be able to corral them. A good introduction will offer the congregation a motivation to put their distractions on hold for a while and do the hard work of listening well to a careful biblical sermon, the kind of sermon that will help them mature both as a congregation and as individual Christians.
A second thing I try to accomplish with introductions is to involve non-Christians who are present and let them know that they are heard, that their concerns and questions and objections are being taken into account in the sermon they're about to hear. Generally, people who disagree with you will assume that the arguments and points you make are off because you don't understand something about them, their concerns, or their perspective. As a preacher and pastor, I genuinely understand that, and I would like to understand them. More, I would like to show them that I am preaching as someone who has at least tried to understand them.
Let me give you an example of what I mean. Here's a fairly brief introduction I (Mark) preached in a recent sermon on Mark 1:35–39, the passage where Simon Peter finds Jesus out praying early in a solitary place, and Jesus teaches His disciples that He had come to preach. My introductions are sometimes longer than this, sometimes more elaborate, and sometimes tie in better with the conclusion of the sermon. But I think this will give you a good idea of what I mean by involving the non-Christians in your congregation:
Enigma, from the Greek word for "fables" and to speak in riddles, means something obscure or hard to understand, like an inscrutable problem or a mysterious person.
It's amazing when you think about it that by far the most written-about person who has ever lived should be such an enigma to so many people. But there's no denying that He is. "I pray to Jesus for the good winds," said one Hindu girl, as she told me of a whole list of gods she prayed to. "I don't believe He ever existed," said another person. Even among those who revere His name, Jesus is often no more than a remote figure, comforting or forbidding by turns, depending on my own emotional state or sense of guilt. Historically we know a lot about who Jesus was in the plain sense of the question—a Jewish first-century itinerant Palestinian teacher. But in the deeper sense—why Jesus was—ah, now that is the enigma.
Why did Jesus live? Why did He come? To meet felt needs? To be a shining example of personal spirituality? To teach the esoteric insights of the ages or the virtuous way to live?
Why did Jesus come? At the time of Jesus' ministry, many different ideas were around. Many thought He had come simply as a rabbi. After all, He was addressed as "rabbi." He proclaimed God's law, taught in synagogues, gathered disciples, debated with the scribes, was asked to settle legal disputes, and even sat as He taught, the traditional rabbinic way of teaching.
Others saw His miracles and thought He had primarily come to perform wonders of healing and exorcism and the multiplying of food. Some saw Him as a reincarnated Old Testament prophet, others as someone who drove out demons by the power of the prince of demons. He was called a king, a glutton, a drunkard, a prophet, a criminal, a revolutionary, God, and a blasphemer. Why did Jesus come?
That's what the Gospel of Mark wants to tell us about this morning. Our text is Mark 1:35–39.
In that introduction my hope was to have helped both the Christians and the non-Christians listen well to the rest of the sermon. My intention was that Christians would not only be informed where the text was in the Bible but would also plant in their minds something of the significance of the issues raised in it. This text often has been preached as "follow Jesus as an example. Go off by yourself to have a quiet time, and make sure to have your morning watch early in the morning." I hope, though, that my congregation will come to understand that far larger issues are at stake here, that Jesus' very identity and purpose are tied up in how he answered Simon Peter's request to come see the crowds.
And for non-Christians listening, my hope was that they would hear and understand that this Christian preacher has some understanding of mystery, has Hindu friends, has conversations with non-Christians, and understands that people have various estimates of Jesus. And I want them to think these things not because I'm fundamentally concerned with what they think about me, but because I want them to be persuaded that they are going to hear a fair presentation of who Jesus is and who He claimed to be.
Exegesis
We've said this before, but it's worth saying it again: The foundation of every good sermon is a good understanding of the text it's expositing. That's true not just for the preacher in his preparation and actual delivery but also for the congregation as they listen. For that reason it's crucial that your sermon clearly explain what is going on in the text.
