Chapter 8
[ Chapter Eight ]
Delivering the Sermon
Is there anything quite like the few seconds right before you open your mouth and begin to preach? The music is done, everything is quiet, all eyes in the building are on you. You step to the pulpit, open your Bible, lay out your notes on the podium, . . . and pause.
Or at least I do. For just two seconds—maybe three—I pause before I begin speaking and let my eyes scan the congregation, maybe even make a split-second's eye contact with some people. It's not for effect, nor is it to try to gather attention the way a schoolteacher might fall conspicuously silent when her class is getting restless. No, that tiny pause is for me. It's to remind myself why I'm there, to press into my own heart one last time the enormity of what I'm doing. "These people," I think, "belong to Jesus. They are His. He loved them, He spilled His blood for them, and He has put all the resources of omnipotence behind His determination to bring them safely home. And now, for the next hour, He's putting them . . . in my hands. To teach them and encourage them."
Richard Baxter, the Puritan preacher, said this: "I preach as never sure to preach again, as a dying man to dying men."16 To stand before a congregation and open the Word to them is an action weighty beyond degree. It is not to speak down to them, as if we ourselves don't desperately need the grace we are holding out to them in our sermons. But it is to stand and speak as one who has found the cure for the deadliest of diseases and to implore our listeners to open their own eyes to that cure as well. It is a weighty and glorious responsibility.
We (Mark and Greg) have talked together about that responsibility—from the preparation of a sermon to its delivery—many times and at great length, and we agree that the best part of the process is actually delivering the sermon, standing in the pulpit and bringing all the preparation and all the writing to fruition in spoken words. It's a wonderful feeling! As wonderful as it is, though, that doesn't mean it's easy. Delivering a sermon is as much work, and has as many pitfalls, as preparing one; and many are the preachers who can prepare a manuscript to end the world and yet still don't seem able to deliver it with freedom and power.
To be perfectly frank, there's finally no way to teach a gift for preaching. As much as every other talent and every other spiritual gift, an ability to preach the Word powerfully is something God gives by His grace alone. Even so, all of us can improve in our delivery of God's Word. No one—not even the Spurgeons, Whitefields, and Pipers of history—are born with every tool for proclamation firmly clicked in place and finely honed. A preacher can always improve, no matter how gifted he is. In this chapter we want to consider some of the issues and questions involved in sermon delivery. As we do, we hope some of this will be useful to you in your labor, to improve your own preaching so that you will be better able to deliver God's Word to your church with clarity and power.
Manuscript or Outline?
Is it better to preach from a manuscript or an outline? In all my (Mark's) years of traveling and speaking on the subject of expositional preaching, it would be hard to recall an event where that question wasn't asked of me. I use a full manuscript in my preaching, usually running somewhere between ten and fifteen pages. With a few exceptions I put every word I'm going to speak on the page. As we talked about earlier in this book, I find that practice helps me to hone my words and present my ideas with the greatest possible force and precision. I love this description of Richard Baxter's preaching:
The sand glass at his side measured the length of the sermon, which was never less than an hour, and his custom was to read it from a closely written manuscript. "I use notes as much as any man when I take pains," he said, "and as little as any man when I am lazy or busy, and have not leisure to prepare."17
"When I take pains." No kidding! Writing a manuscript is certainly a pain. It takes a long time, it's tiring, and it's tedious. But at least for me, the rewards far outweigh the pains. By the time I finish writing, and then read over the sermon once or twice more, I am deeply familiar with every line of it. I know where I am going with the sermon and what I want to say. I've chosen the words carefully, and each one, as far as I am able, is calculated to communicate God's Word with the greatest accuracy and force.
That doesn't mean, of course, that I stand in the pulpit and simply read my manuscript, as if I were giving an academic paper at an academic conference. No, I labor to preach the sermon with passion and conviction, to move the hearts and wills of my listeners so that they are spurred on to respond well to God's Word. It also doesn't mean that I stick slavishly to my manuscript and never say anything that wasn't prepared beforehand. That's just not my nature anyway! Several times in any given sermon, I'll "off-road" from my manuscript, whether it's with a thought that didn't earlier occur to me, or an extra bit of application, or just a humorous aside for no real reason at all. I don't want to be a wooden, word-making contraption standing behind the pulpit. I want to be a human being who knows and feels his need for a Savior and therefore the weight of what he's saying, but I want to be a well-prepared human being who knows and feels those things!
