Chapter 13 of 18

Chapter 9

Chapter 9

[ Chapter Nine ]

Reviewing the Sermon

What do you like to do on Sunday evenings after a long and fruitful Lord's day with your congregation? Go to a movie with friends? Get fast food and watch a TV show? Spend quality time with your family? I (Mark) like all those things, too, but for the last fifteen years, I've spent Sunday nights sitting in my study with my staff, interns, and a few other friends talking about the day and hearing critiques and encouragements.

Without a doubt, this weekly "service review" has been one of the most helpful tools I have found for improving both our services in general and my preaching in particular. Over about an hour and a half, a dozen or so of us review every element of the day in turn, from Sunday school classes to prayers to songs to the day's two sermons. We think about how the songs flowed in the service and how well the congregation sang them. We talk about how the service leader did an excellent job welcoming visitors or how he failed to smile through the entire service and lent it an unhelpfully melancholy air. We talk about the prayers that were prayed and discuss how both their content and their heart came across in the context of the service as a whole.

And then, in the most detail and at the most length, we discuss the sermon, whether I preached it or someone else. Everything is on the table. We talk about the exegesis, the application, the introduction, and the conclusion. We talk about how the sermon affected our hearts, what challenged us, what we didn't understand, and what perhaps could have been done better, or wasn't done at all. Sometimes discussion ensues. Sometimes we all end up agreeing with one another. But regardless of how it goes, the regular discipline of inviting and receiving feedback on my sermons has been instrumental in my growth as a preacher. The men and women who give me feedback have shaped me over the years. They've taught me things about how people hear me that I might otherwise never have discovered. They've convinced me at times that I misunderstood some part of the passage I just preached. They've had good thoughts about the text that never crossed my mind. And, just as importantly, they've encouraged me to keep preaching, week after week, as they've explained how the text of Scripture, through my sermons, has challenged and encouraged them in the faith of Jesus Christ.

We would encourage you to adopt something similar in your own ministry. It doesn't have to look precisely like what we do at Capitol Hill Baptist Church. At Third Avenue Baptist, for instance, we don't do a service review on Sunday evenings. Instead, a few of us get together over coffee early on Tuesday mornings to talk through the prior Sunday. The important thing is that you open some lines of communication so that you can receive feedback on your sermons. That's not just so you can improve, either, as great a benefit as that might be; it's also a safeguard against error, a way for a few trusted members of your congregation to hold you accountable to do your job as a preacher well and not just mail it in week after week.

Occasionally people will ask us why we do a service review. We've already talked about some of those reasons, but we want to mention four more that we often give to people who ask. We do a service review in order to teach each other four important skills for any Christian minister: the ability to give godly criticism, to receive godly criticism, to give godly encouragement, and to receive godly encouragement. All those skills are tested in a profound way when you open yourself and your sermons up to being poked and prodded by certain trusted members of your congregation.

Giving Godly Criticism

Most Christians have no idea how to give godly criticism, how to correct and reprove in a way that is constructive rather than destructive. That's why negative feedback in our churches tends to come in a flood. People simply refrain from offering critical feedback at all because they think the whole idea is ungodly, and then when the situation becomes unbearable, it comes out in a flood of invective and frustration. Criticism, though, doesn't need to be like that. It is not inherently a negative thing. On the contrary, criticism is what the Lord uses to help us grow both as Christians and as preachers. And for that reason we need to take care to invite people to think critically and carefully about our sermons and then teach them to give us feedback on them in a godly way.

Think about Paul's words to Timothy in 2 Timothy 4:2. "Preach the word," he says. "Be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching." Two out of the three words he uses are unambiguously critical. They have to do with correcting error and setting an erring person on the correct path again. Proverbs 9:9 makes a similar point: "Give instruction to a wise man, and he will be still wiser; teach a righteous man, and he will increase in learning." Giving criticism in a godly way—and teaching and inviting others to do the same—is part of our job as pastors. But what does it mean to give criticism in a godly way? Several things come to mind.

