6. The Church
6
The Church
I will put together my church, a church so expansive with energy that not even the gates of hell will be able to keep it out.
Jesus (Matt. 16:18 Message)
I read of a pastor who boarded a plane in a pair of old blue jeans and a polo shirt, looking anything but ministerial. He sat down next to a well-dressed business guy who was reading a copy of the Wall Street Journal. They exchanged the usual pleasantries, and then the pastor asked the man what he did for a living. With obvious pride, the man said: “Oh, I’m in the health and wholeness business. We can change anyone’s self-concept by changing their connection to themselves and their body. It’s really a very profound, powerful thing.” He was a fairly young guy, so the pastor asked him if he had been doing it for very long.
“No,” he said, “I just graduated from the University of Michigan’s School of Business, but they’ve already given me so much responsibility I hope to eventually manage the western part of the operation.”
“So you’re a national organization?”
And he said, “Oh, yes. We are the fastest-growing company of our kind in the nation. It’s really good to be a part of an organization like that, don’t you think?” And the pastor nodded in approval. Then came the inevitable question.
“And what do you do?”
“It’s interesting,” the pastor said. “We actually have similar business interests. You’re in the body-changing business, and I’m in the personality-changing business. In my field, we apply basic theocratic principles to accomplish indigenous personality modification.” The guy had no idea what that meant, but he said, “You know, I’ve heard about that. Do you have an office here in the city?”
“Oh, yes. We have many offices, up and down the state,” the pastor replied. “In fact, we’re national; we have at least one office in every state of the union including Alaska and Hawaii.” By this time, the young guy was racking his brain trying to identify this huge company that he must have heard about or read about somewhere.
The pastor went on: “Yep, in fact, we’ve gone international. And Management has a plan to put at least one office in every country of the world by the end of this business era.” The pastor paused a minute and then asked, “Do you have that in your business?”
The guy said, “Well, no. Not yet. But you mentioned management. How do they make it work?”
“Actually,” the pastor said, “it’s a family business. There’s a Father and a Son . . . they run everything.”
The guy said, “Wow. That must take a lot of capital.”
“You mean money? Yes, it does. No one knows just how much, but we never worry . . . Those of us in the Organization have a saying about our Boss, that ‘He owns the cattle on a thousand hills.’”
“Oh,” the guy said, “he’s into ranching too? Wow. Well, what about you?”
“You mean the employees?” the pastor asked. “They are something to see. They have a ‘Spirit’ that pervades the organization. The Father and Son love each other so much that their love filters down so that we all find ourselves loving one another too. I know this sounds old-fashioned in a world like ours, but I know people in the organization who are willing to die for me. Do you have that in your business?”
“No,” the man said, “not exactly. But what about your benefits? Are they good?”
“Good? They’re amazing. I have complete life insurance, fire insurance—all the basics. You might not believe this, but it’s true: I have holdings in a mansion that’s being built for me right now for my retirement. Do you have that in your business?”
“Not yet,” the young man said, by this time feeling like the health and wholeness market wasn’t exactly the place to be. “But can your operation last? I mean, companies come and go.”
The pastor said, “Oh, I think we’ve got a pretty good future. After all, we’ve got a two-thousand-year run going.”
Nothing compares to the church. No business, no investment, no enterprise, no activity. It’s the heart of God’s plan, and Christians believe it is the hope of the world. As such, it is our conviction that it’s the most dynamic, active, vibrant, forceful project on the planet. It is the one thing we will give our lives to that will live on long after we are gone. And not just for a generation or two, but for all of eternity.
But that may not be what you have experienced.
I don’t know what your background with church is, if you have any at all. Some grew up feeling church was boring and irrelevant, divided and nasty. Others dislike it because it epitomizes “organized religion,” which is a euphemism for being lifeless, if not corrupt. All to say, many people, if they ever do get into the spiritual side of things, don’t want church to be a part of the package. There’s not a single thing about the church that captivates them—or, more to the point, that they think should captivate them.