Preachers are tempted to err in their exegesis in two important ways—either by giving too much information or by giving too little. Either can be hugely detrimental to the power of a sermon to accomplish its purpose. Some preachers, on the one hand, are tempted to skip over the exegetical part of a sermon and move too quickly to illustration and application. It's easy to see the temptation of that approach. Congregations generally perk up when you make it clear that you're moving to application; they respond more and better. Heads nod, "amens" come. That doesn't happen so often when you're explaining the flow of thought in Romans 7. But doing the work of teaching is important nonetheless, not so much because your congregation will find the teaching scintillating but because the teaching of the text provides the foundation from which application can be launched. If you try to apply a text before your congregation understands it, the power of that application will be drained enormously. When the congregation can see clearly that application is coming directly from the meaning of the text, it impacts their minds and hearts with its full power.
The opposite error some preachers make is to give their congregations every piece of information they ran across in their study of the text. The meanings of Greek words, their etymologies, a list of all the other places in Scripture where a certain word is used, archaeological backgrounds of every place mentioned—all of it gets thrown into the discourse as if it's a Wikipedia article on the text instead of a sermon.
It's best not to do that. Instead, the portion of your sermon devoted to teaching should take as its singular goal to help your people understand the weight and balance of the text. You should certainly explain to them why Jesus answers this question as He does or why Paul follows up discussion of this topic with a discussion of that topic. But most of the time the particular etymology of the Greek word underlying that adjective won't be necessary for a congregation to understand the meaning of that text. Yes, it might add some color, or you might find it interesting, but it can also distract from the power of the text's main direction and thrust. I (Greg) preached a sermon some years ago, when I was much greener (!), in which I interrupted my explanation of a certain psalm to explain that when you're going to pronounce the Hebrew word chesed, you have to be careful to make a good, rolling guttural sound in the back of your throat! I'm not sure why I did that. It was a true point; I was and remain absolutely right about it. But it was also completely irrelevant to the point the text was making, and I was pilloried for it later when the church staff reviewed the sermon. In another sermon on the first chapters of Isaiah, I decided to fill my congregation in with detail on the political and geographical situation of Assyria and Egypt vis-à-vis Israel. It was all interesting to me, but it was utterly irrelevant to what God was saying in that text. I could have said what was necessary in two minutes rather than in twenty. That ended up being a seventy-five-minute sermon. It still embarrasses me to think about it.
A good, general rule of thumb is to include only those details necessary to illuminate the meaning of the text and drive its point forward and home. If certain detail doesn't do that, don't use it in the sermon.
Illustrations
Illustrations are easily some of the most abused parts of sermons today. Some preachers abominate them and don't use them at all. Others seem to think that sermons are composed only of illustrations. I (Mark) remember hearing a sermon some years ago in which a preacher gave a ten- or fifteen-minute illustration in a half-hour sermon. In all honesty it was a good story that he told well and convincingly. I remember the details of it even now. I remember the plot line of the story. In fact, I even remember some of the names of the people involved, and that's highly unusual for me. But here's the rub: I could not begin to tell you the passage of Scripture this brother was preaching on, or what his points were, or the spiritual impression of the text. I don't even remember the point he was illustrating with the story. All I remember is the story.
We're told by experts that we live in a narrative age. That may be true, but it also makes one wonder if there has ever been an age—knowing how humans experience time and memory—that wasn't a narrative age. When have people ever not liked stories? Stories involve us. We find stories in the Old Testament, extended images of marriage and adultery used in the prophets, Pharaoh's dreams and Nathan's parable of the rich neighbor taking the poor neighbor's only sheep. And of course, all the history of Israel comes down to us in stories—a set of characters in which action takes place over some period of time. It is only natural, therefore, that preachers communicate by using illustrations, not just in this age but in every age. Nevertheless, we need to take great care in using them. We need to make sure that our illustrations don't overwhelm the sermon, that they don't take too long, and that their own drama doesn't detract from the weight and thrust of the sermon as a whole. Illustrations are meant to illuminate not to obscure. Here, therefore, are a couple of pieces of advice about illustrations:
Illustrations don't have to be stories. Sometimes an arresting description of a scene will serve as a perfect illustration. It will bring a biblical story to life and impress on your hearers the importance of the scene. For example, in Hebrews 13, the author exhorts his readers to go "outside the gate" with Jesus. It's an image of the rejection that would come to Christians because of their allegiance to Christ. Now, in illustrating what the author means there, you could certainly tell a story about a time when you felt rejection because of your faith. But might it not be better, and even more arresting, NOT to tell a story but rather just to describe what the author of Hebrews would have been thinking when he wrote the phrase "outside the gate?" Here's how I (Greg) handled that passage when I preached on it. This is word for word from my notes:
Have to understand what it meant to be "outside the camp," "outside the gate." Inside the gate you had holy ground, but outside was where filth and uncleanness were. Would have been obvious if you could walk up; Judah, Ephraim and their banners. But outside—That's where dead bodies were buried. It's where people relieved themselves. If you went outside the camp, you had to be ritually cleansed before you came back in. And all around, outside the camp, ramshackle huts—lepers who would wail, "Unclean! Unclean!" and run away lest the wind blow their sickness onto someone else. Same outside the city. That's where Jesus died—out there. Even Romans determined that crucifixion was too dirty to be done in the city. Out there, with the uncleanness. Astonishing thought, really, when you think about it, that life would be found in a place of death, that holiness and righteousness would be won in a place of the most revolting uncleanness.
