Chapter 5 of 12

3. Jesus 101

3. Jesus 101

3

Jesus 101

“But what about you?” he asked. “Who do you say I am?”

Jesus (Matt. 16:15)

He was born in a small, obscure village of somewhat questionable repute, the child of a peasant woman. He didn’t go to high school or college. In fact, he never traveled more than two hundred miles from the place where he was born. He never wrote a book. He never held public office. And he was only thirty-three years old when the tide of public opinion turned against him, prompting even his closest friends to abandon him. He was then turned over to his enemies and was nailed to a wooden cross between two criminals. While he was dying, his executioners gambled for his clothing, the only property he had on earth. After he died, he was laid in a borrowed grave through the pity of an acquaintance.

Yet today, he is arguably the central figure of the entire human race. His life even marks our concept of time. We call this AD 2019, Latin for anno Domini, “the year of our Lord.” Anything before that is referenced by BC, meaning, “before Christ.” As Philip Yancey observed about the life of Jesus, “You can gauge the size of a ship that has passed out of sight by the huge wake it leaves behind.” No wonder that everyone, no matter where they are spiritually, is intrigued by Jesus and fascinated by his life and his teaching, message, and mission.

Historicity

Let’s begin with the most obvious question to consider: Did Jesus even exist? Are we talking about someone who is real or is he a myth? Actually, this one is easy to check off the list. No scholar, no matter where they stand on Christianity itself, denies that the man Jesus, the one the Bible talks about, existed in time and history. Jesus is one of the most documented figures in all of human history. You find him listed in the writings of Thallus, who was a first-century Greek writer; Pliny the Younger, a lawyer and author of ancient Rome; the Roman historians Tacitus and Suetonius; and the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus. Of course, the most detailed record is found in the Bible, which gives not one, but four independent, eyewitness biographical accounts written by the men Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. More than a few historians have noted that his is the most documented life in all of ancient history.

So we know Jesus existed.

We also know a few other things for certain. We know that his teaching was of such a compelling nature that, to this day, it’s part of our cultural ethos. Whether memorable lines such as “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you,” or timeless stories like the prodigal son (which you can read in the New Testament of the Bible in Luke 15:11–32), no one has been more spiritually or culturally influential. We also know that miracles were attributed to him. Whether you buy into the possibility of miracles or not, people who witnessed his life said he did them. We know that after a public ministry he was sentenced to death through a Jewish and then Roman legal process. We know that on the third day after his execution there was an empty tomb. A stone was rolled away and the body was gone. Even the Romans owned that. Now, they had their version of what happened, which we’ll explore soon, but that the tomb was empty is without a doubt. And we know his followers went running around the landscape saying that Jesus had risen from the dead and that they had seen him, talked with him, and touched him. This wasn’t just one of the disciples making this claim, or even just a handful, but all of them. There are even records of groups numbering in the hundreds who witnessed the resurrected Jesus at the same time. After that first Easter, the Jesus movement exploded. By AD 100, there were around 25,000 followers. By AD 310, there were 20,000,000. And today, there are billions and Christianity is the world’s largest religious faith.

So who was he . . . really?

What Did Jesus Look Like?

Forensic scientists used cultural and archaeological data to create what they think the face of Jesus looked like. [BBC Photo Library]

One of the things people seem to be the most curious about when it comes to Jesus is what he looked like. Is there a physical description of Jesus? The answer is, “Yes and no.” First, the no. The Bible never says, “Jesus was white, 6′3″, with blond hair and chiseled good looks.” But here’s the “yes” part. We do know that he wasn’t white, 6′3″, with blond hair and chiseled good looks. While there is not a single historical reference to the physical appearance of Jesus and nothing in the Bible that describes his looks, we do know that he was a Mediterranean Jew; therefore, his skin would have had the olive darkness to it that you find in that region to this day. This also means he didn’t speak English. Not even King James English (sorry, he never uttered the words thee or thou). His native tongue was Aramaic. He would have been schooled as a boy in Hebrew and probably Greek, which was the common language of business and commerce, but when walking down the road with family, Aramaic was the language of choice. Being a Mediterranean Jew also means that he wasn’t overly tall—probably well under six feet. And, according to the ancient prophecies surrounding the coming of the Messiah that Christians believe apply to Jesus, he wasn’t physically impressive at all. In fact, the prophet Isaiah wrote in the Old Testament of the Bible that “he had no beauty or majesty to attract us to him, nothing in his appearance that we should desire him” (Isa. 53:2). So the idea that Jesus was “tall, dark, and handsome” is only accurate on the “dark” part.

Painting of Christ Pantocrator in the Church of the Pater Noster, Jerusalem [Wikimedia Commons]

The earliest drawing ever made of him, at least the earliest that is still in existence, dates to the fifth century. The original hangs in one of the most ancient Christian structures on Earth, St. Catherine’s Monastery in the Sinai desert of Egypt. It’s called the Christ Pantocrator, translated “Christ Almighty.” It is the classic picture of Christ that dominated ancient Christianity and continues to be displayed in many churches to this day.

Enhanced photo of the face of Jesus on the Shroud of Turin [Wikimedia Commons]

While the picture is ancient, we are far from certain Jesus looked like this. Forensic anthropologists have tried to re-create what Jesus might have actually looked like from common skeletal remains of that era and region. The image they came up with is not particularly flattering, but would fit the biblical prophecies as well as the distinguishing features of his actual ethnicity.

But if you want to go all the way back, the earliest possible image we have (hotly debated in terms of authenticity) is the famed Shroud of Turin. It is thought to be the shroud the body of Jesus was wrapped in following his crucifixion, and that miraculously carries his image to this day.

In truth, we don’t know what he looked like beyond being short, dark skinned, and without any shot of being named People magazine’s Sexiest Man Alive.

What Was His Childhood Like?