My (Greg's) sermon notes are nowhere near as long as Mark's. Where his run to something like thirteen or fourteen pages, mine are more like three or four. I don't write down every word I plan to say. In fact, it's probably more accurate to call my sermon notes "detailed outlines" than to call them manuscripts. Some parts of my notes are more scripted than other parts. I tend to manuscript application sections more than exegesis sections, for instance, unless I'm going to be working through a particularly tricky text. I also tend to manuscript tight theological teaching that requires more precision in language. I find that I tend to "off-road" quite a lot in my preaching, and I also tend to repeat ideas when I have a sense that they didn't stick the first time I said them. So a detailed outline allows me to work carefully with my wording, but it also creates some space for expansion and elaboration when I'm actually in the pulpit.
One of the things we've noticed, especially in young preachers, is that there's often a tension between accuracy and personality in the pulpit. When a guy takes a full manuscript into the pulpit, he tends to be precise in his wording but also somewhat wooden and chained to the manuscript. His sentences come out sounding very "literary" because the written word sounds different from the spoken word. You've probably noticed that as you've listened to preachers. When someone is just talking, sentences tend not to be very pretty. There are run-ons and fragments and reversals; sentences tend to be short and not elaborate. The written word is different. Sentences are more elaborately constructed with dependent clauses and rhetorical flourishes. They also tend to be longer and more freighted with adjectives and adverbs. That's fine, as far as it goes. The trouble, though, is that your listeners' minds are adept at picking up when you slip into speaking what are obviously written sentences—in other words, when you begin reciting. Think about the lines actors deliver in a school play; that's what it sounds like—slightly artificial no matter how much feeling you put into it.
So how do you avoid that? Some guys, of course, have no problem with it at all. They can take a full manuscript into the pulpit and sound like they're speaking entirely off-the-cuff. You'd never know they planned every line of it in advance. Other guys don't have that kind of natural ability, but they learn over time how to do it. They learn how it feels when they slip into a "literary" voice, and they learn how to adjust and come out of it quickly. One method that might help bring precision and personality together is this: Write out a manuscript. Work hard on the words. But then leave it at home. In other words, do the work of manuscripting, but then take an outline (of whatever level of detail) into the pulpit. Or, alternatively, just shrink your detailed manuscript into six-point font so it's there if you need it but too small to lean on for long. That way you've done the hard work of finding good words and images so that they're in your mind, and yet your mind can also do its work of translating those great words and images into something you'd actually say if you were just talking instead of reading or reciting.
In the end, the important thing isn't whether you use a manuscript or an outline. What's important is that you strive to be careful and precise with your language and at the same time to preach with conviction and passion and personality. "Logic on fire"—that's how Lloyd-Jones once defined preaching. "Light and heat" is how our forebears used to talk about it. They're all right. Leave out either one of those elements—light or heat, logic or fire—and you're left with something far short of biblical preaching.
The Density of Sermons
Again and again we are told today that sermons should be easier to understand than they were in the past—less abstract, more spontaneous, and shorter, with more stories from personal experience and allowing for more participation from those who are listening. All that is taken for granted by many preachers today. Of course there's something to be said for simplicity in preaching. And passion, boldness, and daring in preaching, when wed to the truth, are excellent! None of that should be disputed. But we'd argue that strong content—and a lot of it—is excellent, too! You want your sermons to be filled with content that will feed and nourish your people.
One of the ways preachers most frequently seem to discourage themselves is by believing everybody should remember every bit of what they preach. We put so much time into crafting every point, we think, and then a week later people have difficulty remembering what we said, and that's discouraging. So, we reason, let's give them less! Maybe they'll remember more of it!
If that's how you've been thinking, you need to drive that thought right out of your mind. The point isn't for your congregation to be able to recall, like human Google searches, every sentence or even every point you made. The point is for the Word to shape their hearts and minds and wills, and that can happen even if they don't remember the precise words or points you spoke. Think about it: What novelist writes a novel expecting that you'll remember every plot twist? That's not his goal; his goal is to bring you along in the story, to make you feel the weight of the story, and to affect you with it. Or think about advertising. What advertiser makes a commercial with the thought that you'll remember the ad's dialogue? Again, that's not their goal. The goal is to impress upon your mind the importance and desirability of the product so that you'll be more likely to buy it. They're in the business of shaping minds and hearts.
