4. The Message
4
The Message
Even those who have renounced Christianity and attack it, in their inmost being still follow the Christian ideal, for hitherto neither their subtlety nor the ardour of their hearts has been able to create a higher ideal of man and of virtue than the ideal given by Christ.
Dostoevsky, The Brothers Karamazov
There was a British conference on comparative religions that brought together experts from all over the world to debate what was unique, if anything, about the Christian faith in relation to other religions. Was it the idea that a god became a man? No, other religions had variations on that one. Even the Greek myths were about gods appearing in human form. Was it heaven, life after death, or an eternal soul? Was it love for your neighbor, good works, care for the poor or homeless? Was it about sin or hell or judgment? The debate went on for some time, until C. S. Lewis wandered into the room. (As we read earlier, Lewis journeyed from atheism to agnosticism and then eventually to Christianity and became one of the most famous of all Christian writers and thinkers from his positions at Oxford and Cambridge.) Lewis asked what the debate was about and found out that his colleagues were discussing what Christianity’s unique contribution was among world religions.
“Oh, that’s easy,” he said. “It’s grace.”
And after they thought about it, they had to agree. The heart of the Christian message is the heart of the message Jesus brought to the world: grace, coupled with truth. We tend to get truth. But what is grace? We use the word in so many ways, seldom in the way Jesus used it. And the only way to understand his use of the word is to understand why we need this message so desperately. So let’s get at the “why” before the “what.” In other words, let’s start with why grace is such a unique and needed message. To do that, you have to understand five background issues: the nature of God, the law of God, the human condition, the Old Testament sacrificial system, and then Jesus himself. If this sounds daunting or, even worse, dry, I promise I’ll move fast. But trust me, each is important. Consider the five of them, together, Christian Theology 101.
First, the nature of God. What you need to understand about the nature of God is his holiness and his love. God is truly perfect and holy—sin is repulsive to him. He is allergic to it and cannot look upon it. His holiness demands either the removal or destruction of sin. But God is also love. Which means that much of the activity and any understanding of God lies at the crossroads of holiness and love. It’s the creative tension of all that he is and does.
The second thing to understand is the law—God’s spiritual and moral law. I know, law is not a positive word for many of us. Think of it here not as an arbitrarily set policy but rather as a manifestation of what is right or wrong: God’s standards and his dictates—the very expression of God’s person and God’s will. The law is God and God is the law. It is his very nature and his character. As a result, it is God we either obey or disobey. When we obey it is an act of love, and when we disobey it is an attack on God’s very nature. Cosmic treason. And the penalty is serious—the most serious of all—which is why in the New Testament book of Romans, the Bible offers these words: “for the wages of sin is death” (Rom. 6:23). We are familiar with the reality of physical death, but the Bible also teaches the reality of spiritual death, which is separation from God. Sin causes spiritual death. It breaks the relationship. It destroys the intimacy that God intended to take place between himself and his creation because at its heart, sin is rebellion against God and his character. So punishment or consequences are not simply a possibility, but an inevitability.
This brings us to the issue of the human condition—all of us are sinners. We all have this sin condition and we cannot save ourselves or lift ourselves out of our sinfulness. The word sin is an archery term, and it literally means to “miss the mark.” In archery, if you shoot an arrow toward a target and miss, it is called a sin. It doesn’t matter whether it is by an inch or by a mile, it is still a sin. With that image in mind, take notice of how the Bible describes the human condition: “For everyone has sinned; we all fall short of God’s glorious standard” (Rom. 3:23 NLT). When it comes to living life the way God intended, all of us “miss the mark.” Some of us do better than others, but no one hits the bull’s-eye every time. And sin isn’t just about a failure to be perfect. Sin is about willful choices and conscious decisions that we make to knowingly go against God’s leadership. It is the choice we make with our very soul to go against the moral law and will of God. So whether it’s murder or malice, lust or lying, stealing or slander, it’s falling short. And we can’t change that. We can’t address this. We can’t fix it. We are totally unable to rescue ourselves from our sinful condition. Salvation by works is impossible. There’s nothing we can do to right ourselves before God.
The fourth background issue to understand is the Old Testament sacrificial system. In ancient times, God decreed that the payment for wrongdoing—for a sin—could be covered through the blood of an animal. Though our rebellion deserved death, God’s love allowed for our sin to be addressed through the sacrifice of an animal. That seems strange to us, but it was very intentional by God. He wanted people to see the severity of their sin. He wanted people to see that paying for the sin that comes between them and him is messy, gruesome, and costly, because sin is messy and gruesome and costly. And that it really was a life-or-death issue, so the symbol was a real one. The sacrifice was a substitute for the sinner; it bore the sinner’s guilt and is where we get our term scapegoat. I’m sure you’ve heard of making someone the scapegoat for something—blaming them or pinning something on them. The term comes from the Bible. There was an annual Day of Atonement when a priest made reparations for all the sins of the people. The scapegoat was the goat to which the sins of the Israelites were symbolically transferred on that Day of Atonement. For the sacrifice to be effective, there had to be some kind of connection, some point of commonality between the victim and the sinner for whom it was offered. People would lay their hands on the scapegoat, constituting a confession of guilt on the part of the sinner and a transfer of the guilt from the sinner to the victim.
God also said the animals sacrificed were to be without any kind of blemish or mark. The point was that sin (or imperfection) could only be addressed by perfection. Sin cannot reconcile sin. It can only be dealt with by God himself because the sin was against him and his law; therefore, only he can offer true forgiveness. The sacrificial system served as a sign of what God was going to do. It was offered to God, but it wasn’t something that would finally and ultimately bridge the gap between us and God. Which is why throughout that time, the great prophets of God said that there would be One who would come—from God—who would take away the sins of the world once and for all. The one sacrifice for all time.
