2. But What Kind of God?
2
But What Kind of God?
“What is . . . God?”
I asked the earth and it answered:
“I am not He”;
and all things that are in the earth
made the same confession.
Augustine, Confessions, Book X
I once heard of a little girl who was drawing a picture at school. Her teacher came over and asked her what she was drawing.
“I’m drawing a picture of God.”
Her teacher said, “Honey, you know, nobody really knows what God looks like.”
And the little girl said, “Well, they will when I get through!”
Whether you accept or reject the existence of God, most of us have a picture of that God that we have drawn in our minds, usually based on a series of ideas, feelings, and past experiences from our life. Christianity presents a picture of God that is both unique and compelling, but it may be a picture that is very different from the one you’ve drawn, even if you think you’ve been drawing the Christian one. George Buttrick, former chaplain at Harvard, recalled how students would come into his office and say, “I don’t believe in God.” Buttrick would then reply, “Sit down and tell me what kind of God you don’t believe in. I probably don’t believe in that God either.”
Now, there’s a lot the Christian faith holds about the Person of God: God is Spirit, not flesh and blood; God is personal, not an impersonal energy force; God is living, not a dead totem; God is infinite in terms of space, time, knowledge, and power; God is constant, not in a state of flux. For many people, the real question is not about the Person of God, but his nature. Is this God moral? Does he have integrity? Is he loving? Many aren’t so sure. In fact, most people who reject the idea of God don’t reject the possibility of his existence—they reject what they think they know about him. Particularly, what they think they know about him from the Bible. The reason for this is simple. Sometimes it can seem like the God of the Bible acts in ways we would never dream of acting ourselves. This makes it hard to believe that God—or what we think we know about that God—is right. Many people feel the God of the Bible is angry, mean, capricious, and a bit too quick to send people to hell. They don’t even like the idea of a God who would create a hell, much less send people there. And if he’s supposed to be so good and loving, then why is there so much suffering in the world and why has it gone on for so long? Why doesn’t God step in and stop it? To a lot of people, it seems like we need a better God than the one that we have—or at least a better God than the God of the Bible. I’ve heard people say in one way or another, “When I look at the world and how it’s being run, how it’s playing out . . . if I was God, I could do better.” As an atheist blogger once put it (in a post that has since been taken down), “If I was God, the following words and phrases would not exist . . .
War
Drugs
Disease
Hunger
Murder
Poverty
Rape
Oppression
Sorrow
Poor
Victim
Kill
Fight
Gun
Sadness
Genocide
Third World
Loneliness
Famine
Accident
Death
Jealousy
Weapon
Anger
Slavery
Atrocity
Apology
Homeless
Bomb
Old
Conflict
Abortion
Need
Hate
Molestation
Evil
Natural Disaster
Dictator
Sick
Greed
Steal
Cancer
Crime
Mental Illness
2
On Evil and Suffering
One of the most chilling places I have ever visited is the Dachau Concentration Camp just outside of Munich, Germany. It opened on March 22, 1933. It was the first of the German concentration camps, and the only one kept open throughout the Nazi era. It became a model for every other concentration camp—camps with names such as Auschwitz, Buchenwald, Bergen-Belsen, and Ravensbruck. Dachau did not close until liberated by American troops on April 29, 1945, so it had a twelve-year nightmarish run. By the end of its operation, more than 200,000 human beings from across Europe were robbed of their freedom, tortured, exploited, and—for tens of thousands—eventually killed on its grounds.
I recall finding myself in a part of the camp that was somewhat off the beaten path. I wandered over to a ditch and there was a placard hidden among the weeds that said the man-made ditch served as a stream to carry away the blood from all the people who were shot in the head. It is hard to even explain the emotion of seeing that and reading that sign unless you were standing there.