So if all that’s true, why have Christians made the church so central to their expression of the Christian faith? Because when the church is truly being the church, there is nothing more captivating. Furthermore, Jesus made sure we know it’s central to our expression of the Christian faith.
The Story
Let me tell you a story. And it’s not just a story but the story. It’s the story of all of human history. It’s the story about what God is fundamentally about in this world. And what he is about is the church, the new community.
To tell this story, we have to go all the way back to the very beginning. In fact, before the beginning. Because it begins with who God is. As we’ve already discussed, the Bible tells us that God is unique. He’s triune: that is, three persons who are one God—God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit. The idea of God being about community finds its essence and definition deep within the very being of God, for God himself is a community of three persons in one Being. God is love, and that love flows between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
Now love, by its very nature, seeks to give of itself. And because God is himself a community of oneness, he created us to be a community of oneness as well. One with him and one with each other. Here’s how it’s described in the Bible:
The LORD God said, “It is not good for the man to be alone. I will make a helper suitable for him.” . . .
The LORD God made a woman . . . and he brought her to the man. . . .
That is why a man leaves his father and mother and is united to his wife, and they become one flesh.
Adam and his wife were both naked, and they felt no shame. (Gen. 2:18, 22, 24–25)
When God created Adam, the Bible says that God was displeased with the fact that Adam was alone. Adam had vertical community with God, but no horizontal community with another human being, because he had no one else with whom he could be together in oneness. For there to be true oneness, there had to be a plurality of persons. The woman was created to “help” the man out of his aloneness so that together they could enter into the community of oneness that existed in the very nature of God and was being offered as a gift to humans upon their creation. That is why God decreed that they would become “one flesh.” In God’s math of community, one plus one equals one. And it truly was community. There is much in the line we read in the book of Genesis that says, “Now the man and his wife were both naked, but they felt no shame” (Gen. 2:25 NLT). This was more than moral innocence; it also symbolized the depth of relational transparency these two people had.
But then came what theologians have called “the fall.” As long as the man and the woman were in a right relationship with God—the Creator of community—they were able to maintain their own oneness with each other. The moment they violated their relationship with God by turning their backs on him and going their own way, their oneness with God and with each other was shattered. And that is precisely what they did and what happened. Not only did sin separate humans from God, it separated them from each other. So what did Adam and Eve do after that happened? They clothed themselves, reflecting the first of many barriers that now came into being between humans, and then they hid themselves, reflecting the beginning of the relational divide between humans and God.
This was bigger than simply Adam and Eve. Their fall led to the ongoing disruption of community throughout the growing human race. Think of the fateful decision to build the infamous Tower of Babel that you have probably heard of. Later in Genesis, we read how the peoples of the earth came together to build a huge monument to themselves—naming themselves lord of all. There was no effort to come together in community under God according to God’s design, but an effort to divorce themselves from community with God and create a distorted and perverted sense of oneness. But removed from the true oneness of God, the Author of community, their community was destroyed. God stepped in, in his mercy, and disrupted their efforts because he loved them too much to allow them to completely separate themselves from him and true community. They were then scattered all over the earth, and when they tried to communicate with each other, they found that they could not even understand each other’s speech. In their attempt to build a false community based on false oneness, they lost the capacity to even communicate.
The Tower of Babel by Pieter Bruegel the Elder, 1563 [Wikimedia Commons]
And that’s how the first eleven chapters of Genesis end, bringing the primeval history of the world to a close. But in chapter 12, we see God’s continued investment in the redemptive drama—God’s continued effort to bring people into community with him and with each other. For in chapter 12, we find that God calls out a man named Abram, and through Abram, he begins the Jewish people’s relationship with God. God called them into a community—Israel—through which he reestablished the picture of his oneness, and their oneness with each other, to the entire world. God did not quit on us or on his plan to build community into his creation. Out of the wreckage of the old community, he drew together a new community. Abram was called to leave his old ways, his old home, his old community, and set out. God promised that he would make him into a great nation. God even changed his name from Abram, which means the father of one people, to Abraham, which means the father of many nations. Abraham accepted God’s plan for the new community, a plan that would eventually seek to bring together—in one community—all the peoples of the earth.