At a point and time in history that God chose for reasons known only to him, God did just that. He provided the perfect, once-for-all sacrifice for the sins of all people throughout all of time and history.
And that brings us to Jesus.
Jesus was the fulfillment of the sacrificial system and, because of him, we can now be forgiven once and for all. The writer of the book of Hebrews in the New Testament likens Jesus to the high priest who went into the Temple on the Day of Atonement on behalf of the people to offer the sacrifice for their sins. Except that this time, instead of the blood of sheep or goats, Jesus offered his own blood. Or, as the man known as John the Baptist said upon seeing Jesus, “Look, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world” (John 1:29). This sacrifice is where we see God’s holiness intersecting with God’s love. This is where justice meets mercy. God cannot deal with sin except as his holiness allows it. If he did not punish it, or make adequate satisfaction for it, he would be forgiving it unjustly, which he cannot do. In other words, to simply forgive out of mercy or to redeem with a wave of the hand would cause him to cease to be God. His holiness demanded what sin demands—the just punishment, the death penalty.
So his love had him take our place.
This explains why Jesus, dying on the cross, cried out, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (Matt. 27:46). When you read that, it may sound as if he cried out to God the Father as if he had been abandoned. And to be sure, the word forsaken did literally mean “abandoned.” Jesus was saying, “Why have you left me? Why have you turned away? Why have you left me alone here, now?” Interestingly, in one of the few times in all the Bible, it records him saying this in Aramaic, his boyhood tongue—the most personal, intimate language he could use with his Father. So what was going on? Nothing less than the most terrible moment on the cross of all, worse than anything he had gone through physically. He who knew no sin became sin. Christians talk about Jesus dying for our sins. That he took our place. That he paid the price for our wrongdoing. What that means is the death of Jesus involved taking the sin of all of humanity upon himself. At the moment of his death, Jesus carried the weight of the sins of the world—past, present, and future. Every rape, every murder, every lie, every betrayal, every adulterous relationship, every act of child abuse. When he died he carried the evil of terrorism and genocide, the Nazi Holocaust, the brutality of ISIS. He shouldered the acts of Adolf Hitler, Charles Manson, Saddam Hussein, and Osama bin Laden . . . and me and you. In a single, blazing, soul-wrenching moment, the sins of the world were placed on him. And he carried their stain, their weight, their pain, their evil, their darkness.
He was the scapegoat.
As if there couldn’t be anything worse, at that moment, for the first and only time in all of eternity, the Father had to turn away from him. The community of the Trinity was shattered, and the Son was utterly, terribly, alone as the embodiment of sin itself. It was in the midst of that separation from the Father, that tearing of the Trinity, that impenetrable darkness of sin, that he surrendered his life in sacrifice. So why did he say, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” Was he really expressing hurt that God turned away?
No. He knew this moment would happen. Would it surprise you to find out that he was expressing love and loyalty, allegiance and trust? You see, what many don’t know is that Jesus was quoting a verse from the Old Testament of the Bible—specifically, from the twenty-second chapter in the book of Psalms. It may have been that Jesus’s intent was to quote all of it because as terrible as this moment was, it was clearly all a part of God’s plan. But he physically couldn’t complete the psalm—all he could get out was the first line. So what came next in the twenty-second Psalm? Why out of all of the Scriptures did Jesus quote this one on the cross? When you read Psalm 22 and think about who was saying it, in what condition and what situation, it is stunning:
My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?
Why are you so far from . . .
. . . my cries of anguish? . . .
Yet you are enthroned as the Holy One. . . .
But I am a worm and not a man,
scorned by everyone, despised by the people.
All who see me mock me;
they hurl insults. . . .
I am poured out like water,
and all my bones are out of joint.
My heart has turned to wax;
it has melted within me.
My mouth is dried up like a potsherd,
and my tongue sticks to the roof of my mouth;
you lay me in the dust of death.
Dogs surround me,
a pack of villains encircles me;
they pierce my hands and my feet.
All my bones are on display;
people stare and gloat over me.
They divide my clothes among them
and cast lots for my garment. . . .
I will declare your name to my people;
in the assembly I will praise you.
You who fear the LORD, praise him!
All you descendants of Jacob, honor him!
Revere him, all you descendants of Israel!
For he has not despised or scorned
the suffering of the afflicted one. . . .
All the ends of the earth
will remember and turn to the LORD,
and all the families of the nations
will bow down before him. . . .
Future generations will be told about the Lord.
They will proclaim his righteousness,
declaring to a people yet unborn:
He has done it! (Ps. 22:1, 3, 6–7, 14–18, 22–24, 27, 30–31)
By the way, if you’ve ever wondered why Good Friday—the day commemorating the death of Jesus—is called “good,” it is because of this moment on the cross. Sin is not good. Death is not good. But what he did for us in our sin, through his death, was good.
So this brings us to grace. The best and simplest definition of grace is that which is freely given and totally undeserved. It’s getting what you don’t deserve and not getting what you do. Grace reaches out, in the midst of our sin, and offers forgiveness. Second chances. Yes, salvation. To have what Christ did on the cross applied to your life.
So What Is Grace?
