Chapter 7 of 12

5. The Undermining of Assurance

5. The Undermining of Assurance

5

The Undermining of Assurance

The Lies We Believe

A few years ago, I was walking through a particular area of downtown Louisville when I noticed a series of thunderous booms crashing through the city’s air every few seconds. No one around me seemed too concerned, but it was a little disconcerting. My mind cycled through the possibilities. Was it thunder? No, too rhythmic. Automobile accidents? No—since when do wrecks happen every few seconds in a regular pattern? Bombs dropping? Possible . . . but unlikely.

I didn’t solve the mystery until a few days later when I was driving on the interstate that runs along the Ohio River. Construction had just begun some weeks earlier on a massive new bridge across the river, and now as I looked out across the water I saw what was producing those thunderous booms. Floating on the water was an enormous barge with a towering structure rising from its deck. Every few seconds, some sort of engineering marvel inside that structure would hammer down with enormous force on what I assume was a steel beam, driving it deeper and deeper into the riverbed below. Eventually, that beam would make its way through the unstable mud and silt at the bottom of the river and bite, finally, into bedrock. And the deeper into that bedrock it was driven by the powerful machine above it, the stronger the bridge’s foundation would be.

The memory of those steel beams being driven into bedrock has stuck with me over the years because it’s a wonderful image of what it means to build a foundation for Christian assurance. The currents of life will always flow around and push against us, but as long as our confidence is driven deep into the bedrock of the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God, we’ll be able to stand firm in the full assurance of faith. To be sure, that’s not easy work. Just as it took repeated, ear-splittingly powerful hammer blows to drive those steel beams into the riverbed, so it takes concerted and repeated effort to make sure our confidence and assurance are grounded in the gospel and the promises rather than in ourselves and our own efforts. That’s been our work so far—to identify spiritual bedrock and begin to drive our confidence deeply into it. Even while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us, and God himself has promised that everyone who believes in him will have eternal life.

At this point, though, we should take some time to see and guard against another threat to our assurance. Imagine for a moment if some enemy decided to take down Louisville’s new bridge across the Ohio River. They could use several strategies to do so. If they wanted to take it out quickly, a few well-placed explosives could do the trick in an instant. But what if they wanted to do it more slowly, maybe even make the whole thing look a bit more like a natural process? One idea would be to invent some way to gradually introduce a powerful acid into the bedrock that would soften it and eventually make it too weak to support the bridge’s foundation. The process would be slower than explosives, but just as effective. Given enough time, the whole bridge would come down.

When it comes to our assurance, there are times when life and the Enemy himself set off explosives under our assurance. But it seems that far more often one of Satan’s greatest strategies for destroying our assurance is to introduce a cocktail of acids into the very bedrock of our understanding of both the gospel and God’s promises to those who trust in Jesus. And what are those acids? Lies. Untruths that make the gospel seem less trustworthy and the promises of God less reliable and less comforting. And once those satanic lies have done their work, our assurance collapses into the water.

In this chapter, we’ll spend some time looking at four of those assurance-dissolving lies and think together about precisely why they are untrue and how we can defend against them. Be careful not to let yourself off the hook too easily here. Sometimes, yes, we can embrace these lies as conscious theological principles. But the sad and dangerous truth is that sometimes we find ourselves believing lies without even really being conscious of doing so, and these “hidden” lies can be the hardest to identify and root out. As we consider these four lies, then, ask yourself not just whether you’d consciously affirm them as positive theological principles but also whether they might sometimes sneak into your hidden assumptions without you even really noticing.

Lie #1: Jesus Loves Me, but God the Father Really Doesn’t

Theologically and historically speaking, this lie—Jesus loves me, but God doesn’t—has had a long and notorious history, usually taking the form of drawing a hard distinction between the God of the Old Testament and the incarnate God of the New Testament. The heretic Marcion once declared that the God of the Old Testament was an evil and wrathful deity whom Jesus had come to oppose and defeat. Marcion even began his New Testament at Luke 4:31—“And Jesus came down to Capernaum . . .”—as if Jesus simply descended from heaven!