The gate at the entrance of the Dachau Concentration Camp with the phrase Arbeit Macht Frei (“Work will set you free”) [Wikimedia Commons]
The most spiritually persistent question people ask—across every world religion, every philosophy, every worldview—is, “Why is there evil and suffering in the world?” It’s the question that lingers and never goes away, and it’s the most troubling question for people spiritually, crying out to be answered. People cannot seem to wrap their heads around why evil and suffering exist in the world, and when this question is not answered it can become a huge stumbling block. This is not a question that the Christian faith alone must answer. If you reject Christianity because of the existence of suffering in the world, then you need to reject every philosophy, every worldview, every ideology, every religion. Because the reality of suffering is not just unique for Christianity to explain. I don’t care if you’re Buddhist, Muslim, Mormon, Scientologist, Hindu, or nothing at all—everyone must answer the question about why this is such a screwed-up world. Even atheists. It’s actually one of the biggest arguments against atheism. Atheists may not believe in God, but they believe in the inherent goodness of human beings and the inevitable upward progression of naturalistic evolution. Which means that human beings should be becoming increasingly good and noble, peaceful and humane, through the advances of education, politics, and technology. So in theory it should be a better world every day.
It’s not.
But there is a reason this question about evil and suffering is often laid solely at the feet of Christians. The Bible teaches that God is all-powerful, able to do anything he wants. Further, the Bible teaches that God is thoroughly good—not mean, capricious, or vindictive. Yet bad things happen. There is suffering in the world. And for many, many people, those dynamics just don’t mix. If God is good and all-powerful, he shouldn’t allow bad things to happen. Since they do happen, people then decide either God isn’t good or he isn’t all-powerful. Rabbi Harold Kushner, in his book When Bad Things Happen to Good People, embraced the idea that God cares but is powerless to do anything about it. Elie Wiesel, who suffered through the Holocaust, said of the God described by Kushner, “If that’s who God is, why doesn’t He resign and let someone more competent take his place?” This was the sentiment of C. S. Lewis who, after his wife died from cancer, wrote: “Not that I am (I think) in much danger of ceasing to believe in God. The real danger is of coming to believe such dreadful things about Him. The conclusion I dread is not, ‘So there’s no God after all,’ but ‘So this is what God’s really like. Deceive yourself no longer.’”
So let me try to give the answer the Christian faith gives to the question of suffering. You can compare it to any other answer you want. And it’s really more of a story than some sterile, textbook answer. A deeply relational story. But before I tell it, let me state the obvious: there is no answer that can be given that will satisfy the emotional pain of suffering. In the movie Shadowlands, Anthony Hopkins portrays C. S. Lewis, whose wife died soon after their marriage. In the movie, a minister tries to give Lewis a “God knows best” pat answer, causing Lewis to explode: “No! This is a mess. That’s all anyone can say—it’s just a mess!” For most of us, though, the search is not for an answer that will alleviate the pain as much as a reason for why the pain was ever allowed. So let me see if I can tell you that story.
In the Beginning
God made us in order to love us. We are tenderly crafted and designed, each as an individual, for the purpose of being related to, known, and deeply cherished. Yet this means we are also given the freedom to make choices with our life, to live as fully conscious, self-determining beings. Even to the point of whether we choose to respond to the Creator’s love. God did not choose to seduce us against our will. Instead, he determined to woo us, knowing that in so doing, we might very well spurn his love. But this is the only way to have the relationship be a relationship.
This is the dynamic at the heart of human existence. God could have made me love him, but if he had, his relationship with me—and mine with him—would be meaningless. God wants my relationship with him and with others to be real. So when he created me, he had to take the risk of setting me free. The great leader of Israel, Joshua, voiced some of the most famous words in Scripture when speaking of this amazing liberty in relation to his own life: “If serving the LORD seems undesirable to you, then choose for yourselves this day whom you will serve. . . . But as for me and my household, we will serve the LORD” (Josh. 24:15).
The first instance of this freedom to choose love was, as you might expect, made by the first humans, Adam and Eve. They were given one and only one instruction: “Don’t eat from this one tree.” The tree in the middle of the garden stood as the great authenticator that the love between the first humans and God was real. Then they chose to eat the fruit from that tree. They made the conscious, purposeful decision to go against the love, against the relationship. The Lover was spurned.
Photo of Adam and Eve by Raphael (1509–11), ceiling panel at the Apostolic Palace [Wikimedia Commons]
And then all hell broke loose.