A second set of questions many have about Jesus relate to his childhood: What was it like? What was he like as a child? What was life like for him growing up? There’s not a lot of information to be found here. Most of the biographical material we have begins with his birth and then leapfrogs to his thirtieth year, when he began his public ministry. But there are some things that we do know that might be of interest.

First, it is helpful to be reminded of what the heart of the Christian faith maintains: Jesus is God himself in human form, God the Son, the second person of the Trinity. One of the most amazing teachings in the Bible about God is the idea that God is triune. That his very nature is trinity. The Bible teaches the oneness of God—there are not many gods, but only One God. But then the Bible follows that up with another teaching: there are three persons who are each referred to as God—God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit. Not three gods, but three persons who are one God. So you find Jesus referring to God the Father, but then referring to himself as God as well. And he was God the Son. To be the “son” of someone in the way Jesus was referring to meant to be of the same order as that person, and to have the same qualities as that person. This is mind-boggling to think about on so many levels, but just consider it in terms of God really becoming human, starting off with becoming a baby. Philip Yancey writes that the God who could have roared, “who could order armies and empires about like pawns on a chessboard, this God emerged . . . as a baby who could not speak or eat solid food or control his bladder, [and] who depended on a [poor] teenage [mother] for shelter, food and love.”

This means the childhood of Jesus was very much like any other child’s. Max Lucado writes that once born, he had to have his diaper changed. When he hit puberty, he had pimples. He may have been tone-deaf. Perhaps a girl down the street had a crush on him. It could have been that his knees were bony, or that he had a cowlick in his hair that Mary, his mother, could never do anything with. He was completely divine, but he was also completely human. But that raises all kinds of questions, doesn’t it? This child who was God in human form—what was that like? Lucado made a list of questions he’d like to ask Mary:

What was it like watching him pray?

Did you ever feel awkward teaching him how he created the world?

Did he ever come home with a black eye?

Did he do well in school?

Did he ever have to ask a question about Scripture?

Who was his best friend?

Did you ever think, That’s God eating my soup?

So what do we know about those early years in Jesus’s life? Well, we know he was raised in poverty. We know this from a scene that took place on the fortieth day after his birth. His parents, Mary and Joseph, took him to Jerusalem to present him at the Temple. You see, in Jesus’s day, following the birth of a son, a mother had to wait forty days before going to the Temple to offer a sacrifice for the purpose of her purification. The intent was to consecrate the baby to God. Back then, it was usually just the firstborn who was dedicated in this way, for it was the firstborn who had all the rights of inheritance. As part of the dedication, it was common for the parents to give a sacrifice or an offering. In the Bible we are told that Mary and Joseph chose to offer a pair of doves (or a pair of pigeons), which indicates they were poor. The best and most common sacrifice was a lamb, and the only reason to offer a substitute was if you didn’t have the money for a lamb. This required securing special approval for a pair of doves or a pigeon to be accepted—a recognition that you were so poor you couldn’t afford anything else. Mary and Joseph apparently did this, so we know they were poor.

The Presentation of Jesus in the Temple by Francesco Vittore Carpaccio at the Gallerie dell’Accademia in Venice, Italy [Wikimedia Commons]

Another significant fact we know about his childhood is that he was raised in the town of Nazareth. It was not a large place, just a little village. And not a very good one. Nazareth didn’t carry a good reputation. If I told you I came from Bangladesh, Nigeria, or Syria, images of poverty, violence, or unrest would probably instantly come to mind. Nazareth had a bad social reputation, as well. The people were seen as backward, illiterate, and poor. Later, in the Bible’s record of the life of Jesus, you read that when people heard him referred to as Jesus of Nazareth (that’s how people were identified then—their first name and where they were from), they said, “Nazareth! Can anything good come from there?” (John 1:46). Even the name Nazarene in that day was synonymous with someone who was despised. Let’s just say he came from the wrong side of the tracks.

Another dynamic of Jesus’s childhood that a lot of people either don’t know or don’t think about is how he was raised by a single-parent mother during his formative teenage years. He didn’t have Joseph as his father for very long. One of the better-known details about Mary is that when she was betrothed to Joseph and received her angelic visit about giving birth to Jesus as a virgin, she was young. In that day, engagement usually took place immediately after entering puberty, so Mary would have just entered her teens—as in thirteen, fourteen, or, at the most, fifteen. But what isn’t as well known is that while Mary was young, Joseph was old. So theirs was what is known as a May-December romance. And by our standards, very May and very December. He was probably in his thirties or forties and, as mentioned, she may have been as young as thirteen. But this would not have been uncommon for that day.

Then, whether it was because of his age or illness or both, sometime after Jesus turned twelve Joseph apparently died. The last record of Joseph is when Jesus was twelve, when he and Mary took Jesus to the Temple. The next scene from the life of Jesus, found in all four biographical accounts of his life in the Bible, is when he was thirty and began his public ministry. And in all four accounts, not a word is mentioned of Joseph. When Jesus returns home, when Jesus interacts with Mary—no Joseph. He is never present at any event in Jesus’s adult life, even when the rest of Jesus’s family is there. And on the cross, before his death, Jesus asks a man named John, who was also one of his closest friends and followers, to watch over Mary. This intimates that Jesus, as the eldest son, had carried that responsibility to that point and now was asking another family member (John may have been a cousin of Jesus) to watch over his mother. This tells us that Mary was a widow, and that sometime between the ages of twelve and thirty, probably in Jesus’s teen years, Joseph had died. Regardless of exactly when he died, or what filled his life before this marriage, his death explains why Jesus didn’t begin his public ministry until the age of thirty. He was providing for the family, carrying on as a carpenter as taught by his father. He assumed the role of caregiver until his brothers were able to assume primary care for their mother and the other siblings.

Did He Have Brothers and Sisters?

