Chapter 9 of 12

7. Misusing a Good Tool

7. Misusing a Good Tool

7

Misusing a Good Tool

Mistakes We Make in Considering Our Good Works

Over the years, my dad and I have embarked on a number of home improvement and home repair projects. We’ve taken down walls, built new ones, laid wood flooring and tile, painted, put down carpet, installed electrical wiring and plumbing, and finished a thousand other jobs. Usually, the job goes well. Sometimes it does not.

A few years ago, my dad and I decided to replace a door that led out to my backyard. As far as construction projects go, this one shouldn’t have been too difficult. All we needed was the door, some hinges and screws, a doorknob assembly, and voila! New door. The only trouble was that the home improvement store didn’t have the correct size door; they only had ones that were about six inches too tall to fit my home’s opening. But then again, my dad is a master at this sort of thing, and he’s proven it a hundred times over. “We’ll just get the big door,” he said, “and cut it off at the bottom so it fits.” So that’s what we did, and we were so careful about it. We bought a saw blade that would cut through metal and an end cap to cover up the jagged bottom of the door after it was cut. We measured twice, nay three times, to be sure nothing would go wrong. Even the most obvious pitfall, the one you’re probably expecting we fell into—the fact that if you cut the door off at the bottom, the doorknob won’t fit where it’s supposed to—we brilliantly anticipated and avoided. Instead of cutting only the bottom, we carefully made sure to keep the knob in the center by cutting six inches off both the top and the bottom, which, of course, adds up to twelve inches that we cut off the door.

It’s a moment that’s become Greg-and-Dennis legend in my family. For all our care, for all our having bought the best tools and having made the best, most careful measurements, we still did the job wrong. We misused the good tools we had, and the result was (hilarious) disaster.

Misusing good tools isn’t always hilarious though. Sometimes it just leads to catastrophe. That’s often the case when Christians try to analyze their own good works and fruit to increase their assurance. As we read in the last chapter, the Bible clearly teaches that examining our lives is a good tool, and it is a good thing to do; like a speedometer on a car, it can tell us if things are running smoothly or if something’s wrong. And we can find ourselves being either encouraged even more in the faith or warned that our focus has somehow gone awry. But as with any good tool, there are so many wrong ways to use it, to do that analysis in a way that it was never meant to be done. And when Christians make those mistakes, the results can be catastrophic to assurance.

In this chapter, then, our goal is to consider some of the mistakes we tend to make when we start to do the work of examining our own fruit. My aim here is not to convince you that you shouldn’t practice self-examination; it’s simply to lay down some guardrails that might help you avoid doing that work wrongly. It’s true that Paul commands us to examine ourselves (see 2 Cor. 13:5), but that doesn’t mean we should do so however we see fit. There are ways to do it well and ways not to do it well.

The Practical Syllogism and How to Use It

At some point, Christians realized the Bible’s teaching about good works and their relationship to salvation and therefore assurance is actually a bit of classical logical reasoning known as a syllogism. So, before we go on, let’s talk a little formal logic. In a logical syllogism, a conclusion is drawn from two related premises that are asserted to be true. Here’s a famous example:

All men are mortals.

Socrates is a man.

Therefore, Socrates is a mortal.

Sometimes, of course, a syllogism can be terribly wrong. An old cartoon once showed a penguin looking puzzled as he tried to use a syllogism:

Penguins are black and white.

Old television shows are black and white.

Therefore, penguins are old television shows.

And amusingly, here’s Google Dictionary’s official example of a syllogism:

All dogs are animals.

All animals have four legs.

Therefore, all dogs have four legs.

Wait a second . . .

Anyway, enough of the lesson in logic. The point is, Christians realized that the logical connection between good works and assurance—and the Bible’s exhortation for believers to examine themselves and draw a conclusion from what they see—is in fact a “practical syllogism” (the word practical points to the fact that this syllogism has to do with our praxis, that is, our works) that runs something like this:

Good works are one characteristic of a true Christian.

I am characterized by good works.

Therefore, I have one characteristic of a true Christian.

We can even think about it in negative terms, like this:

If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him.

I love the world.

Therefore, the love of the Father is not in me.