Don’t let this drift gently over your imagination. It is too pronounced, too substantive, for that. Let’s say you’re behind on your mortgage by three, maybe even four payments. You owe thousands and can’t possibly make it up. The bank has started foreclosure proceedings and there’s nothing you can do. Then, somebody with the power to forgive that debt—to step in and have the bank wipe it clean—does so. You are ecstatic! You couldn’t be more grateful. But why is that? It’s because you knew the situation you were in. You knew what was going to happen. You knew you were going to lose your house.
Apart from grace, each of us is going to lose our life. We’re going to face the full penalty for our sin. Our only hope is for a grace-filled, grace-giving God. I usually describe the situation to people this way, because when it was first described to me along these lines, it connected with me. Imagine you are brought to trial for vehicular homicide. You were driving on the road, exceeding the speed limit, and you hit a child on her way home from school. You are brought to trial, the evidence is presented, and from his bench the judge states, “I find you guilty and sentence you to death.” But then he does a strange thing. With compassion in his eyes, he gets up from behind his bench, takes off his robe, walks down to where you stand, embraces you, and says, “But I love you. The penalty must be carried out, for I am an honest and good judge, and what you did was wrong and it must be paid for. But I love you and do not want to see your life end this way. Justice must be carried out. So I will go in your place.” And then he walks out of the courtroom and toward the electric chair.
That’s what Jesus did for you. This is how it’s talked about in the Bible:
We can understand someone dying for a person worth dying for, and we can understand how someone good and noble could inspire us to selfless sacrifice. But God put his love on the line for us by offering his Son in sacrificial death while we were of no use whatever to him. (Rom. 5:7–8 Message)
So what does that grace look like? Feel like? Let’s look at one of the more well-known stories surrounding the life of Jesus:
The teachers of the law and the Pharisees brought in a woman caught in adultery. They made her stand before the group and said to Jesus, “Teacher, this woman was caught in the act of adultery. In the Law Moses commanded us to stone such women. Now what do you say?” . . .
He straightened up and said to them, “Let any one of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.” . . .
At this, those who heard began to go away one at a time . . . until only Jesus was left, with the woman still standing there. Jesus . . . asked her, “Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?”
“No one, sir,” she said.
“Then neither do I condemn you,” Jesus declared. “Go now and leave your life of sin.” (John 8:3–5, 7, 9–11)
That is a story of grace. It is first, though, a story of sin and corruption and decadence and judgment. And then it is a story of grace. So let’s not miss the dark side, or we won’t see how amazing grace really is. There was a lot of darkness. First, we have the sin of the people who brought this woman to Jesus. They didn’t have to bring her to Jesus, heaping shame and ridicule on her in front of everyone. They didn’t care anything about her. They didn’t care if she was beaten or stoned, exposed or humiliated. She was nothing to them. They were cruel and unfeeling. They didn’t even bother bringing the man she was caught with because they didn’t really care about the act at all. They just wanted to trap Jesus. And here was the trap: if Jesus said, “Yes, stone her,” then he would have gotten in trouble with the Roman government in power at that time, because only they had the authority to exercise capital punishment. He would have also lost his reputation among the people as being a “friend of sinners.” But if Jesus said, “Don’t stone her,” then he would have been accused of being light on sin, compromising, and weak—someone who didn’t really embrace God’s law and holiness. They felt that either way, they had him on this. The woman was just a pawn. So there was the conniving, heartless, manipulative sin of the people who brought her before Jesus.
Then there was the sin of the people who caught her in the act. The Bible is very clear that she was, indeed, caught in the act. That language is important because it was the basis by which they were making their legal claim. It meant they had the evidence needed to convict her. In that day, so that suspicious husbands couldn’t accuse their wives without reason, the law required testimony from two witnesses who saw the couple together. And not just together, but lying together and clearly having sex. The two witnesses also had to see this at the same time and place. That’s a high bar of evidence. So how could you reach that bar? Pretty much only one way: you had to set the couple up. The law also said that if you were to see someone about to sin in that way, it was your responsibility as a caring and compassionate person to say something to them to try to prevent it, which obviously didn’t happen. So the witnesses and whoever else was involved in setting her up for the witnesses sinned.
Then you have the sin of the man who was having sex with her. If they were caught in the act, then he was obviously guilty too. But they let him go—he wasn’t needed for the trap (but he certainly was part of the darkness).
Finally, we have the sin of the woman herself. And she did sin. Badly. Not just because she had sex with someone she shouldn’t have, and was caught in the act, but since the penalty being asked for was stoning, that tells us she was probably engaged to be married and was having sex with someone who was not her fiancé. That was the specified penalty for an engaged person who was unfaithful to their fiancé. Unfaithful wives could also be sentenced to death, but the law did not specify how they should die. Here they say she had to be stoned, which tells us she was engaged and sleeping with someone who wasn’t her fiancé. That’s a nasty betrayal of trust and speaks volumes about not only her outer world, but her inner one as well.
So who deserved to be stoned? Who deserved to die? Who had engaged in heinous, premeditated, purposeful pursuit of sinful behavior before a holy God, holding him in contempt with their behavior?
All of them.
Just like all of us.
So what happened next? Jesus’s words to those who brought the woman have become legendary, almost iconic: “Let any one of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her” (John 8:7). Given the darkness of every party involved, we know that no one could throw a stone, because no one was innocent. Then Jesus said that he would not condemn her either. Why?
Jesus didn’t see a woman caught in adultery.
He didn’t see her just through the lens of her sin.
He saw her through the eyes of grace.