The story of how this effort fared among the descendants of Abraham is a tale of unrelenting disasters, described at length in the Old Testament. Despite Abraham, God’s covenant, the continued gift of godly leaders, judges, and prophets, the nation of Israel fell into repeated cycles of rebellion, apostasy, defeats, invasions, divisions, and exiles until, mercifully, God intervened again. And this intervention brought all of history to a defining moment—for that intervention was Jesus. Through Jesus, God’s dream prevailed and the One who could and would save, came—the second Adam, the one who would fulfill oneness and offer that oneness to all of us.
When Jesus willingly died on the cross for our sins, it was for a reason. The vertical dimension of the cross suggests the restoration of our communion with God. It symbolizes the need and potential of every human being to enter into a saving relationship with God through Christ. It reestablishes that communion with him for which we were created but which was forfeited in the garden; we have continued this rejection individually with our own cumulative sinfulness. The horizontal dimension of the cross symbolizes the other aspect of community that the cross offers—that we can be reconciled not only to God, but to each other and be brought together to form one body. So, through Christ, there is the new community, in a new oneness with God and in a new oneness with each other. This is why Jesus boiled down the entire law of the Old Testament into two commandments: love God and love people. In his final prayer recorded in the Bible, in John 17, Jesus prayed for one thing: oneness among his followers. The language he used was fitting when he said, “I have given them the glory you gave me, so they may be one as we are one” (John 17:22 NLT). Jesus prayed for restoration of the oneness among humans entrusted to them in creation: a oneness made in the image of the oneness within the Trinity. For Jesus, the model of oneness among humans was nothing less than that found in the relationship between the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit.
This leads us to the church, the new community. What began with Abraham and the people of Israel was brought into reality through the cross of Christ. The church is the new Israel. Following the resurrection of Jesus, the very birth of the church occurred on what is now called the day of Pentecost. On that day, the people heard and understood others speaking in various languages, declaring the wonders of God. It was the Tower of Babel in reverse. Due to the power of the Holy Spirit to mark God’s true community of people, the many languages were made one. Harmony and unity were now possible through Christ. And the church reflects the oneness God intended in so many ways: relational unity; caring for others at their point of need, such as those who are poor and hungry and homeless; coming together as a body in their use of spiritual gifts; and, supremely, the extension of community to others through Christ. Because the heart of the church’s mission is the invitation of others into community.
But even that isn’t the final word. At the end of time, at the resurrection of all believers, God’s people on earth will be transformed eternally into one body, a fully formed community. And heaven—the ultimate community, the glorified church united with Christ—will reign. So the church, the new community, is the centerpiece of history. The formation of that community of oneness is what history is all about. God has had one priority project throughout history, one that he will bring to climactic conclusion at the end of time—the formation of the new community. The church.
So no wonder we read these words from Jesus: “I [am putting] together my church, a church so expansive with energy that not even the gates of hell will be able to keep it out” (Matt. 16:18 Message). This is also why the earliest followers of Christ immediately joined in this new community and began forming and living the life of the church that was God’s dream from the beginning. Here’s how those early days were described in the New Testament:
They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and to fellowship, to the breaking of bread and to prayer. Everyone was filled with awe at the many wonders and signs performed by the apostles. All the believers were together and had everything in common. They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need. Every day they continued to meet together in the temple courts. They broke bread in their homes and ate together with glad and sincere hearts, praising God and enjoying the favor of all the people. And the Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved. (Acts 2:42–47)
So the church is not some peripheral man-made organization. It is the centerpiece of history and the vanguard of God’s mission. It’s the very cause of Christ. And for the Christ follower? What it brings to bear on their life is irreplaceable. You can’t be a fully devoted follower of Christ and live a life apart from his church, because Christ-following involves interacting with other Christ followers in the context of the church as Christ has designed it. In the Bible, we are told that Christ followers are to “serve one another” (Gal. 5:13), “encourage one another” (1 Thess. 5:11), “accept one another” (Rom. 15:7), “bear with . . . and forgive one another” (Col. 3:13). You can’t do the “one anothers” without “another.” Jesus went so far as to say that it would be the practice of community brought to life in and through the church that would offer the ultimate affirmation to the world about his own life and ministry. Here are his words:
So now I am giving you a new commandment: Love each other. Just as I have loved you, you should love each other. Your love for one another will prove to the world that you are my disciples. (John 13:34 NLT)
And then, a few chapters later, it records his final prayer and it was for the same thing. He said,
I am praying not only for these disciples but also for all who will ever believe in me through their message. I pray that they will all be one, just as you and I are one—as you are in me, Father, and I am in you. And may they be in us so that the world will believe you sent me. . . .