Christian preaching, of course, isn't precisely like either of those examples. There is a propositional, creedal content to the Christian faith that just doesn't exist for, say, Charmin Ultra. We want to preach that content, and over time we pray our people will remember it and use it in their lives. But don't fret when you realize your people aren't retaining everything you say; your words and the truth you present will still be working to shape them and mold them into the likeness of Christ. Besides, over time, the most important truths will stick, and they'll remember them. As preachers of God's Word, we simply want our sermons to be clear and our points to be accurate and firm. Much of the work we do on sermons is simply to prepare those points and then deliver them to those who have ears to hear.
I (Mark) assume that only about 20 percent of the adults hearing my sermons will get most of what I say. But that's fine. Those 20 percent who have an appetite that particular day are the ones I want to feed. People are used to news anchors and magazines and teachers who know more than they do; why shouldn't preachers be in that same category? As long as the gospel is clear to all, is it really a problem to make people reach a little for some of the things taught in the sermon? Does preaching sermons that are a little more demanding at points really make us remote, or intimidating, or unapproachable? I don't think so. If you're a remote, intimidating, unapproachable person, even your simplest sermon is going to be remote, intimidating, and unapproachable. And besides, maybe saying a few things that cause our people to stretch a little in their understanding will help them have confidence in us. Maybe it will give the most mature believers in our churches something else to learn from the sermon, and maybe it will attract the kind of people who show the maturity of valuing both love and knowledge.
"But what about the children?" someone will ask. Brothers, blessing parents will bless children. Helping mom and dad understand the gospel, to understand love, to think through what it means to be a good example and a bad example may all be concepts that are above some of the younger children in attendance at your church, but if the parents come to understand those things, they can teach their children. Besides, you'll do the children no good at all by teaching their parents only things they would have understood fully when they were ten years old.
I would encourage you, therefore, to preach sermons for adults. That doesn't mean your sermons should be complicated and difficult to understand. But they should be as serious and as weighty as life itself. A good rule of thumb is to assume that everyone who ever hears you preach is both very intelligent and very uneducated. In other words, assume they have never been taught about the Christian faith, but that they are fully capable of benefiting from a solid explanation. And then explain it to them. Don't simply assume your listeners are incapable of understanding or uninterested in what Scripture says. If you preach like that, yes, you might be assuming and even asking for a serious level of interest in your sermons. But why is that a bad thing? That's exactly the kind of expectation, seriousness, and interest you want to encourage in your church as they listen to the Word.
And that brings us to another point about sermon delivery.
The Tone of the Sermon
Too many evangelical sermons today smack of a smug triumphalism that is every bit as repulsive as a despairing defeatism. Christian sermons should certainly be suffused with confidence in the triumph of the conquering Lamb, but at the same time they should have about them an air of truth and realism about our cursed world. Sermons, like other aspects of our corporate worship services, should frankly acknowledge the difficulties of living the life of faith. Abraham, Moses, David, Jeremiah, Paul—all lived the life of faith, and they all struggled and suffered as they did. Jesus Himself was more confident of victory than anyone who has ever walked the earth, and yet He loved and patiently taught and retaught, and prayed and groaned and denounced and wept.
So what exactly is the appropriate tone for a Christian sermon? Here are five aspects of the tone we should desire in our sermons:
1. Our tone in preaching should be biblical. At its best our preaching should never smack of parties—Presbyterian or Baptist, Calvinist or Arminian, amillenial or dispensationalist. Rather, our sermons should always be obviously biblical, with any doctrinal distinctives we espouse clearly arising from the text. In that way the powerfully attractive thing becomes not membership in your party but rather faithfulness to God's Word and its truth. Just as the story of the Bible centers on God, so should our preaching. Sermons that are biblical will spend time considering who God is and what He has done. The gospel will naturally be central. We should be preaching not to draw people into one theological group or another but rather to draw them to Christ.
