4. The Supernatural Source of Assurance
4
The Supernatural Source of Assurance
The Witness of the Spirit
The summer after I turned forty years old, I decided more or less on a whim to take a two-week trek to Mount Everest Base Camp. My wife and kids insist it was a midlife crisis. I say it was an adventure, not to mention proof of my continuing youth and vitality! However you want to look at it, though, it was an amazing trip, full of utterly exotic experiences and breathtaking vistas I doubt I will ever see again.
Our hikes every day began very early in the morning. I never quite figured out why, but I think it was at least in part to make sure there would be enough daylight to react if anything ever went wrong. At any rate, most mornings we were at breakfast by 6:00 a.m. and hitting the trail by 6:30. Then, often by noon, we’d arrive at the day’s goal—a Nepalese teahouse where we’d eat, sit in the common room, read or talk to other trekkers, eat again, and then go to bed around 9:00 p.m. Sometimes the afternoon would involve an acclimatization hike during which we’d climb a nearby ridge, ascending a thousand or so feet, and then descend again to sleep.
Honestly, the hikes could be frustrating sometimes, not so much because of the difficulty but because of the clouds. There were entire afternoons when the clouds were so thick we couldn’t see anything farther than the nearest ridge. Imagine knowing that the snowcapped Himalayas are right there in front of you and yet not being able to see them. That was the situation on one of our acclimatization hikes, which I’d been told would be one of the most beautiful hikes of the trek. We were supposed to ascend to a peak called Nangkar Tshang; it was the first time we would cross 16,000 feet (5,000 meters) in altitude, and the views of a mountain called Ama Dablam were said to be breathtaking. So, off we went, and for two hours we saw nothing but clouds. Occasionally, we would think the air was clearing, only to realize another bank of clouds was rolling in.
When we reached the peak of Nangkar Tshang, I took a picture of my altimeter reading because there was nothing else to take a picture of! Then we headed down. I kept squinting my eyes, knowing Ama Dablam was there, but I was unable to catch the slightest glimpse of it. Then, in one unbelievable instant, it happened. Over just a few seconds, the clouds dissipated, and there it was—what some people say is the most beautiful mountain in the world towering over me closer and larger than I ever imagined. I’m not easily brought to tears, but the beauty and enormity of that mountain—the sun all of a sudden glinting off its white faces—did it, and I found myself singing a hymn to the Creator. There was just enough time to snap a few pictures before, just as suddenly, another cloud bank moved in and Ama Dablam vanished. But it was there. I knew it was there, even if it was invisible to me now. But, oh, what an amazing thing it was to be able to see it—not just to know it was there in an objective but blind way but for it to be clearly and gloriously visible to my own eyes!
That kind of experience, in part, is what we mean by the witness of the Spirit. At times in this journey, we may know with all objective confidence that the truths of the gospel and the promises of God are there and true, and yet not be fully sensible of them; we may not see and experience them. But sometimes the Holy Spirit parts the clouds and gives us a vision of those promises in all their enormity that simply takes our breath away.
The Bible’s Teaching on the Spirit’s Witness
The phrase “witness of the Spirit” comes from Romans 8:14–17, where Paul uses it to describe how the Holy Spirit cries out with our own spirits that we are in fact children of God:
For all who are led by the Spirit of God are sons of God. For you did not receive the spirit of slavery to fall back into fear, but you have received the Spirit of adoption as sons, by whom we cry, “Abba! Father!” The Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God, and if children, then heirs—heirs of God and fellow heirs with Christ, provided we suffer with him in order that we may also be glorified with him.
He uses the same idea in Galatians 4:4–7:
But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth his Son, born of woman, born under the law, to redeem those who were under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons. And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, crying, “Abba! Father!” So you are no longer a slave, but a son, and if a son, then an heir through God.
There are several important points to note here. First, notice that in both of these passages, the witness of the Spirit—that is, the Spirit crying out with our spirits that we are children of God—is closely connected to the fact that God has adopted us as his children. What an incredible truth! Not only have we been forgiven, justified, and regenerated, and not only has God promised that he will one day glorify and enthrone us on high with Christ, but God has also actually made us his sons and daughters. This is therefore no distant, cold, clinical, transactional salvation. God has brought us into the closest imaginable relationship with him—beloved, accepted, and welcomed sons and daughters of the King. That’s the context in which Paul teaches that the Spirit witnesses to us: he reminds us, and the universe itself, that even when we struggle, even as we trudge through the acrid smoke of the battlefield, we are children of God.
Notice too that the one who cries, “Abba! Father!” in each passage is different. In Romans, it is the believer—you, me—who cries out, while in the Galatians passage, it is the Spirit himself who does so. These two passages taken together create one of the most beautiful images in the entire Bible. In the Romans 8 passage, the situation seems to be one of near desperation. “You did not receive the spirit of slavery,” Paul writes, “to fall back into fear” (v. 15). In other words, Paul doesn’t envision believers as having a leisurely stroll through the park here. They’re in danger and hard-pressed—tempted in fact to sink through fear and back into the dark slavery of sin. They’re on their knees in the smoke of battle, yet even through choked lungs they still cry out, “Abba! Father!” I’ve had experiences like that. Maybe you have too. And in those moments of desperation, my “cry” is more like a whisper, sometimes choked with tears. “Abba . . . Father . . .”
