7 Thinking Out Loud
SEVEN

Thinking Out Loud
“One word of truth outweighs the world.”
ALEKSANDR SOLZHENITSYN
Catholic scholar George Weigel writes that in June 1959 the commission preparing the agenda for the Second Vatican Council asked all the Catholic bishops of the world what they would like to talk about. A forty-year-old auxiliary bishop of Krakow named Karol Wojtyla—the future Pope John Paul II—sent a single, sharp question: What in the world has happened? How did the twentieth century, which had begun with such high expectations for the human future, produce within a handful of decades two world wars, three totalitarian systems, Auschwitz, the Gulag, mountains of corpses, oceans of blood, the greatest persecutions in Christian history, and a Cold War that threatened the future of the planet? What happened? What happened, Karol Wojtyla suggested, was that the great project of Western humanism had gone off the rails. As John Paul’s biographer, Weigel summarizes the thinking of the late pontiff: “Ideas have consequences, and bad ideas can have lethal consequences.”
Our purpose in developing our minds is our love for God. Our mission, however, is to contend with the darkness for the sake of the light. We do not exercise our intellects merely to explore ideas and arguments. Those who study the history of Christianity as merely an intellectual history miss the point. As Robert Louis Wilken noted, “The study of… Christian thought has been too preoccupied with ideas…. Its mission… [is] to win the hearts and minds of men and women and to change their lives.”
This is a clarion call for the Christian mind to engage in apologetics, which is arguably one of its most needed functions. From the Greek word apologia, which means to defend something, apologetics is giving a defense of the faith, reasons to believe, answers to the questions of the day. Through apologetics the mind supports the task of evangelism, clearing away barriers and objections so that faith may be examined at face value.
Historically, Christian apologetics has leaned toward providing rational evidence for the faith, but there is a growing need for something even more basic, which is a clear explanation of faith. In the world today, the deepest question regarding the Christian faith is “So what?” This is at the heart of both thinking Christianly and communicating Christianity to others. As Thomas Oden has observed, the fact of the resurrection may be maintained in the church, but there is often little interest or communication regarding the significance of the resurrection. Jesus was raised from the dead. So what? The Bible is true. So what? You can have a personal relationship with God. So what?
This is what the Christian mind must understand in order to challenge the world’s mind to consider. If we cannot rise to this task, we will have lost our place in the most critical of conversations—indeed, the only conversation that matters.
The mission of the church is paramount, and what propels the mission forward is an awakened mind, a mind ablaze with God and the things of God. This is the heart of the cultural commission within the Great Commission. The Great Commission calls us to reach out to every person with the gospel of Jesus Christ; the cultural commission calls us to lay hold of every nook and cranny of our world for the kingdom of God. They are not separate endeavors—they are the two edges of the single sword we are to wield. Though frighteningly few Christians embrace the true dynamic and practice of the Great Commission, even fewer take hold of the cultural commission inherent within it. Too often we retreat into our Christian subculture, with its self-concerned books and magazines and radio stations and bumper stickers, sticking our heads in the sand oblivious to the world around us.
Henri Nouwen writes of a priest who told him that he cancelled his subscription to the New York Times because he felt that the endless stories about war, crime, power games and political manipulation only disturbed his mind and heart, and prevented him from meditation and prayer. “That is a sad story,” writes Nouwen. “A real spiritual life does exactly the opposite: it makes us so alert and aware of the world around us, that all that is and happens becomes part of our contemplation and meditation and invites us to a free and fearless response.”
This is the difference between a Christian who is intelligent and a Christian who has an intellect. No one, argues Richard Hofstadter, questions the value of intelligence, that excellence of mind employed with narrow, immediate, predictable ranges that are undeniably practical. Intellect, on the other hand, is the critical, creative and contemplative side of things.
It is also the activist side of things.
For our minds to break free and loom large on the world’s stage, we must recapture the lost art of thinking itself. Having a Christian mind means to think—and to think widely and broadly. This goes beyond the practice of reflection, important as this practice is, for reflection is more of a discipline or skill to be embraced. But now we are talking about application—prayerfully setting the mind to the task at hand. Nouwen’s friend purposefully avoided the New York Times. Nouwen’s reminder should not be lost: the point is to purposefully engage the New York Times.