Not many people consciously believe that anymore, of course, but the idea that God the Son and God the Father are somehow at odds with each other when it comes to our salvation still shows up subtly now and again. You may even have heard this falsehood in gospel presentations or sermons. “Jesus stood between you and the Father’s wrath,” the preacher will say. “When God the Father, the Great Judge of all the earth, would have destroyed you for your sin, Jesus spread his arms on the cross and cried, ‘No!’” Of course, it’s true that Jesus did in fact exhaust the Father’s righteous wrath against sin when he died on the cross. He was without doubt, as Paul says in Romans 3:25, “a propitiation,” a sacrifice of atonement that satisfies and exhausts God’s wrath. It’s also true that those who persist in rebellion against God will endure not only the metaphorical “wrath” of sin’s natural consequences but also the personal wrath of God the Father, the all-righteous Judge of all the earth. “Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life,” John writes, but “whoever does not obey the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God remains on him” (John 3:36, emphasis added).

But to think of God the Father as a wrathful Judge and God the Son as the One who stands in his way and absorbs his anger is fatally simplistic. It’s not true, and it doesn’t even begin to capture what the Bible teaches about the love of the Triune God. Take the propitiation language from Romans 3, for example. Who offered Jesus as a propitiation? God the Father did. And Christ’s death for us while we were still sinners is precisely how “God shows his love for us” (Rom. 5:8). Don’t miss the logical progression here. It’s not that Jesus died for us while we were sinners and then God loved us. It’s that God loved us and therefore Christ died for us while we were sinners. Look also at what Paul writes in Ephesians 2:

You were dead in the trespasses and sins . . . and were by nature children of wrath, like the rest of mankind. But God, being rich in mercy, because of the great love with which he loved us, even when we were dead in our trespasses, made us alive together with Christ—by grace you have been saved—and raised us up with him and seated us with him in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus, so that in the coming ages he might show the immeasurable riches of his grace in kindness toward us in Christ Jesus. (vv. 1, 3–7)

Who saw us in our sin-induced calamity and acted to save us? It was God! Just as God the Son died for us while we were still sinners, so God the Father set the wheels of redemption in motion while we were dead in trespasses and sins. And look at the reason he did so. It was “because of the great love with which he loved us,” a love that erupted from his own divine character, which is “rich in mercy.” But that’s not even the end. Look at the goal God has for showing this love to sinners. It’s so that in the coming ages—that is, for all eternity—he might pour out on them “the immeasurable riches of his grace in kindness toward us in Christ Jesus.”

This is a powerful truth when it comes to the strength of our assurance. If we believe the lie that Jesus loves us but the Father simply tolerates us because Jesus insists on it, then we’ll always harbor a fear that God doesn’t really want us in his presence. He will seem distant, fearsome, and forever faultfinding, and the result will be a nagging desire to escape him rather than run to him. The theologian John Owen writes pointedly about how this lie undermines our assurance:

How few of the saints are experimentally acquainted with this privilege of holding immediate communion with the Father in love! With what anxious, doubtful thoughts do they look upon Him! What fears, what questionings are there, of his good will and kindness! At the best, many think that there is no sweetness at all in God towards us, but what is purchased at the high price of the blood of Jesus.

Of course, it’s true that the blood of Jesus is the means by which God’s love comes to us and benefits us. “That alone is the way of communication,” Owen says. But then he puts the truth beautifully: “But the free fountain and spring of all is in the bosom of the Father (1 John 1:2).” Owen is exactly right. Your salvation is not an act of Jesus in opposition to his Father but rather in perfect union with his Father and the Spirit. If you are a believer, then you can be assured that the entire Triune Godhead—God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit—is united in love and power to save you and bring you safely home.

