Chapter 4
[ Chapter Four ]
What Preaching Does
Think for a minute about the sermons preached in churches all over the world this past Sunday. What do you imagine they were about? What topics were addressed? What questions were asked? What exhortation was given? How many of the sermons preached from pulpits around the world this past Sunday do you imagine cut against the grain of the surrounding culture? How many of them do you imagine simply reinforced the surrounding culture?
A few years ago, the Methodist writer Bill McKibbens wrote an article in Harper's magazine entitled "The Christian Paradox: How a Faithful Nation Gets Jesus Wrong." In that article, McKibbens wrote about the preaching he had heard in evangelical megachurches. "It looks so much like the rest of the culture," he said. "In fact, most of what gets preached in these palaces isn't loony at all. It is disturbingly conventional." He went on:
The pastors focus relentlessly on you and your individual needs. Their goal is to service consumers—not communities but individuals: "seekers" is the term of art, people who feel the need for some spirituality in their (or their children's) lives but who aren't tightly bound to any particular denomination or school of thought. The result is often a kind of soft-focus, comfortable, suburban faith. A New York Times reporter visiting one booming megachurch outside Phoenix recently found the typical scene: a drive-through latte stand, Krispy Kreme doughnuts at every service, and sermons about "how to discipline your children, how to reach your professional goals, how to invest your money, how to reduce your debt." On Sundays children played with church-distributed Xboxes, and many congregants had signed up for a twice-weekly aerobics class called Firm Believers.9
Abdication of leadership is as much leadership as godly initiative-taking. If you fail to steer a boat, it simply flows downstream with the current, liable to all the eddies, rocks, and sandbars in the river, with no way to avoid them. Too many churches today have preachers who look to the culture around them not simply for the most effective methods of communicating their message but for the most effective message to be preached. Not a few churches—and that includes many "evangelical" churches—have tracked so long and so closely with the culture that they have become indistinguishable from it.
Preaching for Effect
Christian preaching, though, has at its heart the desire to make a change, to say something the world does not hear from anywhere else and does not even want to hear. It's not that Christian preachers are looking for ways to be contrarian. It's that the message we have been given to preach is the countercultural, status quo challenging, and offensive declaration that the human race is in rebellion against our King, and that our choices are to be judged for that rebellion or to accept love and forgiveness from His hand. Jesus knew the message He was giving His apostles to preach was not one that would win applause for them. "Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth," He said. "I have not come to bring peace, but a sword" (Matt. 10:34). What the apostles preached was going to cause the world to react against it precisely because it was cutting against the grain. It was a message that was seeking not just to invite people to think on a few things, to meditate on this or that idea, or to give a bit of food for thought. It was a message that was aiming for change.
Christian preaching seeks change. It cuts against the grain of surrounding culture, it challenges presuppositions, it convicts of sin, and it calls people to put their faith in Jesus Christ. It calls them to change direction. All the logical arguments and careful illustrations we use in our preaching are not there simply for artistry; we use them in an effort to have an effect on those who listen. After all, our whole salvation as Christians hangs on the fact that we heard God's voice calling us to repent and believe, to turn from one way of life to another. A change needed to happen, and that change was effected through our hearing of a message. When we preach, we should preach for that same effect in others, too.
One example of this idea of "preaching for effect" comes in the instructions for preachers that are given in the Westminster Directory of Public Worship. Here's what those pastors advised:
In dehortation, reprehension, and publick admonition (which require special wisdom), let him [that is, the preacher], as there shall be cause, not only discover the nature and greatness of the sin, with the misery attending it, but also show the danger his hearers are in to be overtaken and surprised by it, together with the remedies and best way to avoid it.10
Do you see what they're saying there? Go ahead and explain to the people the nature and greatness of a particular sin. Show them the misery that comes along with it and the danger they face if they are overcome with it. But don't stop there! Show them also how to remedy that sin, how to fight against it, and how to avoid it! Of course, much in that quotation could be dismissed as mere moralism if it were divorced from a proclamation of the gospel. But preaching for effect in people's lives in no way necessarily undermines the sheerness of God's grace proclaimed in the gospel. In fact, the working out of the gospel in our lives requires that sin be carefully considered and countered.
