Chapter 7 of 13

5 Sacred Thinking

5 Sacred Thinking

FIVE

image

Sacred Thinking

“We live forward, but we can only think backward.”

SØREN KIERKEGAARD

In his fourteenth encyclical, Fides et Ratio (Faith and Reason), Pope John Paul II expressed dismay that philosophers no longer wrestle with the big questions of life, the questions that most define who we are: What does it all mean? Does life have a purpose? Is death the end? Is there a God? If it is increasingly rare among philosophers, we can only imagine the degree of scarcity among the rest of us.

To reflect means to give thought to something to such a degree

that it brings some kind of realization—an aha moment. It takes an idea and lives with it until it is burned deep within. It takes a question and, like Jacob wrestling with the angel, does not let it go until some form of answer emerges. Christian reflection takes what is read, taught, suggested and announced, and brings it into confrontation with a biblical worldview. It is thinking Christianly.

It is significant that the Latin word schola, from which we get our words scholar and scholarship, means “free time,” joining the importance of fallow time given over to reflection for true intellectual development. In order to nurture the life of the mind, we must protect the time it takes to practice it. Most think this means time devoted to study; in truth, it means the time to study coupled with the time needed to reflect on what we have studied. Otherwise we will be engaging the worst of Malcolm Gladwell’s famed “blink”— how we tend to make immediate assessments about things— which can lead to responding without thinking on things that need to be thought about.

Henri Nouwen insightfully wonders if the fact that so many people ask support, advice and counsel from so many other people is not, in large part, due to their having lost contact with the practice of such reflection. Sometimes one feels, writes Nouwen, “as if one half of the world is asking advice of the other half while both sides are sitting in the same darkness.”

The dynamics of reflection are not difficult to process. Christian reflection involves times of silence and solitude, prayer, and immersion into the Scriptures. On the front end, we take conversations and counsel, reading and experience with us. The authority over all reflection is, of course, holy Scripture, but reflection should not be reduced to Bible study. The complexity of the world and our lives within it depend on the Bible but demand the application of the Bible that only reflection can bring.

As I often challenge my students, the Bible gives us all we must know, but not all that there is to know. Bringing Scripture to bear on something such as bioethics involves taking the Bible’s foundational teaching on creation and what it means to be human, along with the important scriptural teachings on the sanctity of human life, and then reflecting on the implications of such truths in terms of the technological advancements and opportunities of our day. To fall back and declare “The Bible doesn’t say anything about bioethics” is simply not true. Of course it does. But its application takes a willing and educated mind bent on reflection. Great Christian thinkers are often those who have simply taken the time to do it.

Reflection does more, though, than bring insight. It brings a sensitivity, an awareness of things. It provides penetrating insight, an intuitive assessment of the world that cannot come any other way. I recall listening to a lecture at Oxford by the great mystery writer P. D. James on the interplay between Christian theology and her mysteries. She said she was often asked how she could write about murder as a Christian. Her answer was that she was writing about the human condition, including sin, and murder brought that condition into the clearest of lights. She also liked separating fact from fiction. She then added that the world needs such clear thinking, rooted in reflection, “For there is much in our world that is clever,” she said, “yet is not true.” This is what reflection brings to the surface—separating fact from fiction, the merely clever from the true.

Consider the media, perhaps the most important challenge facing Christian reflection. At its most base, the media tell us both what to think about and then how to think about it. Sociologist Christian Smith writes that we may talk about “the culture,” “the media,” “television” and “Hollywood,” but if we think systemically, these are euphemisms for a worldview that constitutes the human self in a very particular way: as an autonomous, rational, self-seeking, cost-benefit calculating consumer. This constitutes a moral order with particular assumptions, narratives, commitments, beliefs, values and goals.

Malcolm Muggeridge tells of taking Mother Teresa into a New York television studio to appear on one of the morning shows. It was the first time that Mother Teresa had been in an American television studio, and as a result she was completely unprepared for the constant interruptions for commercials.

On that particular morning, Muggeridge observed that all of the commercials dealt with food that was being advertised as non-fattening and low in calories. Mother Teresa took it in with a sense of unbelief. Her own work was in trying to nourish the starving, to put some flesh on human skeletons. Suddenly, without even thinking, she said out loud, “I see that Christ is needed in television studios.”

A total silence fell on the studio and everyone there. Muggeridge said that in the midst of the media fantasy, reality had suddenly intruded.