This brings us to another common question: Did Jesus have brothers and sisters? As you read just a moment ago, yes, he had brothers. Christians believe his brothers were half-brothers through Mary, since he was conceived of the Holy Spirit through a virginal conception, part of the miracle surrounding Christ as the God-Man. Probably the most famous of Jesus’s siblings was James, who wrote the part of the New Testament of the Bible known as the book of James. James was a later son of Mary and Joseph, and head of the Jerusalem church. He was one of the select individuals Jesus appeared to after his resurrection. He was called a “pillar” of the early church, meaning someone who was instrumental in building it, keeping it up, making it strong. Another famed follower of Jesus, a man by the name of Paul, was used by God to write much of the New Testament. On Paul’s first visit to Jerusalem, he went immediately to see James, acknowledging the influential nature of his leadership in the early church. When the early church leader Peter was rescued from prison, Peter told his friends to be sure and tell James. Tradition has it that he was known as “old camel knees,” because thick calluses built up on his knees from many years of determined prayer. Tradition also has it that he was martyred through a beheading around AD 62 under the great persecution of Christians by the Roman emperor Nero.

When Did He Know He Was God?

So if Jesus was a normal child who was fully human but also fully God, when did he discover the God side of things? Was he born with some kind of weird maturity so that he knew it from day one? Did it come to him sometime during puberty? Did it happen when he was baptized by the man known as John the Baptist at age thirty, when he began his public ministry? When did Jesus know that he could walk on the water he had to take a bath in?

Nobody knows.

But we have a hint that he knew by the time of puberty, the time of his coming of age, which would have been around twelve. We know this because of the only scene recorded in the Bible about his adolescent years. It’s worth reading:

Every year Jesus’ parents went to Jerusalem for the Passover festival. When Jesus was twelve years old, they attended the festival as usual. After the celebration was over, they started home to Nazareth, but Jesus stayed behind in Jerusalem. His parents didn’t miss him at first, because they assumed he was among the other travelers. But when he didn’t show up that evening, they started looking for him among their relatives and friends.

When they couldn’t find him, they went back to Jerusalem to search for him there. Three days later they finally discovered him in the Temple, sitting among the religious teachers, listening to them and asking questions. All who heard him were amazed at his understanding and his answers.

His parents didn’t know what to think. “Son,” his mother said to him, “why have you done this to us? Your father and I have been frantic, searching for you everywhere.”

“But why did you need to search?” he asked. “Didn’t you know that I must be in my Father’s house?” But they didn’t understand what he meant.

Then he returned to Nazareth with them and was obedient to them. And his mother stored all these things in her heart.

Jesus grew in wisdom and in stature and in favor with God and all the people. (Luke 2:41–52 NLT)

At twelve, Jesus went to the Temple and stayed there day and night. He demonstrated a wisdom and intelligence, a spiritual maturity and insight that was unnatural. He was already amazing people at twelve. And though his parents were frantic, he knew they shouldn’t have been. He knew they should have known where he would be—in his Father’s house. And even that sentence is significant. The Jews of that day would never have simply said “my Father.” That was too informal, too intimate. They would have said “our Father,” or even more likely, “our Father in heaven.” But not Jesus. Just “my Father.” So it would seem that at this time, he knew who he was. It also appears that this knowledge was something he grew into, matured into, and gained an ever-increasing understanding of, as his physical, human life developed. Notice that last line again of the verses above, noting how Jesus matured, growing up in both wisdom and stature.

Was He Ever Married?

So when he grew up, was there a Mrs. Jesus? One of the most common myths surrounding the life of Jesus is that he got married and had children. That’s not surprising since a bestselling novel in modern history, Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code, made that idea its central premise.

At first glance, the plot wasn’t anything that stood out above the normal mystery fare. The murder of a curator at the Louvre in Paris leads to a trail of clues found in the work of Leonardo da Vinci and to the discovery of a centuries-old secret society. But that’s not what grabbed our collective cultural attention. Brown went on to write that the clues in Leonardo’s work and the mission of the secret society revolved around the Holy Grail. This was not referring to the chalice Jesus used during the Last Supper. The novel suggested that the Holy Grail was instead a reference to the bloodline of Jesus. That a woman named Mary Magdalene was the wife of Jesus and the mother of his child. And because she bore descendants, specifically a daughter named Sarah, she was, in fact, the Holy Grail. In the novel, Mary fled after the crucifixion with Sarah to the south of France, where they established the Merovingian line of European royalty. This became the basis for the secret society to preserve the bloodline and protect the secret until it was time to make it known to the world.

The problem with all of this is that Brown contended that he was basing his entire book on fact. So was he? Not according to every reputable scholar on the planet. First, about Mary Magdalene. The Bible states that Mary was a devoted follower of Christ, liberated from a serious illness of some kind that had plagued her life. She was present at his crucifixion and burial and was the first person Jesus appeared to following his resurrection. She was even charged to bring the news of his resurrection to his disciples, which she did. She was a remarkable woman, prominently featured in the New Testament of the Bible and honored throughout Christian history. But married to Jesus or a secret lover? There is absolutely no evidence that indicates Mary had a relationship with Jesus beyond being a devoted spiritual follower. Karen King, a history professor at Harvard University, while never claiming that Jesus was married put forward the possibility of evidence that, after the time of Jesus, people believed he might have been. She now admits there is no evidence for that.

What Did Jesus Say about Himself?

This brings us to the most significant thing to know about Jesus, and it has to do with what Jesus said about himself. It was very direct:

The Jews [said to Jesus], “Aren’t we right in saying that you are a Samaritan and demon-possessed?”

“I am not possessed by a demon,” said Jesus. . . . “Very truly I tell you, whoever obeys my word will never see death.”

At this they exclaimed, “Now we know that you are demon-possessed! Abraham died and so did the prophets, yet you say that whoever obeys your word will never taste death. Are you greater than our father Abraham? He died, and so did the prophets. Who do you think you are?”

Jesus replied, “. . . Your father Abraham rejoiced at the thought of seeing my day; he saw it and was glad.”