First, any godly criticism will be given in the context of love, appreciation, and even encouragement. It's not often that everything a person has done is devoid of good. Almost always, there will be something to encourage before you move to things he did wrong or less than ideally, and you should take that opportunity. That doesn't mean you have to adhere slavishly to the old three-good-things-for-every-bad-thing ratio, but it does mean that your criticism shouldn't come out of nowhere. It should be given in a clear context of appreciation so that the person you're criticizing understands thoroughly that your criticism is coming from a heart of love.

Second, the criticisms you give should be specific. A general criticism that "I had a hard time following your sermon" is not nearly so useful to a man who's just preached as a criticism that "I had a hard time knowing where you were in your outline because you didn't flag the points sufficiently when you moved from one to another." Remember, the goal in giving godly criticism is to help the person you're critiquing to get better, and specific feedback can be implemented the next time that brother preaches in a way general feedback cannot.

Third, it's usually better not to give just a negative assessment of some part of a sermon but rather to give a positive alternative as well. For example, instead of saying, "You shouldn't have illustrated the point that way," it's usually better to say, "I understand the feeling you had that you needed to illustrate that point. I think you were right about that. But instead of doing it like you did, maybe you could have tried this." See the difference? The latter criticism gives a way forward. It provides a way for the guy being critiqued to think about how he might improve when he preaches again.

Finally, your criticisms should always be gentle even if they are firm. They should never be cutting or deliberately witty or calculated to make yourself look good. There's always a temptation to give criticism in a sharp or overly interesting way. And the reality is, that's easy to do. It's far easier to come up with a witty, biting criticism than to preach an entire sermon. So when you give criticism, do it gently even if firmly. Say that something was wrong or ill-advised as firmly as necessary, but don't do a rhetorical pirouette in the process. If you do, yes, you'll draw attention to yourself and make people laugh, but the reason for your critique in the first place—helping the preacher improve—will be lost. He'll simply stop listening to you.

Ultimately, that's the key to giving godly criticism: it's to keep always in mind the purpose of the criticism. Your goal is not to win approval for yourself or to prove that you would have done a better job than the preacher but simply to help the preacher do better next time. Keep that in mind, and your critique will be suffused with a gentle, firm, and ultimately edifying godliness.

Receiving Godly Criticism

If you're reading this book, then you likely find yourself on the receiving end of sermon criticism more often than you do the giving end. For some preachers, receiving criticism about their sermons is incredibly difficult. They find themselves getting defensive, or angry, or depressed if anyone has anything negative to say about their sermons. Being able to receive godly criticism, however, is a crucial means to a long, fruitful, and growing ministry. It's also a matter of wisdom. The book of Proverbs is full of sayings that press on us the importance of hearing words of reproof and correction. Proverbs 13:18, for example, tells us that "poverty and disgrace come to him who ignores instruction, but whoever heeds reproof is honored." Proverbs 15:32 says, "Whoever ignores instruction despises himself, but he who listens to reproof gains intelligence." Proverbs 12:1 puts it most forcefully: "Whoever loves discipline loves knowledge, but he who hates reproof is stupid."

Receiving criticism is never fun, but when it's given in a godly way, it's almost always beneficial. I (Greg) remember the first sermon I preached at Capitol Hill Baptist Church as one of Mark's interns. I also remember the service review that night; more than a decade later, what Mark said to me that evening has stuck with me. For one thing he made raucous fun of me for standing on my tiptoes through the whole sermon. I've tried to fix that problem for a decade now with nothing but failure as a result. He also told me, more importantly, that I should have realized that Jesus Himself interpreted the Old Testament passage I was preaching from and that I should have learned from Him how to understand it. At the time I didn't enjoy that criticism. I childishly wanted the sermon to be flawless. But looking back on it, that criticism of my sermon shaped profoundly the way I think about how to preach the Old Testament. If I want to understand it rightly, I need to look at how Jesus and the apostles understood it. I didn't know it at the time, but Mark was teaching me a profound lesson in the regula fidei, the principle that Scripture is its own best interpreter, and it's paid dividends for more than a decade now.

