6. The Confirming Source of Assurance
6
The Confirming Source of Assurance
The Fruits of Obedience
Besides the gospel of Jesus Christ, the promises of God, and the witness of the Holy Spirit, one more reality bears on the strength or weakness of our assurance—our own lives. My guess is that as a reader of a book like this one, you have been waiting for this chapter. Because despite all we’ve said so far about the other three sources of assurance, several nagging questions have been at the back of your mind: “How do I know my life doesn’t show my faith in the gospel to be a fraud?” “How do I know my works don’t show my faith in God’s promises to be false?” “How do I know my ‘fruit count’ doesn’t prove that the witness of the Spirit in my heart is really not the witness of the Spirit at all?”
Those are important questions that plague many Christians who struggle with assurance of salvation. In fact, it’s this source—the speedometer, so to speak—that shipwrecks assurance in countless Christians’ lives.
Why is that? Perhaps the first answer we should give is that for some professing Christians, the speedometer reads “zero” because they really have no true faith. Their lives—shot through with sin and continuing, unrepentant rebellion against God—show that their faith really is empty. For such people, the fact that they have no assurance of salvation is not a bad thing at all. Their faith in Christ really is superficial and the speedometer is simply telling them so! Those people shouldn’t have a strong sense of assurance of salvation because they truly have no genuine faith in Christ. For them, the solution isn’t to fix the speedometer or to distrust it but rather to listen to it—to heed its warning, recognize that their “faith” is what James calls a “dead faith,” and repent of their sin and trust in Jesus for salvation.
But sometimes and for some Christians—perhaps even for most Christians—that’s not what’s really happening when the speedometer wrecks their assurance. Rather, the problem is often that Christians simply don’t understand how the Bible’s teaching on good works functions theologically, and therefore they make mistakes in using it. In the next couple of chapters, our goal is thus to understand the speedometer—its purpose, function, and place in the architecture of assurance—and then to consider several ways Christians tend to misuse it.
Before we get started, though, it will be helpful to make two important observations about our good works and their role in our assurance. The first is that we’re not spending so much time on this fourth source of assurance because it is the most important. We are spending the most time on it because it is the most complicated and therefore the most prone to being misunderstood and misused. It would be a crying shame if the result of having read this book was that your eyes became even more focused on yourself. Robert Murray McCheyne was exactly right when he counseled, “For every look at yourself, take ten looks at Christ!” In the same way, I hope that after reading this book you understand the architecture of assurance better, and therefore I hope your eyes and heart are fixed more solidly on the gospel and the promises of God. Look at the fruit, yes. Let it be a warning to you when necessary and a confirmation when appropriate. But do not put your faith in it.
Here’s the second observation: many Christians would be surprised to realize that when the Bible talks about the relationship between our good works and assurance, the purpose is almost always to settle believers’ hearts and consciences, to confirm them and comfort them, not to terrify them. Here’s an example. A few years ago, I announced to my church that I was planning to preach a short sermon series through the book of 1 John. I was astonished by the response to that announcement, because more than a handful of people communicated to me that they were terrified to hear those sermons. Why? Because they assumed the message of 1 John—with his three tests of genuine faith or marks of a true Christian—was meant to unsettle Christians’ consciences, to make them doubt their salvation so that they’d be better behaved. In a certain sense, those people’s fear of the message of 1 John was entirely legitimate; the book is notorious for making Christians doubt whether they really are Christians. In fact, nearly every time I’ve heard the book taught, that’s exactly how it’s been used—as a bludgeon to make Christians doubt.