“You are not yet fifty years old,” they said to him, “and you have seen Abraham!”

“Very truly I tell you,” Jesus answered, “before Abraham was born, I am!” At this, they picked up stones to stone him. (John 8:48–49, 51–54, 56–59)

Who did Jesus say he was? He referred to himself here as “I am.” Now that’s either very bad grammar or he was trying to say something very significant.

Let’s explore the significance.

The background of “I am” is found in one of the most famous stories in the Bible, the story of Moses before the burning bush. The entire story of Moses is amazing, which is why almost every movie made on the Bible is either on Moses or Jesus. As a Hebrew baby, he was put in a small boat-like crib on the Nile to avoid being killed, rescued by the daughter of the pharaoh of Egypt, raised as a prince, sent into exile after killing a man who was assaulting a fellow Hebrew—and we haven’t even come to the plagues, the parting of the sea, or the Ten Commandments. But back to “I am.”

God himself was speaking to Moses, telling him to go to the highest authority and power in the land and demand that he release all of his Hebrew slaves. Moses understandably wanted to have a little credibility, so he asked God to give him his name—the very name of God—so that he could say to the people exactly who had sent him. Here’s the answer God gave to Moses: “God said to Moses, ‘I AM WHO I AM. This is what you are to say . . . : “I AM has sent me to you”’” (Exod. 3:14). That phrase—“I AM”—is considered the most holy word in existence because it is the very name of God. It was considered so holy that the Jews would not even write it completely, penning only the four consonants: “YHWH.” Scholars used to think it was pronounced “Je-ho-vah.” We now know that the closest we can make of the actual name in light of the missing vowels is that it was pronounced “Yah-weh.”

God said my name is “Yahweh”—“I AM.”

Now, return to what Jesus said when asked about his identity: “‘Very truly I tell you,’ Jesus answered, ‘before Abraham was born, I am!’” (John 8:58). Jesus claimed the very name of God for himself. He said, “You want to know who I am? I’ll tell you—I am God.” And the people listening understood him completely. They picked up stones to stone him, because this was nothing less than blasphemy. Here a mere man was claiming to be God himself. But this “mere man” made that claim repeatedly throughout his life. Here’s a taste from some of the biographical records:

I am the Son of God. (John 10:36 TLB)

I am the way, the truth, and the life. (John 14:6 GNT)

The high priest asked him, “Are you the Messiah, the Son of the Blessed One?”

“I am,” said Jesus. (Mark 14:61–62)

Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father. (John 14:9)

So in Jesus, we have a person who walked the earth and claimed to be God. No other major religious figure has ever made that claim—not Buddha, not Mohammed, not Confucius. Only Jesus made the claim to be God in human form. So what do you do with that? As has often been observed, there are only four options.

First, you can conclude that Jesus was a stark raving lunatic. Maybe he did think he was God, but he was severely sick psychologically. The problem is that in most cases of severe psychological disorder, the background of the person makes it very clear they had a profile and history of mental illness. But nothing in the historical record of the life of Jesus exhibits a single sign of any of the classical manifestations of mental illness, such as the inability to relate to the real world, inadequacy in personal relationships, or deficiencies in verbal skills. In fact, psychiatrist J. T. Fisher concluded that if you were to survey all of the psychological data that Jesus’s life has to offer, and boil it down to one essential and perfect prescription for mental health, it would be the Sermon on the Mount—the most famous single message Jesus ever proclaimed.

A second choice is to say he was simply a liar. Jesus said he was God but obviously knew he wasn’t. But this would be saying that the man whose teaching has set the standard for integrity and honesty throughout the civilized world was a habitual, premeditated, pathological liar. Even more important to remember is that Jesus was arrested, mocked, beaten, and tortured prior to his execution. Willingly. Jesus was offered a full pardon by the Roman governor, Pilate, if he would simply deny his claim to be God. If a con man could stop a nail being driven into the flesh of his hand by telling the truth, you would think he would. People who are playing the system for personal gain tend to change their game when it stops paying off. They keep up the lie until the deception costs them more than what they gained through the deceit. But Jesus endured it all. He never denied his claim to be God, though given every chance.

A third option is to say that Jesus was just a good man, maybe even a prophet from God, but that’s all. Not many people want to say that Jesus was a lunatic or a liar, but they don’t want to say he was God in human flesh, either. So they land on him being simply a good man, a holy man—no more. But there’s a problem with this option as well. Here’s what C. S. Lewis wrote about this idea:

I am trying here to prevent anyone saying the really foolish thing that people often say about Him: “I’m ready to accept Jesus as a great moral teacher, but I don’t accept His claim to be God.” That is the one thing we must not say. A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic—on a level with the man who says he is a poached egg—or else he would be the Devil of Hell. You must make your choice. Either this man was, and is, the Son of God: or else a madman or something worse. You can shut him up for a fool, you can spit at Him and kill Him as a demon; or you can fall at His feet and call Him Lord and God. But let us not come with any patronising nonsense about His being a great human teacher. He has not left that open to us. He did not intend to.

Lewis is right. Here we have a man who walked the earth and claimed to be God in human form. You can say that Jesus was insane—that the man who has, in the minds of many, given the world its greatest picture of sanity was in fact a stark raving lunatic. You can say that Jesus was a liar—that the man whose teaching has set the standard for integrity and honesty in the civilized world was a habitual, premeditated, pathological deviant.

Or you can fall at his feet and call him Lord, which is, of course, the last of our four options. What you can’t say is that Jesus was just a good man, maybe even a prophet, but that’s all. That is one option he didn’t give.

Why Did He Pray to God If He Was God?