But then think about Galatians 4:6, which says, “Because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, crying, ‘Abba! Father!’” The believer may whisper, but at that precise moment, the Spirit streaks out of heaven like a lightning bolt, joining his voice with the weak, desperate cry of the Christian and splitting the heavens like thunder: “Abba! Father! This is a child of God!” he cries, even when all we can muster is a choked whisper.
It’s critically important to see in all this that the witness of the Spirit—and the assurance it brings—is not a special gift that God gives to some Christians and not others. Some theologians have understood it that way, but that doesn’t seem to be the teaching of the Bible. On the contrary, the Bible couldn’t be clearer that the Spirit is given to every believer, not sometime later in life but at the very moment of salvation. In fact, the Old Testament taught, and Peter reaffirmed in his sermon at Pentecost, that the pouring out of the Spirit was one of the primary marks of the dawning of the messianic age. In other words, if you don’t have the Spirit, you’re outside the Messiah’s kingdom. To be a child of the King is to have his Spirit dwelling in you. Paul teaches this when he speaks of the Holy Spirit as a “seal” in Ephesians 1:13–14:
In him you also, when you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in him, were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, who is the guarantee of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it, to the praise of his glory.
Do you notice what Paul says about when a person receives the seal of the Spirit? It’s not sometime after salvation but “when you heard the word of truth . . . and believed in him.” The Spirit’s coming into your life and beginning his work of testifying with your spirit that you are a child of God happened the moment you bowed your knee to Jesus and trusted in him for salvation.
Notice also that the Spirit’s presence and witness are guarantees of our future, final salvation. When he cries out that we are children of God, that doesn’t mean “just for now” or “but we’ll see what happens.” The indwelling presence of the Spirit in our lives is a down payment on our future salvation, or as Paul put it, “The guarantee of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it” (Eph. 1:14). His cry reverberates through the eons right to the foot of the throne, right to the moment when we are fully and finally declared righteous in God’s sight because of Jesus.
There’s another important issue to consider here, though, because the Spirit’s witness in our lives is not always equally sensible to every believer at every moment. Yes, it is always there; as long as the Spirit lives within us, he bears witness with us that we are children of God. But his witness will be more obvious to us at certain times than at others. Paul seems to acknowledge this when he writes in Romans 5:
Not only that, but we rejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, and endurance produces character, and character produces hope, and hope does not put us to shame, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us. (vv. 3–5)
Paul certainly seems to be talking here again about the witness of the Spirit—his role of pouring into our hearts God’s love and making us sensible of it. But look when that happens: just like in Romans 8, he ties the witness of the Spirit to hard, dark times, times when suffering produces endurance, character, and hope. So, it seems that it may be especially in the hard times, even more than in the easy ones, that the Spirit cries out with a little more volume and parts the clouds so that we become sensible of God’s love for us even more than usual.
The Spirit’s Witness and Our Assurance
In light of everything we’ve learned here, we must keep in mind a few important points regarding the Spirit’s witness. First, we should always remember to keep this third source of assurance—the supernatural witness of the Spirit—in perspective. The witness of the Spirit is not meant to be the primary driving source of your confidence that you are a Christian. If you want your assurance to grow and strengthen, the solution is not simply to sit quietly and hope the Spirit will do it. The solution is to give yourself to deepening your understanding and embrace of the gospel and God’s promises. That in itself will strengthen your faith and assurance, but here’s the thing: it will also give the Spirit the material he always uses to settle and assure your heart.
Think about Paul’s statement again in Romans 5:5, that “God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us.” This verse is referring to a personal, direct experience of the love of God given by the Spirit. But that Spirit-mediated experience of God’s love doesn’t happen out of the blue, as if it were some mystical, trancelike state. How do we know that? Because Paul tells us in the following verses how the Spirit pours the love of God into our hearts. Here’s what he says:
For while we were still weak, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly. For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. (vv. 6–8)
The word for there at the beginning is important. It signals that the Spirit pours the love of God into our hearts because these things are true. In other words, the Spirit’s witness is not content-less. When he pours the love of God into our hearts, he actually takes these very truths of the gospel and makes them sensible to us, igniting them in our hearts. Here’s the point: If you want a heightened experience of the Spirit’s witness (which is there all the time to some degree and has been since the moment you became a Christian), don’t perform some Eastern meditative practice of emptying your mind and waiting on some ecstatic experience. Rather, ask God to give you that experience, but then do the work of stacking your heart with the doctrinal fuel the Holy Spirit ignites. Again, the point is, even when it comes to the witness of the Spirit, the fountainheads of our assurance are the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God. Those are the very things the Spirit uses to pour out an experience of the love of God into our hearts.