But that’s deeply ironic, and even wrong, because John repeatedly says his purpose for writing is so that his readers may know they are children of God, believers in Jesus, and heirs of eternal life. Look how that glorious word know echoes like a drumbeat throughout the book:
By this we know that we have come to know him . . . Therefore we know . . . because you know . . . because you know . . . we know . . . you know . . . we know . . . you know . . . we know . . . we shall know that we are of the truth and reassure our heart before him . . . for he knows everything . . . we know that he abides in us . . . you know the Spirit of God . . . By this we know . . . By this we know . . . so we have come to know . . . By this we know . . . we know . . . we know . . . we know . . . we know . . . so that we may know . . . I write these things to you who believe in the name of the Son of God so that you may know that you have eternal life.
Thirty-seven times in thirty verses John says the goal of his book is knowledge, not doubt. Even as he lays out his three “tests” or “marks,” their purpose is not ultimately to make Christians say, “Oh no, I’ll never live up to that” but rather, “Okay, I can see those realities in myself, not perfectly, not completely, but they’re there.”
That’s how most of the Bible passages that teach on these matters are supposed to function. Even the warning passages, such as Hebrews 6, for example, aren’t there ultimately to terrify but rather to assure, even if that assurance comes by cautioning a believer to stay away from a deadly path. In this chapter, then, we’ll begin to consider the Bible’s teaching on how our own good works relate to our assurance.
How Good Works Are a Confirming Source of Assurance
Throughout history, some Christians have denied that our works should have any bearing on our sense of assurance at all. At some level, that’s understandable, and for a few reasons. For one thing, there’s always the danger that our focus will be too much on our works, even to the point that our faith subtly shifts from Christ to self. Thus, some Christians have argued that works can and should play no role in our assurance, but rather our entire focus should be on Christ and the gospel. Besides, those Christians have argued, until we stand with Jesus, our obedience will be so imperfect as to be a hopelessly unreliable indicator of the reality of our faith. In fact, the argument goes, to find any degree of confidence or assurance in our own works is antithetical to saving faith itself, which by definition requires a renunciation of confidence in our own works.
Those arguments hold some force, to be sure, and we always have to be careful to keep our faith firmly rooted in Christ, not ourselves. To fail in that would be more than unhealthy; it would be eternally deadly. But at the same time, it’s also clear that the Bible draws a connection between the works we do and our sense of confidence that we really are Christians. Let’s look at a few such passages.
1 John
One of the most obvious and famous parts of Scripture that draws a connection between our lives and our assurance is the entire book of 1 John. The book—which is really a circular letter—seems to have been written to a whole group of churches in a particular area, and John’s purpose in writing it was to encourage and ground those believers in the faith, to strengthen them in their confidence in Jesus Christ and his work in their lives. The book’s main feature is a set of three marks of a true Christian against which John encourages his readers to check themselves. And as they do, he says, they will grow in their knowledge that they have eternal life.
The first of those marks of a true Christian is a love for other believers. The connection between love and assurance is clear right from the very beginning of the discussion, when John says in 2:3, “By this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments.” You might read that verse and wonder where it says anything about love, but look how John defines “his commandments” just a few verses later. He really couldn’t make the point any clearer:
Beloved, if our heart does not condemn us, we have confidence before God; and whatever we ask we receive from him, because we keep his commandments and do what pleases him. And this is his commandment, that we believe in the name of his Son Jesus Christ and love one another, just as he has commanded us. (3:21–23, emphasis added)
John identifies “his commandments” as two very specific things—to believe in the name of Jesus and to love one another. We’ll talk about believing in Jesus in a moment, but do you see the logical connection here between assurance and loving others? We know we have come to know Christ, and we can have confidence before God insofar as we keep Christ’s commandment, which is to love one another.
John’s second mark of a true Christian is that they do not love the world, which some theologians have labeled the “moral test” of true faith. John first puts this point negatively in 2:15: “If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him.” It’s important to understand exactly what John means by “if anyone loves the world.” It doesn’t mean enjoying the gifts of God in this present age or even falling at times into sin (which, as John affirms clearly in 1:8, happens to every Christian). Rather, what John means by loving the world is a matter of a person’s fundamental allegiance, the tilt of their heart. Here’s what John is asking: What do you love? What gives you joy? What most powerfully entices your heart? What satisfies it? If you are in Christ, then the fundamental allegiance of your heart ought to reflect that. Your life should be marked by a love for the things of the light, not by a pining for the things of darkness. The logic is clear: if your life is marked by a fundamental allegiance to the darkness, then you have little ground for confidence that you are a child of light.