May they experience such perfect unity that the world will know that you sent me and that you love them as much as you love me. (John 17:20–21, 23 NLT)
Jesus was absolutely convinced that it would be the church, functioning as the church, that would arrest the attention of the world and give ultimate affirmation to his message.
What/Where Is the Church?
So what is an authentic church community? I remember sitting in the boardroom of a prominent Christian business leader. They did a lot of “Christiany” things in this business. He told of the mission trips he had taken with his employees, the investments the company had made from its profits in select boutique ministry ventures, and the Bible study offered on campus for employees. I think I even remember the mention of a corporate chaplain. Then, at the end, he said he wasn’t personally involved in a local church because, after all, “We’re the church too. This company is the church.”
Inside I thought I was going to explode. Everything within me wanted to shout, “No, you are NOT! A company is not the body of Christ instituted as the hope of the world by Jesus himself, chronicled breathtakingly by Luke through the book of Acts, and shaped in thinking and practice by the apostle Paul through letter after letter now captured in the New Testament. A marketplace venture that offers itself on the New York Stock Exchange is not the entity that is so expansive with energy not even the gates of hell can withstand its onslaught. An assembly of employees in cubicles working for end-of-year stock options and bonuses is not the gathering of saints bristling with the power of spiritual gifts as they mobilize to provide justice for the oppressed, service to the widow and the orphan, and compassion for the poor.”
So when do you have the church?
You have the church when you have the message of Christ being proclaimed. You have the church when you have true community being fleshed out—a community of Christ followers across generations and ethnicities, male and female, young and old. You have the church when there is the practice of the “one anothers”—loving, serving, bearing. You have the church when there is worship and service and spiritual growth, all coming together for the singular mission of seeing those far from God brought near to him. You have the church when the sacraments of the Lord’s Supper (or communion) and baptism are being stewarded—times when something sacred is imparted to you. You have the church when there is the biblical structure of pastors providing leadership and oversight. And you have the church when you have the body of Christ operating as it was meant to, with all of the gifts coming together—leaders leading, administrators administrating, artists being artistic, and so on—and all of them coming together as one body.
When you have that, it’s the most breathtakingly beautiful and powerful force on the planet.
Let me give you some pictures of this.
At a recent baptism service, a woman tweeted out a picture of her son being baptized. But it was what she tweeted along with it that stuck with me. She wrote how ten years ago I baptized her and her husband and now we baptized their son. To that she added the hashtags #liveschanged #familieschanged.
Another picture of this.
On a Thursday afternoon, a young woman came by one of our campus offices to give me something. I was in a meeting, so she left it at the front desk. On the back of the envelope I read, “I thought I was going to put this in an offering plate but I think it would be best to give to you directly.” Here’s what her letter said:
I have been coming to your church. . . . I am 23. . . . When I was 12 years old I started cutting myself. Now my arms are covered in an overwhelming amount of scars, but I am proud to say there are no open cuts. I have not cut for probably a year now, but I still have razor blades that are hidden around my room. . . . I quit when I was about to cut one day but heard Jesus in my ear saying, “I bled enough.” He took my pain on the cross and I no longer needed to take it out on myself. But I realized by holding on to razor blades I am not fully letting go of the pain and addiction to cutting. I want to fully let it go now. . . . It says in the Bible, “Cast all your anxiety on Him for He cares for you.” So I’m doing that today. This is an offering plate and I am offering to Jesus today more than any amount of money I could ever offer Him. These are all my razor blades that I have kept hidden around in different places of my reach just in case. I am handing it over to God and I trust you also with this as well. Thank you for all you and this church have done in my life.