So if you’re adding all this up, you may have a nagging question about Jesus’s identity: Why did he pray to God if he was God? And make no mistake, he did. A lot. So who was he praying to? Remember our earlier conversation about the nature of God being triune? The Trinity means that God is community, the perfect relationship between the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. Here’s how Brent Curtis and John Eldredge describe it:

Think of your best moments of love or friendship or creative partnership, the best times with family or friends around the dinner table, your richest conversations, the acts of simple kindness that sometimes seem like the only things that make life worth living. Like the shimmer of sunlight on a lake, these are reflections of the love that flows among the Trinity. We long for intimacy because we are made in the image of perfect intimacy.

Or as the thirteenth-century theologian and philosopher Meister Eckhart wrote, “We were created out of the laughter of the Trinity.” So that’s why you have Jesus—God the Son—praying, talking, and communicating with God the Father.

So Why Did He Come?

So why did God come to Earth in the person of Jesus? Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard writes of the risk and complexity of this divine desire through the tale of a king:

Suppose there was a king who loved a humble maiden. . . . Every statesman feared his wrath and dared not breathe a word of displeasure; every foreign state trembled before his power and dared not omit sending ambassadors with congratulations for the nuptials. . . . Then there awoke in the heart of the king an anxious thought. . . . Would she be happy in the life at his side? Would she be able to summon confidence enough never to remember . . . that he was a king and she had been a humble maiden? For if this memory were to waken in her soul, and like a favored lover sometimes steal her thoughts away from the king, luring her reflections into the seclusion of a silent grief . . . where would then be the glory of their love?

The king wanted true love, but how could her love for him be true? He could bring her to the palace, covering her body with silk and jewels in an effort to coax affection by blinding her eyes.

But this would be a purchased heart.

He could come to her cottage, casting a pall of glory and power over its humble surroundings, driving her to her knees in awe and wonder.

But that would be an overpowered heart.

No, neither elevation of her nor himself could achieve the desired end. Only his own descent. Thus the king becomes a humble servant and seeks to win her heart, for only if it is so won has it been truly given at all.

God could have made us love him, but if he had, his relationship with us—and ours with him—would have been meaningless. As I’ve said before, God wants our relationship with him and with others to be real. So he came to us.

As Jesus.

The Great Test

But how can we know if this story is true? If I told you that I was God in human form, come to earth to show the way and call the world back to myself, you would have every right to say, “Prove it.” People certainly said that to Jesus and, rumor has it, he did prove it through a stunning array of miracles. From walking on water to raising the dead, Jesus silenced more than his fair share of skeptics. But he raised the stakes even further. He laid out a very specific “proof” for his claims that he invited anyone and everyone to judge him by. Christians believe he passed that ultimate litmus test and the entire world is still talking about it. His big proof? Coming back to life after death. He told people all along it was what he was going to do, and that it was going to be the definitive validation that he was who he said he was.

Let me give you a taste of his words:

One day some teachers of religious law and Pharisees came to Jesus and said, “Teacher, we want you to show us a miraculous sign to prove your authority.”

But Jesus replied, “. . . The only sign I will give . . . is the sign of the prophet Jonah. For as Jonah was in the belly of the great fish for three days and three nights, so will the Son of Man be in the heart of the earth for three days and three nights.” (Matt. 12:38–40 NLT)

Some Pharisees and Sadducees were on him again, pressing him to prove himself to them. He told them, “You have a saying that goes, ‘Red sky at night, sailor’s delight; red sky at morning, sailors take warning.’ You find it easy enough to forecast the weather—why can’t you read the signs of the times? . . . The only sign you’ll get is the Jonah sign.” (Matt. 16:1–4 Message)

The Church of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem, said to be the spot of the empty tomb [Wikimedia Commons]

Taking the twelve disciples aside, Jesus said, “Listen, we’re going up to Jerusalem, where all the predictions of the prophets concerning the Son of Man will come true. He will be handed over to the Romans, and he will be mocked, treated shamefully, and spit upon. They will flog him with a whip and kill him, but on the third day he will rise again.” (Luke 18:31–33 NLT)

Over and over again, Jesus made it clear that the one sign you could test him by was whether he would come back from the dead on the third day after his death. And because of that, whether he succeeded means everything. Even the Bible says it’s everything. One of the leaders of the early church, Paul, wrote:

If there’s no resurrection for Christ, everything we’ve told you is smoke and mirrors, and everything you’ve staked your life on is smoke and mirrors. Not only that, but we would be guilty of telling a string of barefaced lies about God, all these affidavits we passed on to you verifying that God raised up Christ—sheer fabrications, if there’s no resurrection. . . . But the truth is that Christ has been raised up. (1 Cor. 15:13–15, 20 Message)

But is it the truth? Did he rise from the dead? J. Warner Wallace is a decorated homicide investigator. After completing training through the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, Wallace joined the force in Torrance, working on the SWAT team on the gang detail and investigating robbery and homicide cases. Later, he became a founding member of the department’s cold-case homicide unit assigned to crack murders nobody else had been able to solve. His natural street-honed skepticism served him well. He once said, “As a cop, if you believe everything people tell you, then you’d never arrest anyone.” So for him, facts need to be solid, witnesses have to be credible, evidence must be persuasive, corroboration is always crucial, and alibis have to be dismantled.

And he’s good—very good—at what he does. Wallace has been awarded the Police and Fire Medal of Valor “Sustained Superiority” award and the CopsWest award for his ability to get to the truth and solve crimes. He’s so good that he’s been featured on Court TV, NBC’s Dateline, and other news outlets when they need expertise on what it takes to arrest killers who thought they got away with murder.

Then he decided to take on the coldest case of his life. One that didn’t go back a few years, or even decades, but one that went back two millennia.

He took on the death and the resurrection of Jesus.