2. Our tone in preaching should be humble. If we are seriously contemplating God and His grace in our preaching, then prideful self-congratulation will find no place in our sermons. They will instead be marked by the aroma of grace. We'll be like the Salvation Army captain I once read about who gave this testimony on his deathbed: "I deserve to be damned. I deserve to be in hell. But God interfered." If we truly understand God's grace, we'll never enter the pulpit thinking that we deserve to be there. Instead we'll know a deep sense of unworthiness before we bring God's Word, and a confirming sense of shame afterwards as we see how God uses His Word in people's lives, and as we consider how much better we're able to preach than to live.
3. Our tone in preaching should be clear. Biblical humility in no way comes from an uncertainty about the truth of our message. Too often today there is a wrong kind of timidity. We actually act as if we are scared that we may be understood. True humility, though, centered on God and His Word, brings a bold clarity. It is the humility of a herald who would not dare change the message of the King who sent him but who also would not dare to speak that message with anything but the firmest conviction of its truth.
4. Our tone in preaching should be sober and serious. In the beginning of his book Counted Righteous in Christ, John Piper laments the ungodly lightness of too many evangelical services today:
The older I get, the less impressed I am with flashy successes and enthusiasms that are not truth-based. Everybody knows that with the right personality, the right music, the right location, and the right schedule you can grow a church without anybody really knowing what doctrinal commitments sustain it, if any. Church-planting specialists generally downplay biblical doctrine in the core values of what makes a church "successful." The long-term effect of this ethos is a weakening of the church that is concealed as long as the crowds are large, the band is loud, the tragedies are few, and persecution is still at the level of preferences.
But more and more this doctrinally-diluted brew of music, drama, life-tips, and marketing seems out of touch with real life in this world—not to mention the next. It tastes like watered-down gruel, not a nourishing meal. It simply isn't serious enough. It's too playful and chatty and casual. Its joy just doesn't feel deep enough or heartbroken or well-rooted. The injustice and persecution and suffering and hellish realities in the world today are so many and so large and so close that I can't help but think that, deep inside, people are longing for something weighty and massive and rooted and stable and eternal. So it seems to me that the trifling with silly little sketches and breezy welcome-to-the-den styles on Sunday morning are just out of touch with what matters in life.
Of course, it works. Sort of. Because, in the name of felt needs, it resonates with people's impulse to run from what is most serious and weighty and what makes them most human and what might open the depths of God to their souls. The design is noble. Silliness is a stepping-stone to substance. But it's an odd path. And evidence is not ample that many are willing to move beyond fun and simplicity. So the price of minimizing truth-based joy and maximizing atmosphere-based comfort is high. More and more, it seems to me, the end might be in view. I doubt that a religious ethos with such a feel of entertainment can really survive as Christian for too many more decades. Crises reveal the cracks.18
5. Our tone in preaching should be suffused with a joyful confidence. While we decry a smug and shallow triumphalism, we also have the confidence of being united to Christ, the eternal Son of God, the Firstborn from among the dead, the returning King! Neither injustice nor immorality, neither falling marital rates nor personal tragedies, neither natural disasters nor economic woes can stay God's hand or slow Christ's return one moment. Like the elderly John on Patmos, imprisoned on a tiny island by the mightiest of empires, so we speak to the powers of this age with no fear but rather with earnest warning, godly threats, and sincere desires for their repentance so that they may join us in the victory of the Lamb.
When It's Done
Few preachers who preach God's Word feel great when the sermon's done. I'm usually thinking about everything I didn't have time to say or even a few things I did say that I wished I hadn't. Then the time for the benediction slips up on me, I give it, and then I sneak to the back door to talk with people as they walk out. Sometimes people come to talk, and I'm humbled and encouraged by the ways they say the Lord used the sermon in their lives. Other times no one says much of anything, which bothers me more than I wish it did.
But the immediate feedback—as much as we crave the instant gratification—isn't the point. A pastorate is made up of a lot of sermons, and the fact is, most of those sermons are going to be singles rather than triples or home runs. But that's fine. If the Lord is so kind as to give you even a long string of singles, that's purely of His grace, and your congregation will benefit and grow from that. You score runs with a string of singles. So don't worry if you haven't hit a home run in a while—and if you hit one today, don't get cocky! Either way, go home, rest, thank God for the grace He gave you to teach and encourage His people again, take some time off, and then start the whole process over the next week. Our God is a good God, and week after week, sermon after sermon, He will give grace and strength and insight to the men who preach His Word.