The third mark of a true Christian that John discusses is, unsurprisingly, that a person holds fast to the truth about Jesus:
Who is the liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist, he who denies the Father and the Son. No one who denies the Son has the Father. Whoever confesses the Son has the Father also. Let what you heard from the beginning abide in you. If what you heard from the beginning abides in you, then you too will abide in the Son and in the Father. And this is the promise that he made to us—eternal life. (2:22–25)
This was the cardinal failing of those who had unsettled the faith of the Christians to whom John was writing this letter. They had abandoned the confession that Jesus was the Christ, left the fellowship of the church, and apparently begun preaching that salvation could be had in another way, probably through some strange and ironic combination of perfectionism (an assertion that they had no sin) and hedonism (loving the world and pursuing its pleasures). John’s exhortation to the believers who remained, therefore, was to see that, unlike those who had left, they themselves still confessed Jesus to be the Christ, they were not living like children of darkness, and they maintained their love for one another. Therefore, they could have some confidence they truly were heirs of the promise of eternal life.
Galatians 5:16–24
The apostle Paul uses the same logic at the end of his letter to the Galatians. The entire letter, from the very beginning, is a biting polemic and devastating argument against any scheme of salvation by works. At the end, though, Paul exhorts his readers not to be given over to the works of the flesh but to be marked by the fruit of the Spirit. Paul creates a catalogue of works of the flesh: “sexual immorality, impurity, sensuality, idolatry, sorcery, enmity, strife, jealousy, fits of anger, rivalries, dissensions, divisions, envy, drunkenness, orgies, and things like these” and warns “that those who do such things will not inherit the kingdom of God” (vv. 19–21). It’s important to note the tense of the verb do. The verse is not referring to those who have done such things but rather to those doing such things or, perhaps even more accurately, to those who are doers of such things. Just as in 1 John, the emphasis is not on the mere action but on the person’s character. Paul is talking about people who claim Christ as Savior and yet whose lives are marked and characterized by these works of the flesh.
In contrast to these works of the flesh, Paul also lists nine virtues he calls “the fruit of the Spirit”: “love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control” (vv. 22–23). These are the fruits that will increasingly mark a Christian’s life.
Here’s what to notice: even in the middle of this hot polemic against salvation by works, Paul isn’t shy about turning his readers’ attention to the fourth source of assurance. If a person’s life was marked by gratifying the desires of the flesh, if it was characterized by these works of the flesh, then that person could have little confidence that the Spirit lived within them and therefore little assurance of salvation. But, of course, the reverse was also true. If Paul’s readers could see in their lives the fruit of the Spirit—the evidence of his transforming work in them—then they could be confident that they would in fact inherit the kingdom of God.
Other Passages
This same logic turns up in other places in the New Testament too. James uses it in James 2:14–26 when he writes that a “faith” that does not result in good works is a dead faith (by which he means no faith at all), and the implication is that we can have some assurance of the genuineness of our faith if it is in fact producing a life of righteousness. Peter too talks about a life devoid of Christian fruit rendering us “ineffective and unproductive” in our knowledge of Jesus, while a life filled with fruit gives us confidence that we will receive a rich welcome into the eternal kingdom of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ (see 2 Pet. 1:11). Paul, Peter, and James all say that even our sufferings produce a sense of assurance in our hearts because as we bear up under them, we see that our faith in Jesus is not superficial, but it is able to bear the weight of hardship, difficulty, and even persecution (see Rom. 5:3–5; 1 Pet. 1:6–8; James 1:2–4).
