Chapter 2 of 12

Introduction

Introduction

Introduction

We are half-hearted creatures, fooling around with drink and sex and ambition, when infinite joy is offered us . . . like an ignorant child who wants to go on making mud pies in a slum because he cannot imagine what is meant by the offer of a holiday by the sea. We are far too easily pleased.

C. S. Lewis, “The Weight of Glory”

Men despise religion; they hate it, and fear it is true.

Pascal, Pensées

I hope you begin this book with a healthy amount of doubt. It’s the best way to explore anything. When you believe something to be true, you are “in one mind” about accepting it; when you do not believe something to be true, you are “in one mind” about rejecting it. “To doubt,” Os Guinness writes, “is to waver between the two, to believe and disbelieve at once and to be ‘in two minds.’”

I’m so glad someone gave me that permission. When I was around nine, it dawned on me that the reason I considered myself a Christian was because my parents were Christians. Like a thunderbolt from the blue it hit me: That’s why I believe all of this—I have been raised to believe it all! Which, of course, did not make it true. My preadolescent brain quickly surmised that if I had been born in India, I would have been raised a Hindu. It would have been Hinduism I believed and accepted. If I had been born in Iran, my parents would have raised me to accept the Muslim faith. If I had been raised in Pittsburgh, my parents would have raised me to accept the cult known as “Steeler Nation” and I would be waving yellow towels in worship.

I remember panicking—what if I wasn’t born in the right place? My entire eternity suddenly seemed to rest on whether my family of origin was geographically correct.

I went to my mother, innocently working in the kitchen and unaware of my spiritual crisis, and asked, “Mom, why are we Christians? You did . . . like . . . check it out first, didn’t you? How do you know we’re believing the right thing?” I then shared my geographical concerns. She did not dismiss me or give me a quick “Don’t worry” kind of reply that would have trivialized my question. She knew me well enough to know that I was serious about the question.

So she did something that was very unusual for a parent to do for their nine-year-old son. She said, “Jim, your father and I have looked at all of the faiths of the world and have determined that Christianity is true. It’s not just about where we live—Christians are all over the world and, in fact, it’s the world’s largest faith. You’ll find Christians in India, in Iran, and other places as well, so it’s not just about geography. But you have to come to that in your own mind. So you are welcome to look into all of the world’s religions and come to your own conclusions. And if, at the end, you want to go to a different church, or believe something else, or believe in nothing at all, that is your choice.”

When she said that to me, I heaved a huge sigh of relief. Not just because they had apparently done their homework, but also because I was allowed to pursue my questions without fear of retribution. Without insecurity. There was something comforting—even reassuring—about such freedom. I learned that questions, by themselves, were not wrong. Neither was good, solid, healthy doubt, which can be the fuel that energizes any faith when seeking understanding.

It was many years before I settled the matter for my own life, so I know what it’s like to approach the Christian faith (or any faith, for that matter) with a healthy dose of skepticism, curiosity, willful disobedience, and, for my part, ignorance. Which is why this is a book about the Christian faith for people who may not be Christians, written by someone who understands not being one. As such, I will try to accomplish two things: first, to explain the Christian faith in a way that doesn’t assume you have a foundational knowledge or understanding of it. I’m not going to assume you were raised in a church or that you’ve had much exposure to the Christian faith. Second, I’d like to try to answer some of the more common questions people standing outside of the Christian faith are quite reasonable to ask based on what they do know or understand about it. And I think you’ll find these answers are uncommon—meaning they may not be the answers you’d expect based on caricatures or ideas you’ve already formed about Christians. If you consider yourself a Christian, I’ve got a feeling you’ll enjoy this conversation, too, as there may be many aspects of the Christian faith you’ve never fully understood or questions that have remained unanswered. You can have doubts even as you believe.

It won’t just be you and me on this journey. You will find that I have invited a partner to join me. His name is C. S. Lewis. He died on the same day as John F. Kennedy and Aldous Huxley, so he’s not exactly a contemporary. I mention him because you will find that as we walk through the Christian faith, I bring him up from time to time. One reason is that his writing and thinking were very helpful to me when I first explored the Christian faith. The second reason is that he also understands what it’s like to be an atheist well into his adult life.

If you’re not familiar with Lewis, you may be familiar with some of his friends, particularly J. R. R. Tolkien of The Lord of the Rings fame. They spent many, many hours together at their favorite Oxford pub, The Eagle and Child (affectionately known by locals as “The Bird and the Baby”). As a plaque on the wall reads:

C. S. Lewis, his brother, W. H. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, Charles Williams and other friends met every Tuesday morning, between the years 1939–1962 in the back room of this their favorite pub. These men, popularly known as the “Inklings,” met here to drink beer and to discuss, among other things, the books they were writing.