The preaching of the Word of God is not a passive activity. It's not a mere meditation that stimulates the mind and goes no further. No, when we preach, we preach for change. We preach for effect. In everything—from the way we introduce our sermons, to the way we illustrate our points, to the way we bring everything down to the conclusion—we preach with the goal of spurring believers on in their maturity in Christ and of awakening nonbelievers to their need for the Savior. In a word, that answers that we preach with two main aims, to edify and to evangelize.
We Preach to Edify
The most extended treatment in the New Testament of what the Christian gathering should be like comes in 1 Corinthians 11–14. Paul says that his chief concern is that everything "must be done for the strengthening of the church." Throughout 1 Corinthians, this is Paul's main standard for deciding what should be done and what should not be done in the congregation. If that's true, then this same standard of usefulness in edification should especially be applied to what we have said is central to the life of the church—preaching. When we preach, we preach to edify.
What does that mean? What, specifically, should we be hoping to see in our churches as a result of our preaching? In 2 Timothy 4, Paul gives what he expects to be his final charge to young Timothy, whom he had left to lead and edify the church in Crete. It's an extraordinarily solemn charge, backed by the weightiest and most glorious truths Paul knew: "I charge you," he says, "in the presence of God and of Christ Jesus, who is to judge the living and the dead, and by his appearing and his kingdom: preach the word" (vv. 1–2). That exhortation doesn't come out of nowhere. In the previous few verses, Paul had already reminded Timothy of the power of the "word," by which he meant "the sacred writings," the Scriptures. Timothy himself knew, from his own experience, the power of the Scriptures. He had been acquainted with them and their power since his childhood, and he knew they "are able to make you wise for salvation" (1 Tim. 3:15). So now Paul charges him to remember that power and unleash it in his congregation.
In the course of encouraging Timothy to preach the Word, Paul lists four main ways those Scriptures are "profitable" in the life of the church. Look at 2 Timothy 3:16: "All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness." This statement from Paul gives us a good, detailed idea of how we should pray for the preaching of the Word to edify our congregations. When you preach the Scriptures, the Scriptures will teach, reprove, correct, and train in righteousness. Let's consider each of these effects the Scriptures have in a church's life.
The words Paul uses in 2 Timothy 3:16 are not chosen at random. In fact, they divide rather neatly into two categories. Scripture is useful for doctrinal instruction, both positively and negatively, and it is useful for ethical instruction, again both positively and negatively. Taken together, all that provides a pretty comprehensive map of what is required to edify a church and build Christians up in Christ. We all need to be instructed both in doctrine and in the Christian life, and we need that instruction not only to be positive, showing the way forward, but also sometimes negative in character, showing us where we have gone wrong.
The first two words Paul uses, teaching and reproof, have to do mainly with doctrinal instruction. To "teach" is to explain the Scriptures, to instruct a congregation in what they say and what they mean. Paul uses the same word in Romans 15:4 when he says, "Whatever was written in former days was written for our instruction." Part of our task in edifying the church through the preaching of the Scriptures is to instruct our congregations in what is true about God and His ways. As people sit week after week under our preaching, their understanding of God ought to be built up and improved so that they know better what the Scriptures say about Him.
The corollary to that, of course, is that the Scriptures—and our preaching of them—are profitable for "reproof." The word appears only here in the New Testament, but where it shows up in other Greek literature, it means something like "an expression of strong disapproval." In other words, it means to confront and show the falsehood of wrong ideas about God and His ways. One of the surprising things you learn as a pastor is how many wrong doctrinal ideas the members of your church have picked up throughout their lives. From books they read, television they watch, even just through their own presuppositions, every congregation has imbibed wrong ideas about God, and therefore they need a pastor who will gently but firmly open the Scriptures and specifically contradict false doctrine.