This brings us to the heart of the mind applied. It is not simply thinking Christianly, for to know is to do. Our goal is to think in order to know how to live. So what does it mean for Christ to lay claim to medicine? To law? To politics? To the economy? To a child in the womb? To sexuality? Consider the words of the prophet Micah:
And what does the LORD require of you?
To act justly and to love mercy
and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
It is not enough to simply understand the nature of justice and love from within a Christian perspective. “We must go on,” writes Dennis Hollinger, “to think about the strategies of justice and love in issues like poverty, race relations, abortion and political life.”
This is the vanguard of Christian thinking—knowing how to live and then working to make the kingdom of God a reality for others to be able to live as well.
THE RESPONSIBILITY OF KNOWLEDGE
As important as a Christian mind is and the cultural commission inherent within it to engage the world accordingly, such pursuits are merely manifestations that flow from the ultimate goal of honoring God through a life lived in obedience to God. It is not simply knowing the truth, but living under it with a free and open heart in worship of the God of truth. This is the heart of wisdom, which is what every mind—and life—is to pursue.
Wisdom is not the same as common sense, at least as it is portrayed in the Bible, nor is it knowledge for knowledge’s sake. Wisdom is the understanding of what God would have us do and then doing it, what God would have us think and then thinking it, what God would have us say and then saying it.
Throughout the Bible the wise person is the one who does the will of the Lord; the foolish person is the one who rebels. A believer’s wisdom is found first in the acknowledgment of true wisdom and then in obedience. This is decisive, for there is a great breakdown between belief and behavior, knowing and doing. The heart of wisdom is their union, as is the heart of true knowledge.
So the greatest application of the mind is not cerebral—it is deeply personal. Its ultimate goal lies in what has been termed the responsibility of knowledge. “Sin,” writes Os Guinness, “is a deliberate violation of the responsibility of knowledge.” For to separate knowing from doing, belief from behavior, is the very nature of sin. In his book Intellectuals, British historian Paul Johnson chronicles the life and thought of such great minds as Jean Jacques Rousseau, Karl Marx, Bertrand Russell and Jean Paul Sartre. He discovered that most of their arguments and philosophies were not based on noble convictions but on the choices they had made in their own lives.
For example, the eighteenth-century French philosopher Jean Jacques Rousseau had five children out of wedlock, and he abandoned them all. Then he maintained, supposedly out of his reasoning, intellect and common sense, that children do not need parents to give them discipline or guidance, and that the state should be responsible for raising them—an idea that is still shaping some educational and child-rearing theories to this day. His conclusions were not based on true reason but on his desire to justify the moral choices he had already made.
So the responsibility of knowledge comes down to nothing less than the lordship of Christ.
YOUR MIND FOR GOD
As I write these closing words, I’m sitting in the Eagle and Child pub in Oxford, England, the pub where (as the plaque on the wall reads):
C. S. Lewis, his brother, W. H. Lewis, J. R. R. Tolkien, Charles Williams and other friends met every Tuesday morning, between the years 1939-1962 in the back room of this their favorite pub. These men, popularly known as the “Inklings,” met here to drink beer and to discuss, among other things, the books they were writing.
I confess to loving English pubs, and particularly this one. The dark interior, the earthy atmosphere, the informal and congenial banter, and most of all the aura of the Inklings and their conversations that still seem to reverberate through the air. While I sit at my favorite little table, just to the side of the fireplace in the “rabbit room” (as it is now called) where the Inklings met, a stream of tourists enter, gaze at the pictures and memorabilia on the wall, and take their pictures. There is a sense of “this is where it happened” written on their faces.
But what, exactly, happened? What is it about Lewis and his friends that creates such a pilgrimage? What has made Lewis in particular the unofficial patron saint of so many Christians around the world?
Certainly not his life, as it was with a Mother Teresa. It has often been suggested that, due to his pipe-smoking, ale-drinking, free-speaking ways, he could not even be hired by the evangelical college that stewards his personal letters.