And know what? It's a good thing, too, because that's where I am. If you knew your heart, you'd cry out "unclean, unclean" because you'd know that where you belong is among the graves and the filth. And yet it's exactly to people like me and you that Jesus came—to the unclean so that we may be clean, to the unholy so that we may be holy. Reverses infection. He suffered and died outside the camp, where I am, where you are. Don't run away, run to Him. GOSPEL Have to realize you're outside the camp, can't win righteousness. Praise God, we find life outside the gate, because that's where we are!
Good to remember when a Christian, too. When sin beats us down, when you find yourself dead spiritually. Jesus is not one who wants you to clean yourself up before you come to him. People say all the time, "Need to get things in order before I go to Him, talk to Him, before I serve Him." As if you should scrub and scrub because you're going to the King's throne room. O friend, if that's what you think, then you don't know Him! This is not a King who is afraid of dirt. This is a King with scars in His hand because He died outside the gate. This is a King who loves those who are dirty and filthy, whose natural place is outside the gate, and who know it, and who come to Him to take mercy from his hand. Dear brothers and sisters, if your sin is heavy and filthy in your life, go to Him; bow down; hand it to Him. It won't be a surprise to him. He suffered and died outside the gate, not to save those who have no sin but to save those who are broken by sin and cry out to Him for salvation.
See, there's no story there, but my hope was that an arresting description of what it meant to be "outside the gate" would set up the truth that Jesus loves sinners who realize they are hopelessly filthy. The description, not a story, set the stage for that point.
Be careful with personal illustrations. One modern habit that is especially problematic is the overuse of the personal illustration, the story of how you did something or spoke to someone. Start a sentence with "I was talking yesterday with . . ." and watch how your congregation tunes back in, how their focus comes right back to the pulpit! That's entirely normal and expected. There's nothing unusual about it because it's a change of pace, you learn something about the speaker, and there may be a little entertainment value, too. But for all their power, personal illustrations should only be used with the greatest of care. If you're a faithful pastor, you'll already have enough temptations to build a congregation too much around yourself and your own personality. In part, God has given you that personality to do just that—to be a winsome preacher of the gospel and to implore people to come to faith in Christ. But on the other hand, you must be careful not to allow your church to become the church of Mark or the church of Greg instead of the church of Jesus Christ. Use yourself sparingly, and never leave the impression that the church's life or health depends on you. Never leave the impression that you're the hero or the smartest, wittiest guy in the city. When you do use personal illustrations, make yourself a bad example sometimes—the person who said the wrong thing rather than the right thing, the person who is in desperate need of God's grace. If your illustrations only illustrate your goodness and brilliance, they have failed to illustrate the gospel of Jesus.
Application
One of the most common questions asked of us as expositional preachers is, "When you preach expositionally, how do you apply the text in the sermon?" First, we should note that behind this question, there may be many questionable assumptions. The questioner may be remembering expositional sermons he has heard (or maybe even preached) which were no different from Bible lectures at college or seminary. They may have been well structured and accurate, but they seemed to have little godly urgency or pastoral wisdom. These expositional sermons may have had little if any application. On the other hand, the questioner may simply be misunderstanding what application really is. There could have been a great deal of application in the sermons in question, but he may simply not have recognized it.
William Perkins, the great sixteenth-century Puritan theologian in Cambridge, instructed preachers to imagine the various kinds of hearers who would be listening to their sermons and to think through applications of the truth preached to several different kinds of hearts—hardened sinners, questioning doubters, weary saints, young enthusiasts; the list goes on and on.14 Let's approach the question slightly differently, though. Many of us who are called to preach God's Word will surely know this already, but it will be helpful to remind ourselves again of this fact: Not only are there different kinds of hearers, but there are also different kinds of application which are themselves all legitimately considered application.
When I preach the Word, I am called to expound the Scriptures, to take a passage of God's Word and explain it clearly, compellingly, even urgently. In this process at least three different kinds of application reflect three different kinds of problems we find in our own Christian pilgrimage. First, we struggle under the blight of ignorance. Second, we wrestle with doubt, often more than we at first realize. Finally, we sin—whether through directly disobedient acts or through sinful negligence. All three of these problems we long to see changed in ourselves and our hearers every time we preach God's Word. And all three give rise to different kinds of legitimate application.
Ignorance is a fundamental problem in a fallen world. We have alienated God from us. We have cut ourselves off from direct fellowship with our Creator. Informing people of the truth about God is itself a powerful type of application and one which we desperately need. This is not an excuse for cold or passionless sermons. I can be every bit as excited (and more) by indicative statements as I can be by imperative commands. The commands of the gospel to repent and believe mean nothing apart from the indicative statements about God, ourselves, and Christ. Information is vital. We are called to teach the truth, to proclaim a great message about God. We want people who hear our messages to change from ignorance to knowledge of the truth. Such heartfelt informing is application.
Doubt is different from simple ignorance. In doubt we take ideas or truths familiar to us, and we question them. This kind of questioning is not rare among Christians. In fact, doubt may well be one of the most important issues to be thoughtfully explored and thoroughly challenged in our preaching. We may sometimes imagine that a little pre-conversion apologetics is the only time we preachers need to address doubt directly, but that's not true. Some people who sat and listened to your sermon last Sunday, and who knew all the facts you mentioned about Christ, or God, or Onesimus, may well have been struggling with whether or not they really believed those facts to be true. Sometimes people's doubt is not articulated. We may not even be aware of it ourselves. But when we begin searchingly to consider Scripture, we find lingering in the shadows questions and uncertainties and hesitancies, all of which make us sadly aware of that gravitational pull of doubt, off there in the distance, drawing us away from the faithful pilgrim's path. To such people—perhaps to such parts of our own hearts—we want to argue for and urge the truthfulness of God's Word and the urgency of believing it. We are called to urge on our hearers to the truthfulness of God's Word. We want people who hear our messages to change from doubt to full-hearted belief of the truth. Such urgent, searching preaching of the truth is application.
Sin, too, is a problem in this fallen world. Ignorance and doubt may be either themselves specific sins, or the result of specific sins, or neither. But sin is certainly more than neglect or doubt. Be assured that people listening to your sermons will have struggled with disobeying God in the week just passed, and they will also struggle with disobeying Him in the week they are just beginning. The sins will vary. Some will be disobedience of action; others will be disobedience of inaction. But whether of commission or omission, sins are disobedience to God. Part of what we are to do when we preach is to challenge God's people to a holiness of life that will reflect the holiness of God Himself. So part of our applying the passage of Scripture we're preaching is to draw out the implications of that passage for our actions this week. We as preachers are called to exhort God's people to obedience to His Word. We want people who hear our message to change from sinful disobedience to joyful obedience to God, according to His will revealed in His Word. Such exhortation to obedience is certainly application.
Of course, the main message we need to apply every time we preach is the gospel. Some people do not yet know the good news of Jesus Christ. Some people who have been sitting under your preaching may have been distracted, or asleep, or daydreaming, or otherwise not paying attention. They need to be informed of the gospel. They need to be told. Others may have heard, understood, and perhaps even genuinely have accepted the truth of the gospel but now find themselves struggling with doubt about the very matters you were addressing (or assuming) in your message. Such people need to be urged to believe the truth of the good news of Christ. And, too, people may have heard and understood but may be slow to repent of their sins. They may not even doubt the truth of what you're saying; they may simply be slow to repent of their sins and to turn to Christ. For such hearers the most powerful application you can make is to exhort them to hate their sins and flee to Christ. In all our sermons we should seek to apply the gospel by informing, urging, and exhorting.
One common challenge we preachers face in applying God's Word in our sermons is that sometimes those who have their problems mainly in one area or another will think you're not applying Scripture in your preaching at all if you're not addressing their particular problem. Are they right? Not necessarily. While your preaching might improve if you do start addressing doubt, for example, more often or more thoroughly, it is not wrong for you to preach to those who need to be informed, or who need to be exhorted to forsake sin, even if the person talking to you isn't so aware of that need.
One final note. Proverbs 23:12 says, "Apply your heart to instruction and your ear to words of knowledge." In English translations the words translated "apply" almost always (maybe always?) refer not to the preacher's work, or even to the Holy Spirit's work, but rather to the work of the one who hears the Word. We are all called to apply the Word to our own hearts and to apply ourselves to that work.
Ultimately, Lloyd-Jones had it right again:
We must ever remember that the Truth of God while meant primarily for the mind is also meant to grip and to influence the entire personality. Truth must always be applied, and to handle a portion of Scripture as one might handle a play of Shakespeare in a purely intellectual and analytical manner is to abuse it. People have often complained that commentaries are "as dry as dust." There is surely something seriously wrong if that is the case. Any kind of exposition of "the glorious gospel of the blessed God" should ever produce such an impression. It is my opinion that we have had far too many brief commentaries on and studies in the Scriptures. The greatest need today is a return to expository preaching. That is what happened in the time of the Reformation and the Puritan Revival and the Evangelical Awakening of the 18th Century. It is only as we return to this that we shall be able to show people the grandeur, glory and majesty of the Scriptures and their message.15
Conclusions
Concluding a sermon can be one of the most difficult parts of preparing to preach. We have all heard sermons where the preacher seems to have a terrible time "landing the plane." He bounces it on the runway six or seven times in a row but always seems to take flight again just when you think he's going to hit the brakes. But "landing the plane" in a sermon is just as important as taking off.
Ideally we as preachers want the conclusion of our sermon to be weighty. We want it to bring the full weight and force of our message down, like a wedge, into the hardened sinner's heart, the complacent Christian's will, or the wounded saint's soul. It needn't be anything loud or dramatic and shouldn't be anything that would distract from the points we've been making from the Scriptures. It should simply drive those points further in with one final, heavy statement or question.
One of the best conclusions I (Mark) can recall was at the conclusion of a sermon on the crucifixion of Christ, from Mark's Gospel. Dick Lucas was preaching, and as he stood there, plain and still in the pulpit, meditating on the work of God in Christ, he finished the sermon in a voice both awed and simple: "Nothing more to be done. No barrier between God's love and you. As far as God is concerned all sins are put away. He will accept you if you come in Jesus' name, not on your own. If you come humbly in His name, you are welcome."
And with the enunciation of the word "welcome," the warmth of God's acceptance of me in Christ thrilled and awed my soul once more. It wasn't just that one sentence. It was the way everything he had been preaching—about my sin, about Christ's love, about atonement and the cross and the wrath of God and substitution and Jesus' death—everything was summed up and encapsulated in that sentence, "If you come humbly in His name, you are welcome." And then it was the way all the blessings of the gospel, the great need of humanity to be reconciled to God, was summed up even in the last word, "welcome." It was a brilliant example of how the entire weight of the sermon came pressing down into the listeners' hearts in the last sentence, even the last word, of the sermon. It left us all not applauding the preacher but silently in awe of Jesus Christ.
That, finally, ought to be the goal of every sermon. If introduction, exegesis, illustrations, application, and conclusion are all working together perfectly, the result ought to be that the whole sermon leaves your congregation thinking not about your brilliance as a preacher but about the burden and message of the text you just preached. It all ought to line up to turn your hearers' eyes to Jesus—to spur them on to love Him, His Word, and His people more.