And with the letter were the razor blades.
One more picture. For Christians the heart of our mission is to the least and the lost. The least meaning those who are poor, hungry, in need of shelter, oppressed, and abused. And the lost meaning those who are in need of God, in need of the saving message of Jesus, and in need of knowing how much he loves them and wants to wrap his arms around them. When it comes to the least and the lost, it’s hard to imagine anyone in the world more abused, more in need of protection and rescue, more in need of hearing that God loves them more than they can imagine, than the children caught up in the sex trafficking industry throughout the world.
Some are runaways, some are kidnapped, some are sold into it by their fathers. But they are just children—eight or nine, maybe ten or twelve years old. They are taken, beaten, raped, and then plied with drugs or alcohol until they become addicts. That way, they can be controlled and forced to service up to twenty customers a day.
One of the worst places in the world for this is the Philippines. Our church found out that organizations such as the International Justice Mission knew where these girls were, knew the dungeons below the brothels where they were kept, but couldn’t rescue them until there was a place where they could go. They have no homes, and many can’t return to their families because it was their fathers who sold them. They have addictions, psychological damage, need to be protected from their pimps while charges are brought, and need to be educated through all this. If you rescue and then just release, you are signing their death warrant. So, as horrific as it sounds, the girls are left in the brothels until there is not only a place to rescue them from, but to rescue them to. When we heard that, we said, “You just need a house? You’re just talking bricks and mortar? We’ll do that.” So we built that house. We helped staff it. And once we did, they started rescuing children.
All to say, when the church is being the church, it really is the hope of the world. And not even the gates of hell can stand up under its onslaught.
So Why So Many Denominations?
So why are there so many denominations? Doesn’t that undercut everything you’ve said about the power and beauty and centrality of the church? Good question. First, let’s lay out what a “denomination” even is. The word itself comes from a Latin word that means “to name.” So if you denominate something, you name it. You set it apart. You give it an identity, and that’s what a religious denomination signifies. The Dictionary of Christianity in America puts it this way: “A Christian denomination is an association or fellowship of organizations within a religion that have the same beliefs or creed, engage in similar practices and cooperate with each other to develop and maintain shared enterprises.”
So how did so many get started?
Well, in truth, they’ve always been around. And what I mean by that is you have always had a diversity within the unity of Christianity. Even in the earliest days of the burgeoning Christian movement. The various churches that sprung to life as Christianity exploded onto the scene were very different from each other. Not in terms of major doctrine, but in terms of style and culture and composition. So you had the high church in Rome that was a bit more formal, the church at Ephesus with the heavy emphasis on teaching, the charismatic church in Corinth, the predominantly black church that was probably started by the Ethiopian eunuch, and on it went. Different churches, different styles, yet all one in Christ and all birthed by the movement of the Holy Spirit, who seemed perfectly happy with the diversity. This helps explain one of the reasons why there are so many denominations. There are lots of different churches because there are a lot of different people, ethnicities, cultures, and stylistic preferences. In fact, Christianity has thousands of denominations around the world. Personally, I like the variety. I’m not wired like you, nor you like me. If you like “smells and bells” and I like drums and power chords—or both—that’s okay.
But that’s not the only reason why there are so many. A lot of the denominations started as protest groups against state-run religions. Throughout history, there have been established state or national churches. They still exist in many countries, particularly in Europe, such as the Church of England. So what did you do if you had a problem with a politically established religion? You had no choice but to start some kind of splinter group.
In America, several of the colonies tried to have an established church, but they didn’t have enough of a majority to pull it off. So the various denominations became the norm, instead of just breakaway options from a state or national church. Throw in what came after the Revolution in terms of religious liberty and the separation of church and state, and then the rush of immigration that brought in all kinds of cultures and ethnicities, and you have what historian Sydney Mead has called “The Lively Experiment.” This was America letting Christianity and individual Christians run free without state control. You want to start a church, you can start a church. You want to start a new denomination, have at it. And people did!