The decision the first humans made to reject God’s leadership and ongoing intimacy within a relationship with him radically altered God’s original design for how the world would operate and how life would be lived. Theologians have termed this the fall, and talk about how we now live in a fallen world. We live in a world that is not the way God intended it to be. When Satan told Eve that if she ate the fruit from the tree God had forbidden them to eat from that she would not die, he lied. That became the day death and dying were born into the human race. Their choice forever stained the relationship of loving intimacy that had been intended for eternity within the Lover’s heart.
Langdon Gilkey observes that few of us find it easy to believe that one act of disobedience brought about a fall for the whole human race that is now continued in us by inheritance. Yet reflecting on his experience in a Japanese internment camp during World War II, where prisoners representing a cross-section of humanity were forced to participate in a living laboratory of community, Gilkey noted that the theological idea of a pervasive warping of our wills is the most accurate description of the reality of life. “What the doctrine of sin has said about man’s present state,” Gilkey concluded, “seemed to fit the facts as I found them.”
As it does for most.
In a scene from the movie Grand Canyon, an attorney tries to get around a traffic jam, but he gets lost in a series of back streets that take him farther and farther into parts of the town that are anything but the tony suburbs of his world. His expensive car stalls, and he uses his cell phone to call for a tow truck. While he waits, five young street toughs come up and circle his car and begin to threaten him. The tow truck arrives, and the driver begins to hook up the car, ignoring the five young men trying to steal it. They, in turn, threaten him. He then takes the leader aside and says, “Man, the world ain’t supposed to work like this. Maybe you don’t know that, but this ain’t the way it’s supposed to be. I’m supposed to be able to do my job without askin’ you if I can. And that dude is supposed to be able to wait with his car without you rippin’ him off. Everything’s supposed to be different than what it is here.”
He is right.
And the results of our collective choice to turn away from God run so deep that it isn’t just moral sin and evil that we face, but natural evil as well. The whole world is sick. In the Bible, we’re told that “the whole creation has been groaning” (Rom. 8:22). This is why we have earthquakes and tidal waves, volcanoes and mudslides, wildfires and birth defects, famine and AIDS. Our world is “The Groaning Planet,” writes Philip Yancey, an author who has invested much of his life in exploring issues like these. The pain and suffering and heartache is a huge cosmic “scream . . . that something is wrong . . . that the entire human condition is out of whack.” These are far from original insights, much less contemporary ones. The medieval Christian philosopher Boethius aptly noted that “evil is not so much an infliction as a deep set infection.” This raises a provocative point: God is not behind what is tragic with this world, much less responsible for it—people are. Or, as G. K. Chesterton once wrote to the editor in response to a request by the London Times for an essay on the topic, “What’s Wrong with the World,”
Dear Sir:
In response to your article, “What’s wrong with the world”—I am.
Yours truly,
G. K. Chesterton
Yancey, whom I mentioned earlier, was contacted by a television producer after the death of Princess Diana and asked to appear on a show to explain how God could have possibly allowed such a tragic accident. “Could it have had something to do with a drunk driver going 90 miles per hour in a narrow tunnel?” he asked the producer. “How, exactly, was God involved?” From this, Yancey reflected on the pervasive nature of the mindset that our actions are actually an indictment of God. For example, when boxer Ray “Boom Boom” Mancini killed a Korean boxer in a match, the athlete said in a press conference, “Sometimes I wonder why God does the things He does.” Or when, in a letter to a Christian family therapist, a young woman wrote how she became pregnant while dating a man and wanted to know why God allowed that to happen to her. Or when South Carolina mother Susan Smith gave her official confession to pushing her two sons into a lake to drown, she said that as she released the car she then went running after it as it sped down the ramp, screaming: “Oh God! Oh God, no! . . . Why did you let this happen!”
Yancey raises the decisive question by asking, “Exactly what role did God play in a boxer pummeling his opponent, a teenage couple losing control in a backseat, or a mother drowning her children?” God let us choose; we did, and our choices have brought continual pain and heartache and destruction. Our self-destructive bent seems to know no bounds. As historian Will Durant once wryly observed, “In the last 3,421 years of recorded history only 268 have seen no war.” On a more personal level, here’s how one psychologist described it: “We drink too much, or gamble compulsively, or allow pornography to control our minds. We drive too fast and work like there’s no tomorrow. We challenge the boss disrespectfully and then blow up when he strikes back. We spend money we don’t have and can’t possibly repay. We fuss and fight at home and create misery. . . . We toy with the dragon of infidelity. . . . Then when the ‘wages’ of those sins and foolishness come due, we turn our shocked faces up to heaven and cry, ‘Why me, Lord?’ In truth, we are suffering the natural consequences of dangerous behavior that is guaranteed to produce pain.”