But it took someone being still and reflecting on what reality entailed. Because of the influences of the media on our world—and our minds—the dynamics of reflection on cultural discourse (which is generally carried out through the media) is decisive. Few of us would have thought twice about the commercial content, much less the messages they were sending, that was so evident to Mother Teresa. But that is where a Christian mind, practiced in reflection, comes into play—and is most needed. For as T. S. Eliot once quipped, “Paganism holds all the most valuable advertising space.” We cannot simply afford to reflect on what culture tells us to know; we also must reflect on what it tells us to feel. By getting someone to feel a certain way, you can lead them to a certain belief through those feelings. In an ABC news story on the death of Princess Diana, Andrew Morton said that Diana’s death was “one of the most awful tragedies of the late 20th century, if not the greatest. … In her death something inside us had died…. People are grieving for lost hopes, lost dreams, lost ambitions.”

That is a very emotional assessment. The continual scenes of grief and crying led us to feel that this was a loss of historic proportions. Yet this simply wasn’t the case. Nothing against Diana, much less those who grieved her passing, but not only was her death far from the greatest tragedy that has occurred to the world over the previous fifty years—eclipsing such things as the Vietnam War, Chernobyl, Tiananmen Square or the explosion of the space shuttle Challenger—but even when compared to the loss of other figures, such as Mother Teresa who died the same week, she lived a life of very little significance. As has been said on more than one occasion, she was mostly famous for being famous. Yet her death greatly overshadowed Mother Teresa’s because we were led to feel that way by the media, so much so that the talk was not that Mother Teresa would be made a saint but that Princess Diana would.

There are many other ways that the media leads us in our feelings. One of the most powerful is through repetition—putting certain alternate choices or lifestyles before us over and over again. Eventually we become so desensitized to reality and the truth that we accept those choices and lifestyles as normal. If the repetitive behavior is exhibited through a character that is particularly likable, the influence is all the more great.

Sexual behavior is a prime example. MTV is often criticized for the incessant sleaze of steamy programming aimed at young people. The critics are not being unreasonable. During a single week in March 2004 the Parents Television Council (PTC) recorded 3,056 flashes of nudity or sexual situations and 2,881 verbal references to sex on MTV. Beyond sexual content, the PTC said it recorded 3,127 instances of “bleeped” profane dialogue and another 1,518 other instances of unedited rough language.

But television as a whole is becoming increasingly sexual. According to a study of the 2004-2005 TV season by the Kaiser Family Foundation, the number of sexual scenes has nearly doubled over an earlier study in 1998. Now seven out of every ten shows have sexual content, averaging five sex scenes per hour.

If the portrayals of premarital sex in the media outnumber sex within marriage—which study after study demonstrates is clearly the case—then premarital sex becomes normal in our thinking. If characters are portrayed as having intercourse after they have just met—and the amount of such portrayals doubled between 1998 and 2004—then that will increasingly be seen as mainstream behavior. As George Lucas, one of the most successful filmmakers in Hollywood history, once said, “For better or worse… films and television tell us the way we conduct our lives, what is right and wrong.”

I once read a speech given by film director Oliver Stone at American University. Stone is well known for such films as Natural Born Killers, Platoon and JFK. In responding to the distortions and factual errors in his films, particularly JFK (presented as a faux-documentary on the Kennedy assassination), Stone said that films should not be the end-all for what is true, saying that people “have a responsibility to read a book.” Nobody, he said, “is going to sit through a three-hour movie and say, ’That’s that.’ ”

He is wrong. That is exactly what people do—and that is precisely what must end. In his famed reminder to H. G. Wells, G. K. Chesterton quipped that the object of opening the mind, as of opening the mouth, is to shut it again on something solid. It has been said that the electronic world has meant a “speeded-up mind,” which is precisely what we cannot afford. As Søren Kierkegaard once counseled, “We live forward, but we can only think backward.”

AN INTEGRATED WORLDVIEW

To engage in such reflection, we must have an integrated sense of things, as opposed to succumbing to a kind of compartmentalization that fails to address the entirety of life. A compartmentalized mind is one that separates aspects of life into distinct categories— job, family, HBO, a quiet time, the business section of the newspaper and AOL—all without integration. Our thinking about one area never informs our thinking about another.

Thus a person can be a Christian but not reflect about science or technology in light of faith. Or even worse, never even have the thought come to mind of reflecting about science or technology in light of faith. So issues related to bioethics are seldom met with a Christian mind that has reflected on the nature of humanity and the sanctity of human life in the light of Scripture. Instead, we simply let CNN tell us what various scientific and technological break-throughs will mean for the quality of our life; we marvel at progress; and then we ponder whether we will be able to afford the procedure. The world of science becomes distinct from the world of faith. To his credit, this is the critique inherent in Michael Crichton’s novel and subsequent film Jurassic Park. “You were so busy pursuing what you could do,” says Ian Malcolm, the scientist portrayed by Jeff Goldblum, to the founder of the park, “that you never stopped to ask yourself if you should do it.”