All this, of course, springs from Jesus’s own teaching about a tree and its fruit:
Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves. You will recognize them by their fruits. Are grapes gathered from thornbushes, or figs from thistles? So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit. A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit. Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. Thus you will recognize them by their fruits. (Matt. 7:15–20)
Most immediately, Jesus is talking here about recognizing false prophets by their fruits, but the logic is the same as that used by later New Testament authors. A healthy tree bears good fruit; therefore, we can tell something about the health of the tree by considering the health of its fruit. If we see good fruit in our lives, we can have some degree of confidence that we have a healthy, vital faith in Jesus. But if all we see is bad fruit—or no fruit—that kind of assurance will be weak or nonexistent. The Bible clearly teaches that relationship.
Good Works Are Meant to Confirm, Not Terrify
Here’s a question: Does the existence of this relationship between our lives and our assurance have to be terrifying? For many Christians, it is—and undeniably so. They know their lives could never measure up to God’s standard, and so when they consider their lives and fruit, they conclude that their fruit is bad or insufficient, and they lose confidence that they’re Christians at all. But that doesn’t seem to be the way the biblical writers intended their words to be understood. In fact, the stated purpose of drawing the connection between works and assurance is usually not to create doubt at all but rather to bring assurance.
Take 1 John, for example. We’ve already noted that John’s stated purpose throughout the book is to bring his readers to a deep confidence that they are heirs of eternal life. So many Christians, though, read John’s letter and employ his tests in exactly the wrong way and therefore draw exactly the wrong conclusions. Understand his book rightly, though, and you’ll see that he wants his readers to come away more assured that they are Christians, not less! So, where do we typically go wrong? Why does the book so often seem so frightening? Well, let me give you four practical guidelines for reading 1 John and applying its tests rightly and helpfully in your life.
First, keep in mind that the very purpose of John’s tests was to bring clarity to his readers. John wrote precisely to cut through the fog that a group of false Christians had created and to give believers some clear, imminently answerable questions they could ask themselves. One of the most striking things about John’s tests is that they are so simple and concrete and answerable. Do I affirm the truth about Jesus? (Yes!) Do I love other believers? (Yes!) Is my allegiance to the world? (No!) So often in our search for assurance, we tend to make up our own questions. Do I love God enough? Is it the right kind of love? Is my faith strong enough, my joy large enough, my passion hot enough? If those are the questions of assurance, then God help us, because none of them can be answered in a concrete and straightforward way. Here’s the point: Don’t make up your own questions. Use John’s. They are simple, meaningful, and above all, straightforwardly answerable.
Second, keep in mind the context of John’s tests. If you read his letter, you quickly come to realize that John had a definite idea of what failure of his tests looked like. In fact, he had in mind a whole group of people he thought had in fact failed—that is, these people who had been members of these churches but who had recently denied that Jesus was the Christ, had hated their fellow believers so much that they had abandoned the church, and had been so convinced they were in fellowship with God that they had felt perfect freedom to live immoral, wicked, hedonistic, world-loving lives. That’s who John had in mind when he thought of someone failing his tests, and he wanted the believers to whom he was writing to be reassured in their faith, to realize much to their own joy, Yeah, we’re not like that.
Third, keep in mind the scope of John’s tests. He wanted his readers to look at and consider the whole picture of their lives, not just one brushstroke on the canvas. This is the point where many Christians go so catastrophically wrong, because they apply John’s tests to one particular moment or area of their lives—usually the worst one—and then despair of their faith and salvation. We often read sentences like 3:6—“No one who abides in him keeps on sinning; no one who keeps on sinning has either seen him or known him”—and think, Well, that’s describing me, because day after day I keep on sinning, so there’s no way I’m a genuine Christian! But that’s not at all how John intended these tests to be used. He knew Christians would commit sins, and he tells us the remedy for that is to confess those sins to our Advocate, Jesus (see 1:9). Rather, what he’s talking about is a life characterized by rebellion against God. I think there are four main reasons for understanding him in this way, and not as pointing an assurance-destroying finger at one or two isolated sins.
First, notice that John writes repeatedly in his book that he’s talking about someone who “keeps on sinning” (3:6) or “makes a practice of sinning” (3:4, 8, 9). That’s more than just “to sin.” It points to continual, deliberate, pervasive sin in a person’s life.
Second, John describes this kind of pervasive sinning as “lawlessness,” which is used in the Bible to describe not a single discrete breaking of the law but rather a heart’s entire character (see 3:4). It’s a deep-rooted, extensive, Satan-like rebellion against God and his Word.
Third, in the structure of John’s book, this discussion of keeping on in sin is parallel to what is described in 2:15–17, in which John describes what he’s talking about here as a love for, or allegiance to, the world. Here’s the point: When John says someone who “keeps on sinning” cannot think they know Jesus, he doesn’t want us to look at just one brushstroke of sin on the canvas of our lives. He wants us to look at the whole painting. It’s not a question of whether the color of sin exists on our canvas; it does, and John knows it. It’s a question of the dominant color.
Fourth, keep in mind the goal of John’s tests, which is to encourage us to put our faith in Christ. He says as much near the end of the book:
For everyone who has been born of God overcomes the world. And this is the victory that has overcome the world—our faith. Who is it that overcomes the world except the one who believes that Jesus is the Son of God? . . . Whoever has the Son has life; whoever does not have the Son of God does not have life. (5:4–5, 12)
The worst mistake we can make with John’s letter is to apply his tests and then think, with great self-assurance, I have to fix the problem, instead of running in empty-handed faith to Christ. And yet so many of us Christians do just that, when John would actually have his tests confirm our faith in Jesus, or—if they turn up a lack of love or a love for the world—send us running not to self but rather to our Advocate before the Father, Jesus the righteous. Thus, John’s message is not “Here are some ways to make yourself morally worthy of the Father’s love” but rather “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1:9).
So, you see, read in its correct context, and with its ultimate purpose and goal in mind, John’s little book is not necessarily terrifying. To be sure, some professing Christians may read his book and not see themselves reflected in it at all, but even then, the right response is not to cower in terror but to repent and believe. But John’s aim was not to terrify his original readers. It was to settle them, to calm them, to encourage them, and it is meant to do the same thing for most of us too. If we hold fast the truth about Jesus, if we have a genuine love for other believers, and if the dominant character of our lives is allegiance to Christ and not the world, here’s what John says: “I write these things to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life” (5:13).
Let’s take stock of what we’ve said so far about this fourth source of assurance. Beginning with Jesus’s own teaching about a tree and its fruit, and continuing in several places throughout the New Testament, the Bible teaches that our lives and fruit do in fact stand in relationship to our sense of confidence that we really are Christians. For most Christians, as for the original readers of 1 John, that reality is not supposed to create a sense of terror but a confirmation that the Spirit really is at work in us producing the fruits of righteousness. For some, though, it will serve as an urgent warning, as it should have for the false Christians in 1 John who had denied the truth about Jesus, abandoned the church, and embraced allegiance to the world.
For all its usefulness, though, it’s critical to remember that this fourth source of assurance is confirming, not driving. In other words, it would be a terrible mistake to think that the way to increase our confidence and assurance is simply to do things to make our lives better. We are to look at the fruit of the Spirit in our lives and be encouraged, but we are not to think, I’ll create more fruit and be even more encouraged! The right way to increase assurance—as well as the fruit that then confirms assurance even more—is to put our focus on the gospel and the promises. If we get in the habit of staring at our own fruit in the hope of engendering a sense of assurance, we will be in serious danger of shifting our faith from Jesus to self. Therefore, focus on the gospel. Focus on the promises. And as you do, the fruits of salvation will grow, and in seeing them you will rejoice all the more.