Now, as long as we remember what John means by “love of the world”—that is, a fundamental allegiance to the world and its sinful patterns over against Jesus—then that’s a perfectly legitimate logical conclusion. It’s exactly the kind of reasoning other New Testament authors use in their books. And therefore, it’s completely legitimate and good for us as Christians to do that kind of self-examination—to run this “practical syllogism” on our own lives and take the conclusion seriously.

That said, it’s important to run that syllogism on our lives correctly, and that’s where so many Christians go wrong and consequently find their assurance collapsing when it really should not be. So, let’s consider six errors Christians often make in using this bit of Bible logic to examine their own lives.

First, it is a mistake to run the practical syllogism too narrowly.

Running the practical syllogism too narrowly is exactly the issue we mentioned in the last chapter regarding John’s statement in 1 John 3:6 that “no one who abides in him keeps on sinning.” John’s intention is not that we should pick out one narrow point in our lives and, on the basis of staring at that, draw the conclusion that we are not really Christians. Rather, John intends for us to consider whether the whole tenor of our lives—the dominant color on our canvas—is allegiance to Christ or, as he calls it, “lawlessness.”

This is a critical point because it is a mistake Christians make all the time when they begin to do the work of self-examination. By focusing too narrowly on one instance of sin or even on a single enduring struggle with sin—and then running the syllogism only on that narrow slice of their life—they wind up with a terrifically inaccurate assessment of their true spiritual state. Think of it like this: on any given apple tree, even the most healthy one, we can always find one bad or rotten apple if we look carefully enough. Imagine taking a snapshot of that one bad apple, showing it to someone who hasn’t looked at the whole tree, and asking them to make an assessment about the health of that apple tree based only on that one zoomed-in photo. The assessment would be suspect at best! And yet that’s exactly what many Christians do with their own lives. They find the bad apple, the errant brushstroke on the canvas, and come to an assurance-crushing conclusion that they must not be a Christian after all.

The biblical and theological error in that kind of thinking should be obvious though. It draws on a wrongheaded perfectionism that fails to acknowledge the biblical teaching that even as Christians, we will still sin until the day we stand before Jesus in glory. The correct way to run the practical syllogism is not to run it on a single apple but to include in our field of view the whole tree—that is, to use a wide-angle lens instead of a zoom lens so that all the fruit is in view. In fact, the best way to examine ourselves may not be to use a photo at all but rather a movie, so we can take into account our growth in grace and holiness, our struggle against sin, and even our sorrow that sin still persists in us.

See? It’s not the mere presence of sin in our lives that raises warning flags that we might not be a Christian. We shouldn’t despair because we see a rotten apple on the tree, even one that hangs there for a long time. To be sure, if most of the apples are rotten or if the tree looks generally unhealthy, then that’s a serious problem. We should never allow ourselves to become content or unconcerned about any bad fruit, as if it’s no big deal if one branch of our tree is diseased or dead. We should always be seeking to identify, repent of, and eliminate all sin that shows up in our lives. But when it comes to our assurance of salvation, the Bible’s exhortation to self-examination is intended to be obeyed broadly, with regard to the whole of our lives and not just one narrow slice of it. If we understand and apply that, we’ll not only head off unwarranted, assurance-collapsing conclusions about ourselves but also be in a better position to see actual dangerous problems taking shape that demand action.

Second, it is a mistake to run the practical syllogism on a comparison of your life with others’.

The fact is, each and every Christian is on a unique path of sanctification and learning to follow Jesus. We all have different struggles, different victories, different hardships, and therefore to look at another Christian and reason, I’m not as fruitful as she is, so therefore I must not be a Christian, or I struggle with this sin and he doesn’t, so I’m probably not a Christian is not a correct use of the syllogism.

And yet as nonsensical as it is, many Christians frequently use just that kind of reasoning. If I don’t have as much courage as Joni Eareckson Tada, we think, or as much passion as John Piper, or as much knowledge as Ravi Zacharias, or as much evangelistic zeal as Mack Stiles, then I can’t possibly be a Christian. Do you remember Trent from the beginning of this book? If you think about it, this was exactly the kind of reasoning that ultimately undermined and eroded his faith. He didn’t see reflected in his own life the sparkling, sustained joy described in the book he was reading, and he wrongly concluded that he probably wasn’t a Christian. His error wasn’t in thinking that Christians are marked by joy. They are! Joy is one of the fruits of the Spirit; even in the midst of hardship and difficulty, Christians are marked by the joy of knowing that trials and tribulations will eventually pass and give way to eternity. No, Trent’s mistake was in thinking that all Christians must experience joy in exactly the same way and to exactly the same degree. But they don’t. For some Christians, the light of eternity shines bright in their eyes almost all the time. For others, the smoke of battle is so thick they can barely see eternity’s light at all. Thus, it was a mistake—and a costly one—for Trent to compare himself to that one particular author, in one particular area, and conclude that he wasn’t a Christian.