So has it been a good thing or a bad thing? Both. What’s bad about it is that it gives the impression Christians can’t get along with each other and that we fight and divide over stupid, petty things. Which, sadly, can be the case. Comedian Emo Philips wrote the following joke:
Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump. I said, “Don’t do it!” He said, “Nobody loves me.” I said, “God loves you. Do you believe in God?”
He said, “Yes.” I said, “Are you a Christian or a Jew?” He said, “A Christian.” I said, “Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?” He said, “Protestant.” I said, “Me, too! What franchise?” He said, “Baptist.” I said, “Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?” He said, “Northern Baptist.” I said, “Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?”
He said, “Northern Conservative Baptist.” I said, “Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?” He said, “Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region.” I said, “Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912.”
He said, “Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912.” I said, “Die, heretic!” And I pushed him over.
It’s fine to have different churches and denominations to reflect differences in personality and style and culture, but it’s not fine if it reflects relational breakdowns. We are to be unified. Now, when the Bible talks about unity, it doesn’t mean uniformity, which is everyone looking and thinking alike. And it doesn’t mean unanimity, which is complete agreement about every little thing across the board. By unity, the Bible means first and foremost a oneness of heart—a relational unity. Being kind to one another, gracious to one another, forgiving of one another. Not assuming the worst, shooting the wounded, or being quick to be suspicious. Biblical unity is about working through conflicts, avoiding slander and gossip, and being generous in spirit. That’s what Jesus was after.
So when disunity in the worst sense is behind a denomination or splinter group, that’s bad. But when it’s just a “different strokes for different folks” kind of thing, it’s not really that big of a deal. It’s certainly no indictment of Christianity. It can actually be a positive thing. Most denominational divides are not hateful or mean spirited, or over big disagreements in the basic doctrines of the Christian faith. They are mostly about differences in preference. They reflect preferred styles of worship, patterns of organization, approaches to ministry, and understandings of custom and tradition. Think of it in terms of what people wear. Many of the differences among Christians are like the differences among people in the style of clothes that they wear. We are all humans underneath, but our clothes display our different personalities and cultures. It would be a huge mistake to assume that the many churches and denominations within Christendom reflect a state of division and chaos. There is instead a unified set of beliefs that has been coupled with great freedom and diversity in the expression of that faith.
Protestant vs. Catholic
So what about the biggest divide within the Christian community—the divide between Protestants and Catholics? Same kind of situation? Mostly, but there is a bit more substance and history here. The earliest church, in the first forty or so years following the resurrection of Jesus, was essentially a movement within Judaism—a group who believed the Messiah had come in the person of Jesus. But then, around AD 70, Jerusalem fell to the Romans, and the Christian movement was dispersed. The most important church that emerged, as you would imagine, was the one in Rome, which was the capital of the Roman Empire.
During the next few centuries, the church defined itself by four very important words: one, holy, catholic, and apostolic. First, the church was to be one, or unified. Second, it was to be a holy church, meaning set apart for God and separate from the world. Third, it was to be catholic, which simply meant “universal”; the church was to be a worldwide church, one that included all believers under its umbrella. So the word catholic was being used of the church long before any kind of institution within Christianity used it for its own name. Finally, the church was to be apostolic, meaning committed to the teaching handed down by Jesus through the apostles as contained in the New Testament.
St. Peter’s Square in Vatican City, Rome [Wikimedia Commons]
A major turning point took place in Christian history in the year 312, when the Roman emperor Constantine converted to the Christian faith. This meant that the Christian church changed from being a persecuted minority to a faith that engulfed all of society, and Christendom was born. When the Roman Empire began to weaken, and the Early Middle Ages started—sometimes called the Dark Ages—the church was just about the only organization around to provide social glue. Particularly after the sacking of Rome by the Visigoths under the leadership of Alaric in AD 410. So the leaders of the church, known as popes, took center stage and gained enormous prestige and influence not just in the religious realm, but socially and politically.
