Chapter 10 of 12

8. What about Besetting Sins?

8. What about Besetting Sins?

8

What about Besetting Sins?

My family makes fun of me because one of my favorite movies is Independence Day, the one in which Will Smith punches the alien in the downed spaceship and says, “Welcome to Earth!” My movie tastes are decidedly lowbrow, which is probably why ID4 appeals to me so much. (ID4 is what its die-hard fans call it; I have no idea why the 4 is there.) At any rate, there are gigantic alien spacecrafts hovering over cities, aerial dogfights between F-15 fighters and alien drones, and famous landmarks being blown to pieces by an alien doomsday weapon. Really, what’s not to love?

In one iconic scene, the president of the United States—a young, charismatic former fighter pilot—is holed away in the bunkers of Area 51. When it finally becomes clear that the aliens’ goal is the total eradication of humankind, the president gives the colorful order, “Nuke ’em. Let’s nuke the scoundrels.” (He doesn’t actually say “scoundrels,” but we’ll leave it at that. Google it if you really need to know!) In response to the president’s order, planes scramble and eventually launch a nuclear missile at one of the smaller alien spaceships. There’s a massive whiteout explosion and everyone, including the president, waits for word on the result. A communications officer in the bunker asks insistently into a radio transmitter, “Has the target been destroyed?” Finally, after what seems like an eternity, a pilot visually confirms, “Negative. Target remains. I repeat, target remains.”

Without a doubt, one of the most urgent questions in many Christians’ minds when they begin to think about the topic of assurance is something like this: “But what about this one particular sin that just seems to persist in my life? I hate it. I struggle against it. I repent of it again and again, but the target just . . . remains.” Does the presence of persistent sin mean a person is not a Christian? Is that the right conclusion to draw from applying the Bible’s practical syllogism?

Right from the beginning, we should acknowledge that the presence of long-persistent sins is a common experience among Christians—so common that it’s even earned its own shorthand nickname, “besetting sins,” meaning particular sins that continue to plague a Christian over time despite their justification, regeneration, and even ongoing sanctification. Sometimes these besetting sins can even become the defining battle of one’s life. Besetting sins take many forms in people’s lives. Selfishness, bitterness, anger, lust, gossip, drunkenness, irresponsibility, laziness, worry—all these and more can persist as pitfalls for years in people’s lives, causing them to fall over and over again. So, how should we think about these besetting sins, especially given the Bible’s teaching that “no one who abides in him keeps on sinning” (1 John 3:6)? I think there is much we can say.

First of all, it’s critical to acknowledge that, in one form or another, every Christian has besetting sins. Yes, of course, the particular sins will differ in form, intensity, and even severity of consequences, but every Christian is beset by sin. How exactly can we say that so unequivocally? Because just as clearly as John says that “no one who abides in him keeps on sinning,” he also says, “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us” (1:8). Even after we become Christians, our sin nature remains. Yes, we are set free from the condemnation of sin and its slavery, but the battle between the flesh and the Spirit remains. That’s Paul’s point in Galatians 5:16–25. As Christians, we will always be tempted to live according to the flesh, but our call is to continue to fight to “walk by the Spirit” (v. 16) and “keep in step with the Spirit” (v. 25).

One of the most arresting images Paul uses in that passage is the call for those who believe in Christ to crucify “the flesh with its passions and desires” (v. 24). The image is striking because it implies that we ought to strive to carry on violent, no-holds-barred war against our sin. Yet at the same time, it reminds us of the ongoing nature of that warfare; it will not end quickly or easily. I love how one pastor described the continuing act of crucifying the flesh:

Crucifixion . . . produced death not suddenly but gradually. . . . True Christians do not succeed in completely destroying it (that is the flesh) while here below; but they have fixed it to the cross and they are determined to keep it there till it expires.