Everyone but Jesus saw a woman caught in adultery. A moral failure. Someone deserving of condemnation and death. But through the extension of grace, Jesus saw a precious child of God. Someone who was a struggler in life and who had made many, many mistakes, just like everyone else. He also saw someone who could get past the struggles and grow toward the person God intended. Just like he sees in me . . . and, if I can be so bold, just like he sees in you. God’s grace is rooted in wild, radical love for us. A love so wild and radical it was sacrificial. Even unto death. Will Campbell, known for his disarmingly earthy approach to spirituality and life, was once asked a critical question: “In ten words or less, what’s the Christian message? . . . Let me have it. Ten words.” The answer became suddenly clear.
“We’re all bastards but God loves us anyway.”
In his book The Ragamuffin Gospel, Brennan Manning writes,
When I get honest, I admit I am a bundle of paradoxes. I believe and I doubt, I hope and I get discouraged, I love and I hate, I feel bad about feeling good, I feel guilty about not feeling guilty. I am trusting and suspicious. I am honest and I still play games. Aristotle said I am a rational animal; I say I am an angel with an incredible capacity for beer.
That’s me. Is it you? But here’s where grace steps in. God knows who you are too. Manning continues:
If Jesus appeared at your dining room table tonight with knowledge of everything you are and are not, total comprehension of your life story and every skeleton hidden in your closet; if He laid out the real state of your present discipleship with the hidden agenda, the mixed motives, and the dark desires buried in your psyche, you would feel His acceptance and forgiveness.
That isn’t all there was to the story of the woman caught in adultery and brought before Jesus. And it’s because grace isn’t all there was to his message. It was a message with grace and truth. This was the defining mark of Jesus’s message. As his biographer and (likely) cousin John wrote, Jesus came “full of grace and truth” (John 1:14). So, after saying he would not condemn her he added these words: “Go now and leave your life of sin” (8:11). In essence: “Turn from the life that led you to this moment, because you are not innocent. Turn from it; see it for what it is. You have been rescued from the penalty of your sin; live like it. You’re better than this.”
To get the message of Jesus, to get grace right, you have to understand that it’s not just about grace. It’s about grace and truth. They are inextricably intertwined. Jesus accepted her as someone who mattered to him, but never did he affirm the life she had been living. Jesus didn’t condemn her for what she did, but he didn’t condone what she did either. Personal acceptance was never combined with lifestyle affirmation. Grace and truth went together. Which means Jesus comes to our defense when we’re about to get stoned, but he’s also the first one to tell us to stop sleeping around. Or stop anything else that is not God’s plan for doing life optimally. As psychologist Henry Cloud has written, grace is accepting relationship. Truth is what is real; it describes how things really are. Truth without grace is just judgment. But grace without truth is just deception. Grace is like a Band-Aid—it’s meant to be applied to something. And ideally grace is applied to a desire for life change and from that, to sin. Almost every story Jesus told dripped with this one message: if you are far from God, you can come home. And when you do, you’ll be met with grace and then challenged with the truth we all so desperately need.
There was a young girl who grew up on a cherry orchard just outside of Traverse City, Michigan. Her parents, who were a bit old-fashioned, tended to overreact to her nose rings, music, and short skirts. They grounded her a few times, and then one night, when her father knocked on her door after an argument to try to reach out to her, she screamed out, “I hate you!” Later that night, she ran away.
She headed for Detroit, a place she had been only once before on a bus trip with her church youth group to watch the Tigers play. Since the papers were filled with lurid details about the gangs, the drugs, and the violence in downtown Detroit, she thought that would be the last place her parents would look for her.
On her second day in the city, she met a man who drove the biggest car she had ever seen. He offered her a ride, bought her lunch, and arranged for her to have a place to stay. He was just so nice. He even gave her some pills to make her feel better than she’d ever felt before. She thought that she had been right all along—her parents had been keeping her from all the fun and from the good life.
That good life went along for a month . . . two months . . . a year. The man with the big car taught her a few things that men like. And since she was underage, men paid a premium for her. Every now and then she thought about her parents back home, but their lives now seemed so boring and plain and old-fashioned that she could hardly believe she grew up there. She had a brief scare when she saw her picture on a billboard with the headline “Have you seen this child?” But now she had blonde hair and, with all the makeup and jewelry she wore, nobody would mistake her for a child.
After a year, the first signs of the illness began to appear. It amazed her how fast her boss turned mean. He told her that he couldn’t risk having anyone around who was sick like that, and he threw her out on the street without a penny to her name.
She found that she was able to turn a couple of tricks a night, but they didn’t pay much, and all the money went to support her drug habit. When winter came, she found herself sleeping on metal grates outside the large downtown department stores. Sleeping is the wrong word, though. A teenage girl at night in downtown Detroit can never relax her guard. Soon dark bands circled her eyes and her cough worsened.
One night, as she lay awake listening for footsteps that might harm her, everything about her life suddenly looked different. She felt, for the first time in a year, like the little girl that she was, lost in a cold and frightening city. She began to cry. Her pockets were empty and she was hungry. She needed a fix. She pulled her legs underneath her and shivered under the newspapers she’d piled on top of her coat trying to stay warm. Suddenly a memory came into her mind of May and springtime in her hometown, with a million cherry trees in bloom and her golden retriever chasing a tennis ball. And she said to herself, “Oh God, why did I leave?” And she started to cry again and knew that more than anything else in the world she wanted to go home. So she tried to call her parents.
Three straight calls, three straight connections to voicemail.