I doubt most Christians make this mistake in self-examination quite so blatantly as Trent made it. But even if it’s less egregious, to base your assurance of faith on comparison with others is still wrongheaded. Of course, it’s a good thing for Christians to have role models, examples to follow who are ahead of them on the journey. But that doesn’t mean you should despair of your faith and conclude that you are not a child of God when you compare yourself to those role models. Think of it like this: My eight-year-old daughter is not as mature as my sixteen-year-old son. She is not as far along the road of growing up. But she is certainly no less my child because of that, and it would be wrong for her to conclude, I’m not as far along in my growth and maturity as my brother, so therefore I am not as much my father’s child as he is. For my daughter to draw that kind of conclusion would be a terrible mistake—one that would leave her tragically, and falsely, doubting her father’s love for her.

Third, it is a mistake to run the practical syllogism on the past instead of the present.

It’s a great temptation for a Christian to consider the sins and patterns of their past and, on the basis of those, conclude that they could not possibly be a Christian. “How could a Christian have done the things I did?” they ask. But that’s just the point of the gospel of Jesus Christ—it provides forgiveness for the past. Think about the apostle Paul. He persecuted the church of Christ to the point of trying to put believers in prison. Later, he would even call himself “the foremost” of sinners (1 Tim. 1:15). And yet Paul knew he had been forgiven of even that heinous sin. “I received mercy for this reason, that in me, as the foremost, Jesus Christ might display his perfect patience as an example to those who were to believe in him for eternal life” (v. 16). Paul knew his past sins were no match for Jesus’s mercy, his past life no reason to think he was not one of God’s children now.

The same is true for you, Christian. You may think back on your life and see a thousand sins for which God would have every right to condemn you. And the worst thing you could do is believe they are so bad that they make it impossible for you to be saved. As Paul discovered, God’s mercy is an ocean of unfathomable depth, and even our greatest sins—once cast into it by Christ—are forever gone. In fact, that’s exactly the point he seemed to be making to the Corinthian Christians:

Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God. (1 Cor. 6:9–11)

To be sure, there’s the bracing warning that people characterized by unrighteousness will not inherit the kingdom of God. But Paul didn’t mention those things with the intention of causing these believers to cower and think, Oh no, that was me before I came to Christ; I must be unforgiveable! On the contrary, he seems to bring up these old sins precisely to make the believers rejoice in the forgiveness they now have in Christ. Thus, he says, “Such were some of you” (emphasis added). Paul brought up these believers’ past sins not to make them feel guilty, much less to doubt their salvation, but to encourage them to celebrate Christ’s work and say, “Yes! I was that, but I am no longer because of Jesus!”

What this means is that the Bible intends for us to examine our present life, not our past one. The question is what our fruit looks like now, not what it looked like some time ago, much less before we came to Christ. Here’s what the Bible says: Christ, through his work on our behalf, has set us free from both the condemnation and the guilt of past sin. If that’s true, then there’s no more tragic way to squander Christ’s gift to us than to fasten the phantom chains of guilt on our wrists and allow them to rob us of the joyful assurance Jesus intends us to have. Examine your life, yes. But let your past sink into the ocean of God’s forgiveness. Like the Corinthian Christians, you should not let your past be a source of fear and doubt; rather, think of it as a celebration for what Christ has done.

Fourth, it is a mistake to run the practical syllogism too frequently.

Though the Bible commands us as Christians to do the work of self-examination, it’s entirely possible for a person to become obsessive in the practice, to the point that every individual word, thought, deed, and motivation becomes evidence—one way or the other—of the genuineness of the person’s faith. That kind of introspective focus is unhealthy.