The second set of words Paul uses here, correction and training in righteousness, refer primarily to ethical concerns. Part of edifying a congregation involves teaching them what it means to live in accord with the Gospel. The word correction was used in several different ways in ancient Greek. The initial meaning of the word was "restoration" or "improvement." It was what you might do to a city or a building that had fallen into ruin. From that meaning, though, arose the idea of "restoring" or "improving" one's ethical character and behavior. That is apparently the meaning Paul uses here. Scripture is useful for restoring a Christian's ethical character that has fallen into disrepair. If "reproof" has to do with confronting and refuting doctrinal error, "correction" has to do with confronting and refuting ethical error.
"Training in righteousness" is the positive counterpart to "correction." Most commonly it had to do with the "upbringing" or "raising" of a child. It was the combination of formative discipline and character development that parents would use to bring a child into productive adulthood. That kind of "training up" to "maturity" is a common theme in Paul's writing. In 1 Corinthians 14:20, for example, he tells Christians that they should not be "children in [their] thinking" but rather "mature." In Ephesians 4:13, when he's listing Christ's gifts to the church (including preachers and teachers!), he says that the end goal is that we should "all attain . . . to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ." What he is telling Timothy, therefore, is something similar. His preaching ought to be aiming at building up Christians; it ought to be contributing to their maturity in Christ, as the teaching of a parent "trains up" a child to full maturity.
Paul's charge to Timothy here about the efficacy and power of Scripture is comprehensive. As the Scriptures are opened and preached, lives are impacted and built up on every level. The effect is broad and profound. People are instructed in right doctrine, protected from error, taught what it means to be mature in Christ, and corrected when their lives deviate from that standard of maturity. Preaching is not just a delivery of information, nor is it just for nonbelievers. We preach to edify the saints.
But that's not all.
We Preach to Evangelize
The basic meaning of the word we translate as "preach"—kerusso—is "to make an official, public announcement" of something. It was something the herald of a king or emperor might do, whether to announce the king's presence, to make known one of his judgments, or to give some news to the people. That's the word used most often of both Jesus' and the apostles' preaching. Matthew opens his account of Jesus' ministry by saying that "Jesus began to preach" (Matt. 4:17). Jesus Himself makes it clear to His disciples in Mark 1:38–39 that His purpose was to preach. Pressed by crowds who knew that He had power to heal, Jesus told Peter, "Let us go on to the next towns, that I may preach there also, for that is why I came out. And he went throughout all Galilee, preaching in their synagogues and casting out demons."
The apostles, too, are said over and over to have preached in the sense of heralding some news. That's the task Jesus gives to His disciples in Matthew 10:7, "Proclaim as you go, saying, 'The kingdom of heaven is at hand!'" In Acts 8:5, Philip goes down to Samaria and "proclaims" or "preaches" Christ to them. That's exactly what Paul does, too, immediately upon regaining his sight; he "proclaimed Jesus in the synagogues, saying, 'He is the Son of God'" (Acts 9:20). Later, in defending his ministry of preaching, Paul argues that it is exactly the act of preaching that God uses to save people from their sins:
For since, in the wisdom of God, the world did not know God through wisdom, it pleased God through the folly of what we preach to save those who believe. For Jews demand signs and Greeks seek wisdom, but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. (1 Cor. 1:21–25)
"We herald Christ crucified," Paul says. We make Him known to a world that does not yet know Him.
Kerusso, however, is not the only word that lies behind our word preach. Perhaps even more to the point is the fact that preach often translates the word euangelizo, "proclaim good news." That's the word Jesus used to sum up His ministry in Luke 4:43, for example: "I must preach the good news of the kingdom of God to the other towns as well; for I was sent for this purpose." The phrase "preach the good news" there is actually one word in the original Greek—euangelizo. "Preach the good news" is the dominant phrase, too, in the book of Acts. It's what the believers did after they were scattered by persecution (Acts 8:4), and it's what Paul and Barnabas did as they traveled from city to city (Acts 14:7, among others).
Given all that, one of the most important things we do when we stand to preach is herald the good news of Jesus Christ. We make Christ known, and we make known the good news that salvation is to be found in Him. Just as Christian preaching should edify believers in Christ, it also ought to call those who do not yet believe to do just that. We should preach to evangelize.