But on the third one, she finally left a message. “Dad, Mom, it’s me. I was wondering about maybe coming home. I’m catching a bus up your way, and it’ll get there about midnight tomorrow. If you’re not there, I get it. I guess I’ll just stay on the bus.”
It took about seven hours for a bus to make all the stops between Detroit and her home, and during that time all she could think about were the flaws in her plan. What if they were out of town and didn’t get the message? What if they were home, but she didn’t give them enough time to be at the bus station? What if they didn’t even want her back?
Then she began to rehearse what she would say:
“Dad, I’m so sorry. I know I was wrong. It’s not your fault—it’s all mine. Dad, can you forgive me?” She said the words over and over, practicing.
When the bus finally rolled into the station, the driver said, “Traverse City, Michigan. Fifteen-minute stop.” Fifteen minutes for her entire life to be decided. She checked herself in a compact mirror, smoothed her hair, licked the lipstick off her teeth. She looked at the tobacco stains on her fingertips and wondered if her parents would notice. If they were even there.
The Return of the Prodigal Son, painted by Rembrandt c. 1669 [Wikimedia Commons]
She got off the bus and walked into the terminal, not knowing what to expect. But not one of a thousand scenes that entered her mind matched what she saw. Because there, within those concrete walls and plastic chairs in that bus terminal, stood a group of forty brothers and sisters, great-aunts and uncles and cousins, a grandmother and even a great-grandmother. They were all wearing goofy party hats and blowing noisemakers, and taped across the entire wall of the terminal was a banner that read, “Welcome home!”
Then out of the crowd stepped her dad. Through tears, she started to say, “Dad, I’m sorry. I know . . .” And he stopped her. “Hush, child. We’ve got no time for that. You’ll be late for the party. A banquet’s waiting for you at home.”
That story is a retelling of a story Jesus told, a story often referred to as the story of the prodigal son. A story that, in one form or another, he told over and over again. A story of someone who turned away from God, found out that it wasn’t the life they wanted, came back . . . and found out they could.
But Can There Really Be Just One Way?
You walk into a Starbucks, and you order a tall, half-caf soy latte at 120 degrees. Or a triple, venti, half-sweet, nonfat caramel macchiato. Or a grande, quad, nonfat, one-pump, no-whip mocha. Or if you’re me, you just say, “Caffeine, please!” According to Starbucks’ Global Chief Marketing Officer, there are now more than 80,000 different ways you can order a Starbucks coffee. When John Naisbitt wrote his prescient book Megatrends back in the ’80s, he said that one of the top ten trends of the modern world would be a shift from no choice to multiple choices. And he was right. We’ve come to expect it. It’s just the way things are.
But what about God? Can’t grace and truth be found in other places? Isn’t there more than just one way to come home? When it comes to an authoritative spiritual text, there’s the Bible, the Bhagavad Gita, the Koran, and the Book of Mormon. When it comes to religious leaders, you can select from Krishna, Buddha, and Mohammed. When it comes to religious groups, you can link up with those in Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, or Scientology. No wonder it’s almost natural to believe that searching for God is like climbing a mountain. Since everyone knows that there is not just one way to climb a mountain—mountains are way too big for that—there must be any number of paths that can be taken. We tend to look at all of the ideas about God throughout all the religions of the world as just different ways up the mountain. So where does that leave you? You’re free to choose! Take your pick from among the countless philosophies and worldviews littering the cultural landscape. Why? Because all roads lead to God. All spiritual paths are equally legitimate. It doesn’t really matter what you believe, much less who, what, or how you worship.
The only problem is that there’s one faith that isn’t playing well in this sandbox, and it happens to be the Christian faith. Jesus spoke directly to this idea and had some provocative words to say: “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6). In that statement, Jesus makes it clear that there is a Father God and that there’s only one way to that Father God—through him. And he was very careful with his language in that verse. Jesus didn’t say that he was a way, or a truth, but the way, the truth, and the life. And that no one—no one—can enter into a full relationship with God apart from him. That was as politically incorrect then as it is now, but it has marked Christianity from its beginning. “It is by the name of Jesus Christ,” the apostle and early Christian leader Peter declared; “salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name given under heaven by which we must be saved” (Acts 4:10, 12 TNIV).
For a lot of people, that just makes them cringe. You may be among them. The idea that Christianity, and specifically Jesus, is the only way to God is so out of sync with the way we think. Beginning with its dismissal of other ways to God. That seems too . . . well . . . dismissive. Is Christianity saying that every other religion is just completely wrong? Actually, no. C. S. Lewis once wrote, “If you are a Christian you do not have to believe that all the other religions are simply wrong all through. . . . If you are a Christian, you are free to think that all these religions, even the queerest ones, might contain at least some hint of the truth.” Lewis goes on to suggest we think of it in terms of arithmetic. There is one and only one right answer to 2 + 2—and that’s 4—but if you were to answer 6 it would be a lot closer than answering 37. While there is only one right answer, some answers are closer to being right than others.
A photo of Tian Tan Buddha, also known as “Big Buddha,” on Lantau Island, Hong Kong [Wikimedia Commons]
That’s not all. If all truth is God’s truth, then it remains truth wherever we find it. So as a Christian, I can appreciate the truth in much of Buddhism’s ideas, such as the first two of the Four Noble Truths that state there is a lot of suffering in the world (obviously), and that our desires are often at the root of that suffering. Buddhism also teaches many things that I can appreciate and affirm as clearly moral: you shouldn’t engage in murder, you shouldn’t steal, you shouldn’t engage in immoral sexual behavior, and you shouldn’t lie.