An analogy using fitness or wellness might be helpful. A person’s weight may be an important and useful indicator of their overall health, but it would be entirely unhealthy for a person to weigh themselves a dozen times a day or after every meal. Not only would that show an unhealthy psychological obsession with what is finally only one of many indicators of health, but it would also fail to give an accurate or useful measure of the person’s health at all. Even worse, the constant fluctuation—up and down, encouragement and discouragement—would likely leave the person incapable of taking the steps that would lead to true health. What’s important is how a person’s weight fluctuates over a few weeks, or even a few months, not a few minutes or hours.

In the same way, a tendency to spiritually “weigh” yourself using too frequent self-examination probably shows an unhealthy obsession with introspection—one that will cause enormous, perhaps even debilitating, fluctuation in your sense of assurance and also, ironically, prevent you from seeing your spiritual health clearly at all. Worst of all, a focus on frequent and unhealthy introspective examination will place you in danger of putting your hope in getting an A+ grade at any given moment rather than on Christ and his work.

Fifth, it is a mistake to do the work of self-examination alone.

When I was a child, some of the commercials that would air during Saturday morning cartoons would show children doing various dangerous stunts—jumping their bikes on ramps or turning flips on a trampoline. And at the bottom of the screen would flash the warning “Don’t try this at home.” In many ways, the work of self-examination should carry a similar warning: “Don’t try this alone.” The fact is, our hearts are inconceivably deceitful, which means we as human beings have a hard time seeing ourselves clearly and assessing ourselves rightly. Sometimes, perhaps most often, we tend to think too highly of ourselves and conclude that things are going well spiritually when actually they are not going well at all. Just as dangerously, though, sometimes we can be blind to the many good things the Holy Spirit is doing in and through our lives. The result is that we unduly focus on problem areas and therefore draw faulty conclusions about our actual overall spiritual health.

What this means is that we really should not make it a habit to do the serious work of self-examination alone. Sure, sometimes it’s fine and good to take a look at our own lives, but it’s even better—and safer—to examine ourselves with the help of other believers. In that way, other Christian brothers and sisters can help us see what we’re incapable of seeing for ourselves—whether that’s pointing out a fruitless branch on the back of our tree or reassuring us that although we’re focusing on one bad apple, the overall health of our tree seems good. All this is why the Bible expects Christians to be vitally connected together in local churches. You see, the church is not just a resource-distribution center; it is a group of Christians who help one another walk faithfully in discipleship to Jesus, including in the work of self-examination. The Christian life was never meant to be lived alone, and self-examination should not be done alone either.

Sixth, it is a mistake to let the practical syllogism become the primary source of your assurance.

Throughout this book, we’ve seen that the driving sources of our spiritual assurance are the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God. By focusing our attention and understanding on these things, we grow in our confidence that Jesus is a powerful Savior—powerful enough to save even sinners like us—and that God will always, infallibly keep his promises to save and preserve those who come to Jesus in faith. If that’s true, then self-examination can certainly be one thread in the rope of our assurance, but it should never be the primary means or source of it. As human beings, we are bent toward a desire to save ourselves or at least to contribute something to our salvation. Because of that, our hearts are frighteningly adept at taking even something like the fruit of the Spirit and turning them into grounds for pride and self-justification. “Look at all this fruit!” we say. “Now I feel like a Christian!” A true Christian, though—one who understands the moral bankruptcy from which they were saved—will learn the difference between gaining humble encouragement from the fruit they see in their life and taking pride in it (thereby putting faith in it). Faith belongs in Jesus alone and never in our own good works, no matter how bountiful those works might be.

So how do you know if you’ve subtly begun to make self-examination of your own fruit the primary source of your assurance? There are a few ways to diagnose that problem. One of the most important ways lies in your general sense of spiritual well-being. What is it that most settles your heart and gives you spiritual comfort? Is it meditation on Jesus or reflection on your own life? Do you find that your sense of well-being is mostly or even entirely dependent on how you’ve “done” this week in avoiding sin or accomplishing spiritual disciplines? If so, then take care. The heart is deceitful and self-righteous above all things, and where it finds the most comfort, there it will put its hope. What a tragedy it would be for you to stand before Jesus with great hope and confidence in all the good works you did in his name and for him to say, “Depart from me, for I never knew you!”