The slow crucifixion of the flesh is not the special burden of a few unfortunate or weak Christians. It’s the call and responsibility of every Christian. To be sure, not every Christian’s fight is the same. Sin has colored us all in a thousand awful ways. For some, the ongoing struggle will be against visible, outward behaviors; for others, it will be against hellish attitudes of the heart. For some, the enemies will come rank upon rank for a lifetime; others will be locked in mortal combat against a single enemy for a lifetime. The important point is to recognize that we as Christians will not be completely freed of sin and its effects until we stand with Jesus. In fact, it seems to be the unbroken expectation of the Bible that until that day, and in one way or another, we will all wrestle with sin (see Prov. 20:9; Matt. 6:12–14; Rom. 7:21–25; Gal. 5:17; James 3:2; 1 John 1:8–10).

Second, the presence of besetting sins does not necessarily call into question our salvation. Of course, it could, and we’ll discuss those particular circumstances shortly, but it’s important to remember that John himself recognized that we will repeatedly sin and repeatedly return to the Savior for forgiveness. “If we confess our sins,” he writes, “he is faithful and just to forgive us” (1 John 1:9).

Even more, Jesus himself seemed to recognize that confession of sin is not a one-and-done proposition. In Matthew 18, Peter asks Jesus how many times he should forgive his brother for sinning against him. At first glance, Peter’s initial suggestion seems reasonable, if not generous: “As many as seven times?” he asks. But Jesus’s answer is nothing short of astonishing: “Jesus said to him, ‘I do not say to you seven times, but seventy-seven times’” (vv. 21–22). Don’t sell him short though! Jesus is not saying you get seventy-seven chances, but seventy-eight is a bridge too far. The numbers are symbolic—seven being the number of completeness and ten of totality. So Jesus’s answer is actually, “Well, what is completeness times totality plus another completeness? Whatever it is, you should forgive that many times.” The real encouragement from that exchange with Peter, though, is in the reason Jesus gives for why we ourselves should be unendingly forgiving. It’s because God has forgiven us infinitely more even than that!

The point from both John’s and Jesus’s teachings is that God seems to know and expect that sin will drive us again and again to the Savior for forgiveness. In fact, that may be part of the reason why God doesn’t simply glorify us and free us from all temptation the instant we become Christians. You realize he could have done that, right? In fact, he will do that the moment we either die or rise to meet Christ in the air. “In a moment,” Paul writes, “in the twinkling of an eye . . . we shall be changed” (1 Cor. 15:52). So, if God can make it happen, then why doesn’t he do it the moment we’re converted? Why does he allow us to go on struggling with sin instead of glorifying us immediately? The bottom line is that we probably can’t know all his reasons, but one is surely so that we may learn more and more deeply how to depend on Jesus for life and salvation. And the fact is that the sins with which we struggle the most, and the temptations that continue to entice us most alluringly throughout our lives, often prove to be some of the things that drive us most strongly to despair of self and to trust in Christ. It’s just as Paul writes at the end of Romans 7: “Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord” (vv. 24–25).

Third, we must ask to what degree we should expect to achieve victory over besetting sins in this life. Some have argued that we should expect total victory over every besetting sin; we should expect it in this life; and if a person doesn’t experience that kind of victory, then they cannot possibly be a true Christian. But given even what we’ve discussed in the first two sections of this chapter, that seems to suggest quite a bit more than the Bible actually promises. The ultimate answer to the questions “How much victory should I expect?” or “How much maturity should I expect?” is that it is all in God’s hands. In Hebrews 6:1, the author exhorts his readers to leave the elementary teachings of Christ and “go on to maturity,” a goal we would think would be within God’s will, no question. But then in verse 3, he makes this cryptic remark: “And this we will do if God permits” (emphasis added). What a strange thing to say! Does that mean God might not permit these believers to press on to maturity? Well, yes, and that shouldn’t be entirely surprising to Christians. Our salvation, our growth, our sanctification, our maturity, even our victory over sin are ultimately in his sovereign hands.