Returning to the Dachau story: when my wife and I went to visit, we took a taxi from our hotel in Munich. We told our German driver where we wanted to go. He didn’t say anything for a long time; he just drove. Then, out of the blue, he said in his thick German accent, “Where you go, it is a very painful place.” Then he paused again and said, “When I was ten or eleven years old, my teacher took us here. She said, ‘We were responsible for two world wars—now we are responsible for freedom.’” Then he paused again and said, “Those were the right words to say, I think.”
And I think so too.
A Father’s Love
After reading all of that you may be tempted to say, “Well, if he knew how it was going to turn out, he should have never created us!” because everything from cancer to concentration camps doesn’t seem worth it. Yet when we blithely say such things, we betray how little we know of true love. Yes, God took a risk. Yes, the choice he gave each of us has resulted in pain and heartache and even tragedy. Yes, it would be tempting to say that it would have been easier on everyone—including God—never to have endured it. But that’s not the way love—real love, at least—works. To remember this, I need only reflect on one of the most defining realities of my life—my own role as a father. I have four children, all of whom are now grown with children of their own. I remember the season of parenting when I had to let go of each one. Seeing them get married, move to other cities, start their own lives and families. Each became free in ways they had never been free before to leave, to make choices on their own, and even to turn away from us if they so wished.
It wasn’t easy. Rebecca, my oldest, was obviously the first child I had to go through this with. I thought it was hard when she went off to her first birthday party and the birthday girl suddenly announced at the start of a game, “Everyone can play but Rebecca,” sending her home in tears.
I thought taking her to first grade, walking her to her desk, and then turning to leave her for an entire day for the first time—and then hearing how another child had purposefully tripped her on the playground—was hard.
I thought pulling out splinters or holding her through the night when she had a fever was hard.
I thought watching her experience the onset of puberty and the painful awkwardness and insecurity of becoming a teenager was hard.
I thought it was hard to send her off to college, where she could go her own way like never before, make her own decisions, choose her own paths and, in the process, wound and be wounded in ways that were unthinkable when I first held her in my arms.
But walking her down an aisle and putting her hand—the hand I had always held from the day she was born—into the hands of someone else . . .
Now that was hard.
Each stage involved granting love-filled freedom. But now our relationship is just that—a relationship, like never before. Without guarantees, without ties, without obligations. It can be scary. She calls, or she doesn’t. She texts, or she doesn’t. She visits, or she doesn’t. It’s a relationship. But as her father, as the one who loves her more than anyone, who would lay down his life for her instantly, let me tell you what has never entered my mind.
Never having her.
Never bringing her into the world.
Never going through life with her.
Even though she can reject me, hurt me, turn from me, and tear out my heart by hurting herself as well as others. If someone were to say, “Why did you ever bother?” my only reply would be, “You have obviously never been a father.” And as one who has stood by the side of countless other fathers who have endured far more pain and anguish than I have—suffering through prodigal years, chronic illnesses, and even death—I can attest to the solidarity that is held toward the sentiment. No matter the wound, no matter the cost, the worth and value of bringing our children into the world goes without question.