Also critical to remember in this regard is that assurance of salvation doesn’t consist solely of the Spirit’s witness, and even less does assurance consist of our experience of the Spirit’s witness. We’ve already said that every believer has the Spirit dwelling within them, and therefore the Spirit does his witnessing work in every believer’s heart. But he doesn’t do so in the same way and with the same intensity at every moment. There are times in life when the Spirit’s direct witness seems relatively quiet to us, sometimes even imperceptible. But that doesn’t mean it is absent, and it also doesn’t mean we should despair of our salvation during those times. On the contrary, our response when the witness of the Spirit seems quiet ought to be to drive our hearts ever more purposefully to the gospel and God’s promises, praying that the Lord will help us have more confidence in them and that the Spirit soon ignites them in a sensible experience of God’s love.
Here’s another important point. It’s critical to keep in mind also that the witness of the Spirit does not trump the other sources of assurance. It always comes in harmony with the other three. Now, on one level, that’s an obvious point to make. If we’re not believers in Christ, then there will be no witness of the Spirit in our hearts because the Holy Spirit will not dwell in our hearts at all. But in a less obvious sense, the witness of the Spirit also cannot be used to negate the testimony of the fourth, confirming source of assurance—the fruits of obedience, which we’ll consider in a later chapter. Here’s what I mean: if our lives are marked not by obedience to Christ but rather by unrepentant sin and allegiance to the world, then we can’t simply say something like, “Well, those things don’t matter because I feel the witness of the Spirit in my heart.” Listen to what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 4:4–5:
I am not aware of anything against myself, but I am not thereby acquitted. It is the Lord who judges me. Therefore do not pronounce judgment before the time, before the Lord comes, who will bring to light the things now hidden in darkness and will disclose the purposes of the heart. Then each one will receive his commendation from God.
Paul’s point here has more to do with his own conscience than with the witness of the Spirit, but the idea is the same. Just because our conscience is clear or we think the Spirit is witnessing with our spirits does not mean everything is fine. If our lives are characterized by darkness, we should not take comfort in a feeling.
Conversely, though, sometimes a believer’s experience of assurance is weaker than perhaps one would expect. That’s when the witness of the Spirit becomes more precious than gold. Here’s how B. B. Warfield puts it:
A man who has none of the marks of a Christian is not entitled to believe himself to be a Christian; only those who are being led by the Spirit of God are children of God. But a man who has all the marks of being a Christian may fall short of his privilege of assurance. It is to such that the witness of the Spirit is superadded, not to take the place of the evidence of “signs,” but to enhance their effect and raise it to a higher plane; not to produce an irrational, unjustified conviction, but to produce a higher and more stable conviction than he would be, all unaided, able to draw; not to supply the lack of evidence, but secure a disease of the mind which will not profit fully by the evidence. . . . The function of the witness of the Spirit of God is, therefore, to give to our halting conclusions the weight of his Divine certitude.
Finally, we have to ask if there’s anything we can do to make it more likely that the Spirit will witness in our souls in this way. Probably the most important answer to give to that question is “Yes, trust in Christ for salvation!” After all, that’s when the Spirit begins to dwell in us, and it’s when he begins to testify with our spirits that we are children of God. Still, though, is there anything we can do to experience an unusually strong witness of the Spirit, a direct and immediate sense of comfort and rest in our salvation? Well, yes, there is. We can pray for it. That’s exactly what Paul does for the Ephesians in Ephesians 3:14–19. He asks the Lord to help them know and experience “what is the breadth and length and height and depth . . . [of] the love of Christ that surpasses knowledge” (vv. 18–19). And who makes Christ’s love sensible to us in that way? Who “pours into our hearts” the love of God? It’s the Holy Spirit (see Rom. 5:5). Paul is praying that the Ephesians would strongly experience the witness of the Spirit, and it is right and good that we should do the same—both for ourselves and for others.
It’s also important to remember here that the Bible seems to indicate that the Spirit tends to give an unusually strong witness not as a kind of spiritual “surprise party” but as wartime reinforcement in the midst of particular hardship, when our own voices have fallen weak and what we need most is encouragement to endure. Maybe that’s in the midst of suffering; maybe it’s in the fires of temptation. But it’s when we have come to the end of our ability to cry out with our own voice, that the Spirit is most likely to thunder forth with his in testimony that we are children of God.
When it comes to the witness of the Spirit, probably the best thing we can do is not to try to manipulate or buy or find it in any way but to pray that God would make the love of Christ sensible and visible to us and then make sure we’re stocking our minds with gospel truths and divine promises so the Spirit can ignite those truths in our hearts when he chooses to do so. After all, like Paul says in Romans 5, the Spirit’s witness isn’t just an untethered feeling; it consists in the Spirit pouring the love of God into our hearts, putting the truths of the gospel in front of our eyes, and supernaturally clearing away the clouds so we can see them in all their sunlit beauty.