He was an atheist, didn’t believe a resurrection had occurred, and wanted to figure out what did happen since his wife had started to dabble a little bit in Christianity. He spent six months of painstaking analysis employing everything he had mastered as a detective: resisting the influence of dangerous presuppositions, emphasizing the importance of abductive reasoning, respecting the nature of circumstantial evidence and the role it plays and does not play, evaluating the reliability of witnesses, examining the choice and meaning of language through forensic statement analysis, determining what’s important evidentially, recognizing the rarity of true conspiracies, establishing reliability by tracing the evidence, getting comfortable with conclusions and, finally, distinguishing between possible alternatives and reasonable alternatives. At the end of his investigation, this cold-case specialist reached his conclusions: Christianity is true beyond a reasonable doubt; the resurrection actually happened. Today, Detective J. Warner Wallace is a committed Christian.

So what was it he found?

There are certain facts any investigation of this nature has in its possession to begin with. We know that Jesus existed. We know that after a public ministry he was sentenced to death through Roman crucifixion. We know that on the third day, there was an empty tomb—the stone was rolled away and the body was gone. We also know that on the third day after his crucifixion, his followers were quite bold in saying that he had risen from the dead and that they had, in fact, seen him. From that starting point, let’s put our detective hats on and look at all of our options.

Did the Disciples Steal the Body?

The first option is that the disciples—or followers of Jesus—stole the body and then spread the idea that he rose from the dead. Jesus had said he would rise from the dead on the third day; so, on the third day, they stole the body so that it would look like it really happened. That way they wouldn’t look stupid for following him. If it became known that Jesus was a fake—that he didn’t rise from the dead like he said he would—they would be the laughingstock of the entire Middle East. So they stole the body, hid it, and then said he rose from the dead. Assuming this option, there were never any post-resurrection appearances and no empty tomb. The body was probably devoured by dogs, following the fate of most crucified Roman criminals without the benefit of a burial cave.

This was actually the primary idea that the enemies of Jesus raised when news of the empty tomb first hit. After the first few tweets came out about Jesus rising from the dead, the news started to trend on Facebook, and the first Instagram of the empty tomb went viral, his enemies sent out a few social media messages of their own. Even the Bible takes note of this and records how the rumor got started. The biography written by Matthew in the New Testament says:

A few of [the guards] went into the city and told the high priests everything that had happened. They called a meeting of the religious leaders and came up with a plan: They took a large sum of money and gave it to the soldiers, bribing them to say, “His disciples came in the night and stole the body while we were sleeping.” They assured them, “If the governor hears about your sleeping on duty, we will make sure you don’t get blamed.” The soldiers took the bribe and did as they were told. That story, cooked up in the Jewish High Council, is still going around. (Matt. 28:11–15 Message)

The problem that story ran into then is the same one it runs into now. The tomb was protected by a full guard of Roman soldiers. A Roman guard contained up to sixteen highly trained, heavily armed, professional fighting men. You couldn’t have just snuck by them during the night, because that would have required all sixteen guards to be asleep at the same time, including the ones posted to keep watch at the time of the supposed abduction. The Roman penalty for sleeping on guard duty was execution. Staying awake on duty was one of the highest values the Roman army held. So this would call for the most sacred vow and highest value of the Roman military to be uniformly discarded. But, even more important, rolling away a two-ton stone makes noise. Lots of noise. The kind of noise that wakes up sleeping Roman guards. All sixteen of them.

That’s not even the biggest reason why this would be hard to believe. Let’s say they pulled it off. Let’s say they did sneak past the guards and somehow rolled the stone away without waking anyone, and then stole the body out from under the noses of the guards. A conspiracy theory of this nature must account for the fact that, according to all four independent biographical accounts recorded in the Bible, the first witnesses to the resurrection were women. This would never have been invented by even the least sophisticated conspirators who wanted to authenticate a failed religious leader, for Jewish courts did not even accept the testimony of female witnesses.

But there’s something even more telling: How does this account for the amazing, overnight transformation of the disciples from a band of frightened, betrayal-oriented cowards into a group of radical revolutionaries who willingly risked their lives to spread the message of the risen Jesus? Would this have happened for what they knew to be a lie? Eleven of the twelve disciples who hypothetically stole the body died martyr deaths. Meaning they willingly, purposefully died for their story. They laid down their lives claiming to be eyewitnesses to the risen Jesus. I say eleven of the twelve because of John. The Roman authorities tried to kill John but were unsuccessful, so he ended up being exiled to the island of Patmos. Regardless, each of the disciples was faced with a decisive moment: deny what you say about Jesus and his resurrection and live, or cling to your pathetic story and die the cruelest, most painful and vicious death possible. Every single disciple faced this test of torture and martyrdom for the sake of the truth of the resurrection of Christ and themselves as personal eyewitnesses, but they stood their ground. And it cost them everything.

Tradition tells us that John’s brother James was beheaded; Matthew was slain with a combination battle-axe and spear; Philip was whipped, thrown into prison, and then crucified; Simon the Zealot was crucified; Peter was crucified in Rome; James (son of Alphaeus) was thrown from the pinnacle of the Temple in Jerusalem and then beaten to death with a fuller’s club; Bartholomew was beaten and then crucified; Andrew was bound to a cross from where he preached to his persecutors until his death; Thomas was run through the body with a lance; Jude was shot with arrows and then crucified; and Matthias, who replaced Judas Iscariot (the disciple who betrayed Jesus), was stoned and then beheaded. Now think about that for a minute. People will die for what they believe to be true—what they think is true—even though it may be false. We see that all the time. But people don’t have a tendency to die for what they know is a lie. Yet each of these eyewitnesses to the resurrected Jesus went to their death saying: “Jesus has risen, and I saw him. Kill me if you must, but it happened.” So did the disciples steal the body? The evidence makes that very hard to believe.

Did the Jewish or Roman Authorities Steal the Body?

A second option is to say that the Jewish or Roman authorities stole the body. The dilemma with this view is one that crime detectives ask all the time: What would the motive be? They were the ones who put guards at the tomb to make sure the body wasn’t stolen. Their biggest fear was somebody stealing the body. That’s public record, and even recorded in the Bible:

The high priests and Pharisees arranged a meeting with Pilate. They said, “Sir, we just remembered that that liar announced while he was still alive, ‘After three days I will be raised.’ We’ve got to get that tomb sealed until the third day. There’s a good chance his disciples will come and steal the corpse and then go around saying, ‘He’s risen from the dead.’ Then we’ll be worse off than before, the final deceit surpassing the first.”