God’s desire to be in a relationship with us is why suffering cannot be reduced to mere injustice, much less punishment. As a Time magazine reporter attempting to understand Christianity’s unique perspective rightly noted, “It is a harrowing invitation to a higher dialogue.” That higher dialogue is love. When one loves, there is risk—risk of suffering, risk of loss, risk of rejection. But without this willingness to be wounded on the deepest of levels, there cannot exist authentic relationship on the deepest of levels. God’s great longing is to commune with us for eternity. As C. S. Lewis wrote in The Problem of Pain, “Try to exclude the possibility of suffering which the order of nature and the existence of free-wills involves, and you will find that you have excluded life itself.” God has refused to let the perils of authentic love prevent him from loving. As Lewis writes in The Four Loves,
To love at all is to be vulnerable. Love anything, and your heart will certainly be wrung and possibly be broken. If you want to make sure of keeping it intact, you must give your heart to no one, not even to an animal. Wrap it carefully round with hobbies and little luxuries; avoid all entanglements; lock it up safe in the casket or coffin of your selfishness. But in that casket—safe, dark, motionless, airless—it will change. It will not be broken; it will become unbreakable, impenetrable, irredeemable. . . . The only place outside Heaven where you can be perfectly safe from all the dangers . . . of love is Hell.
Hopefully now you can imagine why God chose to risk creating us out of a Father’s love for us, but what would our choice have been? Apart from rare and tragic cases of suicide, where emotional and psychological trauma drive a person to self-destruction, few truly wish for their lives to end. Glib statements such as “I wish I had never been born” are seldom meant. Even among the most wretched of conditions, we intuitively understand the priceless nature of life itself, clinging to it tenaciously and thanking God for every next breath. Which is why it’s equally glib to say, “Why doesn’t God just end it all now?” If God wiped out all evil, all wrongdoing, every person who committed harm against another, tonight, how many of us would live to see the dawn? I know I wouldn’t. You see, God could wipe out all evil, all suffering, this very night. But he doesn’t, and the reason he doesn’t is because of his love for people like you and me. Because if at midnight tonight God decreed that all evil would be stamped out in the universe, not one of us would be here at 12:01.
So Where Is God?
So where is God when it comes to the potential pain in my daughter’s life—the pain that might come her way and the pain that might flow back to me—because I chose to have her? The same place God is when it comes to all of the pain in this world: right by our side, caring for us, weeping with us, and longing to hold us in his arms.
Philip Yancey once wrote about a pastor friend of his who was in conflict with his fifteen-year-old daughter. He knew she was using birth control, and several nights she had not bothered to come home at all. As parents, he and his wife had tried various forms of punishment, but nothing seemed to make much of a difference. Their daughter lied to them, deceived them, and always found a way to turn the tables on them, blaming her behavior on them for being so strict. Yancey’s friend said that he remembered standing in front of the window in his living room one night, staring out into the darkness and waiting for his daughter to come home. He said he felt such rage. He was so angry with his daughter for the way she manipulated him and his wife and constantly tried to find ways to hurt them. He was also upset because he knew she was hurting herself more than anyone. In that moment he understood more than ever before the passages in the Bible where God expressed frustration—passages talking about how the people knew how to wound God and how God would cry out in pain.
“And yet I must tell you,” he said, “when my daughter came home that night (or rather the next morning), I wanted nothing in the world so much as to take her in my arms, to love her, to tell her I wanted the best for her. I was a helpless, lovesick father.” Yancey writes that now, when he reflects on God, he holds up that image of the lovesick father. Because it really is the most biblical image you can have—a God who is standing in front of the window, gazing achingly into the darkness, waiting for his child to come home.
Countless numbers of people who have opened up their heart to God’s presence and comfort in the midst of their pain have found this to be true. After being a prisoner in Ravensbruck, one of the infamous concentration camps of Nazi Germany, Corrie ten Boom traveled throughout the world, telling her story of suffering in the context of a faith in God. For thirty-three years following her time in Ravensbruck, she never had a permanent home. When she was eighty-five years old, some friends provided her with a lovely home in California. It was a luxury she never dreamed she would have. One day, as a friend was leaving her home after a visit, he said, “Corrie, hasn’t God been good to give you this beautiful place?” She replied firmly, “God was good when I was in Ravensbruck, too.”
One of the most difficult tasks I was ever called upon to perform was as a pastor of a church outside of Louisville, Kentucky, during my seminary years. A friend and member of the church called and told me that his next-door neighbor had just committed suicide. She was the mother of five girls, and her youngest daughter had found her. They had no church, no pastor. He asked them if it would be all right if he called someone from his church to come. They said yes, so he called me. When I arrived, I saw huddled in a corner of the house the five daughters with their father. I thought: What am I doing here? What could I possibly say, what could I ever do, that would help at this moment? I went over to the family, introduced myself, and said the only words I could think of: “I just want you to know that I’m sorry. I’m so very, very sorry.”