So, don’t for a moment believe the devil’s lie that Jesus loves you, but the Father doesn’t. Don’t be afraid that God the Father is holding his nose as Jesus brings you into his presence, or looking away in disgust and barely managing to hold back his wrath, or even that he only began to love you once Jesus died. On the contrary, remember that salvation sprang like a fountain from his own eternal riches of mercy and love, and revel in the fact that God rejoices over you even now with singing, celebrating that his wayward child is back in his arms.

Lie #2: God Is Fundamentally Stingy and Naturally against Us

As Genesis 3 records, Satan convinced Adam and Eve to join him in his rebellion against the Most High God by blatantly lying to them. As flagrant as his lie was, though, it was also insidiously subtle, leading Adam and Eve to doubt not just one or two things God had said but also, and even more importantly, who God was. Essentially, Satan’s lie came in two parts from his forked tongue. First, he simply and flatly contradicted God’s promise from Genesis 2:17 that Adam and Eve would surely die if they ate from the tree in the center of the garden. “You will not surely die,” Satan said (Gen. 3:4). With that, he tempted Eve to doubt God’s word.

The second part of his falsehood, though, was arguably even more evil, for it tempted Eve to doubt not just God’s word but his character. “For God knows that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil” (v. 5). Satan wanted Adam and Eve to believe that God was denying them something good and desirable, revealing himself to be fundamentally stingy, ungenerous, and unloving. Of course, nothing could have been further from the truth. God had placed Adam and Eve in a beautiful garden full of trees that would meet their every need and fill them with every joy. He had even commanded them to enjoy the fruit of those trees, but Satan’s triumph was to close Adam’s and Eve’s eyes to God’s boundless generosity and focus their minds on the one thing in all creation God had withheld from them—a single tree, which was a reminder to them that their freedom and authority were limited by his own. What the serpent injected into Adam’s and Eve’s minds that day was a venom that convinced them God was not generous and loving and for them but rather fundamentally crabbed and stingy and selfishly against them.

One pastor, Sinclair Ferguson, evocatively calls this satanic falsehood “the Edenic poison,” the lie of the “not-to-be-trusted-because-he-does-not-love-me false Father,” and points out how this poison, once injected into the human psyche, spread universally and has affected sinful human beings ever since. This is how we think about God now; this is what we wrongly believe him to be—a God who desires not to give us joy and happiness but rather to withhold them, at least until we have paid enough to earn his grudging favor. And the sad truth is that this poisonous lie continues to affect us even after the powerful antidote of the gospel of free grace is administered. The gospel tells us that God is unspeakably loving and kind, that his favor does not have to be—indeed, cannot be—earned, but is offered as a free gift to those who believe. It tells us that salvation is not wrested from his unwilling hand but is lavished on his people for eternity out of the inexhaustible riches of his grace. That’s what we believe when we embrace the gospel—and yet still we struggle not to succumb to the lie! The Edenic poison still numbs our minds, tempting us to think that God’s blessings remain locked away—his heart closed, his face stern.

This is a critical point when it comes to our assurance of salvation. When assurance weakens and dies, this is always the rot that has infected the root of faith—a suspicion that the gospel is not really free, that redemption is not really a gift, that what Jesus really meant when he cried out, “It is finished” was “I’ve done my part; now it’s your turn to do yours.” And so we begin to wonder whether our lives truly merit what God is offering, and we assume he is looking down at us, wondering the same thing. And the result of that, as we look into our hearts and see the sin and selfishness that still boil there, is doubt and fear and shame before the eyes of a God we imagine to be shaking his head in disgust.

But how different is the truth of the gospel from that venomous lie. According to Ferguson, the gospel is like a specially designed antidote to the Edenic poison.

The gospel is designed to deliver us from this lie. For it reveals that behind and manifested in the coming of Christ and his death for us is the love of a Father who gives us everything he has: first his Son to die for us and then his Spirit to live within us.

Dear Christian, does this Edenic poison still course through your veins? Then drink deeply of the antidote of the gospel. Remember the infinite well of love from which your salvation springs, the fathomless generosity of a Father who would deliver his only Son to death for your sake, and the bottomless riches he has promised you in eternity (Rom. 8:32). Satan is a liar. The Lord is not stingy and ungenerous and against us. He is Immanuel, God with us, God for us.