The fact is, there is no promise in the Bible of total victory over sin in our lives—even over any particular sin—until we stand in glory with Christ. But even so, it seems reasonable to think we should have a general expectation—though not a watertight guarantee—of some degree of victory over sin. And we certainly should strive and pray for that kind of victory. That’s Paul’s point when he writes that because you have been crucified and resurrected with Christ, you should

let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body, to make you obey its passions. Do not present your members to sin as instruments for unrighteousness, but present yourselves to God as those who have been brought from death to life, and your members to God as instruments for righteousness. For sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace. (Rom. 6:12–14)

Paul’s point is not that we will always win in our battle against sin but that we are free now to fight it and not simply obey it. We are no longer slaves; we are warriors. So, the general expectation would seem to be that we will see some degree of increased victory, and at least periods of victory, as our love for Christ deepens and our ability to stand firm against temptation therefore increases. At the very least, with any particular sin, we can be confident that a true Christian will not be consumed by it. At some point, the God who will not lose a single one of those whom he has given to his Son will say to the destroying waters of sin, “Thus far shall you come, and no farther” (Job 38:11).

Fourth, we should ask at what point any particular persistent sin should cause a Christian to fear for their salvation. The presence of a besetting sin should cause genuine alarm in two situations. The first is when the reality is not that you are struggling with a narrow streak of sin in the tapestry of a life that is otherwise marked by love for God and growth in Christ, but rather you are staring at a pattern of sin that has become the dominant character of your life. When your besetting sins have grown to the point that your affections, plans, thoughts, emotions, actions, and words are determined and shaped by those sins, they have become dangerous—a genuine threat to the credibility of your profession of faith.

The second circumstance that should cause alarm is when your besetting sins have ceased to bother you—when your heart has made peace with those sins and even longs for them, finds comfort in them, justifies them, and no longer rises up in rebellion against them. The point is, you can’t simply categorize a sin in your life as “besetting” and declare that it therefore doesn’t matter anymore or that you’re somehow excused from fighting it. “Well, this is just my besetting sin” is not an excuse not to fight. In fact, such a response might well be more like the response of a child of the darkness than a child of the light.

When it comes to any sin—whether one that’s easily beaten or one that requires a lifetime of warfare—the critical issue is not the behavior itself (after all, not all sins are behaviors at all) but rather how your heart responds to it. I love how one writer beautifully puts this truth:

The difference between an unconverted and a converted man is not that the one has sins and the other has none; but that the one takes part with his cherished sins against a dreaded God, and the other takes part with a reconciled God against his hated sins.

Ultimately, this is the critical question: Have you surrendered to sin, or are you fighting it? The fact is, I would have far more confidence in the true faith of a person who is wholeheartedly fighting a battle with heinous visible sin, regularly losing, and each time crying out to Christ for mercy than I would in a person who has given up on fighting even the smallest, most invisible peccadillo. The former person is a warrior who has said to sin, “You may beat me over and over, but I have a new King now, and for his sake I will never live at peace with you again!” And the other? They have knelt at sin’s feet.

You see, the call to fight is a call to every Christian, whether or not they can identify a particular persistent sin in their life. The important thing in the war against sin is not so much to see victory; that will come in due time, when God permits. For now, the important thing is to make sure you can see the smoke of battle. There’s the question: When you look at your own sin, persistent or not, do you see the smoke of battle? And if not, why not?

Fifth and finally, what should you do with the sin that persists in your life? I think there are two kinds of people we must address here. Perhaps you’re a Christian who is in the midst of a smoky battle against your sin—tempted, torn, tried, weary, worn, and tired—and yet clinging to Jesus for mercy with all your might and doing everything you can to resist sin and war against it. To you, the message is simple: be encouraged and keep fighting! You are not alone in having to fight against sin; that’s exactly what the Bible tells us to expect. After all, a declaration of faith in Jesus is a declaration of war against hell. And guess what happens when you declare war against hell and sin? It declares war right back. Besides, the very mark of a Christian with regard to sin is that they will keep fighting, keep wrestling and striving, keep running the race set before them. And that’s exactly what you’re doing. Listen, your battle with sin will not last forever, and the Bible’s promise is that you will outlast your sin. You will live to see it pulled from your heart by the roots and vanquished. It will take its last breath as you take your first in the bright air of eternity. Live and fight and trust Christ for that day.