But just because there may be goodness and truth in other places doesn’t mean you have also found an equally legitimate way to God. In fact, the full teaching of that religion may involve a road that is heading in the totally opposite direction. Let’s stick with the example of Buddhism. While there is some common ground between Buddhism and Christianity, there are also enormous tension points. The Dalai Lama himself has stated publicly that the central doctrines of Buddhism and Christianity are not compatible. He has been quite open with the fact that you cannot be a Buddhist Christian, or a Christian Buddhist. And he is right. Christianity believes in a personal God; Buddhism does not even believe in a Higher Being (Buddhism is, essentially, an atheistic religion). That is a divide that is simply insurmountable. That’s not two different ways up the same mountain; those are different places on the map.
This is true when you compare Christianity to the other major world religions as well: Christians believe there’s one God; Hindus believe there are millions. Christians embrace Jesus as God himself in human form; Muslims don’t even rank Jesus at the top of the prophets, much less the Savior of the world. When you have divisions like this, you have only two options. You can either say that somebody is right in that particular area and everybody else is wrong, or you can say that everyone is wrong. What you can’t say is that everyone is right—that it’s all the same path, the same idea, the same God. That would be intellectually confused at best and intellectually dishonest at worst. And the areas of disagreement are not trivial in nature. They deal with the very existence of God and, if he does exist, how we enter into a relationship with this God (not to mention the identity of a person like Jesus).
Right about now you may be thinking, Okay, let me add this up. You’re saying that there is just one way to God and it’s through Jesus. And while there may be some truth or good in other religions, that doesn’t mean they are equally valid ways to God. So . . . are you saying that all non-Christian people just wind up in hell? That someone really good, really noble, like Gandhi, is in hell just because he wasn’t a Christian? Because if you are, you’ve lost me. I just can’t believe that’s right. Fair enough. But now let me see if I can add up what you’re saying: all that should matter, in the end, is how good you are. Everyone should be banking on some kind of “goodness quotient.” And since we define goodness in relation to other people, what you’re saying is God should grade on a cosmic curve. And if God doesn’t grade on a curve, you’re not sure you can believe in that God.
Just for fun, let’s remember what grading on a curve is about. It’s when grading is relative. On any given assignment, your grade is based on the performance of the class as a whole. So if everybody does poorly but you make a 75 percent, and that 75 percent is the highest grade in the class, instead of a C suddenly you’ve got an A. Because on a curve, the highest grade, no matter how bad it is, is given the equivalent of a 100 percent—an A. Even though you made a 75 percent, because you did better than everybody else, you get an A. It gets better. Whatever the average grade is becomes the average grade. So if the average is 40, instead of an F, that’s a C.
We like getting graded on a curve. Particularly because we come out looking better, feeling better, and doing better than we deserve. So what might that look like if we were to apply that to spiritual things?
The 2 percent on either side is easy. On the Sinner side are the Hitlers, the bin Ladens, the rapists and pedophiles, telemarketers, and spam senders. We know who’s over there. On the Saint side is Mother Teresa or Gandhi. So those are your F and A grades. Now let’s talk about the Ds. These are the people who are, at best, Sketchy. They aren’t the darkest of the dark, but they are far from Boy Scouts. These are people who lie, cheat, steal. So here we’re talking car salesmen and members of Congress. Before you think that’s a joke, according to a Gallup poll, those really are the two least trusted professions in the United States.
Now for the 14 percent with the B grades. These are the people who are above average in their goodness. They set the day-in, day-out standard for most of us in terms of virtue or spiritual commitment. They are our role models and heroes. They are our celebrities, our Stars. Medical missionaries, like those who risked their lives serving Ebola patients. Christian leaders like the late Billy Graham. Throw in a few pastors and social workers.
So where does that leave most people within the typical bell curve? Those in the C-, C, and C+ range? Which, in our “grading on a curve” minds, means Safe? Not saints, but not sinners. Not a star, but not sketchy either. In other words, me and you. So we’re okay. We’re safe. Any other scale makes us nervous and insecure, so we reject it.
But what if that’s not how God grades? What if the bell curve is all wrong and we’re not graded on a curve at all? What if the whole thing doesn’t even involve a letter grade? What if it is . . . pass/fail?
You’re in or you’re out. You’re through or you’re gone. You say, “Well, I don’t know if I like that.” Well, I don’t imagine that any of us do. It’s scary stuff to think about. But in full transparency, let me give you a headline: that’s what the Bible teaches. The Bible only talks about pass/fail; it doesn’t mention anything about a curve. And here’s where it gets even worse: we aren’t even graded based on a graduated scale at all, but on a person. And that person is God himself. In other words, everything on this pass/fail scale has to do with whether you are as good as God.
So what’s going on? The truth is that none of us are okay—not even one. None of us are “good” enough to earn salvation. As Joseph de Maistre once observed, “I do not know what the heart of the rascal may be; I know what is in the heart of an honest man; it is horrible.” No one is in less of a broken relationship with God, and in less need of the way to God, than anyone else. And that’s the real issue: how to be made right with God. Every human being is in a broken relationship with God through the sin in their life. The only way to repair that relationship is to become reconciled with God himself. The God of the Bible has said that there is one and only one way for that to happen—one and only one way to have your sins against him forgiven. The way he provided, which is through what Jesus did on the cross. Jesus’s death on the cross was the payment for our sins. The only payment that was ever made.
And that’s what makes Jesus the only way.