Another indicator that you may be wrongly putting hope in your fruit rather than in Jesus is how you tend to behave when you fall into sin and begin to pursue repentance. According to the logic of the gospel, you ought to begin with finding and embracing forgiveness in Christ and then, out of the strength of hope and forgiveness, proceed to fighting against sin.

Far too many Christians, though, want to run that logic of repentance backward. They think, First, I have to fix this behavior, and then I will be ready to go to Jesus for forgiveness. You see the problem with that thinking? It’s not much more than salvation by works through the back door—one more way of trying to make ourselves worthy of God’s grace and forgiveness. Here’s the point: Christians do and must fight against sin, but their motivation for that fight is critical. If our motivation is to win God’s favor and prove ourselves worthy of his grace, then our fight is not Jesus-glorifying at all but ultimately self-glorifying; it is anti-gospel. A gospel fight against sin, however, launches from a place of forgiveness, acceptance, and love that has already been won for us by Jesus. We don’t fight sin to win Jesus’s love. We fight sin because we already have Jesus’s love.

In the wake of being defeated by sin, what gives you assurance that you can return to Jesus in repentance and find forgiveness and love? Is it that you’ve cleaned up the mess and recommitted yourself to fighting sin and therefore Jesus will be happy to see you? Or is it simply that Jesus has promised to save sinners—even you—if you come to him in humility and trust?

Conclusion

At various times in history, some Christians have argued that the practical syllogism—that is, the conclusion that we can to some degree confirm our assurance of faith by seeing fruit in our lives, since such fruit is one of the characteristics of a true Christian—is illegitimate precisely because it can look so much like putting faith and hope in one’s own good works. But the syllogism doesn’t need to be cast aside entirely, and in fact, it can’t be if we want to be faithful to the Bible. That’s because the Bible does, several times, exhort and encourage us to find confirmation of our faith in the fruit that we see growing in our own lives.

That doesn’t mean, however, we should launch into that kind of self-examination with abandon. Definite dangers are involved, and those dangers actually lie on both sides—whether we wind up encouraged or discouraged by our introspection. Think about it: If our examination of our good works encourages us, we should be exceedingly careful lest we begin to focus so much on our good works that they become the object of our hope. But there’s also the danger that our self-examination can become so obsessive and narrow and exclusive and discouraging that we wind up undermining our sense of assurance entirely.

Despite all those dangers, though, the Bible insists that self-examination is a good and important practice, as long as we keep the cautions we’ve discussed here carefully in mind. At its best, self-examination can alert us to areas of life that aren’t lining up with our profession of faith in Christ. We may see fruitless areas or areas of rotten fruit because we refuse to surrender them to Jesus. We may even begin to recognize a general lack of spiritual health in our lives and be shocked into action by that realization. In those moments, the right course is not to do more good things and fewer bad things. It’s to return to the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God, to see his excellencies and be renewed by his love and forgiveness, and then—out of that power and security—renew our fight against sin and for holiness.

On the other hand, our self-examination may actually wind up encouraging us in the faith as we see what God is doing in and through us. We may see acts of love that we know are not natural to us apart from Christ, or renewed vigor in pursuing godliness, or a deepening desire for the things of God. It’s not that we would ever hold those good things up as reasons for God to save us, but they may reflexively encourage us to press on even more in the faith, striving to understand more deeply and embrace more tightly the gospel and the promises. The fact is, if you’ve been tending the root of a tree and suddenly begin to see fruit, it is a right, good, and entirely natural response to be encouraged and then redouble your focus on that root. Used rightly, that’s how self-examination ought to work—not as the primary driving source of our assurance but as a confirmation of spiritual health or a warning that it is lacking. Either way, though, the correct response is not to try to increase your assurance by fiddling with the indicator but rather to focus again on the source of both salvation itself and assurance—the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God.

We should address one more knotty problem, though, regarding a particular application of the practical syllogism. Sometimes Christians find themselves repenting over and over again, sometimes even for years, regarding the same sins. And a natural fear is to think, If I were a real Christian, I wouldn’t still be struggling with this sin. Is that true? How should we think about the sins that just seem to beset us, to dog us no matter how often we repent of them? We turn to that question in the next chapter.

↑ Back to top

↑