Even when it comes to scholarship, the question is not simply over facts but over reflective interpretation of those facts. George Marsden gives the example of the Battle of Little Bighorn. Two historians might be able to agree perfectly well on the details—where and when it took place, how many people were killed on both sides, and (perhaps) who fired the first shot. Nonetheless, one scholar might see the battle as Custer’s heroic last stand in a fight to bring peace to the American West; another might see it as a triumph in the Native American fight to resist barbaric invaders. “While at one level such differences might look like mere partisanship,” Marsden writes, “at a deeper level they have to do with largescale beliefs about what the world is, or should be, like.” Mark Noll casts the vision for the comprehensive nature of this kind of thinking by speaking of the “life of the mind”:

By an evangelical “life of the mind” I mean… the effort to think like a Christian—to think within a specifically Christian framework—across the whole spectrum of modern learning, including economics and political science, literary criticism and imaginative writing, historical inquiry and philosophical studies, linguistics and the history of science, social theory and the arts.

This is the essence of the idea of a Christian worldview.1 The term worldview, from the German Weltanschauung (literally, “world perception”), suggests more than a set of ideas by which you judge other ideas. It is, as Gene Edward Veith has written, “a way to engage constructively the whole range of human expression from a Christian perspective.” Or as Jonathan Edwards, arguably the greatest intellect America has ever produced, once contended, the basic goal of any mind is to work toward “the consistency and agreement of our ideas with the ideas of God.”

So the Christian mind gives radically different answers to what James Sire reasonably puts forward as the seven basic questions for any worldview: What is ultimate reality? What is the nature of the world around us? What does it mean to be human? What happens when I die? On what basis are we able to know anything at all? How do we determine right or wrong? What is the meaning of history? Or from a more theological point of view, consider the worldview questions posed by Charles Colson and Nancy Pearcey: Where did we come from and who are we? What has gone wrong with the world? What can we do to fix it? How now shall we live?

Consider the Christian response to the first and most foundational of these questions—where did we come from? There are a limited number of answers at our disposal: (1) we came about by chance (the naturalist contention), (2) we don’t really exist (the Hindu response), or (3) we were spoke into existence by God. Even when people, such as the discoverer of DNA, Francis Crick, suggest that we were seeded here by another race of beings from another planet, they would then have to account for the existence of these other beings. So for the Christian, the answer to “Where did we come from, and who are we?” gives a foundation for thinking that no other answer gives. Because we were created, each person has value, and there is meaning and purpose to every life. There is Someone above and outside of our existence who stands over us as our authority.

Because of this answer, Martin Luther King Jr. could write the immortal words found in his letter from the Birmingham jail:

There are two types of law: just and unjust…. A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law…. Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust. All segregation statutes are unjust because segregation distorts the soul and damages the personality.

King’s argument was based on the dignity and worth bestowed by God on all humans, regardless of what other humans might have to say. He laid claim to a law above human law. No other worldview would have given King the basis for such a claim. And from such a worldview, the world was changed.

But worldviews such as King’s are increasingly rare.

THE DANGER OF AN UNREFLECTIVE LIFE

A new graduate from Baylor University confessed to one of her professors that her college curriculum did not require her life to be formed by serious thinking or living. While she assimilated great reams of information during her four years in the university, she admitted that she did almost no thinking: no tough-minded engagement with life-shaping books and ideas. Her honors degree had never required her to encounter the overarching moral and religious questions or to undertake any serious reevaluation of her life. She admitted the truthfulness of Walker Percy’s aphorism that “you can make all A’s and still flunk life.”

And flunking life in this way can take on nightmarish scenarios.

Kay Haugaard, a professor in Southern California, made this chilling report in The Chronicle of Higher Education.

Her twenty students were discussing Shirley Jackson’s short story “The Lottery,” found in numerous literary anthologies designed for students. Set in a small town in rural America, the townsfolk gather for a seemingly innocent ritual deemed critical for the well-being of the crops and the community, of which the center of attention is a lottery. Mothers and fathers, sons and daughters, come forward to draw pieces of paper. There is great anxiety as they draw their paper; deep relief when they find it blank. Suddenly, the story reveals the frightening truth that the draw is for a human sacrifice. In the end, a woman draws the slip of paper marked by a black spot. Stones are gathered; she is circled—and killed.

Even her small son had pebbles in his hand.

When the New Yorker first published the essay in 1948, it was met by a storm of outrage. The story’s moral—the danger of “going along” in blind social conformity—was repugnant to the generation that had stood up to Hitler.

Times change.

On the warm California night that brought chills to Haugaard, her class registered no moral response at all.

“The end was neat!” one woman offered.

“If it’s a part of a person’s culture,… and if it has worked for them, [it’s okay],” another suggested.

“At this point I gave up,” wrote Haugaard. “No one in the whole class of twenty ostensibly intelligent individuals would go out on a limb and take a stand [even] against human sacrifice.”

1.

On pp. 103-4 of the “Book Lists” appendix, I offer a beginning list of books designed to serve a Christian worldview.

↑ Back to top

↑