Now, as I’ve already acknowledged, there are many visceral reactions against this idea, not the least of which has to do with sincerity. That it isn’t what you believe that matters, but how you believe. Something deep inside of us knows, and I think correctly, that the nature of true spirituality is somehow connected with authenticity. This is why people like Mother Teresa and Nelson Mandela—both Christians—were so widely respected by Christians and non-Christians alike. But it is one thing to value sincerity and another to make sincerity the lone characteristic of spiritual truth, much less spiritual standing. How you believe matters, but so does what you believe. If you say that it doesn’t matter what you believe as long as you are sincere, you miss a very important point. You can be sincerely wrong. I can sincerely believe that when I reach into my medicine cabinet at 3:00 a.m. with a headache that I am taking an aspirin, but if I am really taking cyanide my sincerity will not save me from the perils of the poison I’ve ingested into my system. If I put carbolic acid into my eyes instead of contact lens solution, no matter how sincerely I believe I’ve grabbed the right bottle, I will still do damage to my vision. During World War II, Adolf Hitler sincerely believed that the slaughter of six million Jews was justified, but he was sincerely wrong. Sincerity matters, but it cannot be all that matters, because sincerity alone cannot alter physical, much less moral, reality. So it is not simply the sincerity of our faith that matters, but the object of our faith. Faith is very much like a rope—it matters what you tie it to.
Another visceral concern has to do with spiritual hubris, the idea that no religion should think it is better than another religion. Yes, you might believe you adhere to the truth, but that would be arrogant to assume, so the best thing to do is to function like an agnostic. And by all means, don’t try to convince others of your convictions. But is it really arrogant to tell others about what you believe is true, or is it compassion?
Photo of Penn Jillette at the Rio Hotel in Las Vegas [Wikimedia Commons; Photo Credit: David R. Tribble]
Penn Jillette is the “talkative” half of Penn and Teller, the Las Vegas comedy-illusion team. Penn has been an outspoken atheist. But Christians can learn a lot from a video blog he posted on his personal website that talks about a man who gave him a Bible:
At the end of the show as I’ve mentioned before, we go out and we talk to folks, you know, sign an occasional autograph and shake hands and so on. And there was one guy waiting over to the side in the, uh, what I call the “hover position” after it was all done. . . . He had been the guy who picks the joke during our psychic comedian section of the show. So he had the props from that in his hand because we give those away—the joke book, the envelope, and the paper, and stuff. . . .
And he walked over to me and he said, “I was here last night at the show, and I saw the show and I liked the show. . . .” He was very complimentary about my use of language and complimentary about honesty and stuff. He said nice stuff, no need to go into it, he said nice stuff.
And then he said, “I brought this for you,” and he handed me a Gideon pocket edition. I thought it said from the New Testament but also, Psalms is from the New Testament, right? Little book. . . . And he said, “I wrote in the front of it and I wanted you to have this. I’m kind of proselytizing.” And then he said, “I’m a businessman. I’m sane, I’m not crazy.” And he looked me right in the eye and did all of this. And it was really wonderful.
I believe he knew that I was an atheist. But he was not defensive. And he looked me right in the eyes. And he was truly complimentary . . . it didn’t seem like empty flattery. He was really kind and nice and sane and looked me in the eyes and talked to me and then gave me this Bible. And I’ve always said, you know, that I don’t respect people who don’t proselytize. I don’t respect that at all. If you believe that there’s a heaven and hell and that people could be going to hell or not getting eternal life or whatever, and you think that, well, it’s not really worth telling them this because it would make it socially awkward. . . . How much do you have to hate somebody to not proselytize? How much do you have to hate somebody to believe that everlasting life is possible and not tell them that?
I mean, if I believed beyond a shadow of a doubt that a truck was coming at you and you didn’t believe it, but that truck was bearing down on you, there’s a certain point where I tackle you. And this is more important than that. And I’ve always thought that and I’ve written about that and I’ve thought of it conceptually.
This guy was a really good guy. He was polite, and honest, and sane and he cared enough about me to proselytize and give me a Bible. Which had written in it a little note to me . . . just like, liked your show and so on. And then like five phone numbers for him and an email address if I wanted to get in touch. Now, I know there’s no God. And one polite person living his life right doesn’t change that. But I’ll tell ya, he was a very, very, very good man. And that’s real important. And with that kind of goodness it’s okay to have that deep of a disagreement. I still think that religion does a lot of bad stuff. But man, that was a good man who gave me that book. That’s all I wanted to say.
That line rings so true: If I believe where you stand with Christ will determine your entire eternal trajectory, how much would I have to hate you to not make my convictions known? Ultimately, the question is whether we believe that truth even exists. Historically, the most common idea of truth is the correspondence between our ideas or perceptions and reality. That’s why it’s called the “correspondence theory of truth.” If I make the statement, “It is raining,” it is only true if I look outside and find that it is raining. What is true is that which actually is. The belief in more than one way to God is really a belief that truth does not exist or, even more to the point, that truth doesn’t matter. But it does. Even a skeptic as noteworthy as Sigmund Freud maintained that if “it were really a matter of indifference what we believed, then we might just as well build our bridges of cardboard as of stone, or inject a tenth of a gramme of morphia into a patient instead of a hundredth, or take tear-gas as a narcotic instead of ether.”