Lie #3: Jesus Is Merely the Means to the Greater End of Heaven’s Blessings

Mansions in glory. I remember, as a child growing up in a Baptist church in Texas, mentally measuring the drapes (and the tennis court!) for the mansion waiting for me on the shore of the Crystal Sea. “I’ve got a mansion just over the hilltop,” we’d sing in church. “We will never more wander, but walk on streets that are purest gold!” All praise to Jesus, I thought, for getting me such a good deal!

Eventually, I matured as a Christian and realized that the mansion and the gold pavement aren’t really the point—God is. Being in his presence, seeing his face. But even once we get past the point of thinking about eternity in terms of the real estate, we Christians still have a natural tendency to think of the blessings of salvation as abstracted from (that is, separate from) Jesus. So the thinking goes that Jesus, because of what he did for us, has the right and ability now to give us the blessings of eternity—eternal life, glorification, heaven, the new heaven and new earth, all of it. He has access to it, we think, and can give it to us if he decides to do so. In the end, though, he is merely the means by which we obtain the greater end of heaven’s blessings.

Of course, the Bible teaches no such thing. Jesus is the Alpha and the Omega, the beginning and the end, and the greatest blessing of heaven is not mansions or streets, even ones made of gold, but rather to behold the King there in his beauty, to see him face-to-face, and to be in fellowship with him forever. To most Christians, that’s not a new thought; we know deep down that the Giver matters far more than the gifts he gives, and that he himself is the right object of our affections. But a subtle variation on this theme often creeps into our thinking and can be surprisingly toxic to a strong sense of assurance and confidence in Christ. What is that error? It is to abstract and separate salvation itself from Jesus—not in the sense of thinking that salvation can be attained without him (it can’t) but to think of salvation as something distinct from him and after him, something he can give if we come to him in faith, but that we have not yet grasped even if we have grasped him.

Here’s how the acid of this lie works: When we think of Jesus as the means of salvation—rather than the very essence of it—our minds immediately begin to ask the question “How do I get salvation?” instead of “How do I get Christ?” And the result will always be that our hearts will begin striving to convince the One who can give salvation that we are worthy of it and that he should in fact give it to us. But as we’ve seen time and again, that kind of thinking will sink us into a vortex of trying to attain self-assurance, a project that is doomed to fail and thus will always prove to be depressingly futile.

But the wonder of the gospel is that salvation is not something separate from and distinct from and after Christ. To have Christ is to have salvation. “Christ Jesus,” Paul writes, “became to us wisdom from God, righteousness and sanctification and redemption” (1 Cor. 1:30). See the point there? Jesus does not merely give those things; he is those things. To have him is to have them.

Here’s the thing: If salvation and its blessings are distinct from Christ, and he is merely a means to the end of obtaining them, then no real rest can be found in him. Rest can only be had at some point after him. But if we take the Bible to heart in understanding that to embrace him is to embrace salvation, then we can rest in the knowledge that our salvation really is finished; once we have embraced him, there is nothing greater, nothing more beautiful, nothing after or beyond, and we can rest in the full assurance that by having him, we have all.

The Philippian jailer asked Paul and Silas, “Sirs, what must I do to be saved?” (Acts 16:30). In all likelihood, he wasn’t expecting the answer they gave him. Probably he was thinking they would tell him, right in line with his question, some things to do. Maybe he would have to help them escape from prison, or perform some sacrifices, or convert to Judaism. Who knows? The point is, he was frightened by what God had done around him that night, and he wanted to know what God required of him now. Paul’s answer was likely not at all what he was anticipating because it didn’t call on him to do anything except to embrace in faith the One who had already done everything. “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved” (v. 31). It wasn’t, “Believe in Jesus, then do these things, and you will be saved.” It was simply, “Embrace Jesus, and in so doing, you embrace salvation.”