The girl who had found her mother looked up at me and said, “Would you pray for us?” So I prayed. I don’t remember a single word of that prayer. But when I finished, that little girl looked up at me and simply said, “God’s here, isn’t he?”
And I said, “Yes, he is.”
She said, “I thought so. I could feel him hugging me when you prayed. It’s going to be all right, isn’t it?”
And I said, “Yes, honey, it’s going to be hard, but it’s going to be all right.”
But being with us is not all that God has done.
He’s invested himself in the process of healing the wounds that come from our choices by entering into the suffering process with us in order to lift us out of it. The heart of the Christian faith is that God himself in human form came to earth in the person of Jesus and suffered. He knows about pain. He knows about rejection. He knows about hunger, injustice, and cruelty because he has experienced suffering. An ancient graffito found at the museum on the Palatine Hill in Rome, Italy, shows a crucified figure with a donkey’s head, bearing the inscription “Alexamenos worships his god.” While meant to disparage and even mock, the image rings true.
We worship, as German theologian Jurgen Moltmann observed, the crucified God. Jesus on the cross was God entering into the reality of human suffering, experiencing it just like we do, in order to demonstrate that even when we used our free will to reject him, his love never ended. This was not suffering for its own sake, but suffering so that we might use our free will to choose again—this time, making the right choice. Frederick Buechner put it this way: “Like a father saying about his sick child, ‘I’d do anything to make you well,’ God finally calls his own bluff and does it.” The ultimate deliverance, the most significant healing, the most strategic rescue, has come. Our greatest and most terrible affliction has been addressed. God has given us the greatest answer to our questions. He has given us himself.
And he is going to keep giving himself to any and all who will turn to him until the end of time. And time will come to an end. A missionary was once asked what Jesus will say when he returns to the earth, because Jesus himself said he would return at the end of all things. He thought it was an odd question, but then he remembered a verse in the Bible about Jesus’s return from the first letter that the apostle Paul wrote to the people of the church in Thessolonica. It says, “For the Lord himself will come down from heaven with a commanding shout” (1 Thess. 4:16 NLT, emphasis added). The person wanted to know what Jesus will shout. The missionary thought a moment, and then it came to him. He said, “Enough.” Jesus will shout, “Enough!” Enough suffering, enough starvation, enough terror. Enough death, enough indignity, enough lives trapped in hopelessness. Enough sickness and disease. At the end, when he returns, “Christ will shout, ‘Enough!’”
“Alexamenos worships his god” is a second-century pagan graffito depicting a crucified figure with a donkey’s head. [Wikimedia Commons]
That is the story you need to know.
This raises the real question when it comes to our broken world: Will pain and suffering drive you away from God, or will it drive you to God? The whole reason it is being allowed and that “Enough!” has not been shouted yet is because God is hoping for people like you to turn to him. You may say, “You mean God endures all that for . . . me?” Yes. Do you want to know the reason?
He’s your Father.
The God of the Bible
The questions about why the world is such a sin-stained, screwed-up place are not the end of the matter, are they? While every faith, every philosophy, every worldview must speak to the reason for the existence of a very broken world, the Christian faith has another set of questions waiting in the wings. These questions have to deal with the fact that when people go to the Bible to learn more about God, they find out that it’s God who seems to be behind a lot of the pain and suffering—even the one causing it! It’s the God of the Bible doling out capital punishment for seemingly minor infractions; the one who is asking for blood sacrifices; the one who is calling for the slaughter of entire people groups. The late Christopher Hitchens wrote a book on this titled God Is Not Great. Fellow sympathizer Richard Dawkins calls the God of the Bible a “moral monster.” It doesn’t take familiarity with the names and places to feel the force of Dawkins’s ruthless examination of, particularly, the Old Testament text of the Bible. For example, Dawkins calls God’s commanding Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac to be “disgraceful” and tantamount to “child abuse and bullying.” He calls the killing of the Canaanites by the Israelites, as a dictate from God, an “ethnic cleansing” in which “bloodthirsty massacres” were carried out with “xenophobic relish.” He says that the Israelite leader Joshua’s destruction of Jericho is “morally indistinguishable from Hitler’s invasion of Poland, or Saddam Hussein’s massacres of the Kurds.” Conclusion? “The God of the Old Testament is arguably the most unpleasant character in all fiction; jealous and proud of it; a petty, unjust, unforgiving control-freak; a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser; a misogynistic, homophobic, racist, infanticidal, genocidal, filicidal, pestilential, megalomaniacal, sadomasochistic, capriciously malevolent bully.”