Pilate told them, “You will have a guard. Go ahead and secure it the best you can.” So they went out and secured the tomb, sealing the stone and posting guards.” (Matt. 27:62–66 Message)

So do you see the motive problem? They understood Christianity to be an incredible threat against both Jewish authority and Roman rule. They had a vested interest in making sure people didn’t believe that Jesus rose from the dead. The whole purpose of the crucifixion was to silence Jesus and demoralize his followers. The last thing they would do is steal the body to make it look like he rose from the dead, which would make him and the Christian movement more believable than ever. They wished they did have the body! They would have paraded it through the streets of Jerusalem, saying, “See, he was just a man. Here’s his beat-up, crucified corpse.” But they didn’t. So did the Jewish or Roman authorities steal the body? That flies in the face of everything we know. This is also why nobody has ever seriously entertained the idea that the resurrection can be written off as some kind of mass hallucination due to people’s grief or emotional stress, or that perhaps they mistook someone else (who was alive) for (the very dead) Jesus. Not only would a hallucination or mistaken sighting have to account for every single eyewitness account, but the simple production of a dead body by the Romans would have brought everyone back to reality.

The painting Christ Crucified by Diego Velazquez [Wikimedia Commons]

Did They Just Go to the Wrong Tomb?

A third option is that the disciples just went to the wrong tomb. This option doesn’t attract much attention from people who look carefully at the evidence but needs to be raised in order to be thorough. The thinking is that the disciples were nervous, worried, and full of fear. It would have been relatively easy for them to have simply made a mistake by going to the wrong tomb, finding that tomb empty, and then assuming that Jesus was alive. The problem with this view is that all the Romans would have had to do was point out the right tomb where the guards were posted and the party would have ended. And you still have to deal with all the people who said they saw Jesus after his death—people who were more than willing to go on record, even under threat of death. Consider these words written by the apostle Paul in his letter to the church in Corinth. He noted that Jesus “appeared to Cephas, and then to the Twelve. After that, he appeared to more than five hundred of the brothers and sisters at the same time, most of whom are still living. . . . Then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles, and last of all he appeared to me also” (1 Cor. 15:5–8). In today’s court system, all it takes is one or two eyewitnesses to begin to determine what happened at a particular point and place in time. There were hundreds of eyewitnesses to Jesus being alive after his crucifixion. And again, all of the disciples said they saw him and were willing to die for it.

In fact, they did.

Did Jesus Really Die?

A fourth option is what has been called the “swoon theory.” This was first suggested back in the late 1700s, and then gained attention in the 1960s through a book called The Passover Plot. This idea is a little different than the others; it says that Jesus never really died on the cross. He never resurrected, because he never died. This theory says that he was mistakenly reported to be dead when in reality, he just “swooned” or passed out on the cross from exhaustion, pain, and loss of blood. Or in the immortal words of Miracle Max from one of my favorite movies, The Princess Bride, he was just “mostly dead.” And, as we all know, mostly dead means slightly alive. And from that slightly alive state, after three days he got up, walked around, claimed he rose from the dead, and was received as resurrected.

Even the most die-hard skeptics don’t raise this option very often. First, it makes Jesus out to be the most manipulative, false, lying, deceitful religious figure in all of human history. Not many people feel that way about Jesus. But the big argument against the swoon theory is physical—meaning, what he had to survive.

One of the first things he endured was a savage flogging from the Roman guards. He received thirty-nine lashes with a form of cat-o’-nine-tails, with weighted pellets of lead at the end of the whip and ends that were embedded with bone and metal to add weight—along with razor-sharp hooks. It was designed so that when it hit your back, it dug in. When it was pulled back, whatever flesh was on the hook was ripped out, literally tearing the body apart, often leaving the bones and intestines showing. He received thirty-nine of these lashes. Forty, by Roman law, was considered the death penalty.

Then, he was pierced in the head with multiple wooden stakes. You may have heard that Jesus had a “crown of thorns” placed on his head or have seen pictures of this (like the previous image). But what was used then were date palms, and the thorns were several inches in length. So it wasn’t placed on his head as much as his head was impaled on it. It would be like having a series of three- or four-inch nails driven into your skull, causing massive facial distortion. It was beaten into his skull with the equivalent of a baseball bat to drive the wood as deep into his head as possible. Without a doubt, that alone could have killed anyone.

He then was made to drag his heavy wooden cross all the way up to a hill called Golgotha, which is where he was to be crucified, until he collapsed and could carry it no farther. That indicates that by this time he was already so physically decimated that he couldn’t even walk. He then was nailed to the wooden arms of the cross with spikes that would have been driven into his wrists. Medieval art shows the holes in his palms, but when the Bible says the nails went through his hands, the word used for “hands” translates as anywhere from the wrist up. Based on corpses found who were crucified during that time period, the nail was typically driven through the wrist so as not to tear through the flesh of the hand with the weight of the body hanging on the cross. The goal was for the body to hang. Nails were also driven through the ankle, among the most sensitive nerves that could have been pierced. This is where we get our word excruciating: literally “from the cross,” a pain that is so severe it can only come from crucifixion. After suffering all of that, Jesus then hung on the cross until he essentially suffocated to death. You had to push yourself up against the spike in your ankles to breathe. Eventually the body tires of this and the person chokes to death. And finally, Jesus was pierced in the side with a lance to ensure death, and subsequently pronounced dead by Roman experts.