If the question in our minds is “How can I obtain salvation?” then the answers to that question will ramify into a thousand demands on our time and attention. The requirements will overwhelm us. Instead, we must embrace the answer the Bible gives. How can I obtain salvation? By obtaining Christ. And how do I obtain Christ? Simply and solely and only by faith.

If you have embraced Christ by faith, dear Christian, there is nothing else—nothing else to be done to win salvation and nothing greater to be obtained. By embracing Christ, you have embraced righteousness and salvation. Rest in that truth, and revel in the fact that all that is lacking is the moment when you will look finally into the face of your Redeemer, your Salvation, your King. The great blessing of salvation is not a mansion you do not yet have. It is Jesus himself, and you do have him—right here and right now.

Lie #4: God Has Opened a Door of Salvation, but He Is Largely Indifferent Regarding Who Walks Through It

So many of the lies we believe are variations on the second one we considered—the Edenic poison that God is fundamentally stingy and against us—and this one is no different. Lie number four is the thought that while God has opened the door of salvation and invited us to come in, he largely stands now as an uninterested doorman, welcoming those who come but not uniquely invested in the salvation of any particular person. In a way, this error rises from a misunderstanding of biblical verses such as 1 Timothy 2:4, which says God “desires all people to be saved,” and 2 Peter 3:9, with its teaching that God is patient with us, “not wishing that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance.”

Understood rightly, these verses are a wonderful affirmation of God’s Creator-love for all human beings. He made us all, and therefore as our Creator, he loves us. But verses like these also do not tell the whole story of God’s love, and if we imagine they do, we will fail to appreciate God’s passion for his people. We’ll picture him as offering a generalized invitation to salvation for all humanity but then stepping aside and disinterestedly allowing those who will to accept it. But the Bible actually says far more about God’s love than that. In fact, the Bible talks about several kinds of love that God has for his creation and his people.

The deepest and most profound divine love the Bible teaches is the love that lies at the essence of God’s very character and nature, the mutual love shared eternally between Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in the unity of the Godhead. “God is love,” John says (1 John 4:8), and therefore the love he shows for us is nothing less than the overflow of his own eternal nature.

Even in its overflow, however, that eternal, divine love takes several forms. First, there’s the general love that God has for his entire creation, including the nonhuman parts of it. This is reflected in his declaration in Genesis 1:31 that “God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good.” Jesus too tells of how God’s Creator-love shows itself in his care for the birds of the air and even the grasses of the field (see Matt. 6:25–30). Second, though, there is also the particular love God has for all humanity, that is, for all those who are created in his image. This is a higher love than creation-love, a love reflected in verses such as 1 Timothy 2:4 and 2 Peter 3:9, which highlight that God’s basic desire for all humanity is that none should perish.

But our understanding of God’s love can’t stop there, because the Bible teaches another aspect of God’s love that is not general but rather is focused on individuals. We’ve already seen this particular love in Ephesians 2:4–5, in which Paul writes that “God, being rich in mercy, because of the great love with which he loved us, even when we were dead in our trespasses, made us alive together with Christ.” Do you see the unique nature of that “great love with which he loved us”? That’s not just a general love for all humanity, and we know that because the result of it is that God makes us alive in Christ. If that “great love” were generalized to include all humanity, then all humanity would be made alive in Christ. No, this is a particular, individual, distinguishing, electing love.

Another passage in which we see this particular electing love of God is Romans 8:29–30, right at the beginning of what is often called “The Golden Chain of Salvation.” At the fountainhead of that chain is Paul’s affirmation that “those whom he foreknew he also predestined.” Some misunderstand the word foreknew as simply a kind of divine foresight into the future, as if God looked down through history, saw those who would respond to him in faith, and predestined those who met that qualification. But the Bible knows nothing of that kind of divine fortune-telling in regard to salvation, and as so often is true in the Bible, the word knew is not just about bare knowledge but intimacy. The word means that God “foreloved.” And what happens to those who are foreloved by God in this way? They are—all of them—predestined and then called and then justified and then glorified. To be so foreloved by God in eternity-past is to be assured of being glorified in eternity-future. Again, this is a specific, personal, discriminating love.