So is the God of the Bible a moral monster?
When you read the Bible and find instances of seemingly harsh punishment, the call for sacrifices and even the mass slaughter of entire nations—which, I might add, you do find—do we still have a good and loving God on our hands? Or do we have a terribly evil Being to be rejected, and certainly not to be believed in?
There’s no doubt you can paint a picture of the God of the Bible any way you want if you are selective in what you focus on and take the Scripture out of its original context and meaning. I once saw a YouTube video titled “Scary Mary.” It was a collection of scenes from Disney’s classic family film Mary Poppins. The mashup took what looked like “scary” scenes from the movie out of context, changed the background music, and produced a trailer as though it was a horror film. The mashup obviously did not reveal the true character of Mary Poppins. It was creative but misleading, showing Mary Poppins as evil. Could we be doing this with our image of the God of the Bible?
Slaughters
Let’s look at just one of the concerns about the God of the Bible, arguably the one most discussed—the slaughter of the Canaanites. It is what some have called the most difficult and bloody part of the Bible, and the one that on the surface is the most ethically troubling. It’s found in the Old Testament book of Deuteronomy. The context is critical. God led the people of Israel out of slavery and out of Egypt. He was not only forming them into a new people, a new nation, but taking them to a new land that would become known as the Promised Land. But it wasn’t just given to them. They had to take it, possess it, and, at times, conquer it. And that’s what brings us to one of the bloodiest scenes in the Bible: the slaughter of the Canaanites by the Israelites on the directive of God himself. There are several places where this is referenced in the Bible. Here’s an overview description:
As you approach a town to attack it, you must first offer its people terms for peace. If they accept your terms and open the gates to you, then all the people inside will serve you in forced labor. But if they refuse to make peace and prepare to fight, you must attack the town. When the LORD your God hands the town over to you, use your swords to kill every man in the town. But you may keep for yourselves all the women, children, livestock, and other plunder. You may enjoy the plunder from your enemies that the LORD your God has given you. (Deut. 20:10–14 NLT)
(Before you read on, let me just add that this was not a license to rape and pillage. It was later detailed that if an Israelite took one of these women, it meant that they were going to have to take them as their wife and treat them with all the respect and decorum that came with that marriage. Now let’s continue reading.)
But these instructions apply only to distant towns, not to the towns of the nations in the land you will enter. In those towns that the LORD your God is giving you as a special possession, destroy every living thing. You must completely destroy the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites, just as the LORD your God has commanded you. This will prevent the people of the land from teaching you to imitate their detestable customs in the worship of their gods, which would cause you to sin deeply against the LORD your God. (Deut. 20:15–18 NLT)
So was that an indiscriminate massacre, an ethnic cleansing along the lines of Hitler and the Jewish Holocaust, or Saddam Hussein’s slaughter of the Kurds? Something that deserves not only universal condemnation, but a complete rejection of the God of the Bible? Or is there something more here?
First, this was more than just an invasion or conquest. This was God’s planned punishment of the people of Canaan for their ways, long in the making and in the coming. Yes, God was displacing them from the land to give it to the people of Israel. But that displacement came because of their ferocious, habitual, unrepentant wickedness. And I do mean wicked. The Canaanites were marked by the worst possible aspects of slavery, religious prostitution, and sexual cults. (Not that there’s anything good about slavery, but think taking slavery to the darkest place that you can possibly take it.) Scholars have called the Canaanite cult religion the most sexually depraved of any in the ancient world. They had given themselves over to every kind of sexual depravity, including incest and even bestiality. At their worst, their orgiastic worship of idols even included human sacrifice—both of children and adults. There’s imagery of their cult sexual practice of bathing themselves in blood.