As you might imagine, there were some divisions in the unity of the church. For example, in 1054 there was a split between the Western Latin church, which became the Roman Catholic Church, and the Eastern Greek church, which became known as the Orthodox Church. There were several issues related to the split, not the least of which was the Eastern Greek church’s rejection of the supreme authority of the pope in Rome over the rest of the church. The term pope, which is Latin for father, was initially used for any bishop or church leader. Around the year 1100, it came to be used exclusively of the leader of the church at Rome, and with the split between East and West, he became the leader of the Western half of the church.
But that was nothing compared to the biggest historical division of all—one that would come in the sixteenth century and become known as the Protestant Reformation. There was a clear sense among several Catholic scholars, leaders, and intellectuals that the church had drifted away from the clear teaching of Scripture on some key issues, and it needed to be brought back in line with what the Bible taught. It is important to realize that the spirit of the Reformers was just that: reform. They never wanted to leave the Catholic Church, because that was the only manifestation of the church around. And they certainly never lost their understanding of the importance of the church. In fact, one of the leading Reformers, John Calvin, agreed with what Cyprian of Carthage said more than one thousand years earlier: “You cannot have God as your father unless you have the church for your mother.” And he also agreed with Cyprian’s other famous statement that, “Outside the church there is no hope of remission of sins nor any salvation.” Meaning, the church is the custodian of the gospel. It is the carrier and the communicator of Jesus’s message.
The Reformers also agreed that the church should be one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, but they felt that the way those ideas had evolved under the medieval church’s leadership was wrong. Which is why they were called “Protestants”—they were people in protest. Led by such men as Martin Luther, who posted his Ninety-Five Theses on the door of All Saints’ Church in Wittenberg, Germany, in 1517, the Reformers began their great quest to restore the mother church to her biblical form.
Their effort failed.
In 1520, Luther himself was excommunicated by the pope and condemned by the Holy Roman Emperor. As a result, many, many Christians left what had been the mainstream church of the medieval era, forming the Lutheran and Reformed churches and, later, many other Protestant denominations including the Episcopal, Methodist, and Baptist churches. From that point on, the idea of there being “one” church could not be understood in either sociological or institutional terms, but only in theological terms. Arguably, this is what Jesus had in mind all along anyway. Yes, there are some theological differences. Most surround the role of the authority of Scripture in relation to the role of bishops and the pope, as well as the interplay between grace and faith when it comes to salvation. Yet both Protestants and Catholics believe that it is Jesus alone who saves. And we sign off together on the most ancient of Christian creeds, hammered out by the early Christian church in an effort to distill Christian orthodoxy, such as the Nicene Creed and the Apostles’ Creed. So while Protestants believe that the Reformation was necessary, and that the one true church is no longer the one headquartered in Rome, there is still mutual respect and appreciation. And, even further, mutual enrichment. Most importantly, though, we all continue to stand under one very large umbrella—the umbrella of “mere Christianity.”
The phrase “mere Christianity” was first used by the seventeenth-century Anglican writer Richard Baxter. Baxter lived through the English Civil War between the Protestants and the Catholics and, as a Protestant Puritan, Baxter threw his support behind Oliver Cromwell and the Parliamentary forces. Cromwell then summoned Baxter from his church in Kidderminster, Worcestershire, to help establish the “fundamentals of religion” for the new Protestant government. Baxter did what he asked, but Cromwell complained that Baxter’s summary of Christianity could be affirmed by a Catholic. To which Baxter said, “Good!” Baxter refused to allow Christianity to divide people that way. Or to fall prey to the latest fashion or sect. Christianity was bigger than that. He was convinced that there was a core of orthodox Christianity that Puritans, Anglicans, and Catholics all affirmed and that should have been a source of peace among them.
Here’s what he wrote in 1680:
Must you know what Sect or Party I am of? I am against all Sects and dividing Parties: but if any will call Mere Christian by the name of a Party . . . I am of that Party which is so against Parties. . . . I am a CHRISTIAN, a MERE CHRISTIAN, of no other religion.
Yes.
And it remains the hope of the world.
But let’s be honest, that hope can sometimes be hard to hold when you interact with those who fill its ranks. So let’s talk about that next.