Do you see the importance of this concept to our sense of assurance? It lies here: our confidence that we will finally be saved depends largely on how sure we are that God actually loves us. So, if my vision of God is that he is largely indifferent to me as an individual—that he’s glad for people to come through the doors of heaven but doesn’t much care who they are—then I will always be tempted in a thousand ways to doubt whether he really cares if I am there with him in the end or not. And that in turn will introduce distance and coldness and suspicion into my relationship with him. The Edenic poison will flow again through my heart.

What the Bible teaches, though, is the exact opposite of that. God’s love for us is personal and individual and specific and passionate. If our faith is in Jesus, if we are clinging to him, then God has had his love set on us since before the foundation of the world. The Son of God knew us by name and his response to our slavery under sin, to our death in our transgressions, was not a ho-hum stroll to the doors of heaven and a bored “Come if you want” invitation. No, his response was to roar from his throne with the shout, “I’m going to get them!”

Dear Christian, you are loved—specifically, individually, and particularly. Never for a moment believe the lie that God is somehow indifferent as to whether you finally make it safely home. On the contrary, he has given all the resources of divine omnipotence to the cause of bringing you to his embrace. Why? Because the number of the elect, the population of heaven—the very mission of his Son—would be incomplete without you. Revel again in these words, because they are about you:

My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me. I give them eternal life, and they will never perish, and no one will snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all, and no one is able to snatch them out of the Father’s hand. I and the Father are one. (John 10:27–30)

One in essence, one in glory, and one in omnipotent determination to raise you up at the last day!

Looking Ahead

So far in this book we’ve considered three of what the Bible holds out as sources of our assurance. We’ve seen how the gospel of Jesus Christ undermines at every step our own tendency to desire self-assurance and throws us helpless on the person and work of Jesus Christ. But we’ve also seen how despairing of our own self-worth and learning to trust and rely on Christ alone for our salvation provide an immovably secure foundation for our confidence and assurance. He is the same yesterday, today, and forever; he has finished the work of redemption; and therefore, as the old confession puts it, “he is a compassionate, a suitable, and an all-sufficient Savior.”

We’ve also considered how God’s promises to save all those who come to Christ in faith and to preserve them until the end provide another solid foundation for our assurance. If God has promised something, then he must do it or else violate and contradict his own character. Therefore, if he has said he will save those who come to Christ in faith, he will save those who come to Christ. If he has said he will lose none of those who come but raise them up at the last day, then he will lose none of those who come. In fact, to fail or default on either of those promises would be not just to contradict his own character but also to impugn the honor of his Son.

Those two immovable truths—the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God—are the sources, the drivers, the accelerators of our assurance. If you want to increase your assurance and confidence and faith, focus there. Put the weight of your attention and energy there. Study and meditate on the gospel; remember and deepen your understanding of God’s promises, as well as his own character and love for his Son that undergird them. Assurance is never strengthened by trying to make yourself more worthy of salvation, much less wallowing in worry and guilt that you’re not. God does not call you to make yourself worthy of the blessings of eternity; he calls you to recognize and trust in the fact that Christ is worthy on your behalf and in your place.

Finally, we’ve seen how the Holy Spirit, who dwells in us as a guarantee of our future inheritance from the moment we trust in Christ, testifies with our own spirit that we are children of God. Especially in the times when we are hard-pressed by temptation and hardship, he parts the clouds so that we can see the gospel of Jesus Christ and the promises of God in all their glorious beauty.

There’s still more to consider, though, because the Bible holds out one more truth that bears on our assurance. It’s not a driver of assurance, but it is an indicator that we are children of God, and therefore it also bears on our sense of assurance. That indicator is the fruit of good works. It’s to that topic that we now turn.

↑ Back to top

↑