But perhaps you’re the other kind of person, the kind who is in fact not in the midst of a struggle against sin. It’s not that you’ve defeated it; it’s that you’ve surrendered to it. Perhaps, even by reading parts of this book, you’ve been shocked into realizing that your lack of assurance is entirely warranted because it’s caused by the fact that you are living like a child of the darkness. Sin has become the dominant color on your canvas. If that’s your situation, then what you need to do is simple: repent. Agree with God about the evil of your sin, and repent. Repentance is not just a matter of emotion or of stopping some behavior. It’s a matter of doing everything necessary to embrace the beauty of Christ and learning to love him more than you love your sin.

In the end, when it comes to persistent sin in our lives, there’s no flowchart to follow, as if we could answer six questions and have a diagnosis and prescription in hand. As Christians, we must fight sin with constant vigilance and constant awareness that we are not home yet. We should also constantly remind our hearts that our hope for eternity doesn’t rest in our attaining perfection but rather in our knowing that Jesus attained perfection for us and won our salvation. In our fight against sin, we’re always faced with two pitfalls. One is obvious. It is to stop caring about it, to be defeated by it, to give in to it and sink into the darkness. But the other is evil in its subtlety and just as deadly. It is to make perfection or even victory an idol, to foolishly put our trust in our own sin-fighting prowess rather than in the Savior and to think that one day we will stand before God and say, “I beat it. That’s why you should accept me!” As Christians, we must be vigilant not to fall into either of those traps. Rather, we must be aware of our sin, let it drive us to Christ and his gospel, and then let his love for us and our love for him motivate us in our resistance to sin until he glorifies us in his presence on the last day.

Finally, it’s crucial to understand that our fight as Christians is not only against something but also for something. We don’t just fight against the horror of sin; we fight for the glories of eternity. For all its notoriety as a book that frightens Christians, 1 John is actually chock-full of encouragements to Christians about what they are fighting for, not just what they are fighting against. For example, in 1 John 2:28, John holds out to us the prospect that we can have confidence about the coming of Jesus. We don’t have to dread it as a day of shame and uncovering; instead, we can look forward to it as redeemed people whose sins have been cast into a bottomless sea. We needn’t shrink from that day, but rather we should strain forward to reach it, knowing that when Jesus returns, our struggle with sin will be finished once and for all and we will finally be able to rest.

John also encourages us to rejoice in our adoption as children of God. He writes, “See what kind of love the Father has given to us, that we should be called children of God; and so we are” (1 John 3:1). That verse really should contain more exclamation points, because John is writing with astonished exultation. “Look at this!” he is saying. “Can you believe it?! What kind of love is it that would take sinners like us and make us children of God?” This doctrine of adoption must be one of the most precious and unexpected truths in the entire Bible. Why? Because God could have saved us by doing so much less than that. He could have forgiven us, made us servants, given us the rank of the angels, anything—and the universe would have stood astonished at his mercy. But he did more than all of that. He made us sons and daughters. He put robes on our shoulders and rings on our fingers and embraced us and welcomed us home. That’s why we fight—not just because sin is our mortal enemy, but because God is our Father. We fight as sons and daughters of the King.

Last, John encourages us to look forward to the day when we will be like Jesus: “Beloved, we are God’s children now, and what we will be has not yet appeared; but we know that when he appears we shall be like him, because we shall see him as he is” (v. 2). That has been the goal since the very beginning; it is what God predestined for you as one he foreloved—“to be conformed to the image of his Son” (Rom. 8:29). Take heart in knowing that God’s purposes will never fail. The day is coming when your struggle against sin, your exhausting resistance against the world and the flesh and the devil will end. The day is coming when you will be like Jesus.

I once had a poster hanging in my office that depicted a sculpture. At first glance, it looked like a crystal man, his arms stretched up to heaven, being swallowed from below by some sinister, gray-colored mud creeping up his legs. But at the bottom of the poster were printed the words from 1 John 3:2: “What we will be has not yet appeared.” You see, the crystal man wasn’t being swallowed by his sin; he was escaping it. He was being pulled out of it. Against all odds, he was being glorified and made like Christ. Dear Christian, the day is coming when God will extract you from the battle, remove sin once and for all from your heart, and set you on high with Christ. Until then, keep fighting. Keep resisting. Keep loving. And above all, keep setting your eyes on Jesus.

↑ Back to top

↑