Let’s get back to the Gandhi question. If Christianity is the only way, then does that mean that God is going to send everyone else to hell? Before we address that directly, in light of the “grading on a curve” dynamic, it’s important to understand that the Bible teaches that it isn’t God’s desire that anyone should experience hell as a punishment for their broken relationship with him, but that everyone would receive the gift of eternal life in heaven through Christ. But since God didn’t make us mindless robots, we have a free choice to accept that gift or reject that gift, and there are consequences that come with our freedom to choose or else the choice would be meaningless. Ready for the big reveal? God doesn’t send anyone to hell. We choose our own destination of our own free will. This is how the Bible puts it: “Whoever believes in him [Jesus] is not condemned, but whoever does not believe stands condemned already because they have not believed. . . . This is the verdict: Light has come into the world, but men loved darkness instead” (John 3:18–19). And it’s the same with the person who has chosen to embrace the Christian faith. The judgment of God will simply affirm the decision that has already been made. This is how Jesus phrased it: “Very truly I tell you, whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life and will not be judged but has crossed over from death to life” (John 5:24).
So when someone asks, “How can a loving God send someone to hell?” the answer often surprises: “He doesn’t. We send ourselves.” Think of it this way. Imagine you are out at sea and your boat begins to sink. You are clinging to a life raft in the middle of the ocean. A boat finds you and comes to you and offers to pull you to safety from your raft. You can either let yourself be saved or allow yourself to die. If you refuse their help, they aren’t sending you to a death at sea. You are sending yourself.
Mahatma Gandhi in Delhi, India, 1946 [Wikimedia Commons]
Hell exists because of our decisions and we send ourselves. The life and death of Jesus was about what God was willing to do to save people from the consequences of those decisions. But we have to take him up on the offer. If not, then yes, hell is inevitable. So is Gandhi in hell? The most direct answer is that Gandhi is where Gandhi chose to be. And that’s how the final judgment will work. God will do the right and just thing by everyone. He will make the just judgment. Whatever the verdict is on anyone’s life, it will be right and good. We will go where we decided, to the last dying breath of our life, to go. As C. S. Lewis once observed, we can bend a knee toward God in this life and say, “Thy will be done.” Or, at the end of our life, force God to say to us, “Thy will be done.”
Now, some might push back and say, “But why is there even a hell? That doesn’t sound like a loving God. Why would a loving God have something like hell in existence?”
I totally disagree.
The existence of heaven and hell shows that this is a moral universe, that God is a moral God, and that there is truth and justice and righteousness. Do you really want a spiritual universe, a moral order, without hell? Without punishment? Where Hitler and bin Laden are as rewarded as Mother Teresa? Do you want a cosmic order where pedophiles are praised and rapists are celebrated? Where nothing is seen as sin? A God that just kind of chuckles at it all in some kind of stupid senility? Is that what you think is good and right? I get that hell is disturbing to you. It should be disturbing to you. It’s disturbing to me. Deeply disturbing. It should be a hard-edged truth. But it’s a truth. A necessary truth. There wouldn’t be a moral universe without it. Hell is a terrible, dreadful, horrific place, but its existence isn’t what is evil. Its existence is what is moral.
With that in mind, you might be wondering about those who have never heard about Jesus or who don’t have the mental ability to understand. This is a heartbreaking question because you might have in mind infants or very young children who may have died before having any ability to know or to “hear” about Jesus, much less to respond. Or, perhaps, people with special needs or cognitive challenges that make truly understanding and embracing all of this nearly impossible. As tragic and heartbreaking as the question is, the answer is very simple: ultimately, this is answered in and through the very character of God. What I mean by that is either God is a good God, a just God, a fair God . . . or he’s not. If he is, then he’ll do the right thing by everyone, based on their ability to hear and understand and respond. So when someone asks if their baby who died is in heaven, I can say, “That is the one thing that you don’t need to be worrying about in this moment. Your child is being cradled, right now, in the arms of God. Absolutely they are in heaven.” Why can I say that?
And what about those people in parts of the world who have never even heard about Jesus? Someone who was never told about Jesus? That’s a little different. They are still held accountable based on the knowledge available to them through what can be seen through what has been made. Here’s how it’s talked about in the Bible:
But God shows his anger from heaven against all sinful, wicked people who suppress the truth by their wickedness. They know the truth about God because he has made it obvious to them. For ever since the world was created, people have seen the earth and sky. Through everything God made, they can clearly see his invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature. So they have no excuse for not knowing God.
Yes, they knew God, but they wouldn’t worship him as God or even give him thanks. And they began to think up foolish ideas of what God was like. As a result, their minds became dark and confused. Claiming to be wise, they instead became utter fools. And instead of worshiping the glorious, ever-living God, they worshiped idols made to look like mere people and birds and animals and reptiles. (Rom. 1:18–23 NLT)
Each of us is held accountable by the raw wonder of creation all around us that is so intricate in its design that it begs for the notion of a Creator God. So how could this work positively in someone’s life? Imagine in the darkest recesses of a rainforest, a man is walking along one day and comes upon a tree stump that has died and is rotting. He walks over to it and sees that it’s filled with water. He gazes at his reflection for a few moments and he thinks, You know . . . I didn’t make me. And that totem carving we’ve been worshiping and praying to has never done anything for me. It just seems to be nothing more than any other dead tree. And then he gazes at the sky and the stars and says, “Whoever you are, whatever you are, help! I want to know . . . you.”
Of course.
As C. S. Lewis remarked, “We do know that no man can be saved except through Christ; we do not know that only those who know him can be saved through him.” This does not mean that people will be saved by Christ through the channel of other religions, but simply that all persons will be judged fairly by God on the basis of their knowledge of Christ and their ability to respond to that knowledge. So while Christians believe that choices have consequences, and hell is real, no one has to go there. The way, the truth, and the life is available to us all.