“Swoon” theorists would have us believe this happened next: after Jesus was laid in a damp tomb in burial clothes and seventy-five pounds of burial spices, and endured three days without food, water, or medical attention of any kind, he popped up and said, “I feel better!” He rolled back a stone weighing thousands of pounds, then single-handedly, without any kind of weapon, overpowered a crack team of Rome’s heavily armed, heavily armored, elite fighting troops. He then started walking around town, looking, physically, like pretty much nothing happened—just a few holes here and there but otherwise none the worse for wear.

The resurrection is easier to believe than that.

But even more telling is that medical experts have pored over the biblical record of Jesus’s death. There was even an article in the Journal of the American Medical Association titled, “On the Physical Death of Jesus Christ.” Among the article’s points is that the Bible records, with great detail, that when the spear pierced Jesus’s side, water and blood spilled out. Though the eyewitnesses who recorded that didn’t know it at the time, we now know this was a medically significant detail. It was a sign that the spear pierced the pericardium, which is the sac that surrounds the heart, as well as the heart itself. It is a description of the postmortem separation of the blood into clot and serum, indicating that Jesus was truly dead.

So Are You Saying He Rose from the Dead?

So let’s add this up. If the disciples didn’t steal the body, the Jewish and Roman authorities didn’t steal the body, there wasn’t any kind of mass hallucination, they didn’t go to the wrong tomb, and Jesus didn’t just pass out on the cross and start feeling better in a day or two . . . what option is left? Christians have concluded that he did what he said he was going to do. Why? Because he was who he said he was.

He rose from the dead.

Now, I know that you might be thinking: Time out! I don’t care what the evidence points to. You’re not going to back me into this corner through some kind of hypothetical detective analysis. Dead people don’t rise!

And you’re right. They don’t. We know that now and they knew it then. But that’s the point.

This is what startled N. T. Wright, who taught at both Cambridge and Oxford. In his massive, 800-plus-page academic work on the history surrounding the resurrection event of Jesus, he writes that no one would have ever thought up the resurrection, because nobody believed such a thing possible. Nowhere in paganism, nowhere in Judaism, nowhere in any worldview or philosophy did anybody ever conceive, posit, contemplate, or even suggest that such a thing could—or ever had—taken place. Wright’s conclusion is that “the early Christians did not invent the empty tomb and the ‘meetings’ or ‘sightings’ of the risen Jesus in order to explain a faith they already had. They developed that faith.” And why did they develop it? Because of what they saw, because of what they experienced, because what they didn’t think was going to happen—or could happen—did happen.

So What?

This isn’t an intellectual game. If it happened, it validates Jesus and everything he taught. But there’s more. If it happened to him, it also means it can happen to us. To you. If true, two thousand years ago the power of God was reflected in a single life with such a clear demonstration of might and energy that all of human history was forever changed—culminating in raising that life, physically, from the dead. And through the resurrection of Jesus, God demonstrated his ultimate power, because there is no greater power on earth than power over death. Then the Bible says something equally radical: the very same power that raised Jesus from the dead is available for your life. Here are its words and the promise that goes with them: “[You need to] understand the incredible greatness of God’s power for us who believe him. This is the same mighty power that raised Christ from the dead” (Eph. 1:19–20 NLT). The word for power used in that verse in the original Greek language was the word dunamis, which is where we get our word dynamite. It’s the same word used when referring to the power behind Jesus’s miracles. And, as we just read, the power that raised him from the dead.

That’s some power.

And the Bible says that power can be there for you. Think about that. That means the power that resurrected Jesus can resurrect your life too. Not just after you die a physical death, but here and now! God can take your life, and no matter where you are or where you’ve been, he can bring you to life from any place you feel lifeless. He can give you whatever new beginning you need. Here’s how the Bible puts it: “And just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glorious power of the Father, now we also may live new lives” (Rom. 6:4 NLT).

Beyond a new life, Christians believe that the resurrection of Jesus can give us the power we need to live the way God wants us to live. We live in a day of self-help websites and seminars, apps and tech toys. Such resources and experiences are good for telling us what we are supposed to do, but they can’t give us the power to do it. The Bible promises an external power source, claiming that the power to change our life can come to us from God. We don’t have it within us to live the way we want to live, much less the way we are supposed to live. But the Bible says that the very same power that raised Jesus from the dead is available for your life. You may not be ready to have it, or even believe it, but millions of Christians can testify to the fact that God’s power has altered their lives. Marriages that seemed beyond hope have been restored. Long, habitual, destructive patterns of behavior have been broken. Finances have been straightened out, difficulties on the job have been overcome, and parenting challenges have been met. The resurrection of Jesus matters because it reveals to us that the power of God is there to change our life.

Even that’s not the best of the “so what” when it comes to the resurrection of Jesus. In a letter to a group of Christians who had just chosen to put their trust in Jesus, the early Christian leader Paul reminded them of one more dynamic of the resurrection: “If all we get out of Christ is a little inspiration for a few short years, we’re a pretty sorry lot. But the truth is that Christ has been raised up, the first in a long legacy of those who are going to leave the cemeteries” (1 Cor. 15:19–20 Message).

The Bible says that if there was no resurrection, then there’s no hope for life after death. And if that’s true, then life has no purpose and no meaning. Søren Kierkegaard once compared such a view to a smooth, flat stone that is thrown over the surface of a pond. The stone dances and skims over the surface of the water until that moment comes when, like life without hope beyond death, it runs out of momentum and sinks into nothingness. In a similar vein, Samuel Beckett once put forth a play titled Breath. The curtain opens to a stage littered with nothing but garbage. A soundtrack begins, starting with a baby’s first cry and ending with an old man’s last, dying gasp. Then the curtain closes. Beckett’s point is clear—life is absurd, man is meaningless, existence is pointless. But Christianity maintains that the resurrection did happen, and the Bible says that “because Jesus was raised from the dead, we’ve been given a brand-new life and have everything to live for, including a future in heaven” (1 Pet. 1:3 Message).

And that means hope. But that hope involves embracing a message—a message unlike any ever given.

↑ Back to top

↑