Most of us have a tendency to bristle when we hear criticism of our work. We tend to bristle and start thinking immediately of defenses against what the other person is saying. The key to receiving godly criticism, though, is to trust that the person critiquing your work really is doing so for your good, and then to work hard to see and understand what he or she is saying. Don't immediately defend or excuse; just listen and try to see what they saw. That doesn't mean you can never respond. When you review a sermon, everyone is learning, and sometimes the preacher's response to a particular criticism can teach everyone involved. But it does mean that you should receive the criticism and not immediately snap to a posture that rejects all criticism as illegitimate. Proverbs calls that "stupid." Don't do it.

And what should you do with the criticisms you receive? Well, you certainly shouldn't dwell on them to the point of discouragement. On the contrary, use them to grow! Use them to improve! Treat criticism like you would a bitter pill. Swallow it quickly and thoroughly, and let it do its work in your life and preaching. But don't feel a need to chew it up and savor it! Then, the next time you preach, remember the criticisms and put them to work. If you do, you'll "gain intelligence," as Proverbs says. And you'll become a better preacher as well.

Giving Godly Encouragement

Just as important as giving godly criticism is the ability to give godly encouragement. Believe it or not, encouragement is not always godly. There is a form of encouragement that is little different from flattery, and we ought to avoid that. We shouldn't, however, shy away from giving encouragement just because it can be sinfully corrupted. After all, every good thing can. In any review of a preacher's sermon, it's important not simply to give godly critique but also to give godly encouragement.

Perhaps the best way to do that is to give specific examples of how certain sections of the sermon—this application or that illustration—impacted your life and heart. Of course you should spend some time talking about the more technical aspects of the sermon—the main idea, the outline, the preacher's handling of the text, the way he used illustrations, whether he preached the gospel, and how he concluded. But if you want to give deep, lasting encouragement to a preacher, there really is no better way to do so than to recount how the Lord used his sermon to affect your life.

We're not talking here about flattery. Don't inflate your encouragement beyond the truth. Encourage where encouragement is due, criticize where criticism is due, and be silent otherwise. Similarly, be careful about overusing superlatives in your encouragement. If an illustration was good but not the best you've ever heard, say it was good, but don't say it was the best illustration you've ever heard. If you tend to use superlative words in every piece of encouragement you give, people will quickly realize that fact and learn to discount what you say. Save the superlatives for the superlatives.

Having a congregation that knows how to give godly encouragement can be a huge boon to those who preach the Word week in and week out. Preaching, by necessity, is an emotionally draining activity, and it is even more so if the only feedback the preacher ever receives is negative or even just silence. A congregation that knows how to encourage their pastor will spur him on, perhaps for decades, to keep preaching faithfully and powerfully.

Receiving Godly Encouragement

Most of us have no trouble at all receiving encouragement, at least not on the surface. Compared to receiving criticism, receiving encouragement is relatively easy. But of course it has its own dangers.

As we mentioned above, it's good when a congregation wants to encourage their pastor, to tell him how his sermons have affected their lives and point him to the fruits of his labor in the life of the church. And every pastor needs to hear that kind of encouragement. The danger, of course, is the heart's tendency to begin taking pride in that fruit. We look at the Lord's work in our churches and begin to mistake it for our own. To receive encouragement in a godly way is to receive it humbly with the recognition that any good fruit that comes from our preaching is God's work, the result of His Holy Spirit taking up our words and giving them power in people's lives.