The Bible says that God had been tolerating this for more than four hundred years. Their wickedness kept increasing and increasing and God kept enduring it. Four hundred years of restraint and patience. Why? Because no matter what you’ve heard, judgment is always his last resort. But the wickedness reached a point where Scripture talks about how God couldn’t stomach it anymore and he vomited them out of his mouth (see Gen. 15:16 and Lev. 18:24–30). So what stands out in the Bible is not God’s acts of justice, but how much he is marked by mercy. By restraint. But this was a time when God determined that there was no other recourse but divine judgment.
A second point to remember is that this was a divine, God-ordained action. In other words, it was God’s call to make. Not just the punishment, but the possession of the land—who he was going to give that land to. Israel didn’t have an inherent right to the land. Neither did the Canaanites. But God did. He could give it to whomever he wanted. So if someone says, “I can’t believe God kicked the Canaanites out and gave away their land,” an appropriate response is, “What do you mean by ‘their land’?” This was God’s land. He made it. He could do with it whatever he wanted to do. Israel would never have been justified in doing this had God not ordered it. But God did. So don’t think about this as a simple invasion of one nation into another. Or a strong army beating a weaker army, as if strength or desire gives anyone the right to be aggressive. You’ll never find that in the Bible. This was God saying, “I’m telling you, this land is now yours. It is not theirs.”
But there’s a third observation to make here, and it’s about the command to “destroy every living thing” in the cities. When you read something like that it sounds over the top and unnecessary even for divine judgment. But the command was for the cities, not the outlying areas. This is a critical point. In the culture of the ancient Near East, most people lived in outlying areas, not the cities. The cities were military fortifications for soldiers and military officers. It’s not where the women and children, farmers and laborers lived. So in terms of warfare, this was not about targeting civilians. Also, in the ancient language of the day, even the phrase about destroying everyone in the city was common hyperbole. It wasn’t about literally taking every life, but ensuring that the war was won, the enemy defeated, the task accomplished. Think how in our day we talk about a sports team that blew their opponent away, or slaughtered them, or annihilated them. It’s a form of rhetoric. When you study the language of the ancient Near Eastern cultures, this was very common. They would talk about how they destroyed every man, and then later talk about what they were going to do with the survivors. In other words, destroying everything meant winning decisively, not literally destroying everything. This was more about purifying than purging.
Which brings up the final point to remember in all this, one that is unavoidable: it’s the idea of God’s wrath. And that may be what bothers us the most. That God is a God who is angry with evil, at war with evil, livid with evil. It is as if we have determined God has no right to any emotion but love. And, if he does express anger, we have a bad or immoral God on our hands. But why does an angry God bother us so much? I once read some penetrating words on this from Yale theologian Miroslav Volf. He was born in Croatia and lived through the nightmare years of ethnic strife in the former Yugoslavia—a time that included the destruction of churches, the raping of women, and the murdering of innocents. He once thought that wrath and anger were beneath God, but he said he came to realize that his view of God had been too low:
I used to think that wrath was unworthy of God. Isn’t God love? Shouldn’t divine love be beyond wrath? God is love, and God loves every person and every creature. That’s exactly why God is wrathful against some of them. My last resistance to the idea of God’s wrath was a casualty of the war in the former Yugoslavia, the region from which I come. According to some estimates, 200,000 people were killed and over 3,000,000 were displaced. My villages and cities were destroyed, my people shelled day in and day out, some of them brutalized beyond imagination, and I could not imagine God not being angry. Or think of Rwanda in the last decade of the past century, where 800,000 people were hacked to death in one hundred days! How did God react to the carnage? By doting on the perpetrators in a grandfatherly fashion? By refusing to condemn the bloodbath but instead affirming the perpetrators’ basic goodness? Wasn’t God fiercely angry with them? Though I used to complain about the indecency of the idea of God’s wrath, I came to think that I would have to rebel against a God who wasn’t wrathful at the sight of the world’s evil. God isn’t wrathful in spite of being love. God is wrathful because God is love.
Yes.
When it comes to God, the fire that warms can be the fire that burns. I’m not sure any other kind of God would even matter.