The Eagle and Child pub in Oxford, England [Wikimedia Commons]

If you are familiar with Lewis, it is probably as a result of the movie of his life titled Shadowlands, his seven-volume Chronicles of Narnia (also made into movies), and such works as The Screwtape Letters and Mere Christianity.

Lewis went to University College, Oxford, where he achieved a rare double first in Classics, an additional first in English, and the Chancellor’s Prize for academics. He was shortly offered a teaching position at Magdalen College, Oxford, where he was a fellow and tutor from 1925–54, and then later at the University of Cambridge as professor of Medieval and Renaissance English from 1954–63. In 1931, Lewis came out of atheism into the Christian faith, aided significantly through his friendship with Tolkien. As he journeyed away from his rejection of any type of God, he flirted with several alternate worldviews before Christianity—most seriously Hinduism—but ended with Jesus. But this journey was not without resistance. On the particular day in the Trinity Term of 1929 when he “gave in, and admitted that God was God, and knelt and prayed,” he confessed he did so as “the most reluctant convert in all of England.”

The intellectual questions that plagued him during his spiritual journey—why God allows pain and suffering, how Christianity can be the one and only way to God, the place of miracles—became the very questions he later navigated with such skill. They were my questions too.

I’m also drawn to Lewis because—while thoroughly converted—he didn’t act the way some would say Christians are “supposed to” act. It has been suggested that he could not even be hired by the evangelical college that now stewards his personal letters due to his pipe-smoking, ale-drinking, free-speaking ways. Do you remember what the plaque at The Eagle and Child said they would do when they met at the pub? Drink beer. And do you remember what time it said they often met? In the morning. I’ve spent time at Oxford pursuing various post-doctoral studies. Over many years, in my many hours at The Eagle and Child pub, I’ve had conversations with people who knew Lewis. I have heard tales of how he would often come to class with alcohol on his breath—sometimes with what we might call a bit of a “buzz.” No, not drunk, but without a doubt having clearly imbibed. I was told that he had holes in his coat pockets from putting away his pipe and the ashes burning through. He was also widely known to be loud and somewhat earthy in his stories.

I think we would have liked him.

Addison’s Walk

There is a path on the grounds of Magdalen College where Lewis taught, just a short ways from Merton College where Tolkien resided, called Addison’s Walk. The path runs beside several streams of the River Cherwell. On Saturday, September 19, 1931, Lewis invited two friends to dine with him in his rooms at Magdalen. One was a man by the name of Hugo Dyson, a lecturer in English Literature at Reading University. The other was Tolkien.

On that fall evening, after they had dined, Lewis took his guests on a walk through the Magdalen grounds, ending with a stroll down Addison’s Walk. It was there they began to discuss the idea of metaphor and myth. Lewis had long appreciated myth. As a boy, he loved the great Norse stories of the dying god Balder; and as a man, he grew to love and appreciate the power of myth throughout the history of language and literature. But he didn’t believe in them. Beautiful and moving though they might be, they were, he concluded, ultimately untrue. As he expressed to Tolkien, myths are “lies and therefore worthless, even though breathed through silver.”

“No,” said Tolkien. “They are not lies.”

Later, Lewis recalled that at the moment Tolkien uttered those words, “a rush of wind . . . came so suddenly on the still, warm evening and sent so many leaves pattering down that we thought it was raining. We held our breath.”

Tolkien’s point was that the great myths might just reflect a splintered fragment of the true light. Within the myth, there was something of eternal truth. They talked on, and Lewis became convinced by the force of Tolkien’s argument. They returned to Lewis’s rooms on Staircase III of New Building. Once there, they turned their conversation to Christianity. In the case of Christianity, Tolkien argued, the poet who invented the story was none other than God himself, and the images he used were real men and women and actual history.

Addison’s Walk at Magdalen College, Oxford, England [Wikimedia Commons]

Lewis was floored.

“Do you mean,” he asked, “that the death and resurrection of Christ is the old ‘dying God’ story all over again?”

Yes, Tolkien answered, except that here is a real “dying” God, with a precise location in history and definite historical consequences. The old myth has become fact. Such joining of faith and intellect had never occurred to Lewis.

The time approached 3:00 a.m. and Tolkien had to go home. Lewis and Dyson escorted him down the stairs. They crossed the quadrangle and let him out by the little postern gate on Magdalen Bridge. Lewis remembered that “Dyson and I found more to say to one another, strolling up and down the cloister of New Building, so that we did not get to bed till 4.”

Twelve days later, Lewis wrote to his close boyhood friend Arthur Greeves: “I have just passed on from believing in God to definitely believing in Christ—in Christianity. I will try to explain this another time. My long night talk with Dyson and Tolkien had a good deal to do with it.”

So let’s go on a long walk together. You may not land where Lewis did, but hopefully the journey itself will prove enlightening.

↑ Back to top

↑