Unlike Billy Graham, Lewis didn’t fill stadiums with his oratorical skills. (The only extant recording of which I’m aware is a snippet of him reading from his book The Four Loves.) Even the reenactment of his famed sermon The Weight of Glory, which I heard given by the actor Joss Ackland (who played Lewis in the original BBC version of Shadowlands), was difficult listening.
We could argue that his imagination is what grips us—the fantasies of Narnia, the creativity of Screwtape—and that is certainly a part. But still, such things do not explain the esteem, even the reverence, in which C. S. Lewis is held. Even the fact that most Americans are closet Anglophiles doesn’t quite complete the picture.
So what was it about Lewis? It was his mind.
Lewis is a hero because he was a Christian intellect who stepped forward to engage the world. His Oxford education, his years teaching at Magdalen College (and then later at Cambridge), his abilities to speak of Chaucer and psychoanalysis, Beowulf and humanism, met a need in our spiritual lives that a thousand books on spiritual formation did not address. He was the twentieth century’s most accomplished apologist for the Christian faith.
Who will be the C. S. Lewis of our day? As with figures like Mother Teresa and Billy Graham, there will not be a direct replacement—but the ministry of a Lewis is ever before us, for it is nothing less than a mind for God. One that is willing to think out loud.
But that will not be particularly welcome.
Actress Jada Pinkett Smith was honored as the “Artist of the Year” by the Harvard Foundation for Intercultural and Race Relations at the foundation’s twentieth annual Cultural Rhythms show. In a speech many students considered inspirational and motivating, Pinkett Smith gave a warm, teary thank you and then shared life lessons with the audience. “Don’t let anybody define who you are,” she said. “Don’t let them put you in a box.” She told them about her childhood with teenage parents, both addicted to heroin, but triumphantly proclaimed, “I can stand here on this stage and say that I’ve proven them all wrong.”
She then addressed issues regarding the roles of men and women today, specifically encouraging women to fight against the idea that choosing a career means having to choose against marriage and family. “Women, you can have… a loving man, devoted husband, loving children,… [and a] career…. All you have to do is want it.” Pinkett Smith has been married to actor Will Smith since 1997 and is the mother of two children.
Though the Cultural Rhythms show is designed to feature culturally unique forms of artistic expression, along the lines of varying forms of music, the Bisexual, Gay, Lesbian, Transgender, and Supporters Alliance (BGLTSA) were offended that Pinkett Smith’s comments seemed specific to heterosexual relationships. Conceding that there was nothing in her remarks that were remotely homophobic, the BGLTSA nonetheless expressed concern that her content was “extremely heteronormative”—meaning her comments implied that standard sexual relationships are only between males and females, making BGLTSA members feel uncomfortable.
The BGLTSA called for and received an apology from the Foundation, which is committed to “take responsibility to inform future speakers that they will be speaking to an audience diverse in race, ethnicity, religion, sexuality, gender and class.”
In our day, voices daring to espouse traditional values, much less Christian ones, will be increasingly pressured to remain silent. They will not simply be met with hostility or be trivialized. There is increasing pressure for such voices never to be heard.
This highlights the Christian call to embody one of the more foundational character traits lauded in Scripture: courage. Many years ago the late Brent Curtis gave life-changing advice to author John Eldredge: “Let people feel the weight of who you are,” he said, “and let them deal with it.”
As pressure bears down on voices that would speak winsomely and compellingly into the cultural wasteland in ways that challenge the prevailing ethos, we must take heart in Christ and let people feel the weight of who we are in him, and let them deal with it.
And they will.
A performer in the Cultural Rhythms show who watched Pinkett Smith’s speech said he thought the speech was “insightful.” “You can never appeal to every single group,” he said. “You’ll always in some way be exclusive. I thought her message was clear. I thought it was sincere.”
In other words, he listened. But first, someone had to stand up and speak.
So we end with a prayer, first offered by John R. W. Stott at the end of his short but profound book Your Mind Matters:
I pray earnestly that God will raise up today a new generation of Christian apologists or Christian communicators, who will combine an absolute loyalty to the biblical gospel and an unwavering confidence in the power of the Spirit with a deep and sensitive understanding of the contemporary alternatives to the gospel; who will relate the one to the other with freshness, pungency, authority and relevance; and who will use their minds to reach other minds for Christ.