We should stand in the pulpit every Sunday with a deep sense of dependence on God. We ought to know, deep in our hearts, that if He doesn't bless and empower our work, it will fail. When we see fruit, therefore, the praise is God's. When people are saved through our preaching, the praise is God's. When they repent of sin and awaken to a renewed love for Christ, the praise is God's. And we should be quick to give it to Him. The fact is, our ministry, just as much as our salvation, is a gift of God's grace. We aren't saved because we deserve it, and we don't stand in the pulpit every Sunday teaching God's people because we deserve it, either. We stand there because God has graciously blessed us with the privilege of doing so, and every bit of encouragement we receive should be accepted with a heart filled with gratitude to God.

So receive encouragement; don't deflect it. Don't insist that your people not give it to you. It is important and right that they should do so. Thank them for their encouragement, and take joy in it, but don't dwell on it to the point of self-confidence. With every bit of encouragement you receive, train your mind and heart to humbly acknowledge that all good things—your ministry, your ability to preach, His grace in allowing you to teach His people—are gifts from God above. And we who stand in the pulpit every Sunday to declare a message of grace should take particular care not to lose sight of that.

One Man's Experience of Service Review

Several times a year we invite a number of pastors and other church leaders to spend a weekend with us and participate in all the activities of our church, including the service review. Our hope is that they'll see in our staff and interns the spirit we've been talking about in this chapter, a spirit that graciously gives and receives godly criticism and humbly gives and receives godly encouragement. We also hope those men will see the benefit of doing something like this in their own churches. Here's a description of what one of those brothers saw when he attended our review of a Sunday he'd attended:

If I were to summarize the meeting in a word, I would describe it as . . . detailed. The meeting progressed through every event of the day. They began by reviewing each of the Core Seminar (Sunday School) classes. Most of the classes had someone on staff in attendance. The service review leader (Mark Dever, this time) went through each of the classes and opened discussion concerning the quality of the lesson, the quality of the teaching, and anything that needed improvement (for example, one of the rooms had a noisy A/C unit running throughout the entire class).

The group then began to review the Sunday morning service. Apparently, many of the leaders at Capitol Hill are educated in music. They spent a good deal of time reviewing not only the songs chosen, but also specific details of how the songs were played. . . . Another topic which was reviewed was the prayer. As I mentioned before, the morning service included a significant amount of prayer, and the prayers were led by different leaders in the church. This time of the review was spent critiquing each other's prayers. You may think this is sacrilege, but it seemed quite beneficial. One prayer was pointed out because of his abnormal use of high language during his prayer. It was recommended that he speak in a more conversational manner; "use contractions," Mark suggested. Another prayer was brought up because, due to a slip of the mind, something was prayed that was incorrect and unbiblical. At another point, the younger leaders asked the Senior Pastor for advice on how to prepare for leading the corporate prayer. Overall, it seemed to be an uplifting review session.

Most of the review time was spent, unsurprisingly, critiquing Geoff's sermon. [Geoff was a pastoral assistant at CHBC at the time.] I was amazed by some of the detailed responses some of these men were able to offer. At one point, someone quoted an entire sentence from the sermon, verbatim. Although the details of the critiques are not terribly important to communicate here, it was very clear that the more experienced preachers had much to offer Geoff, who had considerably less pulpit experience, and that Geoff gratefully received the advice. . . .

Walking away from the service review, a few things stood out in my mind. First, the events of that Sunday were reviewed in detail by the church leaders. Surely, one reason so many people look to this church as a model is because of the deliberate nature of CHBC's leadership. Secondly, the critiques were given and received with humility. When an individual (especially the older ones) was critiquing someone else, the critique consistently began with praise before anything critical was brought up. Surely this made it easier to receive the critique. Everyone seemed to take critiques well, especially the more senior elders. Feathers were not ruffled and morale was not reduced by anyone's comments. Creating and maintaining a leadership culture which can accept criticism humbly surely requires much effort—and is definitely worth it.19

We agree, and we pray the Lord will help us do that for our good as preachers, for our good as Christians, and for our churches' good as they grow in Christ through the preached Word of God.

↑ Back to top

↑