That doesn't mean, of course, that every sermon needs to be, in its whole, an evangelistic sermon, aimed primarily at unbelievers. We've already seen that one of the main purposes of preaching is to edify those who are already believers. But Jesus taught us that every text of Scripture ultimately points to Him (Luke 24:27), so the gospel ought naturally to lie at the center of every sermon we preach. Even beyond that, though, much of our preaching could probably benefit from a careful consideration of our text, our sermon points, and our illustrations from the perspective of non-Christians.
There are a few reasons why that kind of perspective would be good for us and our churches. For one thing, keeping the perspective that there will likely be nonbelievers listening to your sermons will actually be more edifying for Christians who attend because it will help you remember why you're speaking about a particular point. When you preach about the Trinity, for example, keeping in mind that non-Christians are listening will keep you from simply "checking the box" and instead will lead you to think about why the Trinity is important and how you could best explain its importance to someone who is brand-new to Christian thinking. When you do that, you actually help Christians understand those doctrinal points better, too, which reminds them of the importance and the applicability of God's Word, gives them fresh reason to praise God, and helps them, too, learn to engage with non-Christians around them.
I (Mark) spent some of my younger years as an agnostic. Because of that experience, I have learned through the years the value of trying to describe and defend biblical truth from a materialistic, naturalistic perspective. I know from my own years as an unbeliever what it means to have a mind full of inadequate, unbelieving presuppositions, and that has helped me through the years in knowing how to place a truth before someone for consideration, how to position it and deploy it, how to present it so that it most sharply challenges bad presuppositions. Most of the time, that's the kind of work we're going to have to do with the non-Christians in attendance at our churches. We're going to have to find a way to grab their attention with what we're saying instead of assuming they're naturally going to be interested in what we have to say. Because of that, I often make a point to address non-Christians directly. So, for example, when I (Mark) was preaching on 1 Corinthians 8 and began to discuss Paul's teaching about our knowledge being guided by love, I addressed non-Christians in the congregation:
My friend, if you're here as a non-Christian this morning, I wonder how this is sounding to you. Have you realized you weren't made to care about only yourself? For that matter, you weren't even made to care about yourself primarily and supremely. In the same way that we were made naturally dependent on our parents for generation and our earliest survival, and on a spouse of the opposite gender sexually, so we were made to be spiritually dependent on Someone Else, on God Himself. But, according to the Bible, we have each sinned and separated ourselves from God. We have rejected Him by choosing to be our own lords, and this self-centeredness leaves us open to the certain judgment of God, the right judgment of God, who will one day judge us. We are made in His image, and in judging us, He will display His glory by vindicating His own character.
That's not all I said to non-Christians, of course. Later on in the sermon, I presented the gospel more fully. But I pray that some who were there found something in that paragraph to think about, perhaps something they'd never thought about before and that would lead them to think of spiritual truth in a new way. I pray that they were unsettled in their unbelief and that they heard something the Holy Spirit would use to convict them of self-dependence and sin.
Brothers, never be afraid to address non-Christians directly in preaching. They generally know who they are, and they're not offended when we do that! Time and time again both of us have had non-Christians tell us after sermons that they appreciated being addressed publicly. It's not embarrassing for them. On the contrary, it let them know, they said, that they were welcome in our meeting, that we had something specific to say to them, and that we cared enough for them to spend some time talking directly to them.
The Word Will Accomplish Its Purpose
In Isaiah 55:11, the Lord makes a staggering and heartening promise: "So shall my word be that goes out from my mouth; it shall not return to me empty, but it shall accomplish that which I purpose, and shall succeed in the thing for which I sent it." When God speaks, His Word will accomplish what He intends it to accomplish. That's what it means to be omnipotent! That's also why we can be certain that the preached Word of God will succeed in its purposes of edification and evangelism. The Holy Spirit uses the preached word to give spiritual life to those who are spiritually dead, and He uses the preached word to conform God's people more closely to the image of Jesus. As preachers of the Word, we should have no less confidence in it than God Himself does. When we preach we should do so with the full conviction that God will accomplish His purposes through His Word. It will not return